
The Future of Insurance - AI in the Future of Claims at JCEA 2026
Episode Detail Recorded live in front of senior Claims leaders, this panel episode of The Future of Insurance brings together two founders rethinking long-standing parts of the property claim. Curtis Kincaid, Founder & CEO of Scopeworx, and Alexis Vertefeuille, Founder & CEO of Sinistar, join Bryan Falchuk to talk about where AI and market data are making a real difference in Claims today, and where they still fall short. Curtis explains why a general-purpose chatbot can't produce a roof estimate a carrier can defend, and how guided inspections and live, weekly labor and material pricing produce consistent results inside Xactimate and Cotality. Alexis describes how a bidding marketplace for temporary housing has sped up placements for displaced families while lowering costs, and why carriers should keep their data organized and in-house as owning their own AI becomes realistic. The conversation also covers AI bias versus human bias, the risk of AI "wrappers," slow adoption cycles, and how the adjuster's role is changing. Guest Bios Curtis Kincaid is the Founder & CEO of Scopeworx, a roof estimating marketplace that produces third-party, unbiased roofing estimates for property claims. He has more than 15 years of experience in insurance and restoration. From 2004 to 2018 he worked in catastrophe adjusting and management, and he then built and led a 17-person estimating firm that produced and settled more than 200,000 estimates. He founded Scopeworx to bring balance and speed to roof claims by giving carriers, contractors, adjusters, attorneys, and homeowners the same transparent, market-based pricing. Alexis Vertefeuille is the Founder & CEO of Sinistar, an AI-enabled temporary housing platform built for insurance claims. He started the company in Quebec after helping a friend's mother who had been displaced by a house fire and spent months in a hotel. He went on to build a bidding marketplace where vetted local hosts compete to house displaced policyholders in furnished homes. He holds a law degree from Université Laval, which he completed while founding Sinistar. He was named to the 2024 Forbes 30 Under 30 North America list in the Social Impact category. This episode was recorded live at the 2026 JCEA Annual Fall Meeting. Show Notes: Bringing the Market Into the Claim: Competition for every relocation: Sinistar invites hosts to bid on each temporary housing placement, which widens supply and, per Alexis, has lowered temporary housing prices by about 15%. Pricing that reflects today: Scopeworx tracks labor from about 3,500 contractors and pulls material pricing by API, updating every Friday, so estimates hold up even when a major CAT event moves the market. Historical data has its own bias: Curtis notes that carrier data built on past settlements reflects past guidelines and negotiations, which live market data helps avoid. Where General-Purpose AI Falls Short: Same prompt, five answers: Curtis's team ran an identical prompt through the same chatbot five times and got estimates up to 30% apart, a result no carrier could defend. AI where it fits: Scopeworx uses AI for routine work like letters, notes, and homeowner texts, and keeps guardrails on estimating, with guided inspections mapping directly to line items in Xactimate or Cotality. Beware the wrapper: Alexis cautions against tools that resell general-purpose models, and says trustworthy AI is trained on one specific decision, much as autonomous vehicles orchestrate task-specific agents. Bias, Trust, and Owning Your Data: The human side of bias: Bryan asks why AI bias draws scrutiny that human bias rarely does. Alexis sees a need for independent testing to show an AI isn't tilted toward profit or particular suppliers. Your model, your priorities: Alexis expects carriers to own or rent models trained on their own data, built around their own priorities on price, quality, or communication, and urges them to organize their data and keep it in-house. Two estimates, one choice: Scopeworx can build a carrier's guidelines into an estimate and also produce one without them, so adjusters can see a public adjuster's challenge coming. Carriers that don't want the second estimate can toggle it off. The Adjuster's Role Going Forward: Seven files an hour: One IA firm cut a 40-minute estimate-writing task to under five seconds, landing within about five cents of the handwritten result and lifting output from about one and a third files per hour to around seven. The decision stays human: Curtis wants adjusters to be more efficient, and points out that the settlement decision still belongs to the adjuster until laws and comfort levels change. Consistency across the street: Technology-driven estimates help keep neighbors with similar losses from getting very different results from the same carrier. The expertise pipeline: Bryan raises a longer-term concern: if AI takes the simpler claims, the Industry needs new ways to develop expertise in its next generation of adjusters. Advice for Claims Leaders: Speed of adoption matters: Curtis warns that tools change so quickly that slow evaluations miss the moment. One carrier took three and a half years to go from proof of concept to adoption. Get your data right: Alexis urges carriers to organize, classify, and name their data now, so they're ready as owning their own AI becomes affordable. Action today: Bryan closes with the point that there are real steps to take now, from preparing data to moving forward with solutions already having impact. This episode is brought to you by The Future of Insurance book series ( future-of-insurance.com ) from Bryan Falchuk. Follow the podcast at future-of-insurance.com/podcast for more details and other episodes. Music courtesy of Hyperbeat Music , available to stream or download on Spotify , Apple Music , and Amazon Music and more.














