The Playbook #5: Education and Values
Playbook 5- Education and Values Robert Frost in his memorable poem The Road Less Travelled writes: Two roads diverged in a wood, and I I took the road less travelled by And that has made all the difference. Words have meaning and words can serve to be a call to action. Robert Frost calls us to take the road less travelled. The road of transformative leadership calls leaders to understand the two roads diverging and calls the transformative leader to take the pro-democracy road, a road far too often less travelled. As Robert Frost writes so poignantly taking that road less travelled may make all the difference. In Playbook 5, we address education and values. Following the mid-term elections in the United States there was a resounding voice of pushback to autocracy and a loud voice for democracy. In Playbook 5 we look at a road less travelled, the Department of Education in the United States. A road that can make all the difference. It is a road of values. Background - Modern Department of Education President Jimmy Carter signed the Department of Education Organization Act on October 17, 1979. This Act (Public Law 96-88) divided the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare (HEW), into two cabinet level departments. Today, they are known as the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the Department of Education (ED). The intent was to provide efficiencies under one roof, rather than programs scattered across the previous HEW. The Department of Education was tasked to provide a focused commitment to equal education opportunities for all, supporting low-income students to receive the same educational opportunities as more financially able communities, to support students with disabilities, and to be the enforcement source for anti-discrimination laws. Was this vision for a separate cabinet level Department of Education worthy? Was it necessary? Story of the Yellow Bus- A young girl lived in the rural South. She lived down a dirt road and was surrounded by other black children in her low-income community. As a young child she would walk down her dirt road and wait to see the yellow bus come by and pick up school age children and take them to school. There were no children on her dirt road getting on the bus. She dreamed of a day when she could get on the bus, go to school, and receive an education the same as the white children. She wanted this for every black child in her community. So, yes this far too often repeated story across our nation was a compelling case then and it remains today. John Dewey- Educator and Philosopher John Dewy made the case for education to not just be about facts, figures, and their memorization, but on engagement, dialog, and critical thinking. What Dewey called experiential learning. Education should engage students, test ideas and offer periods of reflection to consider the outcomes. Engagement with real-world problems was John Dewy’s vision for education. Dewey offered his ideas with a core belief in pragmatism, but with the view that a school and a classroom should function as a mini society. Education should be founded on civic participation, just as democracy should. This should be the role for all, in a classroom, and in our communities. So, how did this play out? Where is the Department of Education today? What has the Trump administration done and what have they failed to do? President Trump has taken a multi-prong approach to dismantle the Department of Education. The primary vehicle to dismantle the ED has been funding, as closure would require congressional approval. The U.S. Department of Education Budget Service describes through their analysis the following likely outcomes following budget cuts: 420,000 teacher and staff jobs lost, resulting in larger class sizes and fewer support staff, 7.5 million students and their families would lose their support both at home and at school, 12 million students would lose access to technical education courses, 10 million students would be adversely affected by cuts to Pell Grants and federal student loan programs. And this is only the funding prong of the Trump effort to dismantle the ED. The Brookings Institution has concluded the following during the Trump administration: The Trump administration has eliminated the focus of the Office of Civil Rights (OCR) to transgender policies, reverse racial discrimination, and antisemitism. The ED has resolved zero cases of racial harassment against Black or Latino students. The Ed has resolved zero cases of sexual harassment or assault. Recent Court rulings have suggested that the ED has disregarded legal precedent and due process by withholding federal funding without following statutory requirements. This cameo of the current state of the ED makes clear the compelling case to revitalize the Department of Education. The Department of Education- Call for Transformative Change Ensure each of the following is revitalized, funded, and robustly supported. Equity in education funding, Ensure funding to low-income communities, Provide support to students with disabilities and their families, Provide civil rights enforcement to prevent discrimination and protect student access in schools, Revitalize, fund, and manage Pell Grants, student aid programs, and work-study programs to enable students to afford the costs of a quality education, and Collect and track data to better understand academic performance, and learning outcomes. These changes would be transformative when compared with the current policies of the ED. An active, engaged, and robust Depart of Education is vital for democracy to thrive. As Dewey said, schools are mini societies that enable democracy to function. They provide experiences, collaboration, and the critical thinking skills so needed in our world today. We are a nation of innovators, creators, and visionaries. Education is the foundation to solving the many challenges of our turbulent world. Education leads to discovery, advancement, and the improvement of the lives of people everywhere. Perhaps one of the greatest benefits of education is the statement that education makes about our values. Education makes clear who we are and what we care about. Education is a clear statement of our democratic values. Education speaks to our identity. Do we value facts, science, the needs of our neighbors? To care for one another, to care for those in need, and especially to be present and supportive in their quest for equality in education. This is a core value; we must celebrate as Americans. Education may be a seldom road travelled, but if we travel that road seldom travelled, it may make all the difference. Education speaks to our values, and our future depends on how we value education.



