The Relevance Era Is Over: What Comes Next for the Church?
Nobody knows exactly what the next era of the church will look like. But there's one thing I'm convinced of: The relevance era is over. For decades, churches have tried to make Christianity more attractive by making church cooler. Better music. Better production. Cultural references. Trendier clothes. Different preaching styles. But what happens when making church cool isn't enough anymore? In Episode 6 of The Urban Pastor Podcast, Charlie Mitchell revisits a conversation originally recorded in 2022 about cultural relevance, spiritual formation, and what the next generation of churches must recover. The problem isn't that churches have engaged culture. The problem is that we've sometimes confused making Christianity appealing with actually teaching people how to follow Jesus. And we're living with the consequences. What's Covered The relevance era of the church. From the cultural shifts of the 1990s and early 2000s to Kirk Franklin, gospel hip-hop, and churches trying to become more approachable, Charlie examines the movement to make Christianity culturally attractive. How culture forms us. We're constantly shaped by the stories, values, and assumptions around us. Simply adopting cultural aesthetics doesn't necessarily challenge the deeper narratives shaping people's lives. The return to apprenticeship to Jesus. The next generation of churches must develop intentional ways to teach people how to follow Jesus, renew their minds, and grow toward spiritual maturity. The cost of non-discipleship. Drawing on a phrase associated with Mark Sayers and the themes of Dietrich Bonhoeffer's The Cost of Discipleship , Charlie explores what happens when people embrace Christianity without learning the practices and expectations of following Jesus. Why spiritual growth needs a process. Using the example of a personal trainer, Charlie explains why discipleship should prepare people for difficulty, discipline, sacrifice, and transformation—not simply promise that everything will get better. Why we need to start from scratch. Church leaders can no longer assume people understand biblical language, Christian beliefs, or how to practice their faith. We need to explain what we've spent generations assuming everybody already knows. Key Quotes “The relevance phase of the church is over.” “The next phase will include a deep and intentional apprenticeship to Jesus.” “What we're dealing with is the cost of non-discipleship.” “Stop making assumptions about people.” The Big Question Are we building churches that people think are cool, or are we developing people who are actually becoming like Jesus? Because those aren't necessarily the same thing. Watch the Original Teaching This conversation was originally recorded in 2022. Watch the video on YouTube: https://youtu.be/tYj2dmCuonA Connect With The Urban Pastor Explore Maroon House: https://bemaroon.com Connect with Charlie Mitchell: https://charliemitchell.me The Urban Pastor Podcast Faith. Culture. Cities. Real Life. No one changes a city alone.

