
A new VLDC, and three stories we couldn't agree on
Is CRI telling us what we actually see? Should AI be refereeing product substitutions? And can lighting really help people living with dementia? In the very first episode of Light Headed, the four founders of the Virtual Lighting Design Community take on three stories from The Pulse, and don't agree on any of them. Ingmar Klaasen (The Integrator), Martin Klaasen (The Strategist), Katia Kolovea (The Communicator) and Amardeep M. Dugar (The Scientist) join from Perth, Athens and Chennai. THE NEW VLDC We start with the platform itself. VLDC has been reorganised: a simpler layout, a Knowledge Library sorted by topic, a member directory you can search by role, expertise, region and availability, an events space covering the whole industry rather than just our own calendar, and a new monthly Member Spotlight. Amardeep explains why one shared events calendar matters in an industry this fragmented, and why the last six years were really the beta test. STORY 1: IS CRI TELLING US WHAT WE ACTUALLY SEE? A paper in Optical Materials argues that shifting a red peak from 620 to 630 nm drops CRI from 86 to 69, yet the light looks better. Amardeep makes the scientific case for moving beyond CRI to IES TM-30. Martin trusts his eye first and reaches for the science second. Katia asks the question underneath both: how do you explain any of this to a client? STORY 2: CAN AI JUDGE PRODUCT SUBSTITUTIONS? Paul Rodenbush argues AI belongs in the substitution process as a neutral comparison layer. Martin wants AI that explains its reasoning so designers learn from it. Amardeep points out that AI can find the closest product, but only the designer knows why the beam angle has to be two degrees. Katia worries about a generation learning to design with their judgement already outsourced. STORY 3: SMART LIGHTING AND DEMENTIA Penn State has won US$3.6 million to test, over five years with 300 residents in ten nursing homes, whether tunable lighting genuinely helps people living with dementia. Amardeep on the gap between what the market claims and what the evidence supports. Martin on why lighting designers are not doctors, and Katia on the fact that we prescribe anyway. We don't settle any of it. That's the point. Tell us where you stand and we'll pick it up next time. READ THE STORIES Is CRI telling us what we actually see? https://members.vld.community/c/world-news/is-cri-telling-us-what-we-actually-see Can AI help project teams judge product substitutions? https://members.vld.community/c/ai-news/can-ai-help-project-teams-judge-product-substitutions Smart lighting trial aims to help people with dementia https://members.vld.community/c/world-news/smart-lighting-trial-aims-to-help-people-with-dementia MENTIONED Lux Futurum Forum 2026, Shenzhen · IES TM-30 · Colour Quality Scale (CQS) · Inside Lighting · US Lighting Trends · The Lighting Police JOIN FREE VLDC is the free global community for everyone who designs, specifies, makes and works with light. Join at members.vld.community Light Headed is free thanks to our Advanced Supporters: Signify, ERCO, WAC Lighting, Casambi, LEDS C4, Aero Light, Photizo and Lighting Recipe Studio. New episode every fortnight. Inform. Innovate. Inspire.










