Is decision-making the key skill for a team today?
Episode Summary Most teams believe they’re making decisions when they’re really just talking. In this episode, Dan Hammond and Pia Lee look at why decision-making is one of the most underestimated team skills, and why it matters more than ever in times of constant change. They cover the ways decisions quietly fail: the loudest voice dominating, people nodding along to avoid friction, the quiet thinkers never speaking, and the “zombie” decisions that drift around an organisation for months without ever being made. The conversation lands on a practical fix: treat decision-making as a facilitated process, not a discussion. Dan walks through a decision process built on the GROW coaching model (Goal, Reality, Options, Will), where you deliberately widen and then narrow who’s involved at each stage. Pia adds lessons from army officers, her rule of always having at least three options, and the value of understanding how different team members process information. They also look at where AI helps teams decide faster, and where human judgement and accountability still have to sit. Key Themes & Takeaways A round-the-table conversation feels like decision-making but rarely produces one, so end every discussion by asking, “What did we actually decide?” Consensus isn’t commitment: people often agree in the room to avoid friction, then shore up their own positions afterwards, which is when politics sets in. Be explicit about roles: who is the decision-maker, who advises, and who just needs to be informed. Use the GROW model as a funnel: keep the goal tight, cast the net wide for reality and options, then narrow back down to the decision-maker to commit. Always generate at least three options, including “do nothing,” because two options turns a decision into a false binary. Non-verbal tools like Post-its, virtual whiteboards and meeting chat surface the views of people who won’t speak up. Use AI to speed up fact-gathering and generating options, but don’t hand it the decision: accountability stays with the humans. Three Reasons to Listen Listen if your team has a decision that’s been “under discussion” for months and nobody can say who owns it. Listen if your meetings end with lots of agreement but nothing changes afterwards. That nodding may not be commitment at all. Listen if you’re curious why one leadership team felt disappointed when they finally made a year-old decision in 25 minutes. Notable Quotes “We think we’re making decisions, but we’re just talking.” — Pia Lee They’re like zombies, aren’t they? They’re undead in the organisation – unmade decisions.” — Dan Hammond The enemy of good decision-making is unspoken disagreement – passivity.” — Pia Lee Resources Decision-making process (GROW-based) mentioned in the episode: https://www.squadify.net/resources/aligned-decision-making/




