
2026 Trustee Week - Day 3: When There Isn't One Right Answer: Trustee Judgement in Practice
What happens when trustees disagree on a difficult decision, and there isn't an obvious right answer? In Day 3 of our Trustees' Week series, we explore how boards balance competing priorities, challenge constructively and make decisions when every option carries some risk. Featuring insights from Kathryn Shepherdson, Jane Rich (The Fore), Jonathan Jelley MBE and Kahvan Bryan (Young Trustees Network), we consider the importance of hearing different perspectives, understanding the decision-making process, recording the reasons behind decisions and knowing when to revisit them. Free Trustees' Week resources: https://www.bancservices.co.uk/ KEY TAKEAWAY Good governance isn't about always finding the right answer. It's about making a well-informed, defensible decision, understanding why it was made and being willing to reconsider when circumstances change. BEST MOMENTS “Information informs judgment, it doesn't replace it.” “I don't think disagreement is unhealthy. Constructive challenge is essential to good governance.” “A decision can be reasonable when it is made and still need to change when circumstances change.” TRUSTEE FINANCE BRIEF If you're a trustee or charity leader who would like more practical prompts to help you engage with charity finances and ask useful questions around the board table, you can join my Trustee Finance Brief. Sign up to receive practical, plain-English finance and governance insights designed to support better board-level conversations. ABOUT YOUR HOST Aishat is a charity finance professional with over 25 years' experience in the nonprofit sector and founder of BAnC Service , a practice supporting charities and nonprofits with financial management, reporting, governance and strategic financial advice. Through The Nonprofit Bookkeeper, she helps charity leaders, trustees and finance professionals make sense of financial information, ask better questions and make informed decisions, while recognising the people and work behind the numbers. She is also the author of Charity Finance from A to Z , a practical guide to making charity finance more accessible. Work with Aishat: www.bancservices.co.uk CONNECT Instagram TikTok















