Energy vs Climate is a live, interactive webinar and podcast where energy experts David Keith , Sara Hastings-Simon and Ed Whittingham break down the trade-offs of the energy transition in Alberta, Canada, and beyond. It's your no-nonsense take on a messy, high-stakes topic: news, analysis, and conversations with guests from industry, government, and civil society. You won't always agree with us, but if you care about where our energy system is headed, this is for you. Guests range from scientists and policy experts to industry leaders, talking through everything from new energy technology to the real-world effects of climate change. www.energyvsclimate.com Produced by Amit Tandon & Bespoke Podcasts
Listen to episodes
60 recent
October 1, 2026Episode 145 min
Steven Guilbeault: A 'Fireside Exit Interview'
On September 17, Ed sat down with former Canadian Environment and Climate Change Canada minister Steven Guilbeault for what we called a "fireside exit interview." Steven spent more than three decades in Canada's environmental movement, then spent seven years in federal politics, four of them running Environment and Climate Change Canada. He resigned from cabinet in November 2025 over the Ottawa-Alberta pipeline deal and left Parliament for good in early September, saying Canada is backsliding on climate action. We recorded it live in partnership with Protect Our Winters (POW) Canada at its 2026 Leadership Summit. David and Sara sat this one out; it was just Steven and Ed and a room full of POW's supporters and ambassadors. Ed's known Steven for a long time, so they had a frank and insightful conversation about climate, advocacy and the vicissitudes of political life. Send us a text (if you'd like a response, please include your email) Follow us on: LinkedIn Bluesky X/Twitter Instagram Energy vs Climate relies on the support of our generous listeners Donate to keep Energy vs Climate going Produced by Bespoke Podcasts
September 10, 202658 min
(Replay) Is Canada's Electrification Bet Still Current? | With Blake Shaffer
This is a replay of our conversation with Dr. Blake Shaffer , an energy economist at the University of Calgary, on Canada's electrification bet. We recorded this in spring 2023, right after the federal budget's big bet on clean electricity. With AI data centres now competing for the same grid capacity electrification needs, it might be even more relevant than it was in 2023. Chapters: 0:00 – Replaying Canada's electrification bet 4:52 – David's new gig: climate systems engineering at UChicago 7:16 – Why electrify: Blake's primer on capacity vs. generation 17:35 – Growth rates, NIMBYism, and selling the switch to consumers 22:11 – Capacity factor, availability, and the "clean" vs. "zero-emission" fight 26:31 – Transmission bottlenecks and interprovincial politics 36:07 – Social license, orphan wells, and Danielle Smith's pushback 44:41 – Grid instability, audience Q&A, and closing thoughts About Our Guest: Blake Shaffer is an Associate Professor of Economics at the University of Calgary where he teaches and researches on electricity markets, climate policy, and energy transitions. Shaffer uses empirical methods to evaluate policy effectiveness and better understand consumer and firm behaviour. Shaffer strives to bring rigorous evidence to help policy makers craft better policy. Send us a text (if you'd like a response, please include your email) Follow us on: LinkedIn Bluesky X/Twitter Instagram Energy vs Climate relies on the support of our generous listeners Donate to keep Energy vs Climate going Produced by Bespoke Podcasts
August 27, 202648 min
(Replay) Battery Storage and How to Make It Better | With Shirley Meng
This is a replay of our conversation with Dr. Shirley Meng from the University of Chicago on battery storage. It's one of our favourite deep dives because batteries touch everything from EV range anxiety to grid scale storage, and even the whole critical minerals conversation. When we recorded this in May 2024, Shirley was predicting real solid state battery platforms by 2027 or 2028, and here we are getting close to that window, so it's worth listening again with that timeline in mind. The fights over re-shoring battery manufacturing, the US-China race, the economics of lithium versus sodium, all of it is just as live today as it was then, or maybe even more so. Episode page and show notes . About Our Guest: Dr. Y. Shirley Meng is a Professor at the Pritzker School of Molecular Engineering at the University of Chicago. She serves as the Chief Scientist of the Argonne Collaborative Center for Energy Storage Science (ACCESS) Argonne National Laboratory. Dr. Meng is the principal investigator of the research group - Laboratory for Energy Storage and Conversion (LESC), that was established at University of California San Diego since 2009. She held the Zable Chair Professor in Energy Technologies at University of California San Diego (UCSD) from 2017-2022. Send us a text (if you'd like a response, please include your email) Follow us on: LinkedIn Bluesky X/Twitter Instagram Energy vs Climate relies on the support of our generous listeners Donate to keep Energy vs Climate going Produced by Bespoke Podcasts
August 13, 202647 min
Stuck in the Middle: The Mid-Transition Crisis & the Energy System's Awkward Middle Age | With Emily Grubert
Decarbonization usually means addition: more wind, solar, EVs. But a real transition also means taking something away. We talk about decarbonization like it's a shopping list: more wind, more solar, more EVs, stacked on top of whatever's already running. But a real transition means something also has to come off the list. Fossil systems have to shrink at the same time clean systems grow, and for a good stretch in the middle, both have to serve the same demand at once. Neither one can do the job alone, and each ends up constraining the other. Civil engineer and environmental sociologist Emily Grubert (University of Notre Dame) calls this overlap the mid-transition, and it's the subject of a paper she co-wrote with Sara. Ed sits down with both of them to work through what the concept actually means once you get past the label. Some of what's in this one: Why refineries and coal plants can't just wind down smoothly to zero, and where the "minimum viable scale" wall actually sits What Alberta's coal phase-out got right, what it missed, and why the coal companies got compensated a lot faster than the communities did Whether the oil sands could shrink one asset at a time, or whether losing one piece, a pipeline, an upgrader, takes more of the system down with it The uncomfortable question at the centre of it all: is a slow, managed phase-out actually the safer path, or just a longer runway for incumbents to extract concessions on the way out. 0:00 Intro 0:35 Cold Open 2:00 What Is the Mid-Transition? 4:36 The 80/20 Rule: Are We Already In It? 5:55 Decarbonization Means Subtraction Too 8:50 What Each System Forces on the Other 12:38 Refineries and the Limits of Ramping Down 15:46 Alberta's Coal Phase-Out, Explained 20:52 Managing Coal Decline in the US 24:11 Fast Payouts for Companies, Slow Support for Communities 27:58 Can the Oil Sands Shrink Smoothly? 35:13 Long Mid-Transition or Short? The Band-Aid Question Send us a text (if you'd like a response, please include your email) Follow us on: LinkedIn Bluesky X/Twitter Instagram Energy vs Climate relies on the support of our generous listeners Donate to keep Energy vs Climate going Produced by Bespoke Podcasts
July 24, 202641 min
Can Octopus Energy Wrap Its Arms Around North America? | Demand Flexibility & More With Eric Davids | BONUS
Octopus Energy paid its UK customers collectively over £100,000 during a recent heat wave, not through new infrastructure, but a text message and a price signal offering demand flexibility. That caught our attention. In this episode, Ed and Sara (David sits this one out) talk with Eric Davids, Head of Strategy for Octopus Energy's US business, about redefining utility-customer relationships, how approaches in the UK stack up against North American utilities' much blunter "please conserve" grid alerts, and what happens when consumers get real price exposure and it doesn't go well. 🎙️ TIMESTAMPS 0:50 – Episode intro 1:54 – Welcome Eric Davids 5:55 – What is demand flexibility? 7:38 – Inside Octopus's £100K UK heat wave response 9:49 – Alberta's grid alerts vs. Octopus's incentives 22:09 – Guardrails against price exposure risk (Winter Storm Uri) 28:19 – Is this just another hype cycle? 35:43 – Equity and the energy transition Send us a text (if you'd like a response, please include your email) Follow us on: LinkedIn Bluesky X/Twitter Instagram Energy vs Climate relies on the support of our generous listeners Donate to keep Energy vs Climate going Produced by Bespoke Podcasts
June 30, 202646 min
BONUS | EvC vs The Internet: David, Sara, and Ed respond to the comment section
They say there's no growth without feedback. This season, you've given us plenty of it. In this episode, David, Sara, and Ed do something most podcasters shouldn't do: they read the comments. Out loud and on purpose. Some feedback was positive. Some was additive. Some fell into the category we're calling "strongly suggestive." If you've ever left a comment on an EvC clip wondering whether David, Sara and Ed actually saw it: they did. This is what they had to say back. Send us a text (if you'd like a response, please include your email) Follow us on: LinkedIn Bluesky X/Twitter Instagram Energy vs Climate relies on the support of our generous listeners Donate to keep Energy vs Climate going Produced by Bespoke Podcasts
June 15, 20261 hr 5 min
BONUS | Where Should Canada’s Nuclear Energy Go From Here? | Toronto Climate Week
Ed's new project, Critical Mass , starts with a deceptively simple question: if Canada decides it wants more nuclear power, can it actually deliver it? The answer turns out to be complicated. As part of the project, we're hosting four live town halls across the country. The first was recorded at Toronto Climate Week on June 5, featuring Todd Smith (former Ontario Minister of Energy, now VP at Candu Energy) and Brendan Frank (VP of Policy at Clean Prosperity) . Together they work through the project's core tensions - cost, democratic legitimacy, and standardization - with the kind of honest talk you've come to expect from EvC. Thank you to Geoff Burt and The Consecon Foundation for helping make the evening possible. Send us a text (if you'd like a response, please include your email) Follow us on: LinkedIn Bluesky X/Twitter Instagram Energy vs Climate relies on the support of our generous listeners Donate to keep Energy vs Climate going Produced by Bespoke Podcasts
May 14, 2026Episode 151 hr 3 min
Mapping the Next Energy Shock with The Economist's Vijay Vaitheeswaran
The aftershocks of the Iran war are reshaping energy markets, investment decisions, and climate politics in very different ways around the world. David, Sara, and Ed sat down with Vijay Vitheeswaran , Global Energy and Climate Innovation Editor at The Economist and 2025 Energy Writer of the Year, to discuss the shock rippling through energy markets since the war in Iran began. On one side are forces accelerating the energy transition like electrification, EV adoption, solar deployment, and rapidly scaling clean tech. On the other are forces pushing toward deeper fossil fuel lock in: energy security fears, coal expansion, oil investment surges, and persistent fossil fuel subsidies. Which force is actually winning? The conversation covered a lot of ground — from samosa vendors in Delhi packing up because cooking fuel tripled in price, to what a potential OPEC collapse could mean for the oil sands. This show's a great listen, especially if you're trying to make sense of a world where the energy transition and fossil fuel lock-in are happening simultaneously. About Our Guest: Vijay Vaitheeswaran is the Global Energy & Climate Innovation Editor of The Economist . He has produced numerous cover stories and won awards for his reporting. He is an accomplished public speaker and his three books have created a stir, with accolades ranging from lengthy reviews in The New Yorker to shortlisting for the FT/McKinsey Business Book of the Year prize. The Financial Times has declared him to be “a writer to whom it is worth paying attention.” Vijay is a Life Member of the Council on Foreign Relations. He serves as an advisor on innovation to the World Economic Forum/Davos, and has taught at NYU Stern Business School and Northwestern University. Vijay is an alumnus of Harvard Business School and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Send us a text (if you'd like a response, please include your email) Follow us on: LinkedIn Bluesky X/Twitter Instagram Energy vs Climate relies on the support of our generous listeners Donate to keep Energy vs Climate going Produced by Bespoke Podcasts
April 30, 2026Episode 1457 min
The Nuclear Option: A Canadian Reality Check with Jason Donev
Nuclear is having a global moment. But the story in Canada is a lot more complicated. David, Sara, and Ed sat down with Prof. Jason Donev of the University of Calgary for a full, unsparing look at where nuclear fits in a rapidly growing and electrifying Canadian grid. Jason is one of the clearest thinkers on energy systems in the country. He's also someone who started out opposed to nuclear and changed his mind. We set this episode up to tackle two questions. First, what is the case for new nuclear right now, given rising electricity demand from electrification, industry, and AI. And second, why Canada, despite decades of experience, has struggled to build new projects beyond Ontario and New Brunswick. A few things you'll hear about: Canada had a nuclear accident in 1952. Jimmy Carter helped clean it up. “Small” modular reactors can be up to 300 megawatts. A CANDU is closer to 700. “Small” is a relative term. Darlington’s BWRX-300 is a closely watched test case for Western SMRs. Will costs fall with follow-on units, or will nuclear repeat its Achilles heel and get more expensive? It turned into a lively and wide-ranging conversation on costs, timelines, small modular reactors, and the deeper issue that keeps coming up with nuclear. The physics may be solved, but the politics and institutions are not. About Our Guest: Prof. Jason Donev is a tenured professor teaching Energy Science and Physics at the University of Calgary. He leads EnergyEducation.ca , the world’s largest and most widely used energy resource for adults. Timestamps: (00:00) Introduction (02:20) Jason's journey from nuclear skeptic to advocate (06:53) A brief history of nuclear in Canada (12:39) Canada's nuclear accident record — what really happened (17:56) The global nuclear resurgence: 40 countries, tripling by 2050 (20:27) SMRs: hype vs. reality (22:58) Is nuclear being used to delay climate action? (30:09) Why Western nuclear costs are "a joke" — and what to do about it (31:57) Nuclear waste: real problem or political football? (36:06) Why nuclear needs BOTH big business AND big government (52:07) What should Canada actually do? 🔗 Related Episodes: ⚛️ The Nuclear Debate with Elizabeth May (S1, Ep. 10) 🔄 Turn the Tables Full References & Notes Send us a text (if you'd like a response, please include your email) Follow us on: LinkedIn Bluesky X/Twitter Instagram Energy vs Climate relies on the support of our generous listeners Donate to keep Energy vs Climate going Produced by Bespoke Podcasts
April 16, 202654 min
The Hosts in the Hot Seat: Turning the Tables on Ed and Sara
EvC Superfan and fellow energy nerd Robert Tremblay turns the tables on Sara and Ed — asking the questions the podcast usually doesn't: how EvC started, the energy transition over the 7 seasons of the show, what's changed, and whether any of it is working. They get into their backgrounds, the EvC origin story (are the rumours about Danielle Smith true?), how the show has evolved, and what they actually think about Canada's climate trajectory. Plus a rapid-fire round... well, at least as rapid-fire as EvC gets. Topic Timestamps 00:00:20 — Intro and episode setup 00:01:07 — Hosts' backgrounds before the podcast 00:07:09 — Origin story: how EvC came to be 00:12:56 — How things have changed since 2020: energy data and political landscape 00:23:04 — Is the Energy vs. Climate premise still relevant? 00:30:35 — Alberta/Canada focus vs. international scope 00:34:30 — Can Alberta lead the energy transition? 00:38:48 — Climate targets: useful or counterproductive? 00:43:00 — Rapid fire questions About Our Guest Host: Rob Tremblay is Policy Manager at Energy Storage Canada , where he leads policy analysis and advocacy efforts across Alberta while contributing to federal and technical policy initiatives nationally. He also Co-Chairs the Board of the Calgary Climate Hub. He's passionate about advancing the energy transition and is a frequent Energy vs Climate listener and questioner. Send us a text (if you'd like a response, please include your email) Follow us on: LinkedIn Bluesky X/Twitter Instagram Energy vs Climate relies on the support of our generous listeners Donate to keep Energy vs Climate going Produced by Bespoke Podcasts
Is this your show?
Claim this listing to keep it up to date, reach guests who want to pitch you, and manage bookings with Guestify.
