
Who Owns the Game? NIL and the Fight Over College Sports
Who decides what a college athlete’s talent is worth? In this episode, we welcome legendary litigator Jim Quinn, former head of litigation at Weil, Gotshal & Manges and founder of JW Quinn ADR, about the legal battles that have shaped athletes’ rights. Jim explains the changes his practice brought to sports, including professional free agency and revenue-linked salary caps. Jim then discusses the NCAA’s amateurism rules, the cases that challenged them, and how NIL collectives and direct school payments work. Jim challenges the position of universities regarding paying athletes for their name, image, and likeness, and explores how money is reshaping recruiting and transfers. Jim also opines on the Protect College Sports Act, whether collective bargaining offers a better way forward, and the challenges ahead for professional sports. Finally, Jim shares career lessons from decades of representing players and advice for young lawyers hoping to enter the field of sports law. Tune in to hear about the fight over who gets paid, who sets the rules, and whose interests those rules protect. Key Points From This Episode: Meet Jim Quinn and hear how he started his career in sports law. Discover why free agency increased franchise values and drove fan interest. Learn why the NBA salary cap on revenues mattered so much for players. Explore what the NCAA’s amateurism rules were and why they became a problem. Find out what NIL collectives do and how they get money to athletes. Understand the difference between money from schools and third-party NIL deals. Uncover why schools don’t want to classify their athletes as employees. See how schools put a fair market value on athletes and decide who gets paid. Hear why the transfer portal has fans worried and whether those fears are valid. What the Protect College Sports Act would limit and who it actually protects. Whether NIL money could become part of high school sports. The next big legal issues in pro sports and where AI might fit in. Jim shares advice on breaking into sports law and his early career lessons. Links Mentioned in Today’s Episode: Jim Quinn on LinkedIn JW Quinn ADR LLC Don’t Be Afraid to Win Protect College Sports Act The National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) NCAA Name, Image and Likeness Fordham University School of Law Corporate Law Center













