Single Life or Joint and Survivor? The Pension Choice You Only Make Once
Picture a man who's 62 and retiring in January. HR drops a thick packet on his desk, and a few pages in there are three boxes. Box one pays him $5,000 a month for life, and it stops when he dies. Box two pays $4,600, and if he dies first, his wife gets $2,300 a month for the rest of her life. Box three pays $4,250, and if he dies first, she keeps the full $4,250. He has to pick one, and he only gets to pick once. (The couple and the figures are illustrative.) In this episode, Brandon and Brantley explain why boxes two and three aren't really a smaller pension. They're the same pension with a life insurance policy bought out of it, and the real question is whether that's the best coverage he can buy for her. What we get into: You're paying a premium either way. The $400 or $750 a month you give up is what it costs to protect your spouse. The plan prices the boxes to be worth about the same on average, so nobody is getting one over on you. But the plan doesn't know your health, and you do. What "pension max" is. For as long as either of us has been in the business, the industry has pitched taking the biggest check and buying life insurance with the difference. It can work in the right case. We've also seen it done badly for a long time. The math the pitch leaves out. Replacing $4,250 a month for 20 years takes a little over $1 million of coverage, before any interest. If the pension has cost-of-living raises, you need even more, or a policy whose death benefit can keep up. At 62, that likely costs more than the $750 a month you freed up. The pitch to watch for. You'll free up $750 a month, the policy costs $500, so you come out $250 ahead. Then you find out the policy was only guaranteed to age 85. Underwriting comes before the box. Most people don't think about this until the packet is in their hands, which is the hardest time to buy coverage. Getting people in their sixties and seventies approved is easier than it used to be, but it still isn't a given. Don't check any box until you have an actual offer at an approved risk class. You can still turn the policy down. Details on the form that change the answer. Some plans raise your check back up if your spouse dies first. In a private plan, your spouse has to sign off in writing before you can take a life-only payout, while government plans set their own rules. And some pensions tie other benefits, like health coverage, to the election, which a life insurance policy can't replace. The lump sum option. Some plans let you take a lump sum and roll it to an IRA or buy your own income annuity. Once in a while an annuity pays more than the pension, mostly depending on where interest rates are when you look. In our experience it's the exception. When to just check the box. The gap between the options is small. Your health may not get you a good offer. Or your spouse is much younger and the survivor income gets cost-of-living raises, so it could pay for decades. In those cases, the pension's own coverage is usually the better deal. Everything here is general and illustrative, and nothing in this episode is a quote. Taxes on pension income belong to your CPA, and plan-specific rules belong to your plan. Our lane is whether a policy can do the survivor option's job better, and how to tell a good design from a bad one. You're already buying life insurance on that page. The only question is who you buy it from. Want more first? Browse our retirement income guides , or see how a guaranteed income annuity works in our guide to single premium immediate annuities . _____________________________________________ Everything in this episode is general, and your situation isn't. If you're looking at that options page right now, or you will be in the next year or two, book 30 minutes with Brandon and bring the page. He'll help you see what the survivor option is really costing you, and whether a policy could do that job better at your health and your ages. If the box your plan already offers is the right one, he'll tell you that too. Book a call with Brandon .







