All Things AI with Allan Church
Allan Church, PhD, co-founder and managing partner of Maestro Consulting and a former PepsiCo talent executive, joins hosts Jackie Sahm and Blake Lepp to examine where AI can help talent management and where it risks amplifying weak practices. The conversation argues that organizations should clarify purpose, measurement content, tools, and decision use before automating, with particular caution around assessment, feedback, ranking, and career decisions. The three also examine where AI can and cannot support talent management, leadership assessment, and succession decisions. They argue that predictive models can reproduce historical survival and bias rather than reveal future potential, and that psychological expertise, critical thinking, and human judgment remain essential for setting strategy, validating measures, and governing how talent data is used. Connect with Allan on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/allanchurch/ Chapters 00:00 Meet Allan Church, PhD 05:05 Church’s AI adoption cycle: intrigue, hype, panic, reality 08:45 Why automation reveals talent-process misalignment 14:45 Where AI can support talent work, and where it should not lead 20:08 AI across selection, development, succession, and onboarding 25:39 Why algorithmic rankings can look scientific without valid content 28:37 What AI misses in Hogan feedback and personality interpretation 31:33 The 40-page AI report that contradicted expert assessment 33:35 Why feedback depends on context, disconnects, and human judgment 37:51 Match the tool and feedback approach to the purpose 39:22 Easy-button AI risks: accuracy, credibility, and privacy 40:33 Promotion prediction may measure organizational survival 43:15 Why executive performance ratings can be contaminated 45:30 Assess future capabilities, not just historical success 49:00 Define and measure leadership content with expertise 51:18 A digital-leadership model tests what leaders actually value 54:58 Sycophantic AI and the need for value-based judgment 56:56 Rethinking the nine-box approach to potential 01:02:32 Peer influence can become a leadership derailment 01:05:02 Why messy organizational data resists simple equations 01:08:20 Where AI fits - and which roles still need human judgment 01:09:32 The expertise paradox: automation can erase the talent bench 01:12:19 AI-generated assessments and the risk of commoditized science 01:17:27 How practitioners can tell research from pseudoscience 01:21:45 Four principles for responsible AI in talent management 01:23:54 Allan on introversion, practice, and building confidence



