
2.180 Why Good Candidates Walk Away: What Your Recruitment Process Is Telling Them – with Carrie Johnston
Why do good candidates walk away from roles that look right on paper? In this episode of Find Grow Keep, I’m joined by Carrie Johnston, Founder and Director of The CommsConnector, to talk about what candidates are really noticing during the recruitment process — and why the reason they give for turning down a job isn’t always the whole story. Carrie has more than 20 years’ experience across agency and client side and works with both candidates and employers, so she gets to hear two quite different perspectives on the same recruitment experience. We talk about why salary often isn’t the main reason good candidates say no, what happens when hiring managers aren’t aligned on the role, and how communication, interview environments and seemingly small interactions can influence candidate experience. Carrie also shares some great real-life examples, including a senior candidate who changed their mind after one interaction in a final interview, and we explore whether AI in recruitment is making the process more efficient or simply more transactional. We cover: Why candidates sometimes give employers a simplified reason for saying no What candidates are learning about your workplace during the recruitment process Why every interview and assessment stage should have a purpose How the interview environment can affect candidate performance Where AI is helping recruitment — and where the human connection is being lost Why being honest about the challenges of a role can help the right candidate say yes What employers can do before going to market to create a better recruitment process Because recruitment really is a two-way process. While you’re deciding whether someone is right for your business, they’re deciding whether your business is somewhere they want to work. Connect with Carrie: https://www.linkedin.com/in/carrieannjohnston Make sure to subscribe to stay updated with new releases on Mondays! Visit https://www.amplifyhr.com.au/ for more insights and resources. Send us Fan Mail Download our free guide, “Getting Stuff Done Through Your People,” giving you the tools to build a culture where people take ownership, goals get achieved, and results follow. https://www.amplifyhr.com.au/downloadable/getting-stuff-done-through-your-people/












