Find partners
The Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors

The Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors

Hosted by Mindy Diamond Financial Advisor Recruiter and Consultant

Episodes

0

Language

EN-US

About the show

Launched in 2017 as Mindy Diamond on Independence, the show has taken on a broader perspective beyond the independent space to include topics, insights, and candid conversations around financial advisor transitions, growth, and an ever-changing industry landscape. Each episode is designed to offer objective guidance and actionable advice with some of the industry’s brightest movers and shakers.

Listen to episodes

60 recent
November 12, 2026Episode 38552 min

Under the Radar: How an Ex-Goldman Advisor Quietly Built an $8.5B RIA

Scott Neu, Co-Founder & CEO, Sage Mountain Former Goldman Sachs advisor Scott Neu shares how he built the $8.5B independent RIA Sage Mountain without acquisitions or traditional marketing, using a high-touch, client-first growth strategy that’s “a mile deep and an inch wide.” In Summary Scott Neu spent 18 years at Goldman Sachs building a nearly $3B wealth management business before an unexpected departure led him to co-found Sage Mountain. Eight years later, the independent multi-family office advises on approximately $8.5B for nearly 200 families, with growth driven by referrals rather than acquisitions or traditional marketing. In this episode, Scott joins Louis Diamond to discuss the service philosophy behind that growth, why he believes independence enables more comprehensive and less conflicted advice, and how Sage Mountain approaches everything from alternative investments to family office services. He also shares candid lessons about getting fired, becoming a CEO, and why, if he were leaving Goldman today, he might choose to join an established independent platform rather than start from scratch. The Storyline For Scott Neu, building an $8.5B independent wealth management firm was never about becoming a high-profile industry entrepreneur. In fact, Scott spent nearly two decades at Goldman Sachs, where he built a business managing close to $3B, and admits he might never have left had Goldman not fired him in 2018. The experience was humbling. But it also became the catalyst for building Sage Mountain, an independent multi-family office designed around a simple philosophy: Do what’s right for clients, even when it means giving up revenue in the short term. Today, Sage Mountain advises on approximately $8.5B for just under 200 families, with a team of roughly 40 professionals. Its advisors serve no more than about 35 clients each, delivering the kind of high-touch, comprehensive service Scott describes as being “a mile deep and an inch wide.” And the firm has achieved that growth without acquisitions, advisor lift-outs, or traditional marketing campaigns. Scott explains how exceptional service and longstanding relationships have become Sage Mountain’s primary growth engine, why the independent model allows the firm to offer advice and investment access differently, and how his thinking about business ownership has evolved. He also discusses the challenges of transitioning clients, building an investment platform, learning to delegate, and creating opportunities for other advisors to share in the enterprise’s value. With Sage Mountain now preparing to recruit established advisory teams, Scott offers a perspective that may surprise advisors considering independence: He believes in the opportunity more than ever, but says building an RIA from scratch may no longer be the smartest way to pursue it. Topics Covered Building an $8.5B independent RIA through organic growth and client referrals How Scott’s Navy experience and 18 years at Goldman Sachs shaped his leadership What defines a true multi-family office and Sage Mountain’s high-touch service model Turning exceptional client service into a sustainable financial advisor growth strategy How compensation structures, investment access, and conflicts influence client advice The unexpected lessons of being fired from Goldman Sachs What Scott learned about client transitions and launching an independent RIA Community-sourced alternative investments and leveraging client buying power Building enterprise value, delegating leadership, and sharing ownership Using AI to expand family office services and give clients back their time Sage Mountain’s next growth phase through advisor recruitment Why joining an established RIA platform may be preferable to starting from scratch > Download a transcript of this episode… This podcast features the CEO of Sage Mountain Advisors, LLC, a registered investment adviser with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. The content of this podcast is for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute investment advice, a solicitation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Nothing discussed should be construed as personalized advice for any individual listener. Opinions expressed are those of the speaker as of the date of recording and are subject to change without notice. All information is believed to be from reliable sources, but no representation is made as to its completeness or accuracy. Past performance is not a guarantee or indicator of future results. Listeners should not act on any information in this podcast without first consulting a qualified financial, legal, or tax professional. For more information about Sage Mountain Advisors, LLC, including investment strategies, fees or objectives can be found in their Form ADV Part 2 and Form CRS which is available on the firm’s website: www.sagemountainadvisors.com . Listen and Learn Highlights for Advisors What does “a mile deep and an inch wide” mean for an $8.5B family office? (06:39) Scott explains Sage Mountain’s minimum-fee model, advisor capacity limits, and commitment to serving a relatively small number of ultra-high-net-worth families. How can exceptional client service become a firm’s primary growth strategy? (08:15) From 24/7 responsiveness to coordinating complex family needs, Scott describes how investing more time in existing clients generates referrals and supports organic growth. What can independent advisors do differently when compensation is aligned with client outcomes? (12:37) Scott shares a private equity allocation experience that illustrates why he wanted greater freedom to act in clients’ interests without relying on transaction-based compensation. How did Scott build a nearly $3B business at Goldman Sachs without cold marketing? (17:02) He discusses networking, influential client relationships, consistent follow-through, and the cumulative effect of earning referrals over decades. Why does Scott wish Goldman Sachs had fired him five years earlier? (20:43) He reflects on the experience that humbled him, changed his leadership philosophy, and ultimately pushed him toward independence. Would Scott launch an independent RIA from scratch if he were making the move today? (22:21) Despite Sage Mountain’s success, he explains why established RIA platforms now offer advisors an attractive combination of infrastructure, ownership, and upside. How did independence change Sage Mountain’s growth potential? (25:39) Scott compares nearly $3B accumulated over 18 years at Goldman with approximately $8.5B after eight years at Sage Mountain, explaining how broader services strengthened the client offering. What are community-sourced alternative investments? (27:13) Scott describes how clients share investment opportunities, Sage Mountain conducts diligence, and the firm uses aggregated buying power to negotiate better economics. What changes when a successful financial advisor becomes a CEO? (34:57) Scott discusses the difficulty of delegating, hiring specialists, and developing a leadership team that allows him to concentrate on clients and business development. How can AI strengthen the future multi-family office model? (39:36) Scott explains why Sage Mountain intends to reinvest technology-driven efficiencies into services that save clients time and deepen relationships. What’s next for Sage Mountain’s advisor recruiting strategy? (45:45) With its first Chief Growth Officer in place, the firm is looking to add established advisors and teams while preserving its service-driven culture. What should experienced wirehouse advisors consider before pursuing independence? (48:06) Scott offers advice on timing, transition challenges, enterprise value, and why he now favors joining an established platform over building everything independently. Key Takeaways Exceptional client service can be a deliberate growth strategy. Sage Mountain’s growth illustrates how consistently delivering a superior client experience can create a referral engine. Scott views the additional time and resources spent serving clients as an investment in future growth, even when that approach reduces short-term margins. A differentiated multi-family office model requires more than an expanded menu of services. Sage Mountain’s approach is built around responsiveness, limited advisor capacity, and taking responsibility for coordinating solutions across a family’s financial life. The objective is not simply to offer more services, but to deliver them with meaningful depth and accountability. Independence can change both the economics and the scope of advice. Scott describes how Sage Mountain’s advice-based compensation model allows it to evaluate investments, negotiate terms, and coordinate services without relying on the transaction economics he encountered at a large firm. That flexibility has helped shape its client offering and growth. The most difficult career disruptions can lead to valuable changes in perspective. Scott is unusually candid about his departure from Goldman Sachs, including his own shortcomings as an employee. He credits the experience with changing how he treats colleagues, leads the firm, and approaches relationships. Building an independent RIA and owning an independent business are no longer the same decision. Scott believes advisors can increasingly access sophisticated investment platforms, technology, reporting, and operational support without building those capabilities themselves. For someone leaving a wirehouse today, joining an established RIA may offer substantial ownership potential with less startup risk. Sustainable enterprise growth requires giving up control. As Sage Mountain expanded, Scott learned to delegate to specialists and develop leadership capabilities beyond his own expertise. His long-term vision includes creating meaningful ownership opportunities for the people who help build the firm. The next competitive advantage may be giving wealthy families more time. Scott sees AI as a way to free up resources that can be reinvested in new services, rather than simply reducing expenses. From coordinating property management to improving next-generation education, his ambition is to make Sage Mountain increasingly valuable in clients’ everyday lives. https://youtu.be/wXkG70wP5p0 Quotable Moments “We limit our advisors to no more than 35 clients, and so we’re a mile deep and an inch wide.” — Scott Neu (06:39) “We want the best, not the most convenient.” — Scott Neu (09:43) “Everyone plays a role in new business by delivering a good experience to our existing clients.” — Scott Neu (10:36) “I don’t need to be paid now.” — Scott Neu (13:46) “In retrospect, I wish they would’ve fired me five years earlier.” — Scott Neu (21:34) “We used our buying power to benefit the client, not put the money in our pocket.” — Scott Neu (28:29) “My only regret is I didn’t do it five years earlier.” — Scott Neu (49:10) FAQs How did Scott Neu grow Sage Mountain to $8.5B without acquisitions? Scott attributes Sage Mountain’s growth primarily to referrals generated through longstanding relationships and exceptional client service. Rather than relying on traditional marketing or acquisitions, the firm invests heavily in responsiveness, comprehensive advice, and serving existing families. At the time of the interview, Sage Mountain had completed no acquisitions or advisor lift-outs. What is Sage Mountain, and how does its multi-family office model work? Sage Mountain is an independent multi-family office co-founded by Scott Neu and Tony Cox. It advises on approximately $8.5B for just under 200 families. The firm offers investment management, tax and estate planning coordination, alternative investment diligence, and broader family office services. Advisors generally serve no more than 35 clients, with a minimum annual fee of approximately $100,000 rather than a fixed asset minimum. Why did Scott Neu leave Goldman Sachs to start an independent RIA? Scott was fired from Goldman Sachs in 2018 after spending 18 years building a substantial private wealth management business. He acknowledges that his own behavior contributed to the departure. The experience prompted him to co-found Sage Mountain, where he could develop a more comprehensive, client-focused advice model and create long-term enterprise value. What are the advantages of independence for financial advisors serving ultra-high-net-worth clients? Scott believes independence provides greater flexibility to coordinate holistic advice, access investments outside traditional firm platforms, negotiate terms, and align compensation more directly with client outcomes. At Sage Mountain, that flexibility supports services extending beyond portfolio management into tax, estate, lending, and broader family needs. What are community-sourced alternative investments? At Sage Mountain, community-sourced alternative investments involve clients sharing private investment opportunities with the firm. Sage Mountain evaluates those opportunities and, when appropriate, aggregates client capital to negotiate more favorable terms. The approach can expand investment access while using the firm’s collective buying power to benefit participating clients. Is it better to start an independent RIA or join an established RIA platform? Scott says that although building Sage Mountain from scratch ultimately succeeded, he would probably choose a different path today. He believes joining an established independent platform can provide access to investment capabilities, reporting, operations, and technology while allowing advisors to earn meaningful equity without bearing all the costs and challenges of launching a new firm. How is Sage Mountain planning to grow beyond referrals? Sage Mountain hired Danica Griffith as Chief Growth Officer to develop an advisor recruitment strategy. Scott describes plans to bring established advisors and teams onto the firm’s platform, initially focusing on advisor lift-outs rather than acquisitions. The goal is to support transitions while offering incoming advisors opportunities to participate in the firm’s equity value. How does Sage Mountain plan to use AI in its family office business? Scott sees AI as a tool for improving operational efficiency and expanding services rather than simply cutting costs. Sage Mountain is using technology to streamline functions such as money movement and onboarding, with the intention of reinvesting the time saved into more personalized services that help clients manage complex financial and personal responsibilities. Scott attributes Sage Mountain’s growth primarily to referrals generated through longstanding relationships and exceptional client service. Rather than relying on traditional marketing or acquisitions, the firm invests heavily in responsiveness, comprehensive advice, and serving existing families. At the time of the interview, Sage Mountain had completed no acquisitions or advisor lift-outs. Sage Mountain is an independent multi-family office co-founded by Scott Neu and Tony Cox. It advises on approximately $8.5B for just under 200 families. The firm offers investment management, tax and estate planning coordination, alternative investment diligence, and broader family office services. Advisors generally serve no more than 35 clients, with a minimum annual fee of approximately $100,000 rather than a fixed asset minimum. Scott was fired from Goldman Sachs in 2018 after spending 18 years building a substantial private wealth management business. He acknowledges that his own behavior contributed to the departure. The experience prompted him to co-found Sage Mountain, where he could develop a more comprehensive, client-focused advice model and create long-term enterprise value. Scott believes independence provides greater flexibility to coordinate holistic advice, access investments outside traditional firm platforms, negotiate terms, and align compensation more directly with client outcomes. At Sage Mountain, that flexibility supports services extending beyond portfolio management into tax, estate, lending, and broader family needs. At Sage Mountain, community-sourced alternative investments involve clients sharing private investment opportunities with the firm. Sage Mountain evaluates those opportunities and, when appropriate, aggregates client capital to negotiate more favorable terms. The approach can expand investment access while using the firm’s collective buying power to benefit participating clients. Scott says that although building Sage Mountain from scratch ultimately succeeded, he would probably choose a different path today. He believes joining an established independent platform can provide access to investment capabilities, reporting, operations, and technology while allowing advisors to earn meaningful equity without bearing all the costs and challenges of launching a new firm. Sage Mountain hired Danica Griffith as Chief Growth Officer to develop an advisor recruitment strategy. Scott describes plans to bring established advisors and teams onto the firm’s platform, initially focusing on advisor lift-outs rather than acquisitions. The goal is to support transitions while offering incoming advisors opportunities to participate in the firm’s equity value. Scott sees AI as a tool for improving operational efficiency and expanding services rather than simply cutting costs. Sage Mountain is using technology to streamline functions such as money movement and onboarding, with the intention of reinvesting the time saved into more personalized services that help clients manage complex financial and personal responsibilities. Related Resources When Growth Starts Working Against Your Business The RIA Builder’s Blueprint Build, Grow & Transact: David Bahnsen on Building a $10.5B Business Worth Selling Scott Neu, CFA Co-Founder Chief Executive Officer Partner Prior to founding Sage Mountain , Scott worked at Goldman Sachs as a Managing Director in the Private Wealth Management division. He has over 20 years experience working closely with individuals, families, and institutions to advise them on investments, intergenerational planning, and philanthropy. He holds an MBA from the Owen Graduate School of Management at Vanderbilt University with a concentration in finance, and he is a CFA charter holder. Early in his career, Scott enlisted for five years in the U.S. Navy as a nuclear power operator on the USS Salt Lake City and a staff instructor at a nuclear prototype facility. Scott serves on the Board of Directors for Danita’s Children which provides resources to impoverished children in Haiti. Scott is also an Eagle Scout and is currently the Assistant Scoutmaster for Troop 197. He lives in Atlanta with his wife and three children. In his free time, Scott enjoys working out and alpine skiing. NOTE: The views and opinions expressed by the guests on this podcast are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Diamond Consultants. Neither Diamond Consultants nor the guests on this podcast are compensated in any way for their participation. View the transcript of this episode… Under the Radar: How an Ex-Goldman Advisor Quietly Built an $8.5B RIA Scott Neu, Co-Founder & CEO, Sage Mountain Louis Diamond (00:05): Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is Under the Radar: How an Ex-Goldman Advisor Quietly Built an Eight and a Half Billion Dollar RIA. It’s a conversation with Scott Neu, co-founder and CEO Sage Mountain Advisors. I’m Louis Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond (00:28): At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. (01:20): Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport. Louis Diamond (01:54): There are plenty of ways to grow an advisory business. You can market, you can acquire, you can recruit, or you can take a much simpler approach, do really good work for people, take care of them, and trust that over time they’ll tell other people. Simple doesn’t mean easy, but when it works, the compounding effect can be pretty extraordinary. My guest today, Scott Neu, is co-founder and CEO of Sage Mountain Advisors, an independent multifamily office managing some eight and a half billion for just under 200 families. Scott spent 18 years at Goldman Sachs where he built a business managing close to three billion in assets before an unexpected turn ended his career there. He’ll tell you very candidly that getting fired humbled him, changed the way he thought about the business and people, and ultimately gave him the push to build something different. Eight years later, Sage Mountain has grown almost entirely through referrals, without acquisitions, and with an intentionally high-touch model Scott describes as a mile deep and an inch wide. (02:59): What I find most interesting is that there’s no complicated growth formula behind it. Scott believes that doing the right thing for clients, even when it means sacrificing revenue or margin in the short term, ultimately creates a better client experience, more referrals, and a stronger business. We talk about what he learned at Goldman, what independence has allowed him to do differently, how Sage Mountain built a family office offering around the needs of ultra-high net worth families, and why knowing what he knows today. Scott says he probably wouldn’t build an RIA from scratch again. It’s a fascinating look at what can happen when service, growth, and enterprise value all start the same basic idea, do right by people and build from there. So let’s get to it. Scott, thanks for joining us today. Scott Neu (03:46): My pleasure. Thanks for having me. Louis Diamond (03:48): Let’s dive in. In pre-recording, you mentioned this is your first podcast and first real interview ever, so we are honored that you’re here and to learn more about Sage Mountain and the amazing firm that you built. Scott Neu (04:00): Thank you so much for having me. Yeah, I’ve not really done much of this, but I have high regard for your podcast and so I figured if I was going to do it, I wanted to do my first one with you. Louis Diamond (04:08): That means a lot. So before getting into your time at Goldman and building your firm, you had definitely a different background than most folks. Spent five years in the Navy as a nuclear power operator. Can you talk about that experience and how’d you go from that into the great world of private wealth management? Scott Neu (04:27): Yeah, it’s definitely a different path. I grew up in a family where we didn’t have the means for me to go to college, and so I joined the Navy out of high school. That was my real purpose of joining the military. I ended up running nuclear power plants on a submarine on the West Coast, and I was in for five years, got out and used my GI bill to go to University of Wyoming, which is the closest university to where I grew up, and got an engineering degree. And then from there went to Vanderbilt, got an MBA. During my MBA, Goldman came to town and had a non-finance concentrator dinner and informed people about wealth management and sounded interesting to me. And so I worked really hard, got an internship there in ’99 and got a full-time offer in 2000 and didn’t know anybody in Atlanta, didn’t really know how to find clients, and just came to Atlanta in 2001 after the training program and started building a business at Goldman. Louis Diamond (05:25): Amazing. Yeah, honestly, credit to Goldman and firms like it for thinking outside the box because there’s so many amazing individuals with non-traditional backgrounds who end up building insanely impressive businesses like yours. It’s amazing how everything lines up that way. Scott Neu (05:41): Thank you. Louis Diamond (05:41): Is there anything from your Navy background that still shows up in how you run Sage Mountain today or how you ran your team at Goldman even? Scott Neu (05:50): Yeah, I mean different things from different places. Super high attention to detail is one. Military gave me discipline and work ethic. Goldman taught me responsiveness, collaboratory work, so taking all of those things and blending them in is part of our DNA at Sage Mountain. Louis Diamond (06:09): Very cool. I like that. And also humility. I’ve caught that in the brief amount of time that we’ve had to spend together. Scott Neu (06:16): We’ve been very blessed. I’m very grateful. Life has a way of giving you lumps when you need to get them, and I’ve gotten my share and I live very differently now. I’m very grateful for everything we’ve been blessed to have. Louis Diamond (06:27): Can you give us a snapshot of your firm today? Assets, size of the team, what types of families you serve, really anything just to give our listeners some context before we really dive into how you built the firm. Scott Neu (06:39): Yeah, we’re hiring a bunch of people right now, so I’m not sure who’s exactly accepted and who isn’t. So I’m going to tell you between 37 and 40 people right now, all in Atlanta, we will open offices in other places in the future for sure. Assets-wise, we advise on a little over eight billion, eight half billion-ish, and our families, we don’t really have a minimum asset. It’s more of a minimum fee is $100,000 a year, and so that’s kind of how we deliver our services is we reverse engineer how much time are we going to dedicate to every slot and then price it from that. We limit our advisors to no more than 35 clients, and so we’re a mile deep and an inch wide. Louis Diamond (07:23): Very interesting. I like that approach too, of not having a hard and fast minimum, but having a minimum fee because I think it’s intentional, right? It shows that you know how much your time is worth, you know how much your advisor capacity is worth, and maybe there’s someone with five million bucks who could be a billion dollar client one day and they want your types of services, so why exclude them from the mix? Scott Neu (07:44): Exactly right. Louis Diamond (07:45): I know from your website that you position Sage Mountain as a multifamily office. It sounds like it very much is, but the industry I think very much overuses the term multifamily office. Anyone who’s doing planning and cares a lot that now says they’re a multifamily office or they provide multifamily office services. So what does it mean to you? And at Sage Mountain, what services or what do you do that makes it a family office or multifamily office in your opinion? Scott Neu (08:15): Part of our DNA is I tell people here, we’re generally the highest paid employee for the families we work for, so try to act like it. And what that means to us is you’re pretty much available 24/7. Weekends, it doesn’t matter, nights doesn’t matter. And our clients know that if they text us, they’re going to get a text back or an email right away, and so responsiveness is part of our DNA. When it comes to services, we pretty much tell people we’ll help you with anything that touches money. It tends to evolve beyond that, family dynamics, helping people get into schools, get into hospitals and get specialized treatment, using our network through our clients to help. We always say Sage family takes care of Sage family, and that’s not the employees, it’s also the clients and we all help each other. It’s one of the things I’m probably the most proud of. So we advise on tax, trust, and estate. People ask all the time, “Do you have an in-house attorney?” (09:09): I have found the best attorneys are out there actually practicing and they’re in front of the most cutting edge stuff and they’re not being filtered through an organization’s compliance machine saying what’s appropriate to show people and what isn’t. And so we tend to just say, “Look, we know we have a lot of trust and estate knowledge and tax knowledge in-house, but we try to find the best expert for solving that problem.” (09:35): Versus have the in-house person be a generalist and say, “Do all this discovery conversation and then giving three names and saying you’re on your own.” (09:43): And so we run the process for mortgages with multiple banks, not just the bank we were attached to. So we want the best, not the most convenient. And so it’s a different approach. It requires more time. We sacrifice margin to be able to deliver that, but we also have been blessed to grow and we don’t have to advertise because our clients, delivering clients a good experience and doing it repetitively over and over again converts our client base into our sales force. Louis Diamond (10:15): I love that. I think it’s exactly right. I mean, another way to think of it is the customer acquisition cost is zero. Obviously you spend a lot of time and energy and it’s all very well-earned, but I’ve always found that being able to predictably grow the business through client referrals by providing great service, that’s a strategy that’s as old as time and it never goes out of favor. Scott Neu (10:36): That’s right. And everybody here, not just the advisors, play an extremely important role, whether it’s account opening and onboarding, whether it’s sending wires in a timely fashion, whether it’s enforcing our security protocol to make sure wires go where they’re supposed to go, it’s investment advice, it’s tax advice, it’s trust and estate advice. Everyone plays a role in new business by delivering a good experience to our existing clients. Louis Diamond (11:00): Makes sense. How have you organized the firm? What’s the org chart? So you’re the founder and CEO. I know you recently hired a chief growth officer, which we’ll talk about, but how many advisors are there and what are the other disciplines or full-time employees that you have? Scott Neu (11:16): We’re hiring a lot of people, so I’ll get this wrong a little bit because it’s in flux. I have six other advisors besides me, and like I said, they’re limited to around 35 clients per, and right now we work with around just shy of 200 families. So that’s the advisory team. Each advisory team has a portfolio manager, which is usually a very seasoned CFA type person who oversees ideas that we push in front of clients from the investment team, implementing the portfolios and preparing for any kind of client deliverable when it touches investments, analysts that support that, client service people that support those teams, and we always have compliance folks that help us make sure that we do things correctly and in accordance with what SEC wants, and that’s kind of how we’re set up. The investment committee is chaired by my partner, Tony Cox. (12:16): Tony was my analyst when we started this. He and I co-founded the firm together and we took a lot of what we learned at Goldman and replicated it, but we tried to cut out all the things we didn’t like about it. And that’s the beauty of the independent channel. Louis Diamond (12:32): What would be an example of cutting out the stuff that you didn’t like or trimming the fat, if you will? Scott Neu (12:37): Here’s our real story. When I was working for a wirehouse, we had a big LBO fund that was very highly regarded, come in and give us meaningful access. It was fund four and it went fine. We had a client come in with about a hundred and some million bucks and he was like, “I want to invest in private equity and this fund is really good.” (12:58): Well, fund five came around after this guy had become a client, and the fund gave, where I worked, far less allocation that time. And so the way the firm gated it or allocated that access, which was more scarce, is they said if you weren’t in fund four, you had to be in fund five, you couldn’t be in fund five. So this guy got frozen out because of just the timing which he became a client. So we knew it had been approved on the platform or it wouldn’t be even allocated to anybody. (13:27): And so we called this fund direct and said, “Hey, can we get a $10 million order for this guy?” (13:33): As you would expect, they said, “Absolutely.” (13:37): It wasn’t 15 minutes, and I was getting a phone call saying, “You can’t do this. You’re not going to get paid on it. We’re not going to get paid on it.” (13:46): The thought process for me has always been, “I don’t need to be paid now. I know that if this guy goes in, he puts $10 million there, it’s probably going to turn into 50. He’s going to remember I did the right thing and I’m going to get 50 to manage in seven years, and he’s probably going to refer me a couple clients along the way because I did the right thing for him and not what was right for me.” (14:06): That’s a difference. I don’t get paid that way, right? I love the fact that we recommend investments to people, but if they say like a private equity fund, I got paid a percentage of every dollar that went in that I got people to do. Now it’s like I’m telling you to do this because I think it’s going to make you money and if it makes you money, two things are probably going to happen. Number one is I get a charge a fee on a bigger number. Number two is you’re going to be happy and refer me business. Pretty simple. Louis Diamond (14:34): I’m sure that was part of your thesis or your motivation to going into the independent world was getting away from some of those dynamics of fund subscriptions and limited allocations and really being a true fiduciary for very wealthy families. Scott Neu (14:50): Look, big firms have amazing access. We have access to things they can’t do because they’re too big. And so it’s not just access, it’s allocation. So recently I know of someone at a big wirehouse that put in for an allocation to Anthropic. He has over $100 million there. He asked for $750,000 of Anthropic and he got 70 grand. So access is one thing. Allocation, you have to have both. These big wirehouses are not going away. They do a fine job for a set of clients, but you don’t need to be a genius to figure out that the winds are blowing towards the independent channel. All you have to do is read AdvisorHub or what you guys talk about, and you know that the flow of advisors is moving away from wirehouses to the independent channel. I’m not read, I’m not saying it doesn’t exist, but I’ve not read many advisors that are independent going to wirehouses. Louis Diamond (15:41): Yeah, I think some of it is different strokes for different folks, and for some people there’s elements of what the big firms provide that is extremely valuable or to start off the name and the business card and that access is very important. And then as the business grows and matures, it changes. Scott Neu (15:59): I am grateful from the opportunity that Goldman Sachs gave me. We would not have the success at Sage Mountain if I didn’t spend time there. The people I met, what I learned. The flip side is as you get more and more mature at a wirehouse and build a book, most people know that people are doing business with them in the latter stages of their careers at a wirehouse more because of the advisor and less because of the business card. And so people that wake up and they’re 40 years old, it’s literally probably never been easier to go independent. And if you’re going to continue to work for another 15 years anyway, going independent is absolutely the way to go if you want to provide a better experience for your clients and actually create real wealth for yourself in the future. Louis Diamond (16:41): Yep. Well said. Going back to your time at Goldman, so you said when you joined the firm out of Vanderbilt with an internship, you had no idea how to get clients, you moved down to Atlanta where you weren’t from. So how’d you build such a successful book at Goldman? Essentially, what was the growth playbook that Goldman taught you or that you kind of self-taught or learned on the job? Scott Neu (17:02): Yeah, so I didn’t ever really cold market. I just spent a ton of time networking. And my first client came from networking with somebody I went to business school with whose wife worked for a family office, and the family office was looking for another investment advisor, and through that relationship, I got an opportunity, and it happened to be a relationship with a wonderful human who I worked extremely hard for, and he took me under his wing, and he helped me meet a ton of people in town because he credentialized me. So networking, a little luck in your network, getting the right client that has influence in the community, and then doing a really good job for that person for a long time, and then building a referral network from one or two clients. So I never really made cold calls. We just work really hard for people and do a good job and they help you out. Louis Diamond (17:53): Yep. When you break it down like that, it sounds easy, but I know especially given the client minimums at Goldman, starting off fresh, getting people to trust you, you definitely can’t take that for granted. I think you’re a humble guy, so you make it sound like it’s not that challenging to do and we don’t market, et cetera, but it’s your own form of marketing, right? It’s your own personal brand and reputation that you’re cultivating and sharing instead of through newspaper ads or online, you’re doing it through word of mouth with people you do a really good job for. Scott Neu (18:25): Yeah, that’s exactly right. And make no mistake, I’m not saying it’s easy because it’s not. I’ll give a shout-out to my wife. Last year she went to 40 client or prospect dinners, so we sacrifice a Friday or Saturday almost every weekend. That’s an extra day of networking for 25 years we’ve had we put in the time. So it’s the cumulative effect of that is a bigger network of people that want to help you. Louis Diamond (18:48): Yeah, it’s the compounding effect of doing the right thing over and over again and working a little bit harder than the guy next to you, but that compounds over time. Very cool. So given what you built at Goldman, I’m sure it was a good enough experience, the brand, the platform, et cetera. Why’d you consider leaving and leave in 2018 to begin with? Scott Neu (19:09): Yeah, so when I left in 2018, I had several opportunities to choose from. Multiple wirehouses were willing to provide very substantial checks upfront to go work with them. And my partner Tony and I had talked about building a firm, an independent firm on our own because we were like, “We think we’re pretty good at this. We’re winning inside even with all these constraints, competitive constraints internally of a big firm.” (19:37): The reason I chose to go build this from scratch with Tony was I think when I hang up my cleats and I pray it’s not for a long time, that something that I think is a more admirable story is instead of me going to a wirehouse and getting tens of millions of dollars, instead let’s go work harder for a long time and not just Scott creates wealth for Scott, but we build something that creates a bunch of wealth for other people not named Scott. And frankly, people ask me all the time, “What’s the vision for the firm?” (20:10): And it’s not, “Hey, I’m going to go try to sell this to private equity and cash out.” To me, I want to continue to dilute to people that are going to grow value of this company and fade out and let them run it for as long as they can. Louis Diamond (20:21): Very cool. In order though to get to the point of getting offers from wirehouses, being in the zone to even think about launching your own RIA, were there a confluence of frustrations or pain points or what really motivated you to step out? Scott Neu (20:43): Goldman fired me. I’ll say this, I wasn’t a great employee, and to be honest with you, I wouldn’t want an employee like I was at Goldman, honestly. I made it easier for them to let me go than they should, than I needed to, but it was a great thing for me. I didn’t feel great when it happened, but what it did is humble me, and what it did is make me realize that things are fragile, that rules apply, that you can’t take anything for granted. So I took that scar tissue and I carry it with me, and I live life very differently. This organization, we truly love each other. People I get to work with, I’m blessed to work with, know I really care about them, and the clients know we really care about them. I was blessed to build a very successful business at Goldman. (21:34): Honestly, I’m not sure I would’ve ever left. In retrospect, I wish they would’ve fired me five years earlier, but they didn’t. I probably deserved it, but they finally did it, and I will say it was good for me not just building this place, but it was good for me as a person. Louis Diamond (21:49): First off, thank you for being humble and being vulnerable. When we hear from advisors who have been fired or let go for whatever reason, my wisdom, which I firmly believe, which you just validated, is things happen for a reason, kind of feels random and unfair and unreasonable right now, and it’s super stressful and your clients are kind of in the wind, but you’ll look back on this and you’ll be grateful for the opportunity because it gave you the push that you wouldn’t have had otherwise, or it gave you a new perspective on things that is only going to make you better. Scott Neu (22:21): Totally agree with that. I’m very blessed. I’m so grateful. There were about 24 months where I wasn’t very grateful. You start to get some traction and building a business is not easy at all. If I was to leave and do this again, let’s say I’m back and I leave Goldman today, I’m not sure I would build a company from scratch because there’s so many offerings now, platform, we’re one of them, where an advisor can leave, come to us, we’re going to lean in hard to make that person successful because like I said, compensation drives behavior and everybody partner takes a pay cut when someone comes here, we’re going to shoulder in and make them successful, and I’m proud of every advisor we’ve hired has crushed it. (23:08): I think I would probably take a bolt onto something like us that’s already got the investment platform, already has the reporting down, is growing quickly, so we know the market is saying this is a good offering, and advisors can come here and literally earn as much equity as they can earn through production. So you get not only the income, but you’re creating terminal value of your business that’s substantially higher than any kind of buyout or retirement package you get at a wirehouse. So I would join someone like Sage Mountain. I would not go do this from the beginning, probably. Louis Diamond (23:43): Interesting. So being a business owner and calling your own shots, having your own brand, that wasn’t and isn’t the guiding light. Scott Neu (23:51): I’ve never chased awards. I don’t go to panels. I don’t go to conferences. I don’t really care about Scott Neu being in lights. I care about my faith, my family, our clients, my employees, and delivering a good experience for them. That’s all I focus on. Louis Diamond (24:05): Fair enough. The clients that followed you from Goldman, how did they initially respond to the move? Scott Neu (24:11): It’s in different waves. First of all, you have the people that say, “We love you. You’ve done a great job for my family. We’ll follow you wherever. Just tell us where we got to go.” (24:19): Then you have another group of people who are like, “We love you, but we want to see this is going to be a going concern. We want to watch it succeed for 12 to 24 months.” (24:28): And in that group, you have some leakage because this momentum takes over. Even though you’ve proven to them you’re a going concern, you’re still going to have some leakage. One thing anyone thinking about leaving should know is you’re going to be surprised on both sides. People that you have literally laid entrapped for 20 years are going to say, “No, I’m not going to come with you.” (24:47): And people that you didn’t pay enough attention to and you though we’re not even going to call will come with you. It’s very odd. I have found no rhyme or reason in migrating my book from Goldman here, let’s just say that. And then the next wave post 24 months on the, “We want to see it be a going concern and then we’ll come,” is it’s just a knife fight. It’s like you’re going to go and you’re going to show you can do more things with less conflicts and better reporting and better holistic advice, and you chip away at the offering and wait for an opening and hopefully the client makes the choice to come work for you, work with you. Sorry. Louis Diamond (25:21): Makes sense. How much, and this is an impossible hypothetical, but how much or what percentage of your business today do you think you would’ve had if you stayed at Goldman? If it’s 2026, you’re still at Goldman versus today, eight billion and growing at Sage Mountain? Scott Neu (25:39): Here’s a different way to look at it. I was at Goldman for 18 years and at the end managed real close to three billion. We’ve been at Sage Mountain for eight years and two months and we’re close to eight and a half billion. That’s a more recent real number. I don’t think I’ve become just a much better salesperson. The reason is because we can do so many things. When I was at a wirehouse, you advise pretty much on the performance of the assets you manage, and that’s about the limited of the conversation. When you move to the independent channel, the table stakes are you will advise me on tax, trust and estate, bill pay, all kinds of things, and the incremental cost is not that material. So most people are like, “If I can get all these extra services that I can’t get at a big wirehouse, why would I not do that?” (26:26): A lot of people hire us for continuity, right? When I worked for a wirehouse, I played a piece of the web. I managed the money that was at the wirehouse. I didn’t generally have visibility on everything else because that becomes the advice business versus selling suitable securities business. And big wirehouses don’t want to do that because they give up a lot of revenue on the broker-dealer side if they move into a peer advisory role, and so it’s follow the money. And so when you move to the advice business, you can give people advice holistically. It’s very difficult to do at a wirehouse. I’m not saying nobody can do it, but it’s not the core business. Louis Diamond (27:04): Makes sense. I saw that you describe your alternatives offering as, and I quote, “community sourced.” What does that really mean and how does it work? Scott Neu (27:13): We have three rules, but one of the rules for clients when they sign up, we give them very quickly, is you show us every deal you’re shown. So roughly we’re approaching 200 families. Those families have obviously had meaningful liquidity events of real estate or private businesses or whatever, and the market’s efficient, deals find them. And so, one of the things we ask every client is, “Do you promise to send us every deal that you’re shown? We’ll help you diligence it. If we like it, we’re going to take a bigger bite than you’re going to do that, and we’re going to squeeze fees for everybody.” (27:47): If funds come to us and say, “Hey, I’m raising X million dollars,” or if fund comes to us and says, “Hey, if you’ll place $50 million with us, we’ll pay you 2% placement fee.” (27:58): We purposely set up our business to not have a broker dealer because we want to be pure in how we’re compensated, just for the advice only. But if we like the fund and we decide we’re going to put 50 million with it, we’ll ask them to sign a side letter and pay it to our LPs because they’ve already said they’ve budgeted a million bucks. We can’t take it, but it’s on the table. Why would we not get a side letter and have it paid to the LPs- Louis Diamond (28:22): So essentially, instead of it coming to you as the advisor, it’s almost like a dividend or distribution to the LPs. Scott Neu (28:29): Because we know the fee is there because we used to work on the sales side, now we work on the buy side. When I was on the sell side, I probably got paid 13 different ways. I get paid one now. It’s really simple. Make the number stay where it is and grow from there. Don’t lose money. And so when you talk to funds that they pay placement agents, if you take a big enough bite, they’ll offer to pay us. But because we have no broker dealer, we have no legal way to accept it by design. And so because of that, if there’s money on the table, we’ll try to get a side letter or think of a real estate deal. We did a smaller deal in Nashville and needed $12 million of equity. We took the whole thing and asked them to cut their promote substantially, so we used our buying power to benefit the client, not put the money in our pocket. Louis Diamond (29:14): Yep. It’s such a different, interesting dynamic. Most advisors aren’t serving the level of wealth that your firm is, so maybe alternatives and things like this are less relevant, but I think the key learning or takeaway is the concept of one way of getting paid, you’re not doing it because you’re trying to make less money or trying to disadvantage the client. It’s more so there’s other ways that you as the firm owner, the clients benefit, but you can do it in a very pure and transparent way rather than, like you said, getting paid 13 different ways at your old firm. Scott Neu (29:47): That’s exactly right. On top of it, if I go get a 2% placement fee and my client gets $2 contributed to their LP stack across a whole bunch of clients, that’s another million dollars we get to manage. And our clients get the million. So to me, it literally is a win-win. Louis Diamond (30:06): Great point. Yeah, I think another recurrent theme in this conversation is doing right by people and then good things happen. That’s the whole growth strategy. Scott Neu (30:15): Yeah, that’s pretty much it. Louis Diamond (30:16): Is there anything from the Goldman days, their platform? I mean, one of the best in the industry, deal flow, intellectual horsepower, lending, et cetera. Is there anything looking back at the Goldman platform or looking at it today, even in a competitive situation where you think they’re still better or that there’s an edge that they have? Scott Neu (30:34): The intellectual capital of that place is insane. It has to be one of the finest collections of intellectual capital on the planet. That’s why we like to hire people from there because they filter really smart, hardworking people. That’s probably the biggest thing is I have a lot of friends back there. It’s a very smart place. So one of the biggest worries I had when we started this, and you could ask Tony this, was how are we going to compete with the Alts platform? Because it’s all I ever knew. And so I espoused access and we’re the best and all that stuff, and I believed it when I was there. And then what I learned, I’ve learned over just the time we’ve built this is that really to be on a big bike platform, you have to be two things. You got to be big and you got to pay. (31:19): And there are a lot of firms that have good enough performance, they don’t need to pay a placement fee. Their performance is the placement fee. And those firms won’t sell through a wirehouse channel because they don’t need to pay a placement fee. And that’s usually one of the ways you get on a platform of a big bank is you pay. And so I don’t knock them for any, but that shilters a lot of really good investments out. And so what I’ve learned is secondary funds. Secondary funds, all I grew up is knowing the really big ones. What you find is it’s no different than any fund. The law of numbers makes it harder to generate returns when you have to deploy so much capital. And so what we have found is finding secondary funds is finding secondaries funds that have a smaller niche that can’t be served by a mega fund. (32:08): And when you lay the performance, it’s just we found a trend that we have had a much better experience with smaller funds, let’s just say that. So it’s been the opposite of what I thought it would be. And it continues to get more and more developed literally every day because of the amount of money that’s moving to the independent channel. Louis Diamond (32:28): But when you’re just starting off like that with hindsight, that seems extremely logical. When you’re first starting off and you’re building your technology stack, you don’t have direct relationships with managers and with wholesalers of these funds, et cetera. How do you even go about sourcing that? How do you boil the ocean and basically cultivate your own platform? Scott Neu (32:49): So how we did it, which is not probably transferable to everybody, but what we did is I knew a lot of large institutional consultants that were friends of mine, are friends of mine. And I called them and I’m like, “We’re looking for managers in this area and this area. Who do you see that fits these categories of managers? Who do you think are really good?” And we would find five or six and then we’d say, “Hey, can you make an introduction for us?” (33:15): And that’s how we started the platform was we used friends that work at large consulting firms who see tons and tons of funds and piggybacked off of what they knew. We combined that with people that I had met in the industry, Tony had met in the industry, and that’s how we built our kind of initial investment platform. And then now when we’ve been blessed to have success we have had, you get literally an email, a fund a day. And most of it, obviously by definition, we don’t do, but finding deal flow now is like, if anything, it’s winnowing through all of it. Louis Diamond (33:57): Yeah. But when you’re first starting off, those emails aren’t necessarily flowing and you now have to diligence all these things that you didn’t have to before. Scott Neu (34:05): Back to my point, if I was doing this again today, knowing what I know now and also juxtaposing that on what’s available now, I’m not sure I would build this from scratch. I would go and bolt onto someone like us who’s already got the platform, already got the reporting, has the systems down and the processes down and not have to hemorrhage a bunch of cash for two years trying to figure it out. Louis Diamond (34:30): Yeah, exactly. You made the challenging and I’d say now well-worn leap of going from an advisor, a leader of your team, a relationship manager, salesperson, et cetera, at Goldman to becoming a CEO. In your case, an advisor and a CEO. What was and what’s been the hardest bit of that change and having not been a CEO before? Scott Neu (34:57): Hardest thing is probably when you grow to the point where you realize you can’t control or monitor everything and you have to just trust people to do a good job and you’re being forced to delegate versus choosing to because of capacity. That was probably the hardest. And what I’ve learned as, it’s when I take a vacation, you go away for two or three weeks and you come back, you realize you’re not quite as important as you though you were because things run better when you’re gone. It’s kind of a similar thing. I’m very blessed to work with a lot of people who work really hard and do really good work. Our standard of deliverable is very high. And so I can delegate all kinds of tasks to very talented people that I’m blessed to work with and they do an excellent job. But it was hard initially because you’re like, “This is my baby. I’ve hemorrhaged cash and blood for this thing. And now I’m turning over a big chunk of this decision making that I used to make.” (35:51): Which by the way, I probably had no skillset to be making, to be honest. And what happens is you get fortunate enough to grow out of everybody’s a generalist and everything and hire true specialists with expertise in their specific areas. And we’re blessed to be in that situation. Louis Diamond (36:06): What would be an example of some of the specialists? Scott Neu (36:08): Our compliance officer, Whitney, she’s amazing. She runs a very tight ship, but she’s very pro making sure we can do business. Not the typical, I’d say business prevention unit, but a lot of compliance is, at least with my experience at big wirehouses. Our chief operating officer, Brent, he has experience in this. I don’t. I can kind of say, “I don’t like doing this or paying for this.” (36:31): It’s not operations. That’s me whining. And so he comes in with a much more methodical approach of, “Here’s where we’re going. I’m going to reverse engineer back what we need to do and how do we create operational leverage?” (36:46): I think I had one class in operations, an MBA class. I don’t know how to do that. So the thing now is I’m really fortunate that I have a very… Tony Cox is probably one of the smartest people I’ve met in my life. And he’s the president, he’s the chief investment officer. You meet him, you’re going to know he’s the smartest guy here, definitely not me. And he is the one that put together the business from the business perspective and is very shrewd in investing. He’s managed billions of dollars since he was like 24. The guy’s got some chops, he’s legit. (37:19): And so having these people that are really talented sitting in all these very important seats allows me to focus on things I really like doing, which is I like spending time with clients and I like finding other clients. And I don’t have to worry about all this other stuff of budgeting and performance reviews. And not that it’s not important, it’s just not what I like to do. But it’s evolved. You’re wearing 13 hats when you start, if you started from scratch and then you move into shed hats over time and there’s probably a couple other hats I’d like to shed, but sooner or later, it’s Danica Griffith hiring Danica. (37:57): I was blessed to work with Danica at Goldman. Amazing. She built an amazing business there, left, went to PNC, started her risk management, ended up running all of risk management. Everything she does, she crushes. She’s amazing. And she joined us in September and she’s our chief growth officer and her job is to go recruit advisors to join Sage Mountain. She gets up every day thinking about how can we add advisors and how can we make our offering better for advisors? And having someone like that is huge. Louis Diamond (38:26): I want to ask you specifically about Danica and just the though behind a chief growth officer, but on your role, it sounds like you still work and service clients directly. If so, as the business continues to grow and grow, do you think that’s ever going to be a happy takeoff? Scott Neu (38:42): I hope not. I love being a client. It’s my number one thing. That’s who I go to dinner with every weekend. Client. All my friends are my client. I mean, if I could write the script, I’m not the CEO someday. I’m still the chairman. I still have my fingers in the direction of the firm, but I get to spend my time spending time with clients, fixing problems for clients and finding new clients. Louis Diamond (39:01): That’s what makes owning and operating your own business so special, is that you get to pick what you’re most passionate about. And if you make the right hires, invest in your team, it affords you the freedom to offload or delegate the things that don’t charge you up. Scott Neu (39:15): I mean, an example would be I don’t get out of bed going, “I’m excited to go to a budgeting meeting for 2027.” We have people here who are extremely talented that probably do that. Same with Whitney in compliance. I don’t get, “Oh, I can’t wait to do a custody audit,” or whatever that is. But she does it and she does it really well and she has passion for it. She’s excellent. I like getting out of bed thinking, “How can I make…” (39:36): I think the firms of the future that will continue to succeed and outrun AI longer are firms that create the ability for clients to recapture more time to do what they want with their time. And so that’s where I focus my time, thinking about if I’m a client and I have all these different things in my life, what are the things I want to shed and what are things I want to keep and how can I shed those in the most efficient way possible? And my goal is to build this firm while we’re creating all of those ways to shed that time and maximize our client’s time they can spend on family and friends and fun. Louis Diamond (40:15): Very cool. What’s the next service area or the next thing that you envision Sage Mountain doing? Scott Neu (40:20): This is not coming soon, but one of them is like, look, we have clients that have real estate all over the place and a lot of it’s vacation homes. Imagine if we had four people here that literally manage those properties for them down to getting license plate tags renewed. It does not mean they’re doing the painting or the snow removal. It means they’re coordinating all of the subcontractors to make sure that when our clients go on vacation that it works, everything works and it’s been tested and painted and doesn’t leak and the cars or tags are correct, all of that stuff. And that’s something that’s going to be hard for AI to take away. We use AI, we’re implementing AI. I believe we have two choices with that as I can put it in my pocket with a savings or we can reinvest in incremental services. (41:05): We are going to choose number two and we’re using AI. We are fortunate to have a company called Atomic Insights. It’s really been helpful on cashiering, money movement stuff, taking out the work of all of the money movement stuff and making it easier where it puts us in more of an approval seat versus a queue it up for approval seat. So Atomic Insight’s been great. Then another firm we’re using a lot is Cedrus. They build it like this agentic AI. They’re building onboarding for us. They’re going to build CRM for us. They’re going to build all kinds of analytical things for us. We’re early adopters and I’m not afraid to buy technology and have it fail, but the savings we get from that in time, therefore humans, meaning we can do more with the same number of people, we will plow into incremental services and try to continue to build the barrier to entry. Louis Diamond (41:59): I love that. It’s such a cool way to think about the competitive moat. It’s not like we’re just going to add more services that’s harder to fire us. We’re really focused on saving people time and there’s certain things that you as a firm are credible or have the scale to offer that, like you said earlier, anything that touches money is a service that you want to be able to offer. Scott Neu (42:18): If I came to you and you had 80 million bucks in four houses, and I know you’re having to call the managers of all your four houses all the time, imagine if we could take that off your plate for 10 grand and you have 50 million, or 15 grand, you’d be like, “Sign me up because now I’ve got a bunch of people that wake up every day focusing on this and I don’t have to do it in my spare time when my grandkids go down.” Louis Diamond (42:39): Yeah. And it’s all coordinated. Anything with property maintenance, it touches the investment account. If they want to sell the property, it’s going to touch their portfolio, it’s going to touch lending. It makes so much sense. Scott Neu (42:50): Yeah. I could go through 20. We don’t have time for that, but those are the things when I think about the future of our business where I want to be. Louis Diamond (42:58): Give me one or two more. You don’t have to go deep. Scott Neu (43:00): All right, I’ll give you one more. This is more of a dream for me. It’s been my experience that everyone talks about next generation education and everyone does it. We do too, but I haven’t seen anyone do it really well. It doesn’t mean they can’t trot up some special psychiatrists and give you some best practices and help you build family mission statements and all that stuff, which we can too. But it’s one of the things I told the partners is I said, “Before I’m done, I hope people will view Sage Mountain as by the way, they’re also best in class and next gen stuff.” By the way, I have no idea how I’m going to do that, but I’m hopefully I have at least 15 more years in the tank running pretty hard and it’s one of the things that’s on my radar screen. Louis Diamond (43:43): Yeah. I mean, look- Scott Neu (43:44): Because you can’t be best in everything as much as you can try, but I sure hope we’re viewed as top tier in that area because to me, the investing piece is important, but when people go to bed at night, their real legacy is their family and their kids. And so it creates a bigger moat if you become an expert in really helping people with next generation and propagating wealth in an efficient and responsible way. Louis Diamond (44:09): Yeah. Aside from it being a noble cause, clearly you’re passionate about it. It also is a great way to protect the business long term because everyone knows the stats about what happens when G1 passes away or transition from matriarch to patriarch to matriarch, et cetera, to the next generation. So if you spend time investing from a good place, not because you’re just trying to keep people’s assets, if you’re building a moat around your business again. I think that the coolest thing is, you said you have 20 other ideas we can talk about offline, if you’re willing to share, is you have the ability to do any and all of this. You have the blank canvas to do it. The limitation is it’s time, it’s human capital, it’s how do we actually do it? Scott Neu (44:50): Like I said, I’m not big into writing books and doing fireside chats and all that stuff. It may work for other people, that’s just not who I am. But I know we have enough experience around here that if we make this a priority over 10 years and we consistently put effort and resources into it, we can do it. And it won’t be just, oh, we can do that to service where we immunize ourself against competition by saying we have it too. That’s not good enough for me. I want to be really good at it, not just use it to immunize myself in a pitch against somebody. Louis Diamond (45:21): Well said. Two more questions for you and we’ll wrap. You mentioned recently hiring Danica Griffith as your chief growth officer. I know I’m seeing from our executive search business, chief growth officer is definitely an in vogue role that candidates are asking about, firms are hiring. What does chief growth officer mean to you and what does the next phase of growth look like as a result for Sage Mountain? Scott Neu (45:45): So we are blessed. All of our growth so far is organic growth. We’ve done zero acquisitions or liftouts or any of that. We’re fortunate to have a firm that’s built a reputation that people just recommend people to, and I hope we are blessed to continue that. Where we are trying to go, we want to then bring on some advisors with established books of business. We could buy a firm, we’ve though about that, but I think the direction we’re going to go is we’re going to do some liftouts first because we want to really be able to nail these transitions because when advisors talk to us, we have an obligation to go all hands on deck and move those clients as fast as we can because I know what it’s like to move a book and it’s scary. And so the faster we can all circle up and go after those clients, which is part of my job and Danica’s job is… (46:40): And so we’re going to add 10 more advisors from an inorganic perspective, think people with 500 to $2 billion books or teams of people with five to $2 billion books and bolt them on and give them access to our platform and give them a path to earn substantial equity for them and their families. So that’s kind of our plan. And so Danica’s job, this is like classic small business. So we tried it with Tony and I and Brent, our COO, trying to do this as kind of a side hustle for a year, and we added exactly zero advisors, but learned a lot. And so the time and money we spent wasn’t wasted, we paid some tuition. But one of the things we learned is we need to have somebody that gets up every day and it’s their primary role. (47:25): I can’t tell you how grateful I am that Danica is the one that’s chosen to take that position because you need to get her on your podcast in a couple of years. You’re going to find out she’s an absolute killer. And so she’s going to do very well and she’s going to help us. Her job is to recruit advisors and then help integrate them into the firm. So she has one leg in ops/integrations and then another leg into advisor recruitment. Louis Diamond (47:49): Last question for you. What’s a bit of advice you’d give someone who was kind of where you were when you were at Goldman, let’s say in 2016, 2017, looking out over the horizon, thinking about the future, what’s something you would tell them or what’s a hard lesson you learned that you wish someone else doesn’t repeat? Scott Neu (48:06): Well, depends on if you want to stay at Goldman or not. Don’t be a jerk like I was for a long time internally, and usually your career trajectory stays a little longer. I would say, look, whether it’s 2016 or today, if you’re late 30s to 47, and let’s say you’re in reasonable health and you’re going to do this business, you want to continue to grow your business, you’re crazy not to go independent. It’s so robustly built out now. I have a lot of respect for Andy Berg. He started Homrich Berg in the late ’80s. I don’t even know there were independent advisors in the late ’80s. I was in high school, no disrespect to Andy, but I have tons of admiration for that guy because there was nothing. Flip side is today you can literally build a business that gives an amazing experience to your clients with effectively zero conflict, and you can bolt onto a platform like Sage Mountain and create an awesome experience for your clients and meaningful terminal value for your family and far more tax efficient, oh, by the way. (49:10): And so if I was 35 to 45, knowing the independent channel now, my only regret is I didn’t do it five years earlier. Flip side is people stay in these jobs because it’s the path of least resistance. I’m not going to kid you. Even if you bolt onto Sage Mountain, it’s going to be two years of hard work and your head’s going to come up and you’re like, “This is the best thing I ever did.” Ask every advisor we have, but it doesn’t mean it’s not two years of hammer down. So if you’re willing to sacrifice two years and work really hard, you end up in a better spot. Louis Diamond (49:42): Yeah. I always say you 10 years from now will always thank you for that three months, six months, nine months of H-E-L-L that you went through in order to pull up the transition. Scott Neu (49:52): It’s funny, the day I left Goldman, I had many, many people calling me and they were like, “This is going to be the best thing that ever happened to you.” (49:59): Obviously they’re all saying that to be kind humans. They were the only one on the line that believed it because I can tell you I didn’t think that, nor did I think it kind of into year three because I thought about the checks I could have had deposited day one from wirehouses thinking, “This thing isn’t even worth that.” (50:17): And then the amount of sacrifice my family and I and my teammates have made is substantial. I’m just very blessed. I’m so pumped I get to work with amazing people. It’s a privilege to work with people I get to work with. It’s a privilege to work with the clients we’re blessed to work with. Just super thankful. But like I said, I just do it a little different now. I don’t think I would take the hardest path. I’d take the medium path, which is I have meaningful upside without a lot of the trauma of starting a business. Louis Diamond (50:50): Scott, this has been a lot of fun. Like I said, I’m going to follow up with you offline about your other 20 ideas, but a couple of things that I’m going to take from this and always remember is just the way that you started the business, started growing at Goldman was it wasn’t cold marketing, it was networking, doing the right thing for people, and then getting referred and referred and basically doing good work and becoming extremely referable as the growth strategy. I think it’s something that everyone can learn from. I also just love the way you talked about sourcing alternatives and the way you can access different things in a conflict-free model. So really appreciate that. We’re your first interview, that you’re gracious enough to talk about Sage Mountain, you’re vulnerable with us, and I learned a ton and I know our audience did too. Scott Neu (51:33): Thanks for having me. I wish you guys the best. Mindy Diamond (51:42): As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously and are dedicated to your clients, but are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook. Under the Radar: How an Ex-Goldman Advisor Quietly Built an $8.5B RIA Scott Neu, Co-Founder & CEO, Sage Mountain Louis Diamond (00:05): Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is Under the Radar: How an Ex-Goldman Advisor Quietly Built an Eight and a Half Billion Dollar RIA. It’s a conversation with Scott Neu, co-founder and CEO Sage Mountain Advisors. I’m Louis Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond (00:28): At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. (01:20): Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport. Louis Diamond (01:54): There are plenty of ways to grow an advisory business. You can market, you can acquire, you can recruit, or you can take a much simpler approach, do really good work for people, take care of them, and trust that over time they’ll tell other people. Simple doesn’t mean easy, but when it works, the compounding effect can be pretty extraordinary. My guest today, Scott Neu, is co-founder and CEO of Sage Mountain Advisors, an independent multifamily office managing some eight and a half billion for just under 200 families. Scott spent 18 years at Goldman Sachs where he built a business managing close to three billion in assets before an unexpected turn ended his career there. He’ll tell you very candidly that getting fired humbled him, changed the way he thought about the business and people, and ultimately gave him the push to build something different. Eight years later, Sage Mountain has grown almost entirely through referrals, without acquisitions, and with an intentionally high-touch model Scott describes as a mile deep and an inch wide. (02:59): What I find most interesting is that there’s no complicated growth formula behind it. Scott believes that doing the right thing for clients, even when it means sacrificing revenue or margin in the short term, ultimately creates a better client experience, more referrals, and a stronger business. We talk about what he learned at Goldman, what independence has allowed him to do differently, how Sage Mountain built a family office offering around the needs of ultra-high net worth families, and why knowing what he knows today. Scott says he probably wouldn’t build an RIA from scratch again. It’s a fascinating look at what can happen when service, growth, and enterprise value all start the same basic idea, do right by people and build from there. So let’s get to it. Scott, thanks for joining us today. Scott Neu (03:46): My pleasure. Thanks for having me. Louis Diamond (03:48): Let’s dive in. In pre-recording, you mentioned this is your first podcast and first real interview ever, so we are honored that you’re here and to learn more about Sage Mountain and the amazing firm that you built. Scott Neu (04:00): Thank you so much for having me. Yeah, I’ve not really done much of this, but I have high regard for your podcast and so I figured if I was going to do it, I wanted to do my first one with you. Louis Diamond (04:08): That means a lot. So before getting into your time at Goldman and building your firm, you had definitely a different background than most folks. Spent five years in the Navy as a nuclear power operator. Can you talk about that experience and how’d you go from that into the great world of private wealth management? Scott Neu (04:27): Yeah, it’s definitely a different path. I grew up in a family where we didn’t have the means for me to go to college, and so I joined the Navy out of high school. That was my real purpose of joining the military. I ended up running nuclear power plants on a submarine on the West Coast, and I was in for five years, got out and used my GI bill to go to University of Wyoming, which is the closest university to where I grew up, and got an engineering degree. And then from there went to Vanderbilt, got an MBA. During my MBA, Goldman came to town and had a non-finance concentrator dinner and informed people about wealth management and sounded interesting to me. And so I worked really hard, got an internship there in ’99 and got a full-time offer in 2000 and didn’t know anybody in Atlanta, didn’t really know how to find clients, and just came to Atlanta in 2001 after the training program and started building a business at Goldman. Louis Diamond (05:25): Amazing. Yeah, honestly, credit to Goldman and firms like it for thinking outside the box because there’s so many amazing individuals with non-traditional backgrounds who end up building insanely impressive businesses like yours. It’s amazing how everything lines up that way. Scott Neu (05:41): Thank you. Louis Diamond (05:41): Is there anything from your Navy background that still shows up in how you run Sage Mountain today or how you ran your team at Goldman even? Scott Neu (05:50): Yeah, I mean different things from different places. Super high attention to detail is one. Military gave me discipline and work ethic. Goldman taught me responsiveness, collaboratory work, so taking all of those things and blending them in is part of our DNA at Sage Mountain. Louis Diamond (06:09): Very cool. I like that. And also humility. I’ve caught that in the brief amount of time that we’ve had to spend together. Scott Neu (06:16): We’ve been very blessed. I’m very grateful. Life has a way of giving you lumps when you need to get them, and I’ve gotten my share and I live very differently now. I’m very grateful for everything we’ve been blessed to have. Louis Diamond (06:27): Can you give us a snapshot of your firm today? Assets, size of the team, what types of families you serve, really anything just to give our listeners some context before we really dive into how you built the firm. Scott Neu (06:39): Yeah, we’re hiring a bunch of people right now, so I’m not sure who’s exactly accepted and who isn’t. So I’m going to tell you between 37 and 40 people right now, all in Atlanta, we will open offices in other places in the future for sure. Assets-wise, we advise on a little over eight billion, eight half billion-ish, and our families, we don’t really have a minimum asset. It’s more of a minimum fee is $100,000 a year, and so that’s kind of how we deliver our services is we reverse engineer how much time are we going to dedicate to every slot and then price it from that. We limit our advisors to no more than 35 clients, and so we’re a mile deep and an inch wide. Louis Diamond (07:23): Very interesting. I like that approach too, of not having a hard and fast minimum, but having a minimum fee because I think it’s intentional, right? It shows that you know how much your time is worth, you know how much your advisor capacity is worth, and maybe there’s someone with five million bucks who could be a billion dollar client one day and they want your types of services, so why exclude them from the mix? Scott Neu (07:44): Exactly right. Louis Diamond (07:45): I know from your website that you position Sage Mountain as a multifamily office. It sounds like it very much is, but the industry I think very much overuses the term multifamily office. Anyone who’s doing planning and cares a lot that now says they’re a multifamily office or they provide multifamily office services. So what does it mean to you? And at Sage Mountain, what services or what do you do that makes it a family office or multifamily office in your opinion? Scott Neu (08:15): Part of our DNA is I tell people here, we’re generally the highest paid employee for the families we work for, so try to act like it. And what that means to us is you’re pretty much available 24/7. Weekends, it doesn’t matter, nights doesn’t matter. And our clients know that if they text us, they’re going to get a text back or an email right away, and so responsiveness is part of our DNA. When it comes to services, we pretty much tell people we’ll help you with anything that touches money. It tends to evolve beyond that, family dynamics, helping people get into schools, get into hospitals and get specialized treatment, using our network through our clients to help. We always say Sage family takes care of Sage family, and that’s not the employees, it’s also the clients and we all help each other. It’s one of the things I’m probably the most proud of. So we advise on tax, trust, and estate. People ask all the time, “Do you have an in-house attorney?” (09:09): I have found the best attorneys are out there actually practicing and they’re in front of the most cutting edge stuff and they’re not being filtered through an organization’s compliance machine saying what’s appropriate to show people and what isn’t. And so we tend to just say, “Look, we know we have a lot of trust and estate knowledge and tax knowledge in-house, but we try to find the best expert for solving that problem.” (09:35): Versus have the in-house person be a generalist and say, “Do all this discovery conversation and then giving three names and saying you’re on your own.” (09:43): And so we run the process for mortgages with multiple banks, not just the bank we were attached to. So we want the best, not the most convenient. And so it’s a different approach. It requires more time. We sacrifice margin to be able to deliver that, but we also have been blessed to grow and we don’t have to advertise because our clients, delivering clients a good experience and doing it repetitively over and over again converts our client base into our sales force. Louis Diamond (10:15): I love that. I think it’s exactly right. I mean, another way to think of it is the customer acquisition cost is zero. Obviously you spend a lot of time and energy and it’s all very well-earned, but I’ve always found that being able to predictably grow the business through client referrals by providing great service, that’s a strategy that’s as old as time and it never goes out of favor. Scott Neu (10:36): That’s right. And everybody here, not just the advisors, play an extremely important role, whether it’s account opening and onboarding, whether it’s sending wires in a timely fashion, whether it’s enforcing our security protocol to make sure wires go where they’re supposed to go, it’s investment advice, it’s tax advice, it’s trust and estate advice. Everyone plays a role in new business by delivering a good experience to our existing clients. Louis Diamond (11:00): Makes sense. How have you organized the firm? What’s the org chart? So you’re the founder and CEO. I know you recently hired a chief growth officer, which we’ll talk about, but how many advisors are there and what are the other disciplines or full-time employees that you have? Scott Neu (11:16): We’re hiring a lot of people, so I’ll get this wrong a little bit because it’s in flux. I have six other advisors besides me, and like I said, they’re limited to around 35 clients per, and right now we work with around just shy of 200 families. So that’s the advisory team. Each advisory team has a portfolio manager, which is usually a very seasoned CFA type person who oversees ideas that we push in front of clients from the investment team, implementing the portfolios and preparing for any kind of client deliverable when it touches investments, analysts that support that, client service people that support those teams, and we always have compliance folks that help us make sure that we do things correctly and in accordance with what SEC wants, and that’s kind of how we’re set up. The investment committee is chaired by my partner, Tony Cox. (12:16): Tony was my analyst when we started this. He and I co-founded the firm together and we took a lot of what we learned at Goldman and replicated it, but we tried to cut out all the things we didn’t like about it. And that’s the beauty of the independent channel. Louis Diamond (12:32): What would be an example of cutting out the stuff that you didn’t like or trimming the fat, if you will? Scott Neu (12:37): Here’s our real story. When I was working for a wirehouse, we had a big LBO fund that was very highly regarded, come in and give us meaningful access. It was fund four and it went fine. We had a client come in with about a hundred and some million bucks and he was like, “I want to invest in private equity and this fund is really good.” (12:58): Well, fund five came around after this guy had become a client, and the fund gave, where I worked, far less allocation that time. And so the way the firm gated it or allocated that access, which was more scarce, is they said if you weren’t in fund four, you had to be in fund five, you couldn’t be in fund five. So this guy got frozen out because of just the timing which he became a client. So we knew it had been approved on the platform or it wouldn’t be even allocated to anybody. (13:27): And so we called this fund direct and said, “Hey, can we get a $10 million order for this guy?” (13:33): As you would expect, they said, “Absolutely.” (13:37): It wasn’t 15 minutes, and I was getting a phone call saying, “You can’t do this. You’re not going to get paid on it. We’re not going to get paid on it.” (13:46): The thought process for me has always been, “I don’t need to be paid now. I know that if this guy goes in, he puts $10 million there, it’s probably going to turn into 50. He’s going to remember I did the right thing and I’m going to get 50 to manage in seven years, and he’s probably going to refer me a couple clients along the way because I did the right thing for him and not what was right for me.” (14:06): That’s a difference. I don’t get paid that way, right? I love the fact that we recommend investments to people, but if they say like a private equity fund, I got paid a percentage of every dollar that went in that I got people to do. Now it’s like I’m telling you to do this because I think it’s going to make you money and if it makes you money, two things are probably going to happen. Number one is I get a charge a fee on a bigger number. Number two is you’re going to be happy and refer me business. Pretty simple. Louis Diamond (14:34): I’m sure that was part of your thesis or your motivation to going into the independent world was getting away from some of those dynamics of fund subscriptions and limited allocations and really being a true fiduciary for very wealthy families. Scott Neu (14:50): Look, big firms have amazing access. We have access to things they can’t do because they’re too big. And so it’s not just access, it’s allocation. So recently I know of someone at a big wirehouse that put in for an allocation to Anthropic. He has over $100 million there. He asked for $750,000 of Anthropic and he got 70 grand. So access is one thing. Allocation, you have to have both. These big wirehouses are not going away. They do a fine job for a set of clients, but you don’t need to be a genius to figure out that the winds are blowing towards the independent channel. All you have to do is read AdvisorHub or what you guys talk about, and you know that the flow of advisors is moving away from wirehouses to the independent channel. I’m not read, I’m not saying it doesn’t exist, but I’ve not read many advisors that are independent going to wirehouses. Louis Diamond (15:41): Yeah, I think some of it is different strokes for different folks, and for some people there’s elements of what the big firms provide that is extremely valuable or to start off the name and the business card and that access is very important. And then as the business grows and matures, it changes. Scott Neu (15:59): I am grateful from the opportunity that Goldman Sachs gave me. We would not have the success at Sage Mountain if I didn’t spend time there. The people I met, what I learned. The flip side is as you get more and more mature at a wirehouse and build a book, most people know that people are doing business with them in the latter stages of their careers at a wirehouse more because of the advisor and less because of the business card. And so people that wake up and they’re 40 years old, it’s literally probably never been easier to go independent. And if you’re going to continue to work for another 15 years anyway, going independent is absolutely the way to go if you want to provide a better experience for your clients and actually create real wealth for yourself in the future. Louis Diamond (16:41): Yep. Well said. Going back to your time at Goldman, so you said when you joined the firm out of Vanderbilt with an internship, you had no idea how to get clients, you moved down to Atlanta where you weren’t from. So how’d you build such a successful book at Goldman? Essentially, what was the growth playbook that Goldman taught you or that you kind of self-taught or learned on the job? Scott Neu (17:02): Yeah, so I didn’t ever really cold market. I just spent a ton of time networking. And my first client came from networking with somebody I went to business school with whose wife worked for a family office, and the family office was looking for another investment advisor, and through that relationship, I got an opportunity, and it happened to be a relationship with a wonderful human who I worked extremely hard for, and he took me under his wing, and he helped me meet a ton of people in town because he credentialized me. So networking, a little luck in your network, getting the right client that has influence in the community, and then doing a really good job for that person for a long time, and then building a referral network from one or two clients. So I never really made cold calls. We just work really hard for people and do a good job and they help you out. Louis Diamond (17:53): Yep. When you break it down like that, it sounds easy, but I know especially given the client minimums at Goldman, starting off fresh, getting people to trust you, you definitely can’t take that for granted. I think you’re a humble guy, so you make it sound like it’s not that challenging to do and we don’t market, et cetera, but it’s your own form of marketing, right? It’s your own personal brand and reputation that you’re cultivating and sharing instead of through newspaper ads or online, you’re doing it through word of mouth with people you do a really good job for. Scott Neu (18:25): Yeah, that’s exactly right. And make no mistake, I’m not saying it’s easy because it’s not. I’ll give a shout-out to my wife. Last year she went to 40 client or prospect dinners, so we sacrifice a Friday or Saturday almost every weekend. That’s an extra day of networking for 25 years we’ve had we put in the time. So it’s the cumulative effect of that is a bigger network of people that want to help you. Louis Diamond (18:48): Yeah, it’s the compounding effect of doing the right thing over and over again and working a little bit harder than the guy next to you, but that compounds over time. Very cool. So given what you built at Goldman, I’m sure it was a good enough experience, the brand, the platform, et cetera. Why’d you consider leaving and leave in 2018 to begin with? Scott Neu (19:09): Yeah, so when I left in 2018, I had several opportunities to choose from. Multiple wirehouses were willing to provide very substantial checks upfront to go work with them. And my partner Tony and I had talked about building a firm, an independent firm on our own because we were like, “We think we’re pretty good at this. We’re winning inside even with all these constraints, competitive constraints internally of a big firm.” (19:37): The reason I chose to go build this from scratch with Tony was I think when I hang up my cleats and I pray it’s not for a long time, that something that I think is a more admirable story is instead of me going to a wirehouse and getting tens of millions of dollars, instead let’s go work harder for a long time and not just Scott creates wealth for Scott, but we build something that creates a bunch of wealth for other people not named Scott. And frankly, people ask me all the time, “What’s the vision for the firm?” (20:10): And it’s not, “Hey, I’m going to go try to sell this to private equity and cash out.” To me, I want to continue to dilute to people that are going to grow value of this company and fade out and let them run it for as long as they can. Louis Diamond (20:21): Very cool. In order though to get to the point of getting offers from wirehouses, being in the zone to even think about launching your own RIA, were there a confluence of frustrations or pain points or what really motivated you to step out? Scott Neu (20:43): Goldman fired me. I’ll say this, I wasn’t a great employee, and to be honest with you, I wouldn’t want an employee like I was at Goldman, honestly. I made it easier for them to let me go than they should, than I needed to, but it was a great thing for me. I didn’t feel great when it happened, but what it did is humble me, and what it did is make me realize that things are fragile, that rules apply, that you can’t take anything for granted. So I took that scar tissue and I carry it with me, and I live life very differently. This organization, we truly love each other. People I get to work with, I’m blessed to work with, know I really care about them, and the clients know we really care about them. I was blessed to build a very successful business at Goldman. (21:34): Honestly, I’m not sure I would’ve ever left. In retrospect, I wish they would’ve fired me five years earlier, but they didn’t. I probably deserved it, but they finally did it, and I will say it was good for me not just building this place, but it was good for me as a person. Louis Diamond (21:49): First off, thank you for being humble and being vulnerable. When we hear from advisors who have been fired or let go for whatever reason, my wisdom, which I firmly believe, which you just validated, is things happen for a reason, kind of feels random and unfair and unreasonable right now, and it’s super stressful and your clients are kind of in the wind, but you’ll look back on this and you’ll be grateful for the opportunity because it gave you the push that you wouldn’t have had otherwise, or it gave you a new perspective on things that is only going to make you better. Scott Neu (22:21): Totally agree with that. I’m very blessed. I’m so grateful. There were about 24 months where I wasn’t very grateful. You start to get some traction and building a business is not easy at all. If I was to leave and do this again, let’s say I’m back and I leave Goldman today, I’m not sure I would build a company from scratch because there’s so many offerings now, platform, we’re one of them, where an advisor can leave, come to us, we’re going to lean in hard to make that person successful because like I said, compensation drives behavior and everybody partner takes a pay cut when someone comes here, we’re going to shoulder in and make them successful, and I’m proud of every advisor we’ve hired has crushed it. (23:08): I think I would probably take a bolt onto something like us that’s already got the investment platform, already has the reporting down, is growing quickly, so we know the market is saying this is a good offering, and advisors can come here and literally earn as much equity as they can earn through production. So you get not only the income, but you’re creating terminal value of your business that’s substantially higher than any kind of buyout or retirement package you get at a wirehouse. So I would join someone like Sage Mountain. I would not go do this from the beginning, probably. Louis Diamond (23:43): Interesting. So being a business owner and calling your own shots, having your own brand, that wasn’t and isn’t the guiding light. Scott Neu (23:51): I’ve never chased awards. I don’t go to panels. I don’t go to conferences. I don’t really care about Scott Neu being in lights. I care about my faith, my family, our clients, my employees, and delivering a good experience for them. That’s all I focus on. Louis Diamond (24:05): Fair enough. The clients that followed you from Goldman, how did they initially respond to the move? Scott Neu (24:11): It’s in different waves. First of all, you have the people that say, “We love you. You’ve done a great job for my family. We’ll follow you wherever. Just tell us where we got to go.” (24:19): Then you have another group of people who are like, “We love you, but we want to see this is going to be a going concern. We want to watch it succeed for 12 to 24 months.” (24:28): And in that group, you have some leakage because this momentum takes over. Even though you’ve proven to them you’re a going concern, you’re still going to have some leakage. One thing anyone thinking about leaving should know is you’re going to be surprised on both sides. People that you have literally laid entrapped for 20 years are going to say, “No, I’m not going to come with you.” (24:47): And people that you didn’t pay enough attention to and you though we’re not even going to call will come with you. It’s very odd. I have found no rhyme or reason in migrating my book from Goldman here, let’s just say that. And then the next wave post 24 months on the, “We want to see it be a going concern and then we’ll come,” is it’s just a knife fight. It’s like you’re going to go and you’re going to show you can do more things with less conflicts and better reporting and better holistic advice, and you chip away at the offering and wait for an opening and hopefully the client makes the choice to come work for you, work with you. Sorry. Louis Diamond (25:21): Makes sense. How much, and this is an impossible hypothetical, but how much or what percentage of your business today do you think you would’ve had if you stayed at Goldman? If it’s 2026, you’re still at Goldman versus today, eight billion and growing at Sage Mountain? Scott Neu (25:39): Here’s a different way to look at it. I was at Goldman for 18 years and at the end managed real close to three billion. We’ve been at Sage Mountain for eight years and two months and we’re close to eight and a half billion. That’s a more recent real number. I don’t think I’ve become just a much better salesperson. The reason is because we can do so many things. When I was at a wirehouse, you advise pretty much on the performance of the assets you manage, and that’s about the limited of the conversation. When you move to the independent channel, the table stakes are you will advise me on tax, trust and estate, bill pay, all kinds of things, and the incremental cost is not that material. So most people are like, “If I can get all these extra services that I can’t get at a big wirehouse, why would I not do that?” (26:26): A lot of people hire us for continuity, right? When I worked for a wirehouse, I played a piece of the web. I managed the money that was at the wirehouse. I didn’t generally have visibility on everything else because that becomes the advice business versus selling suitable securities business. And big wirehouses don’t want to do that because they give up a lot of revenue on the broker-dealer side if they move into a peer advisory role, and so it’s follow the money. And so when you move to the advice business, you can give people advice holistically. It’s very difficult to do at a wirehouse. I’m not saying nobody can do it, but it’s not the core business. Louis Diamond (27:04): Makes sense. I saw that you describe your alternatives offering as, and I quote, “community sourced.” What does that really mean and how does it work? Scott Neu (27:13): We have three rules, but one of the rules for clients when they sign up, we give them very quickly, is you show us every deal you’re shown. So roughly we’re approaching 200 families. Those families have obviously had meaningful liquidity events of real estate or private businesses or whatever, and the market’s efficient, deals find them. And so, one of the things we ask every client is, “Do you promise to send us every deal that you’re shown? We’ll help you diligence it. If we like it, we’re going to take a bigger bite than you’re going to do that, and we’re going to squeeze fees for everybody.” (27:47): If funds come to us and say, “Hey, I’m raising X million dollars,” or if fund comes to us and says, “Hey, if you’ll place $50 million with us, we’ll pay you 2% placement fee.” (27:58): We purposely set up our business to not have a broker dealer because we want to be pure in how we’re compensated, just for the advice only. But if we like the fund and we decide we’re going to put 50 million with it, we’ll ask them to sign a side letter and pay it to our LPs because they’ve already said they’ve budgeted a million bucks. We can’t take it, but it’s on the table. Why would we not get a side letter and have it paid to the LPs- Louis Diamond (28:22): So essentially, instead of it coming to you as the advisor, it’s almost like a dividend or distribution to the LPs. Scott Neu (28:29): Because we know the fee is there because we used to work on the sales side, now we work on the buy side. When I was on the sell side, I probably got paid 13 different ways. I get paid one now. It’s really simple. Make the number stay where it is and grow from there. Don’t lose money. And so when you talk to funds that they pay placement agents, if you take a big enough bite, they’ll offer to pay us. But because we have no broker dealer, we have no legal way to accept it by design. And so because of that, if there’s money on the table, we’ll try to get a side letter or think of a real estate deal. We did a smaller deal in Nashville and needed $12 million of equity. We took the whole thing and asked them to cut their promote substantially, so we used our buying power to benefit the client, not put the money in our pocket. Louis Diamond (29:14): Yep. It’s such a different, interesting dynamic. Most advisors aren’t serving the level of wealth that your firm is, so maybe alternatives and things like this are less relevant, but I think the key learning or takeaway is the concept of one way of getting paid, you’re not doing it because you’re trying to make less money or trying to disadvantage the client. It’s more so there’s other ways that you as the firm owner, the clients benefit, but you can do it in a very pure and transparent way rather than, like you said, getting paid 13 different ways at your old firm. Scott Neu (29:47): That’s exactly right. On top of it, if I go get a 2% placement fee and my client gets $2 contributed to their LP stack across a whole bunch of clients, that’s another million dollars we get to manage. And our clients get the million. So to me, it literally is a win-win. Louis Diamond (30:06): Great point. Yeah, I think another recurrent theme in this conversation is doing right by people and then good things happen. That’s the whole growth strategy. Scott Neu (30:15): Yeah, that’s pretty much it. Louis Diamond (30:16): Is there anything from the Goldman days, their platform? I mean, one of the best in the industry, deal flow, intellectual horsepower, lending, et cetera. Is there anything looking back at the Goldman platform or looking at it today, even in a competitive situation where you think they’re still better or that there’s an edge that they have? Scott Neu (30:34): The intellectual capital of that place is insane. It has to be one of the finest collections of intellectual capital on the planet. That’s why we like to hire people from there because they filter really smart, hardworking people. That’s probably the biggest thing is I have a lot of friends back there. It’s a very smart place. So one of the biggest worries I had when we started this, and you could ask Tony this, was how are we going to compete with the Alts platform? Because it’s all I ever knew. And so I espoused access and we’re the best and all that stuff, and I believed it when I was there. And then what I learned, I’ve learned over just the time we’ve built this is that really to be on a big bike platform, you have to be two things. You got to be big and you got to pay. (31:19): And there are a lot of firms that have good enough performance, they don’t need to pay a placement fee. Their performance is the placement fee. And those firms won’t sell through a wirehouse channel because they don’t need to pay a placement fee. And that’s usually one of the ways you get on a platform of a big bank is you pay. And so I don’t knock them for any, but that shilters a lot of really good investments out. And so what I’ve learned is secondary funds. Secondary funds, all I grew up is knowing the really big ones. What you find is it’s no different than any fund. The law of numbers makes it harder to generate returns when you have to deploy so much capital. And so what we have found is finding secondary funds is finding secondaries funds that have a smaller niche that can’t be served by a mega fund. (32:08): And when you lay the performance, it’s just we found a trend that we have had a much better experience with smaller funds, let’s just say that. So it’s been the opposite of what I thought it would be. And it continues to get more and more developed literally every day because of the amount of money that’s moving to the independent channel. Louis Diamond (32:28): But when you’re just starting off like that with hindsight, that seems extremely logical. When you’re first starting off and you’re building your technology stack, you don’t have direct relationships with managers and with wholesalers of these funds, et cetera. How do you even go about sourcing that? How do you boil the ocean and basically cultivate your own platform? Scott Neu (32:49): So how we did it, which is not probably transferable to everybody, but what we did is I knew a lot of large institutional consultants that were friends of mine, are friends of mine. And I called them and I’m like, “We’re looking for managers in this area and this area. Who do you see that fits these categories of managers? Who do you think are really good?” And we would find five or six and then we’d say, “Hey, can you make an introduction for us?” (33:15): And that’s how we started the platform was we used friends that work at large consulting firms who see tons and tons of funds and piggybacked off of what they knew. We combined that with people that I had met in the industry, Tony had met in the industry, and that’s how we built our kind of initial investment platform. And then now when we’ve been blessed to have success we have had, you get literally an email, a fund a day. And most of it, obviously by definition, we don’t do, but finding deal flow now is like, if anything, it’s winnowing through all of it. Louis Diamond (33:57): Yeah. But when you’re first starting off, those emails aren’t necessarily flowing and you now have to diligence all these things that you didn’t have to before. Scott Neu (34:05): Back to my point, if I was doing this again today, knowing what I know now and also juxtaposing that on what’s available now, I’m not sure I would build this from scratch. I would go and bolt onto someone like us who’s already got the platform, already got the reporting, has the systems down and the processes down and not have to hemorrhage a bunch of cash for two years trying to figure it out. Louis Diamond (34:30): Yeah, exactly. You made the challenging and I’d say now well-worn leap of going from an advisor, a leader of your team, a relationship manager, salesperson, et cetera, at Goldman to becoming a CEO. In your case, an advisor and a CEO. What was and what’s been the hardest bit of that change and having not been a CEO before? Scott Neu (34:57): Hardest thing is probably when you grow to the point where you realize you can’t control or monitor everything and you have to just trust people to do a good job and you’re being forced to delegate versus choosing to because of capacity. That was probably the hardest. And what I’ve learned as, it’s when I take a vacation, you go away for two or three weeks and you come back, you realize you’re not quite as important as you though you were because things run better when you’re gone. It’s kind of a similar thing. I’m very blessed to work with a lot of people who work really hard and do really good work. Our standard of deliverable is very high. And so I can delegate all kinds of tasks to very talented people that I’m blessed to work with and they do an excellent job. But it was hard initially because you’re like, “This is my baby. I’ve hemorrhaged cash and blood for this thing. And now I’m turning over a big chunk of this decision making that I used to make.” (35:51): Which by the way, I probably had no skillset to be making, to be honest. And what happens is you get fortunate enough to grow out of everybody’s a generalist and everything and hire true specialists with expertise in their specific areas. And we’re blessed to be in that situation. Louis Diamond (36:06): What would be an example of some of the specialists? Scott Neu (36:08): Our compliance officer, Whitney, she’s amazing. She runs a very tight ship, but she’s very pro making sure we can do business. Not the typical, I’d say business prevention unit, but a lot of compliance is, at least with my experience at big wirehouses. Our chief operating officer, Brent, he has experience in this. I don’t. I can kind of say, “I don’t like doing this or paying for this.” (36:31): It’s not operations. That’s me whining. And so he comes in with a much more methodical approach of, “Here’s where we’re going. I’m going to reverse engineer back what we need to do and how do we create operational leverage?” (36:46): I think I had one class in operations, an MBA class. I don’t know how to do that. So the thing now is I’m really fortunate that I have a very… Tony Cox is probably one of the smartest people I’ve met in my life. And he’s the president, he’s the chief investment officer. You meet him, you’re going to know he’s the smartest guy here, definitely not me. And he is the one that put together the business from the business perspective and is very shrewd in investing. He’s managed billions of dollars since he was like 24. The guy’s got some chops, he’s legit. (37:19): And so having these people that are really talented sitting in all these very important seats allows me to focus on things I really like doing, which is I like spending time with clients and I like finding other clients. And I don’t have to worry about all this other stuff of budgeting and performance reviews. And not that it’s not important, it’s just not what I like to do. But it’s evolved. You’re wearing 13 hats when you start, if you started from scratch and then you move into shed hats over time and there’s probably a couple other hats I’d like to shed, but sooner or later, it’s Danica Griffith hiring Danica. (37:57): I was blessed to work with Danica at Goldman. Amazing. She built an amazing business there, left, went to PNC, started her risk management, ended up running all of risk management. Everything she does, she crushes. She’s amazing. And she joined us in September and she’s our chief growth officer and her job is to go recruit advisors to join Sage Mountain. She gets up every day thinking about how can we add advisors and how can we make our offering better for advisors? And having someone like that is huge. Louis Diamond (38:26): I want to ask you specifically about Danica and just the though behind a chief growth officer, but on your role, it sounds like you still work and service clients directly. If so, as the business continues to grow and grow, do you think that’s ever going to be a happy takeoff? Scott Neu (38:42): I hope not. I love being a client. It’s my number one thing. That’s who I go to dinner with every weekend. Client. All my friends are my client. I mean, if I could write the script, I’m not the CEO someday. I’m still the chairman. I still have my fingers in the direction of the firm, but I get to spend my time spending time with clients, fixing problems for clients and finding new clients. Louis Diamond (39:01): That’s what makes owning and operating your own business so special, is that you get to pick what you’re most passionate about. And if you make the right hires, invest in your team, it affords you the freedom to offload or delegate the things that don’t charge you up. Scott Neu (39:15): I mean, an example would be I don’t get out of bed going, “I’m excited to go to a budgeting meeting for 2027.” We have people here who are extremely talented that probably do that. Same with Whitney in compliance. I don’t get, “Oh, I can’t wait to do a custody audit,” or whatever that is. But she does it and she does it really well and she has passion for it. She’s excellent. I like getting out of bed thinking, “How can I make…” (39:36): I think the firms of the future that will continue to succeed and outrun AI longer are firms that create the ability for clients to recapture more time to do what they want with their time. And so that’s where I focus my time, thinking about if I’m a client and I have all these different things in my life, what are the things I want to shed and what are things I want to keep and how can I shed those in the most efficient way possible? And my goal is to build this firm while we’re creating all of those ways to shed that time and maximize our client’s time they can spend on family and friends and fun. Louis Diamond (40:15): Very cool. What’s the next service area or the next thing that you envision Sage Mountain doing? Scott Neu (40:20): This is not coming soon, but one of them is like, look, we have clients that have real estate all over the place and a lot of it’s vacation homes. Imagine if we had four people here that literally manage those properties for them down to getting license plate tags renewed. It does not mean they’re doing the painting or the snow removal. It means they’re coordinating all of the subcontractors to make sure that when our clients go on vacation that it works, everything works and it’s been tested and painted and doesn’t leak and the cars or tags are correct, all of that stuff. And that’s something that’s going to be hard for AI to take away. We use AI, we’re implementing AI. I believe we have two choices with that as I can put it in my pocket with a savings or we can reinvest in incremental services. (41:05): We are going to choose number two and we’re using AI. We are fortunate to have a company called Atomic Insights. It’s really been helpful on cashiering, money movement stuff, taking out the work of all of the money movement stuff and making it easier where it puts us in more of an approval seat versus a queue it up for approval seat. So Atomic Insight’s been great. Then another firm we’re using a lot is Cedrus. They build it like this agentic AI. They’re building onboarding for us. They’re going to build CRM for us. They’re going to build all kinds of analytical things for us. We’re early adopters and I’m not afraid to buy technology and have it fail, but the savings we get from that in time, therefore humans, meaning we can do more with the same number of people, we will plow into incremental services and try to continue to build the barrier to entry. Louis Diamond (41:59): I love that. It’s such a cool way to think about the competitive moat. It’s not like we’re just going to add more services that’s harder to fire us. We’re really focused on saving people time and there’s certain things that you as a firm are credible or have the scale to offer that, like you said earlier, anything that touches money is a service that you want to be able to offer. Scott Neu (42:18): If I came to you and you had 80 million bucks in four houses, and I know you’re having to call the managers of all your four houses all the time, imagine if we could take that off your plate for 10 grand and you have 50 million, or 15 grand, you’d be like, “Sign me up because now I’ve got a bunch of people that wake up every day focusing on this and I don’t have to do it in my spare time when my grandkids go down.” Louis Diamond (42:39): Yeah. And it’s all coordinated. Anything with property maintenance, it touches the investment account. If they want to sell the property, it’s going to touch their portfolio, it’s going to touch lending. It makes so much sense. Scott Neu (42:50): Yeah. I could go through 20. We don’t have time for that, but those are the things when I think about the future of our business where I want to be. Louis Diamond (42:58): Give me one or two more. You don’t have to go deep. Scott Neu (43:00): All right, I’ll give you one more. This is more of a dream for me. It’s been my experience that everyone talks about next generation education and everyone does it. We do too, but I haven’t seen anyone do it really well. It doesn’t mean they can’t trot up some special psychiatrists and give you some best practices and help you build family mission statements and all that stuff, which we can too. But it’s one of the things I told the partners is I said, “Before I’m done, I hope people will view Sage Mountain as by the way, they’re also best in class and next gen stuff.” By the way, I have no idea how I’m going to do that, but I’m hopefully I have at least 15 more years in the tank running pretty hard and it’s one of the things that’s on my radar screen. Louis Diamond (43:43): Yeah. I mean, look- Scott Neu (43:44): Because you can’t be best in everything as much as you can try, but I sure hope we’re viewed as top tier in that area because to me, the investing piece is important, but when people go to bed at night, their real legacy is their family and their kids. And so it creates a bigger moat if you become an expert in really helping people with next generation and propagating wealth in an efficient and responsible way. Louis Diamond (44:09): Yeah. Aside from it being a noble cause, clearly you’re passionate about it. It also is a great way to protect the business long term because everyone knows the stats about what happens when G1 passes away or transition from matriarch to patriarch to matriarch, et cetera, to the next generation. So if you spend time investing from a good place, not because you’re just trying to keep people’s assets, if you’re building a moat around your business again. I think that the coolest thing is, you said you have 20 other ideas we can talk about offline, if you’re willing to share, is you have the ability to do any and all of this. You have the blank canvas to do it. The limitation is it’s time, it’s human capital, it’s how do we actually do it? Scott Neu (44:50): Like I said, I’m not big into writing books and doing fireside chats and all that stuff. It may work for other people, that’s just not who I am. But I know we have enough experience around here that if we make this a priority over 10 years and we consistently put effort and resources into it, we can do it. And it won’t be just, oh, we can do that to service where we immunize ourself against competition by saying we have it too. That’s not good enough for me. I want to be really good at it, not just use it to immunize myself in a pitch against somebody. Louis Diamond (45:21): Well said. Two more questions for you and we’ll wrap. You mentioned recently hiring Danica Griffith as your chief growth officer. I know I’m seeing from our executive search business, chief growth officer is definitely an in vogue role that candidates are asking about, firms are hiring. What does chief growth officer mean to you and what does the next phase of growth look like as a result for Sage Mountain? Scott Neu (45:45): So we are blessed. All of our growth so far is organic growth. We’ve done zero acquisitions or liftouts or any of that. We’re fortunate to have a firm that’s built a reputation that people just recommend people to, and I hope we are blessed to continue that. Where we are trying to go, we want to then bring on some advisors with established books of business. We could buy a firm, we’ve though about that, but I think the direction we’re going to go is we’re going to do some liftouts first because we want to really be able to nail these transitions because when advisors talk to us, we have an obligation to go all hands on deck and move those clients as fast as we can because I know what it’s like to move a book and it’s scary. And so the faster we can all circle up and go after those clients, which is part of my job and Danica’s job is… (46:40): And so we’re going to add 10 more advisors from an inorganic perspective, think people with 500 to $2 billion books or teams of people with five to $2 billion books and bolt them on and give them access to our platform and give them a path to earn substantial equity for them and their families. So that’s kind of our plan. And so Danica’s job, this is like classic small business. So we tried it with Tony and I and Brent, our COO, trying to do this as kind of a side hustle for a year, and we added exactly zero advisors, but learned a lot. And so the time and money we spent wasn’t wasted, we paid some tuition. But one of the things we learned is we need to have somebody that gets up every day and it’s their primary role. (47:25): I can’t tell you how grateful I am that Danica is the one that’s chosen to take that position because you need to get her on your podcast in a couple of years. You’re going to find out she’s an absolute killer. And so she’s going to do very well and she’s going to help us. Her job is to recruit advisors and then help integrate them into the firm. So she has one leg in ops/integrations and then another leg into advisor recruitment. Louis Diamond (47:49): Last question for you. What’s a bit of advice you’d give someone who was kind of where you were when you were at Goldman, let’s say in 2016, 2017, looking out over the horizon, thinking about the future, what’s something you would tell them or what’s a hard lesson you learned that you wish someone else doesn’t repeat? Scott Neu (48:06): Well, depends on if you want to stay at Goldman or not. Don’t be a jerk like I was for a long time internally, and usually your career trajectory stays a little longer. I would say, look, whether it’s 2016 or today, if you’re late 30s to 47, and let’s say you’re in reasonable health and you’re going to do this business, you want to continue to grow your business, you’re crazy not to go independent. It’s so robustly built out now. I have a lot of respect for Andy Berg. He started Homrich Berg in the late ’80s. I don’t even know there were independent advisors in the late ’80s. I was in high school, no disrespect to Andy, but I have tons of admiration for that guy because there was nothing. Flip side is today you can literally build a business that gives an amazing experience to your clients with effectively zero conflict, and you can bolt onto a platform like Sage Mountain and create an awesome experience for your clients and meaningful terminal value for your family and far more tax efficient, oh, by the way. (49:10): And so if I was 35 to 45, knowing the independent channel now, my only regret is I didn’t do it five years earlier. Flip side is people stay in these jobs because it’s the path of least resistance. I’m not going to kid you. Even if you bolt onto Sage Mountain, it’s going to be two years of hard work and your head’s going to come up and you’re like, “This is the best thing I ever did.” Ask every advisor we have, but it doesn’t mean it’s not two years of hammer down. So if you’re willing to sacrifice two years and work really hard, you end up in a better spot. Louis Diamond (49:42): Yeah. I always say you 10 years from now will always thank you for that three months, six months, nine months of H-E-L-L that you went through in order to pull up the transition. Scott Neu (49:52): It’s funny, the day I left Goldman, I had many, many people calling me and they were like, “This is going to be the best thing that ever happened to you.” (49:59): Obviously they’re all saying that to be kind humans. They were the only one on the line that believed it because I can tell you I didn’t think that, nor did I think it kind of into year three because I thought about the checks I could have had deposited day one from wirehouses thinking, “This thing isn’t even worth that.” (50:17): And then the amount of sacrifice my family and I and my teammates have made is substantial. I’m just very blessed. I’m so pumped I get to work with amazing people. It’s a privilege to work with people I get to work with. It’s a privilege to work with the clients we’re blessed to work with. Just super thankful. But like I said, I just do it a little different now. I don’t think I would take the hardest path. I’d take the medium path, which is I have meaningful upside without a lot of the trauma of starting a business. Louis Diamond (50:50): Scott, this has been a lot of fun. Like I said, I’m going to follow up with you offline about your other 20 ideas, but a couple of things that I’m going to take from this and always remember is just the way that you started the business, started growing at Goldman was it wasn’t cold marketing, it was networking, doing the right thing for people, and then getting referred and referred and basically doing good work and becoming extremely referable as the growth strategy. I think it’s something that everyone can learn from. I also just love the way you talked about sourcing alternatives and the way you can access different things in a conflict-free model. So really appreciate that. We’re your first interview, that you’re gracious enough to talk about Sage Mountain, you’re vulnerable with us, and I learned a ton and I know our audience did too. Scott Neu (51:33): Thanks for having me. I wish you guys the best. Mindy Diamond (51:42): As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously and are dedicated to your clients, but are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook.

November 5, 2026Episode 38455 min

Partner, Not Acquirer: A Different Private Equity Playbook for Wealth Management

With Haig Ariyan — CEO at Arax and Mike Zabik — Partner, Head of Financial Services at RedBird Capital Partners How Arax and RedBird built a $50B wealth management firm around advisor ownership, organic growth, wirehouse recruiting, and a different approach to private equity. In Summary Private equity has become a powerful force in wealth management, but not every investor approaches the opportunity the same way. Haig Ariyan, CEO of Arax, and Mike Zabik, Partner at RedBird Capital Partners, share how they built a firm from scratch rather than acquiring an existing platform, growing it to approximately $50B in assets and 230 financial advisors. In this conversation with Jason Diamond, they explore what it means to be a partner rather than an acquirer, why advisor equity ownership can accelerate organic growth, and how a hybrid platform can deliver wirehouse-level capabilities with greater flexibility. They also address the questions surrounding private equity valuations, leverage, and exit timelines, along with the opportunities they see in wirehouse team liftouts, ultra-high-net-worth wealth management, and AI-driven advisor productivity. The Storyline There’s no shortage of private equity firms looking to invest in wealth management. And with valuations reaching historically high levels, the competition to acquire established RIAs and recruit successful financial advisors has become increasingly intense. Yet the partnership between Arax and RedBird Capital Partners began with a different premise. Rather than acquire an established wealth management platform and find someone to run it, RedBird set out to find an experienced operator with whom it could build a business from the ground up. That search led Mike Zabik to Haig Ariyan, a veteran wealth management executive whose experience included leadership roles at Alex. Brown and Raymond James. Together, they envisioned a business that would combine the resources, infrastructure, and capital of a large financial institution with the flexibility, ownership opportunities, and entrepreneurial culture of an independent firm. The result was Arax, which has grown to approximately $50B in assets and 230 financial advisors. Their guiding philosophy is to become a “partner of choice, not an acquirer of choice.” But what does that actually mean for financial advisors? For Haig, it means building a platform where advisors help shape the capabilities they use, maintain control over how they serve clients, and participate meaningfully in the equity value of the enterprise they’re helping to grow. For Mike, it means investing in the right people, prioritizing organic growth alongside acquisitions, and resisting the pressure to make business decisions around a predetermined private equity exit timetable. Their discussion with Jason goes well beyond the Arax growth story. They examine the economics of private equity-backed wealth management, including why Mike believes certain businesses can justify EBITDA multiples exceeding 20 times, how leverage complicates the outlook for the largest consolidators, and what advisors should understand about the eventual return of investor capital. They also explore why relatively few PE-backed firms have successfully recruited wirehouse teams directly, despite the significant opportunity, and why Haig considers transition execution just as important as recruiting. Looking ahead, both see opportunities in increasingly complex client needs, the growth of ultra-high-net-worth wealth management, and AI technology that expands advisor capacity. It’s a conversation about the relationship between capital and entrepreneurship, and how the right partnership can influence the business an advisor builds, the clients they serve, and the value they ultimately create. Topics Covered How Arax and RedBird built a wealth management platform from scratch The difference between private equity investors and true operating partners Why Arax emphasizes advisor equity ownership and entrepreneurial culture How hybrid RIA and broker dealer capabilities support sophisticated advisors What wirehouse advisors gain, and what changes, when joining an independent platform The relationship between organic growth, M&A, and enterprise value How advisor equity can create additional incentives for growth Why integrated capabilities, technology, and organic growth influence valuations Private equity EBITDA multiples, leverage, and the potential for RIA IPOs RedBird’s philosophy on exit timing and long-term capital partnerships Why direct wirehouse team liftouts remain an underdeveloped opportunity How AI can improve client onboarding, reporting, prospecting, and advisor productivity The growing opportunity in ultra-high-net-worth wealth management > Download a transcript of this episode… Listen and Learn Highlights for Advisors The origin of a different private equity partnership (04:07) — Mike explains why RedBird was looking for an experienced operator rather than an established platform, and how meeting Haig led to a shared vision for building Arax. Why Arax was designed differently from traditional RIA aggregators (07:27) — Mike describes RedBird’s approach to building businesses from the ground up, while Haig explains the importance of developing a hybrid platform with broker dealer capabilities. How advisor equity ownership changes the relationship (11:34) — Haig discusses creating meaningful ownership opportunities for financial advisors, including the distinction between equity participation and traditional employee forgivable loan arrangements. What independent wealth management can offer wirehouse advisors (18:29) — Haig compares the prescribed capabilities of traditional firms with a partnership model where advisors help shape the resources, services, and solutions available to their clients. Why organic growth matters more than acquisitions alone (20:59) — Mike explains the economics of organic versus inorganic growth, and why he believes firms with strong organic growth profiles command a premium. How equity ownership can accelerate advisor growth (26:13) — Haig describes how ownership gives advisors another reason to grow their practices, expand existing client relationships, and participate in enterprise value creation. What advisors should understand about private equity valuations (33:04) — Jason challenges Mike on high EBITDA multiples and the sustainability of PE-backed wealth management valuations. Mike addresses the economics of building a platform, market fragmentation, and the outlook for larger consolidators. The truth about private equity exit timelines (37:37) — Mike explains why RedBird does not operate Arax around a predetermined exit date, while acknowledging its responsibility to eventually return capital to investors. How AI and integration are shaping Arax’s next phase (41:21) — Haig discusses technology integration, advisor feedback, and how RedBird’s AI team is supporting reporting, practice management, and organic growth. Why more PE-backed RIAs haven’t recruited directly from wirehouses (44:01) — Jason and Haig examine the challenges of direct team liftouts, including recruiting expertise, transition capabilities, and protecting the client experience. Where the next wealth management growth opportunities may emerge (49:10) — Mike identifies generational wealth transfer, ultra-high-net-worth clients, team liftouts, and AI-enabled business development as significant opportunities. AI as augmented intelligence, not advisor replacement (52:23) — Mike explains how RedBird is using AI to increase employee efficiency, improve client acquisition, and free advisors to spend more time on relationships. Key Takeaways 1. The right operating partner can be more important than the acquisition opportunity. RedBird’s decision to build around Haig rather than purchase an existing platform reflects its belief that leadership, operational experience, and entrepreneurial alignment are fundamental to creating enterprise value. For advisors evaluating PE-backed firms, understanding who is making decisions and how the investor and operator work together may be as important as the financial terms. 2. Advisor ownership can fundamentally change the growth equation. A traditional recruiting package may compensate an advisor for changing firms. Meaningful equity participation offers a different opportunity: to share in the value of the larger enterprise. Haig argues that this creates additional incentives for advisors to grow organically, strengthen client relationships, and contribute to the firm’s long-term success. 3. Independence doesn’t have to mean sacrificing capabilities. Arax’s hybrid model is designed to provide financial planning, investment management, alternative investments, lending solutions, and broker dealer capabilities while allowing advisors greater input into how they operate. The distinction is less about the number of resources available and more about whether those resources can be adapted to an advisor’s business and clients. 4. Organic growth is a critical measure of enterprise quality. Mike makes a compelling economic case for organic growth: new assets, revenue, and EBITDA generated without the acquisition costs associated with M&A. He also broadens the definition beyond new client acquisition to include capturing assets held elsewhere, expanding wallet share, and serving more complex client needs. 5. Private equity valuations require a more nuanced analysis. Mike believes integrated, technology-enabled wealth management businesses with strong organic growth profiles can justify premium valuations. However, he also acknowledges the challenges facing the largest consolidators, including leverage, limited pools of potential buyers, and uncertainty surrounding public market valuations. His comments underscore why advisors should understand the financial structure and growth assumptions behind a potential partner. 6. An eventual investor exit is different from a predetermined exit timetable. RedBird will ultimately need to return capital to its limited partners. Mike’s distinction is that Arax is not being managed toward a fixed sale date. For advisors considering a PE-backed firm, the relevant questions include how an investor approaches liquidity, what happens when ownership changes, and whether business decisions are being made with a long-term perspective. 7. Wirehouse recruiting requires specialized expertise. Haig argues that the relative scarcity of direct wirehouse team liftouts among PE-backed RIAs reflects the operational complexity involved. Winning an advisor’s commitment is only the beginning. Successfully transitioning client assets, preserving relationships, and delivering on promised capabilities are essential to sustaining recruiting momentum. 8. AI’s greatest value may be expanding advisor capacity. Rather than viewing AI primarily as a cost-reduction tool, Mike describes its use in client onboarding, reporting, communications, prospecting, and workflow efficiency. The objective is to allow advisors to devote more time to client relationships, business development, and the work that most directly contributes to growth. https://youtu.be/uHwbu2h0otY Quotable Moments “We weren’t looking for a platform, we were looking for a person.” — Mike Zabik, 04:45 “We generate a tremendous amount of alpha going from zero to 100, not starting at 100 and going to 200.” — Mike Zabik, 08:40 “So the most tangible difference is a cultural and commercial one called partnership.” — Haig Ariyan, 20:02 “You would take organic growth over inorganic growth every day of the week.” — Mike Zabik, 20:59 “If you don’t want to bet on the next leg of growth in your business, we probably don’t want to bet on it either.” — Mike Zabik, 32:07 “We don’t have an end game.” — Mike Zabik, 37:37 “Private equity doesn’t inherently know how to lift out a team, speak the language of FA.” — Haig Ariyan, 45:24 “We call it augmented intelligence, not artificial intelligence. We are deploying it to make the humans more efficient, not replace them.” — Mike Zabik, 52:23 FAQs What makes Arax’s private equity partnership model different from a traditional RIA aggregator? Arax was established through a partnership between RedBird Capital Partners and wealth management executive Haig Ariyan, rather than through the acquisition of an existing RIA platform. Its strategy emphasizes recruiting and partnering with high-quality financial advisors, offering meaningful equity ownership, and building an integrated wealth management platform that supports both organic and inorganic growth. What should financial advisors consider before joining a private equity-backed RIA? Advisors should evaluate more than the upfront economics. Important considerations include the ownership structure, investor time horizon, equity participation terms, operating leadership, platform capabilities, decision-making authority, organic growth resources, and how the firm manages advisor transitions. Understanding what changes after joining, and what remains within the advisor’s control, is particularly important. How does equity ownership work for financial advisors joining Arax? Haig explains that Arax offers both W-2 and 1099 affiliation options, with many advisors choosing the W-2 partnership structure because of its equity opportunities. Advisors may receive meaningful ownership tied to their businesses, giving them the potential to benefit from the enterprise value created through organic growth and acquisitions. Specific ownership terms and economics are not detailed in the conversation. How does Arax’s hybrid RIA and broker dealer model benefit financial advisors? The hybrid structure enables advisors to access both fee-based advisory services and brokerage capabilities. Haig notes that approximately 91% of Arax’s business is fee-based advisory, while the remaining 9% includes services such as certain alternative investments, insurance, annuities, transactional fixed income, and executive liquidity strategies. This structure is intended to give sophisticated advisors more flexibility in serving clients with complex needs. Why is organic growth so important to private equity-backed wealth management firms? Organic growth generates additional assets, revenue, and potential earnings without requiring a firm to purchase another business. Mike argues that strong organic growth, particularly when supported by integrated capabilities and technology, can contribute to higher enterprise valuations. At Arax, organic growth initiatives include new client acquisition, expanding relationships with existing clients, and capturing assets previously held elsewhere. Are private equity valuations for RIAs sustainable? Mike argues that high-quality wealth management businesses with recurring revenue, strong organic growth, and integrated operations can support premium EBITDA multiples, including valuations above 20 times in certain cases. However, he distinguishes these businesses from very large consolidators that may face higher leverage, fewer potential buyers, and challenges accessing public markets. His perspective is that valuation sustainability depends on the characteristics and financial structure of the individual business. Does private equity ownership mean an RIA will eventually be sold? Private equity investors generally have an obligation to generate returns and return capital to their investors. Mike acknowledges that RedBird will eventually need to realize its investment in Arax, but says the partnership does not operate under a predetermined exit timetable. Advisors evaluating PE-backed firms should understand the investor’s liquidity strategy, ownership structure, and potential implications of a future transaction. Why haven’t more private equity-backed RIAs recruited wirehouse teams directly? According to Haig, direct wirehouse recruiting requires expertise that private equity investors may not inherently possess. Beyond offering competitive economics, firms must understand wirehouse advisor businesses, execute complex transitions, retain client assets, and minimize disruption. Arax views both direct wirehouse team liftouts and acquisitions of established firms as important components of its growth strategy. How are Arax and RedBird using AI in wealth management? Arax is working with RedBird’s dedicated AI team, RDX, on technology integration, reporting, practice management, and organic growth initiatives. Mike also describes applications involving client onboarding, communications, workflow automation, and prospecting. Their approach emphasizes using AI to improve advisor productivity and expand capacity rather than replace employees. What growth opportunities do Arax and RedBird see in wealth management? Mike identifies generational wealth transfer, increasingly complex client needs, the expansion of ultra-high-net-worth wealth management, direct wirehouse team liftouts, and AI-enabled productivity as important opportunities. He also points to the need for deeper planning capabilities, technology investments, and sophisticated investment solutions to serve affluent clients. Arax was established through a partnership between RedBird Capital Partners and wealth management executive Haig Ariyan, rather than through the acquisition of an existing RIA platform. Its strategy emphasizes recruiting and partnering with high-quality financial advisors, offering meaningful equity ownership, and building an integrated wealth management platform that supports both organic and inorganic growth. Advisors should evaluate more than the upfront economics. Important considerations include the ownership structure, investor time horizon, equity participation terms, operating leadership, platform capabilities, decision-making authority, organic growth resources, and how the firm manages advisor transitions. Understanding what changes after joining, and what remains within the advisor’s control, is particularly important. Haig explains that Arax offers both W-2 and 1099 affiliation options, with many advisors choosing the W-2 partnership structure because of its equity opportunities. Advisors may receive meaningful ownership tied to their businesses, giving them the potential to benefit from the enterprise value created through organic growth and acquisitions. Specific ownership terms and economics are not detailed in the conversation. The hybrid structure enables advisors to access both fee-based advisory services and brokerage capabilities. Haig notes that approximately 91% of Arax’s business is fee-based advisory, while the remaining 9% includes services such as certain alternative investments, insurance, annuities, transactional fixed income, and executive liquidity strategies. This structure is intended to give sophisticated advisors more flexibility in serving clients with complex needs. Organic growth generates additional assets, revenue, and potential earnings without requiring a firm to purchase another business. Mike argues that strong organic growth, particularly when supported by integrated capabilities and technology, can contribute to higher enterprise valuations. At Arax, organic growth initiatives include new client acquisition, expanding relationships with existing clients, and capturing assets previously held elsewhere. Mike argues that high-quality wealth management businesses with recurring revenue, strong organic growth, and integrated operations can support premium EBITDA multiples, including valuations above 20 times in certain cases. However, he distinguishes these businesses from very large consolidators that may face higher leverage, fewer potential buyers, and challenges accessing public markets. His perspective is that valuation sustainability depends on the characteristics and financial structure of the individual business. Private equity investors generally have an obligation to generate returns and return capital to their investors. Mike acknowledges that RedBird will eventually need to realize its investment in Arax, but says the partnership does not operate under a predetermined exit timetable. Advisors evaluating PE-backed firms should understand the investor’s liquidity strategy, ownership structure, and potential implications of a future transaction. According to Haig, direct wirehouse recruiting requires expertise that private equity investors may not inherently possess. Beyond offering competitive economics, firms must understand wirehouse advisor businesses, execute complex transitions, retain client assets, and minimize disruption. Arax views both direct wirehouse team liftouts and acquisitions of established firms as important components of its growth strategy. Arax is working with RedBird’s dedicated AI team, RDX, on technology integration, reporting, practice management, and organic growth initiatives. Mike also describes applications involving client onboarding, communications, workflow automation, and prospecting. Their approach emphasizes using AI to improve advisor productivity and expand capacity rather than replace employees. Mike identifies generational wealth transfer, increasingly complex client needs, the expansion of ultra-high-net-worth wealth management, direct wirehouse team liftouts, and AI-enabled productivity as important opportunities. He also points to the need for deeper planning capabilities, technology investments, and sophisticated investment solutions to serve affluent clients. Related Resources Ownership Matters: What Advisors Need to Know When Evaluating Firms (article) Conducting a Strategic Due Diligence Process: 10 Practical Tips for Financial Advisors (dowload) The Wirehouse Talent Battle: Winners, Losers and What’s Changing (podcast) Haig Ariyan Founder and Chief Executive Officer Haig Ariyan is the Founder and Chief Executive Officer of Arax Investment Partners .(Should we change this to Arax Wealth)? At Arax, Haig oversees all operations, strategic direction, and leadership of the firm. Prior to joining Arax, Haig was the President and CEO of Alex. Brown, America’s first investment banking firm. While at Alex. Brown, Haig oversaw 220 Financial Advisors in 18 offices and $70B in client assets. Haig was the Head of Global Wealth Solutions, the product and solutions platform supporting all of Raymond James’ more than 8,000 affiliated advisors. Prior to leading the sale and integration of Alex. Brown to Raymond James Financial, Haig was the head of Deutsche Bank Wealth Management in the Americas. Haig joined Alex. Brown & Sons in 1996 as a client advisor in Greenwich, Connecticut. After several years of building a successful practice working with high-net-worth families and playing an integral role in Deutsche Bank’s acquisition of BT Alex. Brown, Haig was named Regional Executive of the Greenwich office. In 2005, he was promoted to manage the midtown New York City office, while continuing to oversee the Greenwich business. He was also responsible for opening Deutsche Bank’s Wall Street branch. In 2009, Haig served as Head of the Eastern Region of Private Client Services and one year later was appointed the Head of the American wealth management franchise. Haig started his career at Dean Witter Reynolds. Haig is active on the board of trustees of the Diocese of the Armenian Church as well as the central council of the Armenian General Benevolent Union (AGBU). He has served as chairman of the Armenian Church Endowment Fund’s investment committee and is a member of the board of the Dadourian Foundation, a private family foundation based in New York. Haig is also a member of the board of the MassMutual Trust Company. Haig holds a B.S. from Rutgers University. Mike Zabik Partner and Head of Financial Services Mike Zabik is a Partner and Head of Financial Services at RedBird Capital Partners , where he leads the Firm’s Financial Services investment sector, including its inaugural dedicated Financial Services Fund. Mike leads all sourcing, execution, company building, and monetization initiatives across the Financial Services portfolio. Since 2014, the Firm has invested over $2.2 billion in financial services investments across 11 platforms and completed ~55 add-on acquisitions. Mike is responsible for the Firm’s investments in Aquarian Holdings, Main Street Advisors, Obra Capital, iCreditWorks, Arax Investment Partners, Bishop Street Underwriters, Nuverna Global and Affinia. He also previously led RedBird’s investment in Constellation Affiliated Partners, an MGA platform, sold to Truist in July 2021. In addition to his active investment responsibilities, Mike leads the Portfolio Financing Team, which has structured 50+ financings across the Firm’s portfolio of platform investments. Prior to joining RedBird, Mike was a Vice President at Ares Management LLC for four years, and before that was an Associate at Kelso & Company. Mike began his career at Deutsche Bank in the firm’s Leveraged Finance and Private Debt businesses. Mike has been recognized several times professionally during his tenure at RedBird, including Sports Business Journal’s 40 Under 40 in 2017 and Private Equity International’s Future 40 Leaders: Dealmakers in 2022. Philanthropically, Mike is a member of Indiana University’s Center for Investment Banking & Principal Investment Alumni Executive Committee. Mike holds a B.S. in Finance and Accounting from Indiana University. NOTE: The views and opinions expressed by the guests on this podcast are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Diamond Consultants. Neither Diamond Consultants nor the guests on this podcast are compensated in any way for their participation. View the transcript of this episode… Partner, Not Acquirer: A Different Private Equity Playbook for Wealth Management With Haig Ariyan — CEO at Arax and Mike Zabik — Partner, Head of Financial Services at RedBird Capital Partners Jason Diamond ( 00:05 ): Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is Partner Not Acquirer, a different private equity playbook for wealth management. It’s a conversation with Haig Ariyan, CEO at Arax, and Mike Zabik, partner, head of financial services at RedBird Capital Partners. ( 00:22 ): I’m Jason Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond ( 00:28 ): At Diamond Consultants, we [00:00:30] help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. ( 00:38 ): With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. ( 00:55 ): Our process is education-driven and based on building relationships, starting [00:01:00] as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at (908) 879-1002. ( 01:21 ): Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more [00:01:30] inspired us to create our annual Advisor Transition Report. It’s the award-winning, data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. ( 01:46 ): Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. To download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport. Jason Diamond ( 02:00 ): [00:02:00] There’s certainly no shortage of private equity capital and wealth management today, but capital alone doesn’t create a differentiated firm. The more interesting question is what happens when an investor and an operator start with a blank sheet of paper and ask, “If we could build a wealth management business from scratch, what would we want it to be?” That’s essentially how Arax began. ( 02:23 ): My guests today are Haig Ariyan, CEO of Arax, and Mike Zabik, partner and head of financial services at RedBird Capital Partners. [00:02:30] Their partnership started differently than many PE-backed wealth management stories. RedBird wasn’t looking for an operator to run a business it had already acquired. Mike and his team were looking for the right person to build around, and Haig wasn’t interested in creating another aggregator. The result is a firm built around an idea they describe as becoming a partner of choice, not an acquirer of choice, one that has since grown to approximately 50 billion in assets and 230 financial advisors. ( 02:57 ): What makes their story particularly relevant [00:03:00] is that it gets directly into some of the questions advisors and firm leaders are asking right now. What should private equity actually bring to a wealth management business beyond capital? Why does Arax see wirehouse team lift-outs as an important growth opportunity when relatively few PE-backed firms have cracked that code? And with valuations at historically high levels, what does a private equity investor say about multiples, leverage, and the inevitable question of an exit? ( 03:25 ): We also get into the balance between organic and inorganic growth, how advisor equity changes the growth [00:03:30] equation, and why Mike thinks AI is best used as augmented intelligence, a way to increase advisor capacity rather than replace people. It’s a candid look at what can happen when private equity and wealth management operate as true partners and what it takes to make that partnership work. So let’s get to it. ( 03:53 ): So thrilled to have you both here. Thank you for joining me. Let’s dive right in. Mike, maybe we’ll start with you. Take us back to the beginning, [00:04:00] the brainchild for this idea, start with your backgrounds and what formed this marriage between RedBird and Arax. Mike Zabik ( 04:07 ): Yeah, sure. First of all, thank you for having us. The history of Arax is like the history of RedBird. So just to take a 12-year step back, I was employee number three here. And I joined back when the firm was three guys, three laptops and a whiteboard, and we had less than a hundred million under management. ( 04:22 ): Today, it’s about 120 people and 15 billion of AUM globally. And I’ve had the very fortunate privilege of watching the firm scale and grow [00:04:30] and diversify into what it is today. And if you listen to our founder talk at all about the ethos of this place, it’s always been about building things, not buying things. And FIG is no exception to that. And so we’ll get into it later in the conversation. ( 04:45 ): But when we set out to build Arax, we weren’t looking for a platform, we were looking for a person. And we spent a long time trying to find someone as talented as Haig to build a business around. And I was quite fortunate to meet Haig spring of 2022, [00:05:00] and we basically spent six months mapping out what we wanted to be when we grew up and what the vision for the company was. And I’ll let him get into that a bit in a minute. ( 05:10 ): But we set out to build something special. And I’m not just saying that in the pejorative context. We wanted to build a differentiated wealth management platform that had a slightly different approach to how it was going to be built. That would become a partner of choice, not an acquirer of choice. And we think there’s a fundamental difference between [00:05:30] how we have built this business over the last four years and how some other people are doing it. Jason Diamond ( 05:33 ): And Haig, I’d love your perspective on the same. What is your origin story or how you guys got engaged and ultimately married? Haig Ariyan ( 05:39 ): Jason, thank you. Thanks for having Mike and I together. We actually love telling this story together. And truly we’ve been partners from the start, and I very sincerely refer to Mike as my co-founder of Arax. ( 05:51 ): So what was really profound and vivid to me when I remember the initiation of Arax was that, at that period of time, [00:06:00] I was the CEO of Alex Brown and the head of Global Wealth Solutions for Raymond James. I was getting a lot of calls from private equity firms. And every one of those calls was a private equity investor that had already bought an asset and was looking for an operator, or had a distinct strategy in mind and wanted to see if I would come run it for them and execute upon it. ( 06:21 ): The difference was when RedBird and Mike Zabik called me. They sincerely asked, “What’s your view on the independent wealth management space?” [00:06:30] And that led into a dialogue around, if you were to build a business in the independent wealth space, what would it be? And so that spoke to that ethos that Mike alluded to, which was that they are builders of businesses and they’re looking to back operators, and it’s been sincere from day one. So that really was profoundly different than the other calls we were getting at the time. Jason Diamond ( 06:54 ): Yeah, and I want to click more into that. I especially like that you refer to each other as partners, because I do think that’s a bit of a unique [00:07:00] dynamic between the capital or the private equity sponsor and the wealth management firm. ( 07:05 ): Mike, maybe I’ll ask you from your perspective, Haig saying exactly that, got calls from private equity firms every day. It’s no secret, this is an incredibly crowded space, both for private equity firms, but also a lot of different wealth management platforms and models. What was it specifically that you felt like was a gap that you were trying to address in partnership with Haig? Mike Zabik ( 07:27 ): Yeah, I’d answer it two ways, Jason. One from a macro [00:07:30] perspective and then two from a micro perspective specifically what we did with Haig. I think if you look at the way most private equity funds play not only wealth management, but FIG broadly defined, people start with platforms. They want to start by buying things that are generally 50 to 100 million of EBITDA. ( 07:47 ): They use that as the chassis, and then they want to dump a bunch of stuff into that box and run an aggregator playbook. We have never been an aggregator model, and that’s been very intentional. And we do this across every sub-sector [00:08:00] that we deploy capital in FIG. Very humbly, I think we’re the only shop out there that consistently does de novo platform buy and builds as its core strategy. ( 08:11 ): Nine times out of 10, what we do is we link up with someone like Haig or a team of operators, marry our M&A pipeline with theirs and sit out to build a differentiated business. Different in the sense that we’re not inheriting someone else’s portfolio construction. We’re not buying something the way someone else [00:08:30] wanted to build it, and then say, “Well, if we leverage it a little bit more, cut a few more costs or buy a few more things, we can squeak out a 2X return over the next five years.” ( 08:40 ): We think we generate a tremendous amount of alpha going from zero to 100, not starting at 100 and going to 200. And so despite that, when we told our LPs that we were going to make a play in wealth management, everybody said, “Are you nuts? There are 150 private equity-backed platforms out there. How are you guys going to differentiate [00:09:00] yourselves in a world that is awash in capital and awash in opportunities? And they’re all run by really sophisticated people that have a pretty good sense of what their business is worth.” ( 09:11 ): I think very humbly, one of the most differentiating things that Haig said was he said, “I want to build a hybrid.” And he said very definitively back in 2022, “Hybrid’s not a dirty word.” And so we’ve never thought it is or was, and we thought that having a broker-dealer inside of the business would facilitate [00:09:30] attracting and retaining some of the best and most sophisticated financial advisors in the country. And so we moved very early. ( 09:37 ): And one of the core tenants of what we set out to build was to have that capability, and I think it’s served us really well over the last four years because we’ve been able to attract and retain a number of the most talented financial advisors in the country. Jason Diamond ( 09:51 ): That’s super fair perspective. Haig, do you think that Mike is telling that story honestly, if they lived up to that promise as a partner and allowed you to build this? Because it sounds [00:10:00] like you had ample opportunities to build kind of whatever you wanted with the capital. Has the firm evolved into exactly what Mike is describing, a zero to 100 machine? It seems like yes, based on what we see in the news and the success you’ve had. Haig Ariyan ( 10:12 ): The firm’s evolved into even better than the whiteboard that we put together. But to be very clear about that conversation initially, in addition to what Mike said, they were looking to me to say, “What would your playbook be?” And I admitted at that time, I think this aggregator model [00:10:30] that you’re seeing a lot of private equity firms do, it has legs. ( 10:34 ): You’ve got tailwinds, 16,000 RIAs out there, plenty of capital, awash in the market that wants to invest in it. And it’s a very highly fragmented industry where a lot of these RIAs want to sell. This trend is going to go on for quite some time. And if you want to be an aggregator, I say go for it, you got plenty of time. But that’s not interesting to me, and I don’t think it’s the way you do something differentiated. ( 10:56 ): And Mike agreed to me, he says, “That doesn’t really fit our [00:11:00] RedBird model of doing something differentiated with an operator from a de novo basis. We’d rather do something that is a little bit more bespoke.” And so that immediately the conversation was from me that said, “I firmly believe that what’s missing in the market is a firm that is focused solely on the quality of the financial advisors as a reflection of the quality of clients and staff that you will have. If you key in on the quality of those financial advisors as being the profession’s [00:11:30] best, our chances of success are extremely high. ( 11:34 ): And so in order to be able to attract those best financial advisors, which was Mike’s next question, “Well, how do you do that?” I said, “One, you make them real equity partners, and when you bring in their business, you do it on a tax advantage basis and you make sure they own meaningful equity in what you’re going to build together. You don’t do this highly taxable employee forgivable loan, which is a model of folks renting a platform.” That’s just been a strong belief [00:12:00] I’ve had. And I’m someone who used that employee forgivable loan model for 25 years, but it was always flawed. ( 12:07 ): So I said, “You make them equity partners. Secondly, you give them every tool they need to deliver the great experience their clients are accustomed to.” And inclusive in that tool, BOX is a broker-dealer. And so this whole concept that broker-dealer is a dirty word, this whole concept that you are inherently conflicted, that’s highly offensive to me. The best financial advisors [00:12:30] who have a broker-dealer in their toolkit, are you telling me that financial advisor acts and behaves with conflict versus someone who is a pure advisor? I don’t buy into that. ( 12:41 ): So fast-forward, what we’ve built today on that premise of partnership and a full platform is a $50 billion wealth management firm that is 91% fee-based advisory and 9% broker-dealer business, and that 9% is made up of alternatives [00:13:00] with trails. It’s made up of 10b5-1 plans facilitating corporate executive liquidity. It’s made up of insurance and annuities and some transactional business, particularly for fixed income when rates are very narrow. So it really has evolved into a platform that Mike and I envisioned together and aligned on four and a half years ago. Jason Diamond ( 13:21 ): I don’t get the impression though that while the hybrid model makes sense, you’re not attracting nor do you want the types of advisors who are sitting there churning structured notes and [00:13:30] single stock options. I view it as more, correct me if I’m wrong, you affiliate with big boys and girls and you want to give them the choice to run their business as efficiently as possible, however that may be, whether that’s advisory, brokerage, or otherwise. Is that a fair summary? Haig Ariyan ( 13:44 ): Jason, you just touched on what is one of our other key differentiators in the independent wealth space. When you focus on the best financial advisors in the profession, if you truly stick to that discipline, you don’t tell them how to run their business, you don’t tell them how to change their business. [00:14:00] So we’re not plugging you into a mousetrap that everyone’s doing the same thing. We’re not plugging into an investment plan or a house view where everyone does the same thing. ( 14:08 ): As much as that’s highly scalable and as much as that may trade for a premium, that’s not how you get the best financial professionals to serve those households that are your clients. You embrace what they do, you empower it with greater resources, you give them additional resources to round out their business and their practice, and that helps them grow organically. [00:14:30] So you’re exactly right. But that formula for the best financial advisors, it resonates with them, and then to be a partner in it further resonates with them. Jason Diamond ( 14:39 ): I think that’s right. Mike, I want to ask you this because I think Haig will be too humble to give me the honest answer here. Mike Zabik ( 14:45 ): I can’t wait to hear the question. Jason Diamond ( 14:46 ): We get approached by a lot of private equity firms and the like who want to do something like this. And you already alluded to this, that you were looking for somebody like Haig to come around. I think it’s critical, somebody who speaks the language, somebody who has a reputation. To [00:15:00] what extent do you think that has enabled you to be successful, having the right leader and the right established… I would assume partly it’s a Rolodex also that helped you to really build this business out. Mike Zabik ( 15:10 ): Yeah. I would tell you who we partner with, whether it was Arax or any other platform that we’ve ever done, who we partner with is the most important decision we make over the life of the investment. And so we will spend a tremendous amount of time. It’s a very atypical thing for a private equity guy to say. We raise funds, our job is to deploy the capital, [00:15:30] turn it into more money, and then give it back to our LPs. ( 15:32 ): That being said, we have never been in a rush to put money out the door. We have never done a deal because a sub-sector is hot. We will actually just wait and spend a tremendous amount of time waiting for the right person to come along. And while they’re not unicorns, they’re not mythological creatures, there are very few of them out there, and there is only one Haig guardian, and we spend a lot of time trying to find somebody like Haig. ( 15:59 ): I would tell you [00:16:00] the prerequisites for people that we partner with has evolved over time, but it really comes down to three factors. And I know we’re going to talk about AI later. One is a tremendous amount of operational experience. I’m going to date Haig a little bit. Haig’s been doing this since Sears owned Dean Witter, and it was stocks and socks. So Haig’s been doing this for a long time, right? ( 16:21 ): Haig is an FA’s FA. Haig has been one. Haig has led them. Haig has led big businesses. But [00:16:30] almost as important as the operational capabilities that Haig had running big businesses, like Raymond James Global Wealth Business and Alex Brown, he’s very entrepreneurial. What we also don’t want is someone that wants to come in and inherit someone else’s portfolio construction. ( 16:46 ): And what’s really hard to find, frankly, is people that have Haig’s operational chops but are comfortable being uncomfortable. Because walking away from something that has the robust infrastructure like a Raymond James or an [00:17:00] Alex Brown, and then sitting down the hall from me for a year and having a CFO and two laptops and a whiteboard, is unplugging the matrix and waking up in the real world. ( 17:11 ): And that is terrifying for most people, right? They want to keep the cushy job, or they want to go work at a sponsor-backed private equity portfolio company that already has a hundred million of EBITDA. So it takes a long time to find people like Haig, which is why we run a really concentrated portfolio. And the fund that we’re deploying out of, we’re [00:17:30] going to have six to eight of these partnerships because it takes a long time to find people like Haig. Jason Diamond ( 17:35 ): Yeah. It seems like, especially as you get into the more boutique-y type of space, which I would certainly consider you, the culture and the quality and the makeup of the management teams matter even more. And ultimately, we see that with advisors. Advisors have so much choice today between wirehouses, boutique firms, regional firms like Raymond James, established RIAs, launching their own RIAs, selling to a private equity. All of these are legitimate options, and they’re really making a decision on who to [00:18:00] tie their horse to in some cases. ( 18:02 ): Haig, let me ask you this then. I want to tap into the thread because a lot of our audience is wirehouse or ex-wirehouse advisors, and that’s a world you’re familiar with, or call it W-2 traditional firm land is a world you’re familiar with. You talked about the forgivable loan. Give me the starkest contrast in your mind between the world you live in now, call it the RIA space, versus the traditional firm world from a capabilities perspective, from an advisor experience perspective. Haig Ariyan ( 18:29 ): The starkest [00:18:30] difference to a wirehouse FA’s experience at their wirehouse and what would be, let’s say at Arax. And I won’t speak to the independent wealth world, I’ll speak to Arax. One, these FAs are used to having everything at their fingertips, but those fingertips don’t generally get to everything very efficiently and very effectively, and everything they get to is defined by someone else. It’s predefined for them. It’s prescribed as to how it works. It’s prescribed as to how much [00:19:00] it costs. It’s prescribed as to who it’s for. ( 19:02 ): At Arax, we’ve been very deliberate about getting every resource a financial advisor is accustomed to having at a bank-owned wirehouse, at a wirehouse, at a national firm. And we’ve built out a very robust platform from wealth planning to financial planning, to tax planning, to investment stock, to all the infrastructure that they may in fact need, to practice management. ( 19:26 ): All of that exists, but it’s truly at their fingertips. And they’ve [00:19:30] helped define it, they’ve helped design it. It’s been built in their vision because they are partners in the organization. And if they don’t like the way it’s built or they don’t think it’s the right way, we’re able to modify it quickly. ( 19:42 ): Our decision making is essentially Mike Zabik and Haig Ariyan. Well, really, if it gets to Mike’s level, then it’s something that involves a significant strategic decision or meaningful amount of capital infusion, but the business is run very effectively and we make decisions quickly, and we make [00:20:00] them in partnership with our financial advisors. ( 20:02 ): So the most tangible difference is a cultural and commercial one called partnership. And the business is built for those financial advisors, not by a large firm or a large bank that has shareholders or constituents that they answer to. It’s built for the financial advisors because that means we’re building it for their clients. Jason Diamond ( 20:21 ): Yeah. I love that the answer is centered around both the culture side, but also what that culture and what that ethos enables, which is very much a capabilities [00:20:30] conversation. ( 20:37 ): Mike, maybe I’ll throw this next one at you. And this may be a kind of a simple corporate finance question, but I’m curious what your mentality is around growth. If I gave you the choice, you could acquire a new hundred million dollar business or have one of your existing businesses grow a hundred million, which are you taking and why? What’s your mentality around organic versus inorganic? Because it’s kind of a hot button issue these days for firms, given how expensive recruiting’s gotten. Mike Zabik ( 20:59 ): It’s a [00:21:00] great question, Jason. Haig and I actually spent an hour talking about this morning. I would tell you, you would take organic growth over inorganic growth every day of the week. They’re both critically important, and so we spend a lot of time, energy, and money on both. I think the bigger firms get, the harder it is to consistently generate net flows that are mid to high single-digits, certainly low double-digits. ( 21:26 ): And I think that given where referral programs [00:21:30] are today and where they’re going over the next one to three years, I think that organic growth is only going to get harder. I think that it was very strategic for us. We have no referral programs today, and we have consistently put up, I think, best-in-class net flows, organic growth rates, and without referral programs, and that is incremental AUM and revenue and EBITDA that we’re not paying for. ( 21:59 ): Now that being said, [00:22:00] M&A is a critical component to the growth, and we have found that post partnering with a team of financial advisors that we pull out of a wirehouse or a business that we acquire, we are typically unleashing them and/or empowering them to do even more for the clients that they have, or enable them to attract and retain new clients that they may have otherwise not been able to get. ( 22:25 ): And so especially with the firms and/or teams that are smaller or maybe have [00:22:30] a less sophisticated approach to alts, having a team in-house that can have an elevated conversation about trust, estate tax, and wealth planning, which is becoming more and more important to people or a differentiated robust alts offering with the centralized investment office that we have at Arax, that we do M&A, but then generate organic growth on the back of it. And so they’re both important. ( 22:54 ): I would tell you, we think people in this market pay a premium for three things, businesses that are integrated, [00:23:00] businesses that are tech-enabled, although the definition of tech enablement has changed over the last couple of years, and businesses that have a really strong organic growth profile. Jason Diamond ( 23:08 ): Yeah, that’s a really good synopsis. So let me ask you then, does this become a part of your value prop in your recruiting strategy? Do you say to advisors, “We can help you grow both organically and potentially inorganically when you’re ready for it?” Haig Ariyan ( 23:20 ): It’s an interesting way to pose the question. We make it clear to financial advisors that the continued organic growth of your practice is very important to us. [00:23:30] And during that recruiting process, you learn very quickly if that is important to them. We’re only interested in partners who want to continue to grow their business organically. And by the way, that top 2 to 5% of our profession, one of the key parameters that defines the best financial advisors is that they continue to grow their business organically. ( 23:51 ): We have some of the best financial advisors on the planet that are within our 230 financial advisors. I think as a group, as a business, on average, [00:24:00] we have the best financial advisors in the profession, but they wake up every morning thinking of ways to grow their business. That’s important to us, and that’s important to them. So it’s incumbent upon us to empower them to do so. So yes, it’s very much part of the conversation. Jason Diamond ( 24:14 ): And doesn’t it need to be even further… I don’t mean to push, but doesn’t it need to even be, not only can we help you grow, but because of how competitive it is to recruit and growth is important to you, I agree with you, successful advisors, growth is by definition important. Every firm is promising to these advisors. Morgan Stanley is promising to these advisors [00:24:30] the funnel, right? We’re feeding you relationships from workplace and from E-Trade. So doesn’t it need to be something stronger? ( 24:36 ): And maybe Mike, you alluded to part of this answer with things like trust and estate is part of the answer is offering your advisors more to be able to grow. Mike Zabik ( 24:43 ): Yeah. I mean, I would tell you… I’d answer a couple of different ways, Jason. We have so many different organic growth initiatives going on at the firm. When you join, either if we acquire a going concern business or we recruit you out of one of the wirehouses, we have 10 different [00:25:00] organic growth initiatives going on right now, and some of those are for high net worth profile clients, some of those are for ultra-high net worth profile clients. ( 25:09 ): And so to your point, I think there is a robust set of capabilities, whether that’s trust, estate, tax and wealth planning, whether that’s better access to alternatives, whether that’s augmenting the funnel you have with various technology solutions. If you become part of the family and become part of the partnership, there is a kaleidoscope of [00:25:30] capabilities that are made available to you, which should help drive incremental organic growth. ( 25:35 ): By the way, that’s not just defined as getting incremental clients. In many cases, folks that we have partnered with in the past, there is money away from them somewhere else, right? Either they didn’t have a robust alts offering in their prior lives, and so they don’t often have 100% share of wallet of every client they have. And so organic growth for us isn’t always defined as picking up an incremental [00:26:00] net new client. In many cases, it’s helping either facilitate generational wealth transfer from an M&A transaction or providing interesting investment alternatives that would bring money that was away into Arax AUM. Haig Ariyan ( 26:13 ): Further to that, imagine a scenario, a profession where you as a business person have truly built your business yourself, okay? You’ve established your client relationship to yourself, you’ve brought in all those clients, and yet you don’t own that business. You get paid well, [00:26:30] you get a variable comp that’s a nice component of that business, but you don’t own that business. ( 26:34 ): So imagine a firm like Arax where we and empower you to have a major equity component that is a reflection of your business, or we also empower you to do it fully independent. We offer 1099 and W-2 solutions, but most of RFAs tend to gravitate towards the W-2 partner solution because they’re getting a significant amount of equity. ( 26:57 ): And then when you, as a partner, discuss with them [00:27:00] the power of organic growth in growing the value of that equity, they are further driven to bring in new clients, to grow with their existing clients, not just for the variable comp payout they get, but for the meaningful wealth creation opportunity that’s presented to them and their families on that equity piece. And that’s what’s driving organic growth coupled with all of those resources that Mike’s speaking. Jason Diamond ( 27:23 ): Yeah. It’s a very interesting way to think about it is that you’re really using the equity as another lever there. What is the, [00:27:30] I don’t want to say the tit-for-tat there? But if you’re an advisor, it’s maybe shrouded in opacity a little bit. What does it actually entail? I’m not talking about economically, I’m talking about in practice. ( 27:41 ): You’ve both said now a couple of times, I assume alluding to some of your competitors, we’re not the model where we’re going to take all of our advisors and throw them into the firm managed CIO portfolios and trying to round peg and square hole advisors. What does change though? Tell me as an advisor, what is that experience actually like from running my own business and my own RIA, or I’m at some other firm to [00:28:00] now post partnership with Arax? Haig Ariyan ( 28:02 ): Yeah. I love the expression shredded in opacity, Jason, because I think much of our profession when you’re recruiting, and we’ll touch on recruiting a bit, but much of our profession and the pitch has been historically shredded in opacity. The independent wealth space has solved for that because the clarity that an advisor requires and needs to move their business or sell their business to a different platform outside of a wirehouse [00:28:30] that are generally very well-resourced requires that there is no opaque nature to the conversation. ( 28:38 ): So the strength of a platform in the independent wealth space, we have been able to create a platform somewhat due to the innovation in FinTech today, very much due to the demands of financial advisors and clients, very much due to the fact that we founded this firm in 2022. We had a good 15 years of watching our competitors make mistakes. [00:29:00] We learned from those mistakes. We learned what not to do, and we learned what resources are needed. ( 29:06 ): So when you build a true wealth planning platform, when you build a true investments platform that doesn’t predefine how the advisor has to invest his client’s assets, when you find balance sheet solutions, which was the missing link in the independent wealth space, that’s now being resolved by multiple firms and balance sheets that have come forth to say, “We see the independent wealth space as an opportunity to distribute balance sheet.” [00:29:30] That’s been solved for now. ( 29:31 ): Now, is it that as clean as owning your own balance sheet and going to the private bank or saying, “Hey, I need a mortgage?” Well, it’s gotten there. It’s now very accessible. SBL is click and fun in the independent wealth space. So all these things that we’re missing are now solved for, but you need to have a partner who has put the pieces together in an integrated way so that an advisor who’s lifting out of a large firm, or a firm that [00:30:00] it’s plugging into your organization does not have a cut and paste experience, but as actually joining an integrated platform where these things are right at their fingertips. ( 30:10 ): That is very empowering and doesn’t allow for that being shredded in opacity that you’re referring to. No longer is that an okay solved by your deal terms. It used to be, “Oh, well I’m getting this deal and it’s a good deal, and I’ll figure it out when I get there.” That doesn’t work anymore, Jason, because there’s too many deals out there. You have to actually have a differentiated [00:30:30] offering for them. That’s why I think 230 financial advisors and $50 billion has validated that there’s something differentiated about Arax that we’re doing. Mike Zabik ( 30:40 ): The only thing I was going to add, Jason, for what it’s worth, you don’t have to take our word for it. I think one of the greatest accomplishments that the company has, because you asked about how the FA thinks about organic and inorganic growth, one of the things that’s been most gratifying for me is everybody can say what’s going to happen, just the point that Haig is making. Whether it actually [00:31:00] happens once you become part of the family is a big testament. ( 31:03 ): And so what’s been really compelling, I think, in the message to the market, because all these folks talk to each other. While it’s a really big and dynamic industry, everybody talks, and everybody talks to each other and the world is actually quite small when you break it down. And what’s been really cool to watch is that whether they are businesses that we have acquired or FAs that we have partnered with to pull out of the wirehouses, the number of times that they have [00:31:30] spent six months inside of the family and said, “This actually isn’t what you said it was going to be, it’s better than that,” and then refer one of their friends. ( 31:40 ): I’m thinking of the SRS guys who then turned around and introduced us to their friends at CDRIS, or different financial advisors that we’ve pulled out of wirehouses where they’ve gone back to other friends in their ecosystems and said, “It’s actually going really well. Everything they said was true and it’s actually been a little bit better than that. You should come.” And so a big chunk of our inorganic [00:32:00] activity has actually been referrals from existing capital partners in the cap table. ( 32:07 ): And so the other point, and I’ll say this very bluntly, we don’t buy 100% of anything at RedBird, unless we’re doing a corporate carve out, which has been in the FIG portfolio, I think twice out of a hundred investments. If you want to sell 100% of your company, move to Florida and buy a boat and retire, we are not your guys. And philosophically, if you don’t want to bet on the next leg of growth in [00:32:30] your business, we probably don’t want to bet on it either. ( 32:33 ): And so equity rollover has always been a core component, whether it’s a going concern acquisition or a team lift-out. And it’s important from an economic alignment perspective. It’s important for value creation for those financial advisors. It’s important to drive organic growth. It also really helps for inorganic growth. And they have the opportunity to continue to participate and follow on if they want to, or you have a established capital partner that has [00:33:00] tons of dry powder that’s happy to continue to fund that M&A. Jason Diamond ( 33:04 ): Yeah. So you both gave me the good. I get to be Debbie Downer now. And Mike, I’ll give you two tough ones. And they’re probably the two most common objections we hear. Again, not to bring the rain clouds here, but real objections we hear from advisors. Literally, yesterday I was talking to an advisor. So tell me how you answer these two. ( 33:20 ): Number one, these multiples have gotten unsustainable. I don’t know how these private equity firms are ever going to make money on these investments. And then number two, just the general concept that private equity [00:33:30] has become a little bit of a dirty four-letter word in our industry, either because advisors fear the fast exit, the flip, whatever the case may be, what say you as the face of the big bad empire? Mike Zabik ( 33:42 ): Look, I think they’re both really good questions. And I would say I think you really have to double click and look under the hood from a valuation and a multiples perspective. Because even in the last 12 months, and you think about all of the public market’s volatility, good and bad that has happened [00:34:00] over the last 12 months, and private markets volatility and geopolitical volatility, you can consistently point to 20 plus times multiples for good businesses. And so we think that good businesses that are integrated, tech-enabled, and have a good organic growth profile are worth 20 plus times. ( 34:19 ): Now, what I would tell you is we have consistently built the Arax platform at a multiple well inside of that, and we’re quite proud of that. Because I think very humbly, [00:34:30] we have chosen not to start at a hundred million of EBITDA. We have chosen to start smaller and build it de novo from scratch. And that’s a big part of our playbook. That’s the way we do it in insurance brokerage, the way we do it in fund admins, the way we do it in accountancy. It’s the way that we do it everywhere. Generally speaking, we build these businesses from zero to a hundred plus million of EBITDA over a three to five-year period, but we do it at a much better blended purchase multiple. ( 34:57 ): Now, what I would tell you is you [00:35:00] have to look pretty far back for businesses to be trading for less than 15 times. That’s not me saying that wealth management businesses are going to trade for 15 times anytime soon, because outside of fund administration, it is the most recurring sticky stable revenue base that you can have. And even though people say that it’s tied to public markets, the average business, including one like Arax, has a 0.5 correlation to public markets, not a 1.0 correlation to public markets. You’re very insulated from fixed income. We fortunately have 10 to 15% [00:35:30] exposure in alts, and then we always have a small cash component. ( 35:35 ): And so even in markets of somewhat volatile public equity markets, we’re actually really well insulated. And if you had good organic growth, you’re very insulated. And businesses like that, that have a good organic and inorganic growth profile and a highly fragmented market, will continue to be worth high teens, low 20s multiples for the foreseeable future. ( 35:56 ): The implicit part of your question though is you have businesses that [00:36:00] have gotten really big. And so businesses that are 500 to a billion plus of EBITDA, that’s not where Arax is, but you have businesses that when you think about putting a 20 times multiple on that business, there are not a tremendous number of private equity firms that can spend 10 to 20 billion to buy a business. ( 36:20 ): And so I think what a lot of the “super RIAs” that are hundreds of billions of AUM, they’re all waiting to go public. And the problem is nobody [00:36:30] wants to go first. There’s no public comps, and most of them are levered seven times. Now there are some that are doing, I think, humbly a good job from the outside looking in of deleveraging and being more thoughtful about where that growth comes from and I think preparing themselves to be public. And I think the public markets should appreciate these businesses when they actually become public. ( 36:51 ): And so I think there’s a real dichotomy in what’s going on and for people that play in the “middle market”, we think that opportunity is going to exist for a really long [00:37:00] time. That’s one of the few industries that actually fragments more than it consolidates on a year-in and year-out basis despite all of the private equity activity. So we think we’re probably in the second or third inning, even though private equity has been investing in wealth management for a really long time. Jason Diamond ( 37:15 ): I think you just gave us probably one of the best answers I’ve ever heard to this question by the way, so I applaud you for that. And thank you for putting real multiples to it also instead of talking in vague terms. I look at something like Focus Financial where to me part of the problem is you go public and the public markets just don’t value these firms [00:37:30] at the same multiples that private equity firms seem to. So you don’t have to speak to the industry as a whole, but what is your end game here with this play? Mike Zabik ( 37:37 ): Yeah. I freak people out when I say this, Jason. I said it to Haig when we got into business. I say this in investor meetings. I say this when we talk to prospective partners coming into the business. We don’t have an end game. And I think what Haig really appreciated was we are not your cookie cutter central casting private equity fund. We didn’t show up and say, “We’re going to show up at the fifth board [00:38:00] meeting and talk about how we’re selling this company.” ( 38:02 ): And I think what happens a lot in private equity is that because you have these timetables that have been preordained from when you have to get out, you start making bad short-term and long-term decisions that have very adverse impacts on the businesses. And I think what a lot of people forget is the most valuable asset that Arax or any company in our portfolio has is the people. ( 38:25 ): And when you start making decisions focused solely on capitalism, it has [00:38:30] a really adverse impact on those people. They’re not just line items in a spreadsheet. They’re people that have families and dependents, and frankly, they’re all shareholders in our company. And so what’s good for me is actually good for the management team, and it’s good for the employees, and it’s good for every financial advisor at Arax. And so I think having that mentality, which has been the core ethos of how RedBird has existed since its founding in 2014, has always empowered us to make the right decision at the right time for that company. ( 38:59 ): Now at [00:39:00] some point, because I say all of that, but my job as a private equity guy is to take money from our LPs, turn it into more money, and eventually at some point give it back to them. That’s our job. I very humbly think our job, much more importantly, is to do that at the right time. So at some point, will we be the largest controlling shareholder in the Arax cap table? No, because at some point, we have to generate a return for LPs. ( 39:25 ): I think what’s differentiating is we have set the company up in a way from a cap structure perspective [00:39:30] and a mentality perspective that there’s no definitive timetable on that. And if somebody showed up at the end of the year and said, “We’ll pay you 30 times for what we think is a phenomenal wealth management business,” would Haig and I have to have a real conversation about it? For sure. ( 39:44 ): In the meantime, we have a tremendous amount of dry powder. And I got to tell you, I haven’t been more excited about what we’re doing at Arax than I am right now. And we think the business and the people that we’ve brought into that partnership have a lot of legs to run. [00:40:00] And so I’d be very fortunate to be an investor in this business for a really long time. Jason Diamond ( 40:08 ): Hi, let’s talk about what some of those opportunities are and some of those exciting… I assume AI has to be part of it. So I certainly want to take the opportunity to ask you about AI, and what your plans are and what are advisors asking you about this and how you’re addressing it. What else other than AI as well? You can certainly touch on AI, but are there other things that you look at that you’re spending a lot of time on that are really exciting you as your next [00:40:30] catalyst for advisor growth? Haig Ariyan ( 40:31 ): Well, Jason, first, let me say, you see from this conversation just how lucky I am to have this guy as my partner. It’s all genuine, and it’s all a reflection of what we’ve done over the past four years. I have never felt pressured to operate within a timeline. ( 40:48 ): You know how refreshing and empowering that is for a CEO who’s running a business that’s dependent upon capital from your partner? It’s been focused on the quality of what we’re building from day one [00:41:00] and taking our time getting there and doing it at the right pace. And that actually has resulted in one of the fastest growing wealth management firms in the country. And just hearing Mike speak, which he and I speak every day a couple of times, but hearing him do it in a forum with you, it’s really refreshing and it’s been a real blessing to be able to have that partnership. ( 41:21 ): Rolling into the advisor experience and where we’re going, yeah, tech innovation. And by the way, next week we have our first annual Arax Summit, [00:41:30] and the summit is going to be focused on the future. We branded it as Horizon, so focusing on where we’re going here as partners and as a firm. And on display next week is going to be a lot of that empowerment around AI, around technology, integration. ( 41:47 ): When you make acquisitions and you make as many acquisitions as we have, and when you lift out as many teams as we have, integrating becomes the most challenging part of getting the business in the right position. [00:42:00] We have successfully integrated the majority of firms that joined us or teams that joined us on day one. But what comes with that is multiple investment sets, solutions, multiple tech platforms and solutions. So bringing those all into an aligned solution is very important and critical to our future success and critical to the future of the client experience. ( 42:22 ): And so AI has helped us determine how to get there. It has helped us determine which will be the best outcome, all while you’re doing the traditional [00:42:30] RFPs, while you’re getting advisor feedback, having advisors do beta tests, having them give you input as to what they see as the best solutions, and then creating those solutions for them complimented by AI and helping you get there faster. ( 42:43 ): We’re also very fortunate that RedBird has a team called RDX, which is RedBird’s AI team. And it’s part of the vision that Gerry Cardinale and Mike have had to have an AI team that actually supports their portfolio company. So this team’s been available to help us test out, create, [00:43:00] deliver AI-driven solutions that now are more focused on reporting, they’re more focused on practice management, and they’re more focused on organic growth. ( 43:09 ): At the same time, inorganic growth is, although Mike clearly said organic growth is more important to us, inorganic growth is a process and a muscle that we want to continue to exercise, because we’ve found ourselves to be quite good at being able to execute on it once we determine that it’s the right partner to have. And so when you’re an advisor [00:43:30] here and you’re a partner here, you want to see your business growing organically. You want to focus on it, but you also want to depend on your partners to drive inorganic growth at the same time, to benefit long-term from having that partner you chose. ( 43:44 ): They choose Arax, and they choose me and the team here to be their partner. They want to see us executing on inorganic growth, empowering their practice with everything it needs to grow so that for the long term, we’re building something special defined by the most important ingredient, the quality of the financial advisors, and [00:44:00] the teams that support. Jason Diamond ( 44:01 ): Yeah, it all ties back to certainly a people-driven business at heart. I think we have time for maybe two more, and I want to ask about this. I think Haig, you mentioned this. Recruiting of wirehouse advisors, this is one that kind of vexes me, if I’m being honest. I feel we’ve been saying this for years now, that we would’ve felt we would’ve seen more private equity firms or private equity-backed RIAs recruiting directly, acquiring businesses directly from the wirehouses. ( 44:26 ): We’ve seen a little bit of that, Cresset, NewEdge, some Beacon Pointe, [00:44:30] you guys certainly, but it hasn’t been like a gangbusters trade. The more popular trade seems to be either wirehouse advisors going to another W-2 firm, like a Wire or a Ray J, or if they are interested in independence, either the broker dealer path like an LPL, or launch an RIA or launch an RIA with a platform and maybe consider selling it down the road. ( 44:51 ): Do you think that there’s more to come though for these direct wirehouse lift-outs? Is this a major part of the strategy going forward? Haig Ariyan ( 44:57 ): So Jason, for Arax, [00:45:00] it’s a major part of the strategy. We have an inorganic growth strategy that has two prongs to it. One is the continued acquisition and partnership with firms, and two is the continued lift-out and partnership of teams from wirehouses. You haven’t seen the others do it other than maybe the team at NewEdge, for example, because Straus and Sechan, they know how to do it. We do it because we know how to do it. ( 45:24 ): Private equity doesn’t inherently know how to lift out a team, speak the language of FA. I’ve done it [00:45:30] for 25 years. The competitive nature of it, many people feel like it’s the most competitive it’s been today. Truth be told, go back to the mid 2000s. I was running Deutsche Bank Wealth Management’s Alex Brown business in Midtown New York. I had the New York region. It was a recruiting juggernaut period of time. ( 45:54 ): And in Midtown New York, I was competing with Barry Sommers at Bear Stearns, who now [00:46:00] runs Wells Fargo Wealth Management. Great recruiter. I was competing against Jack Peterson and Mark Stevenson at Lehman, two of the most beloved guys in our profession. I was competing against Matt Gorman at Credit Suisse, and then all the other wirehouse guys that were in Midtown at that time. ( 46:19 ): It was a wonderful period of time, but never was recruiting more intense. And those EFL models will get more and more rich and more and more rich, and they’re still half of what [00:46:30] they are today in terms of recruiting bonuses and sign-ons. So it is something that’s in my DNA. It’s in my team’s DNA. ( 46:40 ): Amy Rizzo, who’s our chief growth officer, she’s been recruiting in South Florida for 10 years, the most competitive market in the country other than maybe Manhattan. So recruiting and lifting out wirehouse teams, you just have to know how to do it. And it’s not a matter of just recruiting them, that’s just the pitch. You have to know how to transfer their businesses so you don’t [00:47:00] disrupt the client experience and that it atrophies. ( 47:03 ): So firms have to be willing to make that capital investment knowing they’re going to keep the business intact. We know how to do that. So we’re totally committed to that two-pronged inorganic growth strategy going forward, which includes lifting out teams and recruiting teams. And I hope that our relationship with Diamond Consulting is only going to get tighter and tighter over that period of time, Jason. Jason Diamond ( 47:23 ): Yeah, absolutely. That certainly speaks to our relationship for sure. And actually, that was part of what my reasoning for [00:47:30] asking Mike the question about you. To me, your single biggest superpower in that space is being able to talk the talk and walk the walk with other wirehouse advisors. And you spoke about the momentum piece of this. I absolutely believe, especially with wirehouse advisors, there’s a little bit of that like, oh, I saw my colleague down the hall, and now I’m starting to ask those questions. I assume you feel that a little bit in your business as well. Haig Ariyan ( 47:52 ): Oh, definitely. Which is why if you make a mistake, you mess up, it can be terminal for your recruiting efforts. [00:48:00] And yet if you do the opposite and you fulfill every obligation you said you would, and you execute on behalf of that FA and his clients, it’s the benefit. And they’re going to tell their former friends, their former employee colleagues who are their friends, they’re going to tell them that, “Hey, this experience went really well.” And then why you make sure that the surprises that advisors are going to experience are upside surprises, not downside surprises. ( 48:26 ): So you start with what could go wrong. You start with where [00:48:30] are the challenges? And then you give them the upside experience. And then they can go to their clients and say, “I’m so pleased to tell you, I’m going to be a partner at Arax. I’m going to bring my clients to Arax. I’m going to be an owner of this organization.” Clients love that. They believe in their financial advisors so much that they’ve entrusted their life’s work to them. Don’t you think they want to see that financial advisor succeed and be an owner? Absolutely. And that’s a very important dynamic to this. Jason Diamond ( 48:58 ): Think about advisors are managing money [00:49:00] on behalf of people, and a lot of these people are entrepreneurs in their own right or very successful business owners in their own right, and they kind of get it. And I think advisors are often surprised by that. So I appreciate that perspective, Haig. ( 49:10 ): Mike, I want to end with you on purpose because I think you have a institutional perspective that is unique or a little more unique on our show. So what is something from your seat that the “retail wealth management crowd” is maybe not thinking about as much, or something that you are spending a lot of your time on these days that you see as kind of the next big thing [00:49:30] over the next couple years. And if it’s something as simple as AI, that’s fair. Mike Zabik ( 49:33 ): I’ll give you a couple answers, Jason, because it’s more than one thing. Some of them are germane to Arax and some are things that we’re doing more broadly defined. We think that the generational wealth transfer that is happening in this country is going to be probably more prolific than it’s been at any other point in history. ( 49:52 ): And the number of billionaires that were created in this year alone, and they’re going to continue to be created over the next handful of years on the back of not only [00:50:00] AI, but just robust open public markets, that wealth transfer and the complexity of the wealth that’s being created is critically important in terms of how you take care of those people. ( 50:10 ): And so what I think you’ve seen Arax be more and more successful with and on over the last 12 to 18 months is servicing those more affluent clients. And the average Arax client fits very squarely in the high net worth bucket. The piece of the pie that is ultra-high net worth, I think more 25 [00:50:30] million plus, is a rapidly growing part of the Arax business. And I think Haig and the team, and we’ve made real meaningful investments in human capital and technological capital to support clients like that and FAs that look after those clients. And so we think that the ultra-high net worth part of the market is a massive opportunity. It’s just as exciting as the high net worth part of the market, and so we’re playing both in different ways. ( 50:58 ): The second thing I would tell you broadly [00:51:00] defined, we don’t think… So I, like you, don’t understand why more people don’t do team lift-outs. And so we’re quite bullish on that and we love the fact that we have a partner that’s been doing it for a really long time, knows how to do it. And I think if you look at what we do over the next three to five years in financial services, and by the way, this isn’t just germane to wealth, we’re doing it in insurance brokerage, we’re doing it in other places. And humbly, I think we’re quite good at it because this is all we do. ( 51:28 ): All we do is FIG, all [00:51:30] we do is asset light, people-based businesses, and I would say a third to a half of what we do in each of these platform investments are team lift-outs. And so I think we’re pretty decent at it, and that’s not going to stop anytime soon. And we think it’s an incredibly accretive part of the inorganic growth pillar to any of these stories, not the least of which Arax. ( 51:53 ): And then I would tell you from an AI perspective, and I was one of the guys that co-wrote the white paper for the firm back in 2022 [00:52:00] when we created the team, and the team is mostly ex-Palantir forward deployed engineers. We are seeing tremendous opportunities. We build stuff in-house that we use for the firm and the employees here. We have incubated businesses like InterPositive that we sold to Netflix earlier this year, and then we have the team working hand in glove with managing teams like Haig and the rest of the team at Arax to empower them. ( 52:23 ): But I would tell you, AI is not the boogeyman. We call it augmented intelligence, not artificial intelligence. We are deploying [00:52:30] it to make the humans more efficient, not replace them. And I think when you start with that ethos and philosophy, A, it takes the temperature down a lot for the people that work at the company. And when you show up and say, “Listen, there are real value creation levers that can be pulled for you and your business.” ( 52:46 ): And it’s not about firing people, and it’s not just about workflow automation and cost savings. This is, to use Arax as a specific example, we use it for both business development and efficiency from a workflow automation perspective, [00:53:00] but not to fire people. On the growth side, we’ve deployed a number of different solutions to really help augment the funnel and make new client acquisition more efficient. ( 53:11 ): And on the workflow automation side, it is much more about first-mile stuff like client onboarding. It is about client comms, client reporting. It is about freeing the financial advisor up to have more time to do the thing that is the highest and best use of their time. And so that’s how we’re deploying AI. ( 53:29 ): That’s not [00:53:30] specific to Arax, that is we’re doing that across the entire portfolio, not only in FIG, but elsewhere in sports media and entertainment. We think the velocity of technological innovation going on right now has probably never been seen, and I think we’re quite excited about where things are going and what you can do with that toolkit over the next one to five years. Jason Diamond ( 53:51 ): That’s what excites me most also is the idea that advisors have long complained. Haig, I’m sure probably the number one thing you heard from advisors about back in the day was [00:54:00] capacity constraint and the endless menial tasks. And AI to me has the ability to turn all that on its head. And to your point, prospecting and managing relationships is where advisors should be spending the majority of their time, not on my learning classes online and the like. ( 54:16 ): I was super excited to have you both on because, to me, Arax and RedBird are the poster child for the happy marriage between private equity and wealth management of what [00:54:30] this could look like. Haig Ariyan ( 54:31 ): I agree with that. Mike Zabik ( 54:31 ): Thank you for that. Jason Diamond ( 54:32 ): I really thought this was a fantastic episode, and I’m looking forward to what the next chapter brings. Haig Ariyan ( 54:36 ): Thanks for having us, Jason. Mike Zabik ( 54:37 ): Yeah, thank you, Jason. Mindy Diamond ( 54:46 ): As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibility seriously and are dedicated to your clients. [00:55:00] But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms, or could a better option exist? ( 55:07 ): Should I Stay or Should I Go is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, [00:55:30] whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook. Partner, Not Acquirer: A Different Private Equity Playbook for Wealth Management With Haig Ariyan — CEO at Arax and Mike Zabik — Partner, Head of Financial Services at RedBird Capital Partners Jason Diamond ( 00:05 ): Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is Partner Not Acquirer, a different private equity playbook for wealth management. It’s a conversation with Haig Ariyan, CEO at Arax, and Mike Zabik, partner, head of financial services at RedBird Capital Partners. ( 00:22 ): I’m Jason Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond ( 00:28 ): At Diamond Consultants, we [00:00:30] help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. ( 00:38 ): With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. ( 00:55 ): Our process is education-driven and based on building relationships, starting [00:01:00] as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at (908) 879-1002. ( 01:21 ): Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more [00:01:30] inspired us to create our annual Advisor Transition Report. It’s the award-winning, data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. ( 01:46 ): Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. To download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport. Jason Diamond ( 02:00 ): [00:02:00] There’s certainly no shortage of private equity capital and wealth management today, but capital alone doesn’t create a differentiated firm. The more interesting question is what happens when an investor and an operator start with a blank sheet of paper and ask, “If we could build a wealth management business from scratch, what would we want it to be?” That’s essentially how Arax began. ( 02:23 ): My guests today are Haig Ariyan, CEO of Arax, and Mike Zabik, partner and head of financial services at RedBird Capital Partners. [00:02:30] Their partnership started differently than many PE-backed wealth management stories. RedBird wasn’t looking for an operator to run a business it had already acquired. Mike and his team were looking for the right person to build around, and Haig wasn’t interested in creating another aggregator. The result is a firm built around an idea they describe as becoming a partner of choice, not an acquirer of choice, one that has since grown to approximately 50 billion in assets and 230 financial advisors. ( 02:57 ): What makes their story particularly relevant [00:03:00] is that it gets directly into some of the questions advisors and firm leaders are asking right now. What should private equity actually bring to a wealth management business beyond capital? Why does Arax see wirehouse team lift-outs as an important growth opportunity when relatively few PE-backed firms have cracked that code? And with valuations at historically high levels, what does a private equity investor say about multiples, leverage, and the inevitable question of an exit? ( 03:25 ): We also get into the balance between organic and inorganic growth, how advisor equity changes the growth [00:03:30] equation, and why Mike thinks AI is best used as augmented intelligence, a way to increase advisor capacity rather than replace people. It’s a candid look at what can happen when private equity and wealth management operate as true partners and what it takes to make that partnership work. So let’s get to it. ( 03:53 ): So thrilled to have you both here. Thank you for joining me. Let’s dive right in. Mike, maybe we’ll start with you. Take us back to the beginning, [00:04:00] the brainchild for this idea, start with your backgrounds and what formed this marriage between RedBird and Arax. Mike Zabik ( 04:07 ): Yeah, sure. First of all, thank you for having us. The history of Arax is like the history of RedBird. So just to take a 12-year step back, I was employee number three here. And I joined back when the firm was three guys, three laptops and a whiteboard, and we had less than a hundred million under management. ( 04:22 ): Today, it’s about 120 people and 15 billion of AUM globally. And I’ve had the very fortunate privilege of watching the firm scale and grow [00:04:30] and diversify into what it is today. And if you listen to our founder talk at all about the ethos of this place, it’s always been about building things, not buying things. And FIG is no exception to that. And so we’ll get into it later in the conversation. ( 04:45 ): But when we set out to build Arax, we weren’t looking for a platform, we were looking for a person. And we spent a long time trying to find someone as talented as Haig to build a business around. And I was quite fortunate to meet Haig spring of 2022, [00:05:00] and we basically spent six months mapping out what we wanted to be when we grew up and what the vision for the company was. And I’ll let him get into that a bit in a minute. ( 05:10 ): But we set out to build something special. And I’m not just saying that in the pejorative context. We wanted to build a differentiated wealth management platform that had a slightly different approach to how it was going to be built. That would become a partner of choice, not an acquirer of choice. And we think there’s a fundamental difference between [00:05:30] how we have built this business over the last four years and how some other people are doing it. Jason Diamond ( 05:33 ): And Haig, I’d love your perspective on the same. What is your origin story or how you guys got engaged and ultimately married? Haig Ariyan ( 05:39 ): Jason, thank you. Thanks for having Mike and I together. We actually love telling this story together. And truly we’ve been partners from the start, and I very sincerely refer to Mike as my co-founder of Arax. ( 05:51 ): So what was really profound and vivid to me when I remember the initiation of Arax was that, at that period of time, [00:06:00] I was the CEO of Alex Brown and the head of Global Wealth Solutions for Raymond James. I was getting a lot of calls from private equity firms. And every one of those calls was a private equity investor that had already bought an asset and was looking for an operator, or had a distinct strategy in mind and wanted to see if I would come run it for them and execute upon it. ( 06:21 ): The difference was when RedBird and Mike Zabik called me. They sincerely asked, “What’s your view on the independent wealth management space?” [00:06:30] And that led into a dialogue around, if you were to build a business in the independent wealth space, what would it be? And so that spoke to that ethos that Mike alluded to, which was that they are builders of businesses and they’re looking to back operators, and it’s been sincere from day one. So that really was profoundly different than the other calls we were getting at the time. Jason Diamond ( 06:54 ): Yeah, and I want to click more into that. I especially like that you refer to each other as partners, because I do think that’s a bit of a unique [00:07:00] dynamic between the capital or the private equity sponsor and the wealth management firm. ( 07:05 ): Mike, maybe I’ll ask you from your perspective, Haig saying exactly that, got calls from private equity firms every day. It’s no secret, this is an incredibly crowded space, both for private equity firms, but also a lot of different wealth management platforms and models. What was it specifically that you felt like was a gap that you were trying to address in partnership with Haig? Mike Zabik ( 07:27 ): Yeah, I’d answer it two ways, Jason. One from a macro [00:07:30] perspective and then two from a micro perspective specifically what we did with Haig. I think if you look at the way most private equity funds play not only wealth management, but FIG broadly defined, people start with platforms. They want to start by buying things that are generally 50 to 100 million of EBITDA. ( 07:47 ): They use that as the chassis, and then they want to dump a bunch of stuff into that box and run an aggregator playbook. We have never been an aggregator model, and that’s been very intentional. And we do this across every sub-sector [00:08:00] that we deploy capital in FIG. Very humbly, I think we’re the only shop out there that consistently does de novo platform buy and builds as its core strategy. ( 08:11 ): Nine times out of 10, what we do is we link up with someone like Haig or a team of operators, marry our M&A pipeline with theirs and sit out to build a differentiated business. Different in the sense that we’re not inheriting someone else’s portfolio construction. We’re not buying something the way someone else [00:08:30] wanted to build it, and then say, “Well, if we leverage it a little bit more, cut a few more costs or buy a few more things, we can squeak out a 2X return over the next five years.” ( 08:40 ): We think we generate a tremendous amount of alpha going from zero to 100, not starting at 100 and going to 200. And so despite that, when we told our LPs that we were going to make a play in wealth management, everybody said, “Are you nuts? There are 150 private equity-backed platforms out there. How are you guys going to differentiate [00:09:00] yourselves in a world that is awash in capital and awash in opportunities? And they’re all run by really sophisticated people that have a pretty good sense of what their business is worth.” ( 09:11 ): I think very humbly, one of the most differentiating things that Haig said was he said, “I want to build a hybrid.” And he said very definitively back in 2022, “Hybrid’s not a dirty word.” And so we’ve never thought it is or was, and we thought that having a broker-dealer inside of the business would facilitate [00:09:30] attracting and retaining some of the best and most sophisticated financial advisors in the country. And so we moved very early. ( 09:37 ): And one of the core tenants of what we set out to build was to have that capability, and I think it’s served us really well over the last four years because we’ve been able to attract and retain a number of the most talented financial advisors in the country. Jason Diamond ( 09:51 ): That’s super fair perspective. Haig, do you think that Mike is telling that story honestly, if they lived up to that promise as a partner and allowed you to build this? Because it sounds [00:10:00] like you had ample opportunities to build kind of whatever you wanted with the capital. Has the firm evolved into exactly what Mike is describing, a zero to 100 machine? It seems like yes, based on what we see in the news and the success you’ve had. Haig Ariyan ( 10:12 ): The firm’s evolved into even better than the whiteboard that we put together. But to be very clear about that conversation initially, in addition to what Mike said, they were looking to me to say, “What would your playbook be?” And I admitted at that time, I think this aggregator model [00:10:30] that you’re seeing a lot of private equity firms do, it has legs. ( 10:34 ): You’ve got tailwinds, 16,000 RIAs out there, plenty of capital, awash in the market that wants to invest in it. And it’s a very highly fragmented industry where a lot of these RIAs want to sell. This trend is going to go on for quite some time. And if you want to be an aggregator, I say go for it, you got plenty of time. But that’s not interesting to me, and I don’t think it’s the way you do something differentiated. ( 10:56 ): And Mike agreed to me, he says, “That doesn’t really fit our [00:11:00] RedBird model of doing something differentiated with an operator from a de novo basis. We’d rather do something that is a little bit more bespoke.” And so that immediately the conversation was from me that said, “I firmly believe that what’s missing in the market is a firm that is focused solely on the quality of the financial advisors as a reflection of the quality of clients and staff that you will have. If you key in on the quality of those financial advisors as being the profession’s [00:11:30] best, our chances of success are extremely high. ( 11:34 ): And so in order to be able to attract those best financial advisors, which was Mike’s next question, “Well, how do you do that?” I said, “One, you make them real equity partners, and when you bring in their business, you do it on a tax advantage basis and you make sure they own meaningful equity in what you’re going to build together. You don’t do this highly taxable employee forgivable loan, which is a model of folks renting a platform.” That’s just been a strong belief [00:12:00] I’ve had. And I’m someone who used that employee forgivable loan model for 25 years, but it was always flawed. ( 12:07 ): So I said, “You make them equity partners. Secondly, you give them every tool they need to deliver the great experience their clients are accustomed to.” And inclusive in that tool, BOX is a broker-dealer. And so this whole concept that broker-dealer is a dirty word, this whole concept that you are inherently conflicted, that’s highly offensive to me. The best financial advisors [00:12:30] who have a broker-dealer in their toolkit, are you telling me that financial advisor acts and behaves with conflict versus someone who is a pure advisor? I don’t buy into that. ( 12:41 ): So fast-forward, what we’ve built today on that premise of partnership and a full platform is a $50 billion wealth management firm that is 91% fee-based advisory and 9% broker-dealer business, and that 9% is made up of alternatives [00:13:00] with trails. It’s made up of 10b5-1 plans facilitating corporate executive liquidity. It’s made up of insurance and annuities and some transactional business, particularly for fixed income when rates are very narrow. So it really has evolved into a platform that Mike and I envisioned together and aligned on four and a half years ago. Jason Diamond ( 13:21 ): I don’t get the impression though that while the hybrid model makes sense, you’re not attracting nor do you want the types of advisors who are sitting there churning structured notes and [00:13:30] single stock options. I view it as more, correct me if I’m wrong, you affiliate with big boys and girls and you want to give them the choice to run their business as efficiently as possible, however that may be, whether that’s advisory, brokerage, or otherwise. Is that a fair summary? Haig Ariyan ( 13:44 ): Jason, you just touched on what is one of our other key differentiators in the independent wealth space. When you focus on the best financial advisors in the profession, if you truly stick to that discipline, you don’t tell them how to run their business, you don’t tell them how to change their business. [00:14:00] So we’re not plugging you into a mousetrap that everyone’s doing the same thing. We’re not plugging into an investment plan or a house view where everyone does the same thing. ( 14:08 ): As much as that’s highly scalable and as much as that may trade for a premium, that’s not how you get the best financial professionals to serve those households that are your clients. You embrace what they do, you empower it with greater resources, you give them additional resources to round out their business and their practice, and that helps them grow organically. [00:14:30] So you’re exactly right. But that formula for the best financial advisors, it resonates with them, and then to be a partner in it further resonates with them. Jason Diamond ( 14:39 ): I think that’s right. Mike, I want to ask you this because I think Haig will be too humble to give me the honest answer here. Mike Zabik ( 14:45 ): I can’t wait to hear the question. Jason Diamond ( 14:46 ): We get approached by a lot of private equity firms and the like who want to do something like this. And you already alluded to this, that you were looking for somebody like Haig to come around. I think it’s critical, somebody who speaks the language, somebody who has a reputation. To [00:15:00] what extent do you think that has enabled you to be successful, having the right leader and the right established… I would assume partly it’s a Rolodex also that helped you to really build this business out. Mike Zabik ( 15:10 ): Yeah. I would tell you who we partner with, whether it was Arax or any other platform that we’ve ever done, who we partner with is the most important decision we make over the life of the investment. And so we will spend a tremendous amount of time. It’s a very atypical thing for a private equity guy to say. We raise funds, our job is to deploy the capital, [00:15:30] turn it into more money, and then give it back to our LPs. ( 15:32 ): That being said, we have never been in a rush to put money out the door. We have never done a deal because a sub-sector is hot. We will actually just wait and spend a tremendous amount of time waiting for the right person to come along. And while they’re not unicorns, they’re not mythological creatures, there are very few of them out there, and there is only one Haig guardian, and we spend a lot of time trying to find somebody like Haig. ( 15:59 ): I would tell you [00:16:00] the prerequisites for people that we partner with has evolved over time, but it really comes down to three factors. And I know we’re going to talk about AI later. One is a tremendous amount of operational experience. I’m going to date Haig a little bit. Haig’s been doing this since Sears owned Dean Witter, and it was stocks and socks. So Haig’s been doing this for a long time, right? ( 16:21 ): Haig is an FA’s FA. Haig has been one. Haig has led them. Haig has led big businesses. But [00:16:30] almost as important as the operational capabilities that Haig had running big businesses, like Raymond James Global Wealth Business and Alex Brown, he’s very entrepreneurial. What we also don’t want is someone that wants to come in and inherit someone else’s portfolio construction. ( 16:46 ): And what’s really hard to find, frankly, is people that have Haig’s operational chops but are comfortable being uncomfortable. Because walking away from something that has the robust infrastructure like a Raymond James or an [00:17:00] Alex Brown, and then sitting down the hall from me for a year and having a CFO and two laptops and a whiteboard, is unplugging the matrix and waking up in the real world. ( 17:11 ): And that is terrifying for most people, right? They want to keep the cushy job, or they want to go work at a sponsor-backed private equity portfolio company that already has a hundred million of EBITDA. So it takes a long time to find people like Haig, which is why we run a really concentrated portfolio. And the fund that we’re deploying out of, we’re [00:17:30] going to have six to eight of these partnerships because it takes a long time to find people like Haig. Jason Diamond ( 17:35 ): Yeah. It seems like, especially as you get into the more boutique-y type of space, which I would certainly consider you, the culture and the quality and the makeup of the management teams matter even more. And ultimately, we see that with advisors. Advisors have so much choice today between wirehouses, boutique firms, regional firms like Raymond James, established RIAs, launching their own RIAs, selling to a private equity. All of these are legitimate options, and they’re really making a decision on who to [00:18:00] tie their horse to in some cases. ( 18:02 ): Haig, let me ask you this then. I want to tap into the thread because a lot of our audience is wirehouse or ex-wirehouse advisors, and that’s a world you’re familiar with, or call it W-2 traditional firm land is a world you’re familiar with. You talked about the forgivable loan. Give me the starkest contrast in your mind between the world you live in now, call it the RIA space, versus the traditional firm world from a capabilities perspective, from an advisor experience perspective. Haig Ariyan ( 18:29 ): The starkest [00:18:30] difference to a wirehouse FA’s experience at their wirehouse and what would be, let’s say at Arax. And I won’t speak to the independent wealth world, I’ll speak to Arax. One, these FAs are used to having everything at their fingertips, but those fingertips don’t generally get to everything very efficiently and very effectively, and everything they get to is defined by someone else. It’s predefined for them. It’s prescribed as to how it works. It’s prescribed as to how much [00:19:00] it costs. It’s prescribed as to who it’s for. ( 19:02 ): At Arax, we’ve been very deliberate about getting every resource a financial advisor is accustomed to having at a bank-owned wirehouse, at a wirehouse, at a national firm. And we’ve built out a very robust platform from wealth planning to financial planning, to tax planning, to investment stock, to all the infrastructure that they may in fact need, to practice management. ( 19:26 ): All of that exists, but it’s truly at their fingertips. And they’ve [00:19:30] helped define it, they’ve helped design it. It’s been built in their vision because they are partners in the organization. And if they don’t like the way it’s built or they don’t think it’s the right way, we’re able to modify it quickly. ( 19:42 ): Our decision making is essentially Mike Zabik and Haig Ariyan. Well, really, if it gets to Mike’s level, then it’s something that involves a significant strategic decision or meaningful amount of capital infusion, but the business is run very effectively and we make decisions quickly, and we make [00:20:00] them in partnership with our financial advisors. ( 20:02 ): So the most tangible difference is a cultural and commercial one called partnership. And the business is built for those financial advisors, not by a large firm or a large bank that has shareholders or constituents that they answer to. It’s built for the financial advisors because that means we’re building it for their clients. Jason Diamond ( 20:21 ): Yeah. I love that the answer is centered around both the culture side, but also what that culture and what that ethos enables, which is very much a capabilities [00:20:30] conversation. ( 20:37 ): Mike, maybe I’ll throw this next one at you. And this may be a kind of a simple corporate finance question, but I’m curious what your mentality is around growth. If I gave you the choice, you could acquire a new hundred million dollar business or have one of your existing businesses grow a hundred million, which are you taking and why? What’s your mentality around organic versus inorganic? Because it’s kind of a hot button issue these days for firms, given how expensive recruiting’s gotten. Mike Zabik ( 20:59 ): It’s a [00:21:00] great question, Jason. Haig and I actually spent an hour talking about this morning. I would tell you, you would take organic growth over inorganic growth every day of the week. They’re both critically important, and so we spend a lot of time, energy, and money on both. I think the bigger firms get, the harder it is to consistently generate net flows that are mid to high single-digits, certainly low double-digits. ( 21:26 ): And I think that given where referral programs [00:21:30] are today and where they’re going over the next one to three years, I think that organic growth is only going to get harder. I think that it was very strategic for us. We have no referral programs today, and we have consistently put up, I think, best-in-class net flows, organic growth rates, and without referral programs, and that is incremental AUM and revenue and EBITDA that we’re not paying for. ( 21:59 ): Now that being said, [00:22:00] M&A is a critical component to the growth, and we have found that post partnering with a team of financial advisors that we pull out of a wirehouse or a business that we acquire, we are typically unleashing them and/or empowering them to do even more for the clients that they have, or enable them to attract and retain new clients that they may have otherwise not been able to get. ( 22:25 ): And so especially with the firms and/or teams that are smaller or maybe have [00:22:30] a less sophisticated approach to alts, having a team in-house that can have an elevated conversation about trust, estate tax, and wealth planning, which is becoming more and more important to people or a differentiated robust alts offering with the centralized investment office that we have at Arax, that we do M&A, but then generate organic growth on the back of it. And so they’re both important. ( 22:54 ): I would tell you, we think people in this market pay a premium for three things, businesses that are integrated, [00:23:00] businesses that are tech-enabled, although the definition of tech enablement has changed over the last couple of years, and businesses that have a really strong organic growth profile. Jason Diamond ( 23:08 ): Yeah, that’s a really good synopsis. So let me ask you then, does this become a part of your value prop in your recruiting strategy? Do you say to advisors, “We can help you grow both organically and potentially inorganically when you’re ready for it?” Haig Ariyan ( 23:20 ): It’s an interesting way to pose the question. We make it clear to financial advisors that the continued organic growth of your practice is very important to us. [00:23:30] And during that recruiting process, you learn very quickly if that is important to them. We’re only interested in partners who want to continue to grow their business organically. And by the way, that top 2 to 5% of our profession, one of the key parameters that defines the best financial advisors is that they continue to grow their business organically. ( 23:51 ): We have some of the best financial advisors on the planet that are within our 230 financial advisors. I think as a group, as a business, on average, [00:24:00] we have the best financial advisors in the profession, but they wake up every morning thinking of ways to grow their business. That’s important to us, and that’s important to them. So it’s incumbent upon us to empower them to do so. So yes, it’s very much part of the conversation. Jason Diamond ( 24:14 ): And doesn’t it need to be even further… I don’t mean to push, but doesn’t it need to even be, not only can we help you grow, but because of how competitive it is to recruit and growth is important to you, I agree with you, successful advisors, growth is by definition important. Every firm is promising to these advisors. Morgan Stanley is promising to these advisors [00:24:30] the funnel, right? We’re feeding you relationships from workplace and from E-Trade. So doesn’t it need to be something stronger? ( 24:36 ): And maybe Mike, you alluded to part of this answer with things like trust and estate is part of the answer is offering your advisors more to be able to grow. Mike Zabik ( 24:43 ): Yeah. I mean, I would tell you… I’d answer a couple of different ways, Jason. We have so many different organic growth initiatives going on at the firm. When you join, either if we acquire a going concern business or we recruit you out of one of the wirehouses, we have 10 different [00:25:00] organic growth initiatives going on right now, and some of those are for high net worth profile clients, some of those are for ultra-high net worth profile clients. ( 25:09 ): And so to your point, I think there is a robust set of capabilities, whether that’s trust, estate, tax and wealth planning, whether that’s better access to alternatives, whether that’s augmenting the funnel you have with various technology solutions. If you become part of the family and become part of the partnership, there is a kaleidoscope of [00:25:30] capabilities that are made available to you, which should help drive incremental organic growth. ( 25:35 ): By the way, that’s not just defined as getting incremental clients. In many cases, folks that we have partnered with in the past, there is money away from them somewhere else, right? Either they didn’t have a robust alts offering in their prior lives, and so they don’t often have 100% share of wallet of every client they have. And so organic growth for us isn’t always defined as picking up an incremental [00:26:00] net new client. In many cases, it’s helping either facilitate generational wealth transfer from an M&A transaction or providing interesting investment alternatives that would bring money that was away into Arax AUM. Haig Ariyan ( 26:13 ): Further to that, imagine a scenario, a profession where you as a business person have truly built your business yourself, okay? You’ve established your client relationship to yourself, you’ve brought in all those clients, and yet you don’t own that business. You get paid well, [00:26:30] you get a variable comp that’s a nice component of that business, but you don’t own that business. ( 26:34 ): So imagine a firm like Arax where we and empower you to have a major equity component that is a reflection of your business, or we also empower you to do it fully independent. We offer 1099 and W-2 solutions, but most of RFAs tend to gravitate towards the W-2 partner solution because they’re getting a significant amount of equity. ( 26:57 ): And then when you, as a partner, discuss with them [00:27:00] the power of organic growth in growing the value of that equity, they are further driven to bring in new clients, to grow with their existing clients, not just for the variable comp payout they get, but for the meaningful wealth creation opportunity that’s presented to them and their families on that equity piece. And that’s what’s driving organic growth coupled with all of those resources that Mike’s speaking. Jason Diamond ( 27:23 ): Yeah. It’s a very interesting way to think about it is that you’re really using the equity as another lever there. What is the, [00:27:30] I don’t want to say the tit-for-tat there? But if you’re an advisor, it’s maybe shrouded in opacity a little bit. What does it actually entail? I’m not talking about economically, I’m talking about in practice. ( 27:41 ): You’ve both said now a couple of times, I assume alluding to some of your competitors, we’re not the model where we’re going to take all of our advisors and throw them into the firm managed CIO portfolios and trying to round peg and square hole advisors. What does change though? Tell me as an advisor, what is that experience actually like from running my own business and my own RIA, or I’m at some other firm to [00:28:00] now post partnership with Arax? Haig Ariyan ( 28:02 ): Yeah. I love the expression shredded in opacity, Jason, because I think much of our profession when you’re recruiting, and we’ll touch on recruiting a bit, but much of our profession and the pitch has been historically shredded in opacity. The independent wealth space has solved for that because the clarity that an advisor requires and needs to move their business or sell their business to a different platform outside of a wirehouse [00:28:30] that are generally very well-resourced requires that there is no opaque nature to the conversation. ( 28:38 ): So the strength of a platform in the independent wealth space, we have been able to create a platform somewhat due to the innovation in FinTech today, very much due to the demands of financial advisors and clients, very much due to the fact that we founded this firm in 2022. We had a good 15 years of watching our competitors make mistakes. [00:29:00] We learned from those mistakes. We learned what not to do, and we learned what resources are needed. ( 29:06 ): So when you build a true wealth planning platform, when you build a true investments platform that doesn’t predefine how the advisor has to invest his client’s assets, when you find balance sheet solutions, which was the missing link in the independent wealth space, that’s now being resolved by multiple firms and balance sheets that have come forth to say, “We see the independent wealth space as an opportunity to distribute balance sheet.” [00:29:30] That’s been solved for now. ( 29:31 ): Now, is it that as clean as owning your own balance sheet and going to the private bank or saying, “Hey, I need a mortgage?” Well, it’s gotten there. It’s now very accessible. SBL is click and fun in the independent wealth space. So all these things that we’re missing are now solved for, but you need to have a partner who has put the pieces together in an integrated way so that an advisor who’s lifting out of a large firm, or a firm that [00:30:00] it’s plugging into your organization does not have a cut and paste experience, but as actually joining an integrated platform where these things are right at their fingertips. ( 30:10 ): That is very empowering and doesn’t allow for that being shredded in opacity that you’re referring to. No longer is that an okay solved by your deal terms. It used to be, “Oh, well I’m getting this deal and it’s a good deal, and I’ll figure it out when I get there.” That doesn’t work anymore, Jason, because there’s too many deals out there. You have to actually have a differentiated [00:30:30] offering for them. That’s why I think 230 financial advisors and $50 billion has validated that there’s something differentiated about Arax that we’re doing. Mike Zabik ( 30:40 ): The only thing I was going to add, Jason, for what it’s worth, you don’t have to take our word for it. I think one of the greatest accomplishments that the company has, because you asked about how the FA thinks about organic and inorganic growth, one of the things that’s been most gratifying for me is everybody can say what’s going to happen, just the point that Haig is making. Whether it actually [00:31:00] happens once you become part of the family is a big testament. ( 31:03 ): And so what’s been really compelling, I think, in the message to the market, because all these folks talk to each other. While it’s a really big and dynamic industry, everybody talks, and everybody talks to each other and the world is actually quite small when you break it down. And what’s been really cool to watch is that whether they are businesses that we have acquired or FAs that we have partnered with to pull out of the wirehouses, the number of times that they have [00:31:30] spent six months inside of the family and said, “This actually isn’t what you said it was going to be, it’s better than that,” and then refer one of their friends. ( 31:40 ): I’m thinking of the SRS guys who then turned around and introduced us to their friends at CDRIS, or different financial advisors that we’ve pulled out of wirehouses where they’ve gone back to other friends in their ecosystems and said, “It’s actually going really well. Everything they said was true and it’s actually been a little bit better than that. You should come.” And so a big chunk of our inorganic [00:32:00] activity has actually been referrals from existing capital partners in the cap table. ( 32:07 ): And so the other point, and I’ll say this very bluntly, we don’t buy 100% of anything at RedBird, unless we’re doing a corporate carve out, which has been in the FIG portfolio, I think twice out of a hundred investments. If you want to sell 100% of your company, move to Florida and buy a boat and retire, we are not your guys. And philosophically, if you don’t want to bet on the next leg of growth in [00:32:30] your business, we probably don’t want to bet on it either. ( 32:33 ): And so equity rollover has always been a core component, whether it’s a going concern acquisition or a team lift-out. And it’s important from an economic alignment perspective. It’s important for value creation for those financial advisors. It’s important to drive organic growth. It also really helps for inorganic growth. And they have the opportunity to continue to participate and follow on if they want to, or you have a established capital partner that has [00:33:00] tons of dry powder that’s happy to continue to fund that M&A. Jason Diamond ( 33:04 ): Yeah. So you both gave me the good. I get to be Debbie Downer now. And Mike, I’ll give you two tough ones. And they’re probably the two most common objections we hear. Again, not to bring the rain clouds here, but real objections we hear from advisors. Literally, yesterday I was talking to an advisor. So tell me how you answer these two. ( 33:20 ): Number one, these multiples have gotten unsustainable. I don’t know how these private equity firms are ever going to make money on these investments. And then number two, just the general concept that private equity [00:33:30] has become a little bit of a dirty four-letter word in our industry, either because advisors fear the fast exit, the flip, whatever the case may be, what say you as the face of the big bad empire? Mike Zabik ( 33:42 ): Look, I think they’re both really good questions. And I would say I think you really have to double click and look under the hood from a valuation and a multiples perspective. Because even in the last 12 months, and you think about all of the public market’s volatility, good and bad that has happened [00:34:00] over the last 12 months, and private markets volatility and geopolitical volatility, you can consistently point to 20 plus times multiples for good businesses. And so we think that good businesses that are integrated, tech-enabled, and have a good organic growth profile are worth 20 plus times. ( 34:19 ): Now, what I would tell you is we have consistently built the Arax platform at a multiple well inside of that, and we’re quite proud of that. Because I think very humbly, [00:34:30] we have chosen not to start at a hundred million of EBITDA. We have chosen to start smaller and build it de novo from scratch. And that’s a big part of our playbook. That’s the way we do it in insurance brokerage, the way we do it in fund admins, the way we do it in accountancy. It’s the way that we do it everywhere. Generally speaking, we build these businesses from zero to a hundred plus million of EBITDA over a three to five-year period, but we do it at a much better blended purchase multiple. ( 34:57 ): Now, what I would tell you is you [00:35:00] have to look pretty far back for businesses to be trading for less than 15 times. That’s not me saying that wealth management businesses are going to trade for 15 times anytime soon, because outside of fund administration, it is the most recurring sticky stable revenue base that you can have. And even though people say that it’s tied to public markets, the average business, including one like Arax, has a 0.5 correlation to public markets, not a 1.0 correlation to public markets. You’re very insulated from fixed income. We fortunately have 10 to 15% [00:35:30] exposure in alts, and then we always have a small cash component. ( 35:35 ): And so even in markets of somewhat volatile public equity markets, we’re actually really well insulated. And if you had good organic growth, you’re very insulated. And businesses like that, that have a good organic and inorganic growth profile and a highly fragmented market, will continue to be worth high teens, low 20s multiples for the foreseeable future. ( 35:56 ): The implicit part of your question though is you have businesses that [00:36:00] have gotten really big. And so businesses that are 500 to a billion plus of EBITDA, that’s not where Arax is, but you have businesses that when you think about putting a 20 times multiple on that business, there are not a tremendous number of private equity firms that can spend 10 to 20 billion to buy a business. ( 36:20 ): And so I think what a lot of the “super RIAs” that are hundreds of billions of AUM, they’re all waiting to go public. And the problem is nobody [00:36:30] wants to go first. There’s no public comps, and most of them are levered seven times. Now there are some that are doing, I think, humbly a good job from the outside looking in of deleveraging and being more thoughtful about where that growth comes from and I think preparing themselves to be public. And I think the public markets should appreciate these businesses when they actually become public. ( 36:51 ): And so I think there’s a real dichotomy in what’s going on and for people that play in the “middle market”, we think that opportunity is going to exist for a really long [00:37:00] time. That’s one of the few industries that actually fragments more than it consolidates on a year-in and year-out basis despite all of the private equity activity. So we think we’re probably in the second or third inning, even though private equity has been investing in wealth management for a really long time. Jason Diamond ( 37:15 ): I think you just gave us probably one of the best answers I’ve ever heard to this question by the way, so I applaud you for that. And thank you for putting real multiples to it also instead of talking in vague terms. I look at something like Focus Financial where to me part of the problem is you go public and the public markets just don’t value these firms [00:37:30] at the same multiples that private equity firms seem to. So you don’t have to speak to the industry as a whole, but what is your end game here with this play? Mike Zabik ( 37:37 ): Yeah. I freak people out when I say this, Jason. I said it to Haig when we got into business. I say this in investor meetings. I say this when we talk to prospective partners coming into the business. We don’t have an end game. And I think what Haig really appreciated was we are not your cookie cutter central casting private equity fund. We didn’t show up and say, “We’re going to show up at the fifth board [00:38:00] meeting and talk about how we’re selling this company.” ( 38:02 ): And I think what happens a lot in private equity is that because you have these timetables that have been preordained from when you have to get out, you start making bad short-term and long-term decisions that have very adverse impacts on the businesses. And I think what a lot of people forget is the most valuable asset that Arax or any company in our portfolio has is the people. ( 38:25 ): And when you start making decisions focused solely on capitalism, it has [00:38:30] a really adverse impact on those people. They’re not just line items in a spreadsheet. They’re people that have families and dependents, and frankly, they’re all shareholders in our company. And so what’s good for me is actually good for the management team, and it’s good for the employees, and it’s good for every financial advisor at Arax. And so I think having that mentality, which has been the core ethos of how RedBird has existed since its founding in 2014, has always empowered us to make the right decision at the right time for that company. ( 38:59 ): Now at [00:39:00] some point, because I say all of that, but my job as a private equity guy is to take money from our LPs, turn it into more money, and eventually at some point give it back to them. That’s our job. I very humbly think our job, much more importantly, is to do that at the right time. So at some point, will we be the largest controlling shareholder in the Arax cap table? No, because at some point, we have to generate a return for LPs. ( 39:25 ): I think what’s differentiating is we have set the company up in a way from a cap structure perspective [00:39:30] and a mentality perspective that there’s no definitive timetable on that. And if somebody showed up at the end of the year and said, “We’ll pay you 30 times for what we think is a phenomenal wealth management business,” would Haig and I have to have a real conversation about it? For sure. ( 39:44 ): In the meantime, we have a tremendous amount of dry powder. And I got to tell you, I haven’t been more excited about what we’re doing at Arax than I am right now. And we think the business and the people that we’ve brought into that partnership have a lot of legs to run. [00:40:00] And so I’d be very fortunate to be an investor in this business for a really long time. Jason Diamond ( 40:08 ): Hi, let’s talk about what some of those opportunities are and some of those exciting… I assume AI has to be part of it. So I certainly want to take the opportunity to ask you about AI, and what your plans are and what are advisors asking you about this and how you’re addressing it. What else other than AI as well? You can certainly touch on AI, but are there other things that you look at that you’re spending a lot of time on that are really exciting you as your next [00:40:30] catalyst for advisor growth? Haig Ariyan ( 40:31 ): Well, Jason, first, let me say, you see from this conversation just how lucky I am to have this guy as my partner. It’s all genuine, and it’s all a reflection of what we’ve done over the past four years. I have never felt pressured to operate within a timeline. ( 40:48 ): You know how refreshing and empowering that is for a CEO who’s running a business that’s dependent upon capital from your partner? It’s been focused on the quality of what we’re building from day one [00:41:00] and taking our time getting there and doing it at the right pace. And that actually has resulted in one of the fastest growing wealth management firms in the country. And just hearing Mike speak, which he and I speak every day a couple of times, but hearing him do it in a forum with you, it’s really refreshing and it’s been a real blessing to be able to have that partnership. ( 41:21 ): Rolling into the advisor experience and where we’re going, yeah, tech innovation. And by the way, next week we have our first annual Arax Summit, [00:41:30] and the summit is going to be focused on the future. We branded it as Horizon, so focusing on where we’re going here as partners and as a firm. And on display next week is going to be a lot of that empowerment around AI, around technology, integration. ( 41:47 ): When you make acquisitions and you make as many acquisitions as we have, and when you lift out as many teams as we have, integrating becomes the most challenging part of getting the business in the right position. [00:42:00] We have successfully integrated the majority of firms that joined us or teams that joined us on day one. But what comes with that is multiple investment sets, solutions, multiple tech platforms and solutions. So bringing those all into an aligned solution is very important and critical to our future success and critical to the future of the client experience. ( 42:22 ): And so AI has helped us determine how to get there. It has helped us determine which will be the best outcome, all while you’re doing the traditional [00:42:30] RFPs, while you’re getting advisor feedback, having advisors do beta tests, having them give you input as to what they see as the best solutions, and then creating those solutions for them complimented by AI and helping you get there faster. ( 42:43 ): We’re also very fortunate that RedBird has a team called RDX, which is RedBird’s AI team. And it’s part of the vision that Gerry Cardinale and Mike have had to have an AI team that actually supports their portfolio company. So this team’s been available to help us test out, create, [00:43:00] deliver AI-driven solutions that now are more focused on reporting, they’re more focused on practice management, and they’re more focused on organic growth. ( 43:09 ): At the same time, inorganic growth is, although Mike clearly said organic growth is more important to us, inorganic growth is a process and a muscle that we want to continue to exercise, because we’ve found ourselves to be quite good at being able to execute on it once we determine that it’s the right partner to have. And so when you’re an advisor [00:43:30] here and you’re a partner here, you want to see your business growing organically. You want to focus on it, but you also want to depend on your partners to drive inorganic growth at the same time, to benefit long-term from having that partner you chose. ( 43:44 ): They choose Arax, and they choose me and the team here to be their partner. They want to see us executing on inorganic growth, empowering their practice with everything it needs to grow so that for the long term, we’re building something special defined by the most important ingredient, the quality of the financial advisors, and [00:44:00] the teams that support. Jason Diamond ( 44:01 ): Yeah, it all ties back to certainly a people-driven business at heart. I think we have time for maybe two more, and I want to ask about this. I think Haig, you mentioned this. Recruiting of wirehouse advisors, this is one that kind of vexes me, if I’m being honest. I feel we’ve been saying this for years now, that we would’ve felt we would’ve seen more private equity firms or private equity-backed RIAs recruiting directly, acquiring businesses directly from the wirehouses. ( 44:26 ): We’ve seen a little bit of that, Cresset, NewEdge, some Beacon Pointe, [00:44:30] you guys certainly, but it hasn’t been like a gangbusters trade. The more popular trade seems to be either wirehouse advisors going to another W-2 firm, like a Wire or a Ray J, or if they are interested in independence, either the broker dealer path like an LPL, or launch an RIA or launch an RIA with a platform and maybe consider selling it down the road. ( 44:51 ): Do you think that there’s more to come though for these direct wirehouse lift-outs? Is this a major part of the strategy going forward? Haig Ariyan ( 44:57 ): So Jason, for Arax, [00:45:00] it’s a major part of the strategy. We have an inorganic growth strategy that has two prongs to it. One is the continued acquisition and partnership with firms, and two is the continued lift-out and partnership of teams from wirehouses. You haven’t seen the others do it other than maybe the team at NewEdge, for example, because Straus and Sechan, they know how to do it. We do it because we know how to do it. ( 45:24 ): Private equity doesn’t inherently know how to lift out a team, speak the language of FA. I’ve done it [00:45:30] for 25 years. The competitive nature of it, many people feel like it’s the most competitive it’s been today. Truth be told, go back to the mid 2000s. I was running Deutsche Bank Wealth Management’s Alex Brown business in Midtown New York. I had the New York region. It was a recruiting juggernaut period of time. ( 45:54 ): And in Midtown New York, I was competing with Barry Sommers at Bear Stearns, who now [00:46:00] runs Wells Fargo Wealth Management. Great recruiter. I was competing against Jack Peterson and Mark Stevenson at Lehman, two of the most beloved guys in our profession. I was competing against Matt Gorman at Credit Suisse, and then all the other wirehouse guys that were in Midtown at that time. ( 46:19 ): It was a wonderful period of time, but never was recruiting more intense. And those EFL models will get more and more rich and more and more rich, and they’re still half of what [00:46:30] they are today in terms of recruiting bonuses and sign-ons. So it is something that’s in my DNA. It’s in my team’s DNA. ( 46:40 ): Amy Rizzo, who’s our chief growth officer, she’s been recruiting in South Florida for 10 years, the most competitive market in the country other than maybe Manhattan. So recruiting and lifting out wirehouse teams, you just have to know how to do it. And it’s not a matter of just recruiting them, that’s just the pitch. You have to know how to transfer their businesses so you don’t [00:47:00] disrupt the client experience and that it atrophies. ( 47:03 ): So firms have to be willing to make that capital investment knowing they’re going to keep the business intact. We know how to do that. So we’re totally committed to that two-pronged inorganic growth strategy going forward, which includes lifting out teams and recruiting teams. And I hope that our relationship with Diamond Consulting is only going to get tighter and tighter over that period of time, Jason. Jason Diamond ( 47:23 ): Yeah, absolutely. That certainly speaks to our relationship for sure. And actually, that was part of what my reasoning for [00:47:30] asking Mike the question about you. To me, your single biggest superpower in that space is being able to talk the talk and walk the walk with other wirehouse advisors. And you spoke about the momentum piece of this. I absolutely believe, especially with wirehouse advisors, there’s a little bit of that like, oh, I saw my colleague down the hall, and now I’m starting to ask those questions. I assume you feel that a little bit in your business as well. Haig Ariyan ( 47:52 ): Oh, definitely. Which is why if you make a mistake, you mess up, it can be terminal for your recruiting efforts. [00:48:00] And yet if you do the opposite and you fulfill every obligation you said you would, and you execute on behalf of that FA and his clients, it’s the benefit. And they’re going to tell their former friends, their former employee colleagues who are their friends, they’re going to tell them that, “Hey, this experience went really well.” And then why you make sure that the surprises that advisors are going to experience are upside surprises, not downside surprises. ( 48:26 ): So you start with what could go wrong. You start with where [00:48:30] are the challenges? And then you give them the upside experience. And then they can go to their clients and say, “I’m so pleased to tell you, I’m going to be a partner at Arax. I’m going to bring my clients to Arax. I’m going to be an owner of this organization.” Clients love that. They believe in their financial advisors so much that they’ve entrusted their life’s work to them. Don’t you think they want to see that financial advisor succeed and be an owner? Absolutely. And that’s a very important dynamic to this. Jason Diamond ( 48:58 ): Think about advisors are managing money [00:49:00] on behalf of people, and a lot of these people are entrepreneurs in their own right or very successful business owners in their own right, and they kind of get it. And I think advisors are often surprised by that. So I appreciate that perspective, Haig. ( 49:10 ): Mike, I want to end with you on purpose because I think you have a institutional perspective that is unique or a little more unique on our show. So what is something from your seat that the “retail wealth management crowd” is maybe not thinking about as much, or something that you are spending a lot of your time on these days that you see as kind of the next big thing [00:49:30] over the next couple years. And if it’s something as simple as AI, that’s fair. Mike Zabik ( 49:33 ): I’ll give you a couple answers, Jason, because it’s more than one thing. Some of them are germane to Arax and some are things that we’re doing more broadly defined. We think that the generational wealth transfer that is happening in this country is going to be probably more prolific than it’s been at any other point in history. ( 49:52 ): And the number of billionaires that were created in this year alone, and they’re going to continue to be created over the next handful of years on the back of not only [00:50:00] AI, but just robust open public markets, that wealth transfer and the complexity of the wealth that’s being created is critically important in terms of how you take care of those people. ( 50:10 ): And so what I think you’ve seen Arax be more and more successful with and on over the last 12 to 18 months is servicing those more affluent clients. And the average Arax client fits very squarely in the high net worth bucket. The piece of the pie that is ultra-high net worth, I think more 25 [00:50:30] million plus, is a rapidly growing part of the Arax business. And I think Haig and the team, and we’ve made real meaningful investments in human capital and technological capital to support clients like that and FAs that look after those clients. And so we think that the ultra-high net worth part of the market is a massive opportunity. It’s just as exciting as the high net worth part of the market, and so we’re playing both in different ways. ( 50:58 ): The second thing I would tell you broadly [00:51:00] defined, we don’t think… So I, like you, don’t understand why more people don’t do team lift-outs. And so we’re quite bullish on that and we love the fact that we have a partner that’s been doing it for a really long time, knows how to do it. And I think if you look at what we do over the next three to five years in financial services, and by the way, this isn’t just germane to wealth, we’re doing it in insurance brokerage, we’re doing it in other places. And humbly, I think we’re quite good at it because this is all we do. ( 51:28 ): All we do is FIG, all [00:51:30] we do is asset light, people-based businesses, and I would say a third to a half of what we do in each of these platform investments are team lift-outs. And so I think we’re pretty decent at it, and that’s not going to stop anytime soon. And we think it’s an incredibly accretive part of the inorganic growth pillar to any of these stories, not the least of which Arax. ( 51:53 ): And then I would tell you from an AI perspective, and I was one of the guys that co-wrote the white paper for the firm back in 2022 [00:52:00] when we created the team, and the team is mostly ex-Palantir forward deployed engineers. We are seeing tremendous opportunities. We build stuff in-house that we use for the firm and the employees here. We have incubated businesses like InterPositive that we sold to Netflix earlier this year, and then we have the team working hand in glove with managing teams like Haig and the rest of the team at Arax to empower them. ( 52:23 ): But I would tell you, AI is not the boogeyman. We call it augmented intelligence, not artificial intelligence. We are deploying [00:52:30] it to make the humans more efficient, not replace them. And I think when you start with that ethos and philosophy, A, it takes the temperature down a lot for the people that work at the company. And when you show up and say, “Listen, there are real value creation levers that can be pulled for you and your business.” ( 52:46 ): And it’s not about firing people, and it’s not just about workflow automation and cost savings. This is, to use Arax as a specific example, we use it for both business development and efficiency from a workflow automation perspective, [00:53:00] but not to fire people. On the growth side, we’ve deployed a number of different solutions to really help augment the funnel and make new client acquisition more efficient. ( 53:11 ): And on the workflow automation side, it is much more about first-mile stuff like client onboarding. It is about client comms, client reporting. It is about freeing the financial advisor up to have more time to do the thing that is the highest and best use of their time. And so that’s how we’re deploying AI. ( 53:29 ): That’s not [00:53:30] specific to Arax, that is we’re doing that across the entire portfolio, not only in FIG, but elsewhere in sports media and entertainment. We think the velocity of technological innovation going on right now has probably never been seen, and I think we’re quite excited about where things are going and what you can do with that toolkit over the next one to five years. Jason Diamond ( 53:51 ): That’s what excites me most also is the idea that advisors have long complained. Haig, I’m sure probably the number one thing you heard from advisors about back in the day was [00:54:00] capacity constraint and the endless menial tasks. And AI to me has the ability to turn all that on its head. And to your point, prospecting and managing relationships is where advisors should be spending the majority of their time, not on my learning classes online and the like. ( 54:16 ): I was super excited to have you both on because, to me, Arax and RedBird are the poster child for the happy marriage between private equity and wealth management of what [00:54:30] this could look like. Haig Ariyan ( 54:31 ): I agree with that. Mike Zabik ( 54:31 ): Thank you for that. Jason Diamond ( 54:32 ): I really thought this was a fantastic episode, and I’m looking forward to what the next chapter brings. Haig Ariyan ( 54:36 ): Thanks for having us, Jason. Mike Zabik ( 54:37 ): Yeah, thank you, Jason. Mindy Diamond ( 54:46 ): As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibility seriously and are dedicated to your clients. [00:55:00] But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms, or could a better option exist? ( 55:07 ): Should I Stay or Should I Go is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, [00:55:30] whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook.

October 29, 2026Episode 38357 min

AI for Financial Advisors: An Expert’s Advice on How and Where to Start

John O’Connell, Founder and Chief Executive Officer of The Oasis Group With hundreds of AI solutions entering wealth management, how can financial advisors determine which tools are worth adopting? John O’Connell, Founder and CEO of The Oasis Group, shares practical guidance on AI implementation, technology selection, data integration, and risk management—and explains why solving the right business problem matters more than adopting the latest technology. In Summary Artificial intelligence is creating new opportunities for financial advisors to improve efficiency, strengthen client relationships, and build more scalable businesses. But with AI capabilities evolving almost daily, determining where to start – and which solutions will deliver meaningful results – has become increasingly complicated. John O’Connell, Founder and CEO of The Oasis Group, works with RIAs, broker dealers, trust companies, and family offices to evaluate, implement, and integrate technology. His firm’s AI WealthTech Map has grown from 17 to 135 companies in approximately 18 months, offering a revealing look at the expanding universe of AI solutions available to advisors. In this conversation with Louis Diamond, John explains how firms can identify valuable AI use cases, evaluate vendors, establish appropriate safeguards, and prepare for a future in which clients are becoming increasingly sophisticated users of AI themselves. His central message: Start with the business problem, become an educated buyer, and remember that human judgment remains essential. The Storyline The challenge isn’t finding AI. It’s knowing what to do with it. A new AI tool launches, an existing wealth management platform announces additional capabilities, or a colleague shares an impressive demonstration. For advisors eager to improve efficiency and stay competitive, the temptation to adopt the latest technology is understandable. But John O’Connell believes that approach often puts the technology ahead of the business need. As Founder and CEO of The Oasis Group, John helps wealth management firms make smarter technology decisions, from selecting and implementing platforms to integrating data and developing effective workflows. His experience offers a perspective on both the opportunities AI creates and the practical challenges firms encounter when putting it to work. And those challenges are becoming more complicated. The Oasis Group’s AI WealthTech Map now includes 135 individual companies, representing approximately 550 variations of capabilities and licensing options. That doesn’t include established wealth management technology providers that are incorporating AI into their existing platforms. For advisors, the sheer number of choices makes it increasingly important to understand what they’re buying, what their existing technology can accomplish, and whether a new solution will actually solve a problem. John’s advice is to start small, but think strategically. He shares a surprisingly simple first use case: Ask AI to interview the employee who knows how to perform an undocumented business process. The result can be a documented workflow that reduces operational risk while helping employees learn how to use AI effectively. From there, firms can begin identifying opportunities with greater potential impact, including client acquisition, internal knowledge management, operational efficiency, and business scalability. But successful implementation requires more than identifying promising applications. John explains why advisors should establish detailed requirements before attending vendor demonstrations, understand the limitations of APIs and Model Context Protocols (MCPs), and create AI policies that address data protection, employee training, and accountability. The conversation also examines an important distinction between employee and independent advisors. While large firms have substantial technology resources, independent advisors may have greater flexibility to adopt emerging tools and develop AI capabilities more quickly. John believes that advantage is particularly relevant as clients increasingly use AI to analyze financial plans, evaluate investment costs, and question recommendations. Ultimately, he sees AI as an opportunity to strengthen – not replace – the value of human financial advice. By automating certain tasks and making information more accessible, advisors can spend more time developing relationships, exercising judgment, and helping clients navigate the complex personal decisions that technology alone cannot address. Topics Covered AI adoption in wealth management: Why implementing AI successfully requires more than purchasing software or activating existing features. Identifying the right AI use cases: How to prioritize business problems, operational bottlenecks, and opportunities for meaningful improvement. Practical applications and ROI: From documenting workflows and improving meeting management to strengthening referrals and internal knowledge sharing. Evaluating AI vendors: Why detailed business requirements should drive technology selection, rather than impressive demonstrations. Wirehouse versus independent AI capabilities: How technology control, implementation speed, and open architecture influence advisors’ ability to adopt AI. The expanding AI WealthTech landscape: What The Oasis Group’s map reveals about the growing number of solutions available to financial advisors. Technology integration and data access: Understanding APIs, MCPs, and direct data feeds—and why connectivity alone doesn’t guarantee functionality. AI governance and cybersecurity: Establishing acceptable use policies, protecting client information, and maintaining human accountability. Training the next generation of advisors: How AI is changing traditional responsibilities and creating new opportunities for professional development. The future of human financial advice: Why AI may enable advisors to serve more clients while making personal relationships and judgment even more valuable. > Download a transcript of this episode… Listen and Learn Highlights for Advisors Why adopting AI isn’t the same as being ready to use it (10:02) John explains why simply activating tools like Microsoft Copilot rarely produces meaningful organization-wide adoption. Training, clearly defined use cases, and appropriate safeguards are essential to getting value from AI investments. Where financial advisors should start with AI (13:27) Rather than attempting to integrate every system and data source, John recommends beginning with a manageable business problem. He demonstrates how AI can document an employee’s specialized knowledge, reduce operational risk, and build confidence in the technology. How AI can create value beyond meeting notes (16:22) AI note-takers can improve efficiency, but their value depends on how firms use the time they save. John also discusses using AI to understand referral sources, identify what clients value, and improve business development. How to evaluate AI vendors without getting distracted by the demo (22:55) John introduces the MoSCoW framework (must-have, should-have, could-have, and won’t-have requirements) and explains how firms can use it to make better technology decisions. Why independent advisors may have an AI advantage (27:18) John compares the technology adoption capabilities of large employee firms and independent businesses, explaining why flexibility and implementation speed can create a meaningful advantage as AI evolves. What 135 AI WealthTech companies reveal about the market (33:21) The Oasis Group’s AI WealthTech Map illustrates the expanding range of available solutions. John explains how advisors can use a client-journey approach to identify relevant technology and avoid unnecessary purchases. What advisors need to understand about AI integrations (36:48) MCPs, APIs, and direct data feeds promise greater connectivity, but their usefulness depends on which information they make available. John explains why advisors need to understand their data requirements before selecting a solution. What an effective AI policy should include (42:41) John outlines essential governance considerations, including approved tools, vendor vetting, model testing, incident response procedures, and the responsibility of advisors to validate AI-generated information. How AI is changing the development of younger advisors (48:33) As technology takes over administrative responsibilities, firms must reconsider how junior advisors learn the skills that matter most, including client observation, diagnostic questioning, and relationship development. Why AI may ultimately expand the reach of financial advice (52:13) John explains why he sees AI as an opportunity rather than a threat. Greater efficiency could allow advisors to serve more families while preserving the human empathy and judgment clients need during important life events. Key Takeaways Start with the problem, not the technology. Identify an operational challenge or business opportunity before evaluating AI tools. A small, well-defined use case can provide immediate value while helping a firm develop the skills needed for broader implementation. AI adoption requires training and accountability. Providing employees with access to AI doesn’t guarantee effective use. Firms need clear policies, practical training, and processes for reviewing and validating AI-generated results. Become an educated technology buyer. Document business requirements, prioritize essential capabilities, and ask vendors to demonstrate how their solutions address specific needs. A compelling demonstration is no substitute for functional compatibility. Understand what your data integrations actually provide. An MCP or API connection is only useful if it makes the information required for a particular workflow available. Advisors should evaluate data access as carefully as the technology itself. Technology flexibility can influence competitive positioning. Independent advisors may be able to implement emerging AI capabilities faster than larger organizations, while employee advisors depend more heavily on the tools and timelines established by their firms. Clients are becoming more sophisticated AI users. As investors use AI to review financial plans, compare costs, and question recommendations, advisors need to understand the technology well enough to respond confidently and effectively. AI can strengthen the value of human advice. Automating routine responsibilities creates opportunities for advisors to focus on judgment, relationships, and client needs. It may also make serving a larger number of families more economically feasible. https://youtu.be/zbw2lim7tNw Quotable Moments On where to start: “I like to say pick a problem that’s really easy for you to solve, and don’t try to boil the ocean.” — John O’Connell (13:27) On AI’s role in financial advice: “If you’re using AI, it’s an accelerant to what you do. It’s not a replacement for your expertise.” — John O’Connell (12:08) On selecting technology: “Here’s my problem I got to solve. What tool can solve that problem?” — John O’Connell (35:56) On the importance of requirements: “You’ve just got to pump the brakes, really put together a set of requirements, and then figure out what’s the best solution for you.” — John O’Connell (41:33) On the future of financial advice: “Can I provide more advice to more people in need? Yes. Can I do that in a way that still provides that empathy and that human connection? Yes.” — John O’Connell (53:16) FAQs How should financial advisors get started with AI? Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. What are the best AI use cases for financial advisors? Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. How can RIAs evaluate AI tools and technology vendors? Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Do independent financial advisors have an advantage when adopting AI? Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. What is The Oasis Group’s AI WealthTech Map? Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. What should financial advisors know about MCPs and APIs? Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. What should an AI acceptable use policy include? Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Will AI replace financial advisors? Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. How is AI changing the role of junior financial advisors? Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo. Related Resources The Next Frontier for Advisors: Evaluating AI in the Early Cycle For years, technology defined the competitive edge in wealth management. Now, a new force is reshaping that landscape. Artificial intelligence is emerging as the next wave of differentiation—prompting advisors to rethink not just where they are today, but which platforms are truly built for what comes next. Explore More Podcasts on AI & Technology Explore conversations with industry leaders on how AI, technology, and evolving infrastructure are shaping the future of wealth management and the advisor experience. AI WealthTech Map: The Oasis Group’s Peaks Perspective on AI Wealth Technology The Oasis Group’s AI WealthTech Map highlights 115 firms developing AI solutions for wealth management, organized by function to help advisors explore the evolving technology landscape. John O’Connell Founder & CEO John is the Founder and CEO of The Oasis Group , which helps wealth management firms navigate technology strategy, cybersecurity, and AI implementation. He created the AI WealthTech Map and the AI Readiness Assessment, and authors the Oasis Peaks Perspective newsletter to over 70,000 subscribers. With 30+ years in the industry, John is also the author of the best-selling book Rise of The Activist Investor and creator of the Activist Investor Arc framework. NOTE: The views and opinions expressed by the guests on this podcast are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Diamond Consultants. Neither Diamond Consultants nor the guests on this podcast are compensated in any way for their participation. View the transcript of this episode… AI for Financial Advisors: An Expert’s Advice on How and Where to Start A conversation with Louis Diamond and John O’Connell, Founder and Chief Executive Officer of The Oasis Group. Louis Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is AI for Financial Advisors: An Expert’s Advice on How and Where to Start. It’s a conversation with John O’Connell, Founder and Chief Executive Officer of The Oasis Group. I’m Louis Diamond, and this is The Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education-driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning, data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Louis Diamond: AI is moving so quickly in wealth management. I think it’s easy for advisors and firms to approach it backwards. The path often goes like this. A new tool launches, a platform adds an AI capability, someone shows you a demo, looks incredible. A friend told you about this chatbot. And the natural reaction is, “How do we start using this in our business?” But maybe the better question is much simpler. What problem are we actually trying to solve? That’s one of the reasons I wanted to talk with John O’Connell, Founder and CEO of The Oasis Group. John and his team advise RIAs, broker-dealers, trust companies, and family offices on technology, data, and of course, AI. And while he comes from a technical background, he has a uniquely practical way of looking at it all. Consider this, The Oasis Group’s AI wealth tech map has grown from just 17 companies to 135 in about 18 months. And John mentions that over 500 firms have submitted applications to be on the map. So the challenge for advisors isn’t finding AI, it’s figuring out what they actually need, what works with their existing technology and data, and where AI can create meaningful value without introducing unnecessary risk. And John’s advice is refreshingly straightforward. Don’t try to boil the ocean, yet recognize there’s much more to AI than note-taking and summarizing content. AI’s real power comes from identifying the problems or bottlenecks you’re trying to solve, and never forget that you’re still the human in the loop. John and I get into some very practical examples of how firms can do that, plus how to prioritize AI initiatives, what advisors should understand about ACIs, MCPs, and data integrations, and why a great demo doesn’t necessarily mean you’re looking at the right technology and much more. Because with AI, changing this quickly, being an early adopter may actually matter. But being an educated buyer and an educated user may matter even more. So let’s get to it. John, thanks for joining us today. John O’Connell: Thank you very much for having me, Louis. Louis Diamond: Awesome. Let’s dive in. Give us some background here on your backstory and what led you to where you are now as the CEO of The Oasis Group. John O’Connell: Thanks. Yeah, so I actually started my career as a computer programmer, believe it or not. Computer science, mathematics background, started as a programmer at Merrill Lynch. From there, I got plucked out of there into KPMG, Peat Marwick, wound up being either a consumer of technology or a provider of technology for my whole career. I did a second tour of duty, if you will, at Merrill. I was there for the end of Merrill, unfortunately, the unpleasantness, as I like to call it. And then after that, I went to Oracle for a number of years running sales at Oracle and financial services. Then, I was in the C-suite of a couple of publicly traded companies. And then in 2019, I created The Oasis Group, and we focused pretty much exclusively in the wealth management space. Louis Diamond: Perfect. And what was it that led you to start your own company? Was there a need you saw in the market or what was the thesis? John O’Connell: I think it was primarily that I was just tired of having a board of directors or someone else who was driving the direction of the company. Believe it or not, in being in the C-suite of two publicly traded firms, what I picked up on pretty quickly was you can have the best intentions in your go-to-market strategy, but if the board decides they want to move in a different direction, they’re going to move in a different direction. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: That was really one of the impetuses for me creating the company. That and the fact that the wealth management space is really exciting. I’ve been in this space for a very long time. It’s a really exciting space to be in. Right? There’s always a ton of change going on in it. We’ve seen this explosion in new technology that has happened really in the wealth space. When I started the firm, it was still this big explosion of new tech that was hitting the marketplace. And I thought that we could really help a lot of firms in choosing technology and figuring out what to use it for and really create it as a force multiplier. Right? There’s so much out there, you could basically spend your whole life just buying tech, at least in the wealth space you can. So we really wanted to just help firms to figure out how to maximize that spend and how to make the right choices. Louis Diamond: That’s perfect. So in a nutshell, didn’t want to have bosses, wanted to be the one who was giving the advice, and really be able to act on the best ideas rather than having a well-thought-out plan stuffed by a board of directors, which I very much respect. And at its core, you’re a consultancy for wealth management firms exclusively, or who’s the target market? John O’Connell: So if you think of the pantheon of wealth management firms as 14 different market segments, we focus primarily on RIAs, trust organizations, broker-dealers, and then family offices. That’s our sweet spot where we do a lot of our work. And it’s not surprising, there’s different technologies for each one of those different segments, right? So it’s quite a bit to keep up to speed on. But when you take a look at those segments, they’re really handling the vast majority of the wealth that’s in the United States. So it plays to our strengths really well to be able to help with that space. Louis Diamond: Perfect. And what’s the typical engagement that your firm is tagged on? Is it helping firms build their tech stack for the first time? Is it retrofitting technology? Is it sorting through RFPs? What’s the typical? Or maybe there’s a couple parts to the answer. John O’Connell: Yeah, it runs the gamut of what you just mentioned. We’ve helped a lot of firms that have broken away, both from wirehouses or when a big M&A happens and they don’t necessarily want to go with the M&A. We’ve helped firms start up from a, “Hey, I was part of a wirehouse. Now, I want to start a completely new tech stack. What do I do?” So we’ve helped people stand that up. We’ve also helped a lot of firms that have been on technology for a long period of time, right? Maybe they’ve been on the tech for a long period of time, and their firm has changed over time. A lot of firms have grown really well or they’ve made small acquisitions. And now, they’ve got two CRMs, need one. How do I get there? So that’s part of what we do as well. We do a lot of work, quite frankly, in the aggregator space too. Right? Private equity has been very active in our space. There’s a lot of firms that are household names at this point in the wealth management space that are buying other firms. So we’ve helped them to be able to bring the technology together. When you think of the RFP side of things, that’s where our trust organization, we do a lot of work in the RFP side for trust organizations. Most RIAs don’t really RFP. For us in that space, it’s helping them to understand what are your real requirements? How do you focus on those? Don’t be enamored by the demo. Go in with a real set of requirements and say, “Show me this.” When you do that, you tend to get a much more accurate viewpoint of what the technology can or cannot do. But on the trust organization side, a lot of them are larger firms. They have more of a procurement organization. They’re more apt to do an RFP, and we help design RFPs, run those RFP processes. And then unlike a lot of the other management consulting firms, we actually do the implementations. Once the firm says, “Yep, this is the direction we want to go in,” we’ll help with everything from data movement, building the new workflows and the new software, helping them with their performance reporting after the fact, handling performance history, which is usually more challenging than you would think, as well as helping them get their training done and their integrations done between the systems. Louis Diamond: Very cool. The typical knock on management consulting or consulting in general is you get an elegant deck. Here’s your problem, here’s a recommended solution, and then things die on a vine because implementation struggles or fails. And I get with tech why it’s so important. It wouldn’t be a podcast in 2026 without asking about AI. I have to imagine technology, AI, wealth management, they’re all synonymous today. So what is it you’re seeing in the AI space? And maybe just that a more specific question, how do you address the gap between firms adopting AI, which is not a hard sell, but probably more importantly, being ready to really use AI? John O’Connell: Yeah, I’m pretty lucky. I think this year I’m going to speak at 24 different events on artificial intelligence and prediction markets. I talk a lot about prediction markets with folks as well. Where we see artificial intelligence… And by the way, when we say technology that we go-to-market with folks, that’s everything around wealth tech, AI, and data. That’s really our sweet spot, which you can imagine from a guy that spent eight half years at Oracle, data’s a big part of that. And really data is kind of like the rocket fuel for the rocket that is AI. Right? With really good data, you can get really great results. But to answer your question most directly, what we see today is a mixed bag. We see a lot of firms that turn on their artificial intelligence. For example, they’ll turn on Microsoft Copilot, and give it to their teams, and they’re expecting their team to just pick it up. And that’s not really what’s going to happen. Do you know what I mean? Without some training, it doesn’t really take. And you wind up finding some diamonds in the rough, people that are really good at it, that are starting to use it pretty extensively. And then for the most part, you’re not getting that real economy of scale that you want with an artificial intelligence implementation. So what we really recommend is, number one, put together an AI acceptable use policy. Put together some really good guardrails. And that’s not just your compliance team saying, “This is what we want you to do around PII.” That’s not going to cut it. You really need to explain to folks, “These are the use cases we want you to use AI. These are the use cases we don’t want you to use AI.” For example, if you’re an RIA and you’re really big on financial planning, you don’t want to use AI with financial planning because that’s your secret sauce. You may want to use it around investment research. Right? If you are one of the, like a family office that picks the best investments for your firm and that’s one of the things that you feel is a differentiator for you, you probably don’t want to use AI there. You probably want to use it for some other things. So really understanding these are use cases that are in balance, this is out of bounds. Here’s the tools we’re going to allow you to use, everything else is out of bounds. And then really sitting down with them and saying, “This is what our expectations are.” With artificial intelligence, with the regulators, and even with the risk management that you’ve got of being sued, quite frankly, as a fiduciary, you’ve got to understand you’re the human in the loop, you’re going to be held accountable. So you’ve got to build that process into your AI acceptable use policy as well, so that people understand if you’re using AI, it’s an accelerant to what you do. It’s not a replacement for your expertise. Louis Diamond: Exactly. John O’Connell: You need to be held accountable for that. And that’s where we find a lot of firms fall short. Louis Diamond: Yep. Well said. Our goal is to always make these episodes as tangible, and we’ll say instructional as possible. So someone listening can take this information, and then get started on something or really dive into the topic. So in the world of AI that’s moving so fast that it was especially relevant here, just ask you some questions to really dive a little bit more into the implementation weeds, if you will. John O’Connell: Sure. Louis Diamond: So how does an advisor think through where AI actually belongs in their business? Like you said, like the human in the loop part. And how do they use it without creating a bigger problem than the one they’re trying to solve? Because I’m guilty of the same thing. You see a cool new tool, it promises you the moon and the stars. Cool, I want to do it because I want to grow faster, I want to be more efficient. But to me, it’s not really a thoughtful approach. And again, I’m guilty of it too. So what’s the right way to think about how an advisor can deploy AI in their business? John O’Connell: I like to say pick a problem that’s really easy for you to solve, and don’t try to boil the ocean. A lot of folks turn to us and say, “I want to take all my CRM data, my financial planning data, and my custodian data, and bring all that together and drive insights across my firm.” And it’s like, “Okay.” Number one, is all of those data sources really clean? Can you bring all that together? Do you even know how to do that at this point? So I like to say pick a much smaller problem, right? Every practice that we’ve talked to, when you talk to them and you say, “Do you have an undocumented workflow that you’ve got? Do you have someplace that all the knowledge is in one person’s head?” And invariably, the answer is always a yes. Right? Okay, why don’t we use AI to solve that problem first? So to give you a great example. You can use artificial intelligence to interview that one expert you’ve got. So let’s say Sally’s the only one that knows how to open up a certain type of an account. Great. Use AI to interview Sally on how to open up that account, and Sally will tell AI, “This is how we do it.” Right? And we’ve actually given these kind of scripts out to people and say, “Okay, here’s 10 things you want to start the conversation with.” As Sally is interviewed by AI, which will be strange for Sally the first time around, what’s happening is AI is actually documenting that entire workflow. And then what you can do is you can say, “I want a document of this workflow and I want a visual representation of it,” maybe in Lucidchart. Guess what? Now what’s happened is you’ve reduced the flight risk of your firm. If Sally’s sick, you have it written down. Right? If Sally leaves, you have it written down. You’ve reduced the flight risk. You got something documented that’s critical to your business, and it’s a first, and there’s no PII involved in that. Right? Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: There’s no customer risk. And by the way, you’ve learned a lot about how to leverage artificial intelligence in your business. So pick the business process that’s not documented. Use artificial intelligence to document that business process. Number one, you’re going to get a great result because you’ve reduced the risk of your business. And number two, you’ve gotten your feet wet on how to use artificial intelligence. Try not to boil the ocean. Try to pick some really easy use cases. And by the way, remember, you are the human in the loop. You’ve got to validate the output of these things. So learn how to do that as a skill, how to validate this output by picking something that’s really small and easy. Louis Diamond: Yeah, it makes sense. John O’Connell: And if you can get that documented, you’re off to the races. Louis Diamond: Yeah. John O’Connell: Now, pick the next process. And you’re going to become very adept at using this technology very quickly. Louis Diamond: It seems like most firms, like the most common AI that firms are using are any of the various platforms for recording and transcribing client meetings. John O’Connell: Yep. Louis Diamond: And then, creating tasks and follow-ups, et cetera. Every firm is meeting with clients. No one likes taking notes. So do you think that’s just been a really good example with really good technology around it where advisors, instead of boiling the ocean, they go with kind of the low-hanging fruit. Would you agree? John O’Connell: I do. I agree with that. What I find really funny though is this. When you ask people, “So you’re using an AI note-taker?” “Yes.” “How many people do you still have in your meeting?” You’re like, “Two or three.” “Okay, then what are they doing?” I’ve been in sales for a very long time, right? In sales, you would know what everyone’s role is that’s in the meeting. Right? Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: You might have technical experts. When I was at Oracle, we were selling technology, you would have technical experts in there. You’d also have someone who was the observer that was watching the body language of your customer as you presented the solution to them, right? And you’d have a scribe, someone who would actually write that stuff down. The scribe goes away with the note-taker. So what are the other people doing in the meeting? Are they learning the craft? So do you have a junior person in the meeting that’s learning how you talk to the client? If that’s the case, they’re an observer, and they should be really soaking in the observations in that meeting. And then, they should be able to tell you what they found in that meeting. So the note-taker doesn’t make all that go away, right? So if you have an observer in your meeting, maybe you’re the advisor and you’ve got a junior person in your meeting, someone still has to review those meeting notes. Louis Diamond: Right. John O’Connell: To make sure that the facts of the meeting are captured, right? And not everything, by the way, should be written down. We’ve got advisors, for example. Advisors learn a lot of different things about their clients. A client may come in and say, “I think I’m going to get divorced.” That’s not something that should be written down in a meeting note and committed to your CRM. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: So who edits those meeting notes afterwards to make sure that what’s being committed to the CRM is accurate? That should be your observer. Louis Diamond: I like it. Kind of a similar question. How does a firm think through what’s going to create the most meaningful value for our advisors or for our clients? So I get that, basically, start off with undocumented processes, the low-hanging fruit, et cetera, but those aren’t necessarily the biggest value drivers for a firm. How should firms think about that? John O’Connell: I think firms should really consider what’s driving their business right now. Right? So a lot of firms, for example, work on referrals. That’s probably the number one lead source that we have in the industry at this point. So if that’s the case, then what you really want to do is you want to start mining some of that data. For example, how many referrals have I gotten from individual clients? Right? If I’ve got someone who consistently gives me referrals, maybe interview that person with an AI note-taker. Why do you give us referrals? What do you feel that we’re doing really well for you? What are we not doing really well for you? Right? Start getting a feel for what’s your sweet spot, or if you will, what’s the heat map that you’ve got around what’s resonating with some of these key clients? So if you are driving your business by referral and you want to be more found, let’s say, by AI search engines, interview your top clients that are providing referrals for you, use an AI note-taker when you’re doing that, ask the AI note-taker to summarize all those conversations together, not individually, together. Feed all those transcripts in and say, “I want you to generate an LLM text for my website with the key points that you find from this.” Louis Diamond: In other words, instead of you as the advisor or the marketing department guessing what your clients want, and especially the ones that are referring you, use your client’s direct words, right? Now you have a common theme. And really what you care about are attracting more of your ideal client. And ideally, they’re people that someone’s referring you. That’s a brilliant way to do it. John O’Connell: And if you use it as LLM text in your website, you have your web team do that. When an LLM searches your website, it looks for that LLM.text. And when it finds that LLM.text, it’s going to index that information. So you’re essentially broadcasting what your ideal client looks like out to the world. Louis Diamond: Very cool. What are you seeing as the fastest or most measurable ROI in the AI world today? We talked about note-taking as one. I would assume that’s probably one of the areas. Are there other areas where you’re seeing quick ROI or the best ROI for firms? John O’Connell: So larger firms, again, in some of the trust organizations we work with or some of the enterprise RIAs that we work with, what they’re doing is they’re putting a lot of the information that they would normally have embedded within, for example, their intranet or their SharePoint, and they’re indexing that using artificial intelligence. So imagine a small chatbot where you can say, “Hey, what’s vacation look like? What are the vacation days this year?” It cuts down significantly on the number of tickets that they get to their HR organization, to their IT organization. Louis Diamond: So in other words, more of like a ask me anything, but internal to your organization, not something that’s being deployed to clients. John O’Connell: Yeah, imagine like the next step of a Wikipedia. Do you know what I mean? What’s the next search capability you can do? So that’s driving a lot of ROI for people. And it’s usually, again, not PII related. Right? So it’s internal, but it can drive a lot of ROI around it. The second thing that we’re seeing where people are generating a lot of ROI is, unfortunately, around undocumented processes, like I had touched on earlier. The mid-size and the smaller firms have tons of these undocumented capabilities that are within their firm. So we are seeing a lot of people generate ROI around that, especially if they’re growing extensively. So I’m going to come back to the aggregator for a moment. In the aggregator model, having those processes well documented so that when you buy a new firm or have a new firm tuck in under you, you can quickly explain what these processes look like. That, we find a very, very significant ROI. It cuts down on the frustration of the new firm as they’re being acquired or they’re coming in because it’s just transparent. Look, here’s what the process looks like. Here’s a way that you can interact with this process really quickly. So it really cuts down on angst that can occur when a firm gets acquired. So we’re seeing a lot of that from an ROI perspective. Louis Diamond: Perfect. And going back to the point we’re talking about earlier with documenting requirements and being really clear on what it is you’re looking for a vendor, an AI vendor, to do for you. When a firm’s thinking through that list, the business requirements, if you will, and obviously if they’re working with you, it’s going to be super detailed and granular. But at a high level, what categories of items should be on this business requirements list so that when someone shows up to a meeting with a vendor, they can turn it over? Or once they still select a platform, they can turn it over to that vendor’s implementation team or to someone like you. John O’Connell: So some of that is going to be more specific to the problem statement that you’ve got, right? So for example, a lot of times when we work with firms, we dig pretty deep on trading and rebalancing, right? Or the way that they want their performance reporting to be set up, or their billing as a good example. So what I would recommend is, if you’re going to look for a new wealth platform for a moment. Right? Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: Let’s say you’re on an existing wealth platform, you’re coming up on the renewal of your wealth platform, and you want to at least see what’s out there, maybe not switch, but at least understand the capabilities. What I would do is, again, use artificial intelligence, but go through each portion of your organization. What does the operations team love and hate about the existing solution? What does your trading team love and hate about it? What does your billing team love and hate about it? Get a list of here’s the things that are going really well. Here’s the things that are super challenging for us. That’s going to be an initial, what we would call a MoSCoW list, the must-have, should-have, could-have, and won’t-have. Then, force rank them. These must be there for me to be successful. These should be there because they’re going to be better than my existing solution. These could be there. Maybe it makes one or two people’s lives easier, but it’s not like a must-have. And these are the things that won’t be there. In other words, today, I’ve got to jump through six hoops to get something to happen. I will not do that tomorrow. Right? So those are the things that you want to get down on paper. Once you have that, give it to the vendor before the demo and say, “Listen, here’s a list of our requirements. I know you’ve got a safe path demo that you want to show us. I’m not interested in that. I really want to see these requirements. And once you’ve got that, there’s nowhere to hide. If it’s seven or eight clicks to do what you can do today in two, it’s completely obvious when you see the demo. So that’s what I would recommend if you’re going to look at any new technology. And quite frankly, you have to be looking at things are changing so quickly, you really need to look at what’s out in the marketplace every time you come up with a vendor renewal. That’s not just me as a technology person saying that. You really do need to look at it. Whether you hire a firm like me or you don’t hire a firm like me, please do because you’re going to be in a better place. And you’re going to be a much more educated, if not buyer of new technology, certainly a much more educated consumer of the existing technology you have. Louis Diamond: I like that. And summarizing or paraphrasing, come up with, I liked what you said, the MoSCoW list by interviewing the key users, and then deliver that list to a vendor before the demo. I’ve sat through demos where it’s like, it sounds amazing on their website and they tell you all these amazing things. Then you get into the questions, “Hey, do you integrate with X, Y, Z? What about this?” And then, it all falls apart. John O’Connell: That’s right. Louis Diamond: And if it doesn’t work for everything you’re doing or most of what you’re doing, then what’s the point? So I like that. It also tests the firms because they can give the same demo a thousand times. So if you’re giving them something a little bit different, you really get to see how their platform or their tool works. Let me ask you a question here. As our role as consultants to advisors, we work with advisors who are sitting within a captive organization. So think like a UBS or Ed Jones or a Merrill. We also work with advisors who are independent in some capacity, whether they’re at an independent BD, they’re owning and operating their own RIA, they’re interested in starting their own RIA, et cetera. How do you square right now, if you had to guess, the two different, I guess, AI strategies that advisors are looking at? On the one hand it’s, “Hey, I’m at XYZ firm. I’m happy enough.” or, “I’m going to go to XYZ firm and really relying upon that firm’s technology team to implement AI and really trusting that this big firm or this firm is watching my back for AI so I don’t have to, and I’m going to use whatever they do.” Versus the more, say, independent or open architecture approach, which is, “I want to pick and choose my own AI,” or, “I want to be able to adopt my AI tools next week when they change.” Do you think one path is better than the other? And maybe just some comments on that because I’m seeing that as like the tug of war. I don’t have an opinion on who’s right and who’s wrong. I think they’re just different. But in essence, a big firm having the tech budget, the compliance, the data, et cetera unlock and keeping the advisor focused versus having complete autonomy to pick and choose the best AI as it changes so quickly. John O’Connell: I think that right now with any new technology innovation, the larger firms are usually slower to react. When they do react, it can be more impactful, right? But it could take a long time to get there. And keep in mind, I was at Merrill. Two times in my career I was at Merrill, right? So when you’re in a large firm, part of the challenge you run into is things are changing so quickly at the moment that you’re not going to be able to move as quickly as you would as an independent. It’s just not going to happen. There’s more impetus around it. It’s trying to change the direction of the Queen Mary. It takes a lot longer to turn the boat around. So I think, right now, independent firms have a significant advantage at the moment. And the reason I say that is, number one, they’re getting exposed to the technology faster and they have more of an ability to get their feet wet on it. It’s a skill. Using artificial intelligence is a skill, being able to prompt it to get the right results, understanding what kind of data you feed it really does affect the results that you get back from it. Bringing that skill takes time. You’re in Park City, you’re probably familiar with Warren Miller. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: He used to make all these ski films. He used to end every one of his movies with, “If you don’t hit the slopes this year, you’ll be a year older when you do.” Right? It’s the same thing with AI. If you don’t start now, you’re just going to be older when you start it, not age-wise, but you’ll be further behind, if you will, the independent firms that have already jumped into this and have started using it. I do feel that the larger firms are at slightly more of a disadvantage at the moment, and I don’t see that gap closing anytime soon. Now, look, you’ve got firms like Bank of America that created Erica, and I think Erica is a great product. I’ve seen it. I think it’s very impactful, but it’s nowhere near what I’m seeing some of the independent firms doing at the moment. They’re just moving significantly faster. Louis Diamond: Yeah. And it sounds like too, other than the speed to make decisions, which has always been the independent technology narrative. I think it’s even more relevant today. It’s also that if you’re an advisor who especially is going to be in this business for a while, if you’re the one who’s responsible or on top of building your own tech stack or being more involved with picking tools, you’re probably going to be better at using AI for the future. And you’re kicking the can down the road if you’re just going to throw up your hands and trust that your firm has got it and you’re just going to ebb and flow with whatever the firm makes available. John O’Connell: And there’s a bigger risk, right? Your clients are using this today. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: We’ve already had advisors that have come to us and said, “My client took the financial plan that I gave them and put them into AI and came back with 20 questions.” I’ve already had firms in the trust organization space that have come back to me and said, “One of the trusts that we did an RFP response to ranked our RFP against our competitors using artificial intelligence.” Or, “They took the trust documents that we had and came back with all these questions, take a look at this.” And we’ve looked at them and we’re like, “Yeah, that was generated by AI.” The technology is so prevalently available right now. This is not like tech where a large firm has had access to it before an independent or before a consumer. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: Any consumer can open up ChatGPT, take your financial plan, roll it in there. Now, we’ll put the security aspects aside for a moment on that, but they can open up literally any one of the four leading large language model products. Take what you’ve given them as output, run it through that product, and come back to you with questions. We even had one advisor that was questioned on the expense ratio. So this client had taken their holdings, put it through Google Finance, got the expense ratios. And came back and said, “Why am I in so many expensive things?” Louis Diamond: Very smart and savvy. John O’Connell: It’s very savvy on the consumer side, but these are questions that consumers are bringing up now to advisors. If you’re in a wirehouse and you’re not being exposed to these kind of questions, it’s only a matter of time before your client comes to you with that as well. And if you don’t have an answer for it, you’re going to look like an unarmed combatant in that conversation. Louis Diamond: It sounds like with your example too, that advisors should be prepared that, because of AI, their clients appear to be more educated or more informed than ever before. John O’Connell: That is correct. Louis Diamond: I always kind of chuckle. Advisors are so focused on the, “I can increase the manager fee from 16 bips to 18 bips.” I’m like, “I work with a financial advisor, I wouldn’t notice.” I feel like there’s a lot of things that a client just trusts their advisors to do. They don’t really question it. But now with AI, I mean, you can stress test and poke holes in anything that someone shares. It’s such an interesting dynamic. Everyone talks about the, oh, AI is going to take the job of an advisor. I think now we’re at the point where it’s like, no, AI is going to make advisors be better advisors and be more transparent. And clients are going to be more challenging to work with because they have more information than ever before. John O’Connell: Yeah. The old joke was you never wanted an engineer or a computer scientist to be your client, right? Louis Diamond: I’ve heard that too. John O’Connell: Because they would question everything. Now, I think that you’re going to see that your consumer is significantly more educated. And your next gen, by the way, is going to be light years ahead of your existing client base. So you’ve got to get on board and understand these technologies and how they work, because you’re going to come across as being an old school advisor, if you will. Right? Louis Diamond: Yeah. John O’Connell: And certainly, we all know the statistics on money movement challenges in our industry. They’re not going to get any better with the use of artificial intelligence. Louis Diamond: Yeah. When you say money movement, meaning when G1 passes away, G2 disproportionately chooses to not work with the incumbent advisor. John O’Connell: That’s correct, and that’s going to continue. I think that number is actually going to go up, believe it or not. Louis Diamond: Interesting. I think we found you because I’ve seen your AI wealth tech map. Can you talk a little bit about the work you did to create this AI wealth tech map? What does it do? What are the segments, or I guess segments of the map? How should people use it? John O’Connell: Yeah, it’s pretty interesting. When we first started the map, the first thing we said is we really wanted it to map a client journey. Right? It wasn’t going to be by a technology, some technology marker we gave it. So for example, we don’t have like a AI note-taker ability in the map. Right? We’ve got it as meeting management, because AI note-takers really should go beyond just taking notes in a meeting. They should be able to schedule a meeting and generate follow-ups and tasks. So it’s really more of a meeting management. So if you think of our AI map, it goes through a client journey. How do you prospect? How do you do discovery with a client? How do you manage meetings with a client? Where did you go with proposals? So it really follows that client journey. When we started the map, which was just about 18 months ago, there were 17 firms on it. The latest map has 135. We demo every one of those tools. So we’ve rejected, on our count at this point, about 30% of the firms that apply for the map get rejected. Louis Diamond: Right. And this is 135 discrete companies, or is it like XYZ company fits into nine different categories, so it’s on here nine times? John O’Connell: 135 individual companies. Louis Diamond: That’s crazy. Think about any AI tool. They’re going to have different modules, the pro, the premium, the free version. They can sign up for this or that. So really, the choices are even more abundant than 135. John O’Connell: Yeah. If you take a look at the number of permutations between licensing levels and their capabilities they’ve got, it’s more like 550 that fit the mark. It’s incredibly interesting, right? And these are new entrants. These are not, like, your incumbent CRM that added a note-taker to it. That’s not on the map at this point. These are net new firms that have entered the space. And because we’ve demoed all of them, we’ve rejected quite a few. Right? If you look at it and you say, like, if we couldn’t implement it as The Oasis Group, we’re like, “This is not ready for prime time.” Right? Because there is vaporware out there. There’s AI washing that we’ve seen where it’s like you’re really a workflow tool. You’re not an AI tool. You do workflow management, but there’s no AI really in this. So if you took those two letters away, your tool would do the exact same thing it does today. So it’s not an AI tool. So we’ve rejected firms like that as well. For better or for worse, there are more and more people with private equity coming into our space that feel that they can solve a lot of these challenges that advisors have. And that’s a great thing for advisors, right? But it’s also a daunting task because you get our map that has so many firms on it. How do you figure out which firm is going to serve you well? And that’s why we really broke it out by the client journey. Right? Someone doesn’t turn and say, “You know what? I need a new CRM today.” It’s more like, “Hey, these are things that are failing. My discovery process is disjointed. It’s not feeding from my prospecting capability into my onboarding capability.” You need to solve that problem. Is it a CRM that solves that problem? Some of them do. Is it a workflow tool that solves that problem? Some of them do. As the advisor, you’re not looking at it from a technology lens, you’re looking at it as, “Here’s my problem I got to solve. What tool can solve that problem?” So that’s why we approached the map the way we did. Louis Diamond: Makes sense. In the last couple of weeks, couple months, what segment of this journey are you seeing the most proliferation of technology? Or maybe put another way, or second part of the question, what are you most excited about that’s coming to market that you’re starting to see some innovation around? John O’Connell: I think the most exciting thing that I’m seeing right now is really around the workflow capabilities and the integration capability. A lot of people are excited about this new integration capability called MCP, Model Context Protocols, which gives you the ability to link data in between systems. And that’s great, right? But at the end of the day, it’s all still built upon what’s exposed via the MCP. And just like people got really excited with APIs, Application Programming Interfaces, and they were like, “They have an API.” They might have an API, but if they only expose 10 fields and you need 30 of them, it doesn’t help you. Right? And I think what we’re finding is people are very excited about MCP technology, but it suffers some of the same challenges you see with APIs. Right? If you’re not exposing the data that I need, it’s not very helpful. Louis Diamond: Right. So I think to make it tangible, you’re talking about MCP being the cloud connectors. And Anthropic at Future Proof dropped the big news that they had now, MCPs with Schwab, with Black Diamond, with Addepar, et cetera. I think I heard that if Schwab is read only and it’s only certain data fields, then the applicability or the usefulness of this new platform is limited because the MCP isn’t as extensive as it could be. John O’Connell: Yeah, I’ll give you a really concrete example of that. Let’s say that you do tax-loss harvesting within your business, and the Schwab MCP does not have the tax law data. Useless to you. You can’t do tax-loss harvesting without the tax law data. So how is that useful to you? So I think what we’re seeing is this really great explosion in new tech and I thought the Anthropic announcement was really interesting. Again, as a buyer, dig under the covers of that. Right? Don’t be just enamored by the fact that they have an MCP connection to Schwab. That’s great. But if you use Schwab’s APIs, you can get, for example, all of that tax law data. You can get actually a lot more data from a direct Schwab integration than you can with any one of the wealth platforms today. Right? So that’s why you see large firms build like a data lake where they take Schwab data directly into the data lake, and then they machinate the data there because data that comes into the wealth platform tends to be a lot than what you can get from a Schwab integration directly. It’s like buyer be educated, so that you’re buying the right thing. It all really comes back to the requirements. If you’re doing tax-loss harvesting, you’ve got to ask the question, “Hey, does your integration include the tax law data that I need, so I can do effective harvesting?” If that’s a requirement, you’ve got to ask those questions. And then whether it’s an MCP connection or an API connection or a direct feed, you’re going to know where you can get the data that you need to be successful. Louis Diamond: Makes sense. Where do you see all this AI going from the vendor standpoint? Do you think it’s something where you see a bunch of vertical integration within wealth, like Orion has always been inquisitive, but Orion buys up seven different AI tools, integrates it into their own, and then all of a sudden you have five or six vendors, Salesforce, whoever, WealthBox, et cetera, start buying the ecosystem underneath them? Or do you think this 135 and growing kind of map of solutions will continue, and advisors and firm owners continue to be like, “There’s seven different note-taking apps, what do I pick?”? John O’Connell: Yeah. I think that you’re going to find a combination of both. Right? So look at Advisor360° bought Parrot AI, and now they’ve got Parrot completely integrated within their solution. Right? So you’ll see firms like that. Wealthbox built their own AI note-taker. So you’re seeing solutions like that. Right? You’re seeing, by the way, all the note-takers are now getting into workflow management, light CRM capability, or data discovery to try to really take over part of that prospecting and sales portion of the advisor workflow. So I think that you’re going to see a combination of all of those things. You’re going to see incumbent firms buying technology to get speed to market, which by the way, comes with integration challenges, data model challenges like you would with any acquisition. You’re going to see firms building their own solutions. Orion is investing pretty heavily in Denali at this point to build their own solution. Advyzon is invested pretty heavily in their AI solution. So I think you’re going to see a combination of all of it. Now, what does that mean for the AI map? The AI map’s not going to slow down. The number of firms that are reaching out to us, we probably have about four to five firms a week that reach out to us to get onto the AI map. We’ve got two folks on The Oasis Group team that focus on getting those people vetted and getting them on the map. I think that you’re going to see the map continue to grow exponentially over the next two years. I just don’t see that slowing down at all at this point. Now, what does that mean for the advisor? It means they’re going to have a lot of choice, but it does mean that they’re going to need to continue to become more of an educated buyer. The demos are always going to look great. In fact, with artificial intelligence, the demos look better than ever. So if you’re going to be a buyer that just goes in and looks at a demo, you’re probably going to buy technology and be unhappy with it after you get that implemented or during the implementation. You’ve just got to pump the brakes, really put together a set of requirements, and then figure out what’s the best solution for you because the demos are going to look fantastic. Don’t get enamored by the demo. Louis Diamond: Makes sense. Let’s talk a little bit about governance and data protection and privacy. Not the most fun element of this. It’s always the, what about safety, security, et cetera? You hit on some of this with the note-taker example. Right? If there’s blatantly wrong information, it’s not the AI note-taker that’s liable, it’s you as the advisor, the human in the loop. So I think that’s part of it, but what’s the quick way to think through what an AI policy should cover? But what are the key elements of it? I guess AI policy or governance for dummies. John O’Connell: You’ve got to be really specific about the tools that are allowed and not allowed to use. Right? So a great example is, if you’re on a $20 a month ChatGPT, you’re paying for it, but it’s a personal ChatGPT. And when you put information into that, OpenAI’s developers have access to that information. Right? Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: Whether they look at it or not. The reality of it is you’ve put your information out in the wild. We tell everyone you need to be on a Teams or an enterprise version of this software to have any of your personal information be safe. That being said, you can roll out this technology very effectively. A lot of people turn to me and they go, “John, we want to turn on Microsoft Copilot.” Microsoft Copilot runs within your Microsoft tenant. It sees everything that you can see anyway, your Microsoft Teams, your Outlook, your SharePoint. You have the same security vulnerability by using any of those technologies as you would with Microsoft Copilot because it all runs in the same tenant anyway. What we recommend to a lot of firms is, number one, be thoughtful about what you’re choosing. Right? If you’re running Microsoft, you’re already under the Microsoft umbrella. If you’re going to go outside to Anthropic or OpenAI or Gemini or Grok or any of those, you’re bringing a new player in, and that new player needs to be vetted. That’s number one. Number two, new models come out without warning and you have no ability to say, “I’m going to put that in production and not put it in production.” If you’re running repeatable prompts or if you’re moving into agentic AI, every time a new model comes out, you need to backtest those results against the old model. That means, let’s say, you’ve got a discovery process that you’ve put in play and your artificial intelligence does the discovery intake. It ranks everything. It goes through all your meeting notes and it fills out all the information you need to start building a financial plan. Right? Great use of artificial intelligence. You need to create a set of test data around that. And when a new model comes out, you need to retest it to make sure you’re getting the same results. Because like it or not, you’re using a piece of software, right? And it’s not when Orion rolls out a new product you can spend three months testing it before you put it in production. When they roll out a new model, it’s in production day one. So you’ve got to backtest that. You’re going to be held accountable for that by the regulators when they catch up. So those need to be in your acceptable use policy. And then, lastly, the third thing that I would say most people ignore, but you need to have it in there is you need an incident response plan that says, “Hey, someone pasted this into an unauthorized AI and ran it. What’s the exposure to the firm? And how do we deal with that exposure?” Because in the SEC world, you’re now operating under those regulatory requirements. And if you’re in the OCC world with the trust organization, you’ve been operating like that for a long time. So if you accidentally put something into an unapproved AI tool, you’ve got to be able to explain, you have to have an incident response plan, you’ve got to have a way to react to that. Beyond what we talked about earlier on these are acceptable tools, these are not, you need to really take into account, how do I test this stuff moving forward when a new model comes out? How do I create a test bed around that? How do I have an incident response plan? All these things need to be part of your AI strategy if you really want to be compliant. Louis Diamond: Yeah, I think too, there’s the compliance side, but there’s also the accountability side. I can imagine this probably happens three times a day in every firm. Someone does something in AI, they turn it over to their manager, to a client, et cetera. There’s something that’s just blatantly wrong. I would imagine there’s a lot of just, “Hey, it’s AI’s fault. It’s not mine.” But I think your point earlier is, no, it’s you as the human that is really over top of this. You, the firm, are liable, responsible, and culpable for whatever the AI says. I think that’s probably part of policies and procedures as well is, the human is the final sign off, not the robot. John O’Connell: And you’ve got to train them on it. I like to say to people, “If you’ve just rolled out Microsoft Copilot broadly to the organization, you’ve given them a chainsaw and you’re asking them to juggle it and hoping nothing bad happens.” Something bad’s going to happen. So you’ve got to train them on things like, “Hey, when I get a result, tell the artificial intelligence. ‘I want you to pressure test this result. I want you to find citations for all the numbers that you’ve given me in here. I want you to explain your logic path. How did you come up with this conclusion from the data that I gave you?’” Artificial intelligence is incredibly good at tattletaling on itself and saying, “Oh, I made that up.” But you’ve got to understand how to use the tool effectively by telling it, “Pressure test yourself. Give me a citation. Give me your logic path.” That’s skills that you get only through training, and then using it. And if you’ve never trained them on it, they don’t have those skills. So it’s not going to be surprising you get a bad result. Louis Diamond: Well said. Two more questions for you, John. John O’Connell: Yep. Louis Diamond: This is more of, we’ll say, the potential downside of AI. It’s amazing, it’s powerful, it makes you more efficient. But I would imagine, and I know you’ve talked about this before, the concept that a lot of what AI is doing now is kind of the entry level junior advisor, kind of entry level advisor type work. The meeting note-taking, follow-ups, reviewing data, et cetera. If AI is doing all of that, and so it’s only going to get better, are new entrants into the industry really at a loss because they’re not going to have exposure to the building blocks or the DNA of a firm of what it means to be an advisor? Or do you think it’s net neutral because, yeah, they might not have that, but if they have these tools already and they know how to use them, then what’s the difference? John O’Connell: I think we need to really rethink the way that we’ve got advisors coming into the organizations. Right? You’re absolutely right. People would start off with, “Oh, we’re going to have you being a junior person, then we’re going to cut your teeth on financial planning, then maybe we’ll cut your teeth a little bit on trading, and then you’re going to get your own book.” A lot of the firms that we’ve talked to, they’re like, “Hey, that program is anywhere between seven to nine years.” That’s a long time to be entering the industry, and then getting your own book, which is probably one of the reasons we see this big washout rate after five years, right? Because they’re like, “I’m another year or two from getting my book, I’m out of here.” So we’ve got to take those two data points, regardless of the technology for a moment, take those two data points to heart. Right? If your program’s seven years and the washout rate in the industry’s five years, you got a gap that you got to figure out how to close regardless of the technology. Now, throw the technology on top of that. Right? So we really need to rethink what do these apprenticeship programs, for lack of a better term, look like in firms? So come back to just that easy meeting notes taker that I mentioned before. Right? Are you the scribe or are you the observer? If you’re the observer, then what should happen after that meeting? Just like we used to do with junior salespeople when I had them coming up in my organizations, we would quiz you after the meeting, “Okay, what did you hear? What were the key things that you heard that would be buying signals? What were the key things that you heard that were blockers? How did I handle one of those blockers? What did you take away from that?” That’s where now you can take that same experience with the note-taker in place and have that junior person really observing the meeting, really observing, “The client said this and I doubled down on that.” The client said, “I feel like we just don’t have enough money to retire.” “Why do you feel that way? Let’s take a look at your plan. Where do we think we can adjust this?” Those are all signals that are building a further relationship with your client and getting to the root cause of their concern. That’s a diagnostic interviewing skill that every good advisor has, but they just have it innately. Right? Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: So how do you get your team member, your new team member, to understand that’s actually a skill? Louis Diamond: Yeah. It’s almost the role of a junior advisor, entry level advisor, it changes. Right? John O’Connell: Yep. Louis Diamond: It’s how good your handwriting is for meeting notes and how you do an outline versus a bullet point list. That was never the value add. The value add was getting the information, which now AI can do, but the real leg up is being more present in the meetings to really understand, like you said, blockers, the buying signals, et cetera. So it’s really a leveling up of these individuals. It’s not necessarily a threat, at least for firms that are handling it right. John O’Connell: It should definitely be a leveling up. And the firms that recognize that and are beginning to go after it now, they’re going to have stronger advisors at the end of it, right? Louis Diamond: Perfect. John O’Connell: Even think of things like body language. When you have a couple in front of you, and one says something, the other one makes a face, that’s something you should be doubling down on. Right? Or at least questioning in the meeting because, look, at some point, one of those two spouses could pass away, and the one that made the face is going to leave your firm. Louis Diamond: Yep. Well said. Last question for you. It’s not an AI interview without this type of question. So AI, very cool, very scary. It’s a confluence of emotions. As it comes to the future of human-led financial advice, the role of the financial advisor, do you look at AI as a threat, an opportunity, net neutral, what’s your read on it? John O’Connell: I think it’s a huge opportunity. And the reason I say that is, listen, if you’ve ever had… You know? I’m at an age now where I’ve had aging parents and I’ve had parents pass away. Right? No one is going to sit across the table for you and say, “Hey, mom or dad just got diagnosed with cancer and let’s talk about that.” AI is never going to do that. That’s a human. That’s you turning to your financial advisor in a time of turmoil and saying, “This is what just happened. Where do we go from here?” And that person calmly taking that information in, understanding that you’re another human being and I understand where you’re coming from, and then having a conversation with you about how we’re going to take care of your family or how we’re going to take care of your aging parent. AI is never going to do that. Now, can AI give me the information at my fingertips? So you just called me and I answered the phone, and you gave me this information. And I can quickly bring up your portfolio and I can quickly tell you how much cash you have available, maybe start making arrangements for someone. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: Yes, AI can give me that information much faster, right? But it’s never going to take away the empathy that I can bring to you as a human. So I think it’s a huge opportunity for advisors. It’s an opportunity for advisors to provide more financial advice to more people. We all know about this 130 rule, right? There’s only 130 families you can handle. I don’t believe that that’s true. I believe that, with technology, you can handle much more. So can I provide more advice to more people in need? Yes. Can I do that in a way that still provides that empathy and that human connection? Yes. So I think that it’s a huge opportunity both for the advisors and the consumer. There are so many Americans who could use financial advice, but don’t have access to it because of either minimums or because of just they don’t have the right relationships yet. Think of all that opportunity. We mint more millionaires in the United States than any country on the planet with the exception of the EU. So there’s more people that need financial advice every year. The advisor just needs to figure out how to leverage technology to provide that to people. Louis Diamond: I like that take that advisors can serve more. So if they can serve more, it translates to more growth, certainly more efficient firms. And I think it also probably creates a natural buffer that if the cost of financial advice goes down. So instead of typical fees, 100 bips, it goes to 70. A good advisor can weather that storm because now they can serve twice as many clients for the same price or cheaper. John O’Connell: Exactly. Louis Diamond: John, this has been really fun. I love talking about AI. I feel like it’s always changing. I always learn something new. But I really like the way you and your firm, you take the macro global view. You’re kind of like the referee of AI, and I absolutely see why you’re probably very busy today with all the technology decisions that firms have plus all the AI decisions. It’s like a whole different vocation that firms now have to tackle, but also an opportunity. John O’Connell: It is, and I love what we do. I just love it. Every day I’m excited to be at work and every day we get to help so many firms. I like to think of the end client really. Right? We’re helping these firms to really do a better job for these families, and these families need this advice. It’s a huge calling, and I love it. Louis Diamond: I can tell. Thanks so much, John. John O’Connell: Thank you very much. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously and are dedicated to your clients, but are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook . AI for Financial Advisors: An Expert’s Advice on How and Where to Start A conversation with Louis Diamond and John O’Connell, Founder and Chief Executive Officer of The Oasis Group. Louis Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is AI for Financial Advisors: An Expert’s Advice on How and Where to Start. It’s a conversation with John O’Connell, Founder and Chief Executive Officer of The Oasis Group. I’m Louis Diamond, and this is The Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education-driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning, data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Louis Diamond: AI is moving so quickly in wealth management. I think it’s easy for advisors and firms to approach it backwards. The path often goes like this. A new tool launches, a platform adds an AI capability, someone shows you a demo, looks incredible. A friend told you about this chatbot. And the natural reaction is, “How do we start using this in our business?” But maybe the better question is much simpler. What problem are we actually trying to solve? That’s one of the reasons I wanted to talk with John O’Connell, Founder and CEO of The Oasis Group. John and his team advise RIAs, broker-dealers, trust companies, and family offices on technology, data, and of course, AI. And while he comes from a technical background, he has a uniquely practical way of looking at it all. Consider this, The Oasis Group’s AI wealth tech map has grown from just 17 companies to 135 in about 18 months. And John mentions that over 500 firms have submitted applications to be on the map. So the challenge for advisors isn’t finding AI, it’s figuring out what they actually need, what works with their existing technology and data, and where AI can create meaningful value without introducing unnecessary risk. And John’s advice is refreshingly straightforward. Don’t try to boil the ocean, yet recognize there’s much more to AI than note-taking and summarizing content. AI’s real power comes from identifying the problems or bottlenecks you’re trying to solve, and never forget that you’re still the human in the loop. John and I get into some very practical examples of how firms can do that, plus how to prioritize AI initiatives, what advisors should understand about ACIs, MCPs, and data integrations, and why a great demo doesn’t necessarily mean you’re looking at the right technology and much more. Because with AI, changing this quickly, being an early adopter may actually matter. But being an educated buyer and an educated user may matter even more. So let’s get to it. John, thanks for joining us today. John O’Connell: Thank you very much for having me, Louis. Louis Diamond: Awesome. Let’s dive in. Give us some background here on your backstory and what led you to where you are now as the CEO of The Oasis Group. John O’Connell: Thanks. Yeah, so I actually started my career as a computer programmer, believe it or not. Computer science, mathematics background, started as a programmer at Merrill Lynch. From there, I got plucked out of there into KPMG, Peat Marwick, wound up being either a consumer of technology or a provider of technology for my whole career. I did a second tour of duty, if you will, at Merrill. I was there for the end of Merrill, unfortunately, the unpleasantness, as I like to call it. And then after that, I went to Oracle for a number of years running sales at Oracle and financial services. Then, I was in the C-suite of a couple of publicly traded companies. And then in 2019, I created The Oasis Group, and we focused pretty much exclusively in the wealth management space. Louis Diamond: Perfect. And what was it that led you to start your own company? Was there a need you saw in the market or what was the thesis? John O’Connell: I think it was primarily that I was just tired of having a board of directors or someone else who was driving the direction of the company. Believe it or not, in being in the C-suite of two publicly traded firms, what I picked up on pretty quickly was you can have the best intentions in your go-to-market strategy, but if the board decides they want to move in a different direction, they’re going to move in a different direction. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: That was really one of the impetuses for me creating the company. That and the fact that the wealth management space is really exciting. I’ve been in this space for a very long time. It’s a really exciting space to be in. Right? There’s always a ton of change going on in it. We’ve seen this explosion in new technology that has happened really in the wealth space. When I started the firm, it was still this big explosion of new tech that was hitting the marketplace. And I thought that we could really help a lot of firms in choosing technology and figuring out what to use it for and really create it as a force multiplier. Right? There’s so much out there, you could basically spend your whole life just buying tech, at least in the wealth space you can. So we really wanted to just help firms to figure out how to maximize that spend and how to make the right choices. Louis Diamond: That’s perfect. So in a nutshell, didn’t want to have bosses, wanted to be the one who was giving the advice, and really be able to act on the best ideas rather than having a well-thought-out plan stuffed by a board of directors, which I very much respect. And at its core, you’re a consultancy for wealth management firms exclusively, or who’s the target market? John O’Connell: So if you think of the pantheon of wealth management firms as 14 different market segments, we focus primarily on RIAs, trust organizations, broker-dealers, and then family offices. That’s our sweet spot where we do a lot of our work. And it’s not surprising, there’s different technologies for each one of those different segments, right? So it’s quite a bit to keep up to speed on. But when you take a look at those segments, they’re really handling the vast majority of the wealth that’s in the United States. So it plays to our strengths really well to be able to help with that space. Louis Diamond: Perfect. And what’s the typical engagement that your firm is tagged on? Is it helping firms build their tech stack for the first time? Is it retrofitting technology? Is it sorting through RFPs? What’s the typical? Or maybe there’s a couple parts to the answer. John O’Connell: Yeah, it runs the gamut of what you just mentioned. We’ve helped a lot of firms that have broken away, both from wirehouses or when a big M&A happens and they don’t necessarily want to go with the M&A. We’ve helped firms start up from a, “Hey, I was part of a wirehouse. Now, I want to start a completely new tech stack. What do I do?” So we’ve helped people stand that up. We’ve also helped a lot of firms that have been on technology for a long period of time, right? Maybe they’ve been on the tech for a long period of time, and their firm has changed over time. A lot of firms have grown really well or they’ve made small acquisitions. And now, they’ve got two CRMs, need one. How do I get there? So that’s part of what we do as well. We do a lot of work, quite frankly, in the aggregator space too. Right? Private equity has been very active in our space. There’s a lot of firms that are household names at this point in the wealth management space that are buying other firms. So we’ve helped them to be able to bring the technology together. When you think of the RFP side of things, that’s where our trust organization, we do a lot of work in the RFP side for trust organizations. Most RIAs don’t really RFP. For us in that space, it’s helping them to understand what are your real requirements? How do you focus on those? Don’t be enamored by the demo. Go in with a real set of requirements and say, “Show me this.” When you do that, you tend to get a much more accurate viewpoint of what the technology can or cannot do. But on the trust organization side, a lot of them are larger firms. They have more of a procurement organization. They’re more apt to do an RFP, and we help design RFPs, run those RFP processes. And then unlike a lot of the other management consulting firms, we actually do the implementations. Once the firm says, “Yep, this is the direction we want to go in,” we’ll help with everything from data movement, building the new workflows and the new software, helping them with their performance reporting after the fact, handling performance history, which is usually more challenging than you would think, as well as helping them get their training done and their integrations done between the systems. Louis Diamond: Very cool. The typical knock on management consulting or consulting in general is you get an elegant deck. Here’s your problem, here’s a recommended solution, and then things die on a vine because implementation struggles or fails. And I get with tech why it’s so important. It wouldn’t be a podcast in 2026 without asking about AI. I have to imagine technology, AI, wealth management, they’re all synonymous today. So what is it you’re seeing in the AI space? And maybe just that a more specific question, how do you address the gap between firms adopting AI, which is not a hard sell, but probably more importantly, being ready to really use AI? John O’Connell: Yeah, I’m pretty lucky. I think this year I’m going to speak at 24 different events on artificial intelligence and prediction markets. I talk a lot about prediction markets with folks as well. Where we see artificial intelligence… And by the way, when we say technology that we go-to-market with folks, that’s everything around wealth tech, AI, and data. That’s really our sweet spot, which you can imagine from a guy that spent eight half years at Oracle, data’s a big part of that. And really data is kind of like the rocket fuel for the rocket that is AI. Right? With really good data, you can get really great results. But to answer your question most directly, what we see today is a mixed bag. We see a lot of firms that turn on their artificial intelligence. For example, they’ll turn on Microsoft Copilot, and give it to their teams, and they’re expecting their team to just pick it up. And that’s not really what’s going to happen. Do you know what I mean? Without some training, it doesn’t really take. And you wind up finding some diamonds in the rough, people that are really good at it, that are starting to use it pretty extensively. And then for the most part, you’re not getting that real economy of scale that you want with an artificial intelligence implementation. So what we really recommend is, number one, put together an AI acceptable use policy. Put together some really good guardrails. And that’s not just your compliance team saying, “This is what we want you to do around PII.” That’s not going to cut it. You really need to explain to folks, “These are the use cases we want you to use AI. These are the use cases we don’t want you to use AI.” For example, if you’re an RIA and you’re really big on financial planning, you don’t want to use AI with financial planning because that’s your secret sauce. You may want to use it around investment research. Right? If you are one of the, like a family office that picks the best investments for your firm and that’s one of the things that you feel is a differentiator for you, you probably don’t want to use AI there. You probably want to use it for some other things. So really understanding these are use cases that are in balance, this is out of bounds. Here’s the tools we’re going to allow you to use, everything else is out of bounds. And then really sitting down with them and saying, “This is what our expectations are.” With artificial intelligence, with the regulators, and even with the risk management that you’ve got of being sued, quite frankly, as a fiduciary, you’ve got to understand you’re the human in the loop, you’re going to be held accountable. So you’ve got to build that process into your AI acceptable use policy as well, so that people understand if you’re using AI, it’s an accelerant to what you do. It’s not a replacement for your expertise. Louis Diamond: Exactly. John O’Connell: You need to be held accountable for that. And that’s where we find a lot of firms fall short. Louis Diamond: Yep. Well said. Our goal is to always make these episodes as tangible, and we’ll say instructional as possible. So someone listening can take this information, and then get started on something or really dive into the topic. So in the world of AI that’s moving so fast that it was especially relevant here, just ask you some questions to really dive a little bit more into the implementation weeds, if you will. John O’Connell: Sure. Louis Diamond: So how does an advisor think through where AI actually belongs in their business? Like you said, like the human in the loop part. And how do they use it without creating a bigger problem than the one they’re trying to solve? Because I’m guilty of the same thing. You see a cool new tool, it promises you the moon and the stars. Cool, I want to do it because I want to grow faster, I want to be more efficient. But to me, it’s not really a thoughtful approach. And again, I’m guilty of it too. So what’s the right way to think about how an advisor can deploy AI in their business? John O’Connell: I like to say pick a problem that’s really easy for you to solve, and don’t try to boil the ocean. A lot of folks turn to us and say, “I want to take all my CRM data, my financial planning data, and my custodian data, and bring all that together and drive insights across my firm.” And it’s like, “Okay.” Number one, is all of those data sources really clean? Can you bring all that together? Do you even know how to do that at this point? So I like to say pick a much smaller problem, right? Every practice that we’ve talked to, when you talk to them and you say, “Do you have an undocumented workflow that you’ve got? Do you have someplace that all the knowledge is in one person’s head?” And invariably, the answer is always a yes. Right? Okay, why don’t we use AI to solve that problem first? So to give you a great example. You can use artificial intelligence to interview that one expert you’ve got. So let’s say Sally’s the only one that knows how to open up a certain type of an account. Great. Use AI to interview Sally on how to open up that account, and Sally will tell AI, “This is how we do it.” Right? And we’ve actually given these kind of scripts out to people and say, “Okay, here’s 10 things you want to start the conversation with.” As Sally is interviewed by AI, which will be strange for Sally the first time around, what’s happening is AI is actually documenting that entire workflow. And then what you can do is you can say, “I want a document of this workflow and I want a visual representation of it,” maybe in Lucidchart. Guess what? Now what’s happened is you’ve reduced the flight risk of your firm. If Sally’s sick, you have it written down. Right? If Sally leaves, you have it written down. You’ve reduced the flight risk. You got something documented that’s critical to your business, and it’s a first, and there’s no PII involved in that. Right? Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: There’s no customer risk. And by the way, you’ve learned a lot about how to leverage artificial intelligence in your business. So pick the business process that’s not documented. Use artificial intelligence to document that business process. Number one, you’re going to get a great result because you’ve reduced the risk of your business. And number two, you’ve gotten your feet wet on how to use artificial intelligence. Try not to boil the ocean. Try to pick some really easy use cases. And by the way, remember, you are the human in the loop. You’ve got to validate the output of these things. So learn how to do that as a skill, how to validate this output by picking something that’s really small and easy. Louis Diamond: Yeah, it makes sense. John O’Connell: And if you can get that documented, you’re off to the races. Louis Diamond: Yeah. John O’Connell: Now, pick the next process. And you’re going to become very adept at using this technology very quickly. Louis Diamond: It seems like most firms, like the most common AI that firms are using are any of the various platforms for recording and transcribing client meetings. John O’Connell: Yep. Louis Diamond: And then, creating tasks and follow-ups, et cetera. Every firm is meeting with clients. No one likes taking notes. So do you think that’s just been a really good example with really good technology around it where advisors, instead of boiling the ocean, they go with kind of the low-hanging fruit. Would you agree? John O’Connell: I do. I agree with that. What I find really funny though is this. When you ask people, “So you’re using an AI note-taker?” “Yes.” “How many people do you still have in your meeting?” You’re like, “Two or three.” “Okay, then what are they doing?” I’ve been in sales for a very long time, right? In sales, you would know what everyone’s role is that’s in the meeting. Right? Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: You might have technical experts. When I was at Oracle, we were selling technology, you would have technical experts in there. You’d also have someone who was the observer that was watching the body language of your customer as you presented the solution to them, right? And you’d have a scribe, someone who would actually write that stuff down. The scribe goes away with the note-taker. So what are the other people doing in the meeting? Are they learning the craft? So do you have a junior person in the meeting that’s learning how you talk to the client? If that’s the case, they’re an observer, and they should be really soaking in the observations in that meeting. And then, they should be able to tell you what they found in that meeting. So the note-taker doesn’t make all that go away, right? So if you have an observer in your meeting, maybe you’re the advisor and you’ve got a junior person in your meeting, someone still has to review those meeting notes. Louis Diamond: Right. John O’Connell: To make sure that the facts of the meeting are captured, right? And not everything, by the way, should be written down. We’ve got advisors, for example. Advisors learn a lot of different things about their clients. A client may come in and say, “I think I’m going to get divorced.” That’s not something that should be written down in a meeting note and committed to your CRM. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: So who edits those meeting notes afterwards to make sure that what’s being committed to the CRM is accurate? That should be your observer. Louis Diamond: I like it. Kind of a similar question. How does a firm think through what’s going to create the most meaningful value for our advisors or for our clients? So I get that, basically, start off with undocumented processes, the low-hanging fruit, et cetera, but those aren’t necessarily the biggest value drivers for a firm. How should firms think about that? John O’Connell: I think firms should really consider what’s driving their business right now. Right? So a lot of firms, for example, work on referrals. That’s probably the number one lead source that we have in the industry at this point. So if that’s the case, then what you really want to do is you want to start mining some of that data. For example, how many referrals have I gotten from individual clients? Right? If I’ve got someone who consistently gives me referrals, maybe interview that person with an AI note-taker. Why do you give us referrals? What do you feel that we’re doing really well for you? What are we not doing really well for you? Right? Start getting a feel for what’s your sweet spot, or if you will, what’s the heat map that you’ve got around what’s resonating with some of these key clients? So if you are driving your business by referral and you want to be more found, let’s say, by AI search engines, interview your top clients that are providing referrals for you, use an AI note-taker when you’re doing that, ask the AI note-taker to summarize all those conversations together, not individually, together. Feed all those transcripts in and say, “I want you to generate an LLM text for my website with the key points that you find from this.” Louis Diamond: In other words, instead of you as the advisor or the marketing department guessing what your clients want, and especially the ones that are referring you, use your client’s direct words, right? Now you have a common theme. And really what you care about are attracting more of your ideal client. And ideally, they’re people that someone’s referring you. That’s a brilliant way to do it. John O’Connell: And if you use it as LLM text in your website, you have your web team do that. When an LLM searches your website, it looks for that LLM.text. And when it finds that LLM.text, it’s going to index that information. So you’re essentially broadcasting what your ideal client looks like out to the world. Louis Diamond: Very cool. What are you seeing as the fastest or most measurable ROI in the AI world today? We talked about note-taking as one. I would assume that’s probably one of the areas. Are there other areas where you’re seeing quick ROI or the best ROI for firms? John O’Connell: So larger firms, again, in some of the trust organizations we work with or some of the enterprise RIAs that we work with, what they’re doing is they’re putting a lot of the information that they would normally have embedded within, for example, their intranet or their SharePoint, and they’re indexing that using artificial intelligence. So imagine a small chatbot where you can say, “Hey, what’s vacation look like? What are the vacation days this year?” It cuts down significantly on the number of tickets that they get to their HR organization, to their IT organization. Louis Diamond: So in other words, more of like a ask me anything, but internal to your organization, not something that’s being deployed to clients. John O’Connell: Yeah, imagine like the next step of a Wikipedia. Do you know what I mean? What’s the next search capability you can do? So that’s driving a lot of ROI for people. And it’s usually, again, not PII related. Right? So it’s internal, but it can drive a lot of ROI around it. The second thing that we’re seeing where people are generating a lot of ROI is, unfortunately, around undocumented processes, like I had touched on earlier. The mid-size and the smaller firms have tons of these undocumented capabilities that are within their firm. So we are seeing a lot of people generate ROI around that, especially if they’re growing extensively. So I’m going to come back to the aggregator for a moment. In the aggregator model, having those processes well documented so that when you buy a new firm or have a new firm tuck in under you, you can quickly explain what these processes look like. That, we find a very, very significant ROI. It cuts down on the frustration of the new firm as they’re being acquired or they’re coming in because it’s just transparent. Look, here’s what the process looks like. Here’s a way that you can interact with this process really quickly. So it really cuts down on angst that can occur when a firm gets acquired. So we’re seeing a lot of that from an ROI perspective. Louis Diamond: Perfect. And going back to the point we’re talking about earlier with documenting requirements and being really clear on what it is you’re looking for a vendor, an AI vendor, to do for you. When a firm’s thinking through that list, the business requirements, if you will, and obviously if they’re working with you, it’s going to be super detailed and granular. But at a high level, what categories of items should be on this business requirements list so that when someone shows up to a meeting with a vendor, they can turn it over? Or once they still select a platform, they can turn it over to that vendor’s implementation team or to someone like you. John O’Connell: So some of that is going to be more specific to the problem statement that you’ve got, right? So for example, a lot of times when we work with firms, we dig pretty deep on trading and rebalancing, right? Or the way that they want their performance reporting to be set up, or their billing as a good example. So what I would recommend is, if you’re going to look for a new wealth platform for a moment. Right? Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: Let’s say you’re on an existing wealth platform, you’re coming up on the renewal of your wealth platform, and you want to at least see what’s out there, maybe not switch, but at least understand the capabilities. What I would do is, again, use artificial intelligence, but go through each portion of your organization. What does the operations team love and hate about the existing solution? What does your trading team love and hate about it? What does your billing team love and hate about it? Get a list of here’s the things that are going really well. Here’s the things that are super challenging for us. That’s going to be an initial, what we would call a MoSCoW list, the must-have, should-have, could-have, and won’t-have. Then, force rank them. These must be there for me to be successful. These should be there because they’re going to be better than my existing solution. These could be there. Maybe it makes one or two people’s lives easier, but it’s not like a must-have. And these are the things that won’t be there. In other words, today, I’ve got to jump through six hoops to get something to happen. I will not do that tomorrow. Right? So those are the things that you want to get down on paper. Once you have that, give it to the vendor before the demo and say, “Listen, here’s a list of our requirements. I know you’ve got a safe path demo that you want to show us. I’m not interested in that. I really want to see these requirements. And once you’ve got that, there’s nowhere to hide. If it’s seven or eight clicks to do what you can do today in two, it’s completely obvious when you see the demo. So that’s what I would recommend if you’re going to look at any new technology. And quite frankly, you have to be looking at things are changing so quickly, you really need to look at what’s out in the marketplace every time you come up with a vendor renewal. That’s not just me as a technology person saying that. You really do need to look at it. Whether you hire a firm like me or you don’t hire a firm like me, please do because you’re going to be in a better place. And you’re going to be a much more educated, if not buyer of new technology, certainly a much more educated consumer of the existing technology you have. Louis Diamond: I like that. And summarizing or paraphrasing, come up with, I liked what you said, the MoSCoW list by interviewing the key users, and then deliver that list to a vendor before the demo. I’ve sat through demos where it’s like, it sounds amazing on their website and they tell you all these amazing things. Then you get into the questions, “Hey, do you integrate with X, Y, Z? What about this?” And then, it all falls apart. John O’Connell: That’s right. Louis Diamond: And if it doesn’t work for everything you’re doing or most of what you’re doing, then what’s the point? So I like that. It also tests the firms because they can give the same demo a thousand times. So if you’re giving them something a little bit different, you really get to see how their platform or their tool works. Let me ask you a question here. As our role as consultants to advisors, we work with advisors who are sitting within a captive organization. So think like a UBS or Ed Jones or a Merrill. We also work with advisors who are independent in some capacity, whether they’re at an independent BD, they’re owning and operating their own RIA, they’re interested in starting their own RIA, et cetera. How do you square right now, if you had to guess, the two different, I guess, AI strategies that advisors are looking at? On the one hand it’s, “Hey, I’m at XYZ firm. I’m happy enough.” or, “I’m going to go to XYZ firm and really relying upon that firm’s technology team to implement AI and really trusting that this big firm or this firm is watching my back for AI so I don’t have to, and I’m going to use whatever they do.” Versus the more, say, independent or open architecture approach, which is, “I want to pick and choose my own AI,” or, “I want to be able to adopt my AI tools next week when they change.” Do you think one path is better than the other? And maybe just some comments on that because I’m seeing that as like the tug of war. I don’t have an opinion on who’s right and who’s wrong. I think they’re just different. But in essence, a big firm having the tech budget, the compliance, the data, et cetera unlock and keeping the advisor focused versus having complete autonomy to pick and choose the best AI as it changes so quickly. John O’Connell: I think that right now with any new technology innovation, the larger firms are usually slower to react. When they do react, it can be more impactful, right? But it could take a long time to get there. And keep in mind, I was at Merrill. Two times in my career I was at Merrill, right? So when you’re in a large firm, part of the challenge you run into is things are changing so quickly at the moment that you’re not going to be able to move as quickly as you would as an independent. It’s just not going to happen. There’s more impetus around it. It’s trying to change the direction of the Queen Mary. It takes a lot longer to turn the boat around. So I think, right now, independent firms have a significant advantage at the moment. And the reason I say that is, number one, they’re getting exposed to the technology faster and they have more of an ability to get their feet wet on it. It’s a skill. Using artificial intelligence is a skill, being able to prompt it to get the right results, understanding what kind of data you feed it really does affect the results that you get back from it. Bringing that skill takes time. You’re in Park City, you’re probably familiar with Warren Miller. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: He used to make all these ski films. He used to end every one of his movies with, “If you don’t hit the slopes this year, you’ll be a year older when you do.” Right? It’s the same thing with AI. If you don’t start now, you’re just going to be older when you start it, not age-wise, but you’ll be further behind, if you will, the independent firms that have already jumped into this and have started using it. I do feel that the larger firms are at slightly more of a disadvantage at the moment, and I don’t see that gap closing anytime soon. Now, look, you’ve got firms like Bank of America that created Erica, and I think Erica is a great product. I’ve seen it. I think it’s very impactful, but it’s nowhere near what I’m seeing some of the independent firms doing at the moment. They’re just moving significantly faster. Louis Diamond: Yeah. And it sounds like too, other than the speed to make decisions, which has always been the independent technology narrative. I think it’s even more relevant today. It’s also that if you’re an advisor who especially is going to be in this business for a while, if you’re the one who’s responsible or on top of building your own tech stack or being more involved with picking tools, you’re probably going to be better at using AI for the future. And you’re kicking the can down the road if you’re just going to throw up your hands and trust that your firm has got it and you’re just going to ebb and flow with whatever the firm makes available. John O’Connell: And there’s a bigger risk, right? Your clients are using this today. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: We’ve already had advisors that have come to us and said, “My client took the financial plan that I gave them and put them into AI and came back with 20 questions.” I’ve already had firms in the trust organization space that have come back to me and said, “One of the trusts that we did an RFP response to ranked our RFP against our competitors using artificial intelligence.” Or, “They took the trust documents that we had and came back with all these questions, take a look at this.” And we’ve looked at them and we’re like, “Yeah, that was generated by AI.” The technology is so prevalently available right now. This is not like tech where a large firm has had access to it before an independent or before a consumer. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: Any consumer can open up ChatGPT, take your financial plan, roll it in there. Now, we’ll put the security aspects aside for a moment on that, but they can open up literally any one of the four leading large language model products. Take what you’ve given them as output, run it through that product, and come back to you with questions. We even had one advisor that was questioned on the expense ratio. So this client had taken their holdings, put it through Google Finance, got the expense ratios. And came back and said, “Why am I in so many expensive things?” Louis Diamond: Very smart and savvy. John O’Connell: It’s very savvy on the consumer side, but these are questions that consumers are bringing up now to advisors. If you’re in a wirehouse and you’re not being exposed to these kind of questions, it’s only a matter of time before your client comes to you with that as well. And if you don’t have an answer for it, you’re going to look like an unarmed combatant in that conversation. Louis Diamond: It sounds like with your example too, that advisors should be prepared that, because of AI, their clients appear to be more educated or more informed than ever before. John O’Connell: That is correct. Louis Diamond: I always kind of chuckle. Advisors are so focused on the, “I can increase the manager fee from 16 bips to 18 bips.” I’m like, “I work with a financial advisor, I wouldn’t notice.” I feel like there’s a lot of things that a client just trusts their advisors to do. They don’t really question it. But now with AI, I mean, you can stress test and poke holes in anything that someone shares. It’s such an interesting dynamic. Everyone talks about the, oh, AI is going to take the job of an advisor. I think now we’re at the point where it’s like, no, AI is going to make advisors be better advisors and be more transparent. And clients are going to be more challenging to work with because they have more information than ever before. John O’Connell: Yeah. The old joke was you never wanted an engineer or a computer scientist to be your client, right? Louis Diamond: I’ve heard that too. John O’Connell: Because they would question everything. Now, I think that you’re going to see that your consumer is significantly more educated. And your next gen, by the way, is going to be light years ahead of your existing client base. So you’ve got to get on board and understand these technologies and how they work, because you’re going to come across as being an old school advisor, if you will. Right? Louis Diamond: Yeah. John O’Connell: And certainly, we all know the statistics on money movement challenges in our industry. They’re not going to get any better with the use of artificial intelligence. Louis Diamond: Yeah. When you say money movement, meaning when G1 passes away, G2 disproportionately chooses to not work with the incumbent advisor. John O’Connell: That’s correct, and that’s going to continue. I think that number is actually going to go up, believe it or not. Louis Diamond: Interesting. I think we found you because I’ve seen your AI wealth tech map. Can you talk a little bit about the work you did to create this AI wealth tech map? What does it do? What are the segments, or I guess segments of the map? How should people use it? John O’Connell: Yeah, it’s pretty interesting. When we first started the map, the first thing we said is we really wanted it to map a client journey. Right? It wasn’t going to be by a technology, some technology marker we gave it. So for example, we don’t have like a AI note-taker ability in the map. Right? We’ve got it as meeting management, because AI note-takers really should go beyond just taking notes in a meeting. They should be able to schedule a meeting and generate follow-ups and tasks. So it’s really more of a meeting management. So if you think of our AI map, it goes through a client journey. How do you prospect? How do you do discovery with a client? How do you manage meetings with a client? Where did you go with proposals? So it really follows that client journey. When we started the map, which was just about 18 months ago, there were 17 firms on it. The latest map has 135. We demo every one of those tools. So we’ve rejected, on our count at this point, about 30% of the firms that apply for the map get rejected. Louis Diamond: Right. And this is 135 discrete companies, or is it like XYZ company fits into nine different categories, so it’s on here nine times? John O’Connell: 135 individual companies. Louis Diamond: That’s crazy. Think about any AI tool. They’re going to have different modules, the pro, the premium, the free version. They can sign up for this or that. So really, the choices are even more abundant than 135. John O’Connell: Yeah. If you take a look at the number of permutations between licensing levels and their capabilities they’ve got, it’s more like 550 that fit the mark. It’s incredibly interesting, right? And these are new entrants. These are not, like, your incumbent CRM that added a note-taker to it. That’s not on the map at this point. These are net new firms that have entered the space. And because we’ve demoed all of them, we’ve rejected quite a few. Right? If you look at it and you say, like, if we couldn’t implement it as The Oasis Group, we’re like, “This is not ready for prime time.” Right? Because there is vaporware out there. There’s AI washing that we’ve seen where it’s like you’re really a workflow tool. You’re not an AI tool. You do workflow management, but there’s no AI really in this. So if you took those two letters away, your tool would do the exact same thing it does today. So it’s not an AI tool. So we’ve rejected firms like that as well. For better or for worse, there are more and more people with private equity coming into our space that feel that they can solve a lot of these challenges that advisors have. And that’s a great thing for advisors, right? But it’s also a daunting task because you get our map that has so many firms on it. How do you figure out which firm is going to serve you well? And that’s why we really broke it out by the client journey. Right? Someone doesn’t turn and say, “You know what? I need a new CRM today.” It’s more like, “Hey, these are things that are failing. My discovery process is disjointed. It’s not feeding from my prospecting capability into my onboarding capability.” You need to solve that problem. Is it a CRM that solves that problem? Some of them do. Is it a workflow tool that solves that problem? Some of them do. As the advisor, you’re not looking at it from a technology lens, you’re looking at it as, “Here’s my problem I got to solve. What tool can solve that problem?” So that’s why we approached the map the way we did. Louis Diamond: Makes sense. In the last couple of weeks, couple months, what segment of this journey are you seeing the most proliferation of technology? Or maybe put another way, or second part of the question, what are you most excited about that’s coming to market that you’re starting to see some innovation around? John O’Connell: I think the most exciting thing that I’m seeing right now is really around the workflow capabilities and the integration capability. A lot of people are excited about this new integration capability called MCP, Model Context Protocols, which gives you the ability to link data in between systems. And that’s great, right? But at the end of the day, it’s all still built upon what’s exposed via the MCP. And just like people got really excited with APIs, Application Programming Interfaces, and they were like, “They have an API.” They might have an API, but if they only expose 10 fields and you need 30 of them, it doesn’t help you. Right? And I think what we’re finding is people are very excited about MCP technology, but it suffers some of the same challenges you see with APIs. Right? If you’re not exposing the data that I need, it’s not very helpful. Louis Diamond: Right. So I think to make it tangible, you’re talking about MCP being the cloud connectors. And Anthropic at Future Proof dropped the big news that they had now, MCPs with Schwab, with Black Diamond, with Addepar, et cetera. I think I heard that if Schwab is read only and it’s only certain data fields, then the applicability or the usefulness of this new platform is limited because the MCP isn’t as extensive as it could be. John O’Connell: Yeah, I’ll give you a really concrete example of that. Let’s say that you do tax-loss harvesting within your business, and the Schwab MCP does not have the tax law data. Useless to you. You can’t do tax-loss harvesting without the tax law data. So how is that useful to you? So I think what we’re seeing is this really great explosion in new tech and I thought the Anthropic announcement was really interesting. Again, as a buyer, dig under the covers of that. Right? Don’t be just enamored by the fact that they have an MCP connection to Schwab. That’s great. But if you use Schwab’s APIs, you can get, for example, all of that tax law data. You can get actually a lot more data from a direct Schwab integration than you can with any one of the wealth platforms today. Right? So that’s why you see large firms build like a data lake where they take Schwab data directly into the data lake, and then they machinate the data there because data that comes into the wealth platform tends to be a lot than what you can get from a Schwab integration directly. It’s like buyer be educated, so that you’re buying the right thing. It all really comes back to the requirements. If you’re doing tax-loss harvesting, you’ve got to ask the question, “Hey, does your integration include the tax law data that I need, so I can do effective harvesting?” If that’s a requirement, you’ve got to ask those questions. And then whether it’s an MCP connection or an API connection or a direct feed, you’re going to know where you can get the data that you need to be successful. Louis Diamond: Makes sense. Where do you see all this AI going from the vendor standpoint? Do you think it’s something where you see a bunch of vertical integration within wealth, like Orion has always been inquisitive, but Orion buys up seven different AI tools, integrates it into their own, and then all of a sudden you have five or six vendors, Salesforce, whoever, WealthBox, et cetera, start buying the ecosystem underneath them? Or do you think this 135 and growing kind of map of solutions will continue, and advisors and firm owners continue to be like, “There’s seven different note-taking apps, what do I pick?”? John O’Connell: Yeah. I think that you’re going to find a combination of both. Right? So look at Advisor360° bought Parrot AI, and now they’ve got Parrot completely integrated within their solution. Right? So you’ll see firms like that. Wealthbox built their own AI note-taker. So you’re seeing solutions like that. Right? You’re seeing, by the way, all the note-takers are now getting into workflow management, light CRM capability, or data discovery to try to really take over part of that prospecting and sales portion of the advisor workflow. So I think that you’re going to see a combination of all of those things. You’re going to see incumbent firms buying technology to get speed to market, which by the way, comes with integration challenges, data model challenges like you would with any acquisition. You’re going to see firms building their own solutions. Orion is investing pretty heavily in Denali at this point to build their own solution. Advyzon is invested pretty heavily in their AI solution. So I think you’re going to see a combination of all of it. Now, what does that mean for the AI map? The AI map’s not going to slow down. The number of firms that are reaching out to us, we probably have about four to five firms a week that reach out to us to get onto the AI map. We’ve got two folks on The Oasis Group team that focus on getting those people vetted and getting them on the map. I think that you’re going to see the map continue to grow exponentially over the next two years. I just don’t see that slowing down at all at this point. Now, what does that mean for the advisor? It means they’re going to have a lot of choice, but it does mean that they’re going to need to continue to become more of an educated buyer. The demos are always going to look great. In fact, with artificial intelligence, the demos look better than ever. So if you’re going to be a buyer that just goes in and looks at a demo, you’re probably going to buy technology and be unhappy with it after you get that implemented or during the implementation. You’ve just got to pump the brakes, really put together a set of requirements, and then figure out what’s the best solution for you because the demos are going to look fantastic. Don’t get enamored by the demo. Louis Diamond: Makes sense. Let’s talk a little bit about governance and data protection and privacy. Not the most fun element of this. It’s always the, what about safety, security, et cetera? You hit on some of this with the note-taker example. Right? If there’s blatantly wrong information, it’s not the AI note-taker that’s liable, it’s you as the advisor, the human in the loop. So I think that’s part of it, but what’s the quick way to think through what an AI policy should cover? But what are the key elements of it? I guess AI policy or governance for dummies. John O’Connell: You’ve got to be really specific about the tools that are allowed and not allowed to use. Right? So a great example is, if you’re on a $20 a month ChatGPT, you’re paying for it, but it’s a personal ChatGPT. And when you put information into that, OpenAI’s developers have access to that information. Right? Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: Whether they look at it or not. The reality of it is you’ve put your information out in the wild. We tell everyone you need to be on a Teams or an enterprise version of this software to have any of your personal information be safe. That being said, you can roll out this technology very effectively. A lot of people turn to me and they go, “John, we want to turn on Microsoft Copilot.” Microsoft Copilot runs within your Microsoft tenant. It sees everything that you can see anyway, your Microsoft Teams, your Outlook, your SharePoint. You have the same security vulnerability by using any of those technologies as you would with Microsoft Copilot because it all runs in the same tenant anyway. What we recommend to a lot of firms is, number one, be thoughtful about what you’re choosing. Right? If you’re running Microsoft, you’re already under the Microsoft umbrella. If you’re going to go outside to Anthropic or OpenAI or Gemini or Grok or any of those, you’re bringing a new player in, and that new player needs to be vetted. That’s number one. Number two, new models come out without warning and you have no ability to say, “I’m going to put that in production and not put it in production.” If you’re running repeatable prompts or if you’re moving into agentic AI, every time a new model comes out, you need to backtest those results against the old model. That means, let’s say, you’ve got a discovery process that you’ve put in play and your artificial intelligence does the discovery intake. It ranks everything. It goes through all your meeting notes and it fills out all the information you need to start building a financial plan. Right? Great use of artificial intelligence. You need to create a set of test data around that. And when a new model comes out, you need to retest it to make sure you’re getting the same results. Because like it or not, you’re using a piece of software, right? And it’s not when Orion rolls out a new product you can spend three months testing it before you put it in production. When they roll out a new model, it’s in production day one. So you’ve got to backtest that. You’re going to be held accountable for that by the regulators when they catch up. So those need to be in your acceptable use policy. And then, lastly, the third thing that I would say most people ignore, but you need to have it in there is you need an incident response plan that says, “Hey, someone pasted this into an unauthorized AI and ran it. What’s the exposure to the firm? And how do we deal with that exposure?” Because in the SEC world, you’re now operating under those regulatory requirements. And if you’re in the OCC world with the trust organization, you’ve been operating like that for a long time. So if you accidentally put something into an unapproved AI tool, you’ve got to be able to explain, you have to have an incident response plan, you’ve got to have a way to react to that. Beyond what we talked about earlier on these are acceptable tools, these are not, you need to really take into account, how do I test this stuff moving forward when a new model comes out? How do I create a test bed around that? How do I have an incident response plan? All these things need to be part of your AI strategy if you really want to be compliant. Louis Diamond: Yeah, I think too, there’s the compliance side, but there’s also the accountability side. I can imagine this probably happens three times a day in every firm. Someone does something in AI, they turn it over to their manager, to a client, et cetera. There’s something that’s just blatantly wrong. I would imagine there’s a lot of just, “Hey, it’s AI’s fault. It’s not mine.” But I think your point earlier is, no, it’s you as the human that is really over top of this. You, the firm, are liable, responsible, and culpable for whatever the AI says. I think that’s probably part of policies and procedures as well is, the human is the final sign off, not the robot. John O’Connell: And you’ve got to train them on it. I like to say to people, “If you’ve just rolled out Microsoft Copilot broadly to the organization, you’ve given them a chainsaw and you’re asking them to juggle it and hoping nothing bad happens.” Something bad’s going to happen. So you’ve got to train them on things like, “Hey, when I get a result, tell the artificial intelligence. ‘I want you to pressure test this result. I want you to find citations for all the numbers that you’ve given me in here. I want you to explain your logic path. How did you come up with this conclusion from the data that I gave you?'” Artificial intelligence is incredibly good at tattletaling on itself and saying, “Oh, I made that up.” But you’ve got to understand how to use the tool effectively by telling it, “Pressure test yourself. Give me a citation. Give me your logic path.” That’s skills that you get only through training, and then using it. And if you’ve never trained them on it, they don’t have those skills. So it’s not going to be surprising you get a bad result. Louis Diamond: Well said. Two more questions for you, John. John O’Connell: Yep. Louis Diamond: This is more of, we’ll say, the potential downside of AI. It’s amazing, it’s powerful, it makes you more efficient. But I would imagine, and I know you’ve talked about this before, the concept that a lot of what AI is doing now is kind of the entry level junior advisor, kind of entry level advisor type work. The meeting note-taking, follow-ups, reviewing data, et cetera. If AI is doing all of that, and so it’s only going to get better, are new entrants into the industry really at a loss because they’re not going to have exposure to the building blocks or the DNA of a firm of what it means to be an advisor? Or do you think it’s net neutral because, yeah, they might not have that, but if they have these tools already and they know how to use them, then what’s the difference? John O’Connell: I think we need to really rethink the way that we’ve got advisors coming into the organizations. Right? You’re absolutely right. People would start off with, “Oh, we’re going to have you being a junior person, then we’re going to cut your teeth on financial planning, then maybe we’ll cut your teeth a little bit on trading, and then you’re going to get your own book.” A lot of the firms that we’ve talked to, they’re like, “Hey, that program is anywhere between seven to nine years.” That’s a long time to be entering the industry, and then getting your own book, which is probably one of the reasons we see this big washout rate after five years, right? Because they’re like, “I’m another year or two from getting my book, I’m out of here.” So we’ve got to take those two data points, regardless of the technology for a moment, take those two data points to heart. Right? If your program’s seven years and the washout rate in the industry’s five years, you got a gap that you got to figure out how to close regardless of the technology. Now, throw the technology on top of that. Right? So we really need to rethink what do these apprenticeship programs, for lack of a better term, look like in firms? So come back to just that easy meeting notes taker that I mentioned before. Right? Are you the scribe or are you the observer? If you’re the observer, then what should happen after that meeting? Just like we used to do with junior salespeople when I had them coming up in my organizations, we would quiz you after the meeting, “Okay, what did you hear? What were the key things that you heard that would be buying signals? What were the key things that you heard that were blockers? How did I handle one of those blockers? What did you take away from that?” That’s where now you can take that same experience with the note-taker in place and have that junior person really observing the meeting, really observing, “The client said this and I doubled down on that.” The client said, “I feel like we just don’t have enough money to retire.” “Why do you feel that way? Let’s take a look at your plan. Where do we think we can adjust this?” Those are all signals that are building a further relationship with your client and getting to the root cause of their concern. That’s a diagnostic interviewing skill that every good advisor has, but they just have it innately. Right? Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: So how do you get your team member, your new team member, to understand that’s actually a skill? Louis Diamond: Yeah. It’s almost the role of a junior advisor, entry level advisor, it changes. Right? John O’Connell: Yep. Louis Diamond: It’s how good your handwriting is for meeting notes and how you do an outline versus a bullet point list. That was never the value add. The value add was getting the information, which now AI can do, but the real leg up is being more present in the meetings to really understand, like you said, blockers, the buying signals, et cetera. So it’s really a leveling up of these individuals. It’s not necessarily a threat, at least for firms that are handling it right. John O’Connell: It should definitely be a leveling up. And the firms that recognize that and are beginning to go after it now, they’re going to have stronger advisors at the end of it, right? Louis Diamond: Perfect. John O’Connell: Even think of things like body language. When you have a couple in front of you, and one says something, the other one makes a face, that’s something you should be doubling down on. Right? Or at least questioning in the meeting because, look, at some point, one of those two spouses could pass away, and the one that made the face is going to leave your firm. Louis Diamond: Yep. Well said. Last question for you. It’s not an AI interview without this type of question. So AI, very cool, very scary. It’s a confluence of emotions. As it comes to the future of human-led financial advice, the role of the financial advisor, do you look at AI as a threat, an opportunity, net neutral, what’s your read on it? John O’Connell: I think it’s a huge opportunity. And the reason I say that is, listen, if you’ve ever had… You know? I’m at an age now where I’ve had aging parents and I’ve had parents pass away. Right? No one is going to sit across the table for you and say, “Hey, mom or dad just got diagnosed with cancer and let’s talk about that.” AI is never going to do that. That’s a human. That’s you turning to your financial advisor in a time of turmoil and saying, “This is what just happened. Where do we go from here?” And that person calmly taking that information in, understanding that you’re another human being and I understand where you’re coming from, and then having a conversation with you about how we’re going to take care of your family or how we’re going to take care of your aging parent. AI is never going to do that. Now, can AI give me the information at my fingertips? So you just called me and I answered the phone, and you gave me this information. And I can quickly bring up your portfolio and I can quickly tell you how much cash you have available, maybe start making arrangements for someone. Louis Diamond: Yep. John O’Connell: Yes, AI can give me that information much faster, right? But it’s never going to take away the empathy that I can bring to you as a human. So I think it’s a huge opportunity for advisors. It’s an opportunity for advisors to provide more financial advice to more people. We all know about this 130 rule, right? There’s only 130 families you can handle. I don’t believe that that’s true. I believe that, with technology, you can handle much more. So can I provide more advice to more people in need? Yes. Can I do that in a way that still provides that empathy and that human connection? Yes. So I think that it’s a huge opportunity both for the advisors and the consumer. There are so many Americans who could use financial advice, but don’t have access to it because of either minimums or because of just they don’t have the right relationships yet. Think of all that opportunity. We mint more millionaires in the United States than any country on the planet with the exception of the EU. So there’s more people that need financial advice every year. The advisor just needs to figure out how to leverage technology to provide that to people. Louis Diamond: I like that take that advisors can serve more. So if they can serve more, it translates to more growth, certainly more efficient firms. And I think it also probably creates a natural buffer that if the cost of financial advice goes down. So instead of typical fees, 100 bips, it goes to 70. A good advisor can weather that storm because now they can serve twice as many clients for the same price or cheaper. John O’Connell: Exactly. Louis Diamond: John, this has been really fun. I love talking about AI. I feel like it’s always changing. I always learn something new. But I really like the way you and your firm, you take the macro global view. You’re kind of like the referee of AI, and I absolutely see why you’re probably very busy today with all the technology decisions that firms have plus all the AI decisions. It’s like a whole different vocation that firms now have to tackle, but also an opportunity. John O’Connell: It is, and I love what we do. I just love it. Every day I’m excited to be at work and every day we get to help so many firms. I like to think of the end client really. Right? We’re helping these firms to really do a better job for these families, and these families need this advice. It’s a huge calling, and I love it. Louis Diamond: I can tell. Thanks so much, John. John O’Connell: Thank you very much. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously and are dedicated to your clients, but are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook .

October 22, 2026Episode 38249 min

Deep Research: How Smart Money Evaluates Wealth Management Firms

Steve Chubak, Managing Director at Wolfe Research What can advisors learn from the way institutional investors evaluate wealth management firms? Wolfe Research’s Steve Chubak offers a different lens on growth, recruiting, AI, pricing, M&A, and what separates stronger firms from the rest. In Summary Financial advisors and institutional investors often evaluate the same wealth management firms—but from very different vantage points. Advisors may be asking whether a firm offers the platform, technology, economics, and resources they need to serve clients and grow their businesses. Institutional investors are digging into another set of questions: Is that growth sustainable? What does it cost? How effectively is the firm deploying capital? And what could change its economics over time? Steve Chubak, Managing Director at Wolfe Research, spends his days studying those questions across the wealth management ecosystem. His research covers firms ranging from wirehouses and regional brokerages to custodians, broker dealers, and alternative asset managers. Here, Steve brings that institutional perspective to the issues that matter directly to advisors. He explains why investors increasingly distinguish between growth generated by recruiting and growth generated by existing advisors, how rising transition assistance is changing the economics of recruiting, and why organic growth remains one of the most important measures of a firm’s health. The discussion also explores AI’s potential impact on productivity, advisor fees, and firm pricing; the evolving economics of cash sweeps and platform fees; the Vanguard-Altruist transaction; consolidation across the industry; and why human advice may prove more resilient than some predictions suggest. The result is a different framework for evaluating the firms advisors work for, partner with, or may someday consider joining. The Storyline Steve occupies a unique seat in the wealth management industry. Rather than evaluating firms as an advisor, recruiter, or executive, he studies them on behalf of institutional investors. His team at Wolfe Research looks across the wealth management ecosystem and analyzes how individual firms are positioned, where growth is coming from, what it costs to generate that growth, and what risks could alter the outlook. That distinction drives the conversation. Jason initially asks what institutional investors may see that retail investors and advisors miss. But the discussion reveals something more useful: Both groups are trying to answer many of the same fundamental questions, just for different reasons. An investor may want to know whether a firm’s organic growth can support its stock price. An advisor considering that firm wants to know whether its platform, economics, technology, and strategy can support their business for years to come. The overlap leads into a deeper discussion of advisor movement and recruiting. Steve explains why investors increasingly care not just about net new assets, but about the cost of acquiring them. As transition packages have risen, the market has become more focused on the difference between “new store” growth generated through recruiting and “same store” growth generated by advisors already on the platform. From there, the conversation turns to AI—not simply as a technology story, but as a potential catalyst for broader changes in wealth management economics. Steve sees significant potential for AI to improve advisor productivity and platform efficiency while raising longer-term questions about pricing, cash monetization, and how firms get paid. This naturally connects to cash sweeps, platform fees, consolidation, M&A, and the competitive positions of some of the industry’s largest firms. Ultimately, Steve’s institutional lens offers advisors another way to evaluate a firm: Look beyond the recruiting package or headline growth number and ask whether the business underneath it is durable. Topics Covered How institutional investors evaluate wealth management firms What advisors and institutional investors may learn from one another Why advisor movement matters to investors Organic growth, net new assets, and the cost of asset acquisition “Same store” versus recruiting-driven growth Rising transition assistance and recruiting economics AI’s impact on advisor productivity and platform efficiency Potential long-term pressure on advisor fees and pricing Cash sweeps, cash monetization, and platform fees Why transparent pricing could better align firms, advisors, and clients The Vanguard-Altruist transaction and the RIA custody landscape The competitive positions of Morgan Stanley, LPL, and Schwab Private equity-backed wealth management firms and leverage How firms should balance recruiting growth with capital discipline Why human financial advice may remain resilient in an AI-driven world The KPIs Steve uses to evaluate wealth management businesses Data ownership, AI, and the potential case for self-clearing M&A, industry consolidation, and why strategic buyers may have to “buy it twice” > Download a transcript of this episode… Listen and Learn Highlights for Advisors How the institutional view differs from the advisor view — 08:05 Steve explains why institutional investors tend to go much deeper on individual companies, competitive positioning, and the “game theory” behind industry change, while advisors often take a broader, relationship-driven view. Why advisor movement matters to Wall Street — 11:28 Jason connects Steve’s research directly to the questions advisors ask when evaluating firms. Steve explains why organic growth, net new assets, and the cost of recruiting advisors receive significant attention from institutional investors. Why all growth isn’t created equal — 13:38 As recruiting packages have increased, investors have become more discerning about the quality and cost of growth. Steve explains why growth generated by existing advisors can sometimes be more attractive than growth purchased through recruiting. AI: Productivity opportunity or pricing threat? — 16:09 Steve describes himself as moderately bullish on AI, particularly because of its potential to improve advisor productivity and platform efficiency, while acknowledging longer-term questions around monetization and pricing. Rethinking cash sweeps and platform fees — 17:55 Steve breaks down how firms monetize client cash and makes the case for a more transparent pricing structure that could better align the economics of clients, advisors, and firms. What Vanguard-Altruist could mean for RIA custody — 23:53 Steve puts the transaction into perspective and discusses Altruist’s potential to move upmarket, while explaining why Schwab’s breadth, scale, technology, and product offering remain formidable competitive advantages. Which firms could keep gaining share? — 26:54 The discussion turns to Morgan Stanley, LPL, and Schwab and why Steve believes each could continue consolidating share within its respective channel. The economics behind increasingly large recruiting deals — 30:48 Jason and Steve debate how much firms should spend to recruit advisors, the importance of capital discipline, and whether maximizing recruiting growth is always worth the cost. Will AI force advisors to lower their fees? — 35:43 Steve sees potential for some pricing pressure but explains why advisory fees have historically demonstrated greater resilience—and why increasingly sophisticated advice may help preserve that value. Why the last 20% of advice may matter most — 38:50 Using his own experience trying to replace a lawyer with an LLM, Steve explains why technology can get surprisingly far while still leaving a critical gap where human expertise, judgment, and reassurance matter. The KPIs that reveal the health of a wealth management firm — 40:51 Steve shares the metrics he looks at first, including organic growth and operating leverage, and explains why unusually low expense growth can sometimes signal underinvestment rather than strength. What could drive the next wave of industry change — 42:18 Data ownership, AI, self-clearing, M&A, and consolidation come together as Steve considers what firms may need to control – and invest in – to remain competitive. Key Takeaways Look beyond headline growth. Recruiting success and strong net new asset numbers can be impressive, but Steve’s institutional framework asks a second question: What did that growth cost? As transition assistance has increased, investors have become more focused on the quality of growth—not simply its quantity. For advisors evaluating a firm, that same question can reveal whether its strategy appears sustainable. Organic growth may tell you more about a platform than recruiting alone. A firm that helps its existing advisors grow can demonstrate something important about the strength of its platform, technology, service, and capabilities. Steve describes organic growth as one of the first metrics he examines when evaluating a wealth management business. AI’s biggest impact may come through its knock-on effects. The immediate opportunity is productivity. The longer-term questions involve pricing, cash monetization, platform fees, data ownership, and competitive positioning. Rather than viewing AI as a standalone technology issue, Steve considers the “game theory” around how one change could force responses across the industry. Firm economics matter to advisors—even if they never plan to become investors. A firm’s capital allocation, growth strategy, recruiting costs, technology investment, and revenue model can ultimately affect the advisors who work there. For an advisor evaluating a potential firm, model, or equity partner, understanding the health of the underlying business can add another dimension to the decision. Human advice still has a powerful value proposition. Steve points to the limited adoption of robo advice relative to early predictions as one reason not to assume technology will eliminate demand for advisors. His own experience using an LLM for legal work illustrates the point: Technology may handle much of the task, but the remaining portion can involve exactly the complexity, judgment, and confidence for which clients value a professional. https://youtu.be/ps_8bq2CE9E Quotable Moments On the difference between institutional and wealth management perspectives: “There are times when [institutional investors] are myopically focused on the numbers.” On what institutional investors increasingly want from growth: “Good NNA profile, but not necessarily overpaying for that growth.” On AI and the wealth management industry: “From an advisor productivity standpoint and from a platform efficiency standpoint, I think that AI is a huge boon or windfall for the industry.” On creating better alignment: “My preference has always been for more transparency and more alignment of incentives.” On the continuing value of human advice: “People do value advice, human intervention.” On technology getting most—but not all—of the way there: “I got about 75 to 80% of the way there. And that last 20%, I was incredibly uncomfortable.” On evaluating a wealth management business: “Organic growth first and foremost.” On M&A involving advisor businesses: “You have to buy it twice.” FAQs What do institutional investors look for when evaluating wealth management firms? Steve identifies organic growth as one of the most important indicators, along with operating leverage and the balance between investing for future growth and delivering earnings today. Investors also examine net new assets, the cost of acquiring those assets, recruiting economics, technology investment, and the durability of a firm’s business model. Why does advisor recruiting matter to institutional investors? Advisor movement can materially affect organic growth and net new assets. But investors increasingly look beyond how many advisors a firm recruits to consider how much it spends to acquire that growth and whether those economics can produce attractive long-term returns. What is the difference between “same store” and “new store” growth in wealth management? In the context of this discussion, “same store” refers to growth generated by advisors already on a firm’s platform, while “new store” growth comes from newly recruited advisors and their assets. As recruiting costs have risen, Steve says investors have placed greater value on strong same-store growth because it can represent a less expensive source of net new assets. How could AI affect financial advisor fees? Steve expects AI to improve advisor productivity and firm efficiency but believes it could create some longer-term pricing pressure. He notes, however, that advisory fees have historically proved more resilient than pricing in areas such as asset management and brokerage, particularly where clients value complexity, judgment, and human advice. Could AI replace financial advisors? Steve does not see technology eliminating the value of human financial advice, particularly for clients with complex tax, trust, investment, and planning needs. He points to the experience of robo advisors as evidence that predictions of widespread replacement of human advice have not played out as many originally expected. What are cash sweeps, and why do they matter? Cash sweeps allow firms to earn revenue from idle client cash held on their platforms. Steve argues that this can create a less transparent exchange of value and suggests the industry could gradually move toward more transparent platform fees paired with more competitive rates on client cash. Will platform fees cause advisors to change firms? Based on Wolfe Research’s analysis of firms that have introduced platform fees, Steve says they did not find tangible evidence of significant disruption to advisor recruiting or organic growth. His view is that advisors may be more focused on the quality of a firm’s technology, service, and overall platform than on a modest platform fee. What makes a wealth management firm attractive from an institutional perspective? Strong organic growth, disciplined spending, effective technology investment, attractive economics, and a sustainable competitive position all matter. Steve also emphasizes the importance of balancing growth with free cash flow rather than pursuing growth at any cost. How could consolidation reshape wealth management? Steve expects scale players to continue gaining share across different channels and discusses Morgan Stanley, LPL, and Schwab as firms with significant competitive advantages in their respective markets. He also sees potential for further M&A, although strategic acquisitions can be complicated by the need not only to acquire a business but also to retain its advisors. What should financial advisors consider when evaluating a firm or equity partner? Beyond payout, recruiting packages, and platform capabilities, advisors can benefit from examining the durability of the underlying business. Organic growth, capital discipline, technology investment, competitive positioning, ownership structure, and the firm’s ability to adapt its revenue model can all offer clues about whether the organization is positioned for the future. Steve identifies organic growth as one of the most important indicators, along with operating leverage and the balance between investing for future growth and delivering earnings today. Investors also examine net new assets, the cost of acquiring those assets, recruiting economics, technology investment, and the durability of a firm’s business model. Advisor movement can materially affect organic growth and net new assets. But investors increasingly look beyond how many advisors a firm recruits to consider how much it spends to acquire that growth and whether those economics can produce attractive long-term returns. In the context of this discussion, “same store” refers to growth generated by advisors already on a firm’s platform, while “new store” growth comes from newly recruited advisors and their assets. As recruiting costs have risen, Steve says investors have placed greater value on strong same-store growth because it can represent a less expensive source of net new assets. Steve expects AI to improve advisor productivity and firm efficiency but believes it could create some longer-term pricing pressure. He notes, however, that advisory fees have historically proved more resilient than pricing in areas such as asset management and brokerage, particularly where clients value complexity, judgment, and human advice. Steve does not see technology eliminating the value of human financial advice, particularly for clients with complex tax, trust, investment, and planning needs. He points to the experience of robo advisors as evidence that predictions of widespread replacement of human advice have not played out as many originally expected. Cash sweeps allow firms to earn revenue from idle client cash held on their platforms. Steve argues that this can create a less transparent exchange of value and suggests the industry could gradually move toward more transparent platform fees paired with more competitive rates on client cash. Based on Wolfe Research’s analysis of firms that have introduced platform fees, Steve says they did not find tangible evidence of significant disruption to advisor recruiting or organic growth. His view is that advisors may be more focused on the quality of a firm’s technology, service, and overall platform than on a modest platform fee. Strong organic growth, disciplined spending, effective technology investment, attractive economics, and a sustainable competitive position all matter. Steve also emphasizes the importance of balancing growth with free cash flow rather than pursuing growth at any cost. Steve expects scale players to continue gaining share across different channels and discusses Morgan Stanley, LPL, and Schwab as firms with significant competitive advantages in their respective markets. He also sees potential for further M&A, although strategic acquisitions can be complicated by the need not only to acquire a business but also to retain its advisors. Beyond payout, recruiting packages, and platform capabilities, advisors can benefit from examining the durability of the underlying business. Organic growth, capital discipline, technology investment, competitive positioning, ownership structure, and the firm’s ability to adapt its revenue model can all offer clues about whether the organization is positioned for the future. Related Resources The Wirehouse Talent Battle: Winners, Losers and What’s Changing Conducting a Strategic Due Diligence Process: 10 Practical Tips for Financial Advisors Steven Chubak, CFA Steven Chubak joined Wolfe Research in September 2018 as a Director and Senior Analyst covering Brokers, Asset Managers & Exchanges. Steven has been recognized as a top three analyst by the Extel All-America Research poll in 2021-2025. Steven previously worked as Senior Equity Research analyst for five years at Nomura Instinet. In 2014 and 2015, he was recognized by Extel as a “Rising Star” for his work in both the Large Cap Bank and Broker/Asset Manager categories. Prior to joining Nomura Instinet, Steven was a partner at Autonomous Research, and before that as an associate analyst at Bank of America and JMP Group. Before embarking on a career in sell-side equity research, he was an associate for the Global Growth team at Alliance Bernstein, and a Structured Products analyst at HSBC. Steven graduated from the NYU Stern School of Business with a degree in Finance/International Business and is a CFA® charterholder. NOTE: The views and opinions expressed by the guests on this podcast are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Diamond Consultants. Neither Diamond Consultants nor the guests on this podcast are compensated in any way for their participation. View the transcript of this episode… Deep Research: How Smart Money Evaluates Wealth Management Firms A conversation with Jason Diamond and Steve Chubak, Managing Director at Wolfe Research. Jason Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is Deep Research: How Smart Money Evaluates Wealth Management Firms. It’s a conversation with Steve Chubak, managing director at Wolfe Research. I’m Jason Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help lead advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Jason Diamond: Financial advisors have plenty of reasons to take a closer look at the wealth management landscape. They may be considering a change of firms or models, evaluating an equity partner, or simply trying to understand whether their current firm is positioned for the future. And when they do, they tend to look at it through a very specific lens. What will this platform allow me to do for my clients? How will it support my business? And does it give me what I need to grow? Institutional investors look at many of those same firms through a very different lens. My guest today, Steve Chubak, is a managing director at Wolfe Research, where he and his team cover the wealth management ecosystem, from wirehouses and regional firms to custodians, broker dealers, and alternative asset managers. His job is to understand not just how these businesses are performing today, but what their performance metrics and key data points tell us about where they may be headed. And that’s where I think this conversation gets especially relevant for advisors, because whether you’re analyzing a company as an investment or evaluating it as a place to build your business, many of the underlying questions are surprisingly similar. Is the growth durable? What is the firm spending to generate it? How effectively is it investing in technology? And what could disrupt its economics over time? Steve offers an institutional perspective on all of it, including why organic growth may tell us more than headline recruiting numbers, what AI could mean for advisor productivity and fees, the changing economics of cash, and how M&A and consolidation could reshape the competitive landscape. It’s a different way to look at the firms advisors work for, partner with, and consider joining, and at what may ultimately separate the strongest wealth management businesses from the rest. So let’s do it. Steve, thanks so much for joining us. Thrilled to have you here. Steve Chubak: No, it’s great to be here. Really appreciate the opportunity to participate. It goes without saying, longtime fan of the podcast, so nice to finally be on. Jason Diamond: Longtime listener, first-time caller, let’s get going. Before we talk about the business side of things, I want to talk about your background, a little bit of a different flavor of guests for us. So tell us what brought you to the world of research, to the world of wealth management. How’d you end up here? Steve Chubak: Yeah, sure. So I graduated from NYU Stern in undergrad. Most of the folks in my class either went into investment banking or markets. In fact, very few went into research. I myself embraced at least the trading side, but realized over time, I actually had a real passion for doing fundamental analysis on stocks. And I realized this passion in 2008, mind you, where there weren’t a ton of job opportunities at the time as I was making that career pivot. But the beauty of the research side is I get to really engage with some of the smartest investors on the planet day-to-day, unpacking really challenging topics. And specific to the wealth management space, I think what’s really unique about the franchise that we’ve built there is most of my competitors might cover a sleeve of companies within the wealth spectrum. We actually cover the whole ecosystem. So we’re one of the few teams and maybe the only team that covers the wirehouses, the regional brokers, the trading shops like IBKR and Schwab, as well as some of the alternative asset managers. So whether it’s the product side or whether it’s the firms that are providing the platforms, we can cover the whole ecosystem. And it’s just an incredibly dynamic space with TAMs that have really powerful structural growth tailwinds. So never a dull moment. Even today, we’re seeing a selloff in the space around some of the concerns around the Meta Muse launch. And look, it always keeps us on our toes. It always keeps us busy and engaged. Jason Diamond: Absolutely. So there’s a lot to unpack there. I want to just take a baby step back and do the five-year-old version of this. Fair to say, your company covers single stocks from a research perspective. Do you also do anything on the industry as a whole, macro, more broad, just so we know what we’re focusing on today? Steve Chubak: Yeah, sure. Because we’ve spent so much time really unpacking all the trends that are really influencing the wealth space today, we do spend a lot of time publishing deep dive industry reports on the wealth names. We’ll do it when we have the opportunities to engage with management. So we did that recently with LPL and Schwab, but we also host a wealth symposium every year and publish a wealth management primer alongside that. It leverages a lot of industry data. Frankly, it leverages some of the pieces that even you guys have published in the past, but really, just trying to analyze the whole ecosystem to take a more holistic view on what some of the growth opportunities are, but also some of the emerging risks that are impacting the space. Jason Diamond: No doubt. With all that said, I think your lens, at least as I see it, is a little different than our typical advisor. Are you spending your day interfacing with these companies, meaning talking to management of LPL, of Raymond James, of Schwab, and trying to get the picture of what’s working, what’s not working? What does the role involve in real words? Steve Chubak: I would say that engaging with the management teams probably composes about 20% of our day, if that. Most of our engagement is in fact with institutional investors that are looking to invest in the space. So someone that is interested in Morgan Stanley but wants to understand the workplace offering, and we’ll schedule a 30 to 45-minute call. We’ll unpack some of our prior research. They’ll ask for certain custom requests, so we can try and extrapolate what the growth is going to look like for that particular segment. And you can really apply that to any of the companies in the wealth space. So it’s always dynamic. From a bottom-up perspective, each of these companies are quite different. They operate in different channels. There’s no shortage of topics to unpack, but I’d say most of the engagement that we do and most of our time is really spent on the research product and engagement with institutional investors. We do speak regularly with the companies, but that’s probably about 10 to maybe 20% of our day. Jason Diamond: That’s what strikes me in talking to you is you take a institutional lens to a pretty retail environment, meaning the business itself skews certainly retail. What is it that surprises you? Let’s start with something maybe not spicy, but a little bit out of the gates with some punch to it. When you talk to institutional investors and then obviously, you spend your day in the world of retail, what surprises you most about that kind of juxtaposition? Steve Chubak: I think the biggest surprise to me is just the level of detail orientation that we get from our institutional investors. The expectation is if we’re going to cover 35 to 40 names, we are going to know these names inside and out. We’re going to have deep familiarity with the history. We’re going to understand the game theory in terms of how the landscape is going to evolve. And certainly when you have these dynamic themes like agentic AI that are getting introduced or injected into the space, that’s sparking quite a bit of controversy and debate, but the expectation is we have to unpack that game theory. We have to understand how each company is competitively positioned. And in that regard, we are going quite a bit deeper. I would say what’s similar to wealth management is that it’s not so much, even though there’s a strong relationship component that exists for both, I would say that on the wealth management side, you’re taking a much more holistic view of your client, of your customer, where it’s not simply trying to get the portfolio asset allocation right. It’s also about understanding the family needs, how can you optimize from a tax standpoint, what are the lending products that you can offer, so I’d say the service that’s being offered is much broader, whereas for the institutional investors, I think the expectation is narrower focus, but we’re going to go much deeper. Jason Diamond: Yeah, that makes a lot of sense to me. I guess what I’m kind of getting at is, do you feel like the retail audience misses something that you see that your institutional audience just gravitates towards? Is there something, or maybe it’s the other way around? Maybe it’s the institutional guys could learn from the retail guys. I don’t mean to lead the witness, but I think you have this unique seat where you straddle both worlds. Steve Chubak: It’s a great question, and I’d say that it’s probably applicable to both. There’s certainly some elements I’d say institutional investors do underappreciate because they’re so deep in the numbers. There are times when they are myopically focused on the numbers. And the reality is too, when there’s periods of uncertainty, and I know we’ll talk about this in a moment, what the implications are for AI on pricing, on cash monetization, in many of those instances, institutional investors will simply capitulate and say, “There’s too much uncertainty. I can’t be involved.” And obviously, on the wealth side, it tends to be quite different where they can appreciate the strength of the relationships. When I engage with a lot of advisors, they talk about leveraging AI in a really constructive and productive way that’s franchise enhancing. I’d say from an institutional investor standpoint, they tend to take a little bit more of a glass half empty view at times. And because of that, you’ll have periods where there’s heightened uncertainty and you’ll see significant retrenchment or disengagement on the part of some of the institutional investors. Jason Diamond: I’m struck by as you’re speaking, your work is similar to ours in some sense in that you’re breaking down 30 to 40 companies into the big wealth management names for the purposes of an institutional investor audience. And I guess my question was framed through how does an institutional investor audience compare to a retail investment audience? The reality is we interface with advisors who think about these same questions you do, but through the lens of what firm do I want to work with? So meaning I need to understand what does the future of Raymond James look like, how does Morgan Stanley’s business model going to evolve, how is AI going to impact LPL’s pricing because I’m making a decision about where to move my book of business. Do you guys have an interest in advisor movement, I guess is my first question? Is that something that institutional investors are keen on? Steve Chubak: Very much so, and I feel like that’s actually one of the products that we publish that has among the strongest, if not the strongest, following amongst a lot of our institutional clients because the reality is what dictates the stock price performance for a lot of the wealth managers is in fact organic growth, I would say, first and foremost. And because of that, there tends to be a really significant focus on not just net new asset growth, but also the cost of that asset acquisition. So no one is a bigger expert, at least in areas like transition assistance than you, Jason. So typically, we’re leaning on experts like yourselves, but to get some insight into the TA dynamics, how it’s impacting the returns for the assets that are being acquired or new business that’s being underwritten. And because of that, there tends to be a greater scrutiny amongst the institutional investors increasingly, not just of who has the strongest M&A profile, but who actually has the highest quality M&A profile given that the cost of asset acquisition and advisor recruitment has gone up pretty dramatically in recent years. Jason Diamond: So meaning, and sorry for dumbing this down into second grade mode, meaning if a firm was having a ton of success recruiting, but they were paying 2,000% transition deals, the institutional audience would look at that and say the cost of your net new assets is just not in line with. Is that kind of what you’re getting at? Steve Chubak: That’s exactly right. And it’s funny too because if I think back 5 to 10 years ago, there was a strong investor contingent, and I’d say even the majority of investors who believe that new advisor growth or new store growth, so to speak, was actually higher quality than same store because the cost to recruit wasn’t that high. And at the same time, the investor perception was if you can recruit new advisors to your platform, that means that you run a great platform from a service standpoint, from a technology standpoint. Whereas today, same store unquestionably, just given the heightened scrutiny and focus on transition assistance is certainly perceived to be higher quality. So there are a number of firms that may not be growing their advisor base as much as some of their peers, but the reality is the same store sales growth is so much more powerful that’s translating into better M&A and it’s a cheaper cost of asset acquisition. So that’s, to me, really the efficient frontier that a lot of investors today are solving for is good M&A profile, but not necessarily overpaying for that growth. Jason Diamond: So I assume that’s like the comments we saw at a Morgan Stanley over the weekend or whatever, it was a week ago, basically saying, “Our advisors grow like crazy. We will still recruit effectively, but maybe not as robustly and holistically, but take our swings when…” Is that sort of the ethos here that you think a lot of firms will start to adapt? Steve Chubak: That’s exactly right. And I think it also speaks to the fact that if you look at Morgan Stanley’s net new asset growth and you benchmark it relative to a broader universe of players, including some of the RIAs and independent broker dealers, what we’ve seen is Morgan Stanley’s M&A is best in class and despite the fact that they haven’t added as many advisors, and that really speaks to, frankly, the strength of the workplace funnel. Jason Diamond: The funnel, agreed. I would’ve thought what you started with, which is that a firm that can recruit well has a solid enough platform that they can probably retain advisors. I agree there are some exceptions to that on both sides, firms that do a really good job of recruiting, but they also have people leaving out the back door, and then the flip side is certainly also true. I think we have to talk about AI here. I was going to bury it for a little bit later, but you brought it up, and I think it’s too tied in to this topic. Let’s just start at the top. Overall, with the advent of AI agentic tools, the news you see every single day, you are A, more bullish on the industry than you were a year ago, B, more bearish, C, neutral? Steve Chubak: I’d say I’m moderately bullish. I have to give a nuanced response here in that I know like any typical sell side would where he’s going to have to hedge his bets and throw in a bunch of caveats. But kidding aside, from a advisor productivity standpoint and from a platform efficiency standpoint, I think that AI is a huge boon or windfall for the industry. The one area where we’re more cautious is really around monetization and pricing. And to be clear, this is not a risk that I view as imminent, but over the next 5, 10, 15 years as these tools grow more sophisticated, as it’s easier to optimize some of your idle cash, as it’s easier to at least attract or source services from a wealth standpoint. They’re being offered more cheaply by a fintech provider or some other competitive threat. It’s really that monetization piece that I’m a bit more cautious on, which is why I do think that the industry needs to pivot to a potentially different pricing model where both advisor as well as the firms themselves have aligned incentives where their revenues, their earnings are tied to the same KPIs and metrics and so they can grow together, commensurate with their customers. Jason Diamond: Yeah, I agree with that. I think that’s, in large part, what the shift from brokerage to fee-based was starting to get at. Explain the cash sweep concept because I don’t think everybody in a retail audience is necessarily familiar with this and how important it is. Can you just take a step back and explain cash sweeps and the impact and how broker dealers make money? Steve Chubak: Yeah, sure. I’m not going to go too far down this rabbit hole. I’ll do my best, Jason, to keep it high level. What we’ve seen over the last, call it, five years is multiple instances where cash monetization, so think about a firm, whether it’s LPL or Schwab, where the advisor has anywhere from one to 3% of their client cash that sits idle for transactional purposes, maybe some bill pay, what have you. Maybe there’s some drawdown vehicles where there’s a capital call. But on those cash balances, that is a significant source of profitability for firms like Schwab and LPL. And to provide some context here, we estimate that about 100% of pre-tax income for some of these firms is in fact derived from monetizing client cash. Now, my issue with this, and this has been the case even prior to some of the growing scrutiny around cash monetization as agentic tools, as tokenization has emerged and reared its ugly head, the reality is it is an opaque exchange of value, I would argue, in that the firm is making money, the advisor does not on these cash balances, and the customer does not. And my preference has always been for more transparency and more alignment of incentives where you would have, in the case of a customer, if their AUM is compounding at 15%, the advisor is also going to clip their fee that will hopefully grow commensurate with that over time. And similarly, I want the firms to be participating in that as well where it is a transparent fee. Let’s say it’s a platform fee where you charge five basis points, but instead of earning a 3% spread on these idle cash balances, you’re actually paying much more competitive deposit rates. I think that’s a better alignment of incentives for all the parties that are involved. It’s also a much more transparent approach to fee monetization. And the reality is cash is just not going to grow as quickly as AUM. And because of some of those structural headwinds to growth, I think it makes a lot more sense for companies in lieu of monetizing cash to the extent that they have historically, actually pivoting and replacing that with a three, four, five basis point platform fee. And it actually still yields a better outcome for everyone involved because I think most of the companies that will do it will likely structure it in a earnings neutral to slightly dilutive manner knowing that AUM could actually compound faster over time. That’s where we get a little bit too far in the weeds, but hopefully that offers some helpful context. Jason Diamond: Yeah, no, super helpful. So basically, the concept is right now, firms are paying below market rates on cash, but they’re also not really charging that much in some cases to leverage their platform. So you’re describing a world where they say, “We’ll pay you market competitive rates on cash. That’s more transparent, but we’re a business after all. We’re probably going to have to implement some form of platform fee to offset that.” I agree with that completely. My question for you from an advisor movement perspective is this. Obviously, from the firm perspective, they love that. The scenario you’re explaining, if they could flip a light switch, if LPL or Schwab could flip a light switch tomorrow and go from 100% sweeps revenue to 100% platform fee revenue, I believe they would do it. But there is a concern about how advisor attrition or movement is impacted if and when you implement a platform fee. So what are your thoughts on if a firm does this, do we see a whole bunch of advisors all of a sudden jump ship? You’re going to turn around and ask me the same question. I know. Steve Chubak: No, I know. I was about to say that actually. And you’re certainly familiar with some of the firms that have introduced a platform fee in the past. We saw this a couple of years ago from Rockefeller. I know Ed Jones had introduced one. And what we tried to do actually as part of our advisor migration analysis or advisor on the move analysis is look at whether we saw any evidence of some slowdown in advisor recruitment, some slowdown in organic growth, and there were really no tangible signs of that. I think there were little evidence of any sort of disruption here. I think it speaks to the fact that the advisors recognize that the firms do need to get paid for the services that are being rendered, and at the same time, they’re going to focus more on the platforms that have high-quality service, high-quality tech. I don’t think a three to five basis point platform fee, especially when your clients are getting paid more competitive rates on cash, is going to deter you from joining or affiliating with a specific firm. Jason Diamond: You didn’t ask, but I will give you my perspective. I agree with you. I take a somewhat nuanced approach here, which is there is a big difference between a basis point and six basis points, and I am curious to see… The other piece of this I’m watching closely is the lack of a first mover advantage. So if one firm, let’s say it’s LPL, decides to go this route, do we immediately see a whole bunch of other firms following suit? I think part of that dictates, and how large of a fear, how large of a change are we talking about, probably dictates a lot of the response. As a whole though, I agree with you. I think we probably look at this a year or two years from now and just call it a necessary structural change of something that needed to happen in our industry. Let’s pivot to M&A. It’s been a little bit of a quiet year in terms of major headline news, but at the time of this recording, a couple of weeks back was Altruist Vanguard announcement, which is probably the biggest one I can think of this year being 2026. Give me your thoughts on Altruist Vanguard. What does it mean for Schwab and Fidelity and the RIA space as a whole? Steve Chubak: Yeah, it’s a really interesting transaction. Candidly, it wasn’t one that was on my bingo card for this year. And I should start off by saying I have a tremendous amount of respect for the Altruist team and what Jason has built. The fact of the matter is this has been a really dominant oligopoly for an extended period of time within the RIA space. They’re one of the few names that were really able to break in, but they’ve been able to have success with that smaller RIA cohort. And I believe there are about 6,000 some odd advisor teams that are on the platform. I haven’t seen explicit AUC numbers, but I believe that the average size is about anywhere from 100 million plus or minus. That would imply about 50 to 75 billion of aggregate AUC on the Altruist platform. And for context, that equates to about 1% of AUC at Schwab. I’d also point out that Schwab has actually recruited more in AUC in each of the last two quarters than the aggregate size of Altruist, just to offer some perspective here. So while I do think Altruist is going to have some success moving up market, they benefit from being able to leverage deep pockets. They certainly are known for being a very tech-forward firm, so I do think they’re going to have success. At the same time, I think they’re going to have success with some of those smaller RIAs still, and Schwab is going to continue to have a fairly dominant position amongst some of the larger RIA teams. Jason Diamond: Is that because Schwab, and let’s call it Fidelity as 1A or 1B, is that because they’ve just become kind of the default options or is there something you feel that they just do better than everybody else? Steve Chubak: I think the breadth of the offering is something that’s really unmatched, and actually, we just had the opportunity to meet with Schwab management. I thought Rick actually articulated that really well. I think he’s also keenly aware of some of the products that are in very strong demand and doing what’s needed to try and offer that in a responsible way. And probably the best example here would be the RIA long short offering, which AQR popularized, which is the demand is incredibly strong. We’ve seen a number of firms that have slowed the pace of growth of late, and that’s simply to manage around some operational difficulties like sourcing some of the borrow. I don’t want to get too in the weeds here, but that’s an example of the type of product where there’s strong RIA demand and Schwab found a way to offer it, and they’re still focused on still being responsible about growing said product, but at the same time, still having that as a driver of accelerating RIA flows. And that’s one of the reasons why even since the Altruist Vanguard deal was announced, what we’re seeing and hearing suggests that RIA flows, at least on the Schwab platform, have remained incredibly robust and resilient throughout. Jason Diamond: So let me ask you this question. I’m going to put you on the spot here. It sounds, based on your comments, there’s some firms, particularly the bigger firms, that you are bullish on. Do you agree with this statement that in 10 years, let’s say, whatever the timeframe is, the wealth management world is dominated by Morgan in the W2 space, Schwab in the independent space, and maybe LPL in the broker dealer space. Is that the world we’re heading towards? Steve Chubak: Yeah, I do think that those three names across those individual channels are going to be consolidators of share. I just think Morgan Stanley, in particular, it’s certainly viewed as the strongest platform within the wirehouse channel amongst many of the investors we engage with. I think they were certainly the most innovative when it came to deploying AI, and every time I engage with Jed about some of their efforts on the technology side, they are clearly pioneers in many different areas. I think Workplace in particular is probably the channel that I’m most bullish on in terms of value prop, growth prospects, but also the cost of asset and acquisition being so much lower within that channel. And so, I feel like they built a really strong ecosystem there. LPL, similarly, I think has just been very innovative in their approach within the IBD channel, whether it’s liquidity and succession, whether it’s their strategic wealth services offering, which serves as somewhat of a hybrid offering to attract some of those wirehouse advisors, and they’ve done a really nice job there. Then, from Schwab’s perspective, they are the behemoth in the RIA space, but I think because of the breadth of the offering, because of the investments they’re making on the technology side, as well as on the product side, that’s going to enable them to have a really dominant position. I think the beauty of Schwab’s competitive position is that even if they’re growing in line with the rest of the RIA industry, that’s still going to support high single-digit to low double-digit AUC growth year to year, just given the structural tailwinds in terms of migration from W-2 to independent, no one knows this better than you, Jason, remains firmly intact. Jason Diamond: It’s hard to poke holes in anything you said. It does feel a little bit like the rich get richer. Again, not to put you on the spot, but will you venture some maybe bearish names, or even if you don’t want to give names, any pockets of the industry that are causing you some anxiety or concern right now? Steve Chubak: I’m always more cautious just on… I mean, this is the opportunity, admittedly, for many of the public names that I cover. On a lot of the PE sponsor-backed names, I always just question, given higher levels of leverage that they employ, particularly in a higher for longer interest rate backdrop as we’re bracing for incremental hikes, and then just questions around what the end game is for some of the private equity firms that actually own many of these names. I don’t necessarily feel like they have the same long-term commitment to match some of the others, and therein lies the opportunity for the likes of whether it’s LPL or Ray Jay to potentially recruit from some of those firms. I think one of the really interesting debates that’s happening now, Jason, is there are some firms that have drawn a clear line in the sand. Whether it’s in Ameriprise, I might even throw Stifel into the mix, that have said, “We are not going to compete with some of these aggressive TA packages. We just don’t believe that the returns, the paybacks are sufficiently compelling.” Whereas there are quite a few other firms, whether it’s LPL, Raymond James- Jason Diamond: Ray J. Steve Chubak: … indicated to us that they can still underwrite a lot of these advisor teams to very attractive IRRs, attractive paybacks, and because of that, they’re going to continue to recruit and recruit fairly aggressively. So there’s definitely different stances that some of the individual firms have taken. They’re still all very committed to the space. I think the willingness to at least match some of the more aggressive TA offers that are out there, we’ve definitely seen greater dispersion on that front. Jason Diamond: So who’s right? I have a very clear point of view. I’ll go first. I believe that firms have been making fun of how high TA have been when they were 100% in W-2 land. So to me, it’s like I use the old quip of democracy is the worst form of government besides all others. TA is the worst form of recruiting besides all others. Who is right? Do you believe that the cautious capitals expensive approach is ultimately going to bear fruit long-term or is it better just to write these ever-increasing recruiting deals? Steve Chubak: No, I do think the firms need to employ discipline here, and there is an efficient frontier that can be had. So this is something we actually unpacked recently after we met with LPL management. And to be clear, this is not their view. This is my personal view and my team’s view that I don’t necessarily need to see LPL grow organically 10% and, as a result, see much weaker free cash flow conversion because that’s something that is getting increasingly scrutinized by the investor community. And so, for us, the efficient frontier is still healthy levels of organic growth at, let’s call it, mid to high single-digit, but being able to marry that with strong free cash flow conversion, what we’ve seen historically is if you have a good balance of both of those items, it’s typically translated into better stock performance, better earnings growth over time. And so, I do think that there’s a balance here to be had. It’s not simply try to maximize TA, match the most competitive offers that are out there in the marketplace. You do have to strike a balance where you still want to continue to grow, focus on organic growth, but not necessarily try to maximize organic growth at the risk of weaker free cash flow conversion. Jason Diamond: I heard an interesting quote on this from a unnamed executive at an unnamed big firm who basically said, “If you are the firm that writes the biggest check, you get the advisors that chase the biggest check.” And I think there’s something to that too, is that firms have become a little bit, I don’t know, gun shy is the right word, but a little bit mindful of the fact that the type of advisor who is likely to take a big check or the biggest possible check is also potentially the type of advisor that might move again. And I’m not villainizing taking the check. I believe advisors deserve to be compensated. It’s risky to move, it’s a hassle to move, but I do think we’re seeing, from our perspective, firms are definitely getting more selective. I don’t know if it’s because cash has gotten more expensive, just because there is a lot of scrutiny on this, but firms are definitely getting more selective about how they deploy max TA packages, max transition assistance packages. Do you agree? Steve Chubak: I certainly agree, but now, Jason, it’s my opportunity to put you on the spot since I’m curious as some of these firms have to underwrite TA packages that have a very long duration, and we are entering a period where agentic AI is front and center. And there’s a lot of concern that firms aren’t going to adequately handicap the risk of monetization pressures, whether that’s lower fee rates on advisory fees over time. I’m not speaking over the next year or two, but given the long duration of some of these TA agreements, how are companies at least handicapping that risk? Jason Diamond: I think it’s a very real risk for deals that were put on the books before firms had any of this on their radar in particular. That’s what I worry about. I think now, firms have a pretty good sense that this is coming, some of these cash dynamics you’re talking about, potentially even some of these AI risks where their advisors are just going to be slightly less profitable. But I do worry a little bit about firms that wrote 11 to 13-year deals four years ago. I will say this, the bull market has solved for a lot of this headache because advisors who grow just make these deals attractive. That’s what we’ve seen is that even these deals that seemed expensive at the time, we’ve seen astronomical growth from some advisors, X market even at a lot of these firms, and then those deals look good in hindsight. I absolutely worry that if we see a prolonged or a sustained kind of neutral to down market, I think these firms wrote deals to high enough IRR numbers that I’m not like, “Oh my God, I’m crying poor.” But I could see a world where firms have to take a write-down on some of their recruits like they’re just not as profitable as they originally envisioned. What are your thoughts? Steve Chubak: Yeah, I think that’s right. We’ve done the IRR math ourselves. I think what we’ve seen, I alluded to some of these numbers earlier, payback periods have probably been extended by about a year. The IRRs have contracted by about 500 basis points, but there are names that could still underwrite to IRRs that are in the upper teens to 20% type range. And I should also note that analysis, since I want to be completely transparent, I had a bunch of clients who complained about it because we evaluated it on a timeline of seven years, but there are advisors who are going to stay on the platform beyond the TA agreement. And if anything, that maybe understates at least some of the returns that can be underwritten by these firms over time. Jason Diamond: Absolutely agree. And I think, look, I don’t worry, at least this is my personal view, I don’t so much worry about the fee compression risk of the agentic just because I think firms have gotten really good at avoiding it. I do worry a little bit about are advisors going to have to start offering a lot more? Are you going to need bigger teams? Just things that, in general, impact firm profitability. But I have a hard time believing. I’d be curious to hear your thoughts. Do you think there’s a world where advisors who are now charging 1% to clients are all of a sudden going to have to start charging 30 bps because of AI? Steve Chubak: I think there’s going to be some marginal pricing pressure, particularly in areas like brokerage. The beauty is that we’ve already been seeing over the last 5 to 10 years a migration to advisory where the pricing and fee rates are much more resilient. And it’s one of the reasons why if you look at asset management fee rates, since the emergence of passive ETFs, they’ve only moved in one direction and that’s steadily lower. Whereas on the wealth side, while brokerage fee rates have come down, what we’ve actually seen on the advisory side is far greater resiliency over time. So that does instill some greater confidence, at least on our part, that the pricing is going to be more resilient. I’d also point out that a lot of the products that are in much stronger demand, someone who covers the alts, certainly the growth in retail alternatives, the proliferation of retail alts, despite some of the recent agita and concerns around the BDC space, the reality is private equity, secondaries, infra funds, they’re in very strong demand. They do generate uncorrelated returns, and especially given how active a lot of these firms will be, and this is where we’re spending a lot of time now in fact, Jason, on the AI data center financing opportunity that as more money is allocated by the retail community to alternatives, that’s also accretive for pricing and for earnings for a lot of the firms as well. So there’s a lot of different trends that we’re seeing in terms of product demand, where companies are pivoting to. And I think Schwab is the best example here where their revenue as a percentage of client assets, which to me is really the litmus test or barometer for how much value you’re providing to the end client, they stack up as best in class on that front. But it also speaks to the fact that they probably have more room to adjust pricing, and they’ve done that in select areas. They’ve raised the SAN threshold, for example, and they’ve taken those actions to at least protect and preserve some of their pricing power, which frankly, I think they’ve earned just given the sheer amount of value they offer based on this metric. Jason Diamond: The other concern we hear, and maybe you don’t model out this far, the other concern we hear is, I agree. My parents are 60 years old, and my advisor can keep charging my parents 1%, but eventually, the kids are going to take over the money and they’re going to have a very different experience with the advisor, with the money, with the fee relationship. Do you give any thought to that, that there’s this great wealth transfer that could be 20 years from… I mean, you have to put some weight to that if you’re modeling out discounted cash flow stock prices, right? Steve Chubak: No, I think that’s certainly fair. Now, at the same time, there are some historical paradigms that do give me some comfort here. So the best example would be the emergence of robo-advisors. And I remember back in 2013 where everyone expected that 20% of millennial assets were going to be managed in some sort of robo offering, and that number today I believe is about 1%- Jason Diamond: Really? Steve Chubak: … of what source you use of the aggregate retail TAM over a decade later. So I think what we’ve learned over time is that people do value advice, human intervention. I know there’s a lot of advisors in the audience. We’re not just at least trying to appease them. I think there’s clear evidence based on some of the historical trends that people want human advice. They want at least some human participation to help even from a handholding perspective. And I will tell you as someone who tried to leverage at least an LLM recently to forego having to pay a lawyer, I got about 75 to 80% of the way there. And that last 20%, I was incredibly uncomfortable and made the determination that DIY might not be the right approach for that sort of thing. And I feel, frankly, similarly on advice that there’s a lot of tax optimization and complexity. There’s a lot of complexity around trusts where people don’t necessarily want to delegate that simply to an agentic tool. Jason Diamond: So you just nailed it, and I love the lawyer analogy because I think it’s high-level professional services, and I think this is more true, the larger your client base is in terms of average clients like more sophisticated clients. I just feel we have this moat and this kind of immunity to a lot of this, and somebody’s going to play this back in 10 years and laugh at me in the face, but to me, it feels like an area. It’s not like my Fios box broke, and I’m okay. I’m comfortable with an AI agent there. It feels like an area that is insulated because to your point, that last 20% is what matters the most and it’s what people seem to value. It gives me comfort too, I will say. We’ve got time for a few more. You mentioned KPIs, key performance indicators. When you look at a company, let’s say I give you two minutes with the company’s financials, what do you look at? What does your mind immediately go to? Is there a certain metric or metrics that you think are the most telling these days? Steve Chubak: Sure. Organic growth first and foremost. As much as I wish that if any of the companies are listening, that they would break out same store versus new store growth, frankly, there’s just been less disclosure around that given some of the heightened competition, but even organic growth at the headline level is certainly something that we focus on. Operating leverage, so as revenues continue to scale, it’s nice that we’re in a bull market. It’s nice that there are significant interest rate tailwinds that are benefiting these firms, but how are they striking that balance between investing for growth and allowing some of that windfall to hit the bottom line? We usually like to see a better balance there. If a company’s compounding revenues at 15% and growing expenses at 2% and the rest of the competition is growing at 5 to 8% in terms of cost growth, that’s something that does not sit well with us because that is a temporary boost to earnings that certainly isn’t going to be durable or sustainable. Jason Diamond: Let me ask you two more questions. I think you and I first started speaking about cash sweeps. It’s probably 18 months ago, which is certainly long before it was on the radar of a lot of advisors and clients. Do you have something else that’s in the back of your mind as this is the next big thing that people aren’t talking enough about? Steve Chubak: I do think this is certainly the next shoe to drop, just given even what’s taking place today with the reaction to the number or the quantum of Meta Muse downloads and what the implications are for financial services broadly. The wealth names are selling off a bit more than some others. You actually saw some insurance brokers sell off yesterday. So anyone that is in services industry or in financial services where there’s a perception that there might be some risk to pricing or monetization, there is certainly an acute sensitivity to that amongst investors at the moment. I would say there are a lot of interesting dynamics that we’re looking at certainly ahead of our wealth conference. I would say certainly, to self-clear or to not self-clear as some of these larger firms continue to scale because do you want to have full ownership of the data? Do you want to ensure that you can maintain all of the different monetization streams within your ecosystem rather than at least having some of that go to the Pershings or Broadridges of the world? I think it’s a really interesting debate just given how valuable that data becomes in an AI world and some of the self-clearing entities potentially being able to leverage that. I’ve never really seen a sufficiently compelling value prop where a firm would go down the path of something that’s highly disruptive like converting to self-clearing. We’ve seen only a handful of instances where that’s happened, but I do think AI and, frankly, the importance of data is changing at least some of that calculus for different firms. Jason Diamond: Yeah. And I think maybe some of the Commonwealth LPL reaction too, I’m seeing some of the non-self-clearing reaction there, too. Commonwealth LPL somewhat intentionally because I want to end with, we spoke a little bit about M&A in the light of Vanguard, but I think going into the year, there were some thoughts of there’s some names. You mentioned Stifel. We’ve talked a little bit about UBS, a little bit about Citi. There’s some names that make sense, at least maybe a little bit. Any M&A news that you’re watching either this year or further ahead? Steve Chubak: It’s a little tough, Jason, because I am precluded from putting any companies in play, but I’ll least speak to what’s been put out in the public domain. Look, for a company like Stifel, I know that there was certainly some speculation that Raymond James might be interested. I don’t know. Ron K. seems to be very happy with what he’s doing. In fact, even at our conference last year in JESS, he took a fake phone call from a journalist to say we’re not for sale. Jason Diamond: I remember that. Steve Chubak: It is something where we’ve seen a number of firms like that that are trading at 10 times, and this is an earnings number, not even EBITDA multiple. So 10 times earnings, historically very discounted multiples. Some of that I think is a function of the AI concerns that are percolating in the marketplace, but if anything, there’s never been a better time to at least source attractive targets in the wealth space, at least in the public domain, given the multiples that the group is trading at today. I think that’s one of the bigger surprises too, Jason, since you mentioned a couple of other things we’re thinking about that come to mind. One, I mentioned Workplace, and there aren’t a lot of obvious corporate stock plan targets, but I do think there are quite a few firms that we’ve spoken with who want to be larger in the retirement space. And so, I do think that’s an area where you might see firms look to expand inorganically over time. That certainly wouldn’t surprise me given it’s still highly fragmented, and there are a lot of scale players in the wealth space that are still too small within retirement specifically. So that’s certainly something that we are monitoring quite closely. The last thing I’d say about just wealth M&A in general, at least amongst strategics versus, say, some of the PE or sponsor-backed purchasers, you have to buy it twice, right? Jason Diamond: Twice. Steve Chubak: That’s always the hesitancy or reluctance on the part of some of the public names in acquiring a strategic or public competitor is the fact that you’re buying the property, and then you also have to retain all the advisors. And when you actually layer all of that into the deal consideration, some of these deals start to get much too expensive. But we still see quite a few acquisitions, at least amongst the privates. I think the biggest surprise to me is that we haven’t seen more convergence yet between private and public multiple in the wealth space. Jason Diamond: Yeah, we’ve seen a couple take privates. Yeah, I don’t disagree with you. I just thought of another one that I want to end on. This is a quick bonus round question. Steve Chubak: Of course. Jason Diamond: What is the number one inbound topic you get? Is it AI? It is for us these days. I’m just curious. Steve Chubak: It is primarily AI. I think it’s really about all of the game theory, candidly, Jason, that we had walked through where whether it’s LPL has been speculated as potentially being a first mover on making changes to cash monetization, the reality is that certainly, someone else could be that brave soul that ends up being the first mover here instead of LPL, but trying to think through the game theory in terms of how do other firms respond? Does this drive broader sweeping changes in terms of pricing? Is it isolated just to the IBD channel, or does it extend to the wires and the pure RIAs as well? There’s a lot of really interesting debate that’s taking place on that front. It’s all AI or AI adjacent. I would just say that it’s definitely cash, but it’s also the game theory and the knock-on effects for others that’s getting quite a bit of focus too that people are trying to navigate here. Jason Diamond: Yeah, that’s exactly what I was going to say, the knock-on effects because it’s, okay, fine, we have this giant topic of AI, but then gaming out how it’s going to impact cash sweeps and monetization and advisor fees and advisor productivity and advisor movement, that’s where the fun begins. So we’ll have to invite you back. This is a topic that’s evolving very rapidly. So I know next year, we’ll probably have an entirely new slate of topics to talk about, but this has been a ton of fun and a really interesting different perspective from a largely institutional seat. So thank you for sharing your wisdom and expertise with us, Steve. It was a pleasure. Steve Chubak: You’ve been a tremendous partner of ours too, so thanks so much for having me on and always enjoy engaging on this topic. Goes without saying. Jason Diamond: Thank you. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibility seriously and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook . Deep Research: How Smart Money Evaluates Wealth Management Firms A conversation with Jason Diamond and Steve Chubak, Managing Director at Wolfe Research. Jason Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is Deep Research: How Smart Money Evaluates Wealth Management Firms. It’s a conversation with Steve Chubak, managing director at Wolfe Research. I’m Jason Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help lead advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Jason Diamond: Financial advisors have plenty of reasons to take a closer look at the wealth management landscape. They may be considering a change of firms or models, evaluating an equity partner, or simply trying to understand whether their current firm is positioned for the future. And when they do, they tend to look at it through a very specific lens. What will this platform allow me to do for my clients? How will it support my business? And does it give me what I need to grow? Institutional investors look at many of those same firms through a very different lens. My guest today, Steve Chubak, is a managing director at Wolfe Research, where he and his team cover the wealth management ecosystem, from wirehouses and regional firms to custodians, broker dealers, and alternative asset managers. His job is to understand not just how these businesses are performing today, but what their performance metrics and key data points tell us about where they may be headed. And that’s where I think this conversation gets especially relevant for advisors, because whether you’re analyzing a company as an investment or evaluating it as a place to build your business, many of the underlying questions are surprisingly similar. Is the growth durable? What is the firm spending to generate it? How effectively is it investing in technology? And what could disrupt its economics over time? Steve offers an institutional perspective on all of it, including why organic growth may tell us more than headline recruiting numbers, what AI could mean for advisor productivity and fees, the changing economics of cash, and how M&A and consolidation could reshape the competitive landscape. It’s a different way to look at the firms advisors work for, partner with, and consider joining, and at what may ultimately separate the strongest wealth management businesses from the rest. So let’s do it. Steve, thanks so much for joining us. Thrilled to have you here. Steve Chubak: No, it’s great to be here. Really appreciate the opportunity to participate. It goes without saying, longtime fan of the podcast, so nice to finally be on. Jason Diamond: Longtime listener, first-time caller, let’s get going. Before we talk about the business side of things, I want to talk about your background, a little bit of a different flavor of guests for us. So tell us what brought you to the world of research, to the world of wealth management. How’d you end up here? Steve Chubak: Yeah, sure. So I graduated from NYU Stern in undergrad. Most of the folks in my class either went into investment banking or markets. In fact, very few went into research. I myself embraced at least the trading side, but realized over time, I actually had a real passion for doing fundamental analysis on stocks. And I realized this passion in 2008, mind you, where there weren’t a ton of job opportunities at the time as I was making that career pivot. But the beauty of the research side is I get to really engage with some of the smartest investors on the planet day-to-day, unpacking really challenging topics. And specific to the wealth management space, I think what’s really unique about the franchise that we’ve built there is most of my competitors might cover a sleeve of companies within the wealth spectrum. We actually cover the whole ecosystem. So we’re one of the few teams and maybe the only team that covers the wirehouses, the regional brokers, the trading shops like IBKR and Schwab, as well as some of the alternative asset managers. So whether it’s the product side or whether it’s the firms that are providing the platforms, we can cover the whole ecosystem. And it’s just an incredibly dynamic space with TAMs that have really powerful structural growth tailwinds. So never a dull moment. Even today, we’re seeing a selloff in the space around some of the concerns around the Meta Muse launch. And look, it always keeps us on our toes. It always keeps us busy and engaged. Jason Diamond: Absolutely. So there’s a lot to unpack there. I want to just take a baby step back and do the five-year-old version of this. Fair to say, your company covers single stocks from a research perspective. Do you also do anything on the industry as a whole, macro, more broad, just so we know what we’re focusing on today? Steve Chubak: Yeah, sure. Because we’ve spent so much time really unpacking all the trends that are really influencing the wealth space today, we do spend a lot of time publishing deep dive industry reports on the wealth names. We’ll do it when we have the opportunities to engage with management. So we did that recently with LPL and Schwab, but we also host a wealth symposium every year and publish a wealth management primer alongside that. It leverages a lot of industry data. Frankly, it leverages some of the pieces that even you guys have published in the past, but really, just trying to analyze the whole ecosystem to take a more holistic view on what some of the growth opportunities are, but also some of the emerging risks that are impacting the space. Jason Diamond: No doubt. With all that said, I think your lens, at least as I see it, is a little different than our typical advisor. Are you spending your day interfacing with these companies, meaning talking to management of LPL, of Raymond James, of Schwab, and trying to get the picture of what’s working, what’s not working? What does the role involve in real words? Steve Chubak: I would say that engaging with the management teams probably composes about 20% of our day, if that. Most of our engagement is in fact with institutional investors that are looking to invest in the space. So someone that is interested in Morgan Stanley but wants to understand the workplace offering, and we’ll schedule a 30 to 45-minute call. We’ll unpack some of our prior research. They’ll ask for certain custom requests, so we can try and extrapolate what the growth is going to look like for that particular segment. And you can really apply that to any of the companies in the wealth space. So it’s always dynamic. From a bottom-up perspective, each of these companies are quite different. They operate in different channels. There’s no shortage of topics to unpack, but I’d say most of the engagement that we do and most of our time is really spent on the research product and engagement with institutional investors. We do speak regularly with the companies, but that’s probably about 10 to maybe 20% of our day. Jason Diamond: That’s what strikes me in talking to you is you take a institutional lens to a pretty retail environment, meaning the business itself skews certainly retail. What is it that surprises you? Let’s start with something maybe not spicy, but a little bit out of the gates with some punch to it. When you talk to institutional investors and then obviously, you spend your day in the world of retail, what surprises you most about that kind of juxtaposition? Steve Chubak: I think the biggest surprise to me is just the level of detail orientation that we get from our institutional investors. The expectation is if we’re going to cover 35 to 40 names, we are going to know these names inside and out. We’re going to have deep familiarity with the history. We’re going to understand the game theory in terms of how the landscape is going to evolve. And certainly when you have these dynamic themes like agentic AI that are getting introduced or injected into the space, that’s sparking quite a bit of controversy and debate, but the expectation is we have to unpack that game theory. We have to understand how each company is competitively positioned. And in that regard, we are going quite a bit deeper. I would say what’s similar to wealth management is that it’s not so much, even though there’s a strong relationship component that exists for both, I would say that on the wealth management side, you’re taking a much more holistic view of your client, of your customer, where it’s not simply trying to get the portfolio asset allocation right. It’s also about understanding the family needs, how can you optimize from a tax standpoint, what are the lending products that you can offer, so I’d say the service that’s being offered is much broader, whereas for the institutional investors, I think the expectation is narrower focus, but we’re going to go much deeper. Jason Diamond: Yeah, that makes a lot of sense to me. I guess what I’m kind of getting at is, do you feel like the retail audience misses something that you see that your institutional audience just gravitates towards? Is there something, or maybe it’s the other way around? Maybe it’s the institutional guys could learn from the retail guys. I don’t mean to lead the witness, but I think you have this unique seat where you straddle both worlds. Steve Chubak: It’s a great question, and I’d say that it’s probably applicable to both. There’s certainly some elements I’d say institutional investors do underappreciate because they’re so deep in the numbers. There are times when they are myopically focused on the numbers. And the reality is too, when there’s periods of uncertainty, and I know we’ll talk about this in a moment, what the implications are for AI on pricing, on cash monetization, in many of those instances, institutional investors will simply capitulate and say, “There’s too much uncertainty. I can’t be involved.” And obviously, on the wealth side, it tends to be quite different where they can appreciate the strength of the relationships. When I engage with a lot of advisors, they talk about leveraging AI in a really constructive and productive way that’s franchise enhancing. I’d say from an institutional investor standpoint, they tend to take a little bit more of a glass half empty view at times. And because of that, you’ll have periods where there’s heightened uncertainty and you’ll see significant retrenchment or disengagement on the part of some of the institutional investors. Jason Diamond: I’m struck by as you’re speaking, your work is similar to ours in some sense in that you’re breaking down 30 to 40 companies into the big wealth management names for the purposes of an institutional investor audience. And I guess my question was framed through how does an institutional investor audience compare to a retail investment audience? The reality is we interface with advisors who think about these same questions you do, but through the lens of what firm do I want to work with? So meaning I need to understand what does the future of Raymond James look like, how does Morgan Stanley’s business model going to evolve, how is AI going to impact LPL’s pricing because I’m making a decision about where to move my book of business. Do you guys have an interest in advisor movement, I guess is my first question? Is that something that institutional investors are keen on? Steve Chubak: Very much so, and I feel like that’s actually one of the products that we publish that has among the strongest, if not the strongest, following amongst a lot of our institutional clients because the reality is what dictates the stock price performance for a lot of the wealth managers is in fact organic growth, I would say, first and foremost. And because of that, there tends to be a really significant focus on not just net new asset growth, but also the cost of that asset acquisition. So no one is a bigger expert, at least in areas like transition assistance than you, Jason. So typically, we’re leaning on experts like yourselves, but to get some insight into the TA dynamics, how it’s impacting the returns for the assets that are being acquired or new business that’s being underwritten. And because of that, there tends to be a greater scrutiny amongst the institutional investors increasingly, not just of who has the strongest M&A profile, but who actually has the highest quality M&A profile given that the cost of asset acquisition and advisor recruitment has gone up pretty dramatically in recent years. Jason Diamond: So meaning, and sorry for dumbing this down into second grade mode, meaning if a firm was having a ton of success recruiting, but they were paying 2,000% transition deals, the institutional audience would look at that and say the cost of your net new assets is just not in line with. Is that kind of what you’re getting at? Steve Chubak: That’s exactly right. And it’s funny too because if I think back 5 to 10 years ago, there was a strong investor contingent, and I’d say even the majority of investors who believe that new advisor growth or new store growth, so to speak, was actually higher quality than same store because the cost to recruit wasn’t that high. And at the same time, the investor perception was if you can recruit new advisors to your platform, that means that you run a great platform from a service standpoint, from a technology standpoint. Whereas today, same store unquestionably, just given the heightened scrutiny and focus on transition assistance is certainly perceived to be higher quality. So there are a number of firms that may not be growing their advisor base as much as some of their peers, but the reality is the same store sales growth is so much more powerful that’s translating into better M&A and it’s a cheaper cost of asset acquisition. So that’s, to me, really the efficient frontier that a lot of investors today are solving for is good M&A profile, but not necessarily overpaying for that growth. Jason Diamond: So I assume that’s like the comments we saw at a Morgan Stanley over the weekend or whatever, it was a week ago, basically saying, “Our advisors grow like crazy. We will still recruit effectively, but maybe not as robustly and holistically, but take our swings when…” Is that sort of the ethos here that you think a lot of firms will start to adapt? Steve Chubak: That’s exactly right. And I think it also speaks to the fact that if you look at Morgan Stanley’s net new asset growth and you benchmark it relative to a broader universe of players, including some of the RIAs and independent broker dealers, what we’ve seen is Morgan Stanley’s M&A is best in class and despite the fact that they haven’t added as many advisors, and that really speaks to, frankly, the strength of the workplace funnel. Jason Diamond: The funnel, agreed. I would’ve thought what you started with, which is that a firm that can recruit well has a solid enough platform that they can probably retain advisors. I agree there are some exceptions to that on both sides, firms that do a really good job of recruiting, but they also have people leaving out the back door, and then the flip side is certainly also true. I think we have to talk about AI here. I was going to bury it for a little bit later, but you brought it up, and I think it’s too tied in to this topic. Let’s just start at the top. Overall, with the advent of AI agentic tools, the news you see every single day, you are A, more bullish on the industry than you were a year ago, B, more bearish, C, neutral? Steve Chubak: I’d say I’m moderately bullish. I have to give a nuanced response here in that I know like any typical sell side would where he’s going to have to hedge his bets and throw in a bunch of caveats. But kidding aside, from a advisor productivity standpoint and from a platform efficiency standpoint, I think that AI is a huge boon or windfall for the industry. The one area where we’re more cautious is really around monetization and pricing. And to be clear, this is not a risk that I view as imminent, but over the next 5, 10, 15 years as these tools grow more sophisticated, as it’s easier to optimize some of your idle cash, as it’s easier to at least attract or source services from a wealth standpoint. They’re being offered more cheaply by a fintech provider or some other competitive threat. It’s really that monetization piece that I’m a bit more cautious on, which is why I do think that the industry needs to pivot to a potentially different pricing model where both advisor as well as the firms themselves have aligned incentives where their revenues, their earnings are tied to the same KPIs and metrics and so they can grow together, commensurate with their customers. Jason Diamond: Yeah, I agree with that. I think that’s, in large part, what the shift from brokerage to fee-based was starting to get at. Explain the cash sweep concept because I don’t think everybody in a retail audience is necessarily familiar with this and how important it is. Can you just take a step back and explain cash sweeps and the impact and how broker dealers make money? Steve Chubak: Yeah, sure. I’m not going to go too far down this rabbit hole. I’ll do my best, Jason, to keep it high level. What we’ve seen over the last, call it, five years is multiple instances where cash monetization, so think about a firm, whether it’s LPL or Schwab, where the advisor has anywhere from one to 3% of their client cash that sits idle for transactional purposes, maybe some bill pay, what have you. Maybe there’s some drawdown vehicles where there’s a capital call. But on those cash balances, that is a significant source of profitability for firms like Schwab and LPL. And to provide some context here, we estimate that about 100% of pre-tax income for some of these firms is in fact derived from monetizing client cash. Now, my issue with this, and this has been the case even prior to some of the growing scrutiny around cash monetization as agentic tools, as tokenization has emerged and reared its ugly head, the reality is it is an opaque exchange of value, I would argue, in that the firm is making money, the advisor does not on these cash balances, and the customer does not. And my preference has always been for more transparency and more alignment of incentives where you would have, in the case of a customer, if their AUM is compounding at 15%, the advisor is also going to clip their fee that will hopefully grow commensurate with that over time. And similarly, I want the firms to be participating in that as well where it is a transparent fee. Let’s say it’s a platform fee where you charge five basis points, but instead of earning a 3% spread on these idle cash balances, you’re actually paying much more competitive deposit rates. I think that’s a better alignment of incentives for all the parties that are involved. It’s also a much more transparent approach to fee monetization. And the reality is cash is just not going to grow as quickly as AUM. And because of some of those structural headwinds to growth, I think it makes a lot more sense for companies in lieu of monetizing cash to the extent that they have historically, actually pivoting and replacing that with a three, four, five basis point platform fee. And it actually still yields a better outcome for everyone involved because I think most of the companies that will do it will likely structure it in a earnings neutral to slightly dilutive manner knowing that AUM could actually compound faster over time. That’s where we get a little bit too far in the weeds, but hopefully that offers some helpful context. Jason Diamond: Yeah, no, super helpful. So basically, the concept is right now, firms are paying below market rates on cash, but they’re also not really charging that much in some cases to leverage their platform. So you’re describing a world where they say, “We’ll pay you market competitive rates on cash. That’s more transparent, but we’re a business after all. We’re probably going to have to implement some form of platform fee to offset that.” I agree with that completely. My question for you from an advisor movement perspective is this. Obviously, from the firm perspective, they love that. The scenario you’re explaining, if they could flip a light switch, if LPL or Schwab could flip a light switch tomorrow and go from 100% sweeps revenue to 100% platform fee revenue, I believe they would do it. But there is a concern about how advisor attrition or movement is impacted if and when you implement a platform fee. So what are your thoughts on if a firm does this, do we see a whole bunch of advisors all of a sudden jump ship? You’re going to turn around and ask me the same question. I know. Steve Chubak: No, I know. I was about to say that actually. And you’re certainly familiar with some of the firms that have introduced a platform fee in the past. We saw this a couple of years ago from Rockefeller. I know Ed Jones had introduced one. And what we tried to do actually as part of our advisor migration analysis or advisor on the move analysis is look at whether we saw any evidence of some slowdown in advisor recruitment, some slowdown in organic growth, and there were really no tangible signs of that. I think there were little evidence of any sort of disruption here. I think it speaks to the fact that the advisors recognize that the firms do need to get paid for the services that are being rendered, and at the same time, they’re going to focus more on the platforms that have high-quality service, high-quality tech. I don’t think a three to five basis point platform fee, especially when your clients are getting paid more competitive rates on cash, is going to deter you from joining or affiliating with a specific firm. Jason Diamond: You didn’t ask, but I will give you my perspective. I agree with you. I take a somewhat nuanced approach here, which is there is a big difference between a basis point and six basis points, and I am curious to see… The other piece of this I’m watching closely is the lack of a first mover advantage. So if one firm, let’s say it’s LPL, decides to go this route, do we immediately see a whole bunch of other firms following suit? I think part of that dictates, and how large of a fear, how large of a change are we talking about, probably dictates a lot of the response. As a whole though, I agree with you. I think we probably look at this a year or two years from now and just call it a necessary structural change of something that needed to happen in our industry. Let’s pivot to M&A. It’s been a little bit of a quiet year in terms of major headline news, but at the time of this recording, a couple of weeks back was Altruist Vanguard announcement, which is probably the biggest one I can think of this year being 2026. Give me your thoughts on Altruist Vanguard. What does it mean for Schwab and Fidelity and the RIA space as a whole? Steve Chubak: Yeah, it’s a really interesting transaction. Candidly, it wasn’t one that was on my bingo card for this year. And I should start off by saying I have a tremendous amount of respect for the Altruist team and what Jason has built. The fact of the matter is this has been a really dominant oligopoly for an extended period of time within the RIA space. They’re one of the few names that were really able to break in, but they’ve been able to have success with that smaller RIA cohort. And I believe there are about 6,000 some odd advisor teams that are on the platform. I haven’t seen explicit AUC numbers, but I believe that the average size is about anywhere from 100 million plus or minus. That would imply about 50 to 75 billion of aggregate AUC on the Altruist platform. And for context, that equates to about 1% of AUC at Schwab. I’d also point out that Schwab has actually recruited more in AUC in each of the last two quarters than the aggregate size of Altruist, just to offer some perspective here. So while I do think Altruist is going to have some success moving up market, they benefit from being able to leverage deep pockets. They certainly are known for being a very tech-forward firm, so I do think they’re going to have success. At the same time, I think they’re going to have success with some of those smaller RIAs still, and Schwab is going to continue to have a fairly dominant position amongst some of the larger RIA teams. Jason Diamond: Is that because Schwab, and let’s call it Fidelity as 1A or 1B, is that because they’ve just become kind of the default options or is there something you feel that they just do better than everybody else? Steve Chubak: I think the breadth of the offering is something that’s really unmatched, and actually, we just had the opportunity to meet with Schwab management. I thought Rick actually articulated that really well. I think he’s also keenly aware of some of the products that are in very strong demand and doing what’s needed to try and offer that in a responsible way. And probably the best example here would be the RIA long short offering, which AQR popularized, which is the demand is incredibly strong. We’ve seen a number of firms that have slowed the pace of growth of late, and that’s simply to manage around some operational difficulties like sourcing some of the borrow. I don’t want to get too in the weeds here, but that’s an example of the type of product where there’s strong RIA demand and Schwab found a way to offer it, and they’re still focused on still being responsible about growing said product, but at the same time, still having that as a driver of accelerating RIA flows. And that’s one of the reasons why even since the Altruist Vanguard deal was announced, what we’re seeing and hearing suggests that RIA flows, at least on the Schwab platform, have remained incredibly robust and resilient throughout. Jason Diamond: So let me ask you this question. I’m going to put you on the spot here. It sounds, based on your comments, there’s some firms, particularly the bigger firms, that you are bullish on. Do you agree with this statement that in 10 years, let’s say, whatever the timeframe is, the wealth management world is dominated by Morgan in the W2 space, Schwab in the independent space, and maybe LPL in the broker dealer space. Is that the world we’re heading towards? Steve Chubak: Yeah, I do think that those three names across those individual channels are going to be consolidators of share. I just think Morgan Stanley, in particular, it’s certainly viewed as the strongest platform within the wirehouse channel amongst many of the investors we engage with. I think they were certainly the most innovative when it came to deploying AI, and every time I engage with Jed about some of their efforts on the technology side, they are clearly pioneers in many different areas. I think Workplace in particular is probably the channel that I’m most bullish on in terms of value prop, growth prospects, but also the cost of asset and acquisition being so much lower within that channel. And so, I feel like they built a really strong ecosystem there. LPL, similarly, I think has just been very innovative in their approach within the IBD channel, whether it’s liquidity and succession, whether it’s their strategic wealth services offering, which serves as somewhat of a hybrid offering to attract some of those wirehouse advisors, and they’ve done a really nice job there. Then, from Schwab’s perspective, they are the behemoth in the RIA space, but I think because of the breadth of the offering, because of the investments they’re making on the technology side, as well as on the product side, that’s going to enable them to have a really dominant position. I think the beauty of Schwab’s competitive position is that even if they’re growing in line with the rest of the RIA industry, that’s still going to support high single-digit to low double-digit AUC growth year to year, just given the structural tailwinds in terms of migration from W-2 to independent, no one knows this better than you, Jason, remains firmly intact. Jason Diamond: It’s hard to poke holes in anything you said. It does feel a little bit like the rich get richer. Again, not to put you on the spot, but will you venture some maybe bearish names, or even if you don’t want to give names, any pockets of the industry that are causing you some anxiety or concern right now? Steve Chubak: I’m always more cautious just on… I mean, this is the opportunity, admittedly, for many of the public names that I cover. On a lot of the PE sponsor-backed names, I always just question, given higher levels of leverage that they employ, particularly in a higher for longer interest rate backdrop as we’re bracing for incremental hikes, and then just questions around what the end game is for some of the private equity firms that actually own many of these names. I don’t necessarily feel like they have the same long-term commitment to match some of the others, and therein lies the opportunity for the likes of whether it’s LPL or Ray Jay to potentially recruit from some of those firms. I think one of the really interesting debates that’s happening now, Jason, is there are some firms that have drawn a clear line in the sand. Whether it’s in Ameriprise, I might even throw Stifel into the mix, that have said, “We are not going to compete with some of these aggressive TA packages. We just don’t believe that the returns, the paybacks are sufficiently compelling.” Whereas there are quite a few other firms, whether it’s LPL, Raymond James- Jason Diamond: Ray J. Steve Chubak: … indicated to us that they can still underwrite a lot of these advisor teams to very attractive IRRs, attractive paybacks, and because of that, they’re going to continue to recruit and recruit fairly aggressively. So there’s definitely different stances that some of the individual firms have taken. They’re still all very committed to the space. I think the willingness to at least match some of the more aggressive TA offers that are out there, we’ve definitely seen greater dispersion on that front. Jason Diamond: So who’s right? I have a very clear point of view. I’ll go first. I believe that firms have been making fun of how high TA have been when they were 100% in W-2 land. So to me, it’s like I use the old quip of democracy is the worst form of government besides all others. TA is the worst form of recruiting besides all others. Who is right? Do you believe that the cautious capitals expensive approach is ultimately going to bear fruit long-term or is it better just to write these ever-increasing recruiting deals? Steve Chubak: No, I do think the firms need to employ discipline here, and there is an efficient frontier that can be had. So this is something we actually unpacked recently after we met with LPL management. And to be clear, this is not their view. This is my personal view and my team’s view that I don’t necessarily need to see LPL grow organically 10% and, as a result, see much weaker free cash flow conversion because that’s something that is getting increasingly scrutinized by the investor community. And so, for us, the efficient frontier is still healthy levels of organic growth at, let’s call it, mid to high single-digit, but being able to marry that with strong free cash flow conversion, what we’ve seen historically is if you have a good balance of both of those items, it’s typically translated into better stock performance, better earnings growth over time. And so, I do think that there’s a balance here to be had. It’s not simply try to maximize TA, match the most competitive offers that are out there in the marketplace. You do have to strike a balance where you still want to continue to grow, focus on organic growth, but not necessarily try to maximize organic growth at the risk of weaker free cash flow conversion. Jason Diamond: I heard an interesting quote on this from a unnamed executive at an unnamed big firm who basically said, “If you are the firm that writes the biggest check, you get the advisors that chase the biggest check.” And I think there’s something to that too, is that firms have become a little bit, I don’t know, gun shy is the right word, but a little bit mindful of the fact that the type of advisor who is likely to take a big check or the biggest possible check is also potentially the type of advisor that might move again. And I’m not villainizing taking the check. I believe advisors deserve to be compensated. It’s risky to move, it’s a hassle to move, but I do think we’re seeing, from our perspective, firms are definitely getting more selective. I don’t know if it’s because cash has gotten more expensive, just because there is a lot of scrutiny on this, but firms are definitely getting more selective about how they deploy max TA packages, max transition assistance packages. Do you agree? Steve Chubak: I certainly agree, but now, Jason, it’s my opportunity to put you on the spot since I’m curious as some of these firms have to underwrite TA packages that have a very long duration, and we are entering a period where agentic AI is front and center. And there’s a lot of concern that firms aren’t going to adequately handicap the risk of monetization pressures, whether that’s lower fee rates on advisory fees over time. I’m not speaking over the next year or two, but given the long duration of some of these TA agreements, how are companies at least handicapping that risk? Jason Diamond: I think it’s a very real risk for deals that were put on the books before firms had any of this on their radar in particular. That’s what I worry about. I think now, firms have a pretty good sense that this is coming, some of these cash dynamics you’re talking about, potentially even some of these AI risks where their advisors are just going to be slightly less profitable. But I do worry a little bit about firms that wrote 11 to 13-year deals four years ago. I will say this, the bull market has solved for a lot of this headache because advisors who grow just make these deals attractive. That’s what we’ve seen is that even these deals that seemed expensive at the time, we’ve seen astronomical growth from some advisors, X market even at a lot of these firms, and then those deals look good in hindsight. I absolutely worry that if we see a prolonged or a sustained kind of neutral to down market, I think these firms wrote deals to high enough IRR numbers that I’m not like, “Oh my God, I’m crying poor.” But I could see a world where firms have to take a write-down on some of their recruits like they’re just not as profitable as they originally envisioned. What are your thoughts? Steve Chubak: Yeah, I think that’s right. We’ve done the IRR math ourselves. I think what we’ve seen, I alluded to some of these numbers earlier, payback periods have probably been extended by about a year. The IRRs have contracted by about 500 basis points, but there are names that could still underwrite to IRRs that are in the upper teens to 20% type range. And I should also note that analysis, since I want to be completely transparent, I had a bunch of clients who complained about it because we evaluated it on a timeline of seven years, but there are advisors who are going to stay on the platform beyond the TA agreement. And if anything, that maybe understates at least some of the returns that can be underwritten by these firms over time. Jason Diamond: Absolutely agree. And I think, look, I don’t worry, at least this is my personal view, I don’t so much worry about the fee compression risk of the agentic just because I think firms have gotten really good at avoiding it. I do worry a little bit about are advisors going to have to start offering a lot more? Are you going to need bigger teams? Just things that, in general, impact firm profitability. But I have a hard time believing. I’d be curious to hear your thoughts. Do you think there’s a world where advisors who are now charging 1% to clients are all of a sudden going to have to start charging 30 bps because of AI? Steve Chubak: I think there’s going to be some marginal pricing pressure, particularly in areas like brokerage. The beauty is that we’ve already been seeing over the last 5 to 10 years a migration to advisory where the pricing and fee rates are much more resilient. And it’s one of the reasons why if you look at asset management fee rates, since the emergence of passive ETFs, they’ve only moved in one direction and that’s steadily lower. Whereas on the wealth side, while brokerage fee rates have come down, what we’ve actually seen on the advisory side is far greater resiliency over time. So that does instill some greater confidence, at least on our part, that the pricing is going to be more resilient. I’d also point out that a lot of the products that are in much stronger demand, someone who covers the alts, certainly the growth in retail alternatives, the proliferation of retail alts, despite some of the recent agita and concerns around the BDC space, the reality is private equity, secondaries, infra funds, they’re in very strong demand. They do generate uncorrelated returns, and especially given how active a lot of these firms will be, and this is where we’re spending a lot of time now in fact, Jason, on the AI data center financing opportunity that as more money is allocated by the retail community to alternatives, that’s also accretive for pricing and for earnings for a lot of the firms as well. So there’s a lot of different trends that we’re seeing in terms of product demand, where companies are pivoting to. And I think Schwab is the best example here where their revenue as a percentage of client assets, which to me is really the litmus test or barometer for how much value you’re providing to the end client, they stack up as best in class on that front. But it also speaks to the fact that they probably have more room to adjust pricing, and they’ve done that in select areas. They’ve raised the SAN threshold, for example, and they’ve taken those actions to at least protect and preserve some of their pricing power, which frankly, I think they’ve earned just given the sheer amount of value they offer based on this metric. Jason Diamond: The other concern we hear, and maybe you don’t model out this far, the other concern we hear is, I agree. My parents are 60 years old, and my advisor can keep charging my parents 1%, but eventually, the kids are going to take over the money and they’re going to have a very different experience with the advisor, with the money, with the fee relationship. Do you give any thought to that, that there’s this great wealth transfer that could be 20 years from… I mean, you have to put some weight to that if you’re modeling out discounted cash flow stock prices, right? Steve Chubak: No, I think that’s certainly fair. Now, at the same time, there are some historical paradigms that do give me some comfort here. So the best example would be the emergence of robo-advisors. And I remember back in 2013 where everyone expected that 20% of millennial assets were going to be managed in some sort of robo offering, and that number today I believe is about 1%- Jason Diamond: Really? Steve Chubak: … of what source you use of the aggregate retail TAM over a decade later. So I think what we’ve learned over time is that people do value advice, human intervention. I know there’s a lot of advisors in the audience. We’re not just at least trying to appease them. I think there’s clear evidence based on some of the historical trends that people want human advice. They want at least some human participation to help even from a handholding perspective. And I will tell you as someone who tried to leverage at least an LLM recently to forego having to pay a lawyer, I got about 75 to 80% of the way there. And that last 20%, I was incredibly uncomfortable and made the determination that DIY might not be the right approach for that sort of thing. And I feel, frankly, similarly on advice that there’s a lot of tax optimization and complexity. There’s a lot of complexity around trusts where people don’t necessarily want to delegate that simply to an agentic tool. Jason Diamond: So you just nailed it, and I love the lawyer analogy because I think it’s high-level professional services, and I think this is more true, the larger your client base is in terms of average clients like more sophisticated clients. I just feel we have this moat and this kind of immunity to a lot of this, and somebody’s going to play this back in 10 years and laugh at me in the face, but to me, it feels like an area. It’s not like my Fios box broke, and I’m okay. I’m comfortable with an AI agent there. It feels like an area that is insulated because to your point, that last 20% is what matters the most and it’s what people seem to value. It gives me comfort too, I will say. We’ve got time for a few more. You mentioned KPIs, key performance indicators. When you look at a company, let’s say I give you two minutes with the company’s financials, what do you look at? What does your mind immediately go to? Is there a certain metric or metrics that you think are the most telling these days? Steve Chubak: Sure. Organic growth first and foremost. As much as I wish that if any of the companies are listening, that they would break out same store versus new store growth, frankly, there’s just been less disclosure around that given some of the heightened competition, but even organic growth at the headline level is certainly something that we focus on. Operating leverage, so as revenues continue to scale, it’s nice that we’re in a bull market. It’s nice that there are significant interest rate tailwinds that are benefiting these firms, but how are they striking that balance between investing for growth and allowing some of that windfall to hit the bottom line? We usually like to see a better balance there. If a company’s compounding revenues at 15% and growing expenses at 2% and the rest of the competition is growing at 5 to 8% in terms of cost growth, that’s something that does not sit well with us because that is a temporary boost to earnings that certainly isn’t going to be durable or sustainable. Jason Diamond: Let me ask you two more questions. I think you and I first started speaking about cash sweeps. It’s probably 18 months ago, which is certainly long before it was on the radar of a lot of advisors and clients. Do you have something else that’s in the back of your mind as this is the next big thing that people aren’t talking enough about? Steve Chubak: I do think this is certainly the next shoe to drop, just given even what’s taking place today with the reaction to the number or the quantum of Meta Muse downloads and what the implications are for financial services broadly. The wealth names are selling off a bit more than some others. You actually saw some insurance brokers sell off yesterday. So anyone that is in services industry or in financial services where there’s a perception that there might be some risk to pricing or monetization, there is certainly an acute sensitivity to that amongst investors at the moment. I would say there are a lot of interesting dynamics that we’re looking at certainly ahead of our wealth conference. I would say certainly, to self-clear or to not self-clear as some of these larger firms continue to scale because do you want to have full ownership of the data? Do you want to ensure that you can maintain all of the different monetization streams within your ecosystem rather than at least having some of that go to the Pershings or Broadridges of the world? I think it’s a really interesting debate just given how valuable that data becomes in an AI world and some of the self-clearing entities potentially being able to leverage that. I’ve never really seen a sufficiently compelling value prop where a firm would go down the path of something that’s highly disruptive like converting to self-clearing. We’ve seen only a handful of instances where that’s happened, but I do think AI and, frankly, the importance of data is changing at least some of that calculus for different firms. Jason Diamond: Yeah. And I think maybe some of the Commonwealth LPL reaction too, I’m seeing some of the non-self-clearing reaction there, too. Commonwealth LPL somewhat intentionally because I want to end with, we spoke a little bit about M&A in the light of Vanguard, but I think going into the year, there were some thoughts of there’s some names. You mentioned Stifel. We’ve talked a little bit about UBS, a little bit about Citi. There’s some names that make sense, at least maybe a little bit. Any M&A news that you’re watching either this year or further ahead? Steve Chubak: It’s a little tough, Jason, because I am precluded from putting any companies in play, but I’ll least speak to what’s been put out in the public domain. Look, for a company like Stifel, I know that there was certainly some speculation that Raymond James might be interested. I don’t know. Ron K. seems to be very happy with what he’s doing. In fact, even at our conference last year in JESS, he took a fake phone call from a journalist to say we’re not for sale. Jason Diamond: I remember that. Steve Chubak: It is something where we’ve seen a number of firms like that that are trading at 10 times, and this is an earnings number, not even EBITDA multiple. So 10 times earnings, historically very discounted multiples. Some of that I think is a function of the AI concerns that are percolating in the marketplace, but if anything, there’s never been a better time to at least source attractive targets in the wealth space, at least in the public domain, given the multiples that the group is trading at today. I think that’s one of the bigger surprises too, Jason, since you mentioned a couple of other things we’re thinking about that come to mind. One, I mentioned Workplace, and there aren’t a lot of obvious corporate stock plan targets, but I do think there are quite a few firms that we’ve spoken with who want to be larger in the retirement space. And so, I do think that’s an area where you might see firms look to expand inorganically over time. That certainly wouldn’t surprise me given it’s still highly fragmented, and there are a lot of scale players in the wealth space that are still too small within retirement specifically. So that’s certainly something that we are monitoring quite closely. The last thing I’d say about just wealth M&A in general, at least amongst strategics versus, say, some of the PE or sponsor-backed purchasers, you have to buy it twice, right? Jason Diamond: Twice. Steve Chubak: That’s always the hesitancy or reluctance on the part of some of the public names in acquiring a strategic or public competitor is the fact that you’re buying the property, and then you also have to retain all the advisors. And when you actually layer all of that into the deal consideration, some of these deals start to get much too expensive. But we still see quite a few acquisitions, at least amongst the privates. I think the biggest surprise to me is that we haven’t seen more convergence yet between private and public multiple in the wealth space. Jason Diamond: Yeah, we’ve seen a couple take privates. Yeah, I don’t disagree with you. I just thought of another one that I want to end on. This is a quick bonus round question. Steve Chubak: Of course. Jason Diamond: What is the number one inbound topic you get? Is it AI? It is for us these days. I’m just curious. Steve Chubak: It is primarily AI. I think it’s really about all of the game theory, candidly, Jason, that we had walked through where whether it’s LPL has been speculated as potentially being a first mover on making changes to cash monetization, the reality is that certainly, someone else could be that brave soul that ends up being the first mover here instead of LPL, but trying to think through the game theory in terms of how do other firms respond? Does this drive broader sweeping changes in terms of pricing? Is it isolated just to the IBD channel, or does it extend to the wires and the pure RIAs as well? There’s a lot of really interesting debate that’s taking place on that front. It’s all AI or AI adjacent. I would just say that it’s definitely cash, but it’s also the game theory and the knock-on effects for others that’s getting quite a bit of focus too that people are trying to navigate here. Jason Diamond: Yeah, that’s exactly what I was going to say, the knock-on effects because it’s, okay, fine, we have this giant topic of AI, but then gaming out how it’s going to impact cash sweeps and monetization and advisor fees and advisor productivity and advisor movement, that’s where the fun begins. So we’ll have to invite you back. This is a topic that’s evolving very rapidly. So I know next year, we’ll probably have an entirely new slate of topics to talk about, but this has been a ton of fun and a really interesting different perspective from a largely institutional seat. So thank you for sharing your wisdom and expertise with us, Steve. It was a pleasure. Steve Chubak: You’ve been a tremendous partner of ours too, so thanks so much for having me on and always enjoy engaging on this topic. Goes without saying. Jason Diamond: Thank you. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibility seriously and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook .

October 15, 2026Episode 38151 min

The Trust Behind the Transition: UBS Breakaways on What It Takes to Move $1B in a Matter of Months

Michael Lee & Steve Armaly—Founders & Managing Partners, Ox Road Capital After leaving UBS to launch Ox Road Capital, Michael Lee, Steve Armaly, and their partners crossed $1B in AUM in just 225 days. They share how years of client trust, partner alignment, and a client-first vision helped make an extraordinary transition possible. In Summary When Michael Lee, Steve Armaly, and their partners left UBS to launch Ox Road Capital, they walked out the door without client information or a single dollar in assets at their new firm. Just 225 days later, Ox Road crossed $1B in AUM. But that extraordinary result was years in the making. Mike and Steve join Mindy to share the story behind the transition: why a highly successful $1.2B UBS team decided its vision had outgrown the employee model, how four partners worked through very different perspectives to reach alignment, and why they ultimately chose independence over the significant recruiting economics available elsewhere. They also discuss the realities of leaving a non-Protocol firm, how clients responded, and why years spent building trusted relationships became one of their most valuable assets during the transition. Today, with approximately $1.1B in AUM, a 93% retention rate, six additional team members, and a growing new-business pipeline, Ox Road is beginning to realize the larger vision behind the move: greater control over resources, technology, marketing, staffing, and the client experience. The Storyline For Mike, the idea of independence dates back to 2009. The entrepreneurial instinct was there, but the infrastructure, economics, and timing weren’t. He joined UBS instead and, over the next 16 years, helped build an extraordinarily successful business. Steve had a similar entrepreneurial streak. Together with partners Brian Blackburn and Jeff Allen, they built an integrated team around financial planning, client service, and portfolio management—and a belief that people perform best when they can “soar with their strengths.” Success, however, eventually created a different question: Could the business they wanted to build continue to thrive within the structure of a traditional firm? Their answer did not come quickly or unanimously. The four partners spent roughly a year working toward alignment, at one point turning to an outside counselor to help them navigate differences that threatened a partnership they considered more important than any particular firm or business model. Once aligned, their priority became clear: Any move had to make things better for clients first. With Diamond Consultants helping them understand a rapidly evolving landscape and evaluate the range of available options, the team ultimately chose to build Ox Road Capital through LPL Strategic Wealth Services. Then came the real test. Leaving non-Protocol UBS meant walking out without client information and trusting that years of doing right by clients would matter. The response offered a powerful answer: Ox Road crossed $1B in AUM just 225 days later. The story is ultimately less about how quickly $1B moved than about everything that happened before it could: years of service, transparency, partnership, and trust. Topics Covered Why Mike first considered independence in 2009—and why the timing wasn’t right The meaning behind the Ox Road name and its connection to humility, service, sacrifice, hard work, and teamwork How four partners built an integrated team around complementary strengths Why partner alignment became one of the hardest parts of the decision When their successful UBS practice began to outgrow the employee model Why serving clients better became the team’s “true north” The economics of choosing long-term ownership over a large recruiting package How the independence landscape has evolved for billion-dollar wirehouse teams Diamond Consultants’ role in helping the team understand and narrow the opportunity set The risks and realities of leaving a non-Protocol firm How years of client trust contributed to a 93% retention rate Why they selected LPL Strategic Wealth Services How greater control is changing staffing, technology, marketing, and the client experience Ox Road’s plans for organic growth and M&A > Download a transcript of this episode… Listen and Learn Highlights for Advisors Why four successful partners weren’t immediately aligned around independence. (12:09) Mike and Steve describe their unusually close partnership, why they make major decisions unanimously, and what happened when the prospect of leaving UBS exposed differences they had never confronted before. When a successful wirehouse practice can begin to outgrow its environment. (17:11) They explain how a desire to build an enduring enterprise, mentor the next generation, and invest more heavily in white-glove service created growing friction with the limitations of the employee model. Why the client had to come first in any decision to move. (26:25) Steve explains the principle that ultimately aligned the partners: A move could improve their own lives, but it first had to create a better experience for their clients. How they evaluated independence—and the economics they were willing to leave behind. (27:49) The partners discuss the financial and personal considerations behind choosing ownership for the long term rather than pursuing a significant recruiting package. What it means to leave a non-Protocol firm with nothing. (32:19) Mike and Steve describe the legal guidance, uncertainty, and leap of faith involved in leaving UBS without client information—and why clarity around their decision helped them manage the risk. How years of client trust helped move $1B in 225 days. (33:32) The team started Ox Road with zero AUM. Mike and Steve explain how clients responded, why there was no elaborate “pitch,” and how years of comprehensive planning, transparency, and service created goodwill long before the transition. What independence has allowed them to change. (39:20) From building their own technology stack to redirecting resources, expanding marketing, and adding staff, Mike and Steve share how greater control is allowing them to “level up” the client experience. Why they chose LPL Strategic Wealth Services. (42:15) Mike explains why the partners wanted control over the P&L, staffing, branding, marketing, and resource allocation while relying on LPL for areas such as cybersecurity and compliance. What’s next for Ox Road Capital. (45:51) With the first-year transition behind them, the partners are turning toward the next phase of the enterprise, including continued organic growth and potential M&A. The advice they’d give advisors who are afraid to make a change. (46:45) Steve returns to the principle at the heart of their story: Honor the client-advisor relationship, understand why you’re considering change, surround yourself with trusted counsel, and don’t underestimate the value of relationships built through years of serving clients well. Key Takeaways Trust is built long before it is tested. Ox Road’s $1B transition didn’t happen in 225 days. In many ways, it took decades. Mike and Steve attribute the outcome to years of comprehensive planning, consistent communication, transparency, and putting clients first. When the team announced its departure, clients already understood who their advisors were and how they made decisions. Partner alignment deserves as much attention as firm selection. For a multi-partner team, determining where to go may be easier than agreeing on whether to go. Ox Road’s four partners spent roughly a year working through different risk tolerances, life circumstances, and priorities before reaching unanimity. Protecting the partnership remained their highest priority throughout the process. The independence opportunity set has changed dramatically. Mike first considered independence in 2009 but concluded that the operational and financial hurdles were too great. Years later, the team discovered not only that the ecosystem had matured, but that the range of models and support structures had evolved substantially even within the previous five years. Ownership was about control, not simply economics. The team could have pursued a significant recruiting package elsewhere. Instead, they wanted the ability to decide how revenue would be reinvested into people, technology, marketing, and client service—and to build an enterprise designed to outlive its founders. Independence doesn’t have to mean doing everything yourself. Ox Road wanted control over the areas it considered essential while avoiding responsibility for functions such as cybersecurity and compliance. LPL Strategic Wealth Services offered a model that allowed the partners to own and operate their business while leveraging outside scale and infrastructure. https://youtu.be/uMAB3lYqPo8 Quotable Moments On partnership: “Our arms are locked together as four partners.” On what ultimately mattered most: “Everything had to point to it being better for the client.” On making a non-Protocol move: “It was a leap of faith to do that because you literally have to walk out with nothing. And we did.” On the difficulty of transition: “Nothing good is easy and transitioning isn’t easy, but it is certainly worth it.” On the foundation for a successful transition: “So much of the hard work is just in how you’ve been running your business that allows you to transition well.” On client loyalty: “It truly is the relationship between the client and the advisor.” On what clients did after the move: “They’ve rallied around us where we have always rallied around them.” On ownership and control: “The ability to control the P&L, the hiring and firing, the allocation of resources, the marketing, the branding—all of the things that were of paramount importance to us—we can do.” On the next chapter: “We have a responsibility to be difference makers.” FAQs Why did the Ox Road Capital team leave UBS? The partners believed the business they wanted to build was becoming increasingly difficult to operate within a traditional employee model. They wanted greater control over staffing, technology, marketing, resource allocation, and the client experience while building an enduring enterprise they could own. How much did Ox Road Capital manage when it left UBS? The team managed approximately $1.2B at UBS. After launching Ox Road Capital, it crossed $1B in AUM 225 days later and reported approximately $1.1B in AUM at the time of the interview. How did Ox Road Capital move $1B after leaving a non-Protocol firm? Because UBS is not part of the Broker Protocol, the advisors left without taking client information and followed legal counsel regarding what they could and could not do. Mike and Steve credit years of comprehensive planning, transparency, consistent service, and trusted client relationships with helping clients make their own decisions about following the team. What was Ox Road Capital’s client retention rate after leaving UBS? Steve says the firm estimates it retained approximately 93% of existing clients and assets. He also says the firm’s pipeline for prospective new clients has never been larger. Why did the team choose independence instead of another wirehouse? Although a team of its size could have pursued substantial recruiting economics at another traditional firm, the partners were focused on long-term ownership and control. They wanted greater freedom to determine how resources were invested and how the enterprise would evolve. Why did Ox Road Capital choose LPL Strategic Wealth Services? The partners wanted control over their P&L, staffing, resource allocation, marketing, and branding without taking on every operational responsibility themselves. They specifically cite cybersecurity and compliance as areas where they wanted the resources and scale of a larger partner. How did four partners get aligned around such a significant decision? Not quickly—and not without some difficulty. The partners spent roughly a year working through their different perspectives and even engaged an outside counselor for a two-day session. Their commitment to keeping the partnership together ultimately provided the foundation for reaching a unanimous decision. What does the name Ox Road Capital mean? The ox represents qualities the partners aspire to embody, including humility, service, sacrifice, hard work, strength, and teamwork. “Road” reflects their view of life and business as a journey in which their paths intersect with those of clients, team members, and others along the way. What is next for Ox Road Capital? With the transition largely behind them, the partners are focused on growing the enterprise. Mike says that includes continued organic growth as well as potential mergers and acquisitions, guided by their belief that the firm has a responsibility to be a “difference maker.” The partners believed the business they wanted to build was becoming increasingly difficult to operate within a traditional employee model. They wanted greater control over staffing, technology, marketing, resource allocation, and the client experience while building an enduring enterprise they could own. The team managed approximately $1.2B at UBS. After launching Ox Road Capital, it crossed $1B in AUM 225 days later and reported approximately $1.1B in AUM at the time of the interview. Because UBS is not part of the Broker Protocol, the advisors left without taking client information and followed legal counsel regarding what they could and could not do. Mike and Steve credit years of comprehensive planning, transparency, consistent service, and trusted client relationships with helping clients make their own decisions about following the team. Steve says the firm estimates it retained approximately 93% of existing clients and assets. He also says the firm’s pipeline for prospective new clients has never been larger. Although a team of its size could have pursued substantial recruiting economics at another traditional firm, the partners were focused on long-term ownership and control. They wanted greater freedom to determine how resources were invested and how the enterprise would evolve. The partners wanted control over their P&L, staffing, resource allocation, marketing, and branding without taking on every operational responsibility themselves. They specifically cite cybersecurity and compliance as areas where they wanted the resources and scale of a larger partner. Not quickly—and not without some difficulty. The partners spent roughly a year working through their different perspectives and even engaged an outside counselor for a two-day session. Their commitment to keeping the partnership together ultimately provided the foundation for reaching a unanimous decision. The ox represents qualities the partners aspire to embody, including humility, service, sacrifice, hard work, strength, and teamwork. “Road” reflects their view of life and business as a journey in which their paths intersect with those of clients, team members, and others along the way. With the transition largely behind them, the partners are focused on growing the enterprise. Mike says that includes continued organic growth as well as potential mergers and acquisitions, guided by their belief that the firm has a responsibility to be a “difference maker.” Related Resources Partnerships: 10 Questions to Help Identify if You’re Still Right for Each Other 10 questions that can help advisors determine the “health” of their partnerships and decide how best to move forward. Transition Announcement: UBS Team Managing $1.25B Launch an Independent Firm with LPL Strategic Wealth A highly accomplished team from UBS – Jeff Allen, Steve Armaly, Brian Blackburn, and Mike Lee – has launched Ox Road Capital, a new independent firm based in Greenville, SC, with guidance from Diamond Consultants. When the Partnership Still Works, But One Partner Wants More Even the strongest financial advisor partnerships can reach a crossroads when partners want different things for the next chapter. Michael S. Lee, CEPA® Founder, Managing Partner Mike has more than 24 years of experience in financial services, focusing on high-net-worth and ultra-high-net-worth individuals, families, and private foundations. He applies sophisticated wealth management techniques to financial planning, trust and estate planning, philanthropic services, concentrated stock management, and tax mitigation strategies. Prior employers include UBS, JPMorgan Chase, and Comerica Bank. Mike is also nationally recognized for his knowledge and perspective on investments, being quoted in The Wall Street Journal, The Palm Beach Post, The Sun Sentinel, Palm Beach Illustrated Magazine, and The Greenville Business Magazine. He has also shared investment insights on a number of radio and TV shows, including an 11-year stint co-hosting “Wealth and Wisdom,” a TV show on PBS (WXEL South Florida) focused on educating the community. Graduating cum laude from Palm Beach Atlantic University with a B.S. in Business Administration and a concentration in Finance, Mike is also a graduate of the Florida Bankers Association’s 3-year Florida Trust School. He is a Certified Exit Planning Advisor (CEPA®) and holds Series 7, 9, 24, and 66 registrations through LPL Financial. Mike moved to Greenville, SC in 2009 with his wife, Stacey, and daughter, Brooke. He’s a former Trustee of Palm Beach Atlantic University, a Director of the Albert E. and Birdie W. Einstein Fund, former Trustee for the Governor’s School of the Arts Foundation Board, former board member for Impact Sports International, and a graduate of Leadership Greenville Class 38. Steve N. Armaly Founder, Managing Partner With over 20 years of experience serving clients, Steve oversees all new relationships and financial planning for the team. Fueled by a passion for both analytics and helping people, his prior roles include Senior Vice President and Wealth Advisor at UBS, management consultant at PricewaterhouseCoopers, and financial analyst with Fluor Corporation. Steve graduated from The Citadel in Charleston, SC with a B.S. in Accounting and Business, and has completed more than 150 hours of advanced training in investments, liabilities, insurance, executive compensation, protection strategies, qualified retirement plan and individual retirement account distributions, business succession planning, gifting to children and descendants, charitable gifting, and distribution of wealth at death. He holds Series 7 AND 66 registrations through LPL Financial, as well as life, health, and long-term care insurance licenses. A resident of Greenville, SC, Steve is an avid outdoorsman who loves all the accessible nature in his home state. He’s also a youth football and basketball coach, board member for local schools, and attends Saint Mary’s Catholic Church. Steve and his wife, Kristen, have four children: Thomas, Elizabeth, Lauren, and Matthew. NOTE: The views and opinions expressed by the guests on this podcast are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Diamond Consultants. Neither Diamond Consultants nor the guests on this podcast are compensated in any way for their participation. View the transcript of this episode… The Trust Behind the Transition: UBS Breakaways on What It Takes to Move $1B in a Matter of Months A conversation with Mindy Diamond and Michael Lee and Steve Armaly, Founders and Managing Partners at Ox Road Capital. Mindy Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is, The Trust Behind the Transition: UBS Breakaways on What It Takes to Move $1B in a Matter of Months. It’s a conversation with Michael Lee and Steve Armaly, founders and managing partners of Ox Road Capital. I’m Mindy Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transition. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual Advisor Transition Report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions, to download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Trust is at the center of every advisor-client relationship, but it’s one thing to believe your clients trust you and another to make a move that puts that belief to the test. That was certainly true for my guest today, Michael Lee and Steve Armaly, founders and managing partners of Ox Road Capital. Along with their partners, Brian Blackburn and Jeff Allen, Mike and Steve had built an extraordinarily successful $1.2 billion business at UBS. Yet over time, they came to believe that the business they wanted to build and the level of white glove service they wanted to provide required greater control over how they invested in their team, technology and client experience. But getting four partners aligned around a move of this magnitude wasn’t easy. Neither was leaving a non-protocol firm walking out the door without client information and trusting that the relationships they had spent years building were strong enough to follow. We had the privilege of helping Mike, Steve, and their partners evaluate their options and ultimately launch Ox Road Capital through LPL Strategic Wealth Services. And what happened next speaks to volumes. They crossed the billion dollar mark just 225 days after leaving UBS. Yet what makes their story worth hearing isn’t simply the number. It’s the thoughtfulness behind the decision, the work it took to get four partners aligned, the choice to prioritize long-term ownership over immediate economics, and the conviction that creating a better business could ultimately make their clients’ lives and their own lives better. And perhaps most of all, it’s what they learned about trusting the relationships they had built long before they ever decided to make a move. So if you’ve ever wondered what it really takes to get multiple partners aligned, how to weigh the risks of a non-protocol transition, or whether the relationships you’ve built with clients are strong enough to withstand a move, Mike and Steve offer an unusually candid look at what those questions feel like before, during, and after a breakaway and what they know now that they’re on the other side. So let’s get to it. Mike and Steve, I am so excited you’re here. It feels especially good to have the privilege of interviewing people that we had the privilege of helping to get here. So welcome. Steve Armaly: Thank you. We’re excited to be here. Michael Lee: Very. Mindy Diamond: Terrific. Okay, so let’s start at the beginning obviously, and I’d love to hear just briefly a little bit about your stories. How’d you get here? Michael Lee: I guess the move to independence for me really started back in my mind back before joining UBS in 2009. It was a dream that was planted, kind of went through a life change halftime as it were in career, wanted to slow things down a little bit. So my wife and I actually relocated from South Florida down in Palm Beach County to Greenville back in 2009, left JP Morgan and joined UBS. So basically that idea was formed back then, but just it was wrong time. Mindy Diamond: I’m going to want to unpack that a little more later. Let’s put a pin in that because I love what you just said. That is true of many people. But Steve, let’s hear from you. Steve Armaly: Yes. I made an industry change in 2004, worked in consulting as a management consultant and as a financial analyst upon graduating from the Citadel and always had an entrepreneurial spirit, I grew up in an entrepreneurial family. But my first day at work as an advisor, I knew I was in the right place. I knew I was doing what I was called to do. It felt so different, never felt like work. But ultimately, I think even at the beginning of my career, I had this desire to one day have my own practice or have a practice that I could be a part of as a team where we would have ownership and more control. So I feel like it was in my blood from the very beginning, but it did take us a while to get there. Mindy Diamond: That’s okay. And again, we’ll unpack that a little more later, but thank you. So I want to give our listeners some perspective. A year ago, you guys left UBS, would love for you to tell us how long you were at UBS, but want to hear a little bit about the size of the business, how many employees you have, the kind of clients you serve. And I don’t know, Mike and Steve, if you want to alternate on that, that’s great. Michael Lee: So I’ve been in the business about 36 years. Steve just mentioned when he made the career change. Jeff, one of our partners, has been in financial services for over 25 years. And Brian, the same thing. So all of us have been around for a bit for sure. We left UBS, we had a team of about 11, and since we came over and formed Ox Road, we’ve hired six more folks. So we manage about 1.1 billion is where we are today. We were at 1.2 back before we left the UBS. Mindy Diamond: Got it. Talk to us about the unusual name Ox Road. I’m always fascinated. I like to ask that, particularly when a name is a little less mainstream. Where’d it come from? How’d you come up with it? Michael Lee: Yeah, so it evolved over a period of time. So we used to be known as the Alpha Group. So when in our earliest stages, there were four partners. I’ll let Steve and Jeff argue over whose last name was first, but it was started out as the ALFA Group, A-L-F-A. It was Allen, Lee, there was another gentleman that was a partner of ours, he’s since passed away, his last name was Fort and then Armaly. Or since Steve’s on the call, we’ll say it was Armaly, Lee, Fort, and Allen and give him props. But that’s where it started. And then a few years later we merged with Brian Blackburn, one of our partners, and then there was a retiring FA that was on his team and we rebranded to ALPHA, A-L-P-H-A. Well, totally unrelated to the move. One morning I was having a quiet time and I was reading in Proverbs, Proverbs 14:4, it says, “Where there are no oxen, the manger is clean, but much revenue comes from the strength of an ox.” Well, that’s interesting. What do I do with that? This was written down for extended generations, but I don’t know how to apply it. So that took me down a path of researching the ox. And it turns out the ox appears all throughout the Bible. It was used for sacrifice. It was a beast of burden, worked in teams. So there was this whole idea of an ox and wherever it showed up, it was humility, it was service, it was sacrifice, it was hard work. So all very admirable attributes. So then when I reread that verse and I said, okay, well, where there’s no teamwork, there’s no prosperity, where there’s no hard work, where there’s no sacrifice. So when I read it in terms of what it symbolized or the essence of an ox, then that was attractive to me. So put a pin in that a couple years later, another quiet time I’m reading, in Psalm 1:19, it’s basically an acrostic with the Hebrew alphabet. So each section of that psalm has a letter associated with it. Well, the first letter is Olive, the Hebrew letter A, which also is symbolically tied to the number one. And it’s also, interestingly enough, to the head of an ox. That was the symbol or the emoji for it. So there was this idea that alpha or olive was tied to the head of an ox. So that’s what started the idea of the ox. So then thinking about the journey, we’re on a journey through life. We’re kind of just passing through and our lives intersect with our clients’ lives, with our team members’ lives, with vendors. And we don’t know how long people are going to be in our lives. Sometimes they drop in for just a little bit and sometimes they’re there for an extended period of time, but we’re all kind of on this road. So this idea of Ox Road came. So it was a nod to the past. There was a direct connection to our old name, Alpha, through the symbol of the ox head, but then there was also this idea of a journey that we were moving forward. So it was a nod to our past, but a clear focus on who we were, those attributes that we all aspire to of hard work and sacrifice and the strength and commitment and humility. That was who we were, but then there was also we’re going on a journey and we have absolutely no idea how big this thing’s going to get. So, there you go. Mindy Diamond: Thank you for sharing that and I love how thoughtful it was. A lot of people really struggle with, oh my God, we just have to come up with something creative, but that’s thoughtful and beautiful and thank you for sharing it. Michael Lee: Yeah. Mindy Diamond: So let me ask, you mentioned bringing two teams together, and I know you’ve got partners, Jeff Allen and Brian Blackburn. So you’re running a big team. How do you divide responsibilities? How does that work? Steve Armaly: Well, early on, Mindy, we believed in the concept of giftedness and ideally we’re all created in a unique way by God and we all have some inherent skills that are just our natural abilities. And we also believe that when you spend time in those natural abilities, you’re energized, you’re refreshed, it motivates you, it meets your needs in a way, much like our conversation earlier today with how you guys feel about what you do in helping people find their home. That’s what really motivates us. And when we looked at our business, we felt like there’s three distinct areas of expertise that you need to provide comprehensive wealth management. And those three areas are financial planning, client service, and portfolio management. And what we wanted to do was design a team where you could spend 80% of your skills in that area that you felt you were gifted within one of those three silos and then spend 20% in the others. And it was the idea of soar with your strengths and manage or lean on your teammates to help you better in the areas where you felt you were weak or just felt like you didn’t have that natural skill set in. And so ultimately from starting with the partners, we aligned ourselves within those three pillars and then we built our staff model to fit within those three pillars also. Mindy Diamond: So one of the things that trips a lot of multi-partner teams is that not everybody has the same goals at the same time. So were all four partners aligned as to the desire to be independent at the same time? Michael Lee: Yeah, that was actually an interesting part of our story is while there was a desire to go independent, from a timing standpoint, I don’t know that… Actually we weren’t all on the same page for a period of about a year, but we got there and that’s a story in and of itself. So Steve, I don’t know if you want to add anything to that or not, but we could do a whole podcast just on that piece. Steve Armaly: We really could, Mindy. Well, I’d love to start by saying as a partnership, we truly looked at partnering, and I hate to use the cliche, but the magnitude of making a decision to have a partner for life as in marriage. And we looked at partnering as a process that you would go through courtship where you really got to know each other, your goals, your objectives, your moral compass, and making sure it all aligns. So we felt very unified. We always use the words, our arms are locked together as four partners. We make our decisions in unison. If we can’t get to an answer where we all are on the same page, we pause, we wait, and we continue to contemplate. But I say all of that to enlighten and maybe let you know how much of a challenge it was with the idea of leaving our past firm. And ultimately, I think as Mike said, we had the desire to do it. We had even discussed it, but we knew there was a time and place for that. We had that sort of on the back shelf. Our focus was to design and build the best team we could. And I think we were very focused on that. But when the time came to consider making the move, we did encounter for the first time that we weren’t completely aligned and it scared us. It was the first time ever that we really were in disagreement, the first time that we had some anxiety about the partnership and who was doing what and how this all was going to work. And thankfully during that time, one of our partners, Jeff, was astute enough to say, “Guys, we clearly are not aligned and we’ve got to get realigned.” And we trusted a partner that we’d met over the years who works in counseling to sit with us. And we basically went through a two-day session to get realigned. And in that timeframe, that’s exactly where we landed, but it was not pretty. And there were certainly some moments where I think we all questioned how could something as good as our team be at risk of ceasing. Michael Lee: One thing I wanted to add that was funny that I think we have to draw a light too. So the guy who was the counselor was actually a marriage counselor that we went to see. Mindy Diamond: I love it. That makes sense. Michael Lee: And we sat down with him and he’s like, “All right, guys, this is a little bit out of my wheelhouse. I’ve never counseled four dudes.” And he said, “So just so you know, if this thing goes south, I don’t bear any responsibility at all for your business.” It was great. Mindy Diamond: I love that you just shared that because I want to normalize what you just said. It is exceedingly rare and it makes sense that it’s rare that four partners, two partners, but certainly four, who come from different backgrounds, different ages, different financial stability, different risk tolerance, different whatever it is, different entrepreneurial spirit, different everything, could possibly be at the same place at the same time. And the fact that it only took you a year to realign is unbelievably short. I am working with teams… I think you guys know that we were lucky enough to facilitate the move of the largest breakaway in the industry, the guys in Atlanta, the OpenArc deal. That deal was 10 years in the making, and one of the senior members of the team got there first. He was all in as far as being an entrepreneur. He had the vision, he wanted it, but most of his other partners were either completely no way, no how, non-starter, or at varying degrees of no or lukewarm. It took 10 years to get to the same place. And that doesn’t mean 10 years of active exploration, but to be honest with you, 10 years is a long time. But that notion of it taking time for everybody to be at the same place makes a lot of sense. I want to normalize that and kudos to you for bringing in outside objective help to get there. The second thing is not all partnerships weather the storm or should. Some are very clear like you, the most important true north is that the band stays together. But others say, I’m working with a team right now that says the senior partners says this process of even beginning to think about what we each want and highlighting the differences shows that now I’m thinking about the fact that I’m really the growth engine and I’m resentful of paying X, Y, and Z to partners that don’t grow as fast. So it highlights fractures and a lot of times the band doesn’t stay together nor should they. So kudos to you is my point for only having it taken a year. But I want to ask you a question, which is, so at what point did… It sounds like you both had entrepreneurial DNA, you realized yours, Mike, you said in 2009 you were thinking about it when you left JP Morgan. Steve, you said you come from an entrepreneurial family and it was always there. So it sounds like wrestling with the desire for more freedom was always there or was there for a long time. But at what point for the two of you did being at UBS and being an employee cease to be enough and what drove that? Michael Lee: Yeah, so we’ve tried to be pretty… Where, and I think it was Jeff that really brought this to light, a number of years ago, we would constantly run into other financial services professionals and even other members in other industries that would say, “Hey, we’re having a lot of trouble attracting young talent. We just can’t find good people.” That’s not been our problem. We have had a ton of young people come through our doors, quality individuals, hardworking. We make a very good use of an intern program that we’re really trying to expose people to this industry and things like that. So for whatever reason, we started feeling called like we’re about building legacy. We’re about building something that’s going to outlive us and we’re about pouring into the next gen of advisors through a mentorship or apprenticeship type program. And that in addition to serving our clients the way that we do through our mission, vision and values, we also felt like this was a key thing that we were doing. So that works for a while inside of a W-2 world until it doesn’t, and that’s what we found. Mindy Diamond: UBS, and not just UBS, but any traditional firm is not really looking for you to build your own firm within the firm. They may tell you it’s okay to be entrepreneurial and you’re running your own business, but in the end they own you. And the notion of you actually building your own firm and then wanting the freedom to run it and compensate your staff the way you want to and name it the way you want to and all of that, that’s when you begin to run into friction. Steve, what I’d love for you to answer about that is, so was the move or the desire to go or the goal of going independent, was it more about running away from what was frustrating you at UBS or limiting you at UBS or more about just we were entrepreneurs and there were a million things we wanted to do when we were running towards something? Steve Armaly: Wow, that’s a great question. I hate to answer it this way, but I would say it’s a little bit of both. Again, our DNA, each of us are a little bit different. I probably had the desires for entrepreneurship that were driving me from the beginning, feeling like that was the eventual landing spot was to get there. And we had a meeting, again, leaning on each other, just trying to get a deeper understanding of our motives. We know each other super well, but ultimately there was one conversation that I distinctly remember that I had defined success as eventually having our own firm and absent of that I would feel like we failed in a sense. So I think a lot of that existed, for instance, for me, probably for Mike also, but even in our difficulties of trying to make a decision of where we all stood and where we wanted to go, we got completely realigned. And the one thing that we were very clear on is that this partnership to us was more than the business. It was really a partnership to do life together. And whether we were going to be at UBS or on our own, wherever, we were committed to being together because we all benefited from that as men. Our families benefited from it. We feel like our clients benefited from it. We just became better men by working together and to stay together was our number one priority. But I think over time, it clearly became evident that what we were building would not operate well in our previous environment. We were building something big well as we were doing, and as much as we got all the accolades, we still didn’t necessarily fit in some of the top tiers. But more than anything, the thing that we saw clearly was the way that we wanted to use the resources that we were blessed with in terms of our revenue is that we could not adequately align it to a staffing model and it just continued to erode with time. The ability to have that margin or the excess to dedicate to resources so that we always could deliver what we call white glove service. It just continued to get chipped away year after year, and certainly some underlying frustrations about how things operated, whether it’s technology or back office or some of the ancillary parts of the business. It’s sort of like a dual mandate was occurring where we had this DNA in us pushing us that way, but there was also an environment there that was clearly showing us that our model didn’t fit well. Mindy Diamond: Well, because you were looking to build something… We call that an incongruence. You were looking to build something that was not really what UBS or any of the big firms designed the infrastructure to be. So you were swimming upstream. But I want to ask you a question, and it goes back to what you said, Mike, about I began to have an interest in independence in 2009, but the industry wasn’t really ready for you in 2009. That’s really the truth. There were outliers. There were people that were going independent because they were just so fiercely entrepreneurial or they had a unique business, but they were outliers. And when people went independent before probably 2018 or so, people thought that they were crazy. They must have lost their mind. So I’m wondering what happened, what went on? What was the interest in 2009? What went into the decision to say, no, it’s not the right time and we’re going to go to UBS? And then at what point did it raise its head? And I’m asking you specifically, Mike, because you mentioned that you sort of began to feel that or sense it or see it so many years ago. Michael Lee: Yeah. So back in 2009, I was in a rare spot inside of JP Morgan. I was a producing manager, and so I never wanted to give up my book. So I would manage business units, but I also wanted to run the money. Was a portfolio manager from the very beginning, taught to think independently, and that was in my DNA. I was just coming up on age 40 at that point in time, and I had my, I’ll call it my Jerry Maguire moment where I was really evaluating what success looked like. And that looked like for me, I wanted to slow things down, I wanted to with my wife and daughter at that point in time in life, and also thought that the only way that I was going to be able to do that is to finally go out and get independent. But as you said, that was a pretty heavy lift when you’ve got obligations at age 40 and responsibilities and everything else like that. So to literally walk out the door and say by myself, I’m going to go start a firm and relocate my family from… It was just a bridge too far for me at that point in time. And I had a conversation with the branch manager at UBS who hired me back then, a guy by the name of Marvin. And the Marvin said, “Well, Mike, it occurs to me you can come to the Carolinas with my money or you can come to the Carolinas with your money.” And that made a whole lot of sense at that moment in time. So I left and joined UBS with their money. Mindy Diamond: So you actually bring up a good point and you’re laughing, but it’s really true that we’re saying the industry wasn’t really ready. And what I mean by that is that right now to become a breakaway, to break away from a major firm, the industry, the ecosystem born to support people like you is vast and great and ready technologically, support-wise, legally, real estate, all of it. There’s a well-worn playbook. But in those days there weren’t. So the industry wasn’t ready. Financially, you weren’t ready, and that makes perfect sense. And the confluence of the two means that for, what, 16 years you put your head down, stayed at UBS. It sounds like it served you well until it didn’t, which is exactly the trajectory we see with most teams, it makes sense. So let me ask you both a question. We talk about financially, and while in a perfect world, it sounds like both of you would’ve loved to be independent many years prior, usually it is the finances that often keep people from doing it sooner. But the reality of working for a big firm is that you’ve got a lot of unvested deferred comp, I’m sure. The reality is that you may owe money back, or at least some of the partners may. The reality is you may have been buying out somebody else’s retiring ALFA program, which is the retiring advisor program. The reality is that on the flip side, the opportunity cost of being paid a very significant deal on a billion dollar plus business at that point to go to a recruiting deal to go to another firm was huge. How did you justify that and to what extent did pursuing all that play into the decision? Steve Armaly: Great question, Mindy. And the one theme that we all agreed on right away if we were to consider making a move is that we had to center on the theme that the client comes first. If we were going to make a move, as much as we knew it could improve our lives, what we wanted it to do first was improve our clients’ lives, a better place to do business and deliver what we think is white glove service. And that was our mantra. Everything had to point to it being better for the client. With that in mind, you hit the nail on the head. The industry has changed tremendously. If you were to consider going independent years ago, it looks totally different than what we experienced. And I think we’re pretty astute. We were head down advisors. We would get phone calls all the time about leaving. We never really entertained those calls because our focus was on the business and we knew if there was a time we would dedicate that, but we didn’t want to be distracted. But I think we had a good pulse on what was out there. But I would say, and I would encourage anybody listening that’s considering the move, is you need to assess the industry because it is much different. It’s different from a financial standpoint. It’s different from an operational standpoint. The level of support that you get and the assistance is really, in a way, you’re waiting to be surprised to a negative, but we were surprised in terms of a positive. It is a much different environment. Mindy Diamond: What you mean is a much different environment than it would’ve been or was 10 years prior. Steve Armaly: Exactly. Mindy Diamond: Got it. So let me ask you a follow-up question to that and feel free either one of you to answer. When you say it took you guys, the four partners a year to get realigned, was everyone aligned from a financial perspective? Okay, I get it’s sort of easy for everyone to say, “We want to make it better for clients.” Everybody gets there. That’s not a hard one to agree on. But what’s really hard for every partner to find unanimous between the partners is the notion that we are all willing to give up a very significant transition deal upfront. We’re all willing to bet it on the long term. We all want to be independent from a financial perspective. Was that part of the issue? Michael Lee: The struggles that we were all having, obviously we were at different stages, but there were some real hurdles that had to be overcome, and Brian won’t mind me mentioning this, but he had some health and some insurance issues that came into play that he had to take … He’s got a special needs child. And so for him, the stakes were very high for him that went well beyond just current financial wellbeing, but what’s going to happen later? So there were some real issues that had to be worked through as we went through this. So I don’t think any of us had an eye toward maybe a big windfall at the end of the thing. It was more about getting set up and getting in an environment. We knew that if we could get to a point where we got to independence, it would work out. It would just work out. So that independence and staying together were the real drivers. And yes, there was a lot of soul searching that needed to take place in order to get there. Mindy Diamond: And you got to really want it. So I want to ask you a question. Today, there are two very valid ways to go independent. One is to do what you did, break away, pull together the resources that you need and build your own firm. And a subset of that is joining a supported independence platform where you can outsource the different aspects of being independent, but still be independent and own your own firm. But the second very valid way is to join an established independent RIA. And because the industry, the independent, the RIA space has matured so much in the last decade, there are many private equity backed or very well capitalized mega RIAs that are very well positioned to not only recruit and acquire businesses that look like yours and fold them in, but also to compensate them well. And what that option does is eliminate the risk of leaving with no money upfront and it eliminates a lot of the startup factor, the house of the brain damage of starting something from scratch. Had you guys ever considered that? Michael Lee: Yeah, and quite honestly, it was to you all… We keep talking about the industry so different from 2009 till now. But really and truly what your firm opened our eyes to was it’s different from what it was five years ago and it’s still changing. So as current and as up to speed as we thought we were, you really opened our eyes to the spectrum of opportunity sets that were out there. And absolutely we did consider the equity and the private equity route and the like. For us, we decided that the four partners was enough for us at this stage and we didn’t want a fifth or a sixth partner out there. It’s not to say that this thing doesn’t evolve down the road, but that’s not our intention. But yeah, we looked at literally everything that you all put in front of us from an opportunity set that existed out there. And the conversations that we had with your firm over the course of the year in particularly were highly valuable to educating us in terms of what the opportunity set looked like. And through those conversations, we were able to really narrow it down to really about three or four, which was a very manageable subset to consider for where we are and what we were trying to accomplish. So it really became clear after those conversations. Mindy Diamond: I love it. And I’m appreciative of the kind words. I want to say that Deborah Aronson, I’ll give her a shout out, is recruiter on our team that had the privilege of working with you. And yes, she is spectacular and did spectacular work here, so I’m thrilled that it worked for you. I want to pivot to the transition itself. So first of all, UBS is not part of the Broker Protocol, so it made the move trickier and riskier. Tell me what that was like and to what extent that additional risk factored into your decisions or lack of alignment for you. Michael Lee: Our lack of unity wasn’t around that piece. We got really good counsel. We followed the rules. It was a leap of faith to do that because you literally have to walk out with nothing. And we did. That’s scary in and of itself. But once we had decided that we were going and we had clarity around where we were going, that just became just another step in the process for us. Steve, I don’t know if you’d agree with that or not, but… Steve Armaly: Yeah, and Mindy, it’s a huge decision and on the surface it is scary. But again, what we found and were continuously impressed with was the support that we got. And especially in the legal area, it’s very well spelled out what you can and can’t do. And if you take their advice and follow it to the T, you’ll be in great shape. And that’s really what it comes down to is listen to counsel, they’re there to help you, and it will work if you follow the rules of the game. Mindy Diamond: Yeah. So the proof is in your pudding because you moved a billion dollars in assets or were at a billion dollars in assets in 225 days post move, which is extraordinary. So yes, you walked out of UBS with zero and 225 days later crossed the billion dollar mark, which is extraordinary. But were there moments in between that were, holy cow, what did we do? Or even moments beforehand is, oh my God, we can’t take client information. We’ve had this information for 16 years or 30 years and what are we going to do? Steve Armaly: Yeah. I think everybody will have a moment in the transition when they’re like, wow, we really did this and you’re going to hit some roadblocks. You’re going to be surprised to the good and maybe some to the bad. But ultimately, in your due diligence, you know your why. Why are we here? Why did we make this move? What is the truth in all of that? You’ve got to remind yourself occasionally about that and have faith and got to believe that this was more than just some decision that was made for self-interest. This was a decision that you pondered, you seek counsel, you had great consultants to help with, and you’ve done something like this in the past, you can do it again. And we all have to be reminded of that on the journey I feel like. Without a doubt, nothing good is easy and transitioning isn’t easy, but it is certainly worth it. Mindy Diamond: Yeah. So let me ask you a question. What did the pitch sound like? So day one, you leave UBS, you’ve got zero in AUM, and you call your first five clients. What did the pitch sound like and how did those clients react to that pitch? Michael Lee: Basically, we announced that we left and that’s it. Mindy Diamond: Remind us why, because the Protocol prohibited you from… Michael Lee: Yeah, we couldn’t do anything in advance and we couldn’t solicit or anything else like that. We were just literally allowed to announce that we had left and that’s it. Mindy Diamond: But I imagine clients had questions for you. So how and why did those assets begin to trickle in? Steve Armaly: And I meant to share this in the previous question too, is that if you’ve truly run your practice, as we all should, where you’re client focused, you’re doing all the things that you should do with your clients. You have comprehensive planning, you’re updating that planning on annual basis, you have regular reviews with your clients, you have open-ended conversations with your clients, and you’ve created an environment where they truly know that you’re there to serve their needs whenever they pop up. So much of the hard work is just in how you’ve been running your business that allows you to transition well because you can rely on that. And I think that, our clients know us well. We’re very transparent. We’re transparent about what we think about financial planning and our investment strategy and what we do. We’re very transparent about how we live our lives even. And so our clients have a vested interest in always asking us why or what’s happening from our standpoint. And they, I think, have grown to trust us that we’re very prudent in our decision making. And as we share that we’ve made a decision to leave after many years and here we are, the questions were really, there must be a good reason and tell us about why and tell us what is it going to look like and what’s it going to look like for us? We loved it. As soon as they opened the door to asking questions, then we were back in the seat of who we’ve always been, which is just very transparent, honest partners who are there to take care of our clients. Mindy Diamond: I love that answer, Steve, because it’s my experience. It’s my experience of being an outsider, a third party looking in, counseling teams. The teams that, first of all, are moving for the right reasons. The reasons being we’re doing this for the benefit of clients. If it’s about self-interest, people can smell that, they sniff that out immediately. But if you’ve always done the right thing by clients and you’re moving for the right reasons, which is for their benefit, it’s, in most cases, the loyalty is rewarded or the loyalty is a reward for always having done the right thing and most people find that. But we all agree it is scary. And I think the people that are the most scared are often the ones that just are less sure. Well, two things are the people that are most scared. One, the people that are less certain that they’ve always done the right things or less certain that their clients know they’ve always done the right thing. And two, the ones that have really a large number of smaller clients. It’s much easier to have faith in a book that will move when you’ve got say under two or 300 clients than in a book that has a thousand clients. I assume you’d agree with that. Steve Armaly: Very much so. And you’re spot on, Mindy. And if you run your practice well… And this is the part that we think some firms have lost sight of, is that it truly is if you are running a practice and serving your clients well, it is the relationship between the client and the advisor. And you build a lot of goodwill if you do it right. And we knew we were leaning in on the goodwill by making a transition, but it’s been amazing to watch our clients rally around us where we have always rallied around them and their life events and their challenges, but they’ve rallied around us and supported us in this transition. And from day one, we had clients coming in just to drop off food and flowers and things to tell us, “Congratulations, what can we do for you?” The last thing they wanted to talk about was their portfolio and their assets. They were genuinely concerned about us and what we were doing and wanted us to know that they were in our corner here to support us. And that was amazing and very reassuring early in the process. Mindy Diamond: So how about the reality of you said we moved because we wanted to do better for clients. Can you give me some examples of the things you’re able to do now that actually make you better able to serve clients? Steve Armaly: There’s a lot of room. Michael Lee: Yeah. From a technology, I mean, one of the things that we were able to do is build our own tech stack, and so that was fun to go through and do that. Some of our marketing things that we’ve been able to do from weekly market updates to we just launched a podcast with Jeff and Brian that we’re particularly proud of. So we’ve been able to, we feel like, level up in just about everything that we were doing before and the ability to redirect resources to areas that are important to us, it’s been fun to do that and that it’s been fast, which has also been great. Mindy Diamond: Yeah, amazing. So you said a billion-two when you left UBS, a billion-one a year later. How much of that is our original clients, how much of that is new assets and how does this sort of ability to market with more freedom, for example, how does that impact your prospecting? Michael Lee: Yeah, Steve’s got that one. Steve Armaly: Well, we believe our retention rate of existing clients and assets was 93%. And interestingly enough, even in the transition process, a lot of our clients were having life events where there were additional assets that were coming in also. So that was a nice shot in the arm in a sense, having clients transition as well as they did and then additional assets coming in. Our pipeline has never been bigger than it is today in terms of new client activity. It’s been amazing to see where we are, maybe the excitement of the transition and the move and how that’s opened more doors to us since making that transition. So the transition is extremely busy. And then on top of that, in the new business world, we’re probably as busy as we’ve ever been with a very strong and healthy pipeline. Mindy Diamond: That’s amazing. What do you think about your value proposition, meaning the value proposition of being independent, what aspects of that appeal to prospects? Michael Lee: We’ve got a lot of business owner clients, and for whatever reason, that kindred spirit of having the responsibility of making payroll, they resonate. So they’re like, “Oh, you guys are one of us, so you get it.” So I think there’s that part that’s maybe hitting a touchpoint that was there before, but it’s even deeper now because it is our own business. So they know the importance because they know how important their business is to them. It’s not a leap of faith to understand that they would assume that same level of commitment to ours. And then I think we’re just able to try to put more resources around the client experience that is also having a direct impact on what that looks like. So the relationships are getting deeper, richer, and fuller. Mindy Diamond: And do any prospects question the lack of a big name firm behind you? Michael Lee: No. One of the things why we chose the structured independence model was there was two things that we did not want to take on right away. And that became clear, again, going back to our conversations with Deb. We did not want to take on the responsibility of cybersecurity ourselves. That was a very tall order, and especially in this day and age, we did not want to have that on our responsibility. And then of course also compliance, which is ever-growing and changing as well. So those two things were very important that we had a good partner with, and LPL has done that. So the ability to control the P&L, the hiring and firing, the allocation of resources, the marketing, the branding, all of the things that were of paramount importance to us, we can do. And then the two areas that we did not want to take on, we left with our partner, LPL. And with their size and scope, they’ve been a tremendous resource and backstop to us. And a lot of our clients didn’t know who LPL was, but once they get an idea of the size and structure of the largest independent broker dealer, that helps. Mindy Diamond: You actually took the words right out of my mouth. My follow-up question was going to be, as you looked at the waterfall of possibilities of ways to go independent, you opted to go for supported independence with LPL Strategic Wealth Services, which is the supported independent model for under the LPL umbrella. And so you answered the question in terms of by doing so, it allowed you to outsource or insource to them the parts you didn’t want. It solved some of the financial, the sort of short-term risk. It allowed you to de-risk to a certain degree in the short-term. So my question is, has LPL delivered? Have they been a good partner? And to what extent are they helping you to grow or get wherever you want to go next? Steve Armaly: I’ll jump in and say right off the bat, yes, they have delivered. And especially in the areas of the ancillary services in setting up a practice to walk in day one, turn on the light switch and be fully operational, they were superb. Unmatched services, we believe in technology, unmatched services in terms of real estate and helping us negotiate leases, find our space, do up-fits, support that we receive from them. I would say they really did surpass our expectations in terms of all the areas that they helped us with marketing, I’m leaving so many of them off the table, but we were really blown away by how good they were. And that’s what really led us to making the decision to go with LPL, and the best part was to see that come to fruition. And the spirit within the firm is what we talked about right away from our first due diligence trip when we met them is we felt like everybody that sat at the table had a desire to do what we do, which is to make our lives better as much as we’re trying to make our clients’ lives better. We felt like that was in their DNA and it really was. And so I’d say that they certainly met our expectations. The transition part, there are areas where we’ve been very transparent with them saying, “Hey, I think we could improve these areas.” The great thing about that is they’ve been very receptive. They want to get better at what they do day in and day out. And that spirit is what we probably appreciate the most is as much as we think we’re good at what we do, we know we don’t know everything and that we have to constantly learn, change, and grow. And they seem to have that same mindset. Mindy Diamond: Love it. I’ve got two final questions for you. One is, so what’s next? The first year for any breakaway team is always about stabilizing the business, learning new systems, making sure clients are set, getting the infrastructure set, all of it. But it’s year two, three, and beyond when it gets really fun. It’s less about transition and stress and more about really looking why you want to independent in the first place. So what are some of the things that are deep in your laboratory or some things you think about? Michael Lee: We feel called to grow and that’s going to mean continuing to grow organically, but we also feel called to grow and that will end up being through mergers and acquisitions as well. So it is a longer term and what that looks like in the first one and all that, we’re still formulating what that looks like to us, but we have a responsibility to be difference makers and we want to lean into that. Mindy Diamond: I love it. Final question. There are so many advisors that are sitting at your former firm, that are sitting at other large firms, that are sitting at small broker dealers that are just scared to go independent, or let’s not even focus on independence, to move in general. A move is a hassle. A move is disruptive. If it’s a non-protocol move, it’s risky. You’ve got partners that may not be aligned. You’ve got the worry. There is no guarantee that clients follow. What if the transition doesn’t work? What if something blows up? What if a million what ifs? What advice would you give to anyone listening who’s in that, “I would love to do it. I wish I could press the easy button or the fast-forward button and just be there, but I’m scared about getting from here to there”? What would you say to them? Steve Armaly: That’s a great question, Mindy. And right off the bat, I would certainly say to anybody to have courage. If you are doing and serving your clients to the best of your ability and running a good practice, then you have everything in place that you need to ultimately move. And regrettably in our industry, and we all say this, but it’s almost as if it’s the answer that everybody knows needs to be put into practice, but for some reason it’s not being put into practice. That is, you’ve got to honor the client-advisor relationship. You have to understand what really makes this profession work is the exchange of trust that occurs between a family and an advisor, and that’s a highly coveted or trusted position. And if we all protect that and do what’s right, then ultimately I think relationships will go anywhere to follow somebody who’s been an honorable leader, who’s given good advice to a family, who’s helped them make wise decisions. I wish that you could pick a home and stay there forever, but ultimately whatever those outside forces are, sometimes they lose sight again of what’s most important, which is the client-advisor relationship. And I would encourage anybody that feels like if they’re in a place where they’ve lost that as their mission, then ultimately their clients and themselves as advisors deserve better. And if you know why you’re doing it, and ultimately it’s to put your clients first, then you have all that you need. The rest of it is to have a trusted partner like your firm and to have somebody help you to digest the landscape and get a great understanding of where your clients are going to be best served, and then to take the advice that they provide to you and the roadmap. In a lot of ways, people will say it’s not difficult, but we know there’s tons of challenges in it, but with the right partners, you’ve got everything you need. Just you have to have faith and belief in why you’re doing it. Mindy Diamond: That’s actually a beautiful answer, and I agree with it because what you’re saying is if you’ve got clarity, a vision, and you’re doing it for the right reasons, you can’t and shouldn’t be held hostage by fears or thinking small. It doesn’t mean that a move is right for everyone, certainly not. But I think you said it better than I ever could and I love it. So I want to thank you both so, so much for your transparency, for your time, for your willingness, for your trust in us. We don’t take that lightly. I think your story will resonate with many. And I am so excited to see what the future holds for you because it seems like it’s very bright. Michael Lee: Thank you. Steve Armaly: Thank you, Mindy. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously and are dedicated to your clients, but are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook. The Trust Behind the Transition: UBS Breakaways on What It Takes to Move $1B in a Matter of Months A conversation with Mindy Diamond and Michael Lee and Steve Armaly, Founders and Managing Partners at Ox Road Capital. Mindy Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is, The Trust Behind the Transition: UBS Breakaways on What It Takes to Move $1B in a Matter of Months. It’s a conversation with Michael Lee and Steve Armaly, founders and managing partners of Ox Road Capital. I’m Mindy Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transition. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual Advisor Transition Report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions, to download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Trust is at the center of every advisor-client relationship, but it’s one thing to believe your clients trust you and another to make a move that puts that belief to the test. That was certainly true for my guest today, Michael Lee and Steve Armaly, founders and managing partners of Ox Road Capital. Along with their partners, Brian Blackburn and Jeff Allen, Mike and Steve had built an extraordinarily successful $1.2 billion business at UBS. Yet over time, they came to believe that the business they wanted to build and the level of white glove service they wanted to provide required greater control over how they invested in their team, technology and client experience. But getting four partners aligned around a move of this magnitude wasn’t easy. Neither was leaving a non-protocol firm walking out the door without client information and trusting that the relationships they had spent years building were strong enough to follow. We had the privilege of helping Mike, Steve, and their partners evaluate their options and ultimately launch Ox Road Capital through LPL Strategic Wealth Services. And what happened next speaks to volumes. They crossed the billion dollar mark just 225 days after leaving UBS. Yet what makes their story worth hearing isn’t simply the number. It’s the thoughtfulness behind the decision, the work it took to get four partners aligned, the choice to prioritize long-term ownership over immediate economics, and the conviction that creating a better business could ultimately make their clients’ lives and their own lives better. And perhaps most of all, it’s what they learned about trusting the relationships they had built long before they ever decided to make a move. So if you’ve ever wondered what it really takes to get multiple partners aligned, how to weigh the risks of a non-protocol transition, or whether the relationships you’ve built with clients are strong enough to withstand a move, Mike and Steve offer an unusually candid look at what those questions feel like before, during, and after a breakaway and what they know now that they’re on the other side. So let’s get to it. Mike and Steve, I am so excited you’re here. It feels especially good to have the privilege of interviewing people that we had the privilege of helping to get here. So welcome. Steve Armaly: Thank you. We’re excited to be here. Michael Lee: Very. Mindy Diamond: Terrific. Okay, so let’s start at the beginning obviously, and I’d love to hear just briefly a little bit about your stories. How’d you get here? Michael Lee: I guess the move to independence for me really started back in my mind back before joining UBS in 2009. It was a dream that was planted, kind of went through a life change halftime as it were in career, wanted to slow things down a little bit. So my wife and I actually relocated from South Florida down in Palm Beach County to Greenville back in 2009, left JP Morgan and joined UBS. So basically that idea was formed back then, but just it was wrong time. Mindy Diamond: I’m going to want to unpack that a little more later. Let’s put a pin in that because I love what you just said. That is true of many people. But Steve, let’s hear from you. Steve Armaly: Yes. I made an industry change in 2004, worked in consulting as a management consultant and as a financial analyst upon graduating from the Citadel and always had an entrepreneurial spirit, I grew up in an entrepreneurial family. But my first day at work as an advisor, I knew I was in the right place. I knew I was doing what I was called to do. It felt so different, never felt like work. But ultimately, I think even at the beginning of my career, I had this desire to one day have my own practice or have a practice that I could be a part of as a team where we would have ownership and more control. So I feel like it was in my blood from the very beginning, but it did take us a while to get there. Mindy Diamond: That’s okay. And again, we’ll unpack that a little more later, but thank you. So I want to give our listeners some perspective. A year ago, you guys left UBS, would love for you to tell us how long you were at UBS, but want to hear a little bit about the size of the business, how many employees you have, the kind of clients you serve. And I don’t know, Mike and Steve, if you want to alternate on that, that’s great. Michael Lee: So I’ve been in the business about 36 years. Steve just mentioned when he made the career change. Jeff, one of our partners, has been in financial services for over 25 years. And Brian, the same thing. So all of us have been around for a bit for sure. We left UBS, we had a team of about 11, and since we came over and formed Ox Road, we’ve hired six more folks. So we manage about 1.1 billion is where we are today. We were at 1.2 back before we left the UBS. Mindy Diamond: Got it. Talk to us about the unusual name Ox Road. I’m always fascinated. I like to ask that, particularly when a name is a little less mainstream. Where’d it come from? How’d you come up with it? Michael Lee: Yeah, so it evolved over a period of time. So we used to be known as the Alpha Group. So when in our earliest stages, there were four partners. I’ll let Steve and Jeff argue over whose last name was first, but it was started out as the ALFA Group, A-L-F-A. It was Allen, Lee, there was another gentleman that was a partner of ours, he’s since passed away, his last name was Fort and then Armaly. Or since Steve’s on the call, we’ll say it was Armaly, Lee, Fort, and Allen and give him props. But that’s where it started. And then a few years later we merged with Brian Blackburn, one of our partners, and then there was a retiring FA that was on his team and we rebranded to ALPHA, A-L-P-H-A. Well, totally unrelated to the move. One morning I was having a quiet time and I was reading in Proverbs, Proverbs 14:4, it says, “Where there are no oxen, the manger is clean, but much revenue comes from the strength of an ox.” Well, that’s interesting. What do I do with that? This was written down for extended generations, but I don’t know how to apply it. So that took me down a path of researching the ox. And it turns out the ox appears all throughout the Bible. It was used for sacrifice. It was a beast of burden, worked in teams. So there was this whole idea of an ox and wherever it showed up, it was humility, it was service, it was sacrifice, it was hard work. So all very admirable attributes. So then when I reread that verse and I said, okay, well, where there’s no teamwork, there’s no prosperity, where there’s no hard work, where there’s no sacrifice. So when I read it in terms of what it symbolized or the essence of an ox, then that was attractive to me. So put a pin in that a couple years later, another quiet time I’m reading, in Psalm 1:19, it’s basically an acrostic with the Hebrew alphabet. So each section of that psalm has a letter associated with it. Well, the first letter is Olive, the Hebrew letter A, which also is symbolically tied to the number one. And it’s also, interestingly enough, to the head of an ox. That was the symbol or the emoji for it. So there was this idea that alpha or olive was tied to the head of an ox. So that’s what started the idea of the ox. So then thinking about the journey, we’re on a journey through life. We’re kind of just passing through and our lives intersect with our clients’ lives, with our team members’ lives, with vendors. And we don’t know how long people are going to be in our lives. Sometimes they drop in for just a little bit and sometimes they’re there for an extended period of time, but we’re all kind of on this road. So this idea of Ox Road came. So it was a nod to the past. There was a direct connection to our old name, Alpha, through the symbol of the ox head, but then there was also this idea of a journey that we were moving forward. So it was a nod to our past, but a clear focus on who we were, those attributes that we all aspire to of hard work and sacrifice and the strength and commitment and humility. That was who we were, but then there was also we’re going on a journey and we have absolutely no idea how big this thing’s going to get. So, there you go. Mindy Diamond: Thank you for sharing that and I love how thoughtful it was. A lot of people really struggle with, oh my God, we just have to come up with something creative, but that’s thoughtful and beautiful and thank you for sharing it. Michael Lee: Yeah. Mindy Diamond: So let me ask, you mentioned bringing two teams together, and I know you’ve got partners, Jeff Allen and Brian Blackburn. So you’re running a big team. How do you divide responsibilities? How does that work? Steve Armaly: Well, early on, Mindy, we believed in the concept of giftedness and ideally we’re all created in a unique way by God and we all have some inherent skills that are just our natural abilities. And we also believe that when you spend time in those natural abilities, you’re energized, you’re refreshed, it motivates you, it meets your needs in a way, much like our conversation earlier today with how you guys feel about what you do in helping people find their home. That’s what really motivates us. And when we looked at our business, we felt like there’s three distinct areas of expertise that you need to provide comprehensive wealth management. And those three areas are financial planning, client service, and portfolio management. And what we wanted to do was design a team where you could spend 80% of your skills in that area that you felt you were gifted within one of those three silos and then spend 20% in the others. And it was the idea of soar with your strengths and manage or lean on your teammates to help you better in the areas where you felt you were weak or just felt like you didn’t have that natural skill set in. And so ultimately from starting with the partners, we aligned ourselves within those three pillars and then we built our staff model to fit within those three pillars also. Mindy Diamond: So one of the things that trips a lot of multi-partner teams is that not everybody has the same goals at the same time. So were all four partners aligned as to the desire to be independent at the same time? Michael Lee: Yeah, that was actually an interesting part of our story is while there was a desire to go independent, from a timing standpoint, I don’t know that… Actually we weren’t all on the same page for a period of about a year, but we got there and that’s a story in and of itself. So Steve, I don’t know if you want to add anything to that or not, but we could do a whole podcast just on that piece. Steve Armaly: We really could, Mindy. Well, I’d love to start by saying as a partnership, we truly looked at partnering, and I hate to use the cliche, but the magnitude of making a decision to have a partner for life as in marriage. And we looked at partnering as a process that you would go through courtship where you really got to know each other, your goals, your objectives, your moral compass, and making sure it all aligns. So we felt very unified. We always use the words, our arms are locked together as four partners. We make our decisions in unison. If we can’t get to an answer where we all are on the same page, we pause, we wait, and we continue to contemplate. But I say all of that to enlighten and maybe let you know how much of a challenge it was with the idea of leaving our past firm. And ultimately, I think as Mike said, we had the desire to do it. We had even discussed it, but we knew there was a time and place for that. We had that sort of on the back shelf. Our focus was to design and build the best team we could. And I think we were very focused on that. But when the time came to consider making the move, we did encounter for the first time that we weren’t completely aligned and it scared us. It was the first time ever that we really were in disagreement, the first time that we had some anxiety about the partnership and who was doing what and how this all was going to work. And thankfully during that time, one of our partners, Jeff, was astute enough to say, “Guys, we clearly are not aligned and we’ve got to get realigned.” And we trusted a partner that we’d met over the years who works in counseling to sit with us. And we basically went through a two-day session to get realigned. And in that timeframe, that’s exactly where we landed, but it was not pretty. And there were certainly some moments where I think we all questioned how could something as good as our team be at risk of ceasing. Michael Lee: One thing I wanted to add that was funny that I think we have to draw a light too. So the guy who was the counselor was actually a marriage counselor that we went to see. Mindy Diamond: I love it. That makes sense. Michael Lee: And we sat down with him and he’s like, “All right, guys, this is a little bit out of my wheelhouse. I’ve never counseled four dudes.” And he said, “So just so you know, if this thing goes south, I don’t bear any responsibility at all for your business.” It was great. Mindy Diamond: I love that you just shared that because I want to normalize what you just said. It is exceedingly rare and it makes sense that it’s rare that four partners, two partners, but certainly four, who come from different backgrounds, different ages, different financial stability, different risk tolerance, different whatever it is, different entrepreneurial spirit, different everything, could possibly be at the same place at the same time. And the fact that it only took you a year to realign is unbelievably short. I am working with teams… I think you guys know that we were lucky enough to facilitate the move of the largest breakaway in the industry, the guys in Atlanta, the OpenArc deal. That deal was 10 years in the making, and one of the senior members of the team got there first. He was all in as far as being an entrepreneur. He had the vision, he wanted it, but most of his other partners were either completely no way, no how, non-starter, or at varying degrees of no or lukewarm. It took 10 years to get to the same place. And that doesn’t mean 10 years of active exploration, but to be honest with you, 10 years is a long time. But that notion of it taking time for everybody to be at the same place makes a lot of sense. I want to normalize that and kudos to you for bringing in outside objective help to get there. The second thing is not all partnerships weather the storm or should. Some are very clear like you, the most important true north is that the band stays together. But others say, I’m working with a team right now that says the senior partners says this process of even beginning to think about what we each want and highlighting the differences shows that now I’m thinking about the fact that I’m really the growth engine and I’m resentful of paying X, Y, and Z to partners that don’t grow as fast. So it highlights fractures and a lot of times the band doesn’t stay together nor should they. So kudos to you is my point for only having it taken a year. But I want to ask you a question, which is, so at what point did… It sounds like you both had entrepreneurial DNA, you realized yours, Mike, you said in 2009 you were thinking about it when you left JP Morgan. Steve, you said you come from an entrepreneurial family and it was always there. So it sounds like wrestling with the desire for more freedom was always there or was there for a long time. But at what point for the two of you did being at UBS and being an employee cease to be enough and what drove that? Michael Lee: Yeah, so we’ve tried to be pretty… Where, and I think it was Jeff that really brought this to light, a number of years ago, we would constantly run into other financial services professionals and even other members in other industries that would say, “Hey, we’re having a lot of trouble attracting young talent. We just can’t find good people.” That’s not been our problem. We have had a ton of young people come through our doors, quality individuals, hardworking. We make a very good use of an intern program that we’re really trying to expose people to this industry and things like that. So for whatever reason, we started feeling called like we’re about building legacy. We’re about building something that’s going to outlive us and we’re about pouring into the next gen of advisors through a mentorship or apprenticeship type program. And that in addition to serving our clients the way that we do through our mission, vision and values, we also felt like this was a key thing that we were doing. So that works for a while inside of a W-2 world until it doesn’t, and that’s what we found. Mindy Diamond: UBS, and not just UBS, but any traditional firm is not really looking for you to build your own firm within the firm. They may tell you it’s okay to be entrepreneurial and you’re running your own business, but in the end they own you. And the notion of you actually building your own firm and then wanting the freedom to run it and compensate your staff the way you want to and name it the way you want to and all of that, that’s when you begin to run into friction. Steve, what I’d love for you to answer about that is, so was the move or the desire to go or the goal of going independent, was it more about running away from what was frustrating you at UBS or limiting you at UBS or more about just we were entrepreneurs and there were a million things we wanted to do when we were running towards something? Steve Armaly: Wow, that’s a great question. I hate to answer it this way, but I would say it’s a little bit of both. Again, our DNA, each of us are a little bit different. I probably had the desires for entrepreneurship that were driving me from the beginning, feeling like that was the eventual landing spot was to get there. And we had a meeting, again, leaning on each other, just trying to get a deeper understanding of our motives. We know each other super well, but ultimately there was one conversation that I distinctly remember that I had defined success as eventually having our own firm and absent of that I would feel like we failed in a sense. So I think a lot of that existed, for instance, for me, probably for Mike also, but even in our difficulties of trying to make a decision of where we all stood and where we wanted to go, we got completely realigned. And the one thing that we were very clear on is that this partnership to us was more than the business. It was really a partnership to do life together. And whether we were going to be at UBS or on our own, wherever, we were committed to being together because we all benefited from that as men. Our families benefited from it. We feel like our clients benefited from it. We just became better men by working together and to stay together was our number one priority. But I think over time, it clearly became evident that what we were building would not operate well in our previous environment. We were building something big well as we were doing, and as much as we got all the accolades, we still didn’t necessarily fit in some of the top tiers. But more than anything, the thing that we saw clearly was the way that we wanted to use the resources that we were blessed with in terms of our revenue is that we could not adequately align it to a staffing model and it just continued to erode with time. The ability to have that margin or the excess to dedicate to resources so that we always could deliver what we call white glove service. It just continued to get chipped away year after year, and certainly some underlying frustrations about how things operated, whether it’s technology or back office or some of the ancillary parts of the business. It’s sort of like a dual mandate was occurring where we had this DNA in us pushing us that way, but there was also an environment there that was clearly showing us that our model didn’t fit well. Mindy Diamond: Well, because you were looking to build something… We call that an incongruence. You were looking to build something that was not really what UBS or any of the big firms designed the infrastructure to be. So you were swimming upstream. But I want to ask you a question, and it goes back to what you said, Mike, about I began to have an interest in independence in 2009, but the industry wasn’t really ready for you in 2009. That’s really the truth. There were outliers. There were people that were going independent because they were just so fiercely entrepreneurial or they had a unique business, but they were outliers. And when people went independent before probably 2018 or so, people thought that they were crazy. They must have lost their mind. So I’m wondering what happened, what went on? What was the interest in 2009? What went into the decision to say, no, it’s not the right time and we’re going to go to UBS? And then at what point did it raise its head? And I’m asking you specifically, Mike, because you mentioned that you sort of began to feel that or sense it or see it so many years ago. Michael Lee: Yeah. So back in 2009, I was in a rare spot inside of JP Morgan. I was a producing manager, and so I never wanted to give up my book. So I would manage business units, but I also wanted to run the money. Was a portfolio manager from the very beginning, taught to think independently, and that was in my DNA. I was just coming up on age 40 at that point in time, and I had my, I’ll call it my Jerry Maguire moment where I was really evaluating what success looked like. And that looked like for me, I wanted to slow things down, I wanted to with my wife and daughter at that point in time in life, and also thought that the only way that I was going to be able to do that is to finally go out and get independent. But as you said, that was a pretty heavy lift when you’ve got obligations at age 40 and responsibilities and everything else like that. So to literally walk out the door and say by myself, I’m going to go start a firm and relocate my family from… It was just a bridge too far for me at that point in time. And I had a conversation with the branch manager at UBS who hired me back then, a guy by the name of Marvin. And the Marvin said, “Well, Mike, it occurs to me you can come to the Carolinas with my money or you can come to the Carolinas with your money.” And that made a whole lot of sense at that moment in time. So I left and joined UBS with their money. Mindy Diamond: So you actually bring up a good point and you’re laughing, but it’s really true that we’re saying the industry wasn’t really ready. And what I mean by that is that right now to become a breakaway, to break away from a major firm, the industry, the ecosystem born to support people like you is vast and great and ready technologically, support-wise, legally, real estate, all of it. There’s a well-worn playbook. But in those days there weren’t. So the industry wasn’t ready. Financially, you weren’t ready, and that makes perfect sense. And the confluence of the two means that for, what, 16 years you put your head down, stayed at UBS. It sounds like it served you well until it didn’t, which is exactly the trajectory we see with most teams, it makes sense. So let me ask you both a question. We talk about financially, and while in a perfect world, it sounds like both of you would’ve loved to be independent many years prior, usually it is the finances that often keep people from doing it sooner. But the reality of working for a big firm is that you’ve got a lot of unvested deferred comp, I’m sure. The reality is that you may owe money back, or at least some of the partners may. The reality is you may have been buying out somebody else’s retiring ALFA program, which is the retiring advisor program. The reality is that on the flip side, the opportunity cost of being paid a very significant deal on a billion dollar plus business at that point to go to a recruiting deal to go to another firm was huge. How did you justify that and to what extent did pursuing all that play into the decision? Steve Armaly: Great question, Mindy. And the one theme that we all agreed on right away if we were to consider making a move is that we had to center on the theme that the client comes first. If we were going to make a move, as much as we knew it could improve our lives, what we wanted it to do first was improve our clients’ lives, a better place to do business and deliver what we think is white glove service. And that was our mantra. Everything had to point to it being better for the client. With that in mind, you hit the nail on the head. The industry has changed tremendously. If you were to consider going independent years ago, it looks totally different than what we experienced. And I think we’re pretty astute. We were head down advisors. We would get phone calls all the time about leaving. We never really entertained those calls because our focus was on the business and we knew if there was a time we would dedicate that, but we didn’t want to be distracted. But I think we had a good pulse on what was out there. But I would say, and I would encourage anybody listening that’s considering the move, is you need to assess the industry because it is much different. It’s different from a financial standpoint. It’s different from an operational standpoint. The level of support that you get and the assistance is really, in a way, you’re waiting to be surprised to a negative, but we were surprised in terms of a positive. It is a much different environment. Mindy Diamond: What you mean is a much different environment than it would’ve been or was 10 years prior. Steve Armaly: Exactly. Mindy Diamond: Got it. So let me ask you a follow-up question to that and feel free either one of you to answer. When you say it took you guys, the four partners a year to get realigned, was everyone aligned from a financial perspective? Okay, I get it’s sort of easy for everyone to say, “We want to make it better for clients.” Everybody gets there. That’s not a hard one to agree on. But what’s really hard for every partner to find unanimous between the partners is the notion that we are all willing to give up a very significant transition deal upfront. We’re all willing to bet it on the long term. We all want to be independent from a financial perspective. Was that part of the issue? Michael Lee: The struggles that we were all having, obviously we were at different stages, but there were some real hurdles that had to be overcome, and Brian won’t mind me mentioning this, but he had some health and some insurance issues that came into play that he had to take … He’s got a special needs child. And so for him, the stakes were very high for him that went well beyond just current financial wellbeing, but what’s going to happen later? So there were some real issues that had to be worked through as we went through this. So I don’t think any of us had an eye toward maybe a big windfall at the end of the thing. It was more about getting set up and getting in an environment. We knew that if we could get to a point where we got to independence, it would work out. It would just work out. So that independence and staying together were the real drivers. And yes, there was a lot of soul searching that needed to take place in order to get there. Mindy Diamond: And you got to really want it. So I want to ask you a question. Today, there are two very valid ways to go independent. One is to do what you did, break away, pull together the resources that you need and build your own firm. And a subset of that is joining a supported independence platform where you can outsource the different aspects of being independent, but still be independent and own your own firm. But the second very valid way is to join an established independent RIA. And because the industry, the independent, the RIA space has matured so much in the last decade, there are many private equity backed or very well capitalized mega RIAs that are very well positioned to not only recruit and acquire businesses that look like yours and fold them in, but also to compensate them well. And what that option does is eliminate the risk of leaving with no money upfront and it eliminates a lot of the startup factor, the house of the brain damage of starting something from scratch. Had you guys ever considered that? Michael Lee: Yeah, and quite honestly, it was to you all… We keep talking about the industry so different from 2009 till now. But really and truly what your firm opened our eyes to was it’s different from what it was five years ago and it’s still changing. So as current and as up to speed as we thought we were, you really opened our eyes to the spectrum of opportunity sets that were out there. And absolutely we did consider the equity and the private equity route and the like. For us, we decided that the four partners was enough for us at this stage and we didn’t want a fifth or a sixth partner out there. It’s not to say that this thing doesn’t evolve down the road, but that’s not our intention. But yeah, we looked at literally everything that you all put in front of us from an opportunity set that existed out there. And the conversations that we had with your firm over the course of the year in particularly were highly valuable to educating us in terms of what the opportunity set looked like. And through those conversations, we were able to really narrow it down to really about three or four, which was a very manageable subset to consider for where we are and what we were trying to accomplish. So it really became clear after those conversations. Mindy Diamond: I love it. And I’m appreciative of the kind words. I want to say that Deborah Aronson, I’ll give her a shout out, is recruiter on our team that had the privilege of working with you. And yes, she is spectacular and did spectacular work here, so I’m thrilled that it worked for you. I want to pivot to the transition itself. So first of all, UBS is not part of the Broker Protocol, so it made the move trickier and riskier. Tell me what that was like and to what extent that additional risk factored into your decisions or lack of alignment for you. Michael Lee: Our lack of unity wasn’t around that piece. We got really good counsel. We followed the rules. It was a leap of faith to do that because you literally have to walk out with nothing. And we did. That’s scary in and of itself. But once we had decided that we were going and we had clarity around where we were going, that just became just another step in the process for us. Steve, I don’t know if you’d agree with that or not, but… Steve Armaly: Yeah, and Mindy, it’s a huge decision and on the surface it is scary. But again, what we found and were continuously impressed with was the support that we got. And especially in the legal area, it’s very well spelled out what you can and can’t do. And if you take their advice and follow it to the T, you’ll be in great shape. And that’s really what it comes down to is listen to counsel, they’re there to help you, and it will work if you follow the rules of the game. Mindy Diamond: Yeah. So the proof is in your pudding because you moved a billion dollars in assets or were at a billion dollars in assets in 225 days post move, which is extraordinary. So yes, you walked out of UBS with zero and 225 days later crossed the billion dollar mark, which is extraordinary. But were there moments in between that were, holy cow, what did we do? Or even moments beforehand is, oh my God, we can’t take client information. We’ve had this information for 16 years or 30 years and what are we going to do? Steve Armaly: Yeah. I think everybody will have a moment in the transition when they’re like, wow, we really did this and you’re going to hit some roadblocks. You’re going to be surprised to the good and maybe some to the bad. But ultimately, in your due diligence, you know your why. Why are we here? Why did we make this move? What is the truth in all of that? You’ve got to remind yourself occasionally about that and have faith and got to believe that this was more than just some decision that was made for self-interest. This was a decision that you pondered, you seek counsel, you had great consultants to help with, and you’ve done something like this in the past, you can do it again. And we all have to be reminded of that on the journey I feel like. Without a doubt, nothing good is easy and transitioning isn’t easy, but it is certainly worth it. Mindy Diamond: Yeah. So let me ask you a question. What did the pitch sound like? So day one, you leave UBS, you’ve got zero in AUM, and you call your first five clients. What did the pitch sound like and how did those clients react to that pitch? Michael Lee: Basically, we announced that we left and that’s it. Mindy Diamond: Remind us why, because the Protocol prohibited you from… Michael Lee: Yeah, we couldn’t do anything in advance and we couldn’t solicit or anything else like that. We were just literally allowed to announce that we had left and that’s it. Mindy Diamond: But I imagine clients had questions for you. So how and why did those assets begin to trickle in? Steve Armaly: And I meant to share this in the previous question too, is that if you’ve truly run your practice, as we all should, where you’re client focused, you’re doing all the things that you should do with your clients. You have comprehensive planning, you’re updating that planning on annual basis, you have regular reviews with your clients, you have open-ended conversations with your clients, and you’ve created an environment where they truly know that you’re there to serve their needs whenever they pop up. So much of the hard work is just in how you’ve been running your business that allows you to transition well because you can rely on that. And I think that, our clients know us well. We’re very transparent. We’re transparent about what we think about financial planning and our investment strategy and what we do. We’re very transparent about how we live our lives even. And so our clients have a vested interest in always asking us why or what’s happening from our standpoint. And they, I think, have grown to trust us that we’re very prudent in our decision making. And as we share that we’ve made a decision to leave after many years and here we are, the questions were really, there must be a good reason and tell us about why and tell us what is it going to look like and what’s it going to look like for us? We loved it. As soon as they opened the door to asking questions, then we were back in the seat of who we’ve always been, which is just very transparent, honest partners who are there to take care of our clients. Mindy Diamond: I love that answer, Steve, because it’s my experience. It’s my experience of being an outsider, a third party looking in, counseling teams. The teams that, first of all, are moving for the right reasons. The reasons being we’re doing this for the benefit of clients. If it’s about self-interest, people can smell that, they sniff that out immediately. But if you’ve always done the right thing by clients and you’re moving for the right reasons, which is for their benefit, it’s, in most cases, the loyalty is rewarded or the loyalty is a reward for always having done the right thing and most people find that. But we all agree it is scary. And I think the people that are the most scared are often the ones that just are less sure. Well, two things are the people that are most scared. One, the people that are less certain that they’ve always done the right things or less certain that their clients know they’ve always done the right thing. And two, the ones that have really a large number of smaller clients. It’s much easier to have faith in a book that will move when you’ve got say under two or 300 clients than in a book that has a thousand clients. I assume you’d agree with that. Steve Armaly: Very much so. And you’re spot on, Mindy. And if you run your practice well… And this is the part that we think some firms have lost sight of, is that it truly is if you are running a practice and serving your clients well, it is the relationship between the client and the advisor. And you build a lot of goodwill if you do it right. And we knew we were leaning in on the goodwill by making a transition, but it’s been amazing to watch our clients rally around us where we have always rallied around them and their life events and their challenges, but they’ve rallied around us and supported us in this transition. And from day one, we had clients coming in just to drop off food and flowers and things to tell us, “Congratulations, what can we do for you?” The last thing they wanted to talk about was their portfolio and their assets. They were genuinely concerned about us and what we were doing and wanted us to know that they were in our corner here to support us. And that was amazing and very reassuring early in the process. Mindy Diamond: So how about the reality of you said we moved because we wanted to do better for clients. Can you give me some examples of the things you’re able to do now that actually make you better able to serve clients? Steve Armaly: There’s a lot of room. Michael Lee: Yeah. From a technology, I mean, one of the things that we were able to do is build our own tech stack, and so that was fun to go through and do that. Some of our marketing things that we’ve been able to do from weekly market updates to we just launched a podcast with Jeff and Brian that we’re particularly proud of. So we’ve been able to, we feel like, level up in just about everything that we were doing before and the ability to redirect resources to areas that are important to us, it’s been fun to do that and that it’s been fast, which has also been great. Mindy Diamond: Yeah, amazing. So you said a billion-two when you left UBS, a billion-one a year later. How much of that is our original clients, how much of that is new assets and how does this sort of ability to market with more freedom, for example, how does that impact your prospecting? Michael Lee: Yeah, Steve’s got that one. Steve Armaly: Well, we believe our retention rate of existing clients and assets was 93%. And interestingly enough, even in the transition process, a lot of our clients were having life events where there were additional assets that were coming in also. So that was a nice shot in the arm in a sense, having clients transition as well as they did and then additional assets coming in. Our pipeline has never been bigger than it is today in terms of new client activity. It’s been amazing to see where we are, maybe the excitement of the transition and the move and how that’s opened more doors to us since making that transition. So the transition is extremely busy. And then on top of that, in the new business world, we’re probably as busy as we’ve ever been with a very strong and healthy pipeline. Mindy Diamond: That’s amazing. What do you think about your value proposition, meaning the value proposition of being independent, what aspects of that appeal to prospects? Michael Lee: We’ve got a lot of business owner clients, and for whatever reason, that kindred spirit of having the responsibility of making payroll, they resonate. So they’re like, “Oh, you guys are one of us, so you get it.” So I think there’s that part that’s maybe hitting a touchpoint that was there before, but it’s even deeper now because it is our own business. So they know the importance because they know how important their business is to them. It’s not a leap of faith to understand that they would assume that same level of commitment to ours. And then I think we’re just able to try to put more resources around the client experience that is also having a direct impact on what that looks like. So the relationships are getting deeper, richer, and fuller. Mindy Diamond: And do any prospects question the lack of a big name firm behind you? Michael Lee: No. One of the things why we chose the structured independence model was there was two things that we did not want to take on right away. And that became clear, again, going back to our conversations with Deb. We did not want to take on the responsibility of cybersecurity ourselves. That was a very tall order, and especially in this day and age, we did not want to have that on our responsibility. And then of course also compliance, which is ever-growing and changing as well. So those two things were very important that we had a good partner with, and LPL has done that. So the ability to control the P&L, the hiring and firing, the allocation of resources, the marketing, the branding, all of the things that were of paramount importance to us, we can do. And then the two areas that we did not want to take on, we left with our partner, LPL. And with their size and scope, they’ve been a tremendous resource and backstop to us. And a lot of our clients didn’t know who LPL was, but once they get an idea of the size and structure of the largest independent broker dealer, that helps. Mindy Diamond: You actually took the words right out of my mouth. My follow-up question was going to be, as you looked at the waterfall of possibilities of ways to go independent, you opted to go for supported independence with LPL Strategic Wealth Services, which is the supported independent model for under the LPL umbrella. And so you answered the question in terms of by doing so, it allowed you to outsource or insource to them the parts you didn’t want. It solved some of the financial, the sort of short-term risk. It allowed you to de-risk to a certain degree in the short-term. So my question is, has LPL delivered? Have they been a good partner? And to what extent are they helping you to grow or get wherever you want to go next? Steve Armaly: I’ll jump in and say right off the bat, yes, they have delivered. And especially in the areas of the ancillary services in setting up a practice to walk in day one, turn on the light switch and be fully operational, they were superb. Unmatched services, we believe in technology, unmatched services in terms of real estate and helping us negotiate leases, find our space, do up-fits, support that we receive from them. I would say they really did surpass our expectations in terms of all the areas that they helped us with marketing, I’m leaving so many of them off the table, but we were really blown away by how good they were. And that’s what really led us to making the decision to go with LPL, and the best part was to see that come to fruition. And the spirit within the firm is what we talked about right away from our first due diligence trip when we met them is we felt like everybody that sat at the table had a desire to do what we do, which is to make our lives better as much as we’re trying to make our clients’ lives better. We felt like that was in their DNA and it really was. And so I’d say that they certainly met our expectations. The transition part, there are areas where we’ve been very transparent with them saying, “Hey, I think we could improve these areas.” The great thing about that is they’ve been very receptive. They want to get better at what they do day in and day out. And that spirit is what we probably appreciate the most is as much as we think we’re good at what we do, we know we don’t know everything and that we have to constantly learn, change, and grow. And they seem to have that same mindset. Mindy Diamond: Love it. I’ve got two final questions for you. One is, so what’s next? The first year for any breakaway team is always about stabilizing the business, learning new systems, making sure clients are set, getting the infrastructure set, all of it. But it’s year two, three, and beyond when it gets really fun. It’s less about transition and stress and more about really looking why you want to independent in the first place. So what are some of the things that are deep in your laboratory or some things you think about? Michael Lee: We feel called to grow and that’s going to mean continuing to grow organically, but we also feel called to grow and that will end up being through mergers and acquisitions as well. So it is a longer term and what that looks like in the first one and all that, we’re still formulating what that looks like to us, but we have a responsibility to be difference makers and we want to lean into that. Mindy Diamond: I love it. Final question. There are so many advisors that are sitting at your former firm, that are sitting at other large firms, that are sitting at small broker dealers that are just scared to go independent, or let’s not even focus on independence, to move in general. A move is a hassle. A move is disruptive. If it’s a non-protocol move, it’s risky. You’ve got partners that may not be aligned. You’ve got the worry. There is no guarantee that clients follow. What if the transition doesn’t work? What if something blows up? What if a million what ifs? What advice would you give to anyone listening who’s in that, “I would love to do it. I wish I could press the easy button or the fast-forward button and just be there, but I’m scared about getting from here to there”? What would you say to them? Steve Armaly: That’s a great question, Mindy. And right off the bat, I would certainly say to anybody to have courage. If you are doing and serving your clients to the best of your ability and running a good practice, then you have everything in place that you need to ultimately move. And regrettably in our industry, and we all say this, but it’s almost as if it’s the answer that everybody knows needs to be put into practice, but for some reason it’s not being put into practice. That is, you’ve got to honor the client-advisor relationship. You have to understand what really makes this profession work is the exchange of trust that occurs between a family and an advisor, and that’s a highly coveted or trusted position. And if we all protect that and do what’s right, then ultimately I think relationships will go anywhere to follow somebody who’s been an honorable leader, who’s given good advice to a family, who’s helped them make wise decisions. I wish that you could pick a home and stay there forever, but ultimately whatever those outside forces are, sometimes they lose sight again of what’s most important, which is the client-advisor relationship. And I would encourage anybody that feels like if they’re in a place where they’ve lost that as their mission, then ultimately their clients and themselves as advisors deserve better. And if you know why you’re doing it, and ultimately it’s to put your clients first, then you have all that you need. The rest of it is to have a trusted partner like your firm and to have somebody help you to digest the landscape and get a great understanding of where your clients are going to be best served, and then to take the advice that they provide to you and the roadmap. In a lot of ways, people will say it’s not difficult, but we know there’s tons of challenges in it, but with the right partners, you’ve got everything you need. Just you have to have faith and belief in why you’re doing it. Mindy Diamond: That’s actually a beautiful answer, and I agree with it because what you’re saying is if you’ve got clarity, a vision, and you’re doing it for the right reasons, you can’t and shouldn’t be held hostage by fears or thinking small. It doesn’t mean that a move is right for everyone, certainly not. But I think you said it better than I ever could and I love it. So I want to thank you both so, so much for your transparency, for your time, for your willingness, for your trust in us. We don’t take that lightly. I think your story will resonate with many. And I am so excited to see what the future holds for you because it seems like it’s very bright. Michael Lee: Thank you. Steve Armaly: Thank you, Mindy. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously and are dedicated to your clients, but are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook.

October 8, 2026Episode 38045 min

The Wirehouse Talent Battle: Winners, Losers and What’s Changing

A Special Industry Update with Louis Diamond and Jason Diamond Wirehouse advisor movement accelerated sharply in the first half of 2026. Louis and Jason Diamond unpack the numbers, the forces driving them, and what they reveal about an increasingly competitive advisor marketplace. In Summary Wirehouse advisor movement reached a notable pace in the first half of 2026. Across Merrill, Morgan Stanley, UBS, and Wells Fargo, 1,449 experienced advisors left while 932 joined—a net decline of 517 advisors in just six months. Yet those aggregate numbers obscure four very different firm-level stories and a much broader shift in the competitive landscape. Louis and Jason Diamond unpack the findings from Diamond Consultants’ 2026 H1 Advisor Transition Report: Wirehouse-Focused Edition , looking beyond headcount to examine where advisors are going, why large teams are moving, what recruiting economics look like, and why wirehouses continue to win sophisticated advisors even as overall attrition rises. The larger story may be one of expanding choice. More than 200 firms recruited at least one wirehouse advisor during the first half of the year, giving advisors more ways to match their business, economic, cultural, and client-service priorities with a model that fits. Want to go deeper into the data? Download Diamond Consultants’ 2026 H1 Advisor Transition Report: Wirehouse-Focused Edition for the complete findings, firm-by-firm analysis, advisor destination data, recruiting economics, and representative transitions. Download the Full Report → The Storyline Wirehouses remain home to some of the largest and most sophisticated financial advisor businesses in the industry. But the market competing for those advisors has changed dramatically. That makes the movement captured in the first half of 2026 particularly revealing. At first glance, the headline is attrition: The four wirehouses lost 517 advisors on a net basis in six months. Dig deeper, however, and the picture becomes far more nuanced. Wells Fargo and Morgan Stanley were net winners, while Merrill and UBS experienced significant net losses. Nearly half of departing wirehouse advisors chose some form of independence, yet more than half remained within an employee model. And 41 teams managing more than $500mm left a wirehouse—including 20 managing $1B or more. Louis and Jason examine what is behind those numbers. Their discussion looks at the push factors driving some advisors to reconsider their firms and the increasingly diverse pull factors drawing them elsewhere. Jason describes a marketplace in which the four wirehouses no longer compete primarily with one another, but with regional firms, boutiques, independent broker dealers, RIAs, platform providers, and other emerging models. They also examine why the movement of the industry’s largest teams deserves particular attention. These advisors often have significant resources, strong economics, access to senior leadership, and well-served clients at their existing firms. Yet some are concluding that having more to lose can also mean having more to gain—whether through greater control, enterprise value, culture, branding, or another business priority. The result isn’t a simple story of wirehouses losing and independence winning. It is a story about a marketplace with more credible choices – and more competition for successful advisors – than ever before. Topics Covered H1 2026 wirehouse advisor movement and net attrition Merrill, Morgan Stanley, UBS, and Wells Fargo recruiting trends Wirehouse-to-wirehouse movement vs. advisor independence Large-team and $1B+ advisor transitions Push and pull factors driving advisor movement Wirehouse, regional, and boutique recruiting deals RIA valuations and private equity-backed acquisitions Enterprise value and advisor ownership Retire-in-place programs and compensation changes AI and technology as recruiting considerations The expanding universe of advisor affiliation models > Download a transcript of this episode… Listen and Learn Highlights for Advisors What does the headline wirehouse attrition number really tell us? (04:28) Jason explains why the 517-advisor net decline is significant, but also why headcount alone provides an incomplete picture of advisor movement. Why is wirehouse advisor movement accelerating? (06:33) The discussion turns to the push factors creating frustration inside firms and the pull factors created by a far broader and more competitive marketplace of alternatives. Why are Wells Fargo and Morgan Stanley outperforming their wirehouse peers? (11:23) Louis and Jason break down the four firms individually, including Morgan Stanley’s organic growth engine and Wells Fargo’s recruiting resurgence. What’s behind the notable movement out of UBS? (16:25) Jason looks beyond advisor count to the size and quality of the teams leaving UBS, while Louis considers the tension that can arise between corporate strategy and what individual advisors want from their firm. Is the real story independence or the explosion of advisor choice? (20:46) While 46% of departing wirehouse advisors chose independence, the conversation reveals an equally important trend: advisors are moving across a much broader range of W-2 and independent models. Why does the movement of $500mm and $1B+ teams matter so much? (26:01) Jason explains why these highly successful teams have both the greatest optionality and, potentially, the most to gain from reconsidering their model. Why do wirehouses remain formidable recruiters? (30:42) Brand, familiarity, investment capabilities, banking and lending, alternatives, and competitive recruiting deals continue to make the wirehouse model attractive to many sophisticated advisors. What are firms paying to recruit top wirehouse teams? (36:02) Louis and Jason compare current W-2 recruiting packages with independent transition economics and the increasingly significant valuations available through RIA and private equity-backed acquisitions. What could shape advisor movement through 2027? (41:34) Compensation changes, retire-in-place programs, RIA valuations and AI emerge as important forces to watch as advisors continue evaluating firms and models. What should advisors ultimately take away from the data? (44:31) The report isn’t intended as a case for changing firms. It’s a way to understand where the industry is heading, what advisors are looking for, and how the competitive landscape is evolving. Key Takeaways Wirehouse movement is elevated on both sides of the ledger. Firms are losing more advisors, but they are also recruiting aggressively, so net headcount is only one measure of what is happening. The four wirehouses are experiencing very different recruiting environments. Wells Fargo and Morgan Stanley were net positive during H1, while UBS and Merrill posted substantial net losses. Independence is gaining share, but this isn’t simply an independence story. While 46% of departing wirehouse advisors chose an independent model, 54% did not. Regional firms, boutiques, and alternative W-2 models are also attracting meaningful advisor talent. The movement of large teams may be more meaningful than overall advisor count. Twenty $1B+ teams left wirehouses during the first half of 2026, despite generally having significant resources and leverage at their existing firms. More choice is changing the recruiting equation. More than 200 firms recruited a wirehouse advisor in H1, increasing the likelihood that advisors can find a model aligned with a highly specific set of priorities. Recruiting economics remain highly competitive. Traditional recruiting packages can exceed 400% of trailing production for select teams, while independent and acquisition models introduce very different ways to monetize and build enterprise value. AI is becoming part of firm evaluation. Advisors increasingly want to understand how prospective firms are approaching AI, whether through large-scale proprietary investment or the flexibility to select emerging third-party tools. https://youtu.be/OZrhTf4nfCU Quotable Moments “The number of big teams in motion is probably the more important number than surely just the number of advisors in motion.” — Jason “These teams that are this size…have the most to lose. What we’re seeing, though…is they flip that logic on its head.” — Jason “More choice means more leverage for advisors.” — Louis “Every firm is recruiting…Every firm is clearly losing advisors, some more than others. But the common through line is successful teams…have more credible destinations for their business than ever before.” — Louis FAQs How many wirehouse advisors moved in the first half of 2026? Across Merrill, Morgan Stanley, UBS, and Wells Fargo, 1,449 experienced advisors left during the first six months of 2026, while 932 joined, resulting in net attrition of 517 advisors. Are all four wirehouses losing advisors? No. The aggregate numbers mask meaningful differences among the firms. Wells Fargo finished H1 with a net gain of 46 advisors, Morgan Stanley gained 23, UBS lost 182, and Merrill lost 404 on a net basis. Where are departing wirehouse advisors going? The destinations are increasingly diverse. In H1 2026, 46% chose an independent model, 24% moved to another wirehouse, and others selected regional, boutique, and alternative employee models. More than 200 firms recruited at least one wirehouse advisor during the period. Are large wirehouse teams also moving? Yes. Forty-one teams managing more than $500mm left a wirehouse in the first half of 2026, including 20 teams managing $1B or more. Twelve of the 41 teams chose another wirehouse, reinforcing that sophisticated teams are evaluating both employee and independent alternatives. Why do advisors continue to choose wirehouses? For many advisors, the appeal includes brand recognition, familiarity, banking and lending, investment capabilities, access to alternatives and SMAs, integrated infrastructure, and competitive recruiting economics. Louis and Jason also note that some perceived capability differences narrow considerably once advisors compare models more closely. What recruiting deals are wirehouses offering financial advisors in 2026? Jason describes typical wirehouse recruiting packages around 325–350% of trailing production, with packages exceeding 400% available for particularly desirable teams. Louis also notes that upfront components for larger practices can reach approximately 175–200% or more, depending on the team and deal structure. Does the report suggest wirehouse advisors should change firms? No. Jason explicitly describes the report as a source of industry and firm-level data rather than a sales pitch for movement. Its purpose is to help advisors understand where the marketplace is heading and the factors influencing advisor decisions. What trends could affect wirehouse advisor movement next? Compensation-plan changes, retire-in-place programs, RIA and private equity valuations, and AI capabilities are among the factors Louis and Jason identify as potentially shaping advisor movement through the remainder of 2026 and into 2027. Across Merrill, Morgan Stanley, UBS, and Wells Fargo, 1,449 experienced advisors left during the first six months of 2026, while 932 joined, resulting in net attrition of 517 advisors. No. The aggregate numbers mask meaningful differences among the firms. Wells Fargo finished H1 with a net gain of 46 advisors, Morgan Stanley gained 23, UBS lost 182, and Merrill lost 404 on a net basis. The destinations are increasingly diverse. In H1 2026, 46% chose an independent model, 24% moved to another wirehouse, and others selected regional, boutique, and alternative employee models. More than 200 firms recruited at least one wirehouse advisor during the period. Yes. Forty-one teams managing more than $500mm left a wirehouse in the first half of 2026, including 20 teams managing $1B or more. Twelve of the 41 teams chose another wirehouse, reinforcing that sophisticated teams are evaluating both employee and independent alternatives. For many advisors, the appeal includes brand recognition, familiarity, banking and lending, investment capabilities, access to alternatives and SMAs, integrated infrastructure, and competitive recruiting economics. Louis and Jason also note that some perceived capability differences narrow considerably once advisors compare models more closely. Jason describes typical wirehouse recruiting packages around 325–350% of trailing production, with packages exceeding 400% available for particularly desirable teams. Louis also notes that upfront components for larger practices can reach approximately 175–200% or more, depending on the team and deal structure. No. Jason explicitly describes the report as a source of industry and firm-level data rather than a sales pitch for movement. Its purpose is to help advisors understand where the marketplace is heading and the factors influencing advisor decisions. Compensation-plan changes, retire-in-place programs, RIA and private equity valuations, and AI capabilities are among the factors Louis and Jason identify as potentially shaping advisor movement through the remainder of 2026 and into 2027. Explore the Data Behind the Conversation The podcast adds context and commentary to the findings. The full report provides the underlying data, analysis, and representative advisor moves. Download the Wirehouse Advisor Transition Report → NOTE: The views and opinions expressed by the guests on this podcast are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Diamond Consultants. Neither Diamond Consultants nor the guests on this podcast are compensated in any way for their participation. View the transcript of this episode… The Wirehouse Talent Battle: Winners, Losers and What’s Changing A Special Industry Update with Louis Diamond and Jason Diamond. Louis Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is The Wirehouse Talent Battle: Winners, Losers, and What’s Changing. It’s a conversation with my partner, Jason Diamond. I’m Louis Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our Annual Advisor Transition Report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Louis Diamond: Advisor movement is nothing new, but the pace and perhaps more importantly, the nature of the movement we saw across the wirehouses during the first half of 2026 is worth paying attention to. And there’s a reason we chose to focus this report specifically on wirehouse advisors. The four wirehouses still represent an enormously important part of the wealth management industry, serving some of its largest and most sophisticated advisors and clients. At the same time, those advisors have more legitimate alternatives competing for their business than ever before. That makes their movement particularly instructive. Where they go, what they leave behind, and what they’re looking for tells us a lot about how the broader industry is evolving. In just six months, 1,449 experienced advisors left Merrill, Morgan Stanley, UBS, and Wells Fargo while 932 joined them. That represents net attrition of 517 advisors, more than the wirehouses lost on a net basis during all of 2025. But those headline numbers don’t tell the whole story. Morgan Stanley and Wells Fargo actually posted positive net advisor growth. Nearly a quarter of departing wirehouse advisors simply chose another wirehouse. At the same time, 46% chose an independent model, and perhaps most notable, 41 teams managing more than $500 million left to wirehouse in the first half of the year, including 20 managing one billion or more. There’s a lot happening beneath the surface. Jason is essentially the architect of our new 2026 first half advisor transition report, wirehouse focused edition. So I’ve asked him to join me to go beyond the numbers, what’s driving the movement, why the four firms are experiencing very different results, where advisors are going, what firms are paying to recruit them, and what all of this may tell us about the evolving competitive landscape. There’s a lot to unpack. Let’s get into it. Jason Diamond: Thanks, Louis. I’m thrilled to be here. I’m excited to discuss. Louis Diamond: Amazing. Yeah, I know these data-driven reports have really become your brainchild. They’re incredibly helpful, I know to me and to a number of advisors and just people in the industry. This report is of extra interest and importance just because of the pace of movement we’re seeing specifically in the wirehouse segment. So I know you looked at the first six months of advisor movement, so January one to the end of June 2026, of course not a full year. We publish that report in 2027, but let’s start with the headline number you have here, which is 517 advisors the wirehouse has lost on a net basis in the first six months. Can you comment how significant that is? Jason Diamond: A couple things. First of all, I’m always excited to write this report because you and I, we spend our day talking to financial advisors, and we think we have a pretty good sense of where the puck is heading and the pace of advisor movement, but it’s hard to tell because we know we only represent a small microcosm of the industry. So I think we had this feeling like advisor movement was up across the board, and this report helped to put numbers to just how elevated movement is. And you alluded to this, recruiting is a two-sided game. It’s part attrition and it’s part inbound, and we saw elevated numbers on both sides of the ledger for the wires. And we’ll talk about, to say the wires is probably a little bit overly generalizing. It’s probably worth breaking down on a firm by firm level, but we’re talking about 1,449 advisors who left a wirehouse versus 932 advisors that joined a wirehouse. So just at a very simple level, when you talk about where is the puck heading, it’s heading away from the wirehouse channel. Overall, the channel is losing advisor talent, but, and this is an important but, there are also plenty of folks in our industry who will be quick to tell you that the wirehouse space is dying and that W-2 models are a thing of the past, that everybody’s going independent, and 932 advisors that joined a wirehouse would tell you something far to the contrary. Louis Diamond: Yeah, numbers are numbers, but without context or grounding, it’s hard to square. Is that a lot? Is that a little? But I know from our 2025 report that if these numbers held that the net wirehouse attrition figures, it would already be far more than the wirehouse’s lost net in 2025. So can you talk a little bit about just the comparison to ’25 and what do you think this means for this year so far? Jason Diamond: You said it well. These would represent absolute records by not just a little, but by a long, long margin. And there is some seasonality to these numbers where it’s not necessarily fair just to double the first half numbers because as we know, very few advisors move in December, for example. But what it ultimately tells me is the things we’ve been talking about are starting to have an impact or continuing to have an impact on advisor mindset and advisor movement. And to rehash, that is to me a two-front story. It is a story of pushes and pulls. When we say pushes, we are talking about frustrations or limitations that people experience. And honestly, the wirehouses, all four of them are guiltier of frustrating or limiting their advisors than probably just about any other firm in the industry. That’s just a reality of life at the biggest firms on the street. So we certainly hear plenty of push factors, but also excitingly from my seat, pull factors, meaning when advisors look out at the landscape today, I think we had a number in the report of 200 different firms recruited a wirehouse advisor in the first half. So you talk about diversity of choice, diversity of legitimate choice. That’s my biggest takeaway because I do think the headcount, while the numbers are eye-popping, what’s more telling to me, and you alluded to this a little bit in your introductory comments, the number of big teams in motion is probably the more important number than truly just the number of advisors in motion, in my opinion. Louis Diamond: Yeah, no doubt. We always caveat in our report since we started doing it that even though we’re guilty now of we’re talking about headcount, that’s a pretty misleading number because a firm can add someone with LOS 4 saying that that washes out a one advisor with a billion who leaves the firm. So it is an imperfect science. It’s impossible for us to really get into granular detail on AUM per move. The only way we can is if there’s an AdvisorHub or news story or the team happened to be on Barron’s or Forbes or some sort of industry list. So we’ll give that caveat that headcount is definitely not the whole story. We focus more on the quality and the size, and we’ll get later into this episode into the number of larger scale teams that were in transition and how that tracks versus other years. I think what’s also interesting is the fact that this net attrition number is so much higher than it’s been because I think probably beginning of this year, maybe end of last year was the first time since 2016, 2017 that we’ve seen all four wirehouses be competitively back into the recruiting market. So you would think that with four really competitive deals from four great firms that that would keep more people in the channel, but it seems to have had the reverse impact in many cases. Jason Diamond: Look, what I think that speaks to partly is the four wirehouses know they’re no longer operating in a world where they’re competing exclusively against each other. They’re equally competing against regional firms, boutique firms, RIAs, broker dealers, platform firms and the like, and that is a reality that just means there’s going to be more churn quote/unquote in the industry because of the fact that advisors are more likely to find their version of perfect. When you look out and say, “Well, I don’t want another wirehouse, but I need to monetize the book and I want to maintain equity and I want X, Y, Z,” you might just find that in what the landscape looks like today. So I think it’s cause and effect. The wires are paying those deals because it is so difficult to recruit. That’s the first thing I’ll say. The other caveat I’d give is recruiting is a wonderful thing, but firms, I’ll call this the Morgan Stanley argument, and they’re right, are quick to point out that same store sales, organic growth matters probably just as much if not more. And Morgan Stanley advisors and wirehouse advisors as a whole tend to grow faster than other advisors in the industry. And so the argument is they may be slowing down quote/unquote on the recruiting side, but if they can feed their advisors faster and their advisors can grow faster, that may ultimately be a winning formula in the long term. What are your thoughts on that? Louis Diamond: I completely agree. It’s way, way cheaper to acquire a new customer through organic means than through inorganic means. It’s better for valuations in the RA world, certainly better for stock prices for publicly traded companies. It also buys loyalty, creates stickiness. So I would agree. Any firm that has a mousetrap to help advisors grow organically, there’s no downside. There’s probably five or six benefits. So you mentioned Morgan Stanley in particular. Let’s zoom into the four wires in particular because I think the attrition numbers, the growth numbers for each of them, they tell wildly different stories. So in the report you talk about how Wells Fargo was net positive. They actually have the highest gains plus 46, and Morgan Stanley was second with positive 23 advisors with UBS negative 182, Merrill negative 404. So massive differences between the net attrition figures for all of them. Can you give some color behind each of them and why you think those numbers are what they are? Jason Diamond: Yeah, so the first thing I do when I look at these numbers is I want to normalize them relative to each other. And so here’s what I mean. Think about the base advisor population at these firms. UBS is by far the smallest of the wires, a half to even a third probably of the size of their peers, Morgan and Merrill in particular. So you see almost 200 net advisors leaving UBS. That’s really more than 400 if you think about it on a normalized basis in terms of Merrill or Morgan. That’s the first thing. The second thing I want to do is I want to say, are there any real outlier events that are causing the data to be misleading? Did a portion of the firm get bought or sold? Was there one team of advisors that had a hundred people on it that left? Is there something that’s skewing the numbers? And Merrill certainly has that. Over a hundred of the Merrill departures left for JP Morgan, and that tells us I think that a lot of those departures are bank advisors in nature. The data is difficult to parse through sometimes of what is a “financial advisor” for the purposes of tracking. So that gives me some confidence that the Merrill attrition story isn’t quite that dire. And then when they look at Morgan Stanley and Wells, no question, that’s one where the numbers match our anecdotal experience. Morgan Stanley to me is like the little engine that could kind of steady eddy, keeps chugging right along as the clear winner over the last five years, certainly in the wirehouse space. We talked about their advisor’s ability to grow organically. The funnel story seems to be working, this idea that they’re feeding their advisors referral relationships from workplace, from E-Trade, and they also seem to have done the best job in terms of just general advisor sentiment of this peer set. Wells I think is an interesting story here. Wells to me, not really a platform or a capability change, but obviously they were hindered dramatically in the past several years by the consumer banking scandal. Really what I would call it is, excuse the expression, but advisors and clients were allergic to the firm name, and we’re just seeing that a beat where now advisors are at least willing to entertain the conversation, more than willing to entertain the conversation. You pair that with a really, really good deal in both channels. And I will caveat this Wells number does include both their PCG and their FiNet channels. So it is probably skewed slightly higher given some of the FiNet channels are technically not really wirehouse moves, but still no question if you think about who is the number one success story of this year in advisor recruiting land, maybe not even just the wires, maybe industry as a whole, I would argue it’s Wells Fargo. Louis Diamond: I would agree. Actually, it’s great to see that Wells has rebounded. Reputations ebb and flow. Who’s hot, who’s not certainly changes. Wells was on the negative side of the ledger for much longer than we’ve seen any firm for a long time. So it’s great to see that they’ve rebounded. And this data too, I mean, I think it’s purest. This does not count the internal moves of W-2, private client group advisors moving independent with FiNet. To us, that’s just net retention. It doesn’t tell an overall story. So that’s great to hear. Let’s drill it a bit more into UBS. I mean, you mentioned it’s the second biggest loser on a net basis, but based upon the size, you make the case that they’ve lost the largest percentage of their population of advisors. So what’s actually happening within UBS? Jason Diamond: The single most concerning data point and probably the most telling data point to me in all of this is the asset numbers that have left UBS in the first half of the year, massive outflows. Said another way, it’s not the number of teams necessarily that have left UBS, it’s the size of those teams. These are not little small bank teams that are going to the local regional bank on the corner. These are franchise marquee corner office teams. We can count certainly double digits of those types of teams. So whenever we see that, it certainly gets our attention because the question is what’s going on under the hood? Are there issues with the firm? I think UBS is an interesting one. They made the compensation plan changes, now it’s a year and a half ago, have realized that that is a difficult genie to put back in the bottle. And I think what it shed light on is advisors just felt like the value they were getting from the firm is no longer worth the 50% of revenue that the firm is taking. The number of headaches that they’re running into, whether it’s I can’t hire support staff, compliance is overly onerous, it’s difficult to grow, it takes me too long to get simple answers, all of that just makes it so that it’s no longer worth it to justify the juice isn’t worth the squeeze. And there’s no question, I feel there is a real momentum trade with financial advisor movement. So advisors see their colleague from a market away, a huge team leaving, and it gets their attention, and then they see three other teams leaving, and they go, “Hmm.” And then almost they feel like they have permission, I think, like, “Hey, I feel this way too, and look, all these other teams are leaving as well.” I think we saw that flywheel. The question is what inning are we in? I don’t think it’s over. I think you’re still going to see some big UBS teams leave. And on top of that, they have been able to recruit inbound. We have seen some teams go inbound into UBS, but it’s taken a really, really lofty deal to be able to do that. When that deal normalizes more, what is their ability to recruit? So I’m curious what your thoughts are. Louis Diamond: I would agree. Yeah, it felt like in 2025, UBS didn’t really recruit anyone, but definitely seeing them pop up more as a winner. So it’s telling that they’re paying a big deal. They have been relatively successful in bringing new advisors into the firm, but they’re still losing and on a pace to lose even more than how they can restock the pond. So I think it’s super interesting. To me, the distinction with UBS right now is fairly simple. It’s what may work for the corporation or for shareholders or for the management team in Switzerland is not what individuals want from their firm. It’s that push and pull or that tug of war of corporate agendas are one thing, corporate strategy, what they’re trying to do is great. It’s their prerogative, but a lot of times those decisions have downstream impacts on advisors, and a lot of times it’s a light bulb moment for advisors of, as long as I’m here, I’m not fully in control and either their changes are good enough for me, I can make peace with them, I can reconcile them. Or it’s a reminder, a wake-up call that unless you’re independent or unless you’re at a firm that has a track record or history of not making compensation plan changes, really making decisions that are framed as far as what’s best for the advisor rather than for the shareholders, this is always going to be a dynamic that’s in play. So I think to me, that’s the short version of what’s happening with UBS. Still a great firm, not going out of business, but I think in a bit of purgatory right now as far as what their strategic play is to stop the outflows, increase the inflows, and really continue to build on a leading wealth management franchise. This whole report, this stat that you pulled is probably the most interesting because it’s so different from how we usually see this data. And maybe once the dust settles on all of 2026, it’ll normalize. But the report says that 46% of departing wirehouse advisors chose independence. To me, that’s a big, big number. I think it’s usually like 25%, 20%. I might be wrong, but this is a massive number. So can you dig into this a little bit more? Jason Diamond: So again, I think there is definitely some skew here based on size of teams because generally speaking, when you think about just in terms of number of moves, count of number of moves, it’s generally smaller independent moves that are the most common, meaning moves towards the independent space. It’s not that there was this massive wave of mega independent breakaways, although we certainly did see those types of moves. When I think about 46% of departing advisors choosing independence, to me, there’s two ways to think through that number. One is the 54% did not, and that is also telling to me that there is still a massive subset of advisors that choose some version of knowing that their life is not going to get better in every way, they still choose a version of captivity for some reason or another. They want the brand, they want the big deal, they worry about what their clients will think about independent. So more than half of advisors still are not going that direction. Now that said, when you see a number like 46%, the other thing it says to me is we never see advisors really going the other way, meaning advisors who are independent very seldom move back towards captive models. So over time, this is a concerning story. The story that the big traditional firms are losing headcount slowly over time, they will need to combat that in some other way. And one way we already spoke about will be organic growth just growing faster than the rate at which their advisors leave. Louis Diamond: No doubt. I think the other piece of it is, so you have 46% who are going independent, that means 54% are on the other side. They’re moving within W2 world, but double click into that 54%. I know for the first half of this year, 24% of all the advisors who transition went to another wirehouse, and that alone is much lower than it’s been. I think usually it’s 50, 52, 54, 55% or so of all wirehouse advisors transition within their channel, move to another wirehouse. So for the first half of this year, to me, the analysis shows more interest in independence, less movement from wirehouse to wirehouse, but still a lot of interest in alternative W2 models. Would you think that’s accurate? Does that tell the story? Jason Diamond: 100%. And that’s really the story that I think if you asked a lot of advisors or even people in the wealth management media, what is the story in your mind? Forget the data. I think it’s that. It’s that certainly independent has its place, but there is a whole slate of, I don’t want to say tier two because it makes it sound like they’re less than, but a whole slate of alternative W2 firms that aren’t the big wirehouses, whether that’s the regional firms like Raymond James and RBC or the boutique firms like Rockefeller that advisors are certainly moving to, which says to us, again, the model is not broken. It’s not an indictment of the W2 model where everybody’s like, “Yeah, this is a no-brainer if you’re not a 1099 or a K-1, it’s bust.” That’s not the story we’re really seeing play out. Louis Diamond: I think it’s honestly kind of the opposite. We’re actually seeing a lot of independent firms start W2 channels. LPL’s had a bunch of success with their Linsco W2 model. Cetera and Osaic now have W2 channels. So it seems like that the pendulum just swings back and forth, but to me, again, highlights number of choices. You said it in your opening, of the advisors who moved in the first half of this year, 200 different destinations. That’s absolutely crazy, considering we have four major firms we’re talking about that picked up about a quarter of those advisors. The fact that the other 75% or so moved to 196 or more different firms, that to me is the hero of this report. It really, really shows the amount of choices. And if you pick through the list, it’s hard to say there’s 200 legitimate options because there’s a lot of one-offs, and this guy was fired, there’s some hair on this. It’s hard to pull that out. But the fact that that many firms have won a wirehouse advisor is incredibly, incredibly telling, and I think the best possible news for an advisor. More choice means more leverage for advisors. It means deals are better. They get better and better and better. And like you said earlier, it means that no matter what your list of items are, your must-haves, your nice-to-haves, you’re probably more likely than ever to be able to match that up with what’s available in the industry, which is very, very cool. So let’s talk a little bit about the quality. Like we said earlier, headcount, a bit of a misleading proxy for success and where the best advisors are voting with their feet. Can you talk a little bit about, let’s say, the teams managing 500 million or more or a billion or more, however you cut it? Jason Diamond: Yeah, and there was a lot of these. You don’t need to track the data to know there was a lot of these just because we saw these are the ones that make the front page of AdvisorHub, and we saw at least one a week really leaving the wirehouses. Now, some of those agreed did direct back towards a wirehouse. UBS even won their share of wirehouse advisors, but we highlight that number for a couple reasons. Number one, those teams have infinite choice. So you talk about all these different spectrum of options. That’s not necessarily true for every team on the landscape. If you’re running a business that’s 800,000 in revenue, you may not have the scale or size to go out and start an RIA, for example. These teams that are this size, we blow their mind sometimes, I think, when we talk about the degree of optionality they have in today’s landscape. That’s the first thing. The second thing is, when you think about their setup at their current firm, these should be the advisors that are the best taken care of, the best compensated, a phoned to the top, their clients are super well-served, they’re growing fast. On paper, these are the people that should not be moving because they have the keys to the kingdom and they have the most to lose, frankly, by something going wrong. They know a transition is risky. What we’re seeing though in these teams moving 20 teams over a billion in assets leaving a wirehouse in the first half of the year, we’re seeing they flip that logic on its head. They say, “Yes, we have the most to lose in some sense, but we also have the most to gain.” And what that looks like can mean something different for every team. It can mean, for some, economically it means let’s recapture as much of our enterprise value as possible. We want to own the economics, so we might be able to sell this someday. For others, it means culture. We just missed the Bank of America or the Merrill of old. We want to get back to that feeling that we had elsewhere. For others, it’s the ability to market or brand yourself. I want to run a podcast. So there’s no definition of what that has to look like, but these teams all for one reason or another, and I guarantee you every single one of those teams, the money might have been a part of it in some capacity. It was not first on the list. I say that hand to God. I think there’s sometimes a perception of like, “Well, yeah, of course these teams are leading because they can get 400% to do so.” Oftentimes, we see teams like this, in fact, taking no money. They’ll say, “I’m going to launch a business and take no money up front because I believe in what I’m building, and I know I’ll be able to sell this thing on the back end.” Louis Diamond: No doubt about it. The valuation multiples for a 500 million or above or a billion dollar and above practice, they scale exponentially versus the production multiples, the 350%, the 400% deal that a W2 model firm pays, it stays stagnant. Of course, the base of the revenue increases, so the valuation increases, but you’re not seeing for a $5 billion team a 600% deal from Morgan Stanley. So I think there’s some of that dynamic, it’s just the valuations are absolutely crazy in other segments of the industry. So we’re seeing either teams jump for that right away, looking to sell their business out of a captive firm to a big RIA or private equity firm, or taking the first step in their play, which is let’s go build something and then in the future we’ll monetize it. So of these big teams, do you know, and I might be putting you on the spot, how many of them move to another wirehouse? So trying to highlight or drill into this trend. So 20 teams over a billion move, which is a big number. I think it’s on par with what we see for a typical year. Do you know how many or what percentage of these stayed within the wirehouse channel? Jason Diamond: Yeah, of the 41 teams over 500 million, 12. So right on par, I think with those, I’ll call it roughly a quarter staying within the wirehouse channel. And those are significant wins for the wirehouses, which again, the fact that we’re seeing 500 million plus teams choosing a wirehouse, these are not fools. These people do extensive due diligence on their life’s work. It shows again the degree to which a wirehouse is a legitimate home for a wealth management business in this day and age. Louis Diamond: Yeah, perfect. So the numbers here, like you said, headcount could be misleading. I think just showing the quality of advisors who are moving and also the quality of advisors staying within the channel is telling. So let’s flip the equation on its head. If advisors are leaving wirehouses at an elevated level like we talked about, why are we still seeing the wirehouse be formable recruiters? Why are they still showing up in virtually every conversation we have with the wirehouse team? Jason Diamond: I think the easy answer to this is a degree of inertia or the easy button, if you will, where advisors, the fact that there’s 200 firms that an advisor might go to is not necessarily a good thing. That also means overwhelm, and it’s sometimes just daunting to even consider all of that. And the wirehouse world is like the cocoon in which a lot of these advisors grew up. It’s like, “I know that world, it’s comfortable, and my clients know that world more importantly.” So I think that’s part of it. I think there is a capability story here to an extent, and some of this might be misconceptions. So to the extent you consider brand a capability, you have to concede that point to the wirehouses. They have the best brands on the street, and clients ultimately may care about brand. I think this gets overstated a little bit, but brand would certainly be one. SMA and alternative platforms are two of the others that get commonly floated. So high net worth focused products that the wirehouses have just done the best job at from an access perspective and from a pricing perspective. And because of that, a lot of wirehouse advisors are pretty heavy users of these types of products. And so what happens is they find it difficult to move the book of business to a firm that’s less competent in that area. We’re seeing a lot of firms bridge that gap from a capability perspective. Banking and lending might be another one. I’m an advisor at Merrill. I have the kid in the candy store mentality. I have access to everything I need all within one house versus if I go independent, that’s a major mindset change to have to shop the street. All of that, plus these are some of the top deals on the street as far as W-2 deals go. It’s easy to see why there are some advisors who just say, “This is the route I’m going to go.” Louis Diamond: Absolutely. Yeah, man, I think you’re right. Especially on the SMA side, we see UBS has these free SMA strategies, so that’s really hard to reconcile or to account for in a transition. I think too, and I’ll see if you agree, that access to SMAs, access to alternatives, access to banking and lending, that’s available everywhere. Is it more so that the wires just do a better job of positioning it or selling it? Or it’s more so just like it’s what these advisors are used to. They’re used to the way it works that I pick up the phone, I call my Bank of America banker, I need an alternative, I click here versus more of an unbundled approach in other segments of the industry. You think that’s part of it too, is it’s not that they access necessarily better at the wires, but it’s easier to digest and it’s just more familiar the way that it all comes together? Jason Diamond: I think it’s 90% what you’re describing. 90%, it’s just a matter of apples here and oranges here, and if you translate the language, you end up in the same spot. That 10% is a legitimate capability gap. It might be a pricing gap. Oh, they actually can access that manager, but Morgan Stanley has $80 trillion in assets with them, so they’re going to get leaner pricing than this independent firm. That 10% is purely a test of an advisor’s mindset. Do you have that growth mindset of, is that a deal breaker for you? Can you find a way, either that means having to have a conversation with clients about switching products, about eating the cost for a period of time, or some advisors will let things like that be a deal breaker? And in our opinion, that’s fine as long as you’re not letting the tail wag the dog, meaning don’t be held hostage because you’re using a lot of QGar at UBS. Louis Diamond: Well said. Do you think this report draws out the fact that wirehouses are in fact becoming more selective about the type of advisor that they actually want to target? If you just follow the pay grid changes, the comp plan changes that all these firms make on an annual basis or semi-annual basis, it seems like they keep pushing up the grid thresholds where there’s certain incentives for larger teams or for teaming. Do you think that some of the wirehouses not recruiting as many of advisors on a net basis is because they’re in fact actually becoming more selective? They’re saying no to someone with a hundred million, 50 million, et cetera, or is that just an oversimplification? Jason Diamond: I think that’s the narrative that they are perpetuating. What does saying no look like? I think it’s almost the equivalent of, we used to call this quiet quitting where they’re not telling these advisors, we don’t want you, but they’re making policies that say to these advisors, we don’t really want you. I think there’s definitely some of that. So meaning if you’re a small advisor, Morgan Stanley’s payout grid is among the worst on the street of their peer set. So you may be ruled out. That’s not Morgan Stanley saying to you, we don’t want you here. I think in a lot of cases, these firms know how competitive the recruiting environment is, and they will take advisors more often than not. So that’s why I’m always not so quick to be like, “Yeah, they’re super selective. They’re saying no to all these $1 and $2 million advisors because that’s just not the world we live in.” Louis Diamond: Yeah, I would tend to agree. Maybe there’s some truth to it. It explains some of it, but not all of it. Let’s talk a little bit about deals. I know it changes a lot of time, very much dependent upon size of the business, quality of the business, competitive dynamics, et cetera. But in general, if you’re a wirehouse advisor who’s considering another W2 model, what’s the typical range we’re seeing? Jason Diamond: So this may be where, to use your point, maybe where we see firms getting more selective is in deal structure where they’ll say, “Here’s our rack rate deal.” So in the case of wirehouse firms, I would put that number at 325 to 350%-ish, but, and it’s a big but, they have the ability, every single one of them in my mind has the ability to get north of 400% for the right team. Wells and UBS are north of 400% right out of the gates. The regional firms too, you think about RBC, Raymond James, even Stifel to a lesser extent, they’re right there when they want to be. But that’s the story to me is if I had to quote a deal, I’d probably quote something fairly conservative, like 325-ish percent, knowing that for the right teams that show well, have a lot of advisory or invested in growth, et cetera, we can do substantially better than that. But firms are absolutely being more selective in that regard, and part of that just capital’s gotten more expensive. Louis Diamond: Yep, exactly. I think too, headline numbers are great to share with your friend at the golf course and, “Oh, Jimmy got this.” But really what matters more is the structure. So what we’ve seen over the last couple of years is the upfront portion of the deal has increased, probably not the same rate as the overall deals have, but we’re definitely seeing for a larger practice, 175% at a minimum upfront. In some cases 200% or more is fairly commonplace, and different options as far as weighting of the backends, easier to hit certain bonuses, carving out assets, the fact that backends are based on AUM now for the most part instead of production, they’re all things that in a competitive market have gotten better for the advisor, even if the overall headline deals and the upfronts I think have gone up, but they’re not going up or changing to keep pace with all the competitive dynamics in the industry. Let’s talk briefly about if a wire team wants to go independent, do they get a deal? What does that look like? Jason Diamond: Maybe, probably they get something. It depends on the version of independence. So the way I think about this is there’s four different paths a wirehouse advisor might walk. One is they might just launch an RIA with one of the major custodians. We see Goldman in this space commonly for wirehouse teams. In that instance, not really. They might get some benefit or startup expense dollars, but they’re not really getting a transition deal. Another path though might be affiliating with an independent broker dealer. So this would be like an LPL, and those absolutely come with a recruiting deal, 100% in some cases of revenue, a hundred basis points on assets, maybe even just north of that. Another path might be these support players or platform firms. So this would be firms like Sanctuary who in many cases do indeed pay transition deals, and the pitch is fairly straightforward. It’s basically, we can help you to look and feel like an RIA, but we take off a lot of the heavy lift from your plate. So things like compliance and cobbling together your tech stack, you don’t have to do. And then the last flavor I would mention briefly, it’s arguably not even independence, but you spoke about it for a second. We’re seeing advisors sell their businesses directly to independent firms, acquirers, private equity firms, roll-ups, et cetera. Those advisors are not independent on the other side. Typically, they get purchased and become W2 employees of the buyer, but those deal structures are eye-popping. You’re talking about multiples. Oftentimes it’s not a revenue multiple, but if I had to quote a revenue multiple, I’d probably say five to 6X top line, maybe 5X top line, so big numbers. Louis Diamond: Yeah, that’s the part that I’m always so interested in because the math for selling your business out of a wire to typically a large PE-backed RIA, the math is so, so, so compelling. Get equity as part of it, which if you run it out over 10 years is potentially even more valuable than the cash. It’s capital gains, either all of it or most of it. Yeah, five and a half, six, sometimes more. I know this report in this episode is about the first half of 2026, but a recent example in September of this year was Eddie Ventrice and Mike Bober down in Boca ran a $20 million plus UBS private wealth team. They sold their practice to Cresset, who’s been on this episode. So that’s a live, really tangible example. We’ve been saying this for years, hasn’t quite picked up yet, but I do think that’s the undiscovered terrain of this recruiting dynamic. I think that has more potential leverage for deals to increase or stay the same than what Raymond James is paying relative to UBS or what Rockefeller is paying relative to Morgan Stanley. I think it’s this X factor of these very aggressive, very well capitalized buyers coming in and taking a dent out of wirehouse recruiting. So again, might be early. We started our breakaway bank with Dynasty to capture this trend, and I’d say it’s early in it, but we’re very bullish it’s going to happen. Let’s talk a little bit forward-looking. What do you think are the biggest forces that will shape advisor movement through the rest of 2026 and even into 2027? Jason Diamond: Compensation plan changes always pop up in this bucket right around this time of year because they do seem to always spur just a little bit of movement, good, bad or indifferent. It’s oftentimes just I think an excuse for advisors to reevaluate. I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention retire in place deals. This is not a new dynamic, nothing to do with the end of the year, but to me, the single biggest determinant of when we run this report next year, what are these numbers going to look like? I would turn that question on its head and say how widespread does adaption of retire in place deals become? Or how much more widespread, I guess I should say. I think it’s a huge determinant about whether advisors can and will move because it represents the most compelling alternative. Compelling, I might put in quotes. You mentioned this private equity valuation story. I’m keeping my eye on that because we have now seen a couple of teams. We were not wrong, we were early, shall we say, to this prediction here, but we’ve now seen a couple of teams where I think you could start to see this come true a little bit more. So meaning the Mariners and Mercers and Beacon Pointe of the world start to acquire more directly from wirehouses. And then lastly, I would certainly mention AI. I don’t think any one firm has figured this out necessarily, but this has become question one on advisors’ due diligence checklist is how are firms addressing this? What are firms doing about this? And we are seeing a number of firms really lean into this from a recruiting perspective. Savvy Wealth, Altruist, I think even Morgan Stanley and LPL to a lesser extent. So those are some of the things I’m watching. Louis Diamond: Yeah, I think those are very accurate. Yeah, this on the AI point, I don’t think right now there’s a clear consensus on whether one type of firm is the right play for someone who’s trying to insulate themselves from the risk of AI or stay ahead of the trends. I see plenty of advisors who say, “I’m trusting that my captive firm, be it Morgan Stanley, Ed Jones, LPL, whoever it is spending billions of dollars on technology, I’m trusting them that they’re boiling the ocean, integrating this stuff, developing their own platforms, and that I’m going to trust them as my partner.” On the flip side, you have advisors that say, “This pace of AI is changing so quickly,” as a future-proof in September, and there’s hundreds of AI FinTech booths that are just all these companies are popping up. So there’s plenty of advisors who say, “I want to be as independent as possible or have the ability to pick and choose AI vendors as they come to market so I can stay ahead of the trend.” So I don’t know. I feel like there isn’t a right or wrong answer, but AI is absolutely becoming and has become a push factor, pushing people to consider change and a pull factor, meaning it’s how advisors are oftentimes evaluating their top destination, especially with younger advisors or folks with a longer runway. So let’s do one more question, and then we’ll wrap here. So we’ve shared a lot of numbers, a lot of information, and thank you for that. And we will link this report in the show notes. It will be on our website. So definitely give it a read, run it through your AI system to unpack it. There’s a lot of information in there. But what should an advisor listening really take from this episode if they take a step back from it? Jason Diamond: A couple things. I think first of all, I hope that the data does not come across in any way as a sales pitch because it’s not supposed to be. It’s not supposed to suggest that advisors need to move in order to achieve their best business life. It’s supposed to show advisors where the puck is heading at an industry level, at a firm level. And I hope that’s how people use it is just to be empowered with that data. And also we try to sprinkle in our commentary. I think we speak to as many or more advisors than anybody and just try to conclude the things that come up the most as pain points, so meaning why are advisors leaving? But then also on the flip side, when advisors are evaluating or joining a firm, what are the things they’re looking to achieve, and what are they really looking for? That’s what I hope advisors will take from the report. And then I’d be remiss if didn’t mention, always seems to be the most popular section is the representative deals where we highlight a couple of the major moves from the year. So I won’t run through them here, you’ll have to read the report, but one that I did find interesting that I’ll talk about for two seconds was Twin Harbor Private Wealth going from Merrill to Wells Fargo FiNet. These are the types of deals we highlight, and we just provide some rationale as to why a team might leave a big wirehouse like Merrill to join the independent channel of Wells Fargo, reasons like continuing to operate under a big brand. You mentioned a big recruiting deal, I’m sure was certainly a part of it and more. So the representative deals I think have become a really good lens into advisor mindset via real firsthand stories. Louis Diamond: There’s a lot of cool takeaways from this, but I think one of my biggest ones to sum it up is every firm is recruiting, gunning for similar types of advisors. Every firm is clearly losing advisors, some more than others, but the common through line is successful teams, advisors in general have more credible destinations for their business than ever before. So there’s going to be pluses, there’s going to be minuses. Who’s going to win in the end? It’s the advisor. And that’s what makes our job great is advisors I think are always in the influence control position. Those who control the gross control the game I’ve heard people say. And I think this report and over 200 different firms won a wirehouse team in the first half of the year, and just seeing the quality of teams in transition should be really good news for any advisor listening to this episode. So thank you for being our resident data expert and data scientist and for giving some really good takeaways on this data and making it interesting and not boring. And we’ll invite everyone to download the report. Again, it’ll be in the show notes. It’s on our website or reach out to Jason or I, and we’re happy to send it to you personally. So, Jason, thanks for doing this today. Jason Diamond: Thank you. This was great, Louis. Really appreciate it. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibility seriously and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? Is a book written with you in mind? It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook . The Wirehouse Talent Battle: Winners, Losers and What’s Changing A Special Industry Update with Louis Diamond and Jason Diamond. Louis Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is The Wirehouse Talent Battle: Winners, Losers, and What’s Changing. It’s a conversation with my partner, Jason Diamond. I’m Louis Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our Annual Advisor Transition Report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Louis Diamond: Advisor movement is nothing new, but the pace and perhaps more importantly, the nature of the movement we saw across the wirehouses during the first half of 2026 is worth paying attention to. And there’s a reason we chose to focus this report specifically on wirehouse advisors. The four wirehouses still represent an enormously important part of the wealth management industry, serving some of its largest and most sophisticated advisors and clients. At the same time, those advisors have more legitimate alternatives competing for their business than ever before. That makes their movement particularly instructive. Where they go, what they leave behind, and what they’re looking for tells us a lot about how the broader industry is evolving. In just six months, 1,449 experienced advisors left Merrill, Morgan Stanley, UBS, and Wells Fargo while 932 joined them. That represents net attrition of 517 advisors, more than the wirehouses lost on a net basis during all of 2025. But those headline numbers don’t tell the whole story. Morgan Stanley and Wells Fargo actually posted positive net advisor growth. Nearly a quarter of departing wirehouse advisors simply chose another wirehouse. At the same time, 46% chose an independent model, and perhaps most notable, 41 teams managing more than $500 million left to wirehouse in the first half of the year, including 20 managing one billion or more. There’s a lot happening beneath the surface. Jason is essentially the architect of our new 2026 first half advisor transition report, wirehouse focused edition. So I’ve asked him to join me to go beyond the numbers, what’s driving the movement, why the four firms are experiencing very different results, where advisors are going, what firms are paying to recruit them, and what all of this may tell us about the evolving competitive landscape. There’s a lot to unpack. Let’s get into it. Jason Diamond: Thanks, Louis. I’m thrilled to be here. I’m excited to discuss. Louis Diamond: Amazing. Yeah, I know these data-driven reports have really become your brainchild. They’re incredibly helpful, I know to me and to a number of advisors and just people in the industry. This report is of extra interest and importance just because of the pace of movement we’re seeing specifically in the wirehouse segment. So I know you looked at the first six months of advisor movement, so January one to the end of June 2026, of course not a full year. We publish that report in 2027, but let’s start with the headline number you have here, which is 517 advisors the wirehouse has lost on a net basis in the first six months. Can you comment how significant that is? Jason Diamond: A couple things. First of all, I’m always excited to write this report because you and I, we spend our day talking to financial advisors, and we think we have a pretty good sense of where the puck is heading and the pace of advisor movement, but it’s hard to tell because we know we only represent a small microcosm of the industry. So I think we had this feeling like advisor movement was up across the board, and this report helped to put numbers to just how elevated movement is. And you alluded to this, recruiting is a two-sided game. It’s part attrition and it’s part inbound, and we saw elevated numbers on both sides of the ledger for the wires. And we’ll talk about, to say the wires is probably a little bit overly generalizing. It’s probably worth breaking down on a firm by firm level, but we’re talking about 1,449 advisors who left a wirehouse versus 932 advisors that joined a wirehouse. So just at a very simple level, when you talk about where is the puck heading, it’s heading away from the wirehouse channel. Overall, the channel is losing advisor talent, but, and this is an important but, there are also plenty of folks in our industry who will be quick to tell you that the wirehouse space is dying and that W-2 models are a thing of the past, that everybody’s going independent, and 932 advisors that joined a wirehouse would tell you something far to the contrary. Louis Diamond: Yeah, numbers are numbers, but without context or grounding, it’s hard to square. Is that a lot? Is that a little? But I know from our 2025 report that if these numbers held that the net wirehouse attrition figures, it would already be far more than the wirehouse’s lost net in 2025. So can you talk a little bit about just the comparison to ’25 and what do you think this means for this year so far? Jason Diamond: You said it well. These would represent absolute records by not just a little, but by a long, long margin. And there is some seasonality to these numbers where it’s not necessarily fair just to double the first half numbers because as we know, very few advisors move in December, for example. But what it ultimately tells me is the things we’ve been talking about are starting to have an impact or continuing to have an impact on advisor mindset and advisor movement. And to rehash, that is to me a two-front story. It is a story of pushes and pulls. When we say pushes, we are talking about frustrations or limitations that people experience. And honestly, the wirehouses, all four of them are guiltier of frustrating or limiting their advisors than probably just about any other firm in the industry. That’s just a reality of life at the biggest firms on the street. So we certainly hear plenty of push factors, but also excitingly from my seat, pull factors, meaning when advisors look out at the landscape today, I think we had a number in the report of 200 different firms recruited a wirehouse advisor in the first half. So you talk about diversity of choice, diversity of legitimate choice. That’s my biggest takeaway because I do think the headcount, while the numbers are eye-popping, what’s more telling to me, and you alluded to this a little bit in your introductory comments, the number of big teams in motion is probably the more important number than truly just the number of advisors in motion, in my opinion. Louis Diamond: Yeah, no doubt. We always caveat in our report since we started doing it that even though we’re guilty now of we’re talking about headcount, that’s a pretty misleading number because a firm can add someone with LOS 4 saying that that washes out a one advisor with a billion who leaves the firm. So it is an imperfect science. It’s impossible for us to really get into granular detail on AUM per move. The only way we can is if there’s an AdvisorHub or news story or the team happened to be on Barron’s or Forbes or some sort of industry list. So we’ll give that caveat that headcount is definitely not the whole story. We focus more on the quality and the size, and we’ll get later into this episode into the number of larger scale teams that were in transition and how that tracks versus other years. I think what’s also interesting is the fact that this net attrition number is so much higher than it’s been because I think probably beginning of this year, maybe end of last year was the first time since 2016, 2017 that we’ve seen all four wirehouses be competitively back into the recruiting market. So you would think that with four really competitive deals from four great firms that that would keep more people in the channel, but it seems to have had the reverse impact in many cases. Jason Diamond: Look, what I think that speaks to partly is the four wirehouses know they’re no longer operating in a world where they’re competing exclusively against each other. They’re equally competing against regional firms, boutique firms, RIAs, broker dealers, platform firms and the like, and that is a reality that just means there’s going to be more churn quote/unquote in the industry because of the fact that advisors are more likely to find their version of perfect. When you look out and say, “Well, I don’t want another wirehouse, but I need to monetize the book and I want to maintain equity and I want X, Y, Z,” you might just find that in what the landscape looks like today. So I think it’s cause and effect. The wires are paying those deals because it is so difficult to recruit. That’s the first thing I’ll say. The other caveat I’d give is recruiting is a wonderful thing, but firms, I’ll call this the Morgan Stanley argument, and they’re right, are quick to point out that same store sales, organic growth matters probably just as much if not more. And Morgan Stanley advisors and wirehouse advisors as a whole tend to grow faster than other advisors in the industry. And so the argument is they may be slowing down quote/unquote on the recruiting side, but if they can feed their advisors faster and their advisors can grow faster, that may ultimately be a winning formula in the long term. What are your thoughts on that? Louis Diamond: I completely agree. It’s way, way cheaper to acquire a new customer through organic means than through inorganic means. It’s better for valuations in the RA world, certainly better for stock prices for publicly traded companies. It also buys loyalty, creates stickiness. So I would agree. Any firm that has a mousetrap to help advisors grow organically, there’s no downside. There’s probably five or six benefits. So you mentioned Morgan Stanley in particular. Let’s zoom into the four wires in particular because I think the attrition numbers, the growth numbers for each of them, they tell wildly different stories. So in the report you talk about how Wells Fargo was net positive. They actually have the highest gains plus 46, and Morgan Stanley was second with positive 23 advisors with UBS negative 182, Merrill negative 404. So massive differences between the net attrition figures for all of them. Can you give some color behind each of them and why you think those numbers are what they are? Jason Diamond: Yeah, so the first thing I do when I look at these numbers is I want to normalize them relative to each other. And so here’s what I mean. Think about the base advisor population at these firms. UBS is by far the smallest of the wires, a half to even a third probably of the size of their peers, Morgan and Merrill in particular. So you see almost 200 net advisors leaving UBS. That’s really more than 400 if you think about it on a normalized basis in terms of Merrill or Morgan. That’s the first thing. The second thing I want to do is I want to say, are there any real outlier events that are causing the data to be misleading? Did a portion of the firm get bought or sold? Was there one team of advisors that had a hundred people on it that left? Is there something that’s skewing the numbers? And Merrill certainly has that. Over a hundred of the Merrill departures left for JP Morgan, and that tells us I think that a lot of those departures are bank advisors in nature. The data is difficult to parse through sometimes of what is a “financial advisor” for the purposes of tracking. So that gives me some confidence that the Merrill attrition story isn’t quite that dire. And then when they look at Morgan Stanley and Wells, no question, that’s one where the numbers match our anecdotal experience. Morgan Stanley to me is like the little engine that could kind of steady eddy, keeps chugging right along as the clear winner over the last five years, certainly in the wirehouse space. We talked about their advisor’s ability to grow organically. The funnel story seems to be working, this idea that they’re feeding their advisors referral relationships from workplace, from E-Trade, and they also seem to have done the best job in terms of just general advisor sentiment of this peer set. Wells I think is an interesting story here. Wells to me, not really a platform or a capability change, but obviously they were hindered dramatically in the past several years by the consumer banking scandal. Really what I would call it is, excuse the expression, but advisors and clients were allergic to the firm name, and we’re just seeing that a beat where now advisors are at least willing to entertain the conversation, more than willing to entertain the conversation. You pair that with a really, really good deal in both channels. And I will caveat this Wells number does include both their PCG and their FiNet channels. So it is probably skewed slightly higher given some of the FiNet channels are technically not really wirehouse moves, but still no question if you think about who is the number one success story of this year in advisor recruiting land, maybe not even just the wires, maybe industry as a whole, I would argue it’s Wells Fargo. Louis Diamond: I would agree. Actually, it’s great to see that Wells has rebounded. Reputations ebb and flow. Who’s hot, who’s not certainly changes. Wells was on the negative side of the ledger for much longer than we’ve seen any firm for a long time. So it’s great to see that they’ve rebounded. And this data too, I mean, I think it’s purest. This does not count the internal moves of W-2, private client group advisors moving independent with FiNet. To us, that’s just net retention. It doesn’t tell an overall story. So that’s great to hear. Let’s drill it a bit more into UBS. I mean, you mentioned it’s the second biggest loser on a net basis, but based upon the size, you make the case that they’ve lost the largest percentage of their population of advisors. So what’s actually happening within UBS? Jason Diamond: The single most concerning data point and probably the most telling data point to me in all of this is the asset numbers that have left UBS in the first half of the year, massive outflows. Said another way, it’s not the number of teams necessarily that have left UBS, it’s the size of those teams. These are not little small bank teams that are going to the local regional bank on the corner. These are franchise marquee corner office teams. We can count certainly double digits of those types of teams. So whenever we see that, it certainly gets our attention because the question is what’s going on under the hood? Are there issues with the firm? I think UBS is an interesting one. They made the compensation plan changes, now it’s a year and a half ago, have realized that that is a difficult genie to put back in the bottle. And I think what it shed light on is advisors just felt like the value they were getting from the firm is no longer worth the 50% of revenue that the firm is taking. The number of headaches that they’re running into, whether it’s I can’t hire support staff, compliance is overly onerous, it’s difficult to grow, it takes me too long to get simple answers, all of that just makes it so that it’s no longer worth it to justify the juice isn’t worth the squeeze. And there’s no question, I feel there is a real momentum trade with financial advisor movement. So advisors see their colleague from a market away, a huge team leaving, and it gets their attention, and then they see three other teams leaving, and they go, “Hmm.” And then almost they feel like they have permission, I think, like, “Hey, I feel this way too, and look, all these other teams are leaving as well.” I think we saw that flywheel. The question is what inning are we in? I don’t think it’s over. I think you’re still going to see some big UBS teams leave. And on top of that, they have been able to recruit inbound. We have seen some teams go inbound into UBS, but it’s taken a really, really lofty deal to be able to do that. When that deal normalizes more, what is their ability to recruit? So I’m curious what your thoughts are. Louis Diamond: I would agree. Yeah, it felt like in 2025, UBS didn’t really recruit anyone, but definitely seeing them pop up more as a winner. So it’s telling that they’re paying a big deal. They have been relatively successful in bringing new advisors into the firm, but they’re still losing and on a pace to lose even more than how they can restock the pond. So I think it’s super interesting. To me, the distinction with UBS right now is fairly simple. It’s what may work for the corporation or for shareholders or for the management team in Switzerland is not what individuals want from their firm. It’s that push and pull or that tug of war of corporate agendas are one thing, corporate strategy, what they’re trying to do is great. It’s their prerogative, but a lot of times those decisions have downstream impacts on advisors, and a lot of times it’s a light bulb moment for advisors of, as long as I’m here, I’m not fully in control and either their changes are good enough for me, I can make peace with them, I can reconcile them. Or it’s a reminder, a wake-up call that unless you’re independent or unless you’re at a firm that has a track record or history of not making compensation plan changes, really making decisions that are framed as far as what’s best for the advisor rather than for the shareholders, this is always going to be a dynamic that’s in play. So I think to me, that’s the short version of what’s happening with UBS. Still a great firm, not going out of business, but I think in a bit of purgatory right now as far as what their strategic play is to stop the outflows, increase the inflows, and really continue to build on a leading wealth management franchise. This whole report, this stat that you pulled is probably the most interesting because it’s so different from how we usually see this data. And maybe once the dust settles on all of 2026, it’ll normalize. But the report says that 46% of departing wirehouse advisors chose independence. To me, that’s a big, big number. I think it’s usually like 25%, 20%. I might be wrong, but this is a massive number. So can you dig into this a little bit more? Jason Diamond: So again, I think there is definitely some skew here based on size of teams because generally speaking, when you think about just in terms of number of moves, count of number of moves, it’s generally smaller independent moves that are the most common, meaning moves towards the independent space. It’s not that there was this massive wave of mega independent breakaways, although we certainly did see those types of moves. When I think about 46% of departing advisors choosing independence, to me, there’s two ways to think through that number. One is the 54% did not, and that is also telling to me that there is still a massive subset of advisors that choose some version of knowing that their life is not going to get better in every way, they still choose a version of captivity for some reason or another. They want the brand, they want the big deal, they worry about what their clients will think about independent. So more than half of advisors still are not going that direction. Now that said, when you see a number like 46%, the other thing it says to me is we never see advisors really going the other way, meaning advisors who are independent very seldom move back towards captive models. So over time, this is a concerning story. The story that the big traditional firms are losing headcount slowly over time, they will need to combat that in some other way. And one way we already spoke about will be organic growth just growing faster than the rate at which their advisors leave. Louis Diamond: No doubt. I think the other piece of it is, so you have 46% who are going independent, that means 54% are on the other side. They’re moving within W2 world, but double click into that 54%. I know for the first half of this year, 24% of all the advisors who transition went to another wirehouse, and that alone is much lower than it’s been. I think usually it’s 50, 52, 54, 55% or so of all wirehouse advisors transition within their channel, move to another wirehouse. So for the first half of this year, to me, the analysis shows more interest in independence, less movement from wirehouse to wirehouse, but still a lot of interest in alternative W2 models. Would you think that’s accurate? Does that tell the story? Jason Diamond: 100%. And that’s really the story that I think if you asked a lot of advisors or even people in the wealth management media, what is the story in your mind? Forget the data. I think it’s that. It’s that certainly independent has its place, but there is a whole slate of, I don’t want to say tier two because it makes it sound like they’re less than, but a whole slate of alternative W2 firms that aren’t the big wirehouses, whether that’s the regional firms like Raymond James and RBC or the boutique firms like Rockefeller that advisors are certainly moving to, which says to us, again, the model is not broken. It’s not an indictment of the W2 model where everybody’s like, “Yeah, this is a no-brainer if you’re not a 1099 or a K-1, it’s bust.” That’s not the story we’re really seeing play out. Louis Diamond: I think it’s honestly kind of the opposite. We’re actually seeing a lot of independent firms start W2 channels. LPL’s had a bunch of success with their Linsco W2 model. Cetera and Osaic now have W2 channels. So it seems like that the pendulum just swings back and forth, but to me, again, highlights number of choices. You said it in your opening, of the advisors who moved in the first half of this year, 200 different destinations. That’s absolutely crazy, considering we have four major firms we’re talking about that picked up about a quarter of those advisors. The fact that the other 75% or so moved to 196 or more different firms, that to me is the hero of this report. It really, really shows the amount of choices. And if you pick through the list, it’s hard to say there’s 200 legitimate options because there’s a lot of one-offs, and this guy was fired, there’s some hair on this. It’s hard to pull that out. But the fact that that many firms have won a wirehouse advisor is incredibly, incredibly telling, and I think the best possible news for an advisor. More choice means more leverage for advisors. It means deals are better. They get better and better and better. And like you said earlier, it means that no matter what your list of items are, your must-haves, your nice-to-haves, you’re probably more likely than ever to be able to match that up with what’s available in the industry, which is very, very cool. So let’s talk a little bit about the quality. Like we said earlier, headcount, a bit of a misleading proxy for success and where the best advisors are voting with their feet. Can you talk a little bit about, let’s say, the teams managing 500 million or more or a billion or more, however you cut it? Jason Diamond: Yeah, and there was a lot of these. You don’t need to track the data to know there was a lot of these just because we saw these are the ones that make the front page of AdvisorHub, and we saw at least one a week really leaving the wirehouses. Now, some of those agreed did direct back towards a wirehouse. UBS even won their share of wirehouse advisors, but we highlight that number for a couple reasons. Number one, those teams have infinite choice. So you talk about all these different spectrum of options. That’s not necessarily true for every team on the landscape. If you’re running a business that’s 800,000 in revenue, you may not have the scale or size to go out and start an RIA, for example. These teams that are this size, we blow their mind sometimes, I think, when we talk about the degree of optionality they have in today’s landscape. That’s the first thing. The second thing is, when you think about their setup at their current firm, these should be the advisors that are the best taken care of, the best compensated, a phoned to the top, their clients are super well-served, they’re growing fast. On paper, these are the people that should not be moving because they have the keys to the kingdom and they have the most to lose, frankly, by something going wrong. They know a transition is risky. What we’re seeing though in these teams moving 20 teams over a billion in assets leaving a wirehouse in the first half of the year, we’re seeing they flip that logic on its head. They say, “Yes, we have the most to lose in some sense, but we also have the most to gain.” And what that looks like can mean something different for every team. It can mean, for some, economically it means let’s recapture as much of our enterprise value as possible. We want to own the economics, so we might be able to sell this someday. For others, it means culture. We just missed the Bank of America or the Merrill of old. We want to get back to that feeling that we had elsewhere. For others, it’s the ability to market or brand yourself. I want to run a podcast. So there’s no definition of what that has to look like, but these teams all for one reason or another, and I guarantee you every single one of those teams, the money might have been a part of it in some capacity. It was not first on the list. I say that hand to God. I think there’s sometimes a perception of like, “Well, yeah, of course these teams are leading because they can get 400% to do so.” Oftentimes, we see teams like this, in fact, taking no money. They’ll say, “I’m going to launch a business and take no money up front because I believe in what I’m building, and I know I’ll be able to sell this thing on the back end.” Louis Diamond: No doubt about it. The valuation multiples for a 500 million or above or a billion dollar and above practice, they scale exponentially versus the production multiples, the 350%, the 400% deal that a W2 model firm pays, it stays stagnant. Of course, the base of the revenue increases, so the valuation increases, but you’re not seeing for a $5 billion team a 600% deal from Morgan Stanley. So I think there’s some of that dynamic, it’s just the valuations are absolutely crazy in other segments of the industry. So we’re seeing either teams jump for that right away, looking to sell their business out of a captive firm to a big RIA or private equity firm, or taking the first step in their play, which is let’s go build something and then in the future we’ll monetize it. So of these big teams, do you know, and I might be putting you on the spot, how many of them move to another wirehouse? So trying to highlight or drill into this trend. So 20 teams over a billion move, which is a big number. I think it’s on par with what we see for a typical year. Do you know how many or what percentage of these stayed within the wirehouse channel? Jason Diamond: Yeah, of the 41 teams over 500 million, 12. So right on par, I think with those, I’ll call it roughly a quarter staying within the wirehouse channel. And those are significant wins for the wirehouses, which again, the fact that we’re seeing 500 million plus teams choosing a wirehouse, these are not fools. These people do extensive due diligence on their life’s work. It shows again the degree to which a wirehouse is a legitimate home for a wealth management business in this day and age. Louis Diamond: Yeah, perfect. So the numbers here, like you said, headcount could be misleading. I think just showing the quality of advisors who are moving and also the quality of advisors staying within the channel is telling. So let’s flip the equation on its head. If advisors are leaving wirehouses at an elevated level like we talked about, why are we still seeing the wirehouse be formable recruiters? Why are they still showing up in virtually every conversation we have with the wirehouse team? Jason Diamond: I think the easy answer to this is a degree of inertia or the easy button, if you will, where advisors, the fact that there’s 200 firms that an advisor might go to is not necessarily a good thing. That also means overwhelm, and it’s sometimes just daunting to even consider all of that. And the wirehouse world is like the cocoon in which a lot of these advisors grew up. It’s like, “I know that world, it’s comfortable, and my clients know that world more importantly.” So I think that’s part of it. I think there is a capability story here to an extent, and some of this might be misconceptions. So to the extent you consider brand a capability, you have to concede that point to the wirehouses. They have the best brands on the street, and clients ultimately may care about brand. I think this gets overstated a little bit, but brand would certainly be one. SMA and alternative platforms are two of the others that get commonly floated. So high net worth focused products that the wirehouses have just done the best job at from an access perspective and from a pricing perspective. And because of that, a lot of wirehouse advisors are pretty heavy users of these types of products. And so what happens is they find it difficult to move the book of business to a firm that’s less competent in that area. We’re seeing a lot of firms bridge that gap from a capability perspective. Banking and lending might be another one. I’m an advisor at Merrill. I have the kid in the candy store mentality. I have access to everything I need all within one house versus if I go independent, that’s a major mindset change to have to shop the street. All of that, plus these are some of the top deals on the street as far as W-2 deals go. It’s easy to see why there are some advisors who just say, “This is the route I’m going to go.” Louis Diamond: Absolutely. Yeah, man, I think you’re right. Especially on the SMA side, we see UBS has these free SMA strategies, so that’s really hard to reconcile or to account for in a transition. I think too, and I’ll see if you agree, that access to SMAs, access to alternatives, access to banking and lending, that’s available everywhere. Is it more so that the wires just do a better job of positioning it or selling it? Or it’s more so just like it’s what these advisors are used to. They’re used to the way it works that I pick up the phone, I call my Bank of America banker, I need an alternative, I click here versus more of an unbundled approach in other segments of the industry. You think that’s part of it too, is it’s not that they access necessarily better at the wires, but it’s easier to digest and it’s just more familiar the way that it all comes together? Jason Diamond: I think it’s 90% what you’re describing. 90%, it’s just a matter of apples here and oranges here, and if you translate the language, you end up in the same spot. That 10% is a legitimate capability gap. It might be a pricing gap. Oh, they actually can access that manager, but Morgan Stanley has $80 trillion in assets with them, so they’re going to get leaner pricing than this independent firm. That 10% is purely a test of an advisor’s mindset. Do you have that growth mindset of, is that a deal breaker for you? Can you find a way, either that means having to have a conversation with clients about switching products, about eating the cost for a period of time, or some advisors will let things like that be a deal breaker? And in our opinion, that’s fine as long as you’re not letting the tail wag the dog, meaning don’t be held hostage because you’re using a lot of QGar at UBS. Louis Diamond: Well said. Do you think this report draws out the fact that wirehouses are in fact becoming more selective about the type of advisor that they actually want to target? If you just follow the pay grid changes, the comp plan changes that all these firms make on an annual basis or semi-annual basis, it seems like they keep pushing up the grid thresholds where there’s certain incentives for larger teams or for teaming. Do you think that some of the wirehouses not recruiting as many of advisors on a net basis is because they’re in fact actually becoming more selective? They’re saying no to someone with a hundred million, 50 million, et cetera, or is that just an oversimplification? Jason Diamond: I think that’s the narrative that they are perpetuating. What does saying no look like? I think it’s almost the equivalent of, we used to call this quiet quitting where they’re not telling these advisors, we don’t want you, but they’re making policies that say to these advisors, we don’t really want you. I think there’s definitely some of that. So meaning if you’re a small advisor, Morgan Stanley’s payout grid is among the worst on the street of their peer set. So you may be ruled out. That’s not Morgan Stanley saying to you, we don’t want you here. I think in a lot of cases, these firms know how competitive the recruiting environment is, and they will take advisors more often than not. So that’s why I’m always not so quick to be like, “Yeah, they’re super selective. They’re saying no to all these $1 and $2 million advisors because that’s just not the world we live in.” Louis Diamond: Yeah, I would tend to agree. Maybe there’s some truth to it. It explains some of it, but not all of it. Let’s talk a little bit about deals. I know it changes a lot of time, very much dependent upon size of the business, quality of the business, competitive dynamics, et cetera. But in general, if you’re a wirehouse advisor who’s considering another W2 model, what’s the typical range we’re seeing? Jason Diamond: So this may be where, to use your point, maybe where we see firms getting more selective is in deal structure where they’ll say, “Here’s our rack rate deal.” So in the case of wirehouse firms, I would put that number at 325 to 350%-ish, but, and it’s a big but, they have the ability, every single one of them in my mind has the ability to get north of 400% for the right team. Wells and UBS are north of 400% right out of the gates. The regional firms too, you think about RBC, Raymond James, even Stifel to a lesser extent, they’re right there when they want to be. But that’s the story to me is if I had to quote a deal, I’d probably quote something fairly conservative, like 325-ish percent, knowing that for the right teams that show well, have a lot of advisory or invested in growth, et cetera, we can do substantially better than that. But firms are absolutely being more selective in that regard, and part of that just capital’s gotten more expensive. Louis Diamond: Yep, exactly. I think too, headline numbers are great to share with your friend at the golf course and, “Oh, Jimmy got this.” But really what matters more is the structure. So what we’ve seen over the last couple of years is the upfront portion of the deal has increased, probably not the same rate as the overall deals have, but we’re definitely seeing for a larger practice, 175% at a minimum upfront. In some cases 200% or more is fairly commonplace, and different options as far as weighting of the backends, easier to hit certain bonuses, carving out assets, the fact that backends are based on AUM now for the most part instead of production, they’re all things that in a competitive market have gotten better for the advisor, even if the overall headline deals and the upfronts I think have gone up, but they’re not going up or changing to keep pace with all the competitive dynamics in the industry. Let’s talk briefly about if a wire team wants to go independent, do they get a deal? What does that look like? Jason Diamond: Maybe, probably they get something. It depends on the version of independence. So the way I think about this is there’s four different paths a wirehouse advisor might walk. One is they might just launch an RIA with one of the major custodians. We see Goldman in this space commonly for wirehouse teams. In that instance, not really. They might get some benefit or startup expense dollars, but they’re not really getting a transition deal. Another path though might be affiliating with an independent broker dealer. So this would be like an LPL, and those absolutely come with a recruiting deal, 100% in some cases of revenue, a hundred basis points on assets, maybe even just north of that. Another path might be these support players or platform firms. So this would be firms like Sanctuary who in many cases do indeed pay transition deals, and the pitch is fairly straightforward. It’s basically, we can help you to look and feel like an RIA, but we take off a lot of the heavy lift from your plate. So things like compliance and cobbling together your tech stack, you don’t have to do. And then the last flavor I would mention briefly, it’s arguably not even independence, but you spoke about it for a second. We’re seeing advisors sell their businesses directly to independent firms, acquirers, private equity firms, roll-ups, et cetera. Those advisors are not independent on the other side. Typically, they get purchased and become W2 employees of the buyer, but those deal structures are eye-popping. You’re talking about multiples. Oftentimes it’s not a revenue multiple, but if I had to quote a revenue multiple, I’d probably say five to 6X top line, maybe 5X top line, so big numbers. Louis Diamond: Yeah, that’s the part that I’m always so interested in because the math for selling your business out of a wire to typically a large PE-backed RIA, the math is so, so, so compelling. Get equity as part of it, which if you run it out over 10 years is potentially even more valuable than the cash. It’s capital gains, either all of it or most of it. Yeah, five and a half, six, sometimes more. I know this report in this episode is about the first half of 2026, but a recent example in September of this year was Eddie Ventrice and Mike Bober down in Boca ran a $20 million plus UBS private wealth team. They sold their practice to Cresset, who’s been on this episode. So that’s a live, really tangible example. We’ve been saying this for years, hasn’t quite picked up yet, but I do think that’s the undiscovered terrain of this recruiting dynamic. I think that has more potential leverage for deals to increase or stay the same than what Raymond James is paying relative to UBS or what Rockefeller is paying relative to Morgan Stanley. I think it’s this X factor of these very aggressive, very well capitalized buyers coming in and taking a dent out of wirehouse recruiting. So again, might be early. We started our breakaway bank with Dynasty to capture this trend, and I’d say it’s early in it, but we’re very bullish it’s going to happen. Let’s talk a little bit forward-looking. What do you think are the biggest forces that will shape advisor movement through the rest of 2026 and even into 2027? Jason Diamond: Compensation plan changes always pop up in this bucket right around this time of year because they do seem to always spur just a little bit of movement, good, bad or indifferent. It’s oftentimes just I think an excuse for advisors to reevaluate. I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention retire in place deals. This is not a new dynamic, nothing to do with the end of the year, but to me, the single biggest determinant of when we run this report next year, what are these numbers going to look like? I would turn that question on its head and say how widespread does adaption of retire in place deals become? Or how much more widespread, I guess I should say. I think it’s a huge determinant about whether advisors can and will move because it represents the most compelling alternative. Compelling, I might put in quotes. You mentioned this private equity valuation story. I’m keeping my eye on that because we have now seen a couple of teams. We were not wrong, we were early, shall we say, to this prediction here, but we’ve now seen a couple of teams where I think you could start to see this come true a little bit more. So meaning the Mariners and Mercers and Beacon Pointe of the world start to acquire more directly from wirehouses. And then lastly, I would certainly mention AI. I don’t think any one firm has figured this out necessarily, but this has become question one on advisors’ due diligence checklist is how are firms addressing this? What are firms doing about this? And we are seeing a number of firms really lean into this from a recruiting perspective. Savvy Wealth, Altruist, I think even Morgan Stanley and LPL to a lesser extent. So those are some of the things I’m watching. Louis Diamond: Yeah, I think those are very accurate. Yeah, this on the AI point, I don’t think right now there’s a clear consensus on whether one type of firm is the right play for someone who’s trying to insulate themselves from the risk of AI or stay ahead of the trends. I see plenty of advisors who say, “I’m trusting that my captive firm, be it Morgan Stanley, Ed Jones, LPL, whoever it is spending billions of dollars on technology, I’m trusting them that they’re boiling the ocean, integrating this stuff, developing their own platforms, and that I’m going to trust them as my partner.” On the flip side, you have advisors that say, “This pace of AI is changing so quickly,” as a future-proof in September, and there’s hundreds of AI FinTech booths that are just all these companies are popping up. So there’s plenty of advisors who say, “I want to be as independent as possible or have the ability to pick and choose AI vendors as they come to market so I can stay ahead of the trend.” So I don’t know. I feel like there isn’t a right or wrong answer, but AI is absolutely becoming and has become a push factor, pushing people to consider change and a pull factor, meaning it’s how advisors are oftentimes evaluating their top destination, especially with younger advisors or folks with a longer runway. So let’s do one more question, and then we’ll wrap here. So we’ve shared a lot of numbers, a lot of information, and thank you for that. And we will link this report in the show notes. It will be on our website. So definitely give it a read, run it through your AI system to unpack it. There’s a lot of information in there. But what should an advisor listening really take from this episode if they take a step back from it? Jason Diamond: A couple things. I think first of all, I hope that the data does not come across in any way as a sales pitch because it’s not supposed to be. It’s not supposed to suggest that advisors need to move in order to achieve their best business life. It’s supposed to show advisors where the puck is heading at an industry level, at a firm level. And I hope that’s how people use it is just to be empowered with that data. And also we try to sprinkle in our commentary. I think we speak to as many or more advisors than anybody and just try to conclude the things that come up the most as pain points, so meaning why are advisors leaving? But then also on the flip side, when advisors are evaluating or joining a firm, what are the things they’re looking to achieve, and what are they really looking for? That’s what I hope advisors will take from the report. And then I’d be remiss if didn’t mention, always seems to be the most popular section is the representative deals where we highlight a couple of the major moves from the year. So I won’t run through them here, you’ll have to read the report, but one that I did find interesting that I’ll talk about for two seconds was Twin Harbor Private Wealth going from Merrill to Wells Fargo FiNet. These are the types of deals we highlight, and we just provide some rationale as to why a team might leave a big wirehouse like Merrill to join the independent channel of Wells Fargo, reasons like continuing to operate under a big brand. You mentioned a big recruiting deal, I’m sure was certainly a part of it and more. So the representative deals I think have become a really good lens into advisor mindset via real firsthand stories. Louis Diamond: There’s a lot of cool takeaways from this, but I think one of my biggest ones to sum it up is every firm is recruiting, gunning for similar types of advisors. Every firm is clearly losing advisors, some more than others, but the common through line is successful teams, advisors in general have more credible destinations for their business than ever before. So there’s going to be pluses, there’s going to be minuses. Who’s going to win in the end? It’s the advisor. And that’s what makes our job great is advisors I think are always in the influence control position. Those who control the gross control the game I’ve heard people say. And I think this report and over 200 different firms won a wirehouse team in the first half of the year, and just seeing the quality of teams in transition should be really good news for any advisor listening to this episode. So thank you for being our resident data expert and data scientist and for giving some really good takeaways on this data and making it interesting and not boring. And we’ll invite everyone to download the report. Again, it’ll be in the show notes. It’s on our website or reach out to Jason or I, and we’re happy to send it to you personally. So, Jason, thanks for doing this today. Jason Diamond: Thank you. This was great, Louis. Really appreciate it. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibility seriously and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? Is a book written with you in mind? It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook .

October 1, 2026Episode 37953 min

The Modern Family Office: Cresset’s CEO & Head of AI on Building for the Future

With Susie Cranston, CEO, Cresset | Kelly Wagman, PhD, Director, Head of AI Strategy, Cresset Cresset CEO Susie Cranston and Head of AI Strategy Kelly Wagman explore the modern family office, AI as a scale enabler, human-led advice, equity, culture, and what Cresset is building next. In Summary What does the modern multi-family office really look like—and how might AI change what it can deliver? Cresset has grown from an idea less than a decade ago into a national wealth management and family office firm with more than $250B in assets under management and advisement and more than 700 professionals. Yet its next chapter isn’t simply about getting bigger. It’s about finding new ways to extend highly customized advice and family office capabilities while preserving the human relationships at the center of the model. CEO Susie Cranston and Kelly Wagman, PhD, Director and Head of AI Strategy, share how Cresset is approaching that challenge. Susie draws on lessons from helping build First Republic’s wealth management business – including the importance of a client-first culture, empowered advisors, and balance-sheet strength – while Kelly explains how Cresset is using AI, integrated data, and firm-specific tools to give advisors greater leverage. The result is a look at a modern family office where technology may expand what advisors can deliver rather than diminish their role—and where culture, ownership, talent, and human advice remain fundamental to the firm’s vision for growth. The Storyline The family office has traditionally been a difficult model to scale. Its value comes from knowing a family deeply and coordinating an increasingly complex set of needs that can stretch from investments and estate planning to family governance, tax strategy, bill pay, household management, and even security. Cresset has invested heavily in that infrastructure from its earliest days. Today, approximately 150 professionals are dedicated to family office services, supporting a broader organization with more than $250B in assets under management and advisement. For Susie, the model also reflects lessons learned during more than a decade at First Republic. She describes how a deeply client-centric culture and empowered client-facing professionals helped create extraordinary loyalty and growth. But the bank’s collapse also left her with an appreciation for the importance of a “fortress balance sheet” and a clearer understanding of the tradeoffs that can come when banking and wealth management coexist within the same organization. Topics Covered What defines a true multi-family office—and why dedicated infrastructure matters How Cresset grew to more than $250B in assets under management and advisement Lessons Susie carried from First Republic to Cresset Why client-first cultures depend on empowering client-facing professionals The importance of balance-sheet strength and business-model structure How Cresset approaches family office wealth strategy and wealth administration Why AI may make sophisticated family office capabilities more scalable How integrated data can improve speed, personalization, and advisor productivity Cresset’s approach to building AI tools versus working with outside vendors Why security, compliance, and data ownership matter in an AI strategy How Cresset thinks about culture, equity, and advisor alignment Equity versus cash when advisors evaluate potential partnerships Independence versus joining a scaled wealth management platform Why AI may increase rather than reduce the value of human advice Cresset’s vision for talent, leadership, and the next decade of the firm > Download a transcript of this episode… Listen and Learn Highlights for Advisors Cresset Today: $250B+, 700+ Professionals and a National Footprint (06:28) Susie describes Cresset today, including its wealth management, institutional consulting, and family office capabilities—and an ownership structure in which employees and clients own approximately 80% of the firm. Lessons From First Republic’s Client-First Culture (08:30) Susie explains why doing what is right for the client—even when it carries a short-term economic cost—can create long-term loyalty, referrals, and a stronger business. She also shares why empowering client-facing professionals was critical to First Republic’s culture. The Hard Lesson: A “Fortress Balance Sheet” (12:19) The collapse of First Republic changed how Susie thinks about financial strength, risk, and the tradeoffs involved when banking and wealth management are combined. Why Cresset—and Why the Independent RIA Model? (14:57) Susie explains what attracted her to Cresset: a client-centric culture, strong balance sheet, and an independent structure capable of serving the increasingly complex needs of ultra-high net worth families. What Does a Real Family Office Look Like? (20:31) With approximately 100 advisors and 150 professionals dedicated to family office services, Susie explains the infrastructure Cresset has built to extend well beyond traditional investment management. AI as a Family Office Scale Enabler (23:53) Susie explains how AI could help extend services such as bill pay and tax support to a broader range of clients and family members—using technology to scale expertise that historically has been difficult and expensive to deliver. The AI Opportunity Starts With Integrated Data (25:22) Kelly explains why Cresset views data as foundational to its AI strategy and how it could support faster answers, more personalization, and more advisor time devoted to clients. Beyond Investments: What Family Office Clients Actually Need (28:15) From estate and tax planning to family governance, household payroll, travel logistics, and security, Susie offers a practical look at the complexity behind comprehensive family office service. Culture, Alignment and the Case for Cresset (33:17) Susie explains why Cresset puts culture first when considering advisor teams or institutional partners—and why ownership and alignment are important parts of the firm’s proposition. Equity as a Currency for Advisor Wealth Creation (36:24) Susie discusses the potential advantages of equity, why Cresset does not require advisors to take it, and why the right answer depends on an advisor’s circumstances and objectives. Joining a Firm vs. Building Your Own (39:14) Susie offers a balanced perspective on independence, including the economics, infrastructure requirements, and a more personal question: How much does an advisor actually want to be their own boss? Cresset’s AI “Sweet Spot” (42:06) Kelly describes Cresset as large enough to invest meaningfully in AI but small enough to remain nimble, allowing it to build firm-specific tools and capabilities around its own data and workflows. Key Takeaways A real family office requires real infrastructure. The term “family office” has become increasingly common across wealth management, but Cresset defines it through dedicated capabilities and people. Its offering extends beyond investments into tax and estate planning, family governance and education, bill pay, household administration, payroll, logistics, and other complex family needs. AI could change the economics of high-touch family office service. Many family office capabilities are expensive and difficult to scale because they rely on specialized professionals. Cresset sees AI as a way to leverage that expertise more broadly, potentially bringing sophisticated services to more members of a family and a wider range of clients. The AI strategy is ultimately a data strategy. Kelly explains that Cresset’s approach goes beyond adopting general-purpose AI tools. Integrated firm data, custom capabilities, build-versus-buy decisions, compliance, security, and thoughtful implementation are central to creating meaningful value for advisors and clients. Human advice may become more valuable—not less. AI can accelerate information retrieval, automate routine work, and increase personalization. But Kelly argues that trust becomes even more important when technology can generate many different answers. The combination of a trusted person working with AI may prove more powerful than either alone. Culture and ownership remain central to Cresset’s growth model. Susie sees culture as a prerequisite for any advisor or firm joining Cresset. Equity can then create another form of alignment by allowing advisors to participate in the enterprise value they help create. Scale should create capability, not simply size. Cresset’s thesis is that its position between very large institutions and smaller independent firms can offer an advantage: sufficient resources to invest in talent, technology, data, and family office infrastructure while remaining nimble enough to put those capabilities to work. https://youtu.be/W9Q5gZ425fs Quotable Moments Susie: “If you always do the right thing for the client, and you’re always delivering the very best you can for the end client, good things happen.” “AI is going to be a tool that really enables that scale.” “Clients are saying they want more human advice, not less, in the world of AI.” “We always say we do culture first no matter what.” Kelly: “Cresset really is at that sweet spot of being big enough to be able to invest in the space, but small enough that we can still be nimble.” “People are better when they’re working with a person who is then working with AI.” FAQs What is a multi-family office? A multi-family office provides coordinated wealth management and other specialized services to multiple ultra-high net worth families. Susie explains that Cresset’s capabilities include investment management as well as estate and tax planning, family governance and education, bill pay, household administration, payroll, travel and logistics, and other services required by complex families. How is Cresset using AI in its family office model? Susie and Kelly describe AI as a way to scale the knowledge and capabilities of Cresset’s family office professionals, automate certain workflows, improve access to information, increase personalization, and give advisors more time to interact with clients. The firm is also developing Cresset-specific AI tools and capabilities around its data and internal knowledge. Can AI make family office services available to more clients? That is one of the opportunities Susie sees. Services that traditionally require significant amounts of specialized human labor may become more scalable through AI and automation, potentially allowing Cresset to extend certain family office capabilities to clients or family members at different wealth levels. Does Cresset believe AI will replace financial advisors? No. Kelly says she is not concerned about AI eliminating the advisor’s role, particularly in the ultra-high net worth market. Instead, she expects AI to raise expectations for speed and personalization while increasing the value of a trusted human advisor who knows how to use the technology effectively. What did Susie learn from First Republic? Susie points to First Republic’s client-first culture and the empowerment of client-facing professionals as important drivers of its success. Its collapse also reinforced for her the importance of maintaining a strong balance sheet and understanding the risks and tradeoffs created when different financial businesses are combined. Why does Cresset emphasize equity for advisors? Susie views equity as a way for advisors to participate in the enterprise value they help create. Cresset does not require teams to take equity, but she argues that ownership can provide alignment, distributions, potential appreciation, and participation in future liquidity events. What should advisors consider when comparing independence with joining a firm like Cresset? Susie suggests advisors examine both the economics and what they actually want from their careers. Building an independent RIA can provide control and ownership, but it also requires responsibility for compliance, custodians, infrastructure, operations, and other functions. For advisors who primarily want to serve clients and grow, joining a larger platform may offer a different tradeoff. What is Cresset building for its next chapter? Susie describes a continued focus on comprehensive wealth management and family office capabilities, investment in experienced talent, and AI-enabled tools that can improve service and scalability. Despite advances in technology, she expects people and human-led advice to remain central to the firm’s strategy. A multi-family office provides coordinated wealth management and other specialized services to multiple ultra-high net worth families. Susie explains that Cresset’s capabilities include investment management as well as estate and tax planning, family governance and education, bill pay, household administration, payroll, travel and logistics, and other services required by complex families. Susie and Kelly describe AI as a way to scale the knowledge and capabilities of Cresset’s family office professionals, automate certain workflows, improve access to information, increase personalization, and give advisors more time to interact with clients. The firm is also developing Cresset-specific AI tools and capabilities around its data and internal knowledge. That is one of the opportunities Susie sees. Services that traditionally require significant amounts of specialized human labor may become more scalable through AI and automation, potentially allowing Cresset to extend certain family office capabilities to clients or family members at different wealth levels. No. Kelly says she is not concerned about AI eliminating the advisor’s role, particularly in the ultra-high net worth market. Instead, she expects AI to raise expectations for speed and personalization while increasing the value of a trusted human advisor who knows how to use the technology effectively. Susie points to First Republic’s client-first culture and the empowerment of client-facing professionals as important drivers of its success. Its collapse also reinforced for her the importance of maintaining a strong balance sheet and understanding the risks and tradeoffs created when different financial businesses are combined. Susie views equity as a way for advisors to participate in the enterprise value they help create. Cresset does not require teams to take equity, but she argues that ownership can provide alignment, distributions, potential appreciation, and participation in future liquidity events. Susie suggests advisors examine both the economics and what they actually want from their careers. Building an independent RIA can provide control and ownership, but it also requires responsibility for compliance, custodians, infrastructure, operations, and other functions. For advisors who primarily want to serve clients and grow, joining a larger platform may offer a different tradeoff. Susie describes a continued focus on comprehensive wealth management and family office capabilities, investment in experienced talent, and AI-enabled tools that can improve service and scalability. Despite advances in technology, she expects people and human-led advice to remain central to the firm’s strategy. Related Resources Listen: Disrupting the Landscape: How a $12B+ Multi-Family Office is Making Waves Amongst Advisors and Their Clients (With Avy Stein, Founder and Co-Chairman of Cresset) Listen: The Evolution of an Elite Advisor: From Breakaway to M&A to Increasing Annual Revenue by $10mm in Just 3 Years (With Justin Berman—Co-Chairman at Cresset and Founder of Berman Capital Advisors) Listen: Next Gen Success: A Masterclass in Building Trust and Credibility in a $7B Multi-Family Office (With Wen Nottebohm—Managing Director, Wealth Advisor at Cresset) Listen: Private Bankers Find Greater Independence: Former $2B J.P. Morgan Team on Their New Chapter with Cresset (with Kevin McGuire and Sarah Burney, Managing Directors and Wealth Advisors at Cresset) Susie Cranston CEO Susie Cranston serves as CEO of Cresset, an award-winning multi-family office and private investment firm. In this role, she leads the development and execution of the firm’s strategic objectives and drives scalable growth. In close partnership with founders Eric Becker and Avy Stein, and alongside Cresset’s executive leadership team, she oversees day-to-day business functions and enterprise-wide initiatives. Her leadership is guided by Cresset’s core commitment to delivering exceptional service and keeping clients at the center of every strategic and operational decision. Susie most recently served as the Chief Operating Officer at First Republic Bank, where she was responsible for the sales, client service, operations, strategic planning, and administrative management of the First Republic Investment Management business. After the firm’s acquisition by JP Morgan Chase, Susie served as the COO and Head of Integration. Susie originally joined First Republic in 2013 as EVP of Private Wealth Management, moving on to build one of the most successful wealth management businesses in the industry. She started her career at McKinsey & Company, where she spent 12 years consulting in various roles of increasing seniority and focused on strategy, risk management, and transformational change for financial services companies. Active in the San Francisco business community, Susie is a “Forever Influential” honoree and three-time recipient of the San Francisco Business Times “Most Influential Women in Business” designation and a member of C200. Susie is also a board member of the Commonwealth Club. She has authored several published articles and a book on women and leadership, How Remarkable Women Lead . Susie earned a Bachelor of Science degree in engineering and an MBA in business from Stanford University. Kelly Wagman Director, Head of AI Strategy Kelly Wagman serves as Director, Head of AI Strategy at Cresset, where she leads initiatives to help advisors and teams harness artificial intelligence to enhance client service and drive business outcomes. She brings deep expertise at the intersection of human-centered design, advanced AI systems, and enterprise technology. Prior to joining Cresset, Kelly earned a doctorate in computer science from the University of Chicago, specializing in human-centered AI. She has also worked in venture capital, focusing on AI startups, and at Microsoft, where she developed enterprise software products. In addition to her PhD, she holds a master’s degree from MIT and a bachelor’s degree from Brown University. Kelly is a frequent speaker and writer on the future of AI in the workplace. Outside of work, she enjoys hiking and skiing, travel and exploring Chicago’s food and arts scene. Disclaimer: Cresset and its representatives may, from time to time, appear on third-party media outlets, including television programs, podcasts, or online publications. Such appearances are for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as an endorsement or recommendation by the media outlet of Cresset or its services. Cresset did not provide any compensation to, and did not receive any compensation from, the media outlet in connection with these appearances. References to Cresset by third-party media are independent of Cresset and are based solely on publicly available information or the outlet’s own editorial discretion. NOTE: The views and opinions expressed by the guests on this podcast are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Diamond Consultants. Neither Diamond Consultants nor the guests on this podcast are compensated in any way for their participation. View the transcript of this episode… The Modern Family Office: Cresset’s CEO & Head of AI on Building for the Future A conversation with Louis Diamond and Susie Cranston, CEO of Cresset, and Kelly Wagman, PhD, Director and Head of AI Strategy at Cresset. Louis Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is The Modern Family Office: Cresset’s CEO & Head of AI on Building for the Future. It’s a conversation with CEO Susie Cranston and director, head of AI strategy, Kelly Wagman. I’m Louis Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. To download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Louis Diamond: For a long time, the family office model has been defined by something that’s inherently difficult to scale. Highly customized advice, deep knowledge of a family, an entire ecosystem of services that can extend well beyond investments into tax and estate planning, family governance, bill pay, household management, security, and just about anything else a complex family might need. But AI has the potential to change that equation, not by replacing the people delivering that advice, but by helping firms bring more expertise, information, and personalization to more clients and potentially expand the kind of family office experience that historically has only been available to the wealthiest families. That’s one of the ideas behind what Cresset is building today. My guests are Susie Cranston, CEO of Cresset and Kelly Wagman, a PhD, the firm’s director, and head of AI strategy. Cresset was founded by Eric Becker and Avy Stein in 2017. And here’s a quick tip. If you do a search for Cresset in our podcast archives, you’ll find an early episode with Avy along with several from top advisors who call the firm home. Today, the firm has grown to more than 250 billion in assets under management and advisement with more than 700 professionals in a significant infrastructure dedicated specifically to family office services. After serving in leadership positions at First Republic Bank and JP Morgan Chase, Susie joined Cresset in 2024 as president and was recently appointed CEO in March of this year. Susie offers a perspective on what she learned from her experience at client-centric First Republic, and how that’s helped her build on the already strong foundation at Cresset. And now she’s taking on the next big thing, how AI can serve as a force multiplier for their model, a charge led by Kelly. We talk about what a true multifamily office looks like today, where AI can create real leverage for advisors and clients, and why both Susie and Kelly believe the future of wealth management will require more human advice, not less, and how AI can help facilitate that. We also get into Cresset’s culture, its use of equity as a currency for growth and alignment, and Susie’s vision for the firm’s next decade. Because the interesting question isn’t whether AI changes the family office, it’s what the family office can become because of it. Let’s get to it. Susie and Kelly, thank you for joining us today. Susie Cranston: It is our pleasure. We are thrilled to be here. Thank you for having us. Louis Diamond: Awesome. Susie, I’ll direct the first question to you. Can you tell us about your professional journey? I know it was a little bit different than most and how you found your way to First Republic, which I believe was your first job within our amazing industry. Susie Cranston: So, the first decade of my career I was at McKinsey. While I didn’t work for a wealth management firm, I did consult in the financial services space. So I spent a little over a decade after studying engineering and as an undergraduate in the wealth space as a consultant, and really decided after I’d been in McKinsey for about 10 years that it would be great to work in a company, but I believe deeply that you’re going to work for a company, it’s got to be a client first company. It’s got to be a company that has a great culture. And so as I was looking around within San Francisco where I’m from, First Republic seemed like a great stop. And so I spent a little over a decade there building primarily our wealth management business, which was about 25 billion in AUM when I joined and about 250 billion when we became part of JP Morgan 10 years later. Louis Diamond: Amazing. And we’ll get into aspects of the time at First Republic. Everyone’s interested to hear more. Kelly, similar question for you. So I know we’ll spend some real time digging into AI and what Cresset’s up to on the AI front a little bit later, but can you give our audience a little bit of perspective on your background and what your role is at Cresset? Kelly Wagman: Sure. I’m the head of AI strategy here at Cresset. I’ve been here for about a year. Previously I did a PhD in computer science focused on AI, and I also worked at Microsoft for a number of years doing enterprise software development. So I am relatively new to the wealth management industry, but very excited about the intersection of technology and business. Louis Diamond: Amazing. Very succinct answer. And if you ever get stumped on the industry, AI can help you understand it better. So Susie, for you. So for listeners who maybe aren’t as familiar with Cresset, and we can’t assume they caught earlier episodes we did with some of your partners like Avy Stein and Justin Berman and Wen, how would you describe the firm today? Who’s it for and what makes Cresset different? Susie Cranston: Thank you. Well, so today Cresset has a little over 250 billion in assets and management and advisement. We are a nationwide firm, so we have over 25 locations nationwide and over 700 professionals delivering services that range from wealth management to institutional consulting, to family office services. And it’s been an incredible journey. Cresset isn’t even 10 years old yet, but it has been a really rewarding one. We are, I should also mention, 80% owned by employees and clients. So- Kelly Wagman: Yes. Louis Diamond: Wow. Susie Cranston: … it’s a very employee client-centric story that we have always had at Cresset. Louis Diamond: Very cool. I remember probably, if Cresset’s been around for 10 years, maybe it was 11 years ago, sitting down with Avy Stein and Eric Becker, your two co-founders, and it was legitimately, it was an idea. There was a premise that there were no clients, there were no advisors, there were no employees, and it’s amazing to see what’s been accomplished in a decade. 700 professionals, professionals, the amount of AUM. And I think pretty much every advisor or person in the industry has at least heard of Cresset. So it’s an amazing testament to you now as the steward of the company, but also to those who came before you. Susie Cranston: Absolutely. I think Eric and Avy famously founded Cresset so that it was founded by clients for clients. They were both retired and that’s probably when they met with you to get your advice and perspective and really decided when they couldn’t find what they wanted in the marketplace to build it themselves. And the fact that so many clients have followed and joined, I think is just a testament to the vision that they had and what we’re trying to build here today. Louis Diamond: Amazing. Maybe I’m biased from the seat doing this podcast, but I think all the best firms that have started in the last 10, 15 years, they started around a similar premise. It was either a manager, an industry executive, even an industry outsider, or in Cresset’s case, clients of financial services firms looking around saying, “Hey, if this doesn’t exist, why don’t we create it?” And that’s their big “aha” moment is trying to think through what are the pain points that I’m uniquely capable of solving for? So it’s a really cool journey. Susie, I know we’re talking about Cresset today, but I asked you about getting into First Republic, but I mean First Republic, everyone knows the end result. But I mean to me, while First Republic was in its heyday and really until the collapse, it had an amazing client-first culture. Advisors were super happy there. I’m sure employees are really happy. I mean, to me, that’s not something that happens by accident. So is there something you could point to about what made First Republic special? I’m sure it was more than just something in the water. Susie Cranston: Well, it’s interesting. It’s a great question. And I think there’s really two pieces of what made First Republic so successful, and there’s probably more to the story, but from my perspective in any event, the first is around having a very client-centric culture. And I think what everybody intuitively knows is that if you always do the right thing for the client, and you’re always delivering the very best you can for the end client, good things happen. However, sometimes that means you do things that are short-term unprofitable or short-term against the best interest of the firm in order to deliver the right thing for the client. And I think one of the things that First Republic always got right was the idea that benefiting the client even at the short-term cost of the firm is always the right decision. And so we always could tell clients with a very straight face and a very strong conviction, that we were doing our best for them. And I think that makes a huge difference in terms of the caliber of the client experience, but also in terms of who wants to work at your firm. And that gets me to the second part that I think First Republic did right, which is we had a very empowered client-facing set of professionals. So, if you really want to be a client-centric firm, the idea that any one manager, the idea that any management team is going to sit in an ivory tower and figure out what needs to happen and be successful, I think is a fallacy. I think the best way to be a client-centric firm is that the people who are interacting with the clients are empowered and are informing the decision-making and the strategy setting that you’re doing as a firm. And so at First Republic, the people that worked with clients always were advising us on what we should do. They were always empowered to do the right thing. And so I think those two ingredients I have seen when those exist in a firm, that’s where you get that magic outcome because what happens over time, and we proved this out at First Republic, when you have great clients that are really loyal and have a fantastic experience, they refer friends and family that are better or equivalent clients, and you get this really wonderful flywheel to go. Louis Diamond: Amazing. Yeah, I mean I saw it firsthand. I would agree with you that legitimately every advisor we have replaced at First Republic, that was one of the first things they said was like, “It’s fun to work here. They listen, we have a voice.” And I know people who are clients of First Republic and the bank, it was always raved reviews about service and about just the level of care that they received. I mean, it’s almost like, I know Raymond James and has been a competitor to yours, but I feel like that’s the way that’s been part of Raymond James’ success has been looking at the advisor as the client, empowering advisors, et cetera. And it sounds easy to replicate, right? We want to be client first, we want to empower advisors, but it’s much harder in practice from a compliance standpoint or from a responding to shareholder standpoint. So, I think it’s amazing and I’m sure that a lot of that is what you’ve carried into your role at Cresset. How about, let’s say, a hard lesson learned? Obviously you weren’t in charge of the balance sheet of First Republic or anything else that happened, but is there a lesson that you carry from the collapse of First Republic or is there anything that it makes you watch out for now that you wouldn’t have known before? Susie Cranston: This will probably make some people laugh, but I have newfound religion around the idea of a fortress balance sheet. Right? So as you said, on the wealth management side, we didn’t control the asset side of the balance sheet as much, but there can be no doubt that when Jamie Diamond talks about JP Morgan’s fortress balance sheet, he knows what he is talking about. So one of the things that I have been myopically focused on at Cresset is making sure we have an incredibly strong Fortress balance sheet because when you’re operating from a position of strength and the balance sheet, you can weather all sorts of storms and you can take advantage of opportunities in the marketplace. But the thing that I also took away from it and has been part of what led me to Cresset was this realization that when you combine banking and wealth management, you’re opening yourself up to risk and challenge in ways that sometimes don’t seem that big of a deal, but then sometimes can be a really big deal. So, it was interesting. I did spend time, I went from First Republic to JP Morgan, and operating in the JP Morgan environment, it’s an incredibly well-run organization and it is highly regulated as all too-big-to-fail banks are. And that has to be when you are a too big to fail bank, a big priority because you don’t get to operate if you don’t follow the regulatory requirements. But having all of those bank regulatory requirements on top of what you can do in wealth management at an RIA does change the offering set that you can provide to clients. Right? So the biggest takeaway from me from this whole last chapter of my career was to really understand and be thoughtful about what you’re getting and what you’re losing when you’re combining different parts of businesses, because sometimes it doesn’t seem like a big deal until it does. Louis Diamond: Yeah, absolutely. It’s almost like it gives you the ability to be skeptical or play devil’s advocate in a way that you probably had known about before, but you didn’t really appreciate it. It’s like things were going so well, amazing reputation, doing things right by clients, crushing earnings, et cetera. But then the unexpected happens and no one ever expects the unexpected to happen, but the ones that are best prepared can weather the storm. So, it makes a lot of sense. So Susie, after First Republic and then a stint at JP Morgan during the integration phase, I’m sure you had quite a number of options. So, why Cresset? What was your why story behind joining Cresset as a professional executive, obviously not as a founder, but what was it that you saw in Cresset that led you to it over any other opportunity or staying with JP Morgan? Susie Cranston: Well, I will say going back to your first question about what made First Republic special, I think having a client-centric firm where you do the right thing for clients, even if it’s against the economic interests of the firm, I think that’s the winning recipe in the professional services space. And I say that from my McKinsey tenure, from my First Republic, JP Morgan tenure, that recipe always works if you’re really running a good business, because even if you take a short-term hit from not doing something in the short-term that you could, the benefit you get from retention, from referrals, all of that does take care of that in the long run, and it’s a better long-term business. I also knew that a big reason why First Republic had been successful was because of its culture. As you alluded to very kindly, it was an incredible place where frontline professionals had a seat at the table. They drove the strategy, they were interacting with us every day to give us their input. And so I felt like I knew that was an incredibly successful model in the wealth management space. And I also learned, as I spent more time at JP Morgan, that if you were going to try to deliver a really client-centric experience in a too-big-to-fail bank, which to be clear, that was the only type of banking I was ever going to do after my First Republic experience. It was either going to be too big to fail or I wasn’t going to do banking. And as I got to know what it would mean to run a business like this in a too-big-to-fail regulatory infrastructure, I started to realize that for the ultra high net worth family office space, there was going to be an opportunity for independent RIAs to really take, not even take market share from the big institutional players, but to take all the new market share that was emerging, right? Because we are in a period of incredible wealth creation in this country right now. I mean, there are over a hundred thousand families in the US alone that have more than a hundred million dollars net worth. Even if you did an inflation adjusted look back 20, 50 years, the number of people that have this much wealth has never been seen before in the history of our country. And so, what really brought me to Cresset was this platform that was incredibly client-centric because it was founded by clients for clients. It had been built in a really robust manner and had the balance sheet strength that I was looking for, and had the ability to deliver these services that this incredible emerging wealth was going to need. Because what we’re really seeing right now in the market, which is so fascinating, is that as people have more and more wealth to manage and it’s more and more complicated, they need that integrated bill pay, tax advice, estate planning, and family governance and education. Right? All the things need to be provided by an integrated provider or someone’s going to just build their own family office. And so those kind of market needs and those realizations were what made Cresset a top choice. And I admit that as I was looking in the space, there weren’t a ton of places that checked all those boxes. And so, I had a very famous conversation with my mom where I said, “Mom, I’m not sure what I’m going to do if Cresset doesn’t end up hiring me,” but fortunately it did end up working out. Louis Diamond: And knowing Avy and Eric, I’m glad you didn’t tell them that. It would’ve hurt your leverage and the negotiations. Susie Cranston: Our right to negotiate. No, they were great. Louis Diamond: Awesome. Kelly, I want to shift some of the attention to you. I noted in your… And I think it’s a new title, it’s Head of AI Strategy Director. What does that actually mean? So are you actually developing your own custom AI tools for Cresset and its advisors, or is it more about, let’s come up with a strategy for how the firm is going to deploy and leverage AI into the future? What does the title mean to you? Kelly Wagman: It’s a good question, and I think I can actually speak to the evolution because I think the role has evolved. So I think of the first step of any strategy being that enablement piece. So I came in really focused on enablement, which meant to me, empowering people to use these new tools. And I think what we realized as we started doing that is that that’s great, but we also needed to be understanding what our use cases were, prioritizing them, starting to build out or look for vendors for particularly complicated things, thinking about our data strategy. And so, my role evolved into this more strategy focused role as we realized we needed to think a little bit bigger picture about AI at Cresset. Louis Diamond: Very cool. And at Cresset, and I always try to square this because I know every company’s different, but is it that the strategy is we’re using Claude and we’re using ChatGPT and whatever else, or are you actually building your own AI tools, or maybe it’s a combination of the two? Kelly Wagman: Yeah, we are definitely building things. We are not building foundation models. We’re not out to replicate ChatGPT or Claude. We are using those tools. But then there are more complicated use cases. You can think about particular operations workflows, or people talk about things like meeting prep or these things that we do want to provide a standardized version to people. So we’re building those. And then we’re also, we use some vendor partners in places where that makes sense as well. Louis Diamond: It makes sense to me. Susie, question for you. I’ve heard the term, “We’re a family office,” or, “We offer family office services” everywhere. It’s almost like water in this industry. Everyone on some website has said it or mentions it, or if you ask them what they do, they say, “We offer family office-like services,” or, “We are a family office or a multifamily office.” So, obviously I know with Cresset, it’s more than just a buzzword. I think last I read, there’s over 150 people just in the family office group alone out of over 700 professionals. So, what do you believe a real family office looks like? What are the services that are being provided, and how does what Cresset provides as a family office or multifamily office differ from a number of other firms that just really like their clients and maybe they work with some larger ones so they can throw the word around? Susie Cranston: So, what really differentiates Cresset is that we have been doing this and investing in this, and building this from day one. So, we have a deep infrastructure across all the elements of family office services that a client might need. And the way to differentiate it that I found when I was looking around at other options several years ago was just ask firms, “How many dedicated people do you have to family office services?” Right? Because a lot of places talk about it, but when you ask how many dedicated professionals, the answer is like, “Well, we got a few here, a few there.” And we have a hundred advisors and 150 people doing family office services. So, when you’re talking to clients about the depth of coverage that we can provide and you’re trying to demonstrate credibly that you can take care of the family’s full range of needs, we have a very competent, compelling, detailed story to tell. And the reason I think this is so important is that because there’s so much wealth being created, there is new populations of people who need support that never needed support in the past and there’s no existing infrastructure for them. At the same time, we’re seeing a decline in the supporting functions for family offices. So the number of people graduating from accounting to programs is down 50% over the last eight years. So you’re seeing the population of supporting professionals is dwindling, getting harder to find, and the demand for this shrinking supply is growing. Right? And so having capability that you can really meaningfully deliver to support families is really important because even the biggest family offices in the country, the biggest names everybody would know if I said them, those family offices don’t do everything in-house themselves because of privacy reasons, because of business continuity reasons. So, there is a really important relationship between being able to deliver family office services and being able to advise and support the wealth of those families. And that has been something that Eric and Avy understood from day one, and so we’ve always invested in that. And listen, it’s a tough choice to make, I think, when you’re starting a business because you have to build out the infrastructure before it’s fully profitable. So, we had to make a very hard choice. Eric and Avy made a hard choice to take that cost on before it was fully profitable, but that has then translated into incredible success. And to tie it into Kelly, who I just have to say we are so fortunate to have, she is a complete star and she’s very modest, but she’s just done amazing work at Cresset. And one of the things that we are also able to do with our knowledge of Family Office is when you have 150 practitioners at Family Office, you can start to say, how do we leverage AI to bring bill pay in an affordable way to clients that have a $20 million net worth? Or how do we do the taxes in an automated way leveraging AI for clients that have 20 million? And you can really start to scale those services. And that’s actually really important when you’re working with families because the matriarch or the patriarch of the family may have hundreds of millions, billions of dollars, but maybe some of the children haven’t inherited it yet. So you’ve got to support the full family where they are at, and AI is going to be a tool that really enables that scale. Louis Diamond: It’s such an interesting use case for AI. And maybe Kelly, you can elaborate. The fact that Cresset has these, I would assume very expensive, very knowledgeable professionals that are working with the top tier of clients, but being able to use AI to take their intellectual capital and what they’re doing at the high end and scaling it to kids or to smaller clients, can you weigh in on that use case and how it’s shaping out at Cresset right now? Kelly Wagman: Yeah, I think a lot of the promise of AI is actually being able to build things on top of integrated data. Once you do that, there’s a lot of unlock that you have. So we spent a lot of time working on how do we get our data into a place where we can start to build some of these things. But I think that also does unlock at the higher end where you can still have very customized bespoke white glove services, but people can get their questions answered more quickly, advisors can spend more time on those client interactions, you can have higher levels of personalization. So I think we spend a lot of time on getting this core platform so that we can then expand use cases in both directions. Louis Diamond: It’s so interesting. When you’re thinking on behalf of Cresset about do we build something ourselves or do we go buy some AI tool off the shelf, whether it’s like a Jump AI or a CogniCor, or some add-on from Addepar or the various tech vendors, how do you think about the trade-off between you and your team building it specifically for Cresset versus buying something off the shelf and maybe customizing elements of it? Kelly Wagman: I think there are two pieces of that. One, I think we need to continue to own our data. Again, I think the data part is very valuable, so I don’t want to have a product that’s going to somehow take that data and make it not accessible to us. And then two, a lot of it comes down to whether the thing is well offered and how customizable it is. I think in this era, people are building software in ways that is more customizable and faster to iterate on. And so if a vendor is building something that is the thing that we want and they’re willing to customize it to us, I think that’s great. If there’s something that just doesn’t exist yet or that we really need to build ourselves, we can also look at that. But in a regulated industry, I think we need very robust software. So, working with vendors, especially on some of these kind of critical areas, is important for that. Louis Diamond: Awesome. Susie Cranston: If I can just add one thing onto that, Louis, I think one of our theories of the case is that given how regulated our industry is, that the AI rollout has to be much more controlled and thoughtful in our industry than it would in something like software, because you can’t have an AI tool that’s overriding compliance features or that’s doing something accidentally that then puts the firm at risk. Right? So that’s part of what I think all of our competitors and we are really being mindful about. Louis Diamond: No doubt about it. Susie, back to the family office question. I think another kind of knock on the term family office is people think it’s like, “Oh, we walk our client’s dogs,” or, “We pick up our client’s dry cleaning.” Maybe that’s part of your answer, but when you look at the services that Cresset provides in its family office, what are the top couple that are the most valuable, or maybe even take another direction, the most out there that clients have requested that you’re now offering? Susie Cranston: So we think about our family office services in two categories of offerings. There’s the wealth strategy piece, and that’s things like the estate and tax planning, the family governance and education. It’s really all the kind of thoughtful planning pieces that you want to put in place to effectively manage your resources. And then we have wealth administration, which is a day-to-day management and oversight of all the trappings that go with your assets, bill pay, tax, all the kind of travel planning and logistics. Another big one is household payroll and household management. Oftentimes wealthy people start to accumulate quite a few different professionals that help them in different capacities, and managing that starts to become a lot of work. You have to manage all the tax pieces, you have to manage the payroll administration, you have to make sure you’re filing all the right documents and following all the right compliance rules in all the different states that you operate in or countries. And then multiply that times you got the yacht going all over and the pilots for the plane going all over. So the complexity of these families multiplies quite quickly. And so I would say the top service that everybody seems to want and we get the most requests for is probably some combination of tax and estate planning, which is part of wealth management in general, but then double clicking to the next level. But family governance and education is a huge focus for a lot of clients. How do they think about raising their children, their grandchildren in ways that don’t allow, that mitigate any potential issues coming from having so much wealth and letting them take advantage of the resources that the family has created? There’s a lot of complex family dynamics that emerge when you’re dealing with wealth. The number one way that wealth is created, as many of us know in this industry, is through owning and operating companies. Ownership of companies is the wealth creator that drives everything in the United States. So, when you think about all of a sudden you’ve got cousins, aunts, uncles, all sorts of different people trying to manage a company together, trying to manage a family business together, having processes and systems and support for how to do that effectively while maintaining the family relationships is really important. So that’s another big one that we get, as well as they’ll pay household administration. That’s just something that a lot of families want help with. But an out there example is security. Right? So we have helped clients exit Israel after the issues that happened there. We’ve helped clients get out of Ukraine when Russia initially invaded. So, there’s all sorts of things involved in being a family office. But if you can’t deliver those services, then the families have no choice but to build their own family office and then the whole benefit of what you’re trying to provide for them is moot. So you do have to be able to accommodate a range of needs. Louis Diamond: It’s crazy. Yeah. I mean honestly, I wish one day I had that much money where those services are made available to me or maybe through Kelly’s work, they will be soon. But it is quite the investment that Avy and Eric made. And I was going to ask a question, but I think you already answered it about what did Avy and Eric get right in the beginning that’s overlooked. I’ll ask it, but I would have to answer first and say really investing, building out a massive organization in very expensive areas before a dollar of client assets came. Would you agree or would you have a different answer? Susie Cranston: No, I’ve thought about this a lot. What is it in what Eric and Avy did that made it so differentiated? And I think you’re spot on, Louis. What Eric and Avy had going for them that I think is often overlooked is they were successful and retired when they started this. So they had all the experience and all the knowledge of decades of being successful, executives, entrepreneurs, founders, and they were okay already. They were set. They could have just stayed retired. And so when they created this business, they didn’t have the pressure of this being the make or break thing for their families. And it allowed them, I think, to really be expansive, do what they thought was right, prioritize the long game as Eric would say, in ways that I think are harder to do if your family’s really all riding on this one thing. Louis Diamond: Yep. On the other hand, it’s if you’re retired and successful, why are you trying to create stress in your life? Susie Cranston: That’s the DNA of Eric and Avy. They are very hardworking. Louis Diamond: Love it. Susie, another question for you and then I’ll turn it back to Kelly. So from First Republic, just you have to live under a rock in this industry to not respect the fact that there’s so many different firms, types of firms, business models that a successful advisor, a team, an independent RIA, could opt to partner with. You can go to sell to an aggregator, you can sell a minority stake in your business, you can launch your own RIA, you can affiliate with a supported independent platform, go to an IBD, go to a wirehouse, probably 50 different types of options. Forget about all the different firms underneath it. So when you’re recruiting or looking to win an M&A deal, what’s your honest case for why Cresset over any other option that someone might have available to them? Susie Cranston: Well, it’s probably twofold. I think on the one hand, Cresset has always been myopic about its culture. We always say we do culture first no matter what. That is the sort of golden rule of our organization. And so I think the first thing that I always say to institutions we’re thinking about partnering with or teams that are thinking of joining is listen to what we’re saying about how we operate our culture. And it is a very client first, take care of clients, take care of colleagues culture. And if that resonates with you, that is wonderful. And if it doesn’t, that’s okay too, but then we should part ways as friends because the culture piece is a really big part of what we’re doing. But the second thing that I think is really important is alignment. And one of the things that was interesting about being at First Republic is that wealth management business that we built drove so much wealth in that business, which was fantastic and people benefited for the time business existed. But if you are a partial owner driving that kind of wealth and opportunity, that allows you to benefit from your hard work in a different way. And I think it is really exciting to be in a place in the industry’s evolution where people that work at Cresset can have the opportunity to do great work for clients and be very culturally aligned and have that benefit their families in ways that we couldn’t do before. Because the way that Cresset is structured, when people join Cresset, the benefits are taxed at capital gains, not income. So there’s a huge delta in the benefit of what ends up staying with the family. But then secondly, what I think people don’t always understand is when you’re thinking about, for example, a deal to join a firm, the equity value can increase so rapidly. So we had a client, a team that joined us two years ago, and the equity value of their deal has already increased the multiple of their deal substantially. And we have distributions, we have periodic liquidity events. So, the wealth creation that can happen here I think is really unique for advisor teams. And I don’t think it’s always well understood, but it’s interesting because it’s a little bit of the cobbler’s kids have no shoes, right? We all as professionals work with families and we see how do families get this wealth. They usually get this wealth by owning enterprises and running businesses. So, here we are today in a place in time where the advisor had the opportunity to do that. And I think for a lot of advisors, that’s really exciting. Louis Diamond: How about I give you two-part question? I’m going to put you on trial here for a little bit. So I think equity is peaks and valleys. It’s either everyone wants it, everyone hates it, and there’s some sort of event or something, whether it was the financial crisis, or I hear XYZ firm just that diluted everyone and couldn’t sell, couldn’t raise capital, and cash is king. There isn’t a perfect answer for every advisor, but make the case for a deal with Cresset that is at least part equity versus a probably larger headline number check from a wirehouse or W2 firm. That’s the first part, and then I’ll get to the second one. Susie Cranston: First of all, I would say at Cresset, I mean, we don’t mandate that people take some percentage of equity. So I think if people really want to go with a cash deal, we would do a competitive deal. It would just be that you don’t have the equity upside and you don’t have the benefit of distribution over time. So, for people that feel really strongly, if they’re a cultural fit, I think we want to accommodate teams where they’re at and different people are at different stages in their lives. But the thing about equity is that it is tied to the underlying value of the business and the underlying value of a wealth business is incredibly stable for the most part. We all know there’ll be a down cycle and there might be a few years where we’re building back up, but in general, the arc of time, I mean the reason we all sit in these wonderful seats is that the market continues to grow and therefore the business continues to grow, if hold onto your clients. And if you’re doing a great job for clients, you’re actually growing their wealth and they’re getting their referrals at the same time. So as you think about whether you want equity or not, you have to ask yourself, “What’s the underlying risk of that equity?” And I think the benefits of equity in this space outweigh the potential risks if you look at it objectively. Now, as I said, I totally understand that at different points in life and different places in your evolution of what your family needs, different things may make more or less sense. But I believe that the people who have been the most successful in our industry over the arc of time, are the ones who’ve taken the initiative, bet on themselves, believed in themselves because the way that equity doesn’t manifest itself is if there isn’t a business. Right? And that can happen in software. People might say, “Oh, now I can vibe code my own version of Salesforce. I don’t need Salesforce anymore.” The risk in wealth management would be that somebody says, “I don’t want someone to manage my money.” And every indication, every survey we’ve seen is that clients are saying they want more human advice, not less in the world of AI. So I think it is certainly a choice that everybody gets to make themselves. And at Cresset, we’re happy to meet teams wherever they want to be met. But I also think if you’re not excited about what you’re building and you’re not excited about what the equity can do, then we might not be at the best place for our team because it is an incredible opportunity. And for those of us that have been doing this for a while, it’s been incredibly lucrative. Louis Diamond: Yep, I would agree. What about the case? What about someone who says, “I’m successful. I grow at 10, 15, 20% per year. It’s better for me to go independent or stay independent and own 100% of my own business. And then 10 years from now when the business has compounded and grown, I can sell it to Cresset. I can sell it to whoever.” What’s the fault in that logic or that same individual, same business? How potentially could a deal with a Cresset or one of your competitors that structures deals in a similar way? How could that be potentially a better outcome for that individual? Susie Cranston: Well, I think it is worth people always doing the numbers on those calculations, right, to see, can you go independent and have that be more lucrative with all the different machinations that are involved in that, than it would be to do a transaction now? And interestingly, both at Cresset and at First Republic, we often had those conversations very explicitly with teams that were thinking of joining. And I think the fact that we had so many teams join First Republic and now Cresset is testament to the fact that starting on your own can be great, but to maintain growth when you all of a sudden have to deal with compliance, custodians, all the back office, all the infrastructure, all the things that go into this space, it can be challenging to sustain that level of growth, take care of all your clients, and add all of that workload on. And then there’s a time value of money. So you’ve got to get offices, you’ve got to get infrastructure, you’ve got to get all these things going. And even with partners, then you’re giving a percentage of the business away. So the question just becomes, I think economically, is it better to try to do it on your own, or is it better to try to make a transaction now? And I think the real deciding factor in all of that really does become, how much do you want to just be your own boss? Because I think economically it’s probably pretty close in terms of you can get a competitive deal that would be similar to doing all of that work and going independent. And so as I’ve talked to teams, if you really want to go be your own boss, then by all means go start your own firm. I think that is an interesting and exciting adventure for many people. If what you love to do is to grow your business and be with clients and make things happen on the client front, which a lot of advisors are incredible at and get so much joy out of, then finding an opportunity where you can join a firm, have a seat at the table and be a leader in terms of the strategy, but not have to do all that incremental work, I think it can make a difference. Louis Diamond: Thank you for giving two very balanced answers and not just eating your own home cooking, but I completely agree that I think anyone can build a financial model or run projections that tilts one way or the other, the join a firm, equity appreciation, et cetera, versus just doing it on their own. So I think so much of it is, what are you most passionate about? What gets you out of bed? And ultimately, under which model do you think is going to have the most fun and you’re going to be the most successful at? And that’s why I love my job. There isn’t a cookie cutter answer. It changes across the board. Susie Cranston: That’s 100% right. Yeah. Louis Diamond: Question for you along the similar lines, but more so on the technology or AI front. In your opinion or in your view, what does an advisor or team access being part of Cresset on the AI front or on the technology front that they couldn’t access strictly as their own if they’re building their own RIA from scratch, or even let’s say at a major financial institution that has more to spend on technology but likely has legacy systems, and is a little bit slower to market than Cresset can be? Kelly Wagman: Yeah, I think to that point, Cresset really is at that sweet spot of being big enough to be able to invest in the space, but small enough that we can still be nimble and offer people some of the best and newest tools. We are building out the wrapper around it to provide a lot of Cresset-specific skills and access to data. So not only do you get access to the LLM, you also get to say, build in skills that help with looking at your email or that help with meetings or that we have a whole suite of tools where people can look up knowledge bases from different teams. So, whether that’s HR, things about banking and lending or these different areas. And so I think that it really empowers the advisors to get started with something that feels a little bit like a Cresset specific assistant that we’re continuing to work on. Susie Cranston: I would also add to that things like talking about family governance and education. So we are thought leaders in all of these spaces. And so, to have access to tools that can help you quickly have answers to some of the common questions that clients have and the assurance that it’s a best practice answer, that’s research that’s used across multiple families, is really valuable. The other thing I would just say having spent time in larger organizations is that as Kelly mentioned earlier, the data is really the critical part to letting AI help advisors be more efficient. And because we are in this kind of sweet spot size, we’re not so big that we can’t have the integrated view of what’s working in clients and have it be across all the different facets that we serve clients for. So we have that integrated view, but we are still at a size where we can actually translate that into things that teams can do. “Hey, this is what was interesting to four other clients of a similar profile, similar size, you should talk to this client about it.” Those kinds of insights I think can get hard in a very large organization where the data is too distributed, and it’s candidly pretty expensive for a very small firm to invest in or they don’t have big enough data set. Kelly Wagman: And on the compliance side, I mean, Susie mentioned this earlier, but I think developing security and compliance around AI is a totally new area because AI is so new, and I think that’s a space where having the support of a firm is really helpful. Louis Diamond: For you, someone who is much more knowledgeable about AI, where it’s going, what it’s capable of, and probably really being able to see around corners better than probably anyone else could, how worried or fearful should an advisor be right now about the stability or about the permanency of their jobs in this industry? The number of advisors I speak to, it depends upon the day. Either, “I need to get a deal now or I need to sell my business, so I’m worried that AI is going to take my job over the next 10 years.” I feel like that number keeps going up and then some people are on the opposite end, which is, “AI is going to make my business more valuable because I’ll have more time to prospect and do the things I actually want to do. Business is going to be more fun and more scalable.” Where do you rate out on that spectrum and just simply how worried should advisors be about the permanency of their roles? Kelly Wagman: I am really not worried about our advisors losing their jobs to AI. So my PhD is actually looking at human-AI interaction and it’s so important I think for people to trust the person that is managing not just their finances, but really many parts of their life. And I think you can get so many different types of answers from AI that actually having that person that you really trust is even more valuable. I would say the flip side of that is that I do think client expectations will change around the speed of delivery, the level of personalization. So I think that it will be important to continue raising the bar on the level of service that we offer people. But especially at the ultra-high net worth space, as Susie said, it’s a growing segment. A lot of these people are new to wealth. Everything that I’ve studied about AI suggests that people are better when they’re working with a person who is then working with AI. Louis Diamond: Well said. Kelly, what’s a win or two that you’ve delivered to Cresset and its advisors on the AI front that you’re really excited about? Kelly Wagman: It’s a good question. I’ll just give you a couple of examples. I know we talked about the, I would call them FAQ GPTs, so the ability for advisors to look up information really quickly, some of these skills around common productivity tasks, including even things like PowerPoint. I don’t know how much you’ve tried doing PowerPoints with things like ChatGPT, but it actually took us quite a bit of work to get things like Cresset’s branding infused in those processes. We have released a note taker, which I think has been a big win for advisors to not have to manually take notes in meetings. And then again, continuing to just build out this centralized platform that will. The whole philosophy is really how do we empower the advisors and how do we make their lives easier? How do we help them spend more time with clients? And so, everything we do really is with that view in mind. Susie Cranston: I think one of the things that would be an example of the integrated data we’ve been talking about are year-end summaries where you can talk about not just, okay, these are the investment returns that we delivered, but what are the tax savings? What are the time that we spend helping with your family governance and education? So really having integrated year-end summaries, for example, that are automated that advisors can then build from so that we can go back to clients on a regular basis to just say, “Hey, this is the value that we’re adding for you and there’s more we could do. Let’s have that conversation too.” So those kinds of things I think have also been quite popular with advisors. Louis Diamond: Fantastic. Two more questions for you guys. So Susie, the first chapter of Cresset is nothing short of amazing. We covered some of it, but you’re steering this next one as the CEO. What are you building over the next few years that isn’t in place today, whether it’s a capability, a client segment, the reach of the firm? Can you characterize the Cresset that you’re building and what it’s going to look like a couple years from now? Susie Cranston: So, I think the Cresset that we’re building is definitely going to continue to have our arms wrapped around the client and particularly in the industries where I think there is a war for talent. So I feel like a total contrarian these days with everyone talking about, “Hey, AI is going to take away jobs.” I think for experienced professionals in the space of working with ultra-high net worth, there is about to be a war for talent and the firms that can solve that solution are going to be the winners because clients are going to need to have that problem solved. So, what I think you’re going to continue to see in Cresset’s evolution is that we’re going to be continuing to double down on making sure that every client that has needs from the wealth management space to the family office service space, that we are there and able to serve them at whatever size and place they are in their personal trajectories. And that will include AI, that will include people. I also think the other thing that we’re very much continuing to build around is making sure that we have the very best people. And that’s been something that we’ve had from the start, but in a world that’s evolving as quickly as the world that we have around us, if you don’t have the best people that are staying very close to what the clients need, I think that’s where firms are going to get in trouble. And so we’re holding the bar for talent as high as we always have, even as we get bigger, which makes it more challenging and also puts the onus on us to really invest in training and development to make sure that we have the best people for generations across the client family need. Louis Diamond: Amazing. It’s such a cool answer that a big part of the vision is doubling down on people. Even though we have Kelly on here and there’s so much chatter about AI job loss and efficiencies and being able to run a larger business with far fewer people, that didn’t come up in your answer at all. It’s more bullish on advice and human-led advice sounds like is a massive theme throughout this episode. Susie Cranston: Yep. Well said. Louis Diamond: Amazing. And last question for you, Susie, then we’ll wrap. For someone who is stepping into a CEO or an executive leadership role for a firm that they didn’t found, what is a piece of advice you’d give them that maybe you learned the hard way or that you would wish to impart on them or something that’s worked really well for you stepping into the top seat of an established firm? Susie Cranston: One of the big questions and sources of anxiety for I’m sure Eric and Avy and myself as I joined the firm is that when you have a transition away from the founders, how do you do that in a way that is graceful and that doesn’t disrupt the business? And I feel like what Eric and Avy did incredibly well and I really benefited from is that they were very deliberate and thoughtful about how to do this because they want to build a hundred-year firm, they want to have succession happen multiple times. And so they wanted to really be the architects of what that blueprint would look like. And I think the other thing I would say as advice for people that are moving into a situation like this is, spending the time together to make sure that culturally that the founders and the next generation of leadership are aligned so that the barometer of when you have to make a hard choice is always clear. So Eric and Avy and I don’t always agree on everything, but we make sure that it’s always with the client’s best interest at heart. And so, even if not everybody gets every part of the answer that they wanted, everybody can live with the outcome because our values have been satisfied and that’s what we agreed to at the start and that’s what we continue to live by. I think one other final little tip that Eric and Avy used between the two of them as co-founders that they’ve graciously extended and now is part of how I lead, they’re still the chairs of the board and they’re still actively involved in lots of things. And so what we have agreed to is that either all three of us agree to do something or we don’t do it. And so, when we have hard decisions, nobody has to feel anxious that we’re going to do something we can’t live with because we know that we’re either going to find a way to agree collectively on what we’re doing or we pass and live to find the next opportunity another day. And that served them well and has now served us well. Louis Diamond: This has been such a cool episode. First off, Kelly, thank you for coming on and giving us a little peek under the hood of AI in general, but specifically what’s going on at Cresset and what Cresset scale enables you to do. And Susie, always an absolute pleasure and very cool to see how you’re making your own mark on Cresset. Thank you for unpacking for me what family office actually means instead of the, I think, diluted version that’s across the industry. And I’m excited to see just the continued evolution and success of your firm. It’s already amazing what’s been accomplished, but I know with you at the helm, this is only the beginning. Susie Cranston: Well, we appreciate that and I would be remiss not to say that you and your team have been fantastic advisors. So we really have always appreciated your guidance and thank you for having us today. It’s been a pleasure. Kelly Wagman: Thanks for having us. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook . The Modern Family Office: Cresset’s CEO & Head of AI on Building for the Future A conversation with Louis Diamond and Susie Cranston, CEO of Cresset, and Kelly Wagman, PhD, Director and Head of AI Strategy at Cresset. Louis Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is The Modern Family Office: Cresset’s CEO & Head of AI on Building for the Future. It’s a conversation with CEO Susie Cranston and director, head of AI strategy, Kelly Wagman. I’m Louis Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. To download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Louis Diamond: For a long time, the family office model has been defined by something that’s inherently difficult to scale. Highly customized advice, deep knowledge of a family, an entire ecosystem of services that can extend well beyond investments into tax and estate planning, family governance, bill pay, household management, security, and just about anything else a complex family might need. But AI has the potential to change that equation, not by replacing the people delivering that advice, but by helping firms bring more expertise, information, and personalization to more clients and potentially expand the kind of family office experience that historically has only been available to the wealthiest families. That’s one of the ideas behind what Cresset is building today. My guests are Susie Cranston, CEO of Cresset and Kelly Wagman, a PhD, the firm’s director, and head of AI strategy. Cresset was founded by Eric Becker and Avy Stein in 2017. And here’s a quick tip. If you do a search for Cresset in our podcast archives, you’ll find an early episode with Avy along with several from top advisors who call the firm home. Today, the firm has grown to more than 250 billion in assets under management and advisement with more than 700 professionals in a significant infrastructure dedicated specifically to family office services. After serving in leadership positions at First Republic Bank and JP Morgan Chase, Susie joined Cresset in 2024 as president and was recently appointed CEO in March of this year. Susie offers a perspective on what she learned from her experience at client-centric First Republic, and how that’s helped her build on the already strong foundation at Cresset. And now she’s taking on the next big thing, how AI can serve as a force multiplier for their model, a charge led by Kelly. We talk about what a true multifamily office looks like today, where AI can create real leverage for advisors and clients, and why both Susie and Kelly believe the future of wealth management will require more human advice, not less, and how AI can help facilitate that. We also get into Cresset’s culture, its use of equity as a currency for growth and alignment, and Susie’s vision for the firm’s next decade. Because the interesting question isn’t whether AI changes the family office, it’s what the family office can become because of it. Let’s get to it. Susie and Kelly, thank you for joining us today. Susie Cranston: It is our pleasure. We are thrilled to be here. Thank you for having us. Louis Diamond: Awesome. Susie, I’ll direct the first question to you. Can you tell us about your professional journey? I know it was a little bit different than most and how you found your way to First Republic, which I believe was your first job within our amazing industry. Susie Cranston: So, the first decade of my career I was at McKinsey. While I didn’t work for a wealth management firm, I did consult in the financial services space. So I spent a little over a decade after studying engineering and as an undergraduate in the wealth space as a consultant, and really decided after I’d been in McKinsey for about 10 years that it would be great to work in a company, but I believe deeply that you’re going to work for a company, it’s got to be a client first company. It’s got to be a company that has a great culture. And so as I was looking around within San Francisco where I’m from, First Republic seemed like a great stop. And so I spent a little over a decade there building primarily our wealth management business, which was about 25 billion in AUM when I joined and about 250 billion when we became part of JP Morgan 10 years later. Louis Diamond: Amazing. And we’ll get into aspects of the time at First Republic. Everyone’s interested to hear more. Kelly, similar question for you. So I know we’ll spend some real time digging into AI and what Cresset’s up to on the AI front a little bit later, but can you give our audience a little bit of perspective on your background and what your role is at Cresset? Kelly Wagman: Sure. I’m the head of AI strategy here at Cresset. I’ve been here for about a year. Previously I did a PhD in computer science focused on AI, and I also worked at Microsoft for a number of years doing enterprise software development. So I am relatively new to the wealth management industry, but very excited about the intersection of technology and business. Louis Diamond: Amazing. Very succinct answer. And if you ever get stumped on the industry, AI can help you understand it better. So Susie, for you. So for listeners who maybe aren’t as familiar with Cresset, and we can’t assume they caught earlier episodes we did with some of your partners like Avy Stein and Justin Berman and Wen, how would you describe the firm today? Who’s it for and what makes Cresset different? Susie Cranston: Thank you. Well, so today Cresset has a little over 250 billion in assets and management and advisement. We are a nationwide firm, so we have over 25 locations nationwide and over 700 professionals delivering services that range from wealth management to institutional consulting, to family office services. And it’s been an incredible journey. Cresset isn’t even 10 years old yet, but it has been a really rewarding one. We are, I should also mention, 80% owned by employees and clients. So- Kelly Wagman: Yes. Louis Diamond: Wow. Susie Cranston: … it’s a very employee client-centric story that we have always had at Cresset. Louis Diamond: Very cool. I remember probably, if Cresset’s been around for 10 years, maybe it was 11 years ago, sitting down with Avy Stein and Eric Becker, your two co-founders, and it was legitimately, it was an idea. There was a premise that there were no clients, there were no advisors, there were no employees, and it’s amazing to see what’s been accomplished in a decade. 700 professionals, professionals, the amount of AUM. And I think pretty much every advisor or person in the industry has at least heard of Cresset. So it’s an amazing testament to you now as the steward of the company, but also to those who came before you. Susie Cranston: Absolutely. I think Eric and Avy famously founded Cresset so that it was founded by clients for clients. They were both retired and that’s probably when they met with you to get your advice and perspective and really decided when they couldn’t find what they wanted in the marketplace to build it themselves. And the fact that so many clients have followed and joined, I think is just a testament to the vision that they had and what we’re trying to build here today. Louis Diamond: Amazing. Maybe I’m biased from the seat doing this podcast, but I think all the best firms that have started in the last 10, 15 years, they started around a similar premise. It was either a manager, an industry executive, even an industry outsider, or in Cresset’s case, clients of financial services firms looking around saying, “Hey, if this doesn’t exist, why don’t we create it?” And that’s their big “aha” moment is trying to think through what are the pain points that I’m uniquely capable of solving for? So it’s a really cool journey. Susie, I know we’re talking about Cresset today, but I asked you about getting into First Republic, but I mean First Republic, everyone knows the end result. But I mean to me, while First Republic was in its heyday and really until the collapse, it had an amazing client-first culture. Advisors were super happy there. I’m sure employees are really happy. I mean, to me, that’s not something that happens by accident. So is there something you could point to about what made First Republic special? I’m sure it was more than just something in the water. Susie Cranston: Well, it’s interesting. It’s a great question. And I think there’s really two pieces of what made First Republic so successful, and there’s probably more to the story, but from my perspective in any event, the first is around having a very client-centric culture. And I think what everybody intuitively knows is that if you always do the right thing for the client, and you’re always delivering the very best you can for the end client, good things happen. However, sometimes that means you do things that are short-term unprofitable or short-term against the best interest of the firm in order to deliver the right thing for the client. And I think one of the things that First Republic always got right was the idea that benefiting the client even at the short-term cost of the firm is always the right decision. And so we always could tell clients with a very straight face and a very strong conviction, that we were doing our best for them. And I think that makes a huge difference in terms of the caliber of the client experience, but also in terms of who wants to work at your firm. And that gets me to the second part that I think First Republic did right, which is we had a very empowered client-facing set of professionals. So, if you really want to be a client-centric firm, the idea that any one manager, the idea that any management team is going to sit in an ivory tower and figure out what needs to happen and be successful, I think is a fallacy. I think the best way to be a client-centric firm is that the people who are interacting with the clients are empowered and are informing the decision-making and the strategy setting that you’re doing as a firm. And so at First Republic, the people that worked with clients always were advising us on what we should do. They were always empowered to do the right thing. And so I think those two ingredients I have seen when those exist in a firm, that’s where you get that magic outcome because what happens over time, and we proved this out at First Republic, when you have great clients that are really loyal and have a fantastic experience, they refer friends and family that are better or equivalent clients, and you get this really wonderful flywheel to go. Louis Diamond: Amazing. Yeah, I mean I saw it firsthand. I would agree with you that legitimately every advisor we have replaced at First Republic, that was one of the first things they said was like, “It’s fun to work here. They listen, we have a voice.” And I know people who are clients of First Republic and the bank, it was always raved reviews about service and about just the level of care that they received. I mean, it’s almost like, I know Raymond James and has been a competitor to yours, but I feel like that’s the way that’s been part of Raymond James’ success has been looking at the advisor as the client, empowering advisors, et cetera. And it sounds easy to replicate, right? We want to be client first, we want to empower advisors, but it’s much harder in practice from a compliance standpoint or from a responding to shareholder standpoint. So, I think it’s amazing and I’m sure that a lot of that is what you’ve carried into your role at Cresset. How about, let’s say, a hard lesson learned? Obviously you weren’t in charge of the balance sheet of First Republic or anything else that happened, but is there a lesson that you carry from the collapse of First Republic or is there anything that it makes you watch out for now that you wouldn’t have known before? Susie Cranston: This will probably make some people laugh, but I have newfound religion around the idea of a fortress balance sheet. Right? So as you said, on the wealth management side, we didn’t control the asset side of the balance sheet as much, but there can be no doubt that when Jamie Diamond talks about JP Morgan’s fortress balance sheet, he knows what he is talking about. So one of the things that I have been myopically focused on at Cresset is making sure we have an incredibly strong Fortress balance sheet because when you’re operating from a position of strength and the balance sheet, you can weather all sorts of storms and you can take advantage of opportunities in the marketplace. But the thing that I also took away from it and has been part of what led me to Cresset was this realization that when you combine banking and wealth management, you’re opening yourself up to risk and challenge in ways that sometimes don’t seem that big of a deal, but then sometimes can be a really big deal. So, it was interesting. I did spend time, I went from First Republic to JP Morgan, and operating in the JP Morgan environment, it’s an incredibly well-run organization and it is highly regulated as all too-big-to-fail banks are. And that has to be when you are a too big to fail bank, a big priority because you don’t get to operate if you don’t follow the regulatory requirements. But having all of those bank regulatory requirements on top of what you can do in wealth management at an RIA does change the offering set that you can provide to clients. Right? So the biggest takeaway from me from this whole last chapter of my career was to really understand and be thoughtful about what you’re getting and what you’re losing when you’re combining different parts of businesses, because sometimes it doesn’t seem like a big deal until it does. Louis Diamond: Yeah, absolutely. It’s almost like it gives you the ability to be skeptical or play devil’s advocate in a way that you probably had known about before, but you didn’t really appreciate it. It’s like things were going so well, amazing reputation, doing things right by clients, crushing earnings, et cetera. But then the unexpected happens and no one ever expects the unexpected to happen, but the ones that are best prepared can weather the storm. So, it makes a lot of sense. So Susie, after First Republic and then a stint at JP Morgan during the integration phase, I’m sure you had quite a number of options. So, why Cresset? What was your why story behind joining Cresset as a professional executive, obviously not as a founder, but what was it that you saw in Cresset that led you to it over any other opportunity or staying with JP Morgan? Susie Cranston: Well, I will say going back to your first question about what made First Republic special, I think having a client-centric firm where you do the right thing for clients, even if it’s against the economic interests of the firm, I think that’s the winning recipe in the professional services space. And I say that from my McKinsey tenure, from my First Republic, JP Morgan tenure, that recipe always works if you’re really running a good business, because even if you take a short-term hit from not doing something in the short-term that you could, the benefit you get from retention, from referrals, all of that does take care of that in the long run, and it’s a better long-term business. I also knew that a big reason why First Republic had been successful was because of its culture. As you alluded to very kindly, it was an incredible place where frontline professionals had a seat at the table. They drove the strategy, they were interacting with us every day to give us their input. And so I felt like I knew that was an incredibly successful model in the wealth management space. And I also learned, as I spent more time at JP Morgan, that if you were going to try to deliver a really client-centric experience in a too-big-to-fail bank, which to be clear, that was the only type of banking I was ever going to do after my First Republic experience. It was either going to be too big to fail or I wasn’t going to do banking. And as I got to know what it would mean to run a business like this in a too-big-to-fail regulatory infrastructure, I started to realize that for the ultra high net worth family office space, there was going to be an opportunity for independent RIAs to really take, not even take market share from the big institutional players, but to take all the new market share that was emerging, right? Because we are in a period of incredible wealth creation in this country right now. I mean, there are over a hundred thousand families in the US alone that have more than a hundred million dollars net worth. Even if you did an inflation adjusted look back 20, 50 years, the number of people that have this much wealth has never been seen before in the history of our country. And so, what really brought me to Cresset was this platform that was incredibly client-centric because it was founded by clients for clients. It had been built in a really robust manner and had the balance sheet strength that I was looking for, and had the ability to deliver these services that this incredible emerging wealth was going to need. Because what we’re really seeing right now in the market, which is so fascinating, is that as people have more and more wealth to manage and it’s more and more complicated, they need that integrated bill pay, tax advice, estate planning, and family governance and education. Right? All the things need to be provided by an integrated provider or someone’s going to just build their own family office. And so those kind of market needs and those realizations were what made Cresset a top choice. And I admit that as I was looking in the space, there weren’t a ton of places that checked all those boxes. And so, I had a very famous conversation with my mom where I said, “Mom, I’m not sure what I’m going to do if Cresset doesn’t end up hiring me,” but fortunately it did end up working out. Louis Diamond: And knowing Avy and Eric, I’m glad you didn’t tell them that. It would’ve hurt your leverage and the negotiations. Susie Cranston: Our right to negotiate. No, they were great. Louis Diamond: Awesome. Kelly, I want to shift some of the attention to you. I noted in your… And I think it’s a new title, it’s Head of AI Strategy Director. What does that actually mean? So are you actually developing your own custom AI tools for Cresset and its advisors, or is it more about, let’s come up with a strategy for how the firm is going to deploy and leverage AI into the future? What does the title mean to you? Kelly Wagman: It’s a good question, and I think I can actually speak to the evolution because I think the role has evolved. So I think of the first step of any strategy being that enablement piece. So I came in really focused on enablement, which meant to me, empowering people to use these new tools. And I think what we realized as we started doing that is that that’s great, but we also needed to be understanding what our use cases were, prioritizing them, starting to build out or look for vendors for particularly complicated things, thinking about our data strategy. And so, my role evolved into this more strategy focused role as we realized we needed to think a little bit bigger picture about AI at Cresset. Louis Diamond: Very cool. And at Cresset, and I always try to square this because I know every company’s different, but is it that the strategy is we’re using Claude and we’re using ChatGPT and whatever else, or are you actually building your own AI tools, or maybe it’s a combination of the two? Kelly Wagman: Yeah, we are definitely building things. We are not building foundation models. We’re not out to replicate ChatGPT or Claude. We are using those tools. But then there are more complicated use cases. You can think about particular operations workflows, or people talk about things like meeting prep or these things that we do want to provide a standardized version to people. So we’re building those. And then we’re also, we use some vendor partners in places where that makes sense as well. Louis Diamond: It makes sense to me. Susie, question for you. I’ve heard the term, “We’re a family office,” or, “We offer family office services” everywhere. It’s almost like water in this industry. Everyone on some website has said it or mentions it, or if you ask them what they do, they say, “We offer family office-like services,” or, “We are a family office or a multifamily office.” So, obviously I know with Cresset, it’s more than just a buzzword. I think last I read, there’s over 150 people just in the family office group alone out of over 700 professionals. So, what do you believe a real family office looks like? What are the services that are being provided, and how does what Cresset provides as a family office or multifamily office differ from a number of other firms that just really like their clients and maybe they work with some larger ones so they can throw the word around? Susie Cranston: So, what really differentiates Cresset is that we have been doing this and investing in this, and building this from day one. So, we have a deep infrastructure across all the elements of family office services that a client might need. And the way to differentiate it that I found when I was looking around at other options several years ago was just ask firms, “How many dedicated people do you have to family office services?” Right? Because a lot of places talk about it, but when you ask how many dedicated professionals, the answer is like, “Well, we got a few here, a few there.” And we have a hundred advisors and 150 people doing family office services. So, when you’re talking to clients about the depth of coverage that we can provide and you’re trying to demonstrate credibly that you can take care of the family’s full range of needs, we have a very competent, compelling, detailed story to tell. And the reason I think this is so important is that because there’s so much wealth being created, there is new populations of people who need support that never needed support in the past and there’s no existing infrastructure for them. At the same time, we’re seeing a decline in the supporting functions for family offices. So the number of people graduating from accounting to programs is down 50% over the last eight years. So you’re seeing the population of supporting professionals is dwindling, getting harder to find, and the demand for this shrinking supply is growing. Right? And so having capability that you can really meaningfully deliver to support families is really important because even the biggest family offices in the country, the biggest names everybody would know if I said them, those family offices don’t do everything in-house themselves because of privacy reasons, because of business continuity reasons. So, there is a really important relationship between being able to deliver family office services and being able to advise and support the wealth of those families. And that has been something that Eric and Avy understood from day one, and so we’ve always invested in that. And listen, it’s a tough choice to make, I think, when you’re starting a business because you have to build out the infrastructure before it’s fully profitable. So, we had to make a very hard choice. Eric and Avy made a hard choice to take that cost on before it was fully profitable, but that has then translated into incredible success. And to tie it into Kelly, who I just have to say we are so fortunate to have, she is a complete star and she’s very modest, but she’s just done amazing work at Cresset. And one of the things that we are also able to do with our knowledge of Family Office is when you have 150 practitioners at Family Office, you can start to say, how do we leverage AI to bring bill pay in an affordable way to clients that have a $20 million net worth? Or how do we do the taxes in an automated way leveraging AI for clients that have 20 million? And you can really start to scale those services. And that’s actually really important when you’re working with families because the matriarch or the patriarch of the family may have hundreds of millions, billions of dollars, but maybe some of the children haven’t inherited it yet. So you’ve got to support the full family where they are at, and AI is going to be a tool that really enables that scale. Louis Diamond: It’s such an interesting use case for AI. And maybe Kelly, you can elaborate. The fact that Cresset has these, I would assume very expensive, very knowledgeable professionals that are working with the top tier of clients, but being able to use AI to take their intellectual capital and what they’re doing at the high end and scaling it to kids or to smaller clients, can you weigh in on that use case and how it’s shaping out at Cresset right now? Kelly Wagman: Yeah, I think a lot of the promise of AI is actually being able to build things on top of integrated data. Once you do that, there’s a lot of unlock that you have. So we spent a lot of time working on how do we get our data into a place where we can start to build some of these things. But I think that also does unlock at the higher end where you can still have very customized bespoke white glove services, but people can get their questions answered more quickly, advisors can spend more time on those client interactions, you can have higher levels of personalization. So I think we spend a lot of time on getting this core platform so that we can then expand use cases in both directions. Louis Diamond: It’s so interesting. When you’re thinking on behalf of Cresset about do we build something ourselves or do we go buy some AI tool off the shelf, whether it’s like a Jump AI or a CogniCor, or some add-on from Addepar or the various tech vendors, how do you think about the trade-off between you and your team building it specifically for Cresset versus buying something off the shelf and maybe customizing elements of it? Kelly Wagman: I think there are two pieces of that. One, I think we need to continue to own our data. Again, I think the data part is very valuable, so I don’t want to have a product that’s going to somehow take that data and make it not accessible to us. And then two, a lot of it comes down to whether the thing is well offered and how customizable it is. I think in this era, people are building software in ways that is more customizable and faster to iterate on. And so if a vendor is building something that is the thing that we want and they’re willing to customize it to us, I think that’s great. If there’s something that just doesn’t exist yet or that we really need to build ourselves, we can also look at that. But in a regulated industry, I think we need very robust software. So, working with vendors, especially on some of these kind of critical areas, is important for that. Louis Diamond: Awesome. Susie Cranston: If I can just add one thing onto that, Louis, I think one of our theories of the case is that given how regulated our industry is, that the AI rollout has to be much more controlled and thoughtful in our industry than it would in something like software, because you can’t have an AI tool that’s overriding compliance features or that’s doing something accidentally that then puts the firm at risk. Right? So that’s part of what I think all of our competitors and we are really being mindful about. Louis Diamond: No doubt about it. Susie, back to the family office question. I think another kind of knock on the term family office is people think it’s like, “Oh, we walk our client’s dogs,” or, “We pick up our client’s dry cleaning.” Maybe that’s part of your answer, but when you look at the services that Cresset provides in its family office, what are the top couple that are the most valuable, or maybe even take another direction, the most out there that clients have requested that you’re now offering? Susie Cranston: So we think about our family office services in two categories of offerings. There’s the wealth strategy piece, and that’s things like the estate and tax planning, the family governance and education. It’s really all the kind of thoughtful planning pieces that you want to put in place to effectively manage your resources. And then we have wealth administration, which is a day-to-day management and oversight of all the trappings that go with your assets, bill pay, tax, all the kind of travel planning and logistics. Another big one is household payroll and household management. Oftentimes wealthy people start to accumulate quite a few different professionals that help them in different capacities, and managing that starts to become a lot of work. You have to manage all the tax pieces, you have to manage the payroll administration, you have to make sure you’re filing all the right documents and following all the right compliance rules in all the different states that you operate in or countries. And then multiply that times you got the yacht going all over and the pilots for the plane going all over. So the complexity of these families multiplies quite quickly. And so I would say the top service that everybody seems to want and we get the most requests for is probably some combination of tax and estate planning, which is part of wealth management in general, but then double clicking to the next level. But family governance and education is a huge focus for a lot of clients. How do they think about raising their children, their grandchildren in ways that don’t allow, that mitigate any potential issues coming from having so much wealth and letting them take advantage of the resources that the family has created? There’s a lot of complex family dynamics that emerge when you’re dealing with wealth. The number one way that wealth is created, as many of us know in this industry, is through owning and operating companies. Ownership of companies is the wealth creator that drives everything in the United States. So, when you think about all of a sudden you’ve got cousins, aunts, uncles, all sorts of different people trying to manage a company together, trying to manage a family business together, having processes and systems and support for how to do that effectively while maintaining the family relationships is really important. So that’s another big one that we get, as well as they’ll pay household administration. That’s just something that a lot of families want help with. But an out there example is security. Right? So we have helped clients exit Israel after the issues that happened there. We’ve helped clients get out of Ukraine when Russia initially invaded. So, there’s all sorts of things involved in being a family office. But if you can’t deliver those services, then the families have no choice but to build their own family office and then the whole benefit of what you’re trying to provide for them is moot. So you do have to be able to accommodate a range of needs. Louis Diamond: It’s crazy. Yeah. I mean honestly, I wish one day I had that much money where those services are made available to me or maybe through Kelly’s work, they will be soon. But it is quite the investment that Avy and Eric made. And I was going to ask a question, but I think you already answered it about what did Avy and Eric get right in the beginning that’s overlooked. I’ll ask it, but I would have to answer first and say really investing, building out a massive organization in very expensive areas before a dollar of client assets came. Would you agree or would you have a different answer? Susie Cranston: No, I’ve thought about this a lot. What is it in what Eric and Avy did that made it so differentiated? And I think you’re spot on, Louis. What Eric and Avy had going for them that I think is often overlooked is they were successful and retired when they started this. So they had all the experience and all the knowledge of decades of being successful, executives, entrepreneurs, founders, and they were okay already. They were set. They could have just stayed retired. And so when they created this business, they didn’t have the pressure of this being the make or break thing for their families. And it allowed them, I think, to really be expansive, do what they thought was right, prioritize the long game as Eric would say, in ways that I think are harder to do if your family’s really all riding on this one thing. Louis Diamond: Yep. On the other hand, it’s if you’re retired and successful, why are you trying to create stress in your life? Susie Cranston: That’s the DNA of Eric and Avy. They are very hardworking. Louis Diamond: Love it. Susie, another question for you and then I’ll turn it back to Kelly. So from First Republic, just you have to live under a rock in this industry to not respect the fact that there’s so many different firms, types of firms, business models that a successful advisor, a team, an independent RIA, could opt to partner with. You can go to sell to an aggregator, you can sell a minority stake in your business, you can launch your own RIA, you can affiliate with a supported independent platform, go to an IBD, go to a wirehouse, probably 50 different types of options. Forget about all the different firms underneath it. So when you’re recruiting or looking to win an M&A deal, what’s your honest case for why Cresset over any other option that someone might have available to them? Susie Cranston: Well, it’s probably twofold. I think on the one hand, Cresset has always been myopic about its culture. We always say we do culture first no matter what. That is the sort of golden rule of our organization. And so I think the first thing that I always say to institutions we’re thinking about partnering with or teams that are thinking of joining is listen to what we’re saying about how we operate our culture. And it is a very client first, take care of clients, take care of colleagues culture. And if that resonates with you, that is wonderful. And if it doesn’t, that’s okay too, but then we should part ways as friends because the culture piece is a really big part of what we’re doing. But the second thing that I think is really important is alignment. And one of the things that was interesting about being at First Republic is that wealth management business that we built drove so much wealth in that business, which was fantastic and people benefited for the time business existed. But if you are a partial owner driving that kind of wealth and opportunity, that allows you to benefit from your hard work in a different way. And I think it is really exciting to be in a place in the industry’s evolution where people that work at Cresset can have the opportunity to do great work for clients and be very culturally aligned and have that benefit their families in ways that we couldn’t do before. Because the way that Cresset is structured, when people join Cresset, the benefits are taxed at capital gains, not income. So there’s a huge delta in the benefit of what ends up staying with the family. But then secondly, what I think people don’t always understand is when you’re thinking about, for example, a deal to join a firm, the equity value can increase so rapidly. So we had a client, a team that joined us two years ago, and the equity value of their deal has already increased the multiple of their deal substantially. And we have distributions, we have periodic liquidity events. So, the wealth creation that can happen here I think is really unique for advisor teams. And I don’t think it’s always well understood, but it’s interesting because it’s a little bit of the cobbler’s kids have no shoes, right? We all as professionals work with families and we see how do families get this wealth. They usually get this wealth by owning enterprises and running businesses. So, here we are today in a place in time where the advisor had the opportunity to do that. And I think for a lot of advisors, that’s really exciting. Louis Diamond: How about I give you two-part question? I’m going to put you on trial here for a little bit. So I think equity is peaks and valleys. It’s either everyone wants it, everyone hates it, and there’s some sort of event or something, whether it was the financial crisis, or I hear XYZ firm just that diluted everyone and couldn’t sell, couldn’t raise capital, and cash is king. There isn’t a perfect answer for every advisor, but make the case for a deal with Cresset that is at least part equity versus a probably larger headline number check from a wirehouse or W2 firm. That’s the first part, and then I’ll get to the second one. Susie Cranston: First of all, I would say at Cresset, I mean, we don’t mandate that people take some percentage of equity. So I think if people really want to go with a cash deal, we would do a competitive deal. It would just be that you don’t have the equity upside and you don’t have the benefit of distribution over time. So, for people that feel really strongly, if they’re a cultural fit, I think we want to accommodate teams where they’re at and different people are at different stages in their lives. But the thing about equity is that it is tied to the underlying value of the business and the underlying value of a wealth business is incredibly stable for the most part. We all know there’ll be a down cycle and there might be a few years where we’re building back up, but in general, the arc of time, I mean the reason we all sit in these wonderful seats is that the market continues to grow and therefore the business continues to grow, if hold onto your clients. And if you’re doing a great job for clients, you’re actually growing their wealth and they’re getting their referrals at the same time. So as you think about whether you want equity or not, you have to ask yourself, “What’s the underlying risk of that equity?” And I think the benefits of equity in this space outweigh the potential risks if you look at it objectively. Now, as I said, I totally understand that at different points in life and different places in your evolution of what your family needs, different things may make more or less sense. But I believe that the people who have been the most successful in our industry over the arc of time, are the ones who’ve taken the initiative, bet on themselves, believed in themselves because the way that equity doesn’t manifest itself is if there isn’t a business. Right? And that can happen in software. People might say, “Oh, now I can vibe code my own version of Salesforce. I don’t need Salesforce anymore.” The risk in wealth management would be that somebody says, “I don’t want someone to manage my money.” And every indication, every survey we’ve seen is that clients are saying they want more human advice, not less in the world of AI. So I think it is certainly a choice that everybody gets to make themselves. And at Cresset, we’re happy to meet teams wherever they want to be met. But I also think if you’re not excited about what you’re building and you’re not excited about what the equity can do, then we might not be at the best place for our team because it is an incredible opportunity. And for those of us that have been doing this for a while, it’s been incredibly lucrative. Louis Diamond: Yep, I would agree. What about the case? What about someone who says, “I’m successful. I grow at 10, 15, 20% per year. It’s better for me to go independent or stay independent and own 100% of my own business. And then 10 years from now when the business has compounded and grown, I can sell it to Cresset. I can sell it to whoever.” What’s the fault in that logic or that same individual, same business? How potentially could a deal with a Cresset or one of your competitors that structures deals in a similar way? How could that be potentially a better outcome for that individual? Susie Cranston: Well, I think it is worth people always doing the numbers on those calculations, right, to see, can you go independent and have that be more lucrative with all the different machinations that are involved in that, than it would be to do a transaction now? And interestingly, both at Cresset and at First Republic, we often had those conversations very explicitly with teams that were thinking of joining. And I think the fact that we had so many teams join First Republic and now Cresset is testament to the fact that starting on your own can be great, but to maintain growth when you all of a sudden have to deal with compliance, custodians, all the back office, all the infrastructure, all the things that go into this space, it can be challenging to sustain that level of growth, take care of all your clients, and add all of that workload on. And then there’s a time value of money. So you’ve got to get offices, you’ve got to get infrastructure, you’ve got to get all these things going. And even with partners, then you’re giving a percentage of the business away. So the question just becomes, I think economically, is it better to try to do it on your own, or is it better to try to make a transaction now? And I think the real deciding factor in all of that really does become, how much do you want to just be your own boss? Because I think economically it’s probably pretty close in terms of you can get a competitive deal that would be similar to doing all of that work and going independent. And so as I’ve talked to teams, if you really want to go be your own boss, then by all means go start your own firm. I think that is an interesting and exciting adventure for many people. If what you love to do is to grow your business and be with clients and make things happen on the client front, which a lot of advisors are incredible at and get so much joy out of, then finding an opportunity where you can join a firm, have a seat at the table and be a leader in terms of the strategy, but not have to do all that incremental work, I think it can make a difference. Louis Diamond: Thank you for giving two very balanced answers and not just eating your own home cooking, but I completely agree that I think anyone can build a financial model or run projections that tilts one way or the other, the join a firm, equity appreciation, et cetera, versus just doing it on their own. So I think so much of it is, what are you most passionate about? What gets you out of bed? And ultimately, under which model do you think is going to have the most fun and you’re going to be the most successful at? And that’s why I love my job. There isn’t a cookie cutter answer. It changes across the board. Susie Cranston: That’s 100% right. Yeah. Louis Diamond: Question for you along the similar lines, but more so on the technology or AI front. In your opinion or in your view, what does an advisor or team access being part of Cresset on the AI front or on the technology front that they couldn’t access strictly as their own if they’re building their own RIA from scratch, or even let’s say at a major financial institution that has more to spend on technology but likely has legacy systems, and is a little bit slower to market than Cresset can be? Kelly Wagman: Yeah, I think to that point, Cresset really is at that sweet spot of being big enough to be able to invest in the space, but small enough that we can still be nimble and offer people some of the best and newest tools. We are building out the wrapper around it to provide a lot of Cresset-specific skills and access to data. So not only do you get access to the LLM, you also get to say, build in skills that help with looking at your email or that help with meetings or that we have a whole suite of tools where people can look up knowledge bases from different teams. So, whether that’s HR, things about banking and lending or these different areas. And so I think that it really empowers the advisors to get started with something that feels a little bit like a Cresset specific assistant that we’re continuing to work on. Susie Cranston: I would also add to that things like talking about family governance and education. So we are thought leaders in all of these spaces. And so, to have access to tools that can help you quickly have answers to some of the common questions that clients have and the assurance that it’s a best practice answer, that’s research that’s used across multiple families, is really valuable. The other thing I would just say having spent time in larger organizations is that as Kelly mentioned earlier, the data is really the critical part to letting AI help advisors be more efficient. And because we are in this kind of sweet spot size, we’re not so big that we can’t have the integrated view of what’s working in clients and have it be across all the different facets that we serve clients for. So we have that integrated view, but we are still at a size where we can actually translate that into things that teams can do. “Hey, this is what was interesting to four other clients of a similar profile, similar size, you should talk to this client about it.” Those kinds of insights I think can get hard in a very large organization where the data is too distributed, and it’s candidly pretty expensive for a very small firm to invest in or they don’t have big enough data set. Kelly Wagman: And on the compliance side, I mean, Susie mentioned this earlier, but I think developing security and compliance around AI is a totally new area because AI is so new, and I think that’s a space where having the support of a firm is really helpful. Louis Diamond: For you, someone who is much more knowledgeable about AI, where it’s going, what it’s capable of, and probably really being able to see around corners better than probably anyone else could, how worried or fearful should an advisor be right now about the stability or about the permanency of their jobs in this industry? The number of advisors I speak to, it depends upon the day. Either, “I need to get a deal now or I need to sell my business, so I’m worried that AI is going to take my job over the next 10 years.” I feel like that number keeps going up and then some people are on the opposite end, which is, “AI is going to make my business more valuable because I’ll have more time to prospect and do the things I actually want to do. Business is going to be more fun and more scalable.” Where do you rate out on that spectrum and just simply how worried should advisors be about the permanency of their roles? Kelly Wagman: I am really not worried about our advisors losing their jobs to AI. So my PhD is actually looking at human-AI interaction and it’s so important I think for people to trust the person that is managing not just their finances, but really many parts of their life. And I think you can get so many different types of answers from AI that actually having that person that you really trust is even more valuable. I would say the flip side of that is that I do think client expectations will change around the speed of delivery, the level of personalization. So I think that it will be important to continue raising the bar on the level of service that we offer people. But especially at the ultra-high net worth space, as Susie said, it’s a growing segment. A lot of these people are new to wealth. Everything that I’ve studied about AI suggests that people are better when they’re working with a person who is then working with AI. Louis Diamond: Well said. Kelly, what’s a win or two that you’ve delivered to Cresset and its advisors on the AI front that you’re really excited about? Kelly Wagman: It’s a good question. I’ll just give you a couple of examples. I know we talked about the, I would call them FAQ GPTs, so the ability for advisors to look up information really quickly, some of these skills around common productivity tasks, including even things like PowerPoint. I don’t know how much you’ve tried doing PowerPoints with things like ChatGPT, but it actually took us quite a bit of work to get things like Cresset’s branding infused in those processes. We have released a note taker, which I think has been a big win for advisors to not have to manually take notes in meetings. And then again, continuing to just build out this centralized platform that will. The whole philosophy is really how do we empower the advisors and how do we make their lives easier? How do we help them spend more time with clients? And so, everything we do really is with that view in mind. Susie Cranston: I think one of the things that would be an example of the integrated data we’ve been talking about are year-end summaries where you can talk about not just, okay, these are the investment returns that we delivered, but what are the tax savings? What are the time that we spend helping with your family governance and education? So really having integrated year-end summaries, for example, that are automated that advisors can then build from so that we can go back to clients on a regular basis to just say, “Hey, this is the value that we’re adding for you and there’s more we could do. Let’s have that conversation too.” So those kinds of things I think have also been quite popular with advisors. Louis Diamond: Fantastic. Two more questions for you guys. So Susie, the first chapter of Cresset is nothing short of amazing. We covered some of it, but you’re steering this next one as the CEO. What are you building over the next few years that isn’t in place today, whether it’s a capability, a client segment, the reach of the firm? Can you characterize the Cresset that you’re building and what it’s going to look like a couple years from now? Susie Cranston: So, I think the Cresset that we’re building is definitely going to continue to have our arms wrapped around the client and particularly in the industries where I think there is a war for talent. So I feel like a total contrarian these days with everyone talking about, “Hey, AI is going to take away jobs.” I think for experienced professionals in the space of working with ultra-high net worth, there is about to be a war for talent and the firms that can solve that solution are going to be the winners because clients are going to need to have that problem solved. So, what I think you’re going to continue to see in Cresset’s evolution is that we’re going to be continuing to double down on making sure that every client that has needs from the wealth management space to the family office service space, that we are there and able to serve them at whatever size and place they are in their personal trajectories. And that will include AI, that will include people. I also think the other thing that we’re very much continuing to build around is making sure that we have the very best people. And that’s been something that we’ve had from the start, but in a world that’s evolving as quickly as the world that we have around us, if you don’t have the best people that are staying very close to what the clients need, I think that’s where firms are going to get in trouble. And so we’re holding the bar for talent as high as we always have, even as we get bigger, which makes it more challenging and also puts the onus on us to really invest in training and development to make sure that we have the best people for generations across the client family need. Louis Diamond: Amazing. It’s such a cool answer that a big part of the vision is doubling down on people. Even though we have Kelly on here and there’s so much chatter about AI job loss and efficiencies and being able to run a larger business with far fewer people, that didn’t come up in your answer at all. It’s more bullish on advice and human-led advice sounds like is a massive theme throughout this episode. Susie Cranston: Yep. Well said. Louis Diamond: Amazing. And last question for you, Susie, then we’ll wrap. For someone who is stepping into a CEO or an executive leadership role for a firm that they didn’t found, what is a piece of advice you’d give them that maybe you learned the hard way or that you would wish to impart on them or something that’s worked really well for you stepping into the top seat of an established firm? Susie Cranston: One of the big questions and sources of anxiety for I’m sure Eric and Avy and myself as I joined the firm is that when you have a transition away from the founders, how do you do that in a way that is graceful and that doesn’t disrupt the business? And I feel like what Eric and Avy did incredibly well and I really benefited from is that they were very deliberate and thoughtful about how to do this because they want to build a hundred-year firm, they want to have succession happen multiple times. And so they wanted to really be the architects of what that blueprint would look like. And I think the other thing I would say as advice for people that are moving into a situation like this is, spending the time together to make sure that culturally that the founders and the next generation of leadership are aligned so that the barometer of when you have to make a hard choice is always clear. So Eric and Avy and I don’t always agree on everything, but we make sure that it’s always with the client’s best interest at heart. And so, even if not everybody gets every part of the answer that they wanted, everybody can live with the outcome because our values have been satisfied and that’s what we agreed to at the start and that’s what we continue to live by. I think one other final little tip that Eric and Avy used between the two of them as co-founders that they’ve graciously extended and now is part of how I lead, they’re still the chairs of the board and they’re still actively involved in lots of things. And so what we have agreed to is that either all three of us agree to do something or we don’t do it. And so, when we have hard decisions, nobody has to feel anxious that we’re going to do something we can’t live with because we know that we’re either going to find a way to agree collectively on what we’re doing or we pass and live to find the next opportunity another day. And that served them well and has now served us well. Louis Diamond: This has been such a cool episode. First off, Kelly, thank you for coming on and giving us a little peek under the hood of AI in general, but specifically what’s going on at Cresset and what Cresset scale enables you to do. And Susie, always an absolute pleasure and very cool to see how you’re making your own mark on Cresset. Thank you for unpacking for me what family office actually means instead of the, I think, diluted version that’s across the industry. And I’m excited to see just the continued evolution and success of your firm. It’s already amazing what’s been accomplished, but I know with you at the helm, this is only the beginning. Susie Cranston: Well, we appreciate that and I would be remiss not to say that you and your team have been fantastic advisors. So we really have always appreciated your guidance and thank you for having us today. It’s been a pleasure. Kelly Wagman: Thanks for having us. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook .

September 24, 2026Episode 37858 min

Build, Grow & Transact: David Bahnsen on Building a $10.5B Business Worth Selling

David Bahnsen, Founder & Managing Partner, The Bahnsen Group From $600mm to $10.5B, David Bahnsen built The Bahnsen Group almost entirely through organic growth. He shares the decisions behind that growth, the value of reinvesting in the business, and why selling to longtime partner Hightower became the right next step. In Summary David Bahnsen left Morgan Stanley in 2015 with eight people and $600mm in client assets, motivated less by dissatisfaction than by what he calls being “intoxicated by the idea of freedom.” Eleven years later, The Bahnsen Group has grown to $10.5B in assets, 106 employees, and 13 offices—with virtually all of that expansion driven organically. But the more instructive story is how that growth happened. David explains how original content and thought leadership became a powerful source of new business, why attracting clients only matters if the firm can deliver an experience that keeps them, and how continual reinvestment in people, tax, planning, investment management, and family office services helped turn a founder-led practice into a national enterprise. He also shares the thinking behind his decision to sell The Bahnsen Group to Hightower after more than a decade of working within its ecosystem. The transaction gives the firm greater resources for technology, HR, supervision, and future inorganic growth while allowing David to maintain control over the brand, P&L, strategy, and client experience. The Storyline When David Bahnsen first appeared on the Diamond Podcast in April 2020, The Bahnsen Group was five years removed from its Morgan Stanley breakaway and had grown from $600mm to roughly $2B. Today, the firm manages $10.5B across 13 offices with more than 100 employees. The numbers are notable, but David’s approach to building the business provides the real lessons. Rather than pursue acquisitions, The Bahnsen Group built an organic growth engine around content, thought leadership, and a distinct investment philosophy. David’s Dividend Cafe now reaches roughly 35,000 subscribers organically, but he is clear that attracting prospective clients was only half of the equation. The firm continually invested in the people, capabilities, and services necessary to deliver on what the content promised. That philosophy extended to how David structured the business. He chose to keep functions that created what Louis describes as “surplus value” inside the firm while relying on Hightower for areas such as supervision, regulatory support, and technology. At the same time, David resisted the temptation to maximize current margins, instead investing in advisor capacity, planning, tax, investment management, family office capabilities, and infrastructure. The result was a business with significant organic growth and enterprise value. Now the story enters its transact phase. After years of operating within Hightower’s ecosystem, David agreed to sell The Bahnsen Group to Hightower. Yet the transaction is less an endpoint than another evolution of the model: Hightower becomes owner while David retains substantial operating autonomy and gains resources to professionalize the firm further and supplement its organic growth with carefully selected acquisitions. It’s the full Build, Grow & Transact arc—and an example of what can happen when independence is treated as the beginning of building a business rather than the destination. Topics Covered How The Bahnsen Group grew from $600mm to $10.5B Building an organic growth engine through content and thought leadership Why attracting clients is only the beginning of sustainable growth Reinvesting profits to build long-term enterprise value Creating advisor capacity without sacrificing the client relationship Deciding what capabilities to own versus outsource Why maximizing margins can limit the business you ultimately build The evolution of David’s relationship with Hightower Why Hightower became the natural buyer of The Bahnsen Group Preserving autonomy and continuity after a transaction Balancing organic growth with future acquisitions Why independence can be a starting point rather than an end goal > Download a transcript of this episode… Listen and Learn Highlights for Advisors Why freedom – not dissatisfaction – drove the breakaway. [04:44] David explains why he left Morgan Stanley despite being successful and well served there. The appeal was ownership: the ability to control how the business operated, how clients were served, and what the firm could ultimately become. How authentic content became an organic growth engine. [09:34] What began as written market updates during the 2008 financial crisis eventually evolved into Dividend Cafe, books, television, podcasts, and other thought leadership. David explains why the content works precisely because attracting clients was never its primary purpose. Why attracting clients isn’t enough. [15:59] A strong content engine can create interest, but the business still needs to deliver. David describes the continual investment in planners, tax capabilities, investment management, family office services, and client experience that allowed the firm to retain and serve the clients its content attracted. Knowing what creates “surplus value.” [22:03] David and Louis discuss the importance of identifying what a firm does exceptionally well and what is better handled by an outside partner. For The Bahnsen Group, that meant keeping investment management, business development, branding, and the client experience close while outsourcing functions such as supervision, regulatory support, and technology. Why maximizing income and building enterprise value are different objectives. [25:08–35:26] David explains why he has continually reinvested in the firm rather than optimizing margins, while Louis connects that philosophy to a recurring Build, Grow & Transact theme: owners willing to sacrifice some current income can create capacity, growth, and greater enterprise value over time. How the advisor role changes in a scalable enterprise. [29:15] With advisors limited to roughly 80 households, The Bahnsen Group surrounds them with planning, tax, estate, operations, marketing, content, and business development resources so they can concentrate on client relationships. David also explains why he believes the industry has more of an “opening business” problem than a closing problem. Why Hightower became the buyer. [37:09] David wasn’t looking to sell. He explains why maintaining control over the brand, P&L, hiring, strategy, and business was non-negotiable—and how Hightower structured a transaction that preserved that autonomy while adding resources the firm needs for its next phase. Why inorganic growth is now entering the picture. [44:01] At $10.5B, the law of large numbers changes what 30% growth requires. David explains why acquisitions will become a supplement to—not a replacement for—the firm’s organic growth engine, with cultural fit playing a critical role in the strategy. Why independence was always the beginning. [50:51] David never viewed breaking away as the achievement itself. Independence gave him the ability to build the business he envisioned, and he now sees the Hightower transaction as the beginning of another phase of that journey. Key Takeaways Organic growth is more than business development. The Bahnsen Group’s content creates awareness and opportunity, but its growth has been sustained by building the capabilities necessary to deliver an increasingly sophisticated client experience. Enterprise value often requires sacrificing current income. Hiring ahead of need, expanding services, creating capacity, and investing in infrastructure may compress margins today while building a stronger and more valuable business over time. Scale should support relationships, not replace them. David rejects the idea that client relationships themselves can be scaled indefinitely. Instead, the firm scales the resources surrounding its advisors so those advisors can remain focused on clients. Outsourcing can be a strategic advantage. The goal is not necessarily to own every capability. David’s approach is to retain the functions where the firm has passion, expertise, or differentiation and leverage outside scale for others. The right transaction can preserve what already works. David’s decision to sell was contingent on maintaining meaningful control over the brand, strategy, P&L, and operating model rather than changing the formula that created the firm’s growth. Organic and inorganic growth don’t have to be competing strategies. The next phase will combine The Bahnsen Group’s existing organic engine with selective acquisitions designed to add scale without creating a collection of disconnected businesses. Independence is a means, not necessarily an end. The larger lesson from David’s story is that independence created the freedom to build. What mattered afterward was how that freedom was used. https://youtu.be/_s8MFJtrbS0 Quotable Moments “I was very intoxicated by the idea of freedom.” — David Bahnsen [04:44] “Relationships don’t scale.” — David Bahnsen [29:15] “Twenty cents of something big is a lot more than 40% of something small.” — David Bahnsen [33:31] “I did not want to go to independence as an ending point. It was a beginning.” — David Bahnsen [50:51] FAQs How did The Bahnsen Group grow from $600mm to $10.5B? The firm’s growth was overwhelmingly organic. David attributes much of the business development engine to original content and thought leadership, supported by continual investment in advisors, planning, tax, investment management, family office capabilities, and the broader client experience. How did content creation contribute to The Bahnsen Group’s growth? David began writing regular market commentary during the 2008 financial crisis. After becoming independent, he developed that work into Dividend Cafe and expanded into books, television, video, and podcasts. Dividend Cafe now has approximately 35,000 subscribers, which David says were acquired organically. Why does David Bahnsen believe in reinvesting in a wealth management business? Rather than maximizing current profit margins, David has invested in people and capabilities when he believes they will improve the client experience or create a better environment for advisors. His philosophy favors building a larger, more durable enterprise over extracting the maximum amount of current income. Why did David Bahnsen sell The Bahnsen Group to Hightower? David says he was not actively looking to sell. The transaction became attractive once Hightower was willing to preserve the firm’s autonomy while providing additional resources in areas including HR, technology, AI, supervision, and future inorganic growth. Will The Bahnsen Group continue to operate independently after the Hightower transaction? According to David, the firm will operate as a wholly owned independent subsidiary. He expects to retain authority over the P&L, hiring and firing, strategy, branding, and other core aspects of the business while drawing more extensively on Hightower’s resources. How will The Bahnsen Group grow after the Hightower transaction? David expects organic growth to remain the foundation. However, as the firm becomes larger, he plans to supplement that growth with selective acquisitions and advisor additions that fit The Bahnsen Group’s system and culture rather than simply aggregating assets. What can financial advisors learn from David Bahnsen’s independence journey? His experience illustrates the importance of defining what independence is intended to accomplish. For David, leaving the wirehouse was not the destination; it provided the control necessary to invest, create, hire, build services, and develop an enterprise around the client experience. The firm’s growth was overwhelmingly organic. David attributes much of the business development engine to original content and thought leadership, supported by continual investment in advisors, planning, tax, investment management, family office capabilities, and the broader client experience. David began writing regular market commentary during the 2008 financial crisis. After becoming independent, he developed that work into Dividend Cafe and expanded into books, television, video, and podcasts. Dividend Cafe now has approximately 35,000 subscribers, which David says were acquired organically. Rather than maximizing current profit margins, David has invested in people and capabilities when he believes they will improve the client experience or create a better environment for advisors. His philosophy favors building a larger, more durable enterprise over extracting the maximum amount of current income. David says he was not actively looking to sell. The transaction became attractive once Hightower was willing to preserve the firm’s autonomy while providing additional resources in areas including HR, technology, AI, supervision, and future inorganic growth. According to David, the firm will operate as a wholly owned independent subsidiary. He expects to retain authority over the P&L, hiring and firing, strategy, branding, and other core aspects of the business while drawing more extensively on Hightower’s resources. David expects organic growth to remain the foundation. However, as the firm becomes larger, he plans to supplement that growth with selective acquisitions and advisor additions that fit The Bahnsen Group’s system and culture rather than simply aggregating assets. His experience illustrates the importance of defining what independence is intended to accomplish. For David, leaving the wirehouse was not the destination; it provided the control necessary to invest, create, hire, build services, and develop an enterprise around the client experience. Related Resources The RIA Builder’s Blueprint How the Freedom to Communicate During a Crisis and Beyond Translated to 4x Growth for this ex-Morgan Stanley Team Mentioned in This Episode Dividend Café The Bahnsen Group Hightower David L. Bahnsen Founder, Managing Partner, and Chief Investment Officer David L. Bahnsen is the founder, Managing Partner, and Chief Investment Officer of The Bahnsen Group, a national private wealth management firm with offices in Newport Beach, New York City, Bend, Nashville, Minneapolis, Austin, Phoenix, West Palm Beach, Dallas, and Grand Rapids, managing over $10 billion in client assets. Prior to launching The Bahnsen Group, he spent eight years as a Managing Director at Morgan Stanley and six years as a Vice President at UBS. He is consistently named one of the top financial advisors in America by Barron’s, Forbes, and the Financial Times. He is a frequent guest on CNBC, Bloomberg, Fox News, and Fox Business, and is a regular contributor to National Review. He hosts the popular weekly podcast, Capital Record, dedicated to a defense of free enterprise and capital markets. He writes a weekly macro commentary at dividendcafe.com. David is a founding Trustee for Pacifica Christian High School of Orange County and serves on the Board of Directors for the Acton Institute, National Review, and Hightower Advisors. He is the author of several best-selling books including Crisis of Responsibility: Our Cultural Addiction to Blame and How You Can Cure It (2018), There’s No Free Lunch: 250 Economic Truths (2021), and Full-Time: Work and the Meaning of Life (2024). His newest book, Profit from the Profit: The Past, Present & Future of Dividend Growth Investing, was released in August 2026. David’s true passions include anything related to USC football, the financial markets, and politics. His ultimate passions are his wife of 24 years, Joleen, their children, Mitchell, Sadie, and Graham, and the life they’ve created together on both coasts. NOTE: The views and opinions expressed by the guests on this podcast are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Diamond Consultants. Neither Diamond Consultants nor the guests on this podcast are compensated in any way for their participation. View the transcript of this episode… Build, Grow & Transact: David Bahnsen on Building a $10.5B Business Worth Selling A conversation with Louis Diamond and David Bahnsen, Founder & Managing Partner of The Bahnsen Group. Louis Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is Build, Grow & Transact: David Bahnsen on Building a $10.5B Business Worth Selling. It’s a conversation with the founder and managing partner of the Bahnsen Group. I’m Louis Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education-driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual Advisor Transition Report. It’s the award-winning, data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Louis Diamond: There’s a big difference between breaking away to create a better version of the business you already have and breaking away because you see an entirely different business you want to build. And I think that distinction becomes even more important as we look at what creates real enterprise value in the wealth management industry today. My guest, David Bahnsen, is a pretty remarkable example. David first joined us in April of 2020, five years after leaving Morgan Stanley with eight people and 600 million in assets. At that time, the Bahnsen Group had grown to roughly two billion. Today, it’s a $10.5 billion business with more than 100 people and 13 offices across the country. Perhaps the most interesting part of that growth story is that virtually all of it has been organic. David didn’t build the firm by buying AUM. He built it by creating an authentic voice, an incredibly effective content engine, investing heavily back into the business, adding services clients actually wanted, and being very deliberate about what his team should own versus what was better outsourced. There’s a lot in that playbook for any advisor who wants to build a business with real enterprise value. But David’s story also gives us something we often don’t get to examine, the full build, grow, and transact arc. For more than a decade, Hightower went from employer to service provider while David maintained ownership and control of the business. Now, the Bahnsen Group is being sold to Hightower, giving David additional resources to pursue the next stage of growth while preserving much of what made the firm successful in the first place. So we get into the decisions behind that extraordinary organic growth, why maximizing current income can work against building long-term enterprise value, how David thinks about content, clients, and scale, and ultimately why someone who was once intoxicated by the idea of freedom decided the next right move was to transact. It’s a great case study in what can happen when independence becomes a starting point rather than the destination. So let’s get to it. David, thank you for coming on our show again. David Bahnsen: Well, it’s wonderful to be back with you. I love listening to the show every week. Louis Diamond: Oh, there you go. Just flattering us now. So for anyone who probably, myself included, doesn’t remember the last time you were on our show, it was April of 2020, a time warp into a crazy time. It was the five-year anniversary of your breakaway in the very, very beginning of the pandemic. Then you still had an amazing business, two billion in assets. But for listeners who may have missed it, and even just to catch us up, can you give us the quick version of your origin story of leaving Morgan Stanley in 2015 with 600 million and eight people and why you did it, just the speed round of compressing a stressful and very important time in your business arc? David Bahnsen: So I was one of those people that in an almost cliche, typical way, the types of folks that your business deals with all the time, left because I wanted independence. I wasn’t unhappy at Morgan Stanley. I wasn’t in need of any particular change, but I was very intoxicated by the idea of freedom and became very committed to the idea that if I were going to run my own business, I needed to run my own business. It started in 2014. We made our official exit in early 2015. And as you said, there were eight people, all of which were folks on my team at Morgan Stanley and 600 million of client assets, and we basically moved 100% of that. When I was on the podcast, April 2020, it’s funny when you were saying that, I can visualize myself at my home office at that point in time in Southern California recording this. And we would’ve been our five-year anniversary, couple billion, so we had a little bit over tripled. We probably had, if I remember correctly at that time, 25, 30 employees. And it’s interesting the linear arc of it, because you fast-forward now, we’re at 10.5 billion and 106 employees. And so it’s just proportionate, the AUM and the headcount and the time gone by, it’s been a very nice, steady arc. But I really loved the idea of being independent. I turned 40 years old in 2014 when I began the extensive due diligence that led to me leaving Morgan Stanley. And it really was that moment that I said, “If I’m going to stay as a corner office guy at a wirehouse, I will stay at Morgan Stanley forever.” I had no issues there. My manager at the time is still, to this day, my best friend in the world. We’re like brothers. I just dedicated my new book to him. I wasn’t unhappy with Morgan. I just liked the idea of having my own business and haven’t looked back since. Louis Diamond: Amazing. Seems like it was probably a pretty good move based upon what you shared, but I think it’s an interesting perspective because I feel like I’m starting to see that more and more is the profile of the advisor who doesn’t have these intense pain points and is relatively well served, is going to be successful, knows how to operate at their firm, but they just want something more. There’s an intangible that staying isn’t going to solve for them. For many, it’s being a business owner, like the path you took. For others it’s, hey, I just want to be recharged. I don’t want to be static. I want something different. I want to monetize. I want to work in a bit of a different way. I think you’re early on that trend, to be honest with you. You were probably right in the middle, even probably even the beginning innings of the independent movement, and I am very excited to dig into how you got from 600 million in 2015 to over 10.5 billion, 11-ish years later. So let’s jump to today, and we’ll spend some time going through dissecting that growth. But today, like you said, 10 and a half billion under management, 100 plus people, 13 offices, including Santa Barbara where you just opened, but Newport Beach, New York City, Nashville, Tennessee, Palm Beach. It’s a real national firm. And I read that you’ve grown over 30% organically over the last decade. So when you look at the firm now versus 2015, what stands out the most? Let’s really dive into that. David Bahnsen: Well, a lot of this is where we’re going to end up going later in the conversation with where I see the next iteration of the company. But when you talk about the last 10 years, it has been the textbook definition of organic growth. There are 13 offices open and zero of them came by acquisition or merger or purchase. We’ve hired two or three advisors out of our 26 advisors that had a little bit of a book, but I mean under 100 million. We never paid for it. I’m talking about hiring people. But you’re looking at an organic story, and I am proud of that, but I also recognize that it wasn’t intentional. And what I mean by that is I didn’t have this strategy in 2014, ’15 where I said, if I can just go independent, I have this evil genius behind me that is going to drive a mousetrap that will get me up to 10.5 Billion. I’ve been as surprised, as many outside observers, but I have a lot of gratitude for it. I understand now why it has worked, and I think that there are people inside of our business that are a little more qualified to understand how the business works than people who are outside of it. Your consultants and professional investors are very smart at what they do, but they don’t necessarily always understand that advisor-client dynamic. And I get why we’ve been successful with it. But I also don’t want to take credit for it as if it were this master strategy. We just tried things and those things that worked, we kept doing more of, and this is where we are. A lot of it, and I spoke to Mindy about this six years ago, it’s been content creation, thought leadership, and the voice that, much to my surprise, has attracted people and never doing it for the purpose of attracting people. This very natural and sincere delivery of a belief system about markets, about the economy, about the world around us, I share things sometimes about my faith, politics in a public square. I’m on television, this podcast. And then the major driver is the written word, which some people might be shocked to hear as we’re talking about a podcast still even exists. But my weekly Dividend Cafe, which is my weekly market commentary, is up to 35,000 subscribers, 100% organic. We’ve never done anything to get any subscribers. And our video and our podcast and everything, the books I write, the television hits, they all have their audience. But most of it goes through that written word. That’s where I get to connect with people that if they like me, they may end up becoming a client. And if they don’t, they won’t, but that’s really been our story though. Louis Diamond: That’s absolutely amazing. There’s so much to unpack there. That amount of growth without anything inorganic, especially the way this industry is going, I don’t think I’ve ever heard that before. That’s amazing in and of itself. But just the way you can track back your meteoric rise to content creation, I think for many listening, it’s either, “Oh my God, that seems so daunting and so crazy.” Others would be like, “Well, I can’t do that, but that sounds great. Of course, he’s been able to grow because he can have an original voice.” As a firm that puts out a lot of original content, podcasts written, Mindy wrote a book, white papers, et cetera, I know the amount of work and dedication and commitment it takes to stick with that for so long. So if you don’t mind, can we double-click into that written word story? How did you get started with it and what’s been the arc or the growth journey? Someone who’s listening who would love to do that, where did you get started? You didn’t just all of a sudden have a book and show up on TV. How did you get started? David Bahnsen: In the truest sense of the word, I grew up loving writing. My father died in his 40s and I was only 20, but he was an intellectual, a brilliant writer, had several books, and I was a nerd in high school. Luckily, I had basketball so that I could still meet a girl here and there and have friends on the team. But I mean, if it were up to me, I would’ve been home reading books and writing papers, and I would turn in extra credit papers more than I would study for a test because I loved writing. So the written thing was there. I don’t know if I was ever good at it or not, but I know I loved doing it, and I would credit my late father with the early seeds of that. When the financial crisis happened in September, the actual week of Lehman’s bankruptcy, September of ’08, about three, four days later, Morgan Stanley’s credit default swaps were blowing out, and now it was not just the market was crashing every day. And of course at that point, Merrill had gone down, AIG had gone down. We were in this cascade, and everybody who lived through it remembers it all well. I remember every detail of it like it were yesterday. But all that happened was once I got my 80th call about what the hell was going on with Morgan, I decided to write up a piece, not send it to compliance for approval and send it out to everyone. And if the firm was at risk of not making it for another day, I wasn’t especially worried about compliance getting mad at me at the time. And I did that, and then a couple days later did it again, just broad update on everything going on, and I never stopped doing it. That’s what it was, just every Friday since September 2008. And then when we left Morgan, at some point along the way I started getting compliance approval and getting a bit more of an audience. We had hundreds of clients that were reading it, and we’d have a few guests that would ask to be signed up as clients were forwarding it around, but that was it. It didn’t have a website, it didn’t have a subscribe feature, it wasn’t a real blog or anything like that. So then in going independent, I was able to incubate it, and we branded it as Dividend Cafe. We’re Dividend Growth investors at my firm. So we put a brand around it. We had a website, and I think we started a podcast and video that was becoming a very large medium around the mid-tens as well, and so we added that shortly later, but it was just because I had the freedom to do it. And then I did do some hit on CNBC like Asia or CNBC World or something. It wasn’t anything with a big audience, but then we sent the clip to someone at Fox and they really liked it, and then they had me, and then I started getting invited more regularly. So now the TV thing was happening, and I always say that TV can be a really good thing for a very small number of people. Obviously, Josh Brown has been incredibly successful with it. He’s very good at it, and it’s done okay. It’s done well for me, but it’s different than people think. You do not go on TV and then get done and all of a sudden the phone rang and someone said, “I saw you. You’re so handsome. I want you to be my advisor.” What it does is it might drive them to other content. It might drive them to the internet where they’re going to find other things about you. And if my name was David Johnson instead of David Bahnsen, I think I would’ve got lost in the SEO and nothing would’ve come of it. I really believe that. But it enabled some people that liked what they heard on TV to start following me in other more substantive and perpetual mediums. And then in 2017, I wrote a book that I wouldn’t have been able to write at Morgan Stanley. I had very strong opinions about the origins of the financial crisis. And I did not believe the left-wing narrative that it was caused by unfettered markets, and I didn’t really believe the right-wing narrative entirely either that it was exclusively caused by government intervention. I believed that all of those things were true but were missing this cultural and moral component about Main Street. I wrote a book on it and I thought there might be 200 clients of my firm that would read it, and it ended up being a bestseller, and that created more television invitations and just to a slightly larger audience. And at this point now, I realized that all of these things were dovetailed together, content, the mediums, coming to Dividend Cafe, coming to an authentic point of view about markets. And then, and this is the thing that is so important because of what you do and do so well in your business and within the kind of practitioners that listen, it wasn’t enough to have a mousetrap that drew people to us. We had to keep them. We had to deliver an advisory experience, and so we were just relentlessly reinvesting back in the business, adding planners, adding tax, adding more investment sophistication, family office, just improving our business, and that’s why we’ve added so much to headcount because we have just constantly wanted to really be what we were attracting people to. Louis Diamond: It’s amazing. The key themes I heard there, there’s a lot, but is it’s not one thing that works. It’s a coordinated strategy. I can attest to that for the content work that we do. There isn’t one single point of growth that comes from content creation. It’s everything working together. You don’t know, especially in this day and age, how people consume information or how a message gets across to them, whether they’re a reader, whether they find you in AI, whether they watch video, whether they saw CNBC in their barbershop. So I think that’s absolutely amazing, and congratulations. Let’s talk a little bit about your breakaway setup, if you will. So when you broke in 2015, you signed on with Hightower, but in a bit of a different way, certainly different than today. You paid Hightower an override on your revenue, or basis points and assets, to be on their platform. But you owned 100% of your business, ran your own P&L, and they provided certain services to you. Thinking back to 2015, and then even up until your recent decision to sell to Hightower, why did you structure it that way rather than under their brand or as an employee or even just having your own RIA, especially given your size and scale? David Bahnsen: There’s actually one piece missing there. You may not have known, but I think is important to the story. When we came in 2015, we were employees and they had a 50/50 net model, and we joined in that capacity. And then when they recapped in 2017, brought a new investor on, eventually changed CEO about a year later, at that point, we were growing. I felt very comfortable with the independent space. I now knew what I didn’t know. I knew what I thought they did well, and I knew what I thought we could do well, and I took advantage of that moment to say, “Guys, I need to be on my own. We need to run our own firm, our own finances, our own payroll, our own brand.” And what the investors wanted at that time was some sort of affiliation that they could count on and not be vulnerable, but I didn’t want to sell and I wanted full control. So I got control, much better control than I had had in my first couple years, and they got a extension of agreement of these services that they could feel good I was going to be a part of their ecosystem. And the cash flows were pretty meaningful as we grew from, at that point, a billion to over 10 billion, and we became obviously a very meaningful contributor to their earnings and revenues. And the CEO who came in was the second CEO in the history of the company. And they now have a third, but that individual, Bob Oros, I knew well because he had been at Fidelity when I chose Fidelity as our primary custodian. Bob and I got along very well. And so over the years, there’d be things that we had impediments that we had to work through, and we worked through them just like adults, like businessmen and women and got stuff done. So it was a good relationship. But we were really quite independent. Very few of my people that worked at Bahnsen Group even knew who Hightower was because we had our own brand, we had our own investment process, the HR, the payroll. And unlike a lot of the other platform teams, they didn’t have too many platform teams, but ours, the accounts payable were massive. I mean, we had to have a whole finance department just because of our growth. So it became a difficult thing for them at this stage to have such a meaningful company within their ecosystem not aligned and not harmonized within the economic model of the rest of the firm. But I would say that decision for 2017 until this year, I don’t regret it at all. Hightower doesn’t regret it at all. They benefited immensely from this growth we’ve gone through, and I very much desired that freedom. Look, if I’m being very candid, Louis, you brought up why didn’t go on my own ADV? At the time in ’14 and ’15, I didn’t know enough. I didn’t understand. And I met with Focus, I met with Dynasty, I met with some others, and you just meet with different people, hear the stories, and the one I went with was Hightower, and there’s pros and cons to all the models. It’s one of the things I wasn’t joking at the beginning. I listen to your guys’ show every week. I’m a sucker for everything happening in our industry. I hear the stories of different successful advisors, and every one of them resonate with me in one way. There might be nine ways it doesn’t resonate, but one way that does because there’s always something that each person’s looking for that some of us can connect with. And at the time, I didn’t know what I didn’t know, but I felt good about the Hightower story, went in that path, and I would argue that we got the best of all worlds in that 2017 to 2026 story because we really got to function independently. We were under their corporate RIA, but other than that, felt very independent. And that’s a testimony to Hightower that they honored that autonomy, but I think it gave me the entrepreneurial thing I needed, and I’m grateful for it. Louis Diamond: Fantastic. So let’s say from the 2017 to 2026 timeframe when you decided to finally sell to Hightower, how did you weigh the leverage that outsourcing certain things provided your business versus paying a fee, obviously, more than what it cost Hightower and not having complete and utter control over your business? How do you track that to your growth, if at all? David Bahnsen: The criteria was always anything we like doing or are good at doing, we’re going to do it, whether Hightower offers it or not. So for example, I’m sitting here in a beautiful office. We have the 31st floor of a building on 54th Street and 6th Avenue, and Hightower has a whole facilities department. We’ve done 13 office leases with no involvement from their facilities department because my wife loves designing the offices. She’s an interior designer. My team loved picking our own locations. I didn’t find negotiating with a broker all that hard. So we were able to do it, we liked it, so we did it. But then the supervision side, the regulatory side, and candidly, a lot of the technology side, which is where some of our talk is about to go in terms of the new transaction, those things I felt more comfortable outsourcing to Hightower who had entire departments and resources geared towards it. And we would do them if we had to, but we weren’t passionate about it. I didn’t want to go understand all the nooks and crannies of the regulatory apparatus. So that was part of their ecosystem, and we were happy to utilize their services there. Investing money, financial facilities, the business development mousetrap we built, those things we were good at, and so we held onto that, and that’s how we viewed the division of labor. Every firm, RIA, IBD, a wire, W, it doesn’t matter. Everyone who optimizes this challenge of doing what you like and not doing what you don’t like is going to grow. It’s hard to do. It’s easier said than done, but that’s the challenge right there. Louis Diamond: I absolutely love that. I think it’s so true, knowing what’s actually going to add surplus value relative to the amount of time you’re doing versus what’s commoditized or back of house or isn’t something that lights you up. Because there’s plenty of RIAs that I’ve interviewed or that I know where they enjoy building technology, they like designing their own compliance organization, and to them, that’s their superpower. That’s what makes them different. For you, it sounds like it was very clear. You knew exactly what you wanted to do. As long as you’re able to still do it, you’re very comfortable with outsourcing certain things that would’ve been a distraction or something that you and your team weren’t world-class at. I want to talk a little bit about some of the deliberate choices you made to take the business from, I would assume it was you as the rainmaker, and now you said you have over 25 advisors. So just thinking about hiring, structuring the business, investing in the business and platform, because I’m sure you’ve had the temptation, maybe not because you’re a business builder, but I think a lot of people love, “Hey, I can make a ton of money if I don’t make that second, third, 125th hire, and instead I just take cash flow. I don’t necessarily need this person. I can make more money or distribute more to my partners.” So I’d love to hear a little bit about some of the deliberate choices you made on hiring and investing in your business. David Bahnsen: There’s two things that I am very hesitant to take credit for, even though they’re true. You had mentioned before when we left in 2014 that we were early innings of wirehouse defections to the independent movement. I was early, but I wasn’t a first inning guy. The real trailblazers were going in 2006, 2007, 2009. 2014 is a lot earlier than those that have gone in the last two or three years, but I was like a third or fourth inning guy, and I don’t deserve credit to be a first inning guy. The other issue is that I reinvest in the business constantly and have not been greedy about maximizing all the margin, but that is easy to say once you’ve already scaled the business, right? You’re already in a place where things are going very well, and then from there, deciding you just really want to run the business the way you want to run it. It’s not as selfless a decision as people may think. It was a luxury. And at the same time, I cannot tell you how bizarre I think it is when people are focusing on maximizing margin versus running the business that they want to have. It’s a high-margin business. There is not a lot of operating leverage in it. More or less, not completely, but more or less expenses go up in proportion to revenue. Particularly for us opening new offices and hiring a lot of new people, our biggest overhead far and away is people. And we started an ETF a couple years ago and I got a chance to learn the polar opposite where my business has tons of pricing power and very little operating leverage and asset management has unbelievable operating leverage. I basically have zero dollars of expenses on my next dollar of revenue, but no pricing power. Louis Diamond: So interesting. David Bahnsen: Yeah. I mean, it really is just two different business models. When we have hired more people, we’ve always done it based on are we going to serve our clients better and enjoy running our business better with these people? We don’t want wasteful positions, but we want the maximum optimization for how to service clients and how to give advisors an ecosystem to function in. So a one-to-one operations to advisor, having planners that are not the client-facing advisor themselves, but are devoted to the behind the scenes planning process. Having a full tax department that does not provide tax services to non-wealth clients, that is only there, a robust tax consulting, tax preparation, tax advisory arm to drive a better client experience for us. These things all erode at margin, and I wouldn’t do it any other way. And the biggest thing, by the way, is the investment management, because then you’re not just talking about profit margin. We’re talking about time. I am a 3:45 AM guy every day because we’re inside markets. We have analysts, traders, investment folks. I think it’s something like 10 or 11 people on the org chart. It costs me millions of dollars a year for us to manage money in-house. There’s no justification for that other than it’s what we want to do, what we believe in. And those that have a outsourced Vanguard DFA-type model, I have no criticism of it in the world, but it just wasn’t us, and so we had to do what we liked doing. Louis Diamond: Yep. And once again, the authenticity shines through. Can we talk a little bit about the financial advice part of the business? I would assume when you’re at Morgan Stanley, you were probably the driver of growth, you were serving personally probably every client or just about all of them. Today, with 10 and a half billion, 25 advisors, just the immense scale of the organization, how do advisors advise? Are you still providing financial advice to clients directly? Are you more of just the CEO, the rainmaker, the strategist? I mean, how do you think about, I guess, allocating clients to your advisors? How have you grown your capacity for financial advice? David Bahnsen: So our leverage is entirely limited by my ability to find like-minded advisors who can go deliver our client experience and be in relationship to clients. It’s why I’m not a big believer in this notion of scalability. I think technology helps scale. I think there’s all kinds of processes you can do more efficiently, but it’s a relationship business and relationships don’t scale. And we have an internal policy philosophy preference, if you will, that no advisor will cover more than 80 households. And so for us to continue growing at the number of households, number of AUM, and therefore number of revenues, all those numbers, of course, have some proportionate relationship with one another, we have to have the advisors to do it. And so as we find advisors that can not drool on themselves and be professionals and deliver an experience to clients, we want them to be generalists. We want them to be very good at what they do, but we don’t want them entering trades. We don’t want them doing their own operations work. We don’t want them having to pick stocks. We’re providing this ecosystem of the tax, the planning, the estate, the operations, the content, the marketing, and the biz dev. They don’t have to go try to rainmake at their kid’s soccer game or join the chamber of commerce or things like that. That we believe we have enough internal biz dev opportunity that what they need to do is cultivate the relationships with the prospective clients we give them. They do have to close that business, but our industry, for all of the talk about this, people diagnose it wrong. We do not have a problem with closing business in our industry. We have a problem with opening business. And so the sourcing is the issue. And for whatever reason, it’s a mystery to me, it’s been a mystery for 27 years, I’ve been pretty good at sourcing business. And so we can share that with our advisors and then expect them to, their job when they wake up and go to bed and everything in between is to be in relationship with clients. Louis Diamond: If I think about, just think of 20 highly successful RIAs and think of some of the biggest and best names in the space, I think a critical connection point or commonality for all those firms is they’ve somehow figured out lead flow or some mechanism or capacity to bring in clients for their advisors. To me, that’s the truly only scalable way to keep adding advisors and growing a business is if there’s enough inbound lead flow that’s cultivated or created by the firm to really feed all the different advisors, and it’s not snap our fingers and it happens. But if you compare that to many other models, the wirehouse model where it’s all on the advisors to go out and find clients, that’s great. And if you find some amazing rainmakers, amazing, and it’s additive, et cetera, but you eventually hit a ceiling because it’s hard to find advisors who have that knack. You’re not bringing in the ideal client every time, and it’s an unpredictable way to grow. So I think I wouldn’t gloss over the fact that you’ve been able to create enough inbound traffic or lead flow through all of your content and thought leadership that you’re able to sustain that type of model. Because it is the best way to grow a business is keep your advisors focused on just being advisors, solve for organic growth, solve for the other things they have to do. And then when you open up a new market or hire an advisor, boom, you got capacity, you got someone trained up, and it’s predictable, your close rate and your ability to scale it from there. So I’ll get off my soapbox, but I think that’s such an important element of the biggest and best and most valuable firms in our industry today. David Bahnsen: I agree with you a thousand percent. And even if you put numbers around it, somebody who has to go make their own rain and service the client, they will expect, if you use wirehouse-like grids around it, this is just round numbers, I know you could turn a knob a little bit, but I view the business as more or less it costs something in the range of 40 cents of a dollar revenue to run the business. There’s 20 cents available to the owner, 20 cents to the person who makes rain and 20 cents to the person servicing the client. It’s back of napkin math. If you are a wirehouse advisor, you’re making the rain and servicing the client, you’re getting two of the 20 cents, you’re getting 40 cents, let’s say. And if you’re the person who owns the business and makes the rain and is the advisor, you can make 60 cents on the dollar. That’s a wonderful margin, and you cap out at a certain level where you just cannot grow any further. I would rather make 20 cents on where we are now. My advisors would rather make 20 cents on where they are because 20 cents of something big is a lot more than 40% of something small. And again, and my numbers are, I’m rounding, but you get the idea. That’s really the kind of business model we’ve done here. Louis Diamond: I think it’s brilliant. And some would argue about the percentages and would say, oh, it costs 40 cents to 30 cents to run a business and we have a small team, but I think philosophically that’s exactly right. And I think something you said too, which is there’s been a common thread in our “Build, Grow, Transact” series. You think about Jason Fertitta of Americana Partners or Matt Kilgroe from Cyndeo and many others that we’ve had or will have, it’s really playing the long game. No one we’ve had on the show is optimizing for how much money can I make this year, next year or the year after. It’s the intentional decisions to invest in capacity, invest in growth, and by choice take less as the owner of the business, but doing it because what you’re building is enterprise value that will sell at a dramatic multiple of that growth and have room to run. So I think that’s the big thing is, again, it sounds easy, it sounds great, but it’s not an easy decision to say, “Hey, I’m going to make less money today and over the next few years because I want to hire the next person or invest in an organic growth funnel.” That’s discipline, for sure. But I think it’s a great takeaway for anyone listening is play the long game, invest where it makes sense, and the riches will follow you later. They don’t have to follow you today or tomorrow. David Bahnsen: And it’s a whole business of playing the long game, not only in the value creation and enterprise value of being independent. But even for wirehouse advisors, I remember back as I was entering the business, that debate about fee-based business versus transactional, and all it was, are you going to play the long game or get more money quickly? There’s temptations in both ways. There’s goals, there’s overhead, reality. Anyone who played the long game in that story from 30 years ago benefited immensely. And now you see it, of course, in what we’re talking about here, playing the long game in the way you run your business has just been the smartest thing anybody could do. Louis Diamond: Absolutely. Especially in this industry where each new client that’s brought on, there’s a lifetime value of a client. That success compounds with market appreciation, with them adding new monies, and then ultimately they’re going to give you referrals hopefully. And then over time, that’s where the real money is. It’s the compounding nature of doing the next right thing rather than, we’ll say, taking a shortcut or not making that investment in the business. I have a ton more questions for you on this topic, but I want to spend enough time on your important decision to sell the business, sell the Bahnsen Group to Hightower in April of 2026. So after more than a decade of being an employee of Hightower, being affiliated with them but really owning your own business, you decided to not just sell the business, but to sell it to the very platform that you’re operating on. So can you just talk about that decision? Why was 2026 the right time? Why did you decide to stay with Hightower rather than any of the other 100 acquirers or a random private equity firm that would love to buy a business that’s growing 30% per year? David Bahnsen: It’s interesting to think about as our deal gets ready to close here at the end of September, if I had gone out and run a process, if I was looking to sell, would I have been interested in conversations with others? And I don’t know the answer to that because I wasn’t looking to sell. There was nothing broken, in my mind, in what we were doing. But when Hightower and her investors came to me, the entire conversation centered not around what we needed and wanted to be a seller, but on what we didn’t want or couldn’t have. And I’ll share the story because I haven’t shared it publicly with anyone. As we were having conversations about a variety of things in the relationship between Hightower and the Bahnsen Group and Hightower’s investor and so forth, there were a couple of different meetings and things and we ended up having a pretty significant meeting in person in their conference rooms here in Midtown. And I’ve had seven eye surgeries, and I have challenges with my eyes and there are all these numbers up on a screen in the conference room. I couldn’t see any of them. And it occurred to me that there was an offer on the screen they wanted to buy the business. We had not discussed that. And I turned to the folks and said, “I don’t really know exactly what it says, but I just want to make something very clear to save time and drive our conversation constructively. There’s no amount of money that I would sell for if I can’t be fully in charge of what we’re doing. Our brand, our business, our autonomy is what I care most about. If there’s a way to have that, protect it, enhance it and do a commercial transaction, I’m open to it.” And I didn’t really think that would be possible, but I will say to their credit, they did not want to interfere with that autonomy and what they believe to be a successful formula inside our company at all. And so while they’re doing a lot right now to build their Hightower Signature Wealth brand, both internally and externally, and are coming up on $50 billion of assets that they’ll have moved onto that platform in trying to create more centralization and consolidation, which I think has a lot of commercial rationalization behind it, what they’re looking to do with the Bahnsen Group is have a wholly owned independent subsidiary where I still have plenary authority to run the business, control of the P&L, hiring and firing, strategy, branding, and yet the resources of Hightower at my disposal more now in the HR front. That gets a little trickier with 106 people that will soon be 150 than it was when it was 20. I’m committed, Louis, to knowing every one of my employees’ names forever and it’s getting harder, but luckily I have a pretty good memory. But the technology side, the AI moment, the way in which a tech stack all intersects, I hate this stuff. And they not only are good at it and like it, but are heavily invested in it. And so it felt to me like if they’re really going to allow me to continue running this and have that control of the P&L, it could be best of all worlds and certainly very value additive to the enterprise of Hightower. And that’s what we worked a few months to put together and everybody is really pleased with the outcome. Louis Diamond: Amazing. I mean it’s an interesting shift in the way I’m seeing a lot of these platforms, that they start off as a fee-for-service affiliation platform and then over time they morph to being buyers of businesses, investors in businesses. And Hightower is definitely, they’re probably at the forefront of really completely shifting or re-identifying themself in the market, especially on buying practices. So I think it’s very interesting that you had this long-term relationship and ultimately having such an amazing business, they were the ultimate buyer of the business. David Bahnsen: And I think it’s important to say for our listeners, you know as well as I do, if we went to market, there would’ve been a lot of interested parties. Louis Diamond: That was going to be my question. David Bahnsen: The organic growth alone would’ve commanded something pretty attractive. We were under Hightower’s ADV. I not only had a positive relationship with them and a good cultural dynamic, which I wouldn’t want to risk changing, but I don’t want to re-paper the size of this business, and so it was just a non-starter. I talked to a couple investment bankers after we were already in LOI and they all said the same thing. You had your most natural buyer. It was the one you were already dating. And that’s how I feel, is if there was going to be a transaction, it made the most sense for us to do it with the one we were already partnered with. Louis Diamond: So was it like, hey, you know exactly who we’re getting in bed with because they’ve already been our partner in this business for a while, and as long as I get what I think is fair value for the business, that’s good enough? I’m sure you could have gotten a turn or two more to have 50 bids and to have the shark circling to push Hightower higher. But it sounds like for you, that was of course important, but that wasn’t the number one driver. It was more how do we preserve what we like, preserve our autonomy and do it with people that we like and trust? David Bahnsen: Yeah, that continuity, in a funny way, I did it the wrong order. I ran a process after I was already at LOI, meaning I did enough to find out, hey, did I just do a good deal or not after I’d already done the deal. And the good news is I did, but it wasn’t the way most people go about doing it. But the continuity thing is there’s always two fronts to it at our size of business. There’s the client continuity and the team. Our team is going to move the payroll from being under Bahnsen Group to Hightower, and there’s benefits and changes and things. But the clients don’t know any difference whatsoever. Custodial, the G numbers, the ADV, there’s no signature required, no negative consent required because they already were under the Hightower ADV before. So this transaction all at once allows us to go into the next iteration of our business, which I’m very excited about, and I think is a wonderful deal for Hightower and what their goals are, but we didn’t have to bother clients with it. And when we say to clients, “Nothing’s going to change,” we can actually mean it. Louis Diamond: Yeah, that’s the definition of it. You mentioned there you’re excited for this next iteration or the next chapter of the company. Can you explain that? I would imagine just continuing your strategy that’s worked so well for the last decade plus, you keep doing that, I mean, you’re going to have a 20, 25, $30 billion business over the next handful of years. So what’s the next chapter? Why change it at all? What are you thinking about? David Bahnsen: Well, it’s funny in a moment now where, first of all, I’ve went out of my way to say that we didn’t grow at all inorganically, and a lot of people have now decided that inorganic growth is a little bit less impressive than organic growth. One of the issues with the law of large numbers is growing 30% at two billion meant adding 600 million and growing 30% at 10 billion means adding three billion in a year. Louis Diamond: That’s fair. David Bahnsen: And then 3.6 billion, the exponential nature of it. And I believe that there are… I’ve never gone to a meeting with an advisor with a checkbook or with a balance sheet, and we want to find some folks that want to join us, join our system, join our culture, not merely aggregate a bunch of unified parts, but in some cases doing that with other people demographically would mean some monetization events. So I do believe that there will be some inorganic growth that we will add to our toolbox as a supplement to our core underlying strategy, which we think is industry leading organic growth. So we want to continue doing more of what we’re doing. And then just as we continue to professionalize based on our size and scale more of those things that are not passions for us, technology, supervision and HR, utilize the mousetrap Hightower has that they do well while maintaining the things that make us uniquely us, which is our branding, our business development, our investment strategy, our delivery of services to clients. I’m not naive enough to think that there won’t be some growing pains and some hiccups and whatnot, but we believe that model, all the parties are very committed to it, and we believe it’s the right model for us. Louis Diamond: Absolutely. I think what’s really cool about what you said was, one, I agree with the concept of law of large numbers. I mean, it’s a fact, right? No matter how much content you put out, it’s going to be hard to bring in 10 billion of net new assets eventually without going inorganic. But I think to me at least the big trap in the industry today is firms either completely ignoring the organic and just focusing on buying and growing that way and pointing to, oh, we grew by this amount. But what you said, which is really cool and important I think is we’re going to continue the organic side to the best of our ability. That’s not going to change. Inorganic is a supplement. It’s not the replacement. I think that’s a really important lesson or discipline that it’s the combination of the two that really builds an enterprise and builds scale. You already had your transaction, but anyone who’s weighing a transaction in the future, buyers will always value a dollar of organic growth than they would inorganic growth. So if you can hit both and you do transactions strategically, you’re not just trying to buy anyone or everyone, but you’re doing it to add the right capacity, add a new discipline, diversify the talent pool, honestly, you can’t lose. Because worst case, it’s not that successful, you still got the organic engine. Or I think knowing you it’s going to be very successful and now all you’ve done is ratcheted up what you’re able to do. So I think it’s a very smart way to look at the decision to go inorganic after all this time. David Bahnsen: Well, I appreciate that. It means a lot coming from you, and of course I agree and you would know a lot more about this than I would. I also believe that some of the things people are afraid of in going inorganic are a byproduct of people hitting the buy button that are not the ones who have to deal with the cultural integration afterwards. When you remove the skin in the game factor, anybody we choose to buy, they’re going to be people I got to have breakfast, lunch, and dinner with. And inorganic growth is a lot more successful when you care about culture than when you don’t. And we’re not planning to just care about it, but to obsess over it. So I feel very excited about it. We have a couple deals that we’ll be announcing here in the fourth quarter to kick things off. And in the meantime, it’s funny, the valuation period of my transaction ended June 30th. My deal closes September 30th, and in this quarter in between, we just had our biggest organic growth ever. So we’re already off to a great start in making money for our new owners. Louis Diamond: There we go. That’s amazing. So was for you the pivot point then the realization that in order to protect our 30% or more growth per year, that we’re going to have to supplement with acquisitions? Was that really the we’ll say the critical link that was the why now moment? Because I would imagine, I mean, given the size of your firm, you could have gotten debt to buy businesses, you could have gone and sold 10%, 20% to a PE firm or a family office. So was it really like, we really want to lean into the inorganic side? Was that what you thought Hightower, and being owned by them, would really unlock for you? David Bahnsen: That is a true statement, but even then that wasn’t true until we got over the original hump of control. That once it was clear that they authentically wanted, not like they were willing to let me run it, but they were willing to memorialize to that they valued what we had done and did not want to disrupt it. And when I became convinced that they were convinced that it was not just best for me, I mean, that’s what I cared about, but they wanted our autonomy out of self-interest because they viewed that it was best for their enterprise to let us continue running independently, that was the sine qua non of everything. And then on the other side of it, it opened up the benefits of the inorganic growth. And I also think I felt a burden to properly professionalize and scale our internal team without me working eight jobs. And I felt that there became a need for specialization in the technology supervision and HR functions that I didn’t have an interest in building in-house. We built in-house our investment, our tax, our family office, our content, all of those things, and I loved it. But these other areas, I felt like we had it good enough, but we were going to benefit from the strategic partnership with them going forward. And so all of those factors together allowed us to put this deal together. Louis Diamond: It makes complete sense. So I mean, there’s this version of your story, and you’ll probably be like, “That’s not my story, clearly.” But you broke away in 2015, you keep doing your thing, grow a couple points here or there. It compounds, you’re at two, three billion without really breaking much of a sweat. Take a lot of vacations, make a lot of money, but you did the opposite, right? You really took independence as a signal like, let’s go, let’s build something, let’s build a real company, a real business. So can you talk about basically how you thought about treating independence as the starting point rather than the terminal destination? David Bahnsen: Well, I think that your question itself, it has the answer in it. It’s so important. I mean, without us knowing each other, you’re really capturing something very biographical. I did not want to go to independence as an ending point. It was a beginning. I intend to do this the rest of my life. I was already financially comfortable, but I didn’t realize that when people talk about payouts like, oh, you’re going to have a higher margin of what you keep as an RIA than W-2 at a wire, I never even thought about that. It was purely for me the type of business I wanted to have, the way in which we went about servicing clients. I’ve said this to good friends of mine over the years. Greg Fleming ran Morgan Stanley Wealth Management at the time, and now of course is CEO of Rockefeller. One of the things the wirehouses did so well was convince me about teaming, about having a business. I’d go to Chairman’s Club every year and they would talk about you build out your team and you have your own little mini group and you’re adding a planner into this, and yet you couldn’t really do it. You couldn’t really hire and fire who you wanted. So they tantalized it. They gave me enough to know that this would be a wonderful way to run an advisory business versus the pure vertical type team that I had. And yet to go be able to pick our own furniture and do our own creative marketing work and all that, you had to be able to have your own checkbook. Independence was the start of a journey, and I really view this next phase of where we’re going as a new journey. I don’t know if I’m going to be good at doing inorganic transactions. We’ll see. But I do want to find out, and I’m determined to become good at running a 150-person company the way I think I was good at running a 30 or 40-person company. And so I’m up for that new challenge. And one thing I’ll say over 27 years from being an independent self-practitioner at PaineWebber through the Morgan Stanley years, through this last phase on our own at Bahnsen Group, it’s always been client-centric. And I just think that those advisors that somehow have that in their DNA, that if you keep everything focused on the client, the rest comes together, it does come together. Louis Diamond: Amazing. There’s been a number of episodes where that’s been a through line is if you do right by the client, that’s your North Star, you’re never really going to lose. Will you grow slower sometimes? Sure. Will it cost you money sometimes? Absolutely. But in the end, the goodwill, we’ll say the spirit, the culture of generosity, it always shines through. Think of any company, even outside of our industry, that’s been their North Star and they don’t lose. It’s brilliant. Last question for you. I think I can probably go for another four hours, but you got some content to create and some new households to bring in, so I’ll let you go after this. For an advisor who’s sitting where you were, let’s say 2012, 2013, 2014, who’s successful, growing, comfortable, they make a lot of money, but sensing that maybe there’s something missing, there’s a business to build, there’s something that’s not really charging them up the way that it used to, what’s one thing you’d tell them? David Bahnsen: You have to overcome the inertia because I think it is a universally true thing in our business that when there’s something holding them back, there’s something not right, there’s something that’s off, it’s still usually pretty good, especially in a good market. You have recurring cash flows, you make a good living, for most people, they’re probably making a better living than they ever thought they’d make doing anything else, and so to say it’s good enough is to me a hallmark of mediocrity. But to say even though it’s already good, I want it to be better. I’m going to have to go dig in to create the right ecosystem, the right apparatus, the right partnerships, the right strategic fit, whether it’s going to a new firm, whether it’s starting your own firm, whether it’s partnering with one of the aggregators or doing your own thing, I mean, there’s so many choices to walk through. But I don’t believe most people say, “Oh no, I’ve just decided where I am is the best.” I think most people decide where I am is good enough. And overcoming that inertia, you will be glad you did because there is a better world waiting when you take that step. And not only a better world for you and your family and enterprise value and cash flow, all that matters, but I’m saying a better world for your peace of mind, for your internal fulfillment of what you’re doing and for the experience you’re able to give a client. Everybody, every advisor worthy of the name should desire to optimize the ecosystem in which they work. Louis Diamond: That is absolute gold and brilliant. I couldn’t agree more. I mean, I feel like the great thing about being an advisor is even if you’re in the most captive environment, you’re the one who gets to choose. Is it good enough and does that work for me? I want to golf four days a week and this works, this checks all my boxes. Or if there’s something more, something that good enough isn’t solving for, that you have the optionality and the ability to go out and do it. And it’s not going to be easy. It’s a lot of work to transition or to build and to do something like you’re doing, but I think every advisor owes it to themself to at least test out that thesis. Is good enough really good enough or is there something better that makes me better, makes my team better, lets me serve clients better, and ultimately is going to be more fulfilling in the end? David, this has been absolutely amazing. We will definitely have you on again soon. I mean, I want to just talk to you every day because I’ve learned so much from this episode. But to me, a couple of the key themes to take away here is focusing everything on clients. It’s the compounding effect of organic growth, playing the long game, optimizing for enterprise value and building a sustainable business rather than income, and ultimately picking your partners and outsourcing, et cetera, wisely. And if you do that as the North Star, you become pretty unstoppable. So congratulations on everything. Congrats on the upcoming closing of your transaction with Hightower and can’t wait to see where you go from here. David Bahnsen: Thank you so much. I really appreciate your kind words and appreciate all the great work you guys do. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibility seriously and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firm’s or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook . Build, Grow & Transact: David Bahnsen on Building a $10.5B Business Worth Selling A conversation with Louis Diamond and David Bahnsen, Founder & Managing Partner of The Bahnsen Group. Louis Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is Build, Grow & Transact: David Bahnsen on Building a $10.5B Business Worth Selling. It’s a conversation with the founder and managing partner of the Bahnsen Group. I’m Louis Diamond, and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education-driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual Advisor Transition Report. It’s the award-winning, data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Louis Diamond: There’s a big difference between breaking away to create a better version of the business you already have and breaking away because you see an entirely different business you want to build. And I think that distinction becomes even more important as we look at what creates real enterprise value in the wealth management industry today. My guest, David Bahnsen, is a pretty remarkable example. David first joined us in April of 2020, five years after leaving Morgan Stanley with eight people and 600 million in assets. At that time, the Bahnsen Group had grown to roughly two billion. Today, it’s a $10.5 billion business with more than 100 people and 13 offices across the country. Perhaps the most interesting part of that growth story is that virtually all of it has been organic. David didn’t build the firm by buying AUM. He built it by creating an authentic voice, an incredibly effective content engine, investing heavily back into the business, adding services clients actually wanted, and being very deliberate about what his team should own versus what was better outsourced. There’s a lot in that playbook for any advisor who wants to build a business with real enterprise value. But David’s story also gives us something we often don’t get to examine, the full build, grow, and transact arc. For more than a decade, Hightower went from employer to service provider while David maintained ownership and control of the business. Now, the Bahnsen Group is being sold to Hightower, giving David additional resources to pursue the next stage of growth while preserving much of what made the firm successful in the first place. So we get into the decisions behind that extraordinary organic growth, why maximizing current income can work against building long-term enterprise value, how David thinks about content, clients, and scale, and ultimately why someone who was once intoxicated by the idea of freedom decided the next right move was to transact. It’s a great case study in what can happen when independence becomes a starting point rather than the destination. So let’s get to it. David, thank you for coming on our show again. David Bahnsen: Well, it’s wonderful to be back with you. I love listening to the show every week. Louis Diamond: Oh, there you go. Just flattering us now. So for anyone who probably, myself included, doesn’t remember the last time you were on our show, it was April of 2020, a time warp into a crazy time. It was the five-year anniversary of your breakaway in the very, very beginning of the pandemic. Then you still had an amazing business, two billion in assets. But for listeners who may have missed it, and even just to catch us up, can you give us the quick version of your origin story of leaving Morgan Stanley in 2015 with 600 million and eight people and why you did it, just the speed round of compressing a stressful and very important time in your business arc? David Bahnsen: So I was one of those people that in an almost cliche, typical way, the types of folks that your business deals with all the time, left because I wanted independence. I wasn’t unhappy at Morgan Stanley. I wasn’t in need of any particular change, but I was very intoxicated by the idea of freedom and became very committed to the idea that if I were going to run my own business, I needed to run my own business. It started in 2014. We made our official exit in early 2015. And as you said, there were eight people, all of which were folks on my team at Morgan Stanley and 600 million of client assets, and we basically moved 100% of that. When I was on the podcast, April 2020, it’s funny when you were saying that, I can visualize myself at my home office at that point in time in Southern California recording this. And we would’ve been our five-year anniversary, couple billion, so we had a little bit over tripled. We probably had, if I remember correctly at that time, 25, 30 employees. And it’s interesting the linear arc of it, because you fast-forward now, we’re at 10.5 billion and 106 employees. And so it’s just proportionate, the AUM and the headcount and the time gone by, it’s been a very nice, steady arc. But I really loved the idea of being independent. I turned 40 years old in 2014 when I began the extensive due diligence that led to me leaving Morgan Stanley. And it really was that moment that I said, “If I’m going to stay as a corner office guy at a wirehouse, I will stay at Morgan Stanley forever.” I had no issues there. My manager at the time is still, to this day, my best friend in the world. We’re like brothers. I just dedicated my new book to him. I wasn’t unhappy with Morgan. I just liked the idea of having my own business and haven’t looked back since. Louis Diamond: Amazing. Seems like it was probably a pretty good move based upon what you shared, but I think it’s an interesting perspective because I feel like I’m starting to see that more and more is the profile of the advisor who doesn’t have these intense pain points and is relatively well served, is going to be successful, knows how to operate at their firm, but they just want something more. There’s an intangible that staying isn’t going to solve for them. For many, it’s being a business owner, like the path you took. For others it’s, hey, I just want to be recharged. I don’t want to be static. I want something different. I want to monetize. I want to work in a bit of a different way. I think you’re early on that trend, to be honest with you. You were probably right in the middle, even probably even the beginning innings of the independent movement, and I am very excited to dig into how you got from 600 million in 2015 to over 10.5 billion, 11-ish years later. So let’s jump to today, and we’ll spend some time going through dissecting that growth. But today, like you said, 10 and a half billion under management, 100 plus people, 13 offices, including Santa Barbara where you just opened, but Newport Beach, New York City, Nashville, Tennessee, Palm Beach. It’s a real national firm. And I read that you’ve grown over 30% organically over the last decade. So when you look at the firm now versus 2015, what stands out the most? Let’s really dive into that. David Bahnsen: Well, a lot of this is where we’re going to end up going later in the conversation with where I see the next iteration of the company. But when you talk about the last 10 years, it has been the textbook definition of organic growth. There are 13 offices open and zero of them came by acquisition or merger or purchase. We’ve hired two or three advisors out of our 26 advisors that had a little bit of a book, but I mean under 100 million. We never paid for it. I’m talking about hiring people. But you’re looking at an organic story, and I am proud of that, but I also recognize that it wasn’t intentional. And what I mean by that is I didn’t have this strategy in 2014, ’15 where I said, if I can just go independent, I have this evil genius behind me that is going to drive a mousetrap that will get me up to 10.5 Billion. I’ve been as surprised, as many outside observers, but I have a lot of gratitude for it. I understand now why it has worked, and I think that there are people inside of our business that are a little more qualified to understand how the business works than people who are outside of it. Your consultants and professional investors are very smart at what they do, but they don’t necessarily always understand that advisor-client dynamic. And I get why we’ve been successful with it. But I also don’t want to take credit for it as if it were this master strategy. We just tried things and those things that worked, we kept doing more of, and this is where we are. A lot of it, and I spoke to Mindy about this six years ago, it’s been content creation, thought leadership, and the voice that, much to my surprise, has attracted people and never doing it for the purpose of attracting people. This very natural and sincere delivery of a belief system about markets, about the economy, about the world around us, I share things sometimes about my faith, politics in a public square. I’m on television, this podcast. And then the major driver is the written word, which some people might be shocked to hear as we’re talking about a podcast still even exists. But my weekly Dividend Cafe, which is my weekly market commentary, is up to 35,000 subscribers, 100% organic. We’ve never done anything to get any subscribers. And our video and our podcast and everything, the books I write, the television hits, they all have their audience. But most of it goes through that written word. That’s where I get to connect with people that if they like me, they may end up becoming a client. And if they don’t, they won’t, but that’s really been our story though. Louis Diamond: That’s absolutely amazing. There’s so much to unpack there. That amount of growth without anything inorganic, especially the way this industry is going, I don’t think I’ve ever heard that before. That’s amazing in and of itself. But just the way you can track back your meteoric rise to content creation, I think for many listening, it’s either, “Oh my God, that seems so daunting and so crazy.” Others would be like, “Well, I can’t do that, but that sounds great. Of course, he’s been able to grow because he can have an original voice.” As a firm that puts out a lot of original content, podcasts written, Mindy wrote a book, white papers, et cetera, I know the amount of work and dedication and commitment it takes to stick with that for so long. So if you don’t mind, can we double-click into that written word story? How did you get started with it and what’s been the arc or the growth journey? Someone who’s listening who would love to do that, where did you get started? You didn’t just all of a sudden have a book and show up on TV. How did you get started? David Bahnsen: In the truest sense of the word, I grew up loving writing. My father died in his 40s and I was only 20, but he was an intellectual, a brilliant writer, had several books, and I was a nerd in high school. Luckily, I had basketball so that I could still meet a girl here and there and have friends on the team. But I mean, if it were up to me, I would’ve been home reading books and writing papers, and I would turn in extra credit papers more than I would study for a test because I loved writing. So the written thing was there. I don’t know if I was ever good at it or not, but I know I loved doing it, and I would credit my late father with the early seeds of that. When the financial crisis happened in September, the actual week of Lehman’s bankruptcy, September of ’08, about three, four days later, Morgan Stanley’s credit default swaps were blowing out, and now it was not just the market was crashing every day. And of course at that point, Merrill had gone down, AIG had gone down. We were in this cascade, and everybody who lived through it remembers it all well. I remember every detail of it like it were yesterday. But all that happened was once I got my 80th call about what the hell was going on with Morgan, I decided to write up a piece, not send it to compliance for approval and send it out to everyone. And if the firm was at risk of not making it for another day, I wasn’t especially worried about compliance getting mad at me at the time. And I did that, and then a couple days later did it again, just broad update on everything going on, and I never stopped doing it. That’s what it was, just every Friday since September 2008. And then when we left Morgan, at some point along the way I started getting compliance approval and getting a bit more of an audience. We had hundreds of clients that were reading it, and we’d have a few guests that would ask to be signed up as clients were forwarding it around, but that was it. It didn’t have a website, it didn’t have a subscribe feature, it wasn’t a real blog or anything like that. So then in going independent, I was able to incubate it, and we branded it as Dividend Cafe. We’re Dividend Growth investors at my firm. So we put a brand around it. We had a website, and I think we started a podcast and video that was becoming a very large medium around the mid-tens as well, and so we added that shortly later, but it was just because I had the freedom to do it. And then I did do some hit on CNBC like Asia or CNBC World or something. It wasn’t anything with a big audience, but then we sent the clip to someone at Fox and they really liked it, and then they had me, and then I started getting invited more regularly. So now the TV thing was happening, and I always say that TV can be a really good thing for a very small number of people. Obviously, Josh Brown has been incredibly successful with it. He’s very good at it, and it’s done okay. It’s done well for me, but it’s different than people think. You do not go on TV and then get done and all of a sudden the phone rang and someone said, “I saw you. You’re so handsome. I want you to be my advisor.” What it does is it might drive them to other content. It might drive them to the internet where they’re going to find other things about you. And if my name was David Johnson instead of David Bahnsen, I think I would’ve got lost in the SEO and nothing would’ve come of it. I really believe that. But it enabled some people that liked what they heard on TV to start following me in other more substantive and perpetual mediums. And then in 2017, I wrote a book that I wouldn’t have been able to write at Morgan Stanley. I had very strong opinions about the origins of the financial crisis. And I did not believe the left-wing narrative that it was caused by unfettered markets, and I didn’t really believe the right-wing narrative entirely either that it was exclusively caused by government intervention. I believed that all of those things were true but were missing this cultural and moral component about Main Street. I wrote a book on it and I thought there might be 200 clients of my firm that would read it, and it ended up being a bestseller, and that created more television invitations and just to a slightly larger audience. And at this point now, I realized that all of these things were dovetailed together, content, the mediums, coming to Dividend Cafe, coming to an authentic point of view about markets. And then, and this is the thing that is so important because of what you do and do so well in your business and within the kind of practitioners that listen, it wasn’t enough to have a mousetrap that drew people to us. We had to keep them. We had to deliver an advisory experience, and so we were just relentlessly reinvesting back in the business, adding planners, adding tax, adding more investment sophistication, family office, just improving our business, and that’s why we’ve added so much to headcount because we have just constantly wanted to really be what we were attracting people to. Louis Diamond: It’s amazing. The key themes I heard there, there’s a lot, but is it’s not one thing that works. It’s a coordinated strategy. I can attest to that for the content work that we do. There isn’t one single point of growth that comes from content creation. It’s everything working together. You don’t know, especially in this day and age, how people consume information or how a message gets across to them, whether they’re a reader, whether they find you in AI, whether they watch video, whether they saw CNBC in their barbershop. So I think that’s absolutely amazing, and congratulations. Let’s talk a little bit about your breakaway setup, if you will. So when you broke in 2015, you signed on with Hightower, but in a bit of a different way, certainly different than today. You paid Hightower an override on your revenue, or basis points and assets, to be on their platform. But you owned 100% of your business, ran your own P&L, and they provided certain services to you. Thinking back to 2015, and then even up until your recent decision to sell to Hightower, why did you structure it that way rather than under their brand or as an employee or even just having your own RIA, especially given your size and scale? David Bahnsen: There’s actually one piece missing there. You may not have known, but I think is important to the story. When we came in 2015, we were employees and they had a 50/50 net model, and we joined in that capacity. And then when they recapped in 2017, brought a new investor on, eventually changed CEO about a year later, at that point, we were growing. I felt very comfortable with the independent space. I now knew what I didn’t know. I knew what I thought they did well, and I knew what I thought we could do well, and I took advantage of that moment to say, “Guys, I need to be on my own. We need to run our own firm, our own finances, our own payroll, our own brand.” And what the investors wanted at that time was some sort of affiliation that they could count on and not be vulnerable, but I didn’t want to sell and I wanted full control. So I got control, much better control than I had had in my first couple years, and they got a extension of agreement of these services that they could feel good I was going to be a part of their ecosystem. And the cash flows were pretty meaningful as we grew from, at that point, a billion to over 10 billion, and we became obviously a very meaningful contributor to their earnings and revenues. And the CEO who came in was the second CEO in the history of the company. And they now have a third, but that individual, Bob Oros, I knew well because he had been at Fidelity when I chose Fidelity as our primary custodian. Bob and I got along very well. And so over the years, there’d be things that we had impediments that we had to work through, and we worked through them just like adults, like businessmen and women and got stuff done. So it was a good relationship. But we were really quite independent. Very few of my people that worked at Bahnsen Group even knew who Hightower was because we had our own brand, we had our own investment process, the HR, the payroll. And unlike a lot of the other platform teams, they didn’t have too many platform teams, but ours, the accounts payable were massive. I mean, we had to have a whole finance department just because of our growth. So it became a difficult thing for them at this stage to have such a meaningful company within their ecosystem not aligned and not harmonized within the economic model of the rest of the firm. But I would say that decision for 2017 until this year, I don’t regret it at all. Hightower doesn’t regret it at all. They benefited immensely from this growth we’ve gone through, and I very much desired that freedom. Look, if I’m being very candid, Louis, you brought up why didn’t go on my own ADV? At the time in ’14 and ’15, I didn’t know enough. I didn’t understand. And I met with Focus, I met with Dynasty, I met with some others, and you just meet with different people, hear the stories, and the one I went with was Hightower, and there’s pros and cons to all the models. It’s one of the things I wasn’t joking at the beginning. I listen to your guys’ show every week. I’m a sucker for everything happening in our industry. I hear the stories of different successful advisors, and every one of them resonate with me in one way. There might be nine ways it doesn’t resonate, but one way that does because there’s always something that each person’s looking for that some of us can connect with. And at the time, I didn’t know what I didn’t know, but I felt good about the Hightower story, went in that path, and I would argue that we got the best of all worlds in that 2017 to 2026 story because we really got to function independently. We were under their corporate RIA, but other than that, felt very independent. And that’s a testimony to Hightower that they honored that autonomy, but I think it gave me the entrepreneurial thing I needed, and I’m grateful for it. Louis Diamond: Fantastic. So let’s say from the 2017 to 2026 timeframe when you decided to finally sell to Hightower, how did you weigh the leverage that outsourcing certain things provided your business versus paying a fee, obviously, more than what it cost Hightower and not having complete and utter control over your business? How do you track that to your growth, if at all? David Bahnsen: The criteria was always anything we like doing or are good at doing, we’re going to do it, whether Hightower offers it or not. So for example, I’m sitting here in a beautiful office. We have the 31st floor of a building on 54th Street and 6th Avenue, and Hightower has a whole facilities department. We’ve done 13 office leases with no involvement from their facilities department because my wife loves designing the offices. She’s an interior designer. My team loved picking our own locations. I didn’t find negotiating with a broker all that hard. So we were able to do it, we liked it, so we did it. But then the supervision side, the regulatory side, and candidly, a lot of the technology side, which is where some of our talk is about to go in terms of the new transaction, those things I felt more comfortable outsourcing to Hightower who had entire departments and resources geared towards it. And we would do them if we had to, but we weren’t passionate about it. I didn’t want to go understand all the nooks and crannies of the regulatory apparatus. So that was part of their ecosystem, and we were happy to utilize their services there. Investing money, financial facilities, the business development mousetrap we built, those things we were good at, and so we held onto that, and that’s how we viewed the division of labor. Every firm, RIA, IBD, a wire, W, it doesn’t matter. Everyone who optimizes this challenge of doing what you like and not doing what you don’t like is going to grow. It’s hard to do. It’s easier said than done, but that’s the challenge right there. Louis Diamond: I absolutely love that. I think it’s so true, knowing what’s actually going to add surplus value relative to the amount of time you’re doing versus what’s commoditized or back of house or isn’t something that lights you up. Because there’s plenty of RIAs that I’ve interviewed or that I know where they enjoy building technology, they like designing their own compliance organization, and to them, that’s their superpower. That’s what makes them different. For you, it sounds like it was very clear. You knew exactly what you wanted to do. As long as you’re able to still do it, you’re very comfortable with outsourcing certain things that would’ve been a distraction or something that you and your team weren’t world-class at. I want to talk a little bit about some of the deliberate choices you made to take the business from, I would assume it was you as the rainmaker, and now you said you have over 25 advisors. So just thinking about hiring, structuring the business, investing in the business and platform, because I’m sure you’ve had the temptation, maybe not because you’re a business builder, but I think a lot of people love, “Hey, I can make a ton of money if I don’t make that second, third, 125th hire, and instead I just take cash flow. I don’t necessarily need this person. I can make more money or distribute more to my partners.” So I’d love to hear a little bit about some of the deliberate choices you made on hiring and investing in your business. David Bahnsen: There’s two things that I am very hesitant to take credit for, even though they’re true. You had mentioned before when we left in 2014 that we were early innings of wirehouse defections to the independent movement. I was early, but I wasn’t a first inning guy. The real trailblazers were going in 2006, 2007, 2009. 2014 is a lot earlier than those that have gone in the last two or three years, but I was like a third or fourth inning guy, and I don’t deserve credit to be a first inning guy. The other issue is that I reinvest in the business constantly and have not been greedy about maximizing all the margin, but that is easy to say once you’ve already scaled the business, right? You’re already in a place where things are going very well, and then from there, deciding you just really want to run the business the way you want to run it. It’s not as selfless a decision as people may think. It was a luxury. And at the same time, I cannot tell you how bizarre I think it is when people are focusing on maximizing margin versus running the business that they want to have. It’s a high-margin business. There is not a lot of operating leverage in it. More or less, not completely, but more or less expenses go up in proportion to revenue. Particularly for us opening new offices and hiring a lot of new people, our biggest overhead far and away is people. And we started an ETF a couple years ago and I got a chance to learn the polar opposite where my business has tons of pricing power and very little operating leverage and asset management has unbelievable operating leverage. I basically have zero dollars of expenses on my next dollar of revenue, but no pricing power. Louis Diamond: So interesting. David Bahnsen: Yeah. I mean, it really is just two different business models. When we have hired more people, we’ve always done it based on are we going to serve our clients better and enjoy running our business better with these people? We don’t want wasteful positions, but we want the maximum optimization for how to service clients and how to give advisors an ecosystem to function in. So a one-to-one operations to advisor, having planners that are not the client-facing advisor themselves, but are devoted to the behind the scenes planning process. Having a full tax department that does not provide tax services to non-wealth clients, that is only there, a robust tax consulting, tax preparation, tax advisory arm to drive a better client experience for us. These things all erode at margin, and I wouldn’t do it any other way. And the biggest thing, by the way, is the investment management, because then you’re not just talking about profit margin. We’re talking about time. I am a 3:45 AM guy every day because we’re inside markets. We have analysts, traders, investment folks. I think it’s something like 10 or 11 people on the org chart. It costs me millions of dollars a year for us to manage money in-house. There’s no justification for that other than it’s what we want to do, what we believe in. And those that have a outsourced Vanguard DFA-type model, I have no criticism of it in the world, but it just wasn’t us, and so we had to do what we liked doing. Louis Diamond: Yep. And once again, the authenticity shines through. Can we talk a little bit about the financial advice part of the business? I would assume when you’re at Morgan Stanley, you were probably the driver of growth, you were serving personally probably every client or just about all of them. Today, with 10 and a half billion, 25 advisors, just the immense scale of the organization, how do advisors advise? Are you still providing financial advice to clients directly? Are you more of just the CEO, the rainmaker, the strategist? I mean, how do you think about, I guess, allocating clients to your advisors? How have you grown your capacity for financial advice? David Bahnsen: So our leverage is entirely limited by my ability to find like-minded advisors who can go deliver our client experience and be in relationship to clients. It’s why I’m not a big believer in this notion of scalability. I think technology helps scale. I think there’s all kinds of processes you can do more efficiently, but it’s a relationship business and relationships don’t scale. And we have an internal policy philosophy preference, if you will, that no advisor will cover more than 80 households. And so for us to continue growing at the number of households, number of AUM, and therefore number of revenues, all those numbers, of course, have some proportionate relationship with one another, we have to have the advisors to do it. And so as we find advisors that can not drool on themselves and be professionals and deliver an experience to clients, we want them to be generalists. We want them to be very good at what they do, but we don’t want them entering trades. We don’t want them doing their own operations work. We don’t want them having to pick stocks. We’re providing this ecosystem of the tax, the planning, the estate, the operations, the content, the marketing, and the biz dev. They don’t have to go try to rainmake at their kid’s soccer game or join the chamber of commerce or things like that. That we believe we have enough internal biz dev opportunity that what they need to do is cultivate the relationships with the prospective clients we give them. They do have to close that business, but our industry, for all of the talk about this, people diagnose it wrong. We do not have a problem with closing business in our industry. We have a problem with opening business. And so the sourcing is the issue. And for whatever reason, it’s a mystery to me, it’s been a mystery for 27 years, I’ve been pretty good at sourcing business. And so we can share that with our advisors and then expect them to, their job when they wake up and go to bed and everything in between is to be in relationship with clients. Louis Diamond: If I think about, just think of 20 highly successful RIAs and think of some of the biggest and best names in the space, I think a critical connection point or commonality for all those firms is they’ve somehow figured out lead flow or some mechanism or capacity to bring in clients for their advisors. To me, that’s the truly only scalable way to keep adding advisors and growing a business is if there’s enough inbound lead flow that’s cultivated or created by the firm to really feed all the different advisors, and it’s not snap our fingers and it happens. But if you compare that to many other models, the wirehouse model where it’s all on the advisors to go out and find clients, that’s great. And if you find some amazing rainmakers, amazing, and it’s additive, et cetera, but you eventually hit a ceiling because it’s hard to find advisors who have that knack. You’re not bringing in the ideal client every time, and it’s an unpredictable way to grow. So I think I wouldn’t gloss over the fact that you’ve been able to create enough inbound traffic or lead flow through all of your content and thought leadership that you’re able to sustain that type of model. Because it is the best way to grow a business is keep your advisors focused on just being advisors, solve for organic growth, solve for the other things they have to do. And then when you open up a new market or hire an advisor, boom, you got capacity, you got someone trained up, and it’s predictable, your close rate and your ability to scale it from there. So I’ll get off my soapbox, but I think that’s such an important element of the biggest and best and most valuable firms in our industry today. David Bahnsen: I agree with you a thousand percent. And even if you put numbers around it, somebody who has to go make their own rain and service the client, they will expect, if you use wirehouse-like grids around it, this is just round numbers, I know you could turn a knob a little bit, but I view the business as more or less it costs something in the range of 40 cents of a dollar revenue to run the business. There’s 20 cents available to the owner, 20 cents to the person who makes rain and 20 cents to the person servicing the client. It’s back of napkin math. If you are a wirehouse advisor, you’re making the rain and servicing the client, you’re getting two of the 20 cents, you’re getting 40 cents, let’s say. And if you’re the person who owns the business and makes the rain and is the advisor, you can make 60 cents on the dollar. That’s a wonderful margin, and you cap out at a certain level where you just cannot grow any further. I would rather make 20 cents on where we are now. My advisors would rather make 20 cents on where they are because 20 cents of something big is a lot more than 40% of something small. And again, and my numbers are, I’m rounding, but you get the idea. That’s really the kind of business model we’ve done here. Louis Diamond: I think it’s brilliant. And some would argue about the percentages and would say, oh, it costs 40 cents to 30 cents to run a business and we have a small team, but I think philosophically that’s exactly right. And I think something you said too, which is there’s been a common thread in our “Build, Grow, Transact” series. You think about Jason Fertitta of Americana Partners or Matt Kilgroe from Cyndeo and many others that we’ve had or will have, it’s really playing the long game. No one we’ve had on the show is optimizing for how much money can I make this year, next year or the year after. It’s the intentional decisions to invest in capacity, invest in growth, and by choice take less as the owner of the business, but doing it because what you’re building is enterprise value that will sell at a dramatic multiple of that growth and have room to run. So I think that’s the big thing is, again, it sounds easy, it sounds great, but it’s not an easy decision to say, “Hey, I’m going to make less money today and over the next few years because I want to hire the next person or invest in an organic growth funnel.” That’s discipline, for sure. But I think it’s a great takeaway for anyone listening is play the long game, invest where it makes sense, and the riches will follow you later. They don’t have to follow you today or tomorrow. David Bahnsen: And it’s a whole business of playing the long game, not only in the value creation and enterprise value of being independent. But even for wirehouse advisors, I remember back as I was entering the business, that debate about fee-based business versus transactional, and all it was, are you going to play the long game or get more money quickly? There’s temptations in both ways. There’s goals, there’s overhead, reality. Anyone who played the long game in that story from 30 years ago benefited immensely. And now you see it, of course, in what we’re talking about here, playing the long game in the way you run your business has just been the smartest thing anybody could do. Louis Diamond: Absolutely. Especially in this industry where each new client that’s brought on, there’s a lifetime value of a client. That success compounds with market appreciation, with them adding new monies, and then ultimately they’re going to give you referrals hopefully. And then over time, that’s where the real money is. It’s the compounding nature of doing the next right thing rather than, we’ll say, taking a shortcut or not making that investment in the business. I have a ton more questions for you on this topic, but I want to spend enough time on your important decision to sell the business, sell the Bahnsen Group to Hightower in April of 2026. So after more than a decade of being an employee of Hightower, being affiliated with them but really owning your own business, you decided to not just sell the business, but to sell it to the very platform that you’re operating on. So can you just talk about that decision? Why was 2026 the right time? Why did you decide to stay with Hightower rather than any of the other 100 acquirers or a random private equity firm that would love to buy a business that’s growing 30% per year? David Bahnsen: It’s interesting to think about as our deal gets ready to close here at the end of September, if I had gone out and run a process, if I was looking to sell, would I have been interested in conversations with others? And I don’t know the answer to that because I wasn’t looking to sell. There was nothing broken, in my mind, in what we were doing. But when Hightower and her investors came to me, the entire conversation centered not around what we needed and wanted to be a seller, but on what we didn’t want or couldn’t have. And I’ll share the story because I haven’t shared it publicly with anyone. As we were having conversations about a variety of things in the relationship between Hightower and the Bahnsen Group and Hightower’s investor and so forth, there were a couple of different meetings and things and we ended up having a pretty significant meeting in person in their conference rooms here in Midtown. And I’ve had seven eye surgeries, and I have challenges with my eyes and there are all these numbers up on a screen in the conference room. I couldn’t see any of them. And it occurred to me that there was an offer on the screen they wanted to buy the business. We had not discussed that. And I turned to the folks and said, “I don’t really know exactly what it says, but I just want to make something very clear to save time and drive our conversation constructively. There’s no amount of money that I would sell for if I can’t be fully in charge of what we’re doing. Our brand, our business, our autonomy is what I care most about. If there’s a way to have that, protect it, enhance it and do a commercial transaction, I’m open to it.” And I didn’t really think that would be possible, but I will say to their credit, they did not want to interfere with that autonomy and what they believe to be a successful formula inside our company at all. And so while they’re doing a lot right now to build their Hightower Signature Wealth brand, both internally and externally, and are coming up on $50 billion of assets that they’ll have moved onto that platform in trying to create more centralization and consolidation, which I think has a lot of commercial rationalization behind it, what they’re looking to do with the Bahnsen Group is have a wholly owned independent subsidiary where I still have plenary authority to run the business, control of the P&L, hiring and firing, strategy, branding, and yet the resources of Hightower at my disposal more now in the HR front. That gets a little trickier with 106 people that will soon be 150 than it was when it was 20. I’m committed, Louis, to knowing every one of my employees’ names forever and it’s getting harder, but luckily I have a pretty good memory. But the technology side, the AI moment, the way in which a tech stack all intersects, I hate this stuff. And they not only are good at it and like it, but are heavily invested in it. And so it felt to me like if they’re really going to allow me to continue running this and have that control of the P&L, it could be best of all worlds and certainly very value additive to the enterprise of Hightower. And that’s what we worked a few months to put together and everybody is really pleased with the outcome. Louis Diamond: Amazing. I mean it’s an interesting shift in the way I’m seeing a lot of these platforms, that they start off as a fee-for-service affiliation platform and then over time they morph to being buyers of businesses, investors in businesses. And Hightower is definitely, they’re probably at the forefront of really completely shifting or re-identifying themself in the market, especially on buying practices. So I think it’s very interesting that you had this long-term relationship and ultimately having such an amazing business, they were the ultimate buyer of the business. David Bahnsen: And I think it’s important to say for our listeners, you know as well as I do, if we went to market, there would’ve been a lot of interested parties. Louis Diamond: That was going to be my question. David Bahnsen: The organic growth alone would’ve commanded something pretty attractive. We were under Hightower’s ADV. I not only had a positive relationship with them and a good cultural dynamic, which I wouldn’t want to risk changing, but I don’t want to re-paper the size of this business, and so it was just a non-starter. I talked to a couple investment bankers after we were already in LOI and they all said the same thing. You had your most natural buyer. It was the one you were already dating. And that’s how I feel, is if there was going to be a transaction, it made the most sense for us to do it with the one we were already partnered with. Louis Diamond: So was it like, hey, you know exactly who we’re getting in bed with because they’ve already been our partner in this business for a while, and as long as I get what I think is fair value for the business, that’s good enough? I’m sure you could have gotten a turn or two more to have 50 bids and to have the shark circling to push Hightower higher. But it sounds like for you, that was of course important, but that wasn’t the number one driver. It was more how do we preserve what we like, preserve our autonomy and do it with people that we like and trust? David Bahnsen: Yeah, that continuity, in a funny way, I did it the wrong order. I ran a process after I was already at LOI, meaning I did enough to find out, hey, did I just do a good deal or not after I’d already done the deal. And the good news is I did, but it wasn’t the way most people go about doing it. But the continuity thing is there’s always two fronts to it at our size of business. There’s the client continuity and the team. Our team is going to move the payroll from being under Bahnsen Group to Hightower, and there’s benefits and changes and things. But the clients don’t know any difference whatsoever. Custodial, the G numbers, the ADV, there’s no signature required, no negative consent required because they already were under the Hightower ADV before. So this transaction all at once allows us to go into the next iteration of our business, which I’m very excited about, and I think is a wonderful deal for Hightower and what their goals are, but we didn’t have to bother clients with it. And when we say to clients, “Nothing’s going to change,” we can actually mean it. Louis Diamond: Yeah, that’s the definition of it. You mentioned there you’re excited for this next iteration or the next chapter of the company. Can you explain that? I would imagine just continuing your strategy that’s worked so well for the last decade plus, you keep doing that, I mean, you’re going to have a 20, 25, $30 billion business over the next handful of years. So what’s the next chapter? Why change it at all? What are you thinking about? David Bahnsen: Well, it’s funny in a moment now where, first of all, I’ve went out of my way to say that we didn’t grow at all inorganically, and a lot of people have now decided that inorganic growth is a little bit less impressive than organic growth. One of the issues with the law of large numbers is growing 30% at two billion meant adding 600 million and growing 30% at 10 billion means adding three billion in a year. Louis Diamond: That’s fair. David Bahnsen: And then 3.6 billion, the exponential nature of it. And I believe that there are… I’ve never gone to a meeting with an advisor with a checkbook or with a balance sheet, and we want to find some folks that want to join us, join our system, join our culture, not merely aggregate a bunch of unified parts, but in some cases doing that with other people demographically would mean some monetization events. So I do believe that there will be some inorganic growth that we will add to our toolbox as a supplement to our core underlying strategy, which we think is industry leading organic growth. So we want to continue doing more of what we’re doing. And then just as we continue to professionalize based on our size and scale more of those things that are not passions for us, technology, supervision and HR, utilize the mousetrap Hightower has that they do well while maintaining the things that make us uniquely us, which is our branding, our business development, our investment strategy, our delivery of services to clients. I’m not naive enough to think that there won’t be some growing pains and some hiccups and whatnot, but we believe that model, all the parties are very committed to it, and we believe it’s the right model for us. Louis Diamond: Absolutely. I think what’s really cool about what you said was, one, I agree with the concept of law of large numbers. I mean, it’s a fact, right? No matter how much content you put out, it’s going to be hard to bring in 10 billion of net new assets eventually without going inorganic. But I think to me at least the big trap in the industry today is firms either completely ignoring the organic and just focusing on buying and growing that way and pointing to, oh, we grew by this amount. But what you said, which is really cool and important I think is we’re going to continue the organic side to the best of our ability. That’s not going to change. Inorganic is a supplement. It’s not the replacement. I think that’s a really important lesson or discipline that it’s the combination of the two that really builds an enterprise and builds scale. You already had your transaction, but anyone who’s weighing a transaction in the future, buyers will always value a dollar of organic growth than they would inorganic growth. So if you can hit both and you do transactions strategically, you’re not just trying to buy anyone or everyone, but you’re doing it to add the right capacity, add a new discipline, diversify the talent pool, honestly, you can’t lose. Because worst case, it’s not that successful, you still got the organic engine. Or I think knowing you it’s going to be very successful and now all you’ve done is ratcheted up what you’re able to do. So I think it’s a very smart way to look at the decision to go inorganic after all this time. David Bahnsen: Well, I appreciate that. It means a lot coming from you, and of course I agree and you would know a lot more about this than I would. I also believe that some of the things people are afraid of in going inorganic are a byproduct of people hitting the buy button that are not the ones who have to deal with the cultural integration afterwards. When you remove the skin in the game factor, anybody we choose to buy, they’re going to be people I got to have breakfast, lunch, and dinner with. And inorganic growth is a lot more successful when you care about culture than when you don’t. And we’re not planning to just care about it, but to obsess over it. So I feel very excited about it. We have a couple deals that we’ll be announcing here in the fourth quarter to kick things off. And in the meantime, it’s funny, the valuation period of my transaction ended June 30th. My deal closes September 30th, and in this quarter in between, we just had our biggest organic growth ever. So we’re already off to a great start in making money for our new owners. Louis Diamond: There we go. That’s amazing. So was for you the pivot point then the realization that in order to protect our 30% or more growth per year, that we’re going to have to supplement with acquisitions? Was that really the we’ll say the critical link that was the why now moment? Because I would imagine, I mean, given the size of your firm, you could have gotten debt to buy businesses, you could have gone and sold 10%, 20% to a PE firm or a family office. So was it really like, we really want to lean into the inorganic side? Was that what you thought Hightower, and being owned by them, would really unlock for you? David Bahnsen: That is a true statement, but even then that wasn’t true until we got over the original hump of control. That once it was clear that they authentically wanted, not like they were willing to let me run it, but they were willing to memorialize to that they valued what we had done and did not want to disrupt it. And when I became convinced that they were convinced that it was not just best for me, I mean, that’s what I cared about, but they wanted our autonomy out of self-interest because they viewed that it was best for their enterprise to let us continue running independently, that was the sine qua non of everything. And then on the other side of it, it opened up the benefits of the inorganic growth. And I also think I felt a burden to properly professionalize and scale our internal team without me working eight jobs. And I felt that there became a need for specialization in the technology supervision and HR functions that I didn’t have an interest in building in-house. We built in-house our investment, our tax, our family office, our content, all of those things, and I loved it. But these other areas, I felt like we had it good enough, but we were going to benefit from the strategic partnership with them going forward. And so all of those factors together allowed us to put this deal together. Louis Diamond: It makes complete sense. So I mean, there’s this version of your story, and you’ll probably be like, “That’s not my story, clearly.” But you broke away in 2015, you keep doing your thing, grow a couple points here or there. It compounds, you’re at two, three billion without really breaking much of a sweat. Take a lot of vacations, make a lot of money, but you did the opposite, right? You really took independence as a signal like, let’s go, let’s build something, let’s build a real company, a real business. So can you talk about basically how you thought about treating independence as the starting point rather than the terminal destination? David Bahnsen: Well, I think that your question itself, it has the answer in it. It’s so important. I mean, without us knowing each other, you’re really capturing something very biographical. I did not want to go to independence as an ending point. It was a beginning. I intend to do this the rest of my life. I was already financially comfortable, but I didn’t realize that when people talk about payouts like, oh, you’re going to have a higher margin of what you keep as an RIA than W-2 at a wire, I never even thought about that. It was purely for me the type of business I wanted to have, the way in which we went about servicing clients. I’ve said this to good friends of mine over the years. Greg Fleming ran Morgan Stanley Wealth Management at the time, and now of course is CEO of Rockefeller. One of the things the wirehouses did so well was convince me about teaming, about having a business. I’d go to Chairman’s Club every year and they would talk about you build out your team and you have your own little mini group and you’re adding a planner into this, and yet you couldn’t really do it. You couldn’t really hire and fire who you wanted. So they tantalized it. They gave me enough to know that this would be a wonderful way to run an advisory business versus the pure vertical type team that I had. And yet to go be able to pick our own furniture and do our own creative marketing work and all that, you had to be able to have your own checkbook. Independence was the start of a journey, and I really view this next phase of where we’re going as a new journey. I don’t know if I’m going to be good at doing inorganic transactions. We’ll see. But I do want to find out, and I’m determined to become good at running a 150-person company the way I think I was good at running a 30 or 40-person company. And so I’m up for that new challenge. And one thing I’ll say over 27 years from being an independent self-practitioner at PaineWebber through the Morgan Stanley years, through this last phase on our own at Bahnsen Group, it’s always been client-centric. And I just think that those advisors that somehow have that in their DNA, that if you keep everything focused on the client, the rest comes together, it does come together. Louis Diamond: Amazing. There’s been a number of episodes where that’s been a through line is if you do right by the client, that’s your North Star, you’re never really going to lose. Will you grow slower sometimes? Sure. Will it cost you money sometimes? Absolutely. But in the end, the goodwill, we’ll say the spirit, the culture of generosity, it always shines through. Think of any company, even outside of our industry, that’s been their North Star and they don’t lose. It’s brilliant. Last question for you. I think I can probably go for another four hours, but you got some content to create and some new households to bring in, so I’ll let you go after this. For an advisor who’s sitting where you were, let’s say 2012, 2013, 2014, who’s successful, growing, comfortable, they make a lot of money, but sensing that maybe there’s something missing, there’s a business to build, there’s something that’s not really charging them up the way that it used to, what’s one thing you’d tell them? David Bahnsen: You have to overcome the inertia because I think it is a universally true thing in our business that when there’s something holding them back, there’s something not right, there’s something that’s off, it’s still usually pretty good, especially in a good market. You have recurring cash flows, you make a good living, for most people, they’re probably making a better living than they ever thought they’d make doing anything else, and so to say it’s good enough is to me a hallmark of mediocrity. But to say even though it’s already good, I want it to be better. I’m going to have to go dig in to create the right ecosystem, the right apparatus, the right partnerships, the right strategic fit, whether it’s going to a new firm, whether it’s starting your own firm, whether it’s partnering with one of the aggregators or doing your own thing, I mean, there’s so many choices to walk through. But I don’t believe most people say, “Oh no, I’ve just decided where I am is the best.” I think most people decide where I am is good enough. And overcoming that inertia, you will be glad you did because there is a better world waiting when you take that step. And not only a better world for you and your family and enterprise value and cash flow, all that matters, but I’m saying a better world for your peace of mind, for your internal fulfillment of what you’re doing and for the experience you’re able to give a client. Everybody, every advisor worthy of the name should desire to optimize the ecosystem in which they work. Louis Diamond: That is absolute gold and brilliant. I couldn’t agree more. I mean, I feel like the great thing about being an advisor is even if you’re in the most captive environment, you’re the one who gets to choose. Is it good enough and does that work for me? I want to golf four days a week and this works, this checks all my boxes. Or if there’s something more, something that good enough isn’t solving for, that you have the optionality and the ability to go out and do it. And it’s not going to be easy. It’s a lot of work to transition or to build and to do something like you’re doing, but I think every advisor owes it to themself to at least test out that thesis. Is good enough really good enough or is there something better that makes me better, makes my team better, lets me serve clients better, and ultimately is going to be more fulfilling in the end? David, this has been absolutely amazing. We will definitely have you on again soon. I mean, I want to just talk to you every day because I’ve learned so much from this episode. But to me, a couple of the key themes to take away here is focusing everything on clients. It’s the compounding effect of organic growth, playing the long game, optimizing for enterprise value and building a sustainable business rather than income, and ultimately picking your partners and outsourcing, et cetera, wisely. And if you do that as the North Star, you become pretty unstoppable. So congratulations on everything. Congrats on the upcoming closing of your transaction with Hightower and can’t wait to see where you go from here. David Bahnsen: Thank you so much. I really appreciate your kind words and appreciate all the great work you guys do. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibility seriously and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firm’s or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook .

September 17, 2026Episode 37749 min

Unleashing Potential: Why Capacity is an Advisor’s Biggest Competitive Advantage

Michael Kim — CEO & President, AssetMark AssetMark CEO Michael Kim explains why advisor growth increasingly depends on creating capacity—and using outsourcing, technology, and AI to spend more time where advisors add the greatest value. In Summary Growth is a priority for nearly every advisory firm. But as client expectations expand and the business of wealth management becomes more complex, growth increasingly depends on an advisor’s ability to create capacity. Jason Diamond speaks with Michael Kim, CEO and President of AssetMark, about why the strongest firms are intentional about where advisors spend their time—and equally intentional about what they delegate, outsource, or automate. Drawing on AssetMark’s work with more than 12,000 independent financial advisors, Michael shares his perspective on organic growth, outsourcing investment management, AI, client experience, scale, and the evolving role of the advisor. His central message is straightforward: Advisors can do almost anything, but they can’t do everything. Sustainable growth requires deciding where they create the greatest value and building the business around it. The Storyline Michael Kim calls himself a “growth guy.” But his definition of growth goes well beyond adding assets, buying another practice, or simply getting bigger. After working with thousands of independent advisors throughout his career at Fidelity and AssetMark, Michael sees organic growth as one of the clearest measures of the health and durability of an advisory business. And the firms that consistently achieve it tend to have something in common: They treat growth as an intentional business priority rather than something they hope will happen. That creates a more fundamental question: Where should advisors actually spend their time? Michael argues that clients increasingly value the advisor—not simply the portfolio. They want guidance around taxes, wealth transfer, estate planning, business decisions, and the broader issues surrounding their wealth. Yet delivering that level of advice requires capacity. AssetMark’s Annual Impact of Outsourcing Survey, he says, finds that advisors who outsource gain more than nine hours per week—essentially another working day. AI potentially adds another layer of leverage. Michael sees its opportunity in two areas: productivity and experience. AssetMark’s developing Talk Tracks capability, for example, uses AI to prepare potential talking points and planning opportunities before client meetings. But Michael also cautions against allowing technology to depersonalize the relationship. As clients themselves become more informed through AI, the advisor’s ability to deliver deeply personal, trusted guidance may become even more important. That brings the discussion back to growth. Advisors are increasingly both trusted counselors and business owners. Building a scalable enterprise means making deliberate decisions about technology, outsourcing, talent, client experience, and where their own time produces the greatest return. Topics Covered Organic growth in wealth management Advisor capacity and productivity Outsourcing investment management AI in wealth management AssetMark Talk Tracks Advisor client experience The advisor as “wealth counselor” Scaling an advisory firm Fee compression and operating leverage RIA growth and independence M&A and access to capital > Download a transcript of this episode… Listen and Learn Highlights for Advisors What separates advisory firms that consistently grow from those that plateau? (12:36) Michael says the most successful growth-oriented firms are intentional about growth. They develop a plan, experiment with new approaches, and—most importantly—execute consistently. Why does Michael consider organic growth such an important measure of an advisory business? (15:27) Organic growth is not simply about adding clients. Michael describes it as a predictor of the health and durability of the business—something that also matters to potential investors and buyers. Should investment management still be a core part of an advisor’s value proposition? (18:42) Michael argues that clients increasingly want something broader: a trusted “wealth counselor” who can help them navigate taxes, wealth transfer, estate planning, and other complex financial decisions. How much capacity can outsourcing actually create for advisors? (23:05) According to AssetMark’s Annual Impact of Outsourcing Survey, advisors who outsource report gaining more than nine hours per week. Michael argues that time can be redirected toward clients and higher-impact business activities. Where does Michael see the greatest opportunity for AI in wealth management? (25:34) He identifies two areas: productivity and experience. AssetMark is embedding AI into advisor workflows, including its Talk Tracks capability designed to surface insights and potential planning conversations before client meetings. Could AI make the advisor-client relationship less personal? (30:12) Michael acknowledges the risk but sees a larger opportunity. As clients arrive better informed through AI, advisors can differentiate through more personal, emotionally connected guidance around the issues that matter most. How should advisors think about scale as fee pressure continues? (41:12) For Michael, scale does not simply mean cutting costs. It means using technology, people, outsourcing, and other resources to deliver a better client experience more efficiently. Where would Michael invest first if he were running an independent RIA? (43:11) Existing clients come first. Before M&A or other growth investments, he would invest in making the client experience stronger and the firm easier to do business with. Key Takeaways Growth requires intention. The firms Michael sees growing most successfully do not treat growth as a side project; they plan for it, invest in it, and consistently execute against it. Organic growth is a measure of business health. Beyond adding assets, it can signal the durability and potential enterprise value of an advisory firm. Capacity has become a strategic advantage. Advisors need to determine which activities require their direct involvement and which can be delegated, outsourced, or automated. The advisor’s value proposition is expanding. Portfolio management increasingly sits alongside tax planning, wealth transfer, estate planning, and other advice that clients expect from a trusted “wealth counselor.” AI should create better conversations, not simply greater efficiency. Michael sees the bigger opportunity in using AI to improve both productivity and the client experience. Scale is not synonymous with cost-cutting. Strategic investments in technology, talent, and outside expertise can allow firms to serve clients better while managing economic pressure. Client experience remains the foundation. Even when presented with opportunities to pursue M&A or other investments, Michael would prioritize strengthening relationships with existing clients first. https://youtu.be/vqlWGWAD08o Quotable Moments “Growth isn’t something that the advisors do as a hobby. It is arguably the number one priority.” — Michael Kim, 13:18 “Organic growth is the number one predictor of the health of the business.” — Michael Kim, 15:27 “The most important thing that the clients want from that advisor is the advisor, not the portfolio or which ETF that they selected.” — Michael Kim, 19:23 “The advisors can do anything, but they can’t do everything.” — Michael Kim, 23:05 FAQs Why is capacity so important for financial advisor growth? Advisors face expanding client expectations while still having a finite amount of time. Michael Kim argues that creating capacity through outsourcing, technology, AI, and delegation allows advisors to spend more time on client relationships and the activities that have the greatest impact on growth. What does Michael Kim believe drives organic growth for advisory firms? He emphasizes intentionality, planning, creativity, and consistent execution. Rather than treating growth as something that happens naturally through referrals, successful firms make it an ongoing business priority. How can outsourcing investment management help financial advisors? Outsourcing can shift research, portfolio management, trading, reporting, technology, and other functions to providers with greater scale. Michael says AssetMark’s Annual Impact of Outsourcing Survey found that advisors who outsource gain more than nine hours per week. How is AssetMark using AI for financial advisors? AssetMark is embedding AI into advisor workflows with the goal of improving productivity and client experience. Michael discusses Talk Tracks, a capability designed to surface relevant client insights and potential planning conversations before meetings. Will AI replace financial advisors? Michael does not believe it will. Instead, he expects clients to use AI themselves and arrive at advisor meetings better informed. That could make an advisor’s ability to provide trusted, personal, emotionally connected guidance even more valuable. How can advisory firms scale without sacrificing client experience? Michael describes scale as more than lowering costs. Firms can invest in technology, specialized personnel, outsourcing, and other resources that allow them to operate more efficiently while improving the quality and breadth of the client experience. Advisors face expanding client expectations while still having a finite amount of time. Michael Kim argues that creating capacity through outsourcing, technology, AI, and delegation allows advisors to spend more time on client relationships and the activities that have the greatest impact on growth. He emphasizes intentionality, planning, creativity, and consistent execution. Rather than treating growth as something that happens naturally through referrals, successful firms make it an ongoing business priority. Outsourcing can shift research, portfolio management, trading, reporting, technology, and other functions to providers with greater scale. Michael says AssetMark’s Annual Impact of Outsourcing Survey found that advisors who outsource gain more than nine hours per week. AssetMark is embedding AI into advisor workflows with the goal of improving productivity and client experience. Michael discusses Talk Tracks, a capability designed to surface relevant client insights and potential planning conversations before meetings. Michael does not believe it will. Instead, he expects clients to use AI themselves and arrive at advisor meetings better informed. That could make an advisor’s ability to provide trusted, personal, emotionally connected guidance even more valuable. Michael describes scale as more than lowering costs. Firms can invest in technology, specialized personnel, outsourcing, and other resources that allow them to operate more efficiently while improving the quality and breadth of the client experience. Related Resources When Growth Starts Working Against Your Business The RIA Builder’s Blueprint: Four Pillars of a Strong Independent Firm Michael Kim Chief Executive Officer and President of AssetMark With more than 30 years of industry experience, he has set the strategic vision for the firm, which encompasses AssetMark’s platform of curated investments, technology solutions, business consulting, operations support, and M&A that serve the best interests of financial advisors and their investors. Michael joined AssetMark in 2010 and has held a number of leadership positions, including Head of National Sales and Consulting, Chief Client Officer, and President / CEO (2021–Present). Michael was instrumental during AssetMark’s leveraged buyout transition to Genstar in 2013, its sale to Huatai Securities in 2016, its IPO in 2019, and its sale to GTCR in 2024. Before joining AssetMark, Michael was an executive at Fidelity’s Institutional Wealth Services, serving over 3,000 advisory firms. He began his career in public accounting at Coopers & Lybrand, LLC. Michael received his Bachelor of Arts in Economics from the University of California, Los Angeles. NOTE: The views and opinions expressed by the guests on this podcast are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Diamond Consultants. Neither Diamond Consultants nor the guests on this podcast are compensated in any way for their participation. View the transcript of this episode… Unleashing Potential: Why Capacity is an Advisor’s Biggest Competitive Advantage A conversation with Jason Diamond and Michael Kim, CEO & President of AssetMark. Jason Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is Unleashing Potential: Why Capacity Is an Advisor’s Biggest Competitive Advantage. It’s a conversation with Michael Kim, the CEO and president of AssetMark. I’m Jason Diamond, and this is The Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education-driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Jason Diamond: One of the biggest challenges facing advisory firms today isn’t finding more opportunities, it’s creating enough capacity to pursue them. For years, advisors have tried to solve that problem by working harder, adding staff, or becoming more efficient. Today, technology, outsourcing, and AI are creating an entirely different playbook. The question isn’t simply how to do more, it’s how to spend more time doing things that actually matter. That’s why I’m excited to welcome Michael Kim to the podcast. Michael is CEO and president of AssetMark. Founded in 1996, it provides some 12,000 independent advisors and registered investment advisors, RIAs, with outsourced investment strategies, AI tools, and digital workflows, custodial integration, and practice management consulting. Over the last 16 years, he’s had a front row seat to the evolution of independent wealth management and has developed a reputation as what many know him as the growth guy. And Michael’s perspective is a practical one. He doesn’t think about growth as simply gathering more assets or acquiring more firms, he sees it as building an intentional business, one where advisors spend more time where they add the greatest value while leveraging technology, outsourcing and AI to expand their capacity without losing sight of what matters most, delivering an exceptional client experience. Our conversation covers where advisors should and shouldn’t be spending their time, why organic growth remains the best measure of a healthy business, how AI can strengthen rather than replace client relationships, and why the advisors who thrive over the next decade may look much more like CEOs than portfolio managers. I think you’ll come away with a different way of approaching growth, and perhaps more importantly what it actually takes to achieve it. So, let’s dive in. Michael, thanks again for joining us. Before we dive into the business, let’s talk about the personal. Tell us about your background, what brought you to the world of wealth management. Michael Kim: Yeah, first of all, Jason, thrilled to be here. Thank you for having me, I’m looking forward to our conversation. My goodness, what brought me to this industry? There’s several reasons. First and foremost, I love working with other people and specifically in a position where we can help others. How fortunate are we, Jason, where we get to work with, in my opinion, the best financial advisors where their core mission is to help others, and specifically helping their clients’ goals and dreams come true, and we get to be part of that? And just for me to be and our teams to be part of that, that is just humbling and exciting. That’s one of the big reasons. Let’s see, I love working with the business owners and entrepreneurs. I have a little bit of entrepreneurial gene, both of my parents are entrepreneurs as well. So Jason, I know you could appreciate that. Working with entrepreneurs, and for me it is all about relationships. Really being able to build deep, personal, professional relationships where we can learn off of each other, help each other, and really do good for clients, the community, and the industry. My goodness, what a perfect industry to be in. I mean, those are just some of the reasons that brought me to this great place. I’ve been with AssetMark for, gosh, now 16 years. Just still feels like day number one here, Jason, but I know we’ll get into a lot more details, but so many different things that have brought me here to this industry. Jason Diamond: Wow, 16 years. I definitely want to double click into that. I’m sure you’ve seen the firm evolve a lot. By the way, I feel like you feel, what a blessing and what an amazing industry. Of all the industries in the world and of all the kind of verticals and niches, I just think it’s such an incredible, not only industry, but an incredible time in our industry. Part of that is the proliferation of choice for advisors, and how many different ways there are for an advisor to run a sophisticated, successful, entrepreneurial business. No matter what that could mean within a wirehouse, by the way. I don’t mean that to mean independent. So, I want to talk about all of that. I think your perspective is unique. Whole career at AssetMark or did you start elsewhere? That’s the last question we’ll ask on background. Michael Kim: Yeah, so like I said, 16 years here at AssetMark, and I’ve had pretty much all the different leadership responsibilities here. I became president and CEO a few years ago. The other interesting part of my journey here at AssetMark is over that 16-year period, Jason, five different owners. My goodness, five different sort of capital providers and owners and investors coming into the business. We’ve had the fortune of working with large strategic firms to great private equity firms. We even took the company public, so we did the whole New York Stock Exchange, ringing the bell and the whole nine yards. And in 2024, we took the company private again, and we’re just super excited. Our current owner is GTCR, just incredible private equity investors, partners, friends. And we’ve actually known those guys for a number of years before the deal. And through series of different conversations, it was just the right fit. And we’ve been with them for over two years now, and I just feel like we’re just barely scratch the surface, Jason, in terms of all the different things that we can do with them. And let’s see, prior to AssetMark, I was with Fidelity, we were talking a little earlier, and that’s where I cut my teeth. And I had a chance to work with RIA firms, I was managing all the RIA wealth management relationships at Fidelity for a number of years, spent a big portion of my Fidelity tenure in Boston, as all roads go through Boston for Fidelity. Jason Diamond: We’re going Boston, baby. Michael Kim: Exactly. And Jason, you know what’s really interesting is I started with Fidelity back in the late ’90s, and back then, my goodness, people really didn’t know the RIA industry. We’d have to remind them it’s RIA, not IRA, that whole nine yards. And it’s just really special to see the RIA and the independent industry just grow to what it is today and just really making that impact to the clients. I know we’ll dig into a lot more of those details. And then actually prior to Fidelity, I’m a CPA by training. So, I’m a recovering CPA, as I like to say, and no accounting jokes, Jason, today here. All right? Jason Diamond: I didn’t prepare any. No promises though. A couple things I want to ask you about. First of all, position the positives of the various owners you’ve had. That sounds also though potentially disruptive, 5 different owners in 15 years. Thoughts on that? And then, the other thing is not a question, more of a compliment. I always think people of Fidelity Schwab in the ’90s, early 2000s, part of me feels like you must want to say a little bit like, “I told you so. We were right about this call and this movement.” So, if you want to use this platform to do so, you’re welcome to. Michael Kim: Well, it’s funny, I’ll take the second part of the question first. It is interesting just reflecting back on the earlier days of the RIA industry. Back in the ’90s, I mean, it was such a cottage industry. Most of our time was really spent on educating not just advisors but other players in the industry about what it means to be an independent, trusted, fiduciary advisor to the clients. And again, in this day and age, Jason, I mean that is just part of our everyday vernacular. Jason Diamond: You take that for granted. Michael Kim: Exactly. But back then, educating the advisor that, yes, they get to control their own destiny and they get to own the economics. And most importantly, they get to really control the client experience and helping that client really fulfill their goals and dreams and the outcomes that they’ve been working together on. And so, really having that type of both a advisory discussion but also a business discussion, it’s just been super fulfilling. And I too have learned quite a bit just in terms of what it means to be both a business owner and an advisor. But that’s one of the big things that we’ve all experienced, especially in the earlier days and as this industry continues to mature. Even back then, Jason, I saw the potential and it was interesting. I remember thinking to myself, “My goodness,” not just the wires and the banks and other brokerage firms, but really again, going back to the benefit to the end client, that investor to have that trusted advisor where there was no conflict, that advisor was sitting on the same side of the table as himself and really doing what was clearly in the best interest of the client. Again, today it’s part of our DNA, part of what we talk about, but back then it was a newer concept. And so, we just feel very humble to have been part of that in the early days. I think your first question was about the different series of owners and investors that we’ve had. And again, as I reflect back on this, Jason, five different firms. We had a life insurance company, we had private equity, actually two different PE firms come together for joint ownership. We actually had a foreign brokerage firm that owned us for a number of years, and then also the being publicly traded and now being private again. My view, Jason, is that every type of capital structure, there’s pros and cons, but two things that I want to just maybe share with you and your audience is that first and foremost, regardless of the capital structure, it really is incumbent on the management team to do what’s in the best interest of the client. Again, it’s a no-brainer, but really reminding your teams that do always do what’s in the best interest of the client, and then you execute to the T and the rest should usually take care of itself, number one. And then number two, what we’ve learned is never forget about the culture of your firm. Regardless of, again, the capital structure and the type of priorities that different owners, investors ask you to focus on, absolutely those are important business priorities, but none of that would be possible, Jason, without the right culture, and really all the different employees and colleagues and teammates growing in the same direction, Jason. And again, we’ll get into a lot more because there’s actually a great level of parallel in terms of the lessons that we learn to what we’re seeing in the advisor community as they’re operating their own businesses. So, I know we’ll unpack a lot of that, but those are just some of the themes that I recall as I think about our journey here. Jason Diamond: That’s a really thoughtful answer, thank you. I want to ask you a question on clarifying. You used the term clients. When you think about your clients, you are talking about financial advisors who in turn are serving their end clients. Is that correct? Michael Kim: That’s right. Jason Diamond: Let’s talk about this. You’ve worked with, whether it’s Fidelity or now the last 16 years I would imagine thousands of advisors, probably mostly independent advisors. And growth, at least today is the number one thing in our conversations that comes up of advisors that want to grow. What do you think separates advisors who are able to grow from those who are not, or are less effective at it? Michael Kim: Yeah, great question. So just by the way, context, today at AssetMark we work with over 12,000 individual financial advisors, and at Fidelity, thousands of independent RIA firms. And so, we’ve been very fortunate to have seen, Jason, a lot of different models and best practices. And to your point about growth- Jason Diamond: And worst practices. Michael Kim: Well, we’ll keep it best practices here, and lots of incredible lessons learned as well. Jason, what’s interesting is I think one of the common threads that we see in the most successfully growth-oriented firms has been the advisors and their teams are intentional about growth. And what I mean by that is growth isn’t something that the advisors do as a hobby. It is arguably the number one priority. In fact, we have a saying here at AssetMark that growth is life. And if you’re not growing, you’re dead. So, a big part of the focus is, okay, how do we put the right plan together? A simple thing like a marketing plan. I mean, Jason, it is amazing the opportunity that we have to help advisors really craft their own marketing narrative and the unique capabilities that they bring. So, let’s talk about it and let’s figure out ways to leverage that secret sauce to drive referrals and other new opportunities. And so, really having that intentional focus starting with a marketing plan. And to me, I always suggest to our advisors that let’s get creative. Let’s not try to do the same old things and keep banging our head against the wall. Let’s try new things, let’s learn from it, let’s fine-tune it. I mean, things like digital leads and really leveraging the social media aspect. Most advisors still are not, I would say comfortable or confident in leveraging the digital platforms or different channels. To me, this is a huge opportunity for advisors, for other enterprises to leverage the digital platforms to get their word out and really leverage that in a way to drive new opportunities. And then the third is execution. My goodness, you can get creative, you can have all kinds of great marketing strategies, but if you’re not executing and doing the things that you say you’re going to do, and do it right and do it again the next day, it’s all for show. And so, we always talk about how do we help our advisors come up with the best marketing strategy, get creative in some of those ideas, and then let’s go roll up our sleeves and let’s go execute, let’s really bring those great ideas to reality, and let’s figure out a way to fine-tune it, sharpen it, do it better, and the next day do it all over again. And just being intentional, Jason, to sum it all up, I think is a huge part of what growth is all about. And I guess last thing I’ll mention here is, Jason, you know this, but I just can’t stress this enough. Organic growth is the number one predictor of the health of the business. I’m speaking from experience. I mean, the five different owners and the capital provider changes that we’ve experienced, one of the key things that they’ve always asked for and we’ve demonstrated in the early parts of our conversations is our ability to grow the business. That organic growth, again, it is a huge part of that strategic business consideration. Jason Diamond: Well, I totally agree with that. There’s an element of organic growth is probably the number one predictor of a healthy, vibrant business. And also to your point, because some advisors say, “Okay, great. Who cares? My business is good enough for me.” But to your point, a buyer cares about it so it impacts valuation as well. You gave a really thoughtful answer as to the question of growth and intentionality around growth, I maybe should have started here. Your answer was broader than I maybe expected, so give us the elevator pitch for AssetMark. What does your company do? Michael Kim: Yeah, so at AssetMark we are in the business of serving independent financial advisors as the premier wealth platform. We focus on delivering the best investment experience with the most integrated digital technology and the most personalized service and experience. The last thing that we always talk about is really the community of like-minded advisors that we support. As I mentioned, we are fortunate to serve over 12,000 plus individual financial advisors in the independent space. And we talk a lot about community. And the reason for that, Jason, is in many cases the advisors are out there on the island to themselves and they are wondering about things like growth. And so, what we try to bring in is really a lot of the peer-to-peer type of learning, opportunity for different advisors to connect with one another, learn from each other, and really sharpen their value proposition or their narrative. And so that community aspect, it is something special. And we actually have many advisors, Jason, where it’s the third generation advisor that have been working with AssetMark that have been connecting with one another. When you go to some of our conferences and events, I always like to say it is the industry’s largest study group out there. And so, we get to be part of that and we get to host that. And so anyway, that’s a little bit about the AssetMark store, we are in business of serving independent financial advisors. Jason Diamond: I think there’s a lot of different elements of that value prop that we can talk about, but the one that I think is probably most closely associated in the market is investment management. Let’s talk about investment management, or more specifically the idea of outsourcing investment management to somebody else. Because especially for wirehouse advisors, I think there’s this perception, real or not, that’s a core part of what an advisor does. And I’ve seen the statistics, I know that most advisors are not particularly good at investment management, but they’ve sold their clients on this is a part of what we do for you, financial planning, investment management, and the like. So, what say you? What are your thoughts on the idea that investment management has to be a part of the core financial advisor experience? Michael Kim: Yeah. No, totally get it. And I mean, we have thousands and thousands of conversations about this very issue. And Jason, you’re right. I mean, so many advisors believe that their value to their clients is about building the best 60/40 balance portfolio. And with all that in mind, in this day and age with technology and really accessibility to the different investment products and strategies, what advisors have to realize is that the most important thing that the clients want from that advisor is the advisor, not the portfolio or which ETF that they selected. The number one thing, and this is based on the most recent spectrum survey, the number one thing that particularly the higher net worth investors, what they ask and what they expect from their advisors isn’t a investment product or a portfolio design, it’s actually advice on taxes and wealth transfer. Think about that. They want to know how that advisor is going to help them optimize their taxes, they want to know how the wealth that they worked so hard their entire life, how that’s going to be passed on in the most tax-efficient and the most consistent way, consistent with their goals and objectives to their adult children, et cetera. And so, part of I think the new age perspective has to be that the advisor really positioning themselves as that trusted, holistic advisor. A wealth counselor is really the term that I like to use. As a wealth counselor, yes, investment management is an important part, but it’s one of number of different components that the clients are expecting. And Jason, when I think about the more successful advisors in our ecosystem, they’re leading with taxes, they’re leading with creating trust for their grandchildren, they’re leading with creating family LLCs and how all of that fits into the broader picture. Because in this day and age of creating a good 60/40 portfolio, I think those are table stakes at this point. And so, a big part of this is how do we help the advisors really broaden their expertise so that they feel confident in talking about these other array of services? Frankly, these services that their clients are expecting and demanding that their advisors deliver. And last thing I’ll mention is here’s the cold harsh reality. If that advisor isn’t delivering those types of services, especially to that next gen client, guess what? That next gen client who’s about to inherit a lot of the wealth from their parents and so forth, they’re probably looking and in conversations with other advisors as well. And so, we just want to ensure that there’s a longevity of the client relationships by helping that advisor deliver a full array of the wealth planning capabilities. You could tell I’m pretty passionate about this, Jason, I can go on, but yeah, this is a very important part of one of the key developments that we’re seeing in the industry. Jason Diamond: I could tell I’m not the first person to ask you, I wouldn’t have expected that I’d be the first person to ask you this. It was a very thoughtful answer. I think part of what you’re saying is because advisors need to deliver so much, probably more than ever, because a lot of what you’re describing is table stakes, outsourcing investment management is the only way to get there. It’s a zero-sum game, you have finite amount of time, and what your clients are saying is they want more of you. So, by giving up some of what’s table stakes into a more systematic kind of process, you’re able to do more. Is that a fair summary? Michael Kim: Absolutely, and you hit the nail on the head. I mean, it is all about time management and capacity. Yes, the advisors can do anything, but they can’t do everything. And so, what they have to really make a strategic decision on is what are the activities that will generate the highest level of impact to the clients, and frankly to their business? And so, delegate and outsource the other activities, whether it be research, portfolio management, trading, reporting, technology, et cetera, to a provider that has the scale and really delivering those types of capabilities so that advisor can spend the extra time with a client. And just one last unique stat or insight to share. We do a survey every year, Jason, and I would be happy to make this study available to your audience. It’s called Annual Impact of Outsourcing Survey, and it measures the amount of extra time created by those advisors who’ve made a conscious decision to outsource. This year it’s over nine hours per week. So, think about that. Nine extra hours per week today. And so, that’s like having an extra day in a week plus. And so, that’s just an example of the type of capacity that outsourcing creates. The other important benefit to this is not just freeing up time and creating capacity, but now you get to deliver other experts and other resources to your clients, and you get to be, you meaning the advisor, becomes really the quarterback for all those different experts that are serving that client relationships. And so again, it’s something that we believe is fundamental. We absolutely believe that’s going to be a key part that will fuel the advisor’s growth going forward as well. Jason Diamond: So it’s a perfect segue, because I agree. The capacity conversation, it comes up over and over again. In fact, one of the ways it manifests itself is obviously as a recruiter, we hear about movement and it becomes a catalyst for movement. Like, “Hey, I’m spending all my time doing the wrong things and I need to spend more time doing XYZ.” The other thing that comes to mind when we think about capacity, yes, I hear you, outsourcing. There’s clearly elements like compliance. Yeah, you don’t need to be doing that yourself, you can outsource that. But what about AI would be the other obvious way to me that advisors can force multiply themselves? Give me your thoughts on A, what are you guys doing in this space? And then B, what are your thoughts just on the impact on the wealth management industry at large? Michael Kim: Yeah, great question. You can’t have a podcast or any conversation this day and age without AI, right? Jason Diamond: No. You knew it was coming, sorry. Michael Kim: No, this is great. And look, I mean, personally I believe that AI is going to change everything. Now, what does that really mean? Two areas that we think a lot about both internally at AssetMark, but also what we believe we can expect to see in the industry. Number one, it’s all about productivity. And then number two, it’s about experience. So, how do we think about positioning AI, leveraging AI to improve productivity, and more importantly, delivering even a better experience? And so, internally at AssetMark, we’re doing all the different things in terms of all of our Zoom meetings, the virtual meetings, the note-taking and so forth. To me, again, those are table stakes now. And advisors themselves as well, as they’re having these types of meetings, using all the usual products in the industry that we’re all very familiar with, making sure that is a core part of, I guess the workflow to really streamline and expedite the follow-up process, the notes and summaries of the conversations. A specific example, one of the things that we launched is really around Slack, our enterprise level for ChatGPT and so forth. Again, it is just something that is accelerating the pace of business internally at AssetMark. From an experience point of view, Jason, oh my goodness, we can go on and on on this. At AssetMark, a big part of what we think about is how do we embed AI into the workflow so that it’s just regular part of how we do things as opposed to going somewhere, maybe figuring out how to work with an agent and this and that? We are in the process of launching a new capability called Talk Tracks. And so, this is actually for advisors. So, an advisor who taps into our website right before a client meeting, we will literally create talk tracks for that advisor on what are some of the insights that they should share with their client on their portfolio? Maybe they should be taking a required minimum distribution. Maybe they should be thinking about opening up a 529 because they have grandchildren, or maybe they should be doing some other planning activities. The point is it uses AI to gather the different data points, not just from the client but really just scouring the entire industry and other clients with similar profiles, and bringing in different suggestions literally as bullet point talk points for the advisor. And just based on early feedback, man, Jason, this is like our advisors love it. I mean, our advisors are saying that program alone, Talk Tracks, has really saved about two hours per day, because normally they would have to figure out the talking points for the upcoming meeting, and we will be doing all of that for that advisor. And so again, we believe that productivity will be super enhanced. And then the experience is, to me, that is where the gold mine is in terms of opportunities for AI to contribute. And last thing I’ll mention here, you and I, we often get the question of, “Okay, what does this mean for advisors? Will AI replace advisors and so forth?” No, because investors, at the end of the day they want that emotional security of knowing that they’re going to be okay. Now having said that, I do believe that advisors need to change how they engage with their clients, because that client is going to be coming into that meeting with the advisor having done their research, having asked their best friend ChatGPT about what to expect in that upcoming meeting. It’s very analogous to, I don’t know about you, but if I go see my doctor, I go to WebMD and I’m asking WebMD, “Okay, what should I be thinking about? These are my symptoms,” et cetera, so that I can actually have a much more intelligent, impactful conversation with my physician. I don’t see anything different in that the clients, the end clients will come in with some level of preliminary research, virtual conversation with their friend Chat, and then that allows that engagement with their trusted advisor to be that much It’s more meaningful. And so, I absolutely believe that it will really enhance the client experience provided that the advisors are prepared for this type of a change in the industry. Jason Diamond: And that’s an interesting spin, the idea that clients themselves will use the tool to get better educated, to basically become better clients for advisors. One thing that comes to mind with some of your talk points, I think it’s a brilliant idea. I think it’s clearly another obvious example of capacity saver. Do you think there’s a risk with that and with just AI tools in general of depersonalizing the relationship and just almost making things a little bit cookie cutter? I’ll tell you what comes to mind for me is I can tell in some cases when I get an AI email, and it makes me cringe. I’m not even talking about a spam email, I’m talking about an email that somebody tried to write to me but they used AI as a way to basically write me three paragraphs. So, give me your thoughts on is there a risk here that this just becomes this really depersonalized experience? Michael Kim: Absolutely, I do think that there’s that risk there. I do believe that it’s actually happening already. If you think about just the basics of portfolio construction and just different investment vehicles, whether it’s an ETF fund, security, what have you, chances are that advisor will come into that meeting having done some research and they may know or be more familiar with the underlying vehicles than the past generation. So, the advisors who’s hanging their hat on portfolio construction, that 60/40 balance portfolio that I alluded to earlier as really the reason why that client should be working with them, that is going to be a very non-personal or less personal relationship. Now, imagine even with AI though, that the advisor has cracked a code on how to humanize that engagement and really deliver much more of an emotionally connected experience. That’s where I think the advisors will have an opportunity to really elevate. So as I said earlier, think about those advisors that have not only built really a durable portfolio to help that client achieve their portfolio goals, but wrapping that with tax planning, wrapping that with family planning or estate planning, and really being that first call that the clients make in the event of something, something happens, that’s where the real emotions come in. And part of it is this evolution that the advisors are on where Jason, you know this better than I do, in the past they were brokers and now recently they were more the investment portfolio managers. And then really going forward it’s about how do they deliver that real deeply personal and that trusted engagement about wealth transfer, about tax management, about business exit planning if they’re business owners. And really those are the moments where the advisors will not only earn their keep, but elevate themselves from rest of the pack. I absolutely believe that this evolution and the opportunity that frankly AI and other developments are catalyzing, if positioned properly the advisors can benefit from this type of a change in an incredible way. Jason Diamond: I think there’s tremendous opportunity for advisors that harness this the right way. It brings me to an interesting question. I don’t think everybody who listens to our show is contemplating change or making a change of firms, but certainly there’s a subset of advisors who are at least curious. And technology is one area. It always comes up. I wonder, advisors don’t know what they don’t know in this realm. So, I think about a wirehouse advisor who’s been conditioned to think that the sandbox is the sandbox and it works well enough, and it probably does. They can service clients within that sandbox. So, how is that wirehouse advisor supposed to think about this new world that you’re talking about where he doesn’t even know the right questions to ask because it’s so completely foreign? Michael Kim: It’s such a great question, and it’s an important question that all advisors, particularly ones that are in a wirehouse or captive type of environment should be asking. And I think if you double click that question, it’s about how do they become even a better trusted advisor to their clients? Number one. And then number two, could they also build their own business as well? Meaning could they become a business owner or entrepreneur and control their own destiny? And to me, as we were talking earlier about the growth of the independent space, the independent, the industry is, I mean, this is where these two themes are hitting the road. One of the biggest opportunities that I see is for advisors to not only fulfill the goals and dreams of their end clients, but actually for themselves and for their office mates and for their colleagues as well. Why not? Why not create their own entity that they can control, and really control their own destiny in terms of the desired business outcomes? Now to your point, most advisors don’t know how to really plug in a CRM with a financial planning, with a portfolio management system and how all those things work. And compliance, you mentioned that earlier is such an important part. So, the big thing is how does that advisor continue to focus first and foremost on their clients, but bringing in outsource partners that can help them deliver to this fully integrated tech stack, this workflow that will actually create a better experience for their team, but also for their clients as well? And then growth. How do they really think about growth within the firm, but also leveraging outside experts like AssetMark and others to really get that next high net worth client? And so, the point is the advisor shouldn’t feel like they have to do all of this work on their own. Really leverage the different experts that are out there. And Jason, I mean, you know exactly all the different things that wirehouse advisors should do as they’re contemplating different affiliation models. Similarly, if the advisor is looking for that easy button on investments, or technology, or growth or what have you, leverage the different industry experts out there that are in the business of helping advisors achieve those goals. So, it’s one of those things where it may feel daunting initially, but really the opportunity that we have is to educate those advisors and share with them on how we can really help their business goals come true as well. Jason Diamond: Yeah, it’s a good answer. To me, there’s two ways to think about the Kitces map, if you will, of the massive ecosystem. On the one hand, it’s overwhelming and daunting. But on the other hand, you mentioned the term cottage industry. Think about how far from a FinTech perspective and an investment tech perspective, and just a wealth management tech perspective the industry has come where it’s a blessing that all of these different solutions exist. And also, part and parcel to all these solutions is there’s a lot of different education solutions out there also. So, I think that’s the number one takeaway is advisors not feeling like they need to do this alone because there are so many different options. I think your lens into this is unique given the number of advisors, that you need literally thousands of advisors. So, we spoke about AI, we spoke about this outsourcing. What is another maybe trend or something you’re keeping your eye on, or something you’re hearing from your advisors that our audience might not be aware of? Give us a preview. Michael Kim: Yeah. So for me, I’m a growth guy, Jason, and I always come back to growth. And the number one, I think about the organic growth aspect. And we can spend hours on this, but probably two things that I just want to share with your audience. Organic growth, not only is it the best measure on the health and really the durability of the business, but it also is really like the north star. It should be the north star of any business. I mean, new clients is a lifeblood of any business out there. And so, part of being a business owner means thinking strategically about how do I continue to lead this new teammates and the new firm to ensure that there’s continuous pipeline of new clients coming in for all the different reasons that we talked about. Number two, have a plan. I know it sounds simple, but have a plan. And there are people like yourselves and our firm and others that can help. When I think about what does that plan should entail, just start with existing clients. How do I help retain and grow my existing clients? And then number two, how do I get a few more new clients? And that could be referrals, that could be other lead generation programs, but just really put those thoughts on paper. Anyway, so organic growth. And then, on the inorganic growth side, this is, Jason, where there’s just so much activity and here’s the best part. I still feel like, Jason, we are in the bottom of first inning of this massive pace of not just consolidation, but really the growth of this independent segment. Experts like yourselves and others that are helping the wire or others, advisors in other ecosystems come in to this independent space. Succession, we haven’t talked about that today, but succession I think is going to be a massive tailwind behind many of these consolidations. And then the third thing that I’ll mention is the access to capital. I heard someone say the other day that capital is commodity. Before, that was the key thing that was either a catalyst or maybe a headwind for this type of inorganic growth. Today, capital is somewhat of a commodity. And so, there’s so many different PE investors or institutional firms that are coming into this space. And so, part of it is to really thinking about what your right target audience is and how your structure and your strategy is going to be different than the guy next door and making sure that you execute. And the capital will be there. Believe me, the capital will be there. And I just think, Jason, that the inorganic growth opportunity is going to continue to accelerate in this space here. Jason Diamond: There’s PE money coming into the space? I hadn’t heard that before. Michael Kim: Yeah, it’s maybe one or two. Jason Diamond: Let me ask you a few follow-ups there. I think that the tie-in there, the thing that people might be worried about then would be decompression, whether it’s because firms need to just spend more because advisor needs, whatever the case may be. Do you think that it’s the same playbook for advisors to avoid that? Lean into AI tools, lean into things like outsourcing, lean into M&A inorganic, things like that? Or is there more to it? Or is this just something that you don’t worry about at all? Michael Kim: No, I mean, we worry, we study, we keep a very close eye on the fee trends out there. And there is always pressure on the fees, and I think it’s healthy that there’s pressure on the fees. I think a big part of when we talk about fees, the other word that is synonymous with the fee compression is scale. Are we able to scale? Are the advisors able to scale in terms of their delivery mechanisms and their operations? And so, what scale means is being … Doesn’t necessarily mean cutting expenses and doing it with lower costs. To me, it is thinking more strategically about are there areas in terms of different technology that we can invest in so that over time we can deliver even a better experience in a more scaled way? Are there personnel that we can bring in to the firm that can bring a certain level of expertise that will help us take the business and the client experience to the next level? And so, there’s many different ways to scale it, but decompression is synonymous with scale. And so, as a business owner, which now advisors are both trusted advisors but also business owners, they should be thinking a lot more about how they can scale their operation. We at AssetMark, we have over 1,100 employees and we’re expecting to grow at least 20% year over year. And our view is how do we leverage AI? How do we leverage technology? How do we leverage some of the offshore contractors and other scale levers to make sure that we’re doing it without creating additional fee pressure, economic pressure to ourselves and to our clients? And so, it’s always a fun exercise to go through. We’re actually starting a planning process already, but scale aspect, Jason, is an important part of this conversation. Jason Diamond: Good answer, yep. All right, two more. I’m going to give you a fun one here. I’m giving you a lateral, I don’t know if this is a demotion, but let’s say you’re hypothetically you’re now CEO of a small to medium-sized independent firm, an RIA. You’ve got capital. To your point, capital is somewhat easy to come by. Here are your choices. A, you explore M&A, go buy a business right now. B, trip to Hawaii for all the founders. Or C, is there some business reinvestment that excites you that you think businesses should be doing? Michael Kim: That trip to Hawaii is very enticing, but when I think about the opportunity as a leader of the firm, call me a little bit of old-fashioned here but I go back to our existing clients as the number one place of investments. For me, we can do all kinds of really fun, sexy things, but if we don’t take care of our current base of clients, everything falls apart. And so, first and foremost, how do we take care of our clients? And for me, what that really means is how do we deliver the best service experience? At AssetMark, one of the key things that we are maniacal about is how do we continue to be known as the easiest place to do business for advisors? Similarly, for an advisory firm and the leaders of that advisory firm, I would submit that they should be thinking about how do they serve their clients so that the clients view that firm as the firm that all clients should be working with. And generally we think a lot about that day-to-day experience, delighting that client, that unexpected delight. I mean, my God, things like that. It doesn’t cost a lot, but it goes so far in terms of just really strengthening that experience. So that is, to me, the foundation. And after that, I also want to invest in additional organic growth capabilities. I think things like retirement is an incredibly underserved market. It is one of the largest segments of our wealth space, but arguably one of the more underserved markets. Jason Diamond: It’s not the sexiest space. Michael Kim: It’s not the sexiest, but it is an important … I mean, retirement is important, Jason. So we at AssetMark, we recently launched our self-directed brokerage program, and this is really opportunity for advisors to tap into the 401k accounts. It’s almost like a pre-rollover type of strategy, but that’s an example where we believe that there’s tons of opportunities even for advisors to serve their clients. And then, with whatever’s left in the checkbook, we love to look at the right advisors that we can potentially tuck into that firm and really branch out in terms of our presence. So, those are just some of the things that I think we would prioritize with some of the extra capital that may be coming into it. Jason Diamond: You’re hired. Michael Kim: And then we take that trip to Hawaii. Jason Diamond: Time for one more, this has been fantastic. I really appreciate the wisdom you’ve shared. Let’s fast-forward now 10 years. What are you hoping that people are saying about AssetMark and the role you’ve played in helping advisors to build businesses? And let’s go beyond just from a portfolio management, investment management perspective. Michael Kim: Yeah. As we look forward, and we actually have these types of conversations as part of our strategic planning session, let’s just say 10 years from now, what we want to be known as really that premier wealth platform, a business partner, a trusted business partner, a friend that advisors will view as a partner that helped them achieve their business goals. Meaning, let’s just say a wirehouse advisor who decided to come into the independent space, we were the firm that really helped them serve their clients better through our investments, digital and service, and then really help them grow to that next level. And so, we want to be known as a premier wealth platform that has really propelled the growth of the independent advisory firms to levels that they would not have been able to do on their own. And by the way, have some fun along the way. So have some fun, really be part of that special AssetMark community, that community of like-minded advisors by really helping that advisory firm achieve their strategic growth objectives. I hope that, Jason, with all of our employees, 1,100 employees coming in every day, our mission is to make a difference in the lives of our advisors and their clients, and I hope that we’re fulfilling that mission. I hope that we are working hard in 10 years as we are now, delivering on that promise and really making that impact each and every day for our valued advisors. Jason Diamond: I have no doubt you will. Thank you so much, Michael. This has been an absolute blast. Appreciate you coming on. Michael Kim: Thank you, Jason. That was a lot of fun. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously, and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms, or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions, and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook . Unleashing Potential: Why Capacity is an Advisor’s Biggest Competitive Advantage A conversation with Jason Diamond and Michael Kim, CEO & President of AssetMark. Jason Diamond: Welcome to the latest episode of our podcast series for financial advisors. Today’s episode is Unleashing Potential: Why Capacity Is an Advisor’s Biggest Competitive Advantage. It’s a conversation with Michael Kim, the CEO and president of AssetMark. I’m Jason Diamond, and this is The Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique, or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education-driven and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at 908-879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Jason Diamond: One of the biggest challenges facing advisory firms today isn’t finding more opportunities, it’s creating enough capacity to pursue them. For years, advisors have tried to solve that problem by working harder, adding staff, or becoming more efficient. Today, technology, outsourcing, and AI are creating an entirely different playbook. The question isn’t simply how to do more, it’s how to spend more time doing things that actually matter. That’s why I’m excited to welcome Michael Kim to the podcast. Michael is CEO and president of AssetMark. Founded in 1996, it provides some 12,000 independent advisors and registered investment advisors, RIAs, with outsourced investment strategies, AI tools, and digital workflows, custodial integration, and practice management consulting. Over the last 16 years, he’s had a front row seat to the evolution of independent wealth management and has developed a reputation as what many know him as the growth guy. And Michael’s perspective is a practical one. He doesn’t think about growth as simply gathering more assets or acquiring more firms, he sees it as building an intentional business, one where advisors spend more time where they add the greatest value while leveraging technology, outsourcing and AI to expand their capacity without losing sight of what matters most, delivering an exceptional client experience. Our conversation covers where advisors should and shouldn’t be spending their time, why organic growth remains the best measure of a healthy business, how AI can strengthen rather than replace client relationships, and why the advisors who thrive over the next decade may look much more like CEOs than portfolio managers. I think you’ll come away with a different way of approaching growth, and perhaps more importantly what it actually takes to achieve it. So, let’s dive in. Michael, thanks again for joining us. Before we dive into the business, let’s talk about the personal. Tell us about your background, what brought you to the world of wealth management. Michael Kim: Yeah, first of all, Jason, thrilled to be here. Thank you for having me, I’m looking forward to our conversation. My goodness, what brought me to this industry? There’s several reasons. First and foremost, I love working with other people and specifically in a position where we can help others. How fortunate are we, Jason, where we get to work with, in my opinion, the best financial advisors where their core mission is to help others, and specifically helping their clients’ goals and dreams come true, and we get to be part of that? And just for me to be and our teams to be part of that, that is just humbling and exciting. That’s one of the big reasons. Let’s see, I love working with the business owners and entrepreneurs. I have a little bit of entrepreneurial gene, both of my parents are entrepreneurs as well. So Jason, I know you could appreciate that. Working with entrepreneurs, and for me it is all about relationships. Really being able to build deep, personal, professional relationships where we can learn off of each other, help each other, and really do good for clients, the community, and the industry. My goodness, what a perfect industry to be in. I mean, those are just some of the reasons that brought me to this great place. I’ve been with AssetMark for, gosh, now 16 years. Just still feels like day number one here, Jason, but I know we’ll get into a lot more details, but so many different things that have brought me here to this industry. Jason Diamond: Wow, 16 years. I definitely want to double click into that. I’m sure you’ve seen the firm evolve a lot. By the way, I feel like you feel, what a blessing and what an amazing industry. Of all the industries in the world and of all the kind of verticals and niches, I just think it’s such an incredible, not only industry, but an incredible time in our industry. Part of that is the proliferation of choice for advisors, and how many different ways there are for an advisor to run a sophisticated, successful, entrepreneurial business. No matter what that could mean within a wirehouse, by the way. I don’t mean that to mean independent. So, I want to talk about all of that. I think your perspective is unique. Whole career at AssetMark or did you start elsewhere? That’s the last question we’ll ask on background. Michael Kim: Yeah, so like I said, 16 years here at AssetMark, and I’ve had pretty much all the different leadership responsibilities here. I became president and CEO a few years ago. The other interesting part of my journey here at AssetMark is over that 16-year period, Jason, five different owners. My goodness, five different sort of capital providers and owners and investors coming into the business. We’ve had the fortune of working with large strategic firms to great private equity firms. We even took the company public, so we did the whole New York Stock Exchange, ringing the bell and the whole nine yards. And in 2024, we took the company private again, and we’re just super excited. Our current owner is GTCR, just incredible private equity investors, partners, friends. And we’ve actually known those guys for a number of years before the deal. And through series of different conversations, it was just the right fit. And we’ve been with them for over two years now, and I just feel like we’re just barely scratch the surface, Jason, in terms of all the different things that we can do with them. And let’s see, prior to AssetMark, I was with Fidelity, we were talking a little earlier, and that’s where I cut my teeth. And I had a chance to work with RIA firms, I was managing all the RIA wealth management relationships at Fidelity for a number of years, spent a big portion of my Fidelity tenure in Boston, as all roads go through Boston for Fidelity. Jason Diamond: We’re going Boston, baby. Michael Kim: Exactly. And Jason, you know what’s really interesting is I started with Fidelity back in the late ’90s, and back then, my goodness, people really didn’t know the RIA industry. We’d have to remind them it’s RIA, not IRA, that whole nine yards. And it’s just really special to see the RIA and the independent industry just grow to what it is today and just really making that impact to the clients. I know we’ll dig into a lot more of those details. And then actually prior to Fidelity, I’m a CPA by training. So, I’m a recovering CPA, as I like to say, and no accounting jokes, Jason, today here. All right? Jason Diamond: I didn’t prepare any. No promises though. A couple things I want to ask you about. First of all, position the positives of the various owners you’ve had. That sounds also though potentially disruptive, 5 different owners in 15 years. Thoughts on that? And then, the other thing is not a question, more of a compliment. I always think people of Fidelity Schwab in the ’90s, early 2000s, part of me feels like you must want to say a little bit like, “I told you so. We were right about this call and this movement.” So, if you want to use this platform to do so, you’re welcome to. Michael Kim: Well, it’s funny, I’ll take the second part of the question first. It is interesting just reflecting back on the earlier days of the RIA industry. Back in the ’90s, I mean, it was such a cottage industry. Most of our time was really spent on educating not just advisors but other players in the industry about what it means to be an independent, trusted, fiduciary advisor to the clients. And again, in this day and age, Jason, I mean that is just part of our everyday vernacular. Jason Diamond: You take that for granted. Michael Kim: Exactly. But back then, educating the advisor that, yes, they get to control their own destiny and they get to own the economics. And most importantly, they get to really control the client experience and helping that client really fulfill their goals and dreams and the outcomes that they’ve been working together on. And so, really having that type of both a advisory discussion but also a business discussion, it’s just been super fulfilling. And I too have learned quite a bit just in terms of what it means to be both a business owner and an advisor. But that’s one of the big things that we’ve all experienced, especially in the earlier days and as this industry continues to mature. Even back then, Jason, I saw the potential and it was interesting. I remember thinking to myself, “My goodness,” not just the wires and the banks and other brokerage firms, but really again, going back to the benefit to the end client, that investor to have that trusted advisor where there was no conflict, that advisor was sitting on the same side of the table as himself and really doing what was clearly in the best interest of the client. Again, today it’s part of our DNA, part of what we talk about, but back then it was a newer concept. And so, we just feel very humble to have been part of that in the early days. I think your first question was about the different series of owners and investors that we’ve had. And again, as I reflect back on this, Jason, five different firms. We had a life insurance company, we had private equity, actually two different PE firms come together for joint ownership. We actually had a foreign brokerage firm that owned us for a number of years, and then also the being publicly traded and now being private again. My view, Jason, is that every type of capital structure, there’s pros and cons, but two things that I want to just maybe share with you and your audience is that first and foremost, regardless of the capital structure, it really is incumbent on the management team to do what’s in the best interest of the client. Again, it’s a no-brainer, but really reminding your teams that do always do what’s in the best interest of the client, and then you execute to the T and the rest should usually take care of itself, number one. And then number two, what we’ve learned is never forget about the culture of your firm. Regardless of, again, the capital structure and the type of priorities that different owners, investors ask you to focus on, absolutely those are important business priorities, but none of that would be possible, Jason, without the right culture, and really all the different employees and colleagues and teammates growing in the same direction, Jason. And again, we’ll get into a lot more because there’s actually a great level of parallel in terms of the lessons that we learn to what we’re seeing in the advisor community as they’re operating their own businesses. So, I know we’ll unpack a lot of that, but those are just some of the themes that I recall as I think about our journey here. Jason Diamond: That’s a really thoughtful answer, thank you. I want to ask you a question on clarifying. You used the term clients. When you think about your clients, you are talking about financial advisors who in turn are serving their end clients. Is that correct? Michael Kim: That’s right. Jason Diamond: Let’s talk about this. You’ve worked with, whether it’s Fidelity or now the last 16 years I would imagine thousands of advisors, probably mostly independent advisors. And growth, at least today is the number one thing in our conversations that comes up of advisors that want to grow. What do you think separates advisors who are able to grow from those who are not, or are less effective at it? Michael Kim: Yeah, great question. So just by the way, context, today at AssetMark we work with over 12,000 individual financial advisors, and at Fidelity, thousands of independent RIA firms. And so, we’ve been very fortunate to have seen, Jason, a lot of different models and best practices. And to your point about growth- Jason Diamond: And worst practices. Michael Kim: Well, we’ll keep it best practices here, and lots of incredible lessons learned as well. Jason, what’s interesting is I think one of the common threads that we see in the most successfully growth-oriented firms has been the advisors and their teams are intentional about growth. And what I mean by that is growth isn’t something that the advisors do as a hobby. It is arguably the number one priority. In fact, we have a saying here at AssetMark that growth is life. And if you’re not growing, you’re dead. So, a big part of the focus is, okay, how do we put the right plan together? A simple thing like a marketing plan. I mean, Jason, it is amazing the opportunity that we have to help advisors really craft their own marketing narrative and the unique capabilities that they bring. So, let’s talk about it and let’s figure out ways to leverage that secret sauce to drive referrals and other new opportunities. And so, really having that intentional focus starting with a marketing plan. And to me, I always suggest to our advisors that let’s get creative. Let’s not try to do the same old things and keep banging our head against the wall. Let’s try new things, let’s learn from it, let’s fine-tune it. I mean, things like digital leads and really leveraging the social media aspect. Most advisors still are not, I would say comfortable or confident in leveraging the digital platforms or different channels. To me, this is a huge opportunity for advisors, for other enterprises to leverage the digital platforms to get their word out and really leverage that in a way to drive new opportunities. And then the third is execution. My goodness, you can get creative, you can have all kinds of great marketing strategies, but if you’re not executing and doing the things that you say you’re going to do, and do it right and do it again the next day, it’s all for show. And so, we always talk about how do we help our advisors come up with the best marketing strategy, get creative in some of those ideas, and then let’s go roll up our sleeves and let’s go execute, let’s really bring those great ideas to reality, and let’s figure out a way to fine-tune it, sharpen it, do it better, and the next day do it all over again. And just being intentional, Jason, to sum it all up, I think is a huge part of what growth is all about. And I guess last thing I’ll mention here is, Jason, you know this, but I just can’t stress this enough. Organic growth is the number one predictor of the health of the business. I’m speaking from experience. I mean, the five different owners and the capital provider changes that we’ve experienced, one of the key things that they’ve always asked for and we’ve demonstrated in the early parts of our conversations is our ability to grow the business. That organic growth, again, it is a huge part of that strategic business consideration. Jason Diamond: Well, I totally agree with that. There’s an element of organic growth is probably the number one predictor of a healthy, vibrant business. And also to your point, because some advisors say, “Okay, great. Who cares? My business is good enough for me.” But to your point, a buyer cares about it so it impacts valuation as well. You gave a really thoughtful answer as to the question of growth and intentionality around growth, I maybe should have started here. Your answer was broader than I maybe expected, so give us the elevator pitch for AssetMark. What does your company do? Michael Kim: Yeah, so at AssetMark we are in the business of serving independent financial advisors as the premier wealth platform. We focus on delivering the best investment experience with the most integrated digital technology and the most personalized service and experience. The last thing that we always talk about is really the community of like-minded advisors that we support. As I mentioned, we are fortunate to serve over 12,000 plus individual financial advisors in the independent space. And we talk a lot about community. And the reason for that, Jason, is in many cases the advisors are out there on the island to themselves and they are wondering about things like growth. And so, what we try to bring in is really a lot of the peer-to-peer type of learning, opportunity for different advisors to connect with one another, learn from each other, and really sharpen their value proposition or their narrative. And so that community aspect, it is something special. And we actually have many advisors, Jason, where it’s the third generation advisor that have been working with AssetMark that have been connecting with one another. When you go to some of our conferences and events, I always like to say it is the industry’s largest study group out there. And so, we get to be part of that and we get to host that. And so anyway, that’s a little bit about the AssetMark store, we are in business of serving independent financial advisors. Jason Diamond: I think there’s a lot of different elements of that value prop that we can talk about, but the one that I think is probably most closely associated in the market is investment management. Let’s talk about investment management, or more specifically the idea of outsourcing investment management to somebody else. Because especially for wirehouse advisors, I think there’s this perception, real or not, that’s a core part of what an advisor does. And I’ve seen the statistics, I know that most advisors are not particularly good at investment management, but they’ve sold their clients on this is a part of what we do for you, financial planning, investment management, and the like. So, what say you? What are your thoughts on the idea that investment management has to be a part of the core financial advisor experience? Michael Kim: Yeah. No, totally get it. And I mean, we have thousands and thousands of conversations about this very issue. And Jason, you’re right. I mean, so many advisors believe that their value to their clients is about building the best 60/40 balance portfolio. And with all that in mind, in this day and age with technology and really accessibility to the different investment products and strategies, what advisors have to realize is that the most important thing that the clients want from that advisor is the advisor, not the portfolio or which ETF that they selected. The number one thing, and this is based on the most recent spectrum survey, the number one thing that particularly the higher net worth investors, what they ask and what they expect from their advisors isn’t a investment product or a portfolio design, it’s actually advice on taxes and wealth transfer. Think about that. They want to know how that advisor is going to help them optimize their taxes, they want to know how the wealth that they worked so hard their entire life, how that’s going to be passed on in the most tax-efficient and the most consistent way, consistent with their goals and objectives to their adult children, et cetera. And so, part of I think the new age perspective has to be that the advisor really positioning themselves as that trusted, holistic advisor. A wealth counselor is really the term that I like to use. As a wealth counselor, yes, investment management is an important part, but it’s one of number of different components that the clients are expecting. And Jason, when I think about the more successful advisors in our ecosystem, they’re leading with taxes, they’re leading with creating trust for their grandchildren, they’re leading with creating family LLCs and how all of that fits into the broader picture. Because in this day and age of creating a good 60/40 portfolio, I think those are table stakes at this point. And so, a big part of this is how do we help the advisors really broaden their expertise so that they feel confident in talking about these other array of services? Frankly, these services that their clients are expecting and demanding that their advisors deliver. And last thing I’ll mention is here’s the cold harsh reality. If that advisor isn’t delivering those types of services, especially to that next gen client, guess what? That next gen client who’s about to inherit a lot of the wealth from their parents and so forth, they’re probably looking and in conversations with other advisors as well. And so, we just want to ensure that there’s a longevity of the client relationships by helping that advisor deliver a full array of the wealth planning capabilities. You could tell I’m pretty passionate about this, Jason, I can go on, but yeah, this is a very important part of one of the key developments that we’re seeing in the industry. Jason Diamond: I could tell I’m not the first person to ask you, I wouldn’t have expected that I’d be the first person to ask you this. It was a very thoughtful answer. I think part of what you’re saying is because advisors need to deliver so much, probably more than ever, because a lot of what you’re describing is table stakes, outsourcing investment management is the only way to get there. It’s a zero-sum game, you have finite amount of time, and what your clients are saying is they want more of you. So, by giving up some of what’s table stakes into a more systematic kind of process, you’re able to do more. Is that a fair summary? Michael Kim: Absolutely, and you hit the nail on the head. I mean, it is all about time management and capacity. Yes, the advisors can do anything, but they can’t do everything. And so, what they have to really make a strategic decision on is what are the activities that will generate the highest level of impact to the clients, and frankly to their business? And so, delegate and outsource the other activities, whether it be research, portfolio management, trading, reporting, technology, et cetera, to a provider that has the scale and really delivering those types of capabilities so that advisor can spend the extra time with a client. And just one last unique stat or insight to share. We do a survey every year, Jason, and I would be happy to make this study available to your audience. It’s called Annual Impact of Outsourcing Survey, and it measures the amount of extra time created by those advisors who’ve made a conscious decision to outsource. This year it’s over nine hours per week. So, think about that. Nine extra hours per week today. And so, that’s like having an extra day in a week plus. And so, that’s just an example of the type of capacity that outsourcing creates. The other important benefit to this is not just freeing up time and creating capacity, but now you get to deliver other experts and other resources to your clients, and you get to be, you meaning the advisor, becomes really the quarterback for all those different experts that are serving that client relationships. And so again, it’s something that we believe is fundamental. We absolutely believe that’s going to be a key part that will fuel the advisor’s growth going forward as well. Jason Diamond: So it’s a perfect segue, because I agree. The capacity conversation, it comes up over and over again. In fact, one of the ways it manifests itself is obviously as a recruiter, we hear about movement and it becomes a catalyst for movement. Like, “Hey, I’m spending all my time doing the wrong things and I need to spend more time doing XYZ.” The other thing that comes to mind when we think about capacity, yes, I hear you, outsourcing. There’s clearly elements like compliance. Yeah, you don’t need to be doing that yourself, you can outsource that. But what about AI would be the other obvious way to me that advisors can force multiply themselves? Give me your thoughts on A, what are you guys doing in this space? And then B, what are your thoughts just on the impact on the wealth management industry at large? Michael Kim: Yeah, great question. You can’t have a podcast or any conversation this day and age without AI, right? Jason Diamond: No. You knew it was coming, sorry. Michael Kim: No, this is great. And look, I mean, personally I believe that AI is going to change everything. Now, what does that really mean? Two areas that we think a lot about both internally at AssetMark, but also what we believe we can expect to see in the industry. Number one, it’s all about productivity. And then number two, it’s about experience. So, how do we think about positioning AI, leveraging AI to improve productivity, and more importantly, delivering even a better experience? And so, internally at AssetMark, we’re doing all the different things in terms of all of our Zoom meetings, the virtual meetings, the note-taking and so forth. To me, again, those are table stakes now. And advisors themselves as well, as they’re having these types of meetings, using all the usual products in the industry that we’re all very familiar with, making sure that is a core part of, I guess the workflow to really streamline and expedite the follow-up process, the notes and summaries of the conversations. A specific example, one of the things that we launched is really around Slack, our enterprise level for ChatGPT and so forth. Again, it is just something that is accelerating the pace of business internally at AssetMark. From an experience point of view, Jason, oh my goodness, we can go on and on on this. At AssetMark, a big part of what we think about is how do we embed AI into the workflow so that it’s just regular part of how we do things as opposed to going somewhere, maybe figuring out how to work with an agent and this and that? We are in the process of launching a new capability called Talk Tracks. And so, this is actually for advisors. So, an advisor who taps into our website right before a client meeting, we will literally create talk tracks for that advisor on what are some of the insights that they should share with their client on their portfolio? Maybe they should be taking a required minimum distribution. Maybe they should be thinking about opening up a 529 because they have grandchildren, or maybe they should be doing some other planning activities. The point is it uses AI to gather the different data points, not just from the client but really just scouring the entire industry and other clients with similar profiles, and bringing in different suggestions literally as bullet point talk points for the advisor. And just based on early feedback, man, Jason, this is like our advisors love it. I mean, our advisors are saying that program alone, Talk Tracks, has really saved about two hours per day, because normally they would have to figure out the talking points for the upcoming meeting, and we will be doing all of that for that advisor. And so again, we believe that productivity will be super enhanced. And then the experience is, to me, that is where the gold mine is in terms of opportunities for AI to contribute. And last thing I’ll mention here, you and I, we often get the question of, “Okay, what does this mean for advisors? Will AI replace advisors and so forth?” No, because investors, at the end of the day they want that emotional security of knowing that they’re going to be okay. Now having said that, I do believe that advisors need to change how they engage with their clients, because that client is going to be coming into that meeting with the advisor having done their research, having asked their best friend ChatGPT about what to expect in that upcoming meeting. It’s very analogous to, I don’t know about you, but if I go see my doctor, I go to WebMD and I’m asking WebMD, “Okay, what should I be thinking about? These are my symptoms,” et cetera, so that I can actually have a much more intelligent, impactful conversation with my physician. I don’t see anything different in that the clients, the end clients will come in with some level of preliminary research, virtual conversation with their friend Chat, and then that allows that engagement with their trusted advisor to be that much It’s more meaningful. And so, I absolutely believe that it will really enhance the client experience provided that the advisors are prepared for this type of a change in the industry. Jason Diamond: And that’s an interesting spin, the idea that clients themselves will use the tool to get better educated, to basically become better clients for advisors. One thing that comes to mind with some of your talk points, I think it’s a brilliant idea. I think it’s clearly another obvious example of capacity saver. Do you think there’s a risk with that and with just AI tools in general of depersonalizing the relationship and just almost making things a little bit cookie cutter? I’ll tell you what comes to mind for me is I can tell in some cases when I get an AI email, and it makes me cringe. I’m not even talking about a spam email, I’m talking about an email that somebody tried to write to me but they used AI as a way to basically write me three paragraphs. So, give me your thoughts on is there a risk here that this just becomes this really depersonalized experience? Michael Kim: Absolutely, I do think that there’s that risk there. I do believe that it’s actually happening already. If you think about just the basics of portfolio construction and just different investment vehicles, whether it’s an ETF fund, security, what have you, chances are that advisor will come into that meeting having done some research and they may know or be more familiar with the underlying vehicles than the past generation. So, the advisors who’s hanging their hat on portfolio construction, that 60/40 balance portfolio that I alluded to earlier as really the reason why that client should be working with them, that is going to be a very non-personal or less personal relationship. Now, imagine even with AI though, that the advisor has cracked a code on how to humanize that engagement and really deliver much more of an emotionally connected experience. That’s where I think the advisors will have an opportunity to really elevate. So as I said earlier, think about those advisors that have not only built really a durable portfolio to help that client achieve their portfolio goals, but wrapping that with tax planning, wrapping that with family planning or estate planning, and really being that first call that the clients make in the event of something, something happens, that’s where the real emotions come in. And part of it is this evolution that the advisors are on where Jason, you know this better than I do, in the past they were brokers and now recently they were more the investment portfolio managers. And then really going forward it’s about how do they deliver that real deeply personal and that trusted engagement about wealth transfer, about tax management, about business exit planning if they’re business owners. And really those are the moments where the advisors will not only earn their keep, but elevate themselves from rest of the pack. I absolutely believe that this evolution and the opportunity that frankly AI and other developments are catalyzing, if positioned properly the advisors can benefit from this type of a change in an incredible way. Jason Diamond: I think there’s tremendous opportunity for advisors that harness this the right way. It brings me to an interesting question. I don’t think everybody who listens to our show is contemplating change or making a change of firms, but certainly there’s a subset of advisors who are at least curious. And technology is one area. It always comes up. I wonder, advisors don’t know what they don’t know in this realm. So, I think about a wirehouse advisor who’s been conditioned to think that the sandbox is the sandbox and it works well enough, and it probably does. They can service clients within that sandbox. So, how is that wirehouse advisor supposed to think about this new world that you’re talking about where he doesn’t even know the right questions to ask because it’s so completely foreign? Michael Kim: It’s such a great question, and it’s an important question that all advisors, particularly ones that are in a wirehouse or captive type of environment should be asking. And I think if you double click that question, it’s about how do they become even a better trusted advisor to their clients? Number one. And then number two, could they also build their own business as well? Meaning could they become a business owner or entrepreneur and control their own destiny? And to me, as we were talking earlier about the growth of the independent space, the independent, the industry is, I mean, this is where these two themes are hitting the road. One of the biggest opportunities that I see is for advisors to not only fulfill the goals and dreams of their end clients, but actually for themselves and for their office mates and for their colleagues as well. Why not? Why not create their own entity that they can control, and really control their own destiny in terms of the desired business outcomes? Now to your point, most advisors don’t know how to really plug in a CRM with a financial planning, with a portfolio management system and how all those things work. And compliance, you mentioned that earlier is such an important part. So, the big thing is how does that advisor continue to focus first and foremost on their clients, but bringing in outsource partners that can help them deliver to this fully integrated tech stack, this workflow that will actually create a better experience for their team, but also for their clients as well? And then growth. How do they really think about growth within the firm, but also leveraging outside experts like AssetMark and others to really get that next high net worth client? And so, the point is the advisor shouldn’t feel like they have to do all of this work on their own. Really leverage the different experts that are out there. And Jason, I mean, you know exactly all the different things that wirehouse advisors should do as they’re contemplating different affiliation models. Similarly, if the advisor is looking for that easy button on investments, or technology, or growth or what have you, leverage the different industry experts out there that are in the business of helping advisors achieve those goals. So, it’s one of those things where it may feel daunting initially, but really the opportunity that we have is to educate those advisors and share with them on how we can really help their business goals come true as well. Jason Diamond: Yeah, it’s a good answer. To me, there’s two ways to think about the Kitces map, if you will, of the massive ecosystem. On the one hand, it’s overwhelming and daunting. But on the other hand, you mentioned the term cottage industry. Think about how far from a FinTech perspective and an investment tech perspective, and just a wealth management tech perspective the industry has come where it’s a blessing that all of these different solutions exist. And also, part and parcel to all these solutions is there’s a lot of different education solutions out there also. So, I think that’s the number one takeaway is advisors not feeling like they need to do this alone because there are so many different options. I think your lens into this is unique given the number of advisors, that you need literally thousands of advisors. So, we spoke about AI, we spoke about this outsourcing. What is another maybe trend or something you’re keeping your eye on, or something you’re hearing from your advisors that our audience might not be aware of? Give us a preview. Michael Kim: Yeah. So for me, I’m a growth guy, Jason, and I always come back to growth. And the number one, I think about the organic growth aspect. And we can spend hours on this, but probably two things that I just want to share with your audience. Organic growth, not only is it the best measure on the health and really the durability of the business, but it also is really like the north star. It should be the north star of any business. I mean, new clients is a lifeblood of any business out there. And so, part of being a business owner means thinking strategically about how do I continue to lead this new teammates and the new firm to ensure that there’s continuous pipeline of new clients coming in for all the different reasons that we talked about. Number two, have a plan. I know it sounds simple, but have a plan. And there are people like yourselves and our firm and others that can help. When I think about what does that plan should entail, just start with existing clients. How do I help retain and grow my existing clients? And then number two, how do I get a few more new clients? And that could be referrals, that could be other lead generation programs, but just really put those thoughts on paper. Anyway, so organic growth. And then, on the inorganic growth side, this is, Jason, where there’s just so much activity and here’s the best part. I still feel like, Jason, we are in the bottom of first inning of this massive pace of not just consolidation, but really the growth of this independent segment. Experts like yourselves and others that are helping the wire or others, advisors in other ecosystems come in to this independent space. Succession, we haven’t talked about that today, but succession I think is going to be a massive tailwind behind many of these consolidations. And then the third thing that I’ll mention is the access to capital. I heard someone say the other day that capital is commodity. Before, that was the key thing that was either a catalyst or maybe a headwind for this type of inorganic growth. Today, capital is somewhat of a commodity. And so, there’s so many different PE investors or institutional firms that are coming into this space. And so, part of it is to really thinking about what your right target audience is and how your structure and your strategy is going to be different than the guy next door and making sure that you execute. And the capital will be there. Believe me, the capital will be there. And I just think, Jason, that the inorganic growth opportunity is going to continue to accelerate in this space here. Jason Diamond: There’s PE money coming into the space? I hadn’t heard that before. Michael Kim: Yeah, it’s maybe one or two. Jason Diamond: Let me ask you a few follow-ups there. I think that the tie-in there, the thing that people might be worried about then would be decompression, whether it’s because firms need to just spend more because advisor needs, whatever the case may be. Do you think that it’s the same playbook for advisors to avoid that? Lean into AI tools, lean into things like outsourcing, lean into M&A inorganic, things like that? Or is there more to it? Or is this just something that you don’t worry about at all? Michael Kim: No, I mean, we worry, we study, we keep a very close eye on the fee trends out there. And there is always pressure on the fees, and I think it’s healthy that there’s pressure on the fees. I think a big part of when we talk about fees, the other word that is synonymous with the fee compression is scale. Are we able to scale? Are the advisors able to scale in terms of their delivery mechanisms and their operations? And so, what scale means is being … Doesn’t necessarily mean cutting expenses and doing it with lower costs. To me, it is thinking more strategically about are there areas in terms of different technology that we can invest in so that over time we can deliver even a better experience in a more scaled way? Are there personnel that we can bring in to the firm that can bring a certain level of expertise that will help us take the business and the client experience to the next level? And so, there’s many different ways to scale it, but decompression is synonymous with scale. And so, as a business owner, which now advisors are both trusted advisors but also business owners, they should be thinking a lot more about how they can scale their operation. We at AssetMark, we have over 1,100 employees and we’re expecting to grow at least 20% year over year. And our view is how do we leverage AI? How do we leverage technology? How do we leverage some of the offshore contractors and other scale levers to make sure that we’re doing it without creating additional fee pressure, economic pressure to ourselves and to our clients? And so, it’s always a fun exercise to go through. We’re actually starting a planning process already, but scale aspect, Jason, is an important part of this conversation. Jason Diamond: Good answer, yep. All right, two more. I’m going to give you a fun one here. I’m giving you a lateral, I don’t know if this is a demotion, but let’s say you’re hypothetically you’re now CEO of a small to medium-sized independent firm, an RIA. You’ve got capital. To your point, capital is somewhat easy to come by. Here are your choices. A, you explore M&A, go buy a business right now. B, trip to Hawaii for all the founders. Or C, is there some business reinvestment that excites you that you think businesses should be doing? Michael Kim: That trip to Hawaii is very enticing, but when I think about the opportunity as a leader of the firm, call me a little bit of old-fashioned here but I go back to our existing clients as the number one place of investments. For me, we can do all kinds of really fun, sexy things, but if we don’t take care of our current base of clients, everything falls apart. And so, first and foremost, how do we take care of our clients? And for me, what that really means is how do we deliver the best service experience? At AssetMark, one of the key things that we are maniacal about is how do we continue to be known as the easiest place to do business for advisors? Similarly, for an advisory firm and the leaders of that advisory firm, I would submit that they should be thinking about how do they serve their clients so that the clients view that firm as the firm that all clients should be working with. And generally we think a lot about that day-to-day experience, delighting that client, that unexpected delight. I mean, my God, things like that. It doesn’t cost a lot, but it goes so far in terms of just really strengthening that experience. So that is, to me, the foundation. And after that, I also want to invest in additional organic growth capabilities. I think things like retirement is an incredibly underserved market. It is one of the largest segments of our wealth space, but arguably one of the more underserved markets. Jason Diamond: It’s not the sexiest space. Michael Kim: It’s not the sexiest, but it is an important … I mean, retirement is important, Jason. So we at AssetMark, we recently launched our self-directed brokerage program, and this is really opportunity for advisors to tap into the 401k accounts. It’s almost like a pre-rollover type of strategy, but that’s an example where we believe that there’s tons of opportunities even for advisors to serve their clients. And then, with whatever’s left in the checkbook, we love to look at the right advisors that we can potentially tuck into that firm and really branch out in terms of our presence. So, those are just some of the things that I think we would prioritize with some of the extra capital that may be coming into it. Jason Diamond: You’re hired. Michael Kim: And then we take that trip to Hawaii. Jason Diamond: Time for one more, this has been fantastic. I really appreciate the wisdom you’ve shared. Let’s fast-forward now 10 years. What are you hoping that people are saying about AssetMark and the role you’ve played in helping advisors to build businesses? And let’s go beyond just from a portfolio management, investment management perspective. Michael Kim: Yeah. As we look forward, and we actually have these types of conversations as part of our strategic planning session, let’s just say 10 years from now, what we want to be known as really that premier wealth platform, a business partner, a trusted business partner, a friend that advisors will view as a partner that helped them achieve their business goals. Meaning, let’s just say a wirehouse advisor who decided to come into the independent space, we were the firm that really helped them serve their clients better through our investments, digital and service, and then really help them grow to that next level. And so, we want to be known as a premier wealth platform that has really propelled the growth of the independent advisory firms to levels that they would not have been able to do on their own. And by the way, have some fun along the way. So have some fun, really be part of that special AssetMark community, that community of like-minded advisors by really helping that advisory firm achieve their strategic growth objectives. I hope that, Jason, with all of our employees, 1,100 employees coming in every day, our mission is to make a difference in the lives of our advisors and their clients, and I hope that we’re fulfilling that mission. I hope that we are working hard in 10 years as we are now, delivering on that promise and really making that impact each and every day for our valued advisors. Jason Diamond: I have no doubt you will. Thank you so much, Michael. This has been an absolute blast. Appreciate you coming on. Michael Kim: Thank you, Jason. That was a lot of fun. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously, and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firms, or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions, and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook .

September 10, 2026Episode 37646 min

Why So Many Successful Advisors Feel Stuck – Best of Replay

With Louis Diamond and Mindy Diamond Louis and Mindy Diamond explore why successful financial advisors can feel stuck despite thriving businesses—and how agency, enterprise value, risk, legacy, and a clear true north can help them evaluate what comes next. In Summary Successful advisors by definition have thriving businesses, loyal clients, and enviable careers—yet still wonder whether comfort has replaced energy. Louis and Mindy Diamond examine why success itself can make change harder, how the desire for agency competes with the disruption of a transition, and why record practice valuations, longer careers, and expanded optionality are prompting more advisors to question the status quo. They also offer practical questions to help advisors clarify their true north, risk tolerance, time horizon, and legacy before deciding whether to stay or explore something new. The Storyline By every external measure, top advisors today are doing exceptionally well. They have strong production, loyal clients, growing teams, and successful businesses. Yet some privately wonder why the work no longer feels as satisfying as they expected. Louis and Mindy explain that the tension is not a sign of failure. For many advisors, it appears after they have succeeded and can see another 15 or 20 years of more of the same ahead. The question becomes whether their business still gives them the agency, control, and professional energy they want. That distinction between comfort and energy can be difficult to recognize. An advisor may enjoy an excellent quality of life and a business that runs smoothly while still feeling comfortably uncomfortable. The catalyst is often not a breaking point, but a renewed desire to build, grow, create enterprise value, or leave a different legacy. Success also creates powerful reasons to stay. A healthy pipeline, loyal clients, unvested compensation, retire-in-place programs, and the short-term disruption of a transition can make change difficult to justify. At the same time, record valuations, longer careers, multigenerational teams, and a broader range of firm and affiliation models have made the opportunity cost of staying more visible. The discussion does not assume that every advisor should move. Instead, Louis and Mindy focus on how to make an intentional decision: define your true north, identify what you are trying to solve for, assess your tolerance for risk and disruption, and learn what is possible before committing to a change. Topics Covered Why successful advisors can feel stuck Agency, control, and professional satisfaction Comfort versus energy in a thriving business Defining an advisor’s true north When more of the same becomes a constraint Fear of change versus fear of standing still Recruiting deals, practice valuations, and enterprise value Longer careers and multigenerational teams Risk tolerance, disruption, and client portability Creating clarity without committing to a move > Download a transcript of this episode… Listen and Learn Highlights for Advisors What feels different for successful advisors today? (02:09) Mindy explains why top advisors are increasingly willing to examine the status quo as their choices expand and the value of their businesses rises. Why can objectively successful advisors still feel unsettled? (04:51) Mindy identifies agency as a central need for top advisors and explains why a loss of control can create deep frustration even when the business is performing well. What does a fire in the belly reveal? (08:22) Mindy shares the example of a highly successful wirehouse team whose interest in change comes from a desire for renewed energy and legacy, not from a final breaking point. How is being comfortable different from being energized? (11:53) Louis and Mindy explore the difference between a business that provides an excellent life and one that still feels professionally satisfying, including the feeling of being comfortably uncomfortable. When does more of the same become a constraint? (17:49) They discuss how repeating a successful formula can continue to produce results while limiting growth, ownership, or the entrepreneurial spark an advisor wants to pursue. How do advisors reconcile fear of change with fear of standing still? (27:16) Mindy and Louis explain why those competing concerns can persist for years and how a firm decision, a compelling opportunity, or a moment of personal clarity can shift the balance. Why is this question surfacing more often now? (29:48) Record valuations, elevated recruiting deals, expanded optionality, peer movement, longer careers, and next-generation needs are changing how advisors assess the cost of staying. Which questions should advisors ask before considering a move? (36:35) Mindy and Louis outline questions about true north, frustration, risk appetite, disruption, legacy, time horizon, and the regret of never testing what might be possible. Key Takeaways Success and professional fulfillment are not the same thing. An advisor can have strong growth, loyal clients, and an excellent quality of life while still feeling that comfort has replaced energy. Agency is a core need for many top advisors. Firm policies, compensation changes, technology limits, or other decisions can feel especially disruptive when they reduce control over the business or client experience. Good enough can become a constraint. A proven business model may continue to work financially while limiting growth, ownership, enterprise value, or the professional satisfaction an advisor wants next. Success creates powerful inertia. A strong pipeline, unvested compensation, retire-in-place programs, client relationships, and the disruption of a transition can all make the status quo difficult to challenge. The opportunity cost of staying has become more visible. Record valuations, elevated recruiting deals, broader affiliation choices, longer careers, and peer movement give advisors more reasons to understand what else may be possible. True north should come before due diligence. Advisors need to define what they want to solve for and how they weigh control, risk, enterprise value, legacy, and time horizon before evaluating firms or models. Education does not require a move. Self-awareness and a clear view of the available options can help an advisor make an intentional decision, including the decision to stay. https://youtu.be/nrmtRBlJJVs Quotable Moments “I’m comfortably uncomfortable.” — Mindy Diamond “You’ve always got to be really clear on what your true north is.” — Mindy Diamond “Which regret is bigger to you, trying something and failing or never testing what’s possible?” — Louis Diamond “It’s okay to want more. There’s nothing wrong with you for wanting more. At the same time, there’s nothing wrong about being comfortable.” — Louis Diamond FAQs Why do successful financial advisors feel stuck even when their businesses are thriving? External success does not always create professional energy or fulfillment. Some advisors have excellent businesses but feel they have lost agency, stopped growing in ways that matter to them, or settled into a version of success that no longer fits their goals. What does agency mean for a financial advisor? Agency is control over an advisor’s professional life and business. It can include how the advisor serves clients, uses technology, builds a team, makes decisions, and plans for growth or succession. Is being comfortable in a business the same as being energized by it? Not always. Comfort can reflect a strong business, good income, loyal clients, and a healthy quality of life. Energy comes from feeling engaged by what the advisor is building and where the business is headed. Why can success make it harder for an advisor to change firms? Successful advisors often have more to disrupt, including client relationships, team dynamics, a growing pipeline, unvested compensation, and valuable retire-in-place benefits. The immediate costs and risks of a transition can outweigh a benefit that may be larger over the long term. Why are more successful advisors questioning the status quo now? Practice valuations and recruiting deals are high, the range of affiliation models has expanded, and advisors see respected peers make changes. Longer careers and the needs of next-generation partners also give many teams more time and reason to reconsider their future. What is an advisor’s true north? True north is the set of priorities that should guide an advisor’s decision. It defines what the advisor wants to build, what needs to change, and how factors such as control, ownership, legacy, risk, and time horizon should be weighted. What should an advisor ask before considering a move? Key questions include what is causing frustration, how significant it is, what outcome the advisor wants, how much disruption and client risk the team can tolerate, and whether staying in the same place for another 10 or 15 years would still feel satisfying. How can an advisor create clarity without committing to change? Start with self-awareness, then learn what options exist through informed conversations and competitive analysis. Understanding the landscape can strengthen a decision to stay or reveal a better fit without obligating the advisor to move. External success does not always create professional energy or fulfillment. Some advisors have excellent businesses but feel they have lost agency, stopped growing in ways that matter to them, or settled into a version of success that no longer fits their goals. Agency is control over an advisor’s professional life and business. It can include how the advisor serves clients, uses technology, builds a team, makes decisions, and plans for growth or succession. Not always. Comfort can reflect a strong business, good income, loyal clients, and a healthy quality of life. Energy comes from feeling engaged by what the advisor is building and where the business is headed. Successful advisors often have more to disrupt, including client relationships, team dynamics, a growing pipeline, unvested compensation, and valuable retire-in-place benefits. The immediate costs and risks of a transition can outweigh a benefit that may be larger over the long term. Practice valuations and recruiting deals are high, the range of affiliation models has expanded, and advisors see respected peers make changes. Longer careers and the needs of next-generation partners also give many teams more time and reason to reconsider their future. True north is the set of priorities that should guide an advisor’s decision. It defines what the advisor wants to build, what needs to change, and how factors such as control, ownership, legacy, risk, and time horizon should be weighted. Key questions include what is causing frustration, how significant it is, what outcome the advisor wants, how much disruption and client risk the team can tolerate, and whether staying in the same place for another 10 or 15 years would still feel satisfying. Start with self-awareness, then learn what options exist through informed conversations and competitive analysis. Understanding the landscape can strengthen a decision to stay or reveal a better fit without obligating the advisor to move. Related Resources How to Free Yourself from the “If Only” Mindset Here are the 5 most common self-limiting statements that advisors share—and ways to reframe your thinking. Limitless Growth: Building the Business You Want and the Life to Match Stephanie Bogan, founder of Limitless Advisor, offers a glimpse into the advice and perspective she shares with advisors and business leaders in the wealth management world, focusing on mindset and methods, and their relationship to achieving one’s best business life. NOTE: The views and opinions expressed by the guests on this podcast are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Diamond Consultants. Neither Diamond Consultants nor the guests on this podcast are compensated in any way for their participation. View the transcript of this episode… Best of Replay: Why So Many Successful Advisors Feel Stuck An Industry Update with Louis Diamond and Mindy Diamond. Louis Diamond: Welcome to a replay of one of the most popular episodes from our podcast series for financial advisors. Why So Many Successful Advisors Feel Stuck. It’s a Special Industry Update with Mindy Diamond. I’m Louis Diamond and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education-driven, and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at (908) 879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning, data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Louis Diamond: We spend a lot of time talking with advisors who, by every external measure, are doing exceptionally well. They’ve built real businesses with strong production, loyal clients and teams that continue to grow, and yet behind closed doors, many of these same advisors are quietly asking a different set of questions. Not how do I fix what’s broken, but why doesn’t this feel as good as I expected? That tension is showing up more frequently than it did five or 10 years ago, and it’s not because advisors are failing. In many cases, it’s because they’ve won and now find themselves staring at another 15 to 20 years of more the same, unsure whether comfort has slowly replaced energy. This industry update is about that very moment. I asked Mindy to join me to unpack what we’re hearing from successful advisors across the industry, why success itself can become a constraint, how fear of change competes with fear of standing still, and why record valuations, longer careers and the maturity of the independent space are changing the psychology of decision-making. We also talk about the right questions to ask before considering a move, questions about control, enterprise value, legacy and time horizon, and how advisors can create clarity without forcing a decision. There’s lot to explore here, so let’s get into it. Mindy, thanks for joining us. Mindy Diamond: Oh, I’m so happy to be here. Always. Louis Diamond: This is a fun topic. So today we’re just going to dive right in. I’m curious, from your vantage point and talking and working with many of the best advisors in the industry at a high level, what are you hearing from successful advisors today that feels different from five or 10 years ago? Mindy Diamond: First of all, for the most part, I think that top advisors are loathe to move. And they may have a bunch of frustrations or things that they wish were different, but generally speaking, they’ve always been well taken care of. They have the bat phone to the top, it’s good enough and nobody wants to mess with success. But two things are true today more than ever before, that the competitive landscape, there are more options than ever before, that their businesses are worth more than before. I guess it’s more than two things. That they’re thinking about their business as a business and saying, “Yeah, it’s a hassle to move, but if I can maximize the value of my business more elsewhere and at the same time solve for what I want to, maybe I really do need to consider it. And so I think that it’s a time of more consideration, that top advisors, in particular, are just not willing to settle for the status quo. Louis Diamond: Yeah, no doubt. The only thing I would add, but I completely agree, is that today the retire in place or succession opportunities for a wirehouse advisor to transition or sell their business to their next generation or to another team or even an independent advisor, to sell their business to their broker dealer or to someone within their firm, those opportunities, the internal options, I think are more compelling than ever. So we hear a lot from really successful advisors who, that actually doesn’t matter if they’re successful or let’s say they’re mid-tier in the industry, where it’s much easier to stay. And the firms are smart. They’ve made these internal deals better for the retiring advisor at the expense of the inheriting advisor, but they definitely try to create the easy button for someone who’s successful and might be fairly close to the end zone of their career. Mindy Diamond: And yeah, unequivocally. And so I think what happens is that, as these senior advisors are weighing the notion of will I eventually take my firm’s retire in place program, hit that easy button, if you will, take the path of lease resistance? Before they do, most of them will, and absolutely should, at least get educated about what else is out there. Not with an eye toward moving necessarily, but with an eye toward knowing what their value is before they sign on for the next seven to 10 years. Louis Diamond: No doubt about it. So I think for the most part, we’re talking about mostly top two, advisors who are objectively winning. They have amazing businesses, they’re growing, they have loyal clients. Work-life balance is probably pretty good. So why do so many of these advisors still feel unsettled at the end of the day? Mindy Diamond: Because I think that without question, the number one thing that every advisor, but definitely the most successful advisors want, is agency. Agency over their professional life and anything, any day, any event that smacks of loss of agency or less agency than they would like, less control than they would like, makes them feel unsettled is a good word. Unsettled is probably a euphemism for exceedingly frustrated, really angry, ready to go. So look, our job in talking to these folks is, first of all, to say to them, there is no perfection anywhere. So the first thing is you may be annoyed that your firm did X, Y and Z, or you don’t have control over A, B, and C, or you may want more of A, B and C, but at the end of the day, you need to be sure that you’re aware of the hassle factor, you’re willing to trade one set of problems for potentially another. I guess what I’m saying is you got to really be sure that you want it. That’s the bottom line. Louis Diamond: No doubt. I would also add a bit of a different spin that a lot of advisors, these folks that I think by any objective measure, they’re killing it. You look at any of their friends outside the industry, their friends probably look at them and say, “Wow, this advisor has an amazing life.” And I think we’d probably say the same, but I think we see it where there’s a difference between being professionally motivated and energized versus just being comfortable. And I think with a lot of folks, especially if it’s a fee-based business, their clients are mostly friends. They grinded in the early years. They still work hard, but now things are on autopilot. So I think some people around unsettled because they have 10, 15, 20, 25 years left to work and they look and say, “This is great. I make a good living. Life’s not that hard,” but they’re missing that spark that they used to have. Mindy Diamond: I couldn’t agree more. I actually love that spin, and if I can, I’ll share an example of a conversation I had literally just last week. So talking with one of three senior partners on a very successful wirehouse team, without a doubt, one of the top teams in the industry, and this is a team that absolutely has a bat phone to the top. This is a team that gets referrals from their firm. So if another advisor leaves, they’re the go-to. If someone has an investment banking deal and needs to bring in a wealth advisor, they would go to this team. This is the team or one of a few teams. And I talked to them probably every six months for the last 10 years, and I’m not kidding, and we just have a nice relationship. They trust me. No, I would never sell them. And so they just want to understand the pulse on things. And for years, that’s essentially what they’ve said is, “We’re killing it, we’re crushing it. We are the go-to team and everything is hitting on all cylinders. And we know that we’ve got our firm’s retire in place programs when two of our senior partners are ready to cash out.” But just last week, not even the senior most member, probably the second to senior most member called and said, “It’s all working well, but I have this fire in my belly.” That’s a good way to say it, right? I have the sense that I’m missing something. And so some of the time, it’s about just getting to that place, say, when the straw that breaks the camel’s back. Something happens, you can’t take it any more, time to go. But with those top advisors, more often than not, it’s not about straw that breaks the camel’s back. It’s much more about fire in my belly. I realize that will I feel good if, at the end of the day, five minutes, five years or 20 years from now, will I feel good if I leave it all behind? We’re right here. Louis Diamond: Yep, exactly. Yeah, I think part of it is legacy, but the other part is just fast forwarding the tape. If you say 20 years from now, and you look back in the last 20 years, is you plus 20 years going to feel satisfied and encouraged and excited about what you were accomplishing? Or was it more of a, yeah, it was good, it was easy. I bought three houses and I have a boat. Or was it more about the personal joy of growing and building something and being part of something? Mindy Diamond: That’s actually a very good way to say it. Where can the top advisor find that joy? So let’s say I’m hitting on all cylinders, top of the food chain at fill in the blank firm, a traditional firm. What are typically the things that advisor, the options that advisor might consider that could ignite that joy? Louis Diamond: Yeah, I mean, honestly, probably a bad nonspecific answer, but it really could be anything. I mean, we see plenty of teams that are with one major wirehouse, they move to another one and just the act of transitioning is re-energizing. They have backend bonuses to hit. This new firm has a bit of a different culture, they feel more important again, and that’s their spark. Others, it would be we’re building something, we’re creating our own firm. Others might be I’m now an equity partner in something that I have a hand in, I have a voice. They actually listen to me. So I think it can be all of the above. It’s more about what is it that an advisor is most interested in? And then at this point in the industry, it’s choose your own adventure. If you have some sort of feeling or urge, whether it’s I want to do something different, I want to grow faster, I’m frustrated by X, Y, Z, it’s more about filling in the blanks of what your next journey looks like. And my guess is just thinking about that is going to provide that natural spark or ignition. Mindy Diamond: Yeah. And if I can, the piece of advice that I gave to this team, and I think is worth mentioning here, you’re absolutely right. Choose your own adventure. To us, I think we would both say that most exciting thing about being in our position and being the counselor or the guide or the Sherpa to advisors as they consider what comes next is the amount of choice that they have and how exciting the next chapter can be. But what I said to this team or the one advisor on this team is, “You’ve always got to be really clear on what your true north is.” So yes, there’s a lot of options. An advisor can find joy or reignite the spark at any number of choices, more than ever before. But being really clear before you begin to take meetings or think about it on what you’re looking to solve for, what’s most important to you really matters or else you wind up just spinning your wheels for a lot of time. Louis Diamond: Clearly agree. How do you distinguish between being comfortable in your business and being energized by a business? Do you think there’s a difference? Mindy Diamond: Yeah, look, I think in some cases, they could be one and the same. I think somebody can be comfortable because they feel energized. They’re hitting on all cylinders. They’ve got a lot of agency and professional control over their business. They’re where they want to be. They’re living their true north. But I think in many cases, and many of the advisors we’ve counseled, they aren’t one of the same. I’m comfortable because, as you said, I have a great quality of life, I’m making great money, I have a lot of freedom to coach my kids’ basketball team. I can work from home, I can travel when I want to, I have great clients. I may not technically own my business, but I feel as though I do. I’m comfortable enough. But what this advisor last week said to me, and what we hear a lot, is I’m comfortably uncomfortable. That I am comfortable enough. If I retired from here, I will have made a ton of money, I will have done good work and it all would be good enough. But whether or not good enough is really good enough in terms of professionally satisfying and everything you want it to be is a very different question. Louis Diamond: Exactly. I’ll give an example of that. I have an advisor I speak to who’s independent. So he’s been independent for his entire career at a broker dealer. He’s an absolute stone-cold killer. I told him that. He’s probably top three advisors at his BD, so it’s great for the ego. He’s on the conference circuit and sharing his best practices, but he’s in his 40s and said to me, “I can continue to rinse, repeat, I can continue to get the accolades and be on the main stage, but I feel like I’m missing something. I just know how to run the same place and I don’t really see how that’s going to change.” So he has a pretty hard decision because it’s nice to feel important, it’s nice to grow without a lot of extra effort, but for this individual, it’s becoming clear that spark or feeling energized again is his true north. Mindy Diamond: And so what would he look at? In other words, if you are already top of the food chain at your broker dealer, and by the way, we see that a lot, that advisors in the independent space that work under broker dealer that are number one, they are the one at the conference that everybody goes up to and said, “Oh my God, I hear such great things about you. I want to learn from you.” So what is it he’s missing? Louis Diamond: For this individual, what he thinks he’s missing is the chance to really build his own platform. So if this gentleman decides to make a change, it’s definitively going to be to build his own RIA, where he can pick and choose all the technology. He’s really bullish about his personal network and being able to recruit like-minded folks in to do acquisitions. And his North Star is going to be, how do I build the most valuable enterprise that I can sell for a whole boatload of money 15 years from now? It’s a great example because this person has everything that most people would want, but he’s still wanting more. And what he’s looking to accomplish is probably similar to a lot of people, but the means that he’s going to get there and the weighting that he’s putting on his criteria are different. And that’s what, I think, the best part of being an advisor is you have so much choice. There’s no one telling you, “You have to grow, you have to do this, you have to care about money, you have to onboard X number of clients.” It’s much more about how do you listen to your heart and then make intentional choices to make it happen, essentially. Mindy Diamond: Yeah, and I think that’s the calculus. His calculus is it’s more than enough here. The question is, am I willing to upset what’s more than good enough, upset that apple cart in order to get something that is marginally better? And his answer, or our advice to somebody like that, is it really depends upon how much you want it. If it will feel soulful to you, if, at the end of the day, you will feel better about the professional legacy you left behind, having built something bigger and better with less limitations, then you’ll do it. You have to decide how much you want it. It’s interesting, if I can go back to this example, this team’s true north is a little different and it’s worth contrasting. So while, for sure, they would love nothing more than to maximize enterprise value, and they recognize that if they and any of their partners retire through their firm’s retire in place program, it’s a way of monetizing, but they look at their firm as a monopolistic buyer. That was the term that they used. My comment to them is, “So what? Monopolistic or not, if, at the end of the day, it allows you to do what you need to do when you get paid a fair value, who cares if they’re monopolistic?” That really is the truth. But their true north is they would love to build something. They don’t need to build their own platform. In fact, they would want nothing more than to plug into an already existing platform. And they recognize that by doing so, they’re giving up some enterprise value. And the way to maximize enterprise value the fullest is to go out and build your own. But in this particular instance, they don’t want to do that. They’ve got partners that some are in their 60s and that’s not going to be appealing to them. So their true north might be something a little bit different. I think the point here is being really clear on what you’re true north is really important because it guides the set of choices. Louis Diamond: No doubt. At what point do you think more of the same stops being a growth strategy and starts becoming a constraint? Mindy Diamond: Oh, well, just that. Your example was the perfect example, right? That I am doing incredibly well. I could keep on doing this, but in some way, it’s not only constraining my growth, but in some way it’s constraining my professional satisfaction. And I think more often than not, it’s about that. Because the audience I think we’re talking to in this podcast are really successful folks. There’s no question that there’s nothing we can tell them that would suggest that they’re not successful as they are. So if they decide to upset the apple cart or they decide to look for more, it’s because there is that fire in your belly, that something, that entrepreneurial spark or that something that’s not being satisfied. Louis Diamond: I agree. Yeah. I think sometimes it’s a matter of time says to me, if someone finds something that works, it’s a pretty sound business strategy to rinse, repeat, and keep doing it, focus on what’s essential, cut out the rest. You read any business book, it’s going to tell you double down on what’s working, cut out the rest. The 80/20, et cetera. But I think eventually you keep doing the same thing over and over again, and it might still yield results, but is it yielding the growth? Is it yielding exponential results? And at some point, does just doing the same thing, is it still driving you in the same way? Mindy Diamond: Yeah, and I think a lot of times people don’t really know what they’re missing. In other words, the growth strategy is working. I’m growing X amount per year. I’m living a good life. I’m consistently in the top five advisors in my firm. It’s working and nobody could argue that it isn’t. I think it’s just more about a lot of times as advisors, one of two things, either one of their friends move, a professional colleague that they respect and they say, “Holy cow, he was here or she was here for 30 years, like me, killing it. She would’ve been the last person I would’ve thought would move.” And then suddenly she does, and it makes them say, “What am I missing? What did she see that I am not aware of?” Or a lot of times these folks will, another example I’ll give you. An advisor that I’ve worked with for many years, probably 25 years, who is top of the food chain, doing incredibly well, never really thought about moving, talked over the years, “Boy, it would be nice to build something of my own, but the truth of the matter is that success and the thought of having to go back to zero and build something from scratch, no way.” But you and I came across an opportunity that was unbelievably compelling, and without going into too much detail about the opportunity, suddenly when we talked about that opportunity with this advisor, what he said was, “You can’t be what you can’t see.” All of a sudden we painted the picture of something that’s really compelling I didn’t even know I wanted, but holy cow, now I know I really want it. Louis Diamond: Yeah, because something, this dream was made tangible. It put a face on something that this advisor didn’t realize they were missing. I mean, I see this every day, this next question, I’d love to get your opinion. I feel like most advisors, they may sense something is off or something’s changing or shifting under their feet, but they say anyway, why do you think success is often the very thing that keeps advisors stuck? Mindy Diamond: Yeah, I think it’s more than good enough. And for most of us, most of the time, I might have that little voice in me or that little inkling that says, gee, maybe it could be better. Or gee, I wonder if or something of the sort, but I have a zillion competing priorities. I’m a dad or I’m a mom or I want to travel, or I’m 60 years old, or I’m filling any blank at any time. And I think that it’s really hard to give up on that. And I think that the example we just gave, of this advisor that saw an opportunity, a unique opportunity that solved for a lot of the things that he didn’t even know he was missing, that happens more often than not. Louis Diamond: Yep, I agree. I think too, what happens is a lot of advisors think about moving as strictly a financial trade. My grid rate is this and my fees are that I can get 3.5X here, but only 2X up front have Y in deferred comp. And I think when advisors are thinking about that, which is a reasonable lens to look through, end of the day, they’re business people. If the business is growing and they have to place Y or they know how to get things done, it’s much harder to justify that change. It’s like people who sell their house top of the market, it’s like, hey, it’s this thing and keep growing, and do you feel like you’re missing out because you’re leaving at this point in time? Typically, too, when things are good, clients are happy, the reviews are easier. We see it a lot with the market being up. In 2025, the market was up almost 20%, much harder for some folks to justify moving because they feel like, whether it’s artificial or it’s real, that their business is really cranking. So I think that’s a big part of it as well. Mindy Diamond: Yeah. And maybe another little spin on it is a lot of times to move is really, from a financial perspective, may only be marginally better in the short-term, whether it be because after taxes, the amount of tabs you get upfront is not that much greater than the deal you could get by retiring through your firm’s sunset program. Or if you move, you’re going to be leaving some clients behind. So if you factor in the breakage from losing clients and the short-term upside, the delta may not be that great. We see a lot of times when an advisor is already independent and they’re at a net 60 or 65% payout and they’re looking at something that gives them a 70% net payout and they say, “Yeah, okay, so those extra basis points are nice, but is it nice enough? Is it worth the hassle?” The answer to that is it is entirely an inside job. For some that delta, even if that delta was only 2 cents, would be more than enough to justify the change. And for others, if the delta was 2000000%, it wouldn’t be enough. So what’s this positive? What’s this positive or determinant is how badly they want it. How badly, beyond the financial piece, they want what another opportunity would give them. Either that I really have this fire in my belly, and I love that term, and I just can’t solve for it. I can’t extinguish that fire here. I can’t feed that fire here. Or opportunistically, I want to be something I just can’t here, and I want it so badly that even if, financially, it’s only marginally better in the short-term, I’m willing to go through the hassle to get it. Louis Diamond: No doubt. And one last point to put a bow on this segment is I think there’s also an element that advisors who are growing or they have a big pipeline, and to me, the best advisors always have a big pipeline. They always have the next big prospect. There’s definitely some, I think, real fear that I’m going from growing 10% per year to reflexively choosing to make my life really hard for a couple of months to slow down growth, perhaps lose some of the pipeline, lose some of the big clients I just onboarded. And that’s really hard to justify because the trade-off is that much more apparent to them. Mindy Diamond: Yeah. Which you really want it. Louis Diamond: But that’s always going to be the case. That’s the point. The good advisors, for the most part, are always growing and always doing these things. So it’s like running on a treadmill. The same thing with unvested deferred compensation. I have 2 million of unvested deferred, it’s so hard to walk away from. The counterpoint is you’re always going to have that. If anything, it’s just going to grow. So again, it’s taking a step back to take multiple steps forward. Some people want that and are excited by it. Some people aren’t, but that’s okay. Mindy Diamond: Yeah, and I think that’s the whole point. While we get paid to move people, our position and the relationships we’ve had for years with top advisors, with every advisor, is they trust us because we’re never looking to just sell them on a hot opportunity. We’ll bring opportunities to them and say, “Here’s what’s available, here’s what the upside could be,” but we know and respect better than anyone that you got to really want it. It is a hassle. It’s hard work to move, and you’ve got to have a real confidence in your clients, your current clients, that they’re going to follow you. You’ve got to have real confidence that your pipeline will follow you, that what’s not certain. You’ve got to have confidence that you can tolerate the risk, and you’ve got to have confidence that your team’s going to follow you and that you’ve got the support you need. And not everyone has the appetite for it, nor should they. Louis Diamond: Exactly. I mean, I would say there’s two competing, I guess, thoughts that oftentimes go through an advisor’s mind, and they’re both extremely reasonable. The first one is the fear of change, but at the same time it’s the fear of staying exactly where they are for another 10, 15, 20 years. How do you think advisors can reconcile the tensions, like the angel on one shoulder, the devil on the other? One’s super comfortable and safe. The other one is an unknown. One’s exciting, one, et cetera. So how would you reconcile that? Mindy Diamond: Well, first of all, the short answer is it takes years. The two examples I just raised, and I’ll ask you the same question, are advisors that I’ve been talking to for 10 years plus. In one case, it could be 15 or 20. So for 10 or 15 years, there was always a certain amount of angst, a certain amount of curiosity, but not at all a willingness to do anything about it until in one case, something happened. Something happened that made them realize that they’re paying an awful lot of money to their firm for value they’re not getting anymore, feeling limited. And so they decided to pick up their head and look elsewhere. In the other case, it was opportunistic. Really was perfectly happy doing their thing and heard or saw an opportunity that sounded compelling and began exploring. Now, I don’t know whether either one of these teams will ultimately move, so let’s say that, but these conversations are many years in the making. So I think the point I’m making is that devil on one side, an angel on the other are those two competing voices. They exist for a long time until either, in some cases, they never get reconciled and the advisor just retires and it is what it is. In other cases, they get reconciled, but sometimes five, 10 years after the voices begin to surface and they don’t happen, they don’t get reconciled until something happens to force it. Louis Diamond: Yeah. I also look at this concept as we’ll call it a midlife career crisis. So I’m 40 years old. Instead of buying three motorcycles and a Porsche and going skydiving, I’m thinking about my business. And sometimes, I think people just wake up and say, “Wow, I don’t really know what my identity is and I need to do something different. I need that additional spark.” So I think sometimes too, it’s just either an age thing or a certain birthday comes up or it’s just that a moment of clarity that pops into the mind. Mindy Diamond: Totally agree. Louis Diamond: Why do you think this feeling is showing up now more than ever? Is it because of recruiting deals? Is it because of the movement toward independence? Is it something else or somethings else? Mindy Diamond: Yes, I think it’s all of the above, and I think that’s the cool thing. Valuations are at an all-time high. So even if an advisor has zero interest in going independent, you have to be living under a rock not to know that your business has real value. That business, outside of the constraints of a major firm, is worth much more than it is on the inside. Now, that doesn’t mean that everybody should go independent, or will, but the fact that those multiples are hanging out there and that recruiting deals are at an all-time high, and they are, the fact that there’s more optionality, which means an advisor, if they go out and explore, is more likely to find their personal version of Utopia or something closest to it. The fact that movement begets movement. That’s something we haven’t talked about, but it’s worth mentioning that all you have to do is read AdvisorHub or just be sitting in your office and every day, watch somebody you respect make a move. And so the more you see top advisors move, the more you say maybe there really is something else out there for me as well. And then you and I always say that the big firms are one policy change, one comp change, one mandate, one something away from frustrating the heck out of a large constituency because the bottom line is, as long as you’re an employee, you’re vulnerable or captive to whatever choices the firm makes. Louis Diamond: Yeah. I think you’re talking about, in a very nice way, what happened with UBS at the end of 2024, but we even see it outside of the wirehouses. There’s independent firms that layer in new fees or they don’t allow their advisors to text. There’s always that risk that something big coming down the pike that motivates someone. I’ll give you two other reasons why they think this is happening with more frequency. The first one is advisors’ careers are oftentimes longer, either because they’re bringing their kids into the business or the business is so lucrative, and if the business is mostly fee-based and it’s on autopilot, it’s like, why should I hang up the old boots when I can just work for another handful of years? So I think with longer advisor careers and the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow, which is either a big exit or a retire in place deal, I think advisors just grapple with more and they grapple with it for longer. Mindy Diamond: Yeah, you brought up a point. I’m so happy you brought it up. I’m sitting here next to my son, my next generation. I have said oftentimes that, without my sons coming into the business, I don’t know that I would’ve had the same relationship to the business as I aged. As I got older, and I’ll be transparent, I’m 63-year-old now, if 10 years ago, my sons had not decided to join me, I think that I might have said, “I’ll work as long as it feels soulful and good, and if something better comes along, great.” But it wasn’t until they came along that I really began to think about everything through their lens. It was less about me because by the time I was 50, from a financial perspective, I could have left if I wanted to. But as long as my kids weren’t in the business, there’s no way I was going to do that. There was no way I wouldn’t want what was the absolute best for the business. And I guess that’s a long-winded way of saying in an industry where there’s so many multigenerational businesses, father-son, mother-daughter, whatever it is, senior advisors that really care, even if they’re not family, about their next generation, when they begin to look at their business through the lens of their next generation, the technology may be good enough for me, but it’s sure not cutting edge enough. Or they say things like, “The bureaucracy is killing me, but I work three hours a day,” or, “I have such a good life, I don’t want to upset the apple cart.” But then all of a sudden, one day we get a call either from that senior advisor, for whom it was more than good enough for years, or from the next generation that says, “This is not what I want. It may have been good enough for my dad and my mom, but it’s not good enough for me.” So it’s a long-winded way of saying I think that the next generation really forces the senior advisors, the elder states, G1 to grapple with whether or not this is good enough. Louis Diamond: Yep. I’ll answer my own question first and then get your opinion, because I feel pretty strongly about my answer. In thinking about our four to five point list here of why this is a bigger deal now, I tap in with more frequency. The question for both of us is which one do you think has the biggest psychological impact on advisors right now? I’m going to go first because I’m excited about my answer. I think by far, it’s practice valuations by far. Because what’s happening is advisors are reading news articles, hearing from their friend, getting cold-called from corporate development folks at firms, and they hear what used to be just ludicrous multiples. These were multiples that were reserved 100, $200 million revenue business are now getting paid to a three to $5 million practice. And any advisor, even ones who aren’t super financially motivated, I think just hearing about this, knowing what’s possible has a major psychological impact. It’s making it that much harder for folks to say, “You know what? It’s comfortable. It’s easy. I can retire here because the opportunity cost of staying put has accelerated that much.” What do you think? Mindy Diamond: So unequivocally, and I am money motivated for sure, so I agree with you. But at my stage and age, if I were an advisor, I absolutely wouldn’t be able to ignore the impact that maximizing enterprise value might have and how awesome it would be to be building a business that could be worth more. But I would equally, if not more so, be really concerned about, A, how it would feel. Like am I going to be able to live the professional life, do what’s soulful for me? Am I going to be able to build the business I want to? Is this going to be the business, the legacy I’m going to feel good about? Is this going to be the business that I want my sons to take over? And that, to me, would be equally important. And I’m making it about me, but I think that’s what a lot of senior advisors would say. Louis Diamond: No doubt. So for folks that are questioning their situation, what do you think is a question or three or four or five of the right questions they should start asking themselves before even thinking about making a move? Mindy Diamond: Yeah. Well, one is, listen, what’s your true north? And even before, I mean question two, and I think what I just said, assessing your true north, figuring out where your true north is, one, because question two is what is it that’s bothering you? What is it that you’re frustrated by? And simultaneously, to what extent does it frustrate you? Like how, okay, so I feel mildly annoyed that I have to do X, but is it enough to make me want to move? So being clear on that is important. But I think even before you begin to delineate how frustrated you are, you have to be really clear on what you want to be when you grow up. What is it that would feel soulful? What are you trying to solve for? What are the parameters or realities that you need to take into account? You’d love to do X, but you have a senior partner that you know is never going to want that, whatever it is. So what is the true north? What are you frustrated by? Then it’s what risk appetite do I have? Louis Diamond: To take risks, yeah. Mindy Diamond: What risk appetite and what appetite in general do I have for disruption to my life? How tolerant will I be if one of my clients doesn’t follow with me, because that is really possible? How tolerant will I be if I spend a few months and I’m working harder than I’ve ever worked in my life, whatever it may be. And then I think it’s that question, what I want to be when I grow up is really what’s just positive. Do I want to be a business owner or am I a big corporate person and that’s just who I am and I’m comfortable with leveraging the name that’s on the door? Louis Diamond: No doubt. I think an interesting one is ask yourself, if I stayed exactly where I am for the next 15 years, would I be proud of what I built? I think it’s a really important one sometimes too, when I’m speaking with advisors who are worried about a transition, and honestly people should be worried about a transition. It’s terrible. There’s no sugar-coating it. It’s a lot of work. It’s scary. It’s a risk. You’re disrupting your life, all your client’s life, et cetera. But sometimes, I’d say, the reframe is the three months, four months, whatever it is of backbreaking work that you put in, is that worth it for the next 10, 15, 20 years of doing something that really sparks you more? And I think, again, it comes back to your question of risk appetite, but I think just thinking about that is a lot of people get lost in the immediacy of the risk and of the work, but they forget to look beyond that work to what’s possible on the other side of the rainbow. Mindy Diamond: And how important it is to get it. In other words, I may be very clear that I would like to have X. I’d like to do Y. I would love, I mean we hear this all the time. I’d love to be independent and build my own business. Boy, if I were 20 years younger or I was, whatever it was. So the point of the matter is you can be aware of wanting those things. It’s admirable to want them, but whether or not you actually should go after them, that’s an inside job. Louis Diamond: No doubt. I think another one I like is which regret is bigger to you, trying something and failing or never testing what’s possible? I think that’s a good one. Another philosophical one. Okay. Let’s change gears a little bit here. So for successful, we’ll say mid-career advisors, why do you think the biggest risk is oftentimes not making the wrong move, but choosing the status quo by default? Mindy Diamond: Answering it from the perspective, we’ve had a lot of senior advisors that say, “I look back on my career and if only I had made the move or gone to this 15 years ago.” So I think that’s the you get comfortable in the discomfort, it’s easier to stay put, and then before you know it in your head, you’re too old or you’re too settled or you’re too entrenched and you can’t go or it’s too late to go. Or in some cases, you’ve got so much unvested deferred comp, it’s too expensive to go. And so I don’t think that’s only about mid-career. I think you want to make sure that you’ve lived a professional life that’s not filled with regret. That’s really what I think. Louis Diamond: No doubt about it. I think too, the fear of making the wrong move, call it buyer’s remorse, if you will. I honestly don’t really see it happen all that often. When I see it happen, it’s because someone went to their second or third choice firm because they got paid an extra 10% of their production. That’s where the wrong decision comes in. I usually find when advisors are thorough, they’re thoughtful, they’re making decisions for the right reasons, and there is a base level of motivation to do something different. You can’t really make the wrong choice. And I think, but again, it’s risk tolerance, et cetera. Let me give you two more questions here. What’s one step an advisor can take today to create clarity without committing to change? Mindy Diamond: Well, that question is the fundamental definition of how you and I see the world. So we traffic in advisors that are 10 years, 20 years from making a move or may never move. To us, it’s just about the relationship. That may sound foofy and crazy, but it is the truth. And so those conversations are all about being self-aware. That’s number one. Know thyself. Being self-aware of what’s important to me, what can I live with, how much risk tolerance do I have, et cetera. And then it’s also about having a clear understanding about what’s possible. So continuing to have conversation with people like you and I, continuing to read AdvisorHub or whatever it is about transitions that happen. Understanding the opportunities that are out there is not necessarily because you’re going to go take one of them or you’re going to change, but knowledge is power. It empowers you where you are. It’s competitive analysis, and that’s smart. That can only serve you well. Louis Diamond: Yep. I completely agree. One last question here, and I think probably a lot of people listening to this are thinking this personification of an advisor or advisors that we’re describing, are they just complainers? Are they just being ungrateful? On the one hand, there’s probably folks that are early in their careers working their butt up who are saying, “Hey, just be grateful for what you have. It’s really hard to get to where you are. So why are you looking a gift horse in the mouth?” So what would you say to that line of thinking, that questioning the status quo or questioning something that’s really good, does that means someone’s ungrateful or restless? Mindy Diamond: Oh my God, no. I think that the smartest and most successful, and honestly most grounded and grateful people are those that question the status quo. You can be, can and should be, simultaneously grateful for what you have. We say to advisors all the time, “We’re not from Merrill Lynch’s training program that catapulted you to the seat you are in now to become a 3 million, 5 million, $7 million advisor. You may be mad at Merrill Lynch now, or you may want something more than Merrill Lynch can give you today, but it doesn’t mean you’re ungrateful for what Merrill gave you.” And that’s the answer. I think that you can be grateful for this wonderful life that you’ve been afforded, but at the same time, aware of the fact that you may want more, and that’s a healthy, wonderful thing. Louis Diamond: Completely agree. Yeah. I mean, it’s similar to any large Fortune 500 company. You think of Apple, how many times they’ve reinvented themselves or everything that’s happening with AI. I think a big part of this too is future-proofing, right? It’s okay. It’s not being ungrateful. It’s more I’m taking proactive action to make sure I do have a business in 15 to 20 years, and that I’m positioning to myself and my clients to do the best possible work together. This is the fun topic. It’s obviously something on the mind of a live of advisor. It comes up probably in every group that we ever consult with, whether they’re a wirehouse advisor, they’re a private banker, they’re independent, et cetera. So I think a lot to learn here. My big takeaway from today is it’s okay to want more. There’s nothing wrong with you for wanting more. At the same time, there’s nothing wrong about being comfortable. Thank you very much for today. Mindy Diamond: Amen. My pleasure. Good topic. Louis Diamond: Thank you for joining us. We’ll be back with a new episode next week, so be sure to listen in. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firm’s, or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook . Best of Replay: Why So Many Successful Advisors Feel Stuck An Industry Update with Louis Diamond and Mindy Diamond. Louis Diamond: Welcome to a replay of one of the most popular episodes from our podcast series for financial advisors. Why So Many Successful Advisors Feel Stuck. It’s a Special Industry Update with Mindy Diamond. I’m Louis Diamond and this is the Diamond Podcast for Financial Advisors. Mindy Diamond: At Diamond Consultants, we help elite advisors identify the right environment for their businesses to thrive, whether that’s at a wirehouse, boutique or independent firm. With nearly three decades of experience, we’ve guided thousands of advisors and represented more than a quarter of a trillion dollars in assets transitioned. And each year, one in four advisors managing a billion dollars or more who change firms are our clients. Our process is education-driven, and based on building relationships, starting as your strategic partner well before you’re even thinking of a move. To schedule a confidential conversation, call us at (908) 879-1002. Wondering why advisors change firms and where they’re headed? Are transition deals going up or down? Those very questions and more inspired us to create our annual advisor transition report. It’s the award-winning, data-driven resource designed for advisors that connects the dots between the motivations around movement and the firm’s appetite for top talent. Arm yourself with the knowledge you need to make smart decisions. Download your copy at diamond-consultants.com/transitionreport . Louis Diamond: We spend a lot of time talking with advisors who, by every external measure, are doing exceptionally well. They’ve built real businesses with strong production, loyal clients and teams that continue to grow, and yet behind closed doors, many of these same advisors are quietly asking a different set of questions. Not how do I fix what’s broken, but why doesn’t this feel as good as I expected? That tension is showing up more frequently than it did five or 10 years ago, and it’s not because advisors are failing. In many cases, it’s because they’ve won and now find themselves staring at another 15 to 20 years of more the same, unsure whether comfort has slowly replaced energy. This industry update is about that very moment. I asked Mindy to join me to unpack what we’re hearing from successful advisors across the industry, why success itself can become a constraint, how fear of change competes with fear of standing still, and why record valuations, longer careers and the maturity of the independent space are changing the psychology of decision-making. We also talk about the right questions to ask before considering a move, questions about control, enterprise value, legacy and time horizon, and how advisors can create clarity without forcing a decision. There’s lot to explore here, so let’s get into it. Mindy, thanks for joining us. Mindy Diamond: Oh, I’m so happy to be here. Always. Louis Diamond: This is a fun topic. So today we’re just going to dive right in. I’m curious, from your vantage point and talking and working with many of the best advisors in the industry at a high level, what are you hearing from successful advisors today that feels different from five or 10 years ago? Mindy Diamond: First of all, for the most part, I think that top advisors are loathe to move. And they may have a bunch of frustrations or things that they wish were different, but generally speaking, they’ve always been well taken care of. They have the bat phone to the top, it’s good enough and nobody wants to mess with success. But two things are true today more than ever before, that the competitive landscape, there are more options than ever before, that their businesses are worth more than before. I guess it’s more than two things. That they’re thinking about their business as a business and saying, “Yeah, it’s a hassle to move, but if I can maximize the value of my business more elsewhere and at the same time solve for what I want to, maybe I really do need to consider it. And so I think that it’s a time of more consideration, that top advisors, in particular, are just not willing to settle for the status quo. Louis Diamond: Yeah, no doubt. The only thing I would add, but I completely agree, is that today the retire in place or succession opportunities for a wirehouse advisor to transition or sell their business to their next generation or to another team or even an independent advisor, to sell their business to their broker dealer or to someone within their firm, those opportunities, the internal options, I think are more compelling than ever. So we hear a lot from really successful advisors who, that actually doesn’t matter if they’re successful or let’s say they’re mid-tier in the industry, where it’s much easier to stay. And the firms are smart. They’ve made these internal deals better for the retiring advisor at the expense of the inheriting advisor, but they definitely try to create the easy button for someone who’s successful and might be fairly close to the end zone of their career. Mindy Diamond: And yeah, unequivocally. And so I think what happens is that, as these senior advisors are weighing the notion of will I eventually take my firm’s retire in place program, hit that easy button, if you will, take the path of lease resistance? Before they do, most of them will, and absolutely should, at least get educated about what else is out there. Not with an eye toward moving necessarily, but with an eye toward knowing what their value is before they sign on for the next seven to 10 years. Louis Diamond: No doubt about it. So I think for the most part, we’re talking about mostly top two, advisors who are objectively winning. They have amazing businesses, they’re growing, they have loyal clients. Work-life balance is probably pretty good. So why do so many of these advisors still feel unsettled at the end of the day? Mindy Diamond: Because I think that without question, the number one thing that every advisor, but definitely the most successful advisors want, is agency. Agency over their professional life and anything, any day, any event that smacks of loss of agency or less agency than they would like, less control than they would like, makes them feel unsettled is a good word. Unsettled is probably a euphemism for exceedingly frustrated, really angry, ready to go. So look, our job in talking to these folks is, first of all, to say to them, there is no perfection anywhere. So the first thing is you may be annoyed that your firm did X, Y and Z, or you don’t have control over A, B, and C, or you may want more of A, B and C, but at the end of the day, you need to be sure that you’re aware of the hassle factor, you’re willing to trade one set of problems for potentially another. I guess what I’m saying is you got to really be sure that you want it. That’s the bottom line. Louis Diamond: No doubt. I would also add a bit of a different spin that a lot of advisors, these folks that I think by any objective measure, they’re killing it. You look at any of their friends outside the industry, their friends probably look at them and say, “Wow, this advisor has an amazing life.” And I think we’d probably say the same, but I think we see it where there’s a difference between being professionally motivated and energized versus just being comfortable. And I think with a lot of folks, especially if it’s a fee-based business, their clients are mostly friends. They grinded in the early years. They still work hard, but now things are on autopilot. So I think some people around unsettled because they have 10, 15, 20, 25 years left to work and they look and say, “This is great. I make a good living. Life’s not that hard,” but they’re missing that spark that they used to have. Mindy Diamond: I couldn’t agree more. I actually love that spin, and if I can, I’ll share an example of a conversation I had literally just last week. So talking with one of three senior partners on a very successful wirehouse team, without a doubt, one of the top teams in the industry, and this is a team that absolutely has a bat phone to the top. This is a team that gets referrals from their firm. So if another advisor leaves, they’re the go-to. If someone has an investment banking deal and needs to bring in a wealth advisor, they would go to this team. This is the team or one of a few teams. And I talked to them probably every six months for the last 10 years, and I’m not kidding, and we just have a nice relationship. They trust me. No, I would never sell them. And so they just want to understand the pulse on things. And for years, that’s essentially what they’ve said is, “We’re killing it, we’re crushing it. We are the go-to team and everything is hitting on all cylinders. And we know that we’ve got our firm’s retire in place programs when two of our senior partners are ready to cash out.” But just last week, not even the senior most member, probably the second to senior most member called and said, “It’s all working well, but I have this fire in my belly.” That’s a good way to say it, right? I have the sense that I’m missing something. And so some of the time, it’s about just getting to that place, say, when the straw that breaks the camel’s back. Something happens, you can’t take it any more, time to go. But with those top advisors, more often than not, it’s not about straw that breaks the camel’s back. It’s much more about fire in my belly. I realize that will I feel good if, at the end of the day, five minutes, five years or 20 years from now, will I feel good if I leave it all behind? We’re right here. Louis Diamond: Yep, exactly. Yeah, I think part of it is legacy, but the other part is just fast forwarding the tape. If you say 20 years from now, and you look back in the last 20 years, is you plus 20 years going to feel satisfied and encouraged and excited about what you were accomplishing? Or was it more of a, yeah, it was good, it was easy. I bought three houses and I have a boat. Or was it more about the personal joy of growing and building something and being part of something? Mindy Diamond: That’s actually a very good way to say it. Where can the top advisor find that joy? So let’s say I’m hitting on all cylinders, top of the food chain at fill in the blank firm, a traditional firm. What are typically the things that advisor, the options that advisor might consider that could ignite that joy? Louis Diamond: Yeah, I mean, honestly, probably a bad nonspecific answer, but it really could be anything. I mean, we see plenty of teams that are with one major wirehouse, they move to another one and just the act of transitioning is re-energizing. They have backend bonuses to hit. This new firm has a bit of a different culture, they feel more important again, and that’s their spark. Others, it would be we’re building something, we’re creating our own firm. Others might be I’m now an equity partner in something that I have a hand in, I have a voice. They actually listen to me. So I think it can be all of the above. It’s more about what is it that an advisor is most interested in? And then at this point in the industry, it’s choose your own adventure. If you have some sort of feeling or urge, whether it’s I want to do something different, I want to grow faster, I’m frustrated by X, Y, Z, it’s more about filling in the blanks of what your next journey looks like. And my guess is just thinking about that is going to provide that natural spark or ignition. Mindy Diamond: Yeah. And if I can, the piece of advice that I gave to this team, and I think is worth mentioning here, you’re absolutely right. Choose your own adventure. To us, I think we would both say that most exciting thing about being in our position and being the counselor or the guide or the Sherpa to advisors as they consider what comes next is the amount of choice that they have and how exciting the next chapter can be. But what I said to this team or the one advisor on this team is, “You’ve always got to be really clear on what your true north is.” So yes, there’s a lot of options. An advisor can find joy or reignite the spark at any number of choices, more than ever before. But being really clear before you begin to take meetings or think about it on what you’re looking to solve for, what’s most important to you really matters or else you wind up just spinning your wheels for a lot of time. Louis Diamond: Clearly agree. How do you distinguish between being comfortable in your business and being energized by a business? Do you think there’s a difference? Mindy Diamond: Yeah, look, I think in some cases, they could be one and the same. I think somebody can be comfortable because they feel energized. They’re hitting on all cylinders. They’ve got a lot of agency and professional control over their business. They’re where they want to be. They’re living their true north. But I think in many cases, and many of the advisors we’ve counseled, they aren’t one of the same. I’m comfortable because, as you said, I have a great quality of life, I’m making great money, I have a lot of freedom to coach my kids’ basketball team. I can work from home, I can travel when I want to, I have great clients. I may not technically own my business, but I feel as though I do. I’m comfortable enough. But what this advisor last week said to me, and what we hear a lot, is I’m comfortably uncomfortable. That I am comfortable enough. If I retired from here, I will have made a ton of money, I will have done good work and it all would be good enough. But whether or not good enough is really good enough in terms of professionally satisfying and everything you want it to be is a very different question. Louis Diamond: Exactly. I’ll give an example of that. I have an advisor I speak to who’s independent. So he’s been independent for his entire career at a broker dealer. He’s an absolute stone-cold killer. I told him that. He’s probably top three advisors at his BD, so it’s great for the ego. He’s on the conference circuit and sharing his best practices, but he’s in his 40s and said to me, “I can continue to rinse, repeat, I can continue to get the accolades and be on the main stage, but I feel like I’m missing something. I just know how to run the same place and I don’t really see how that’s going to change.” So he has a pretty hard decision because it’s nice to feel important, it’s nice to grow without a lot of extra effort, but for this individual, it’s becoming clear that spark or feeling energized again is his true north. Mindy Diamond: And so what would he look at? In other words, if you are already top of the food chain at your broker dealer, and by the way, we see that a lot, that advisors in the independent space that work under broker dealer that are number one, they are the one at the conference that everybody goes up to and said, “Oh my God, I hear such great things about you. I want to learn from you.” So what is it he’s missing? Louis Diamond: For this individual, what he thinks he’s missing is the chance to really build his own platform. So if this gentleman decides to make a change, it’s definitively going to be to build his own RIA, where he can pick and choose all the technology. He’s really bullish about his personal network and being able to recruit like-minded folks in to do acquisitions. And his North Star is going to be, how do I build the most valuable enterprise that I can sell for a whole boatload of money 15 years from now? It’s a great example because this person has everything that most people would want, but he’s still wanting more. And what he’s looking to accomplish is probably similar to a lot of people, but the means that he’s going to get there and the weighting that he’s putting on his criteria are different. And that’s what, I think, the best part of being an advisor is you have so much choice. There’s no one telling you, “You have to grow, you have to do this, you have to care about money, you have to onboard X number of clients.” It’s much more about how do you listen to your heart and then make intentional choices to make it happen, essentially. Mindy Diamond: Yeah, and I think that’s the calculus. His calculus is it’s more than enough here. The question is, am I willing to upset what’s more than good enough, upset that apple cart in order to get something that is marginally better? And his answer, or our advice to somebody like that, is it really depends upon how much you want it. If it will feel soulful to you, if, at the end of the day, you will feel better about the professional legacy you left behind, having built something bigger and better with less limitations, then you’ll do it. You have to decide how much you want it. It’s interesting, if I can go back to this example, this team’s true north is a little different and it’s worth contrasting. So while, for sure, they would love nothing more than to maximize enterprise value, and they recognize that if they and any of their partners retire through their firm’s retire in place program, it’s a way of monetizing, but they look at their firm as a monopolistic buyer. That was the term that they used. My comment to them is, “So what? Monopolistic or not, if, at the end of the day, it allows you to do what you need to do when you get paid a fair value, who cares if they’re monopolistic?” That really is the truth. But their true north is they would love to build something. They don’t need to build their own platform. In fact, they would want nothing more than to plug into an already existing platform. And they recognize that by doing so, they’re giving up some enterprise value. And the way to maximize enterprise value the fullest is to go out and build your own. But in this particular instance, they don’t want to do that. They’ve got partners that some are in their 60s and that’s not going to be appealing to them. So their true north might be something a little bit different. I think the point here is being really clear on what you’re true north is really important because it guides the set of choices. Louis Diamond: No doubt. At what point do you think more of the same stops being a growth strategy and starts becoming a constraint? Mindy Diamond: Oh, well, just that. Your example was the perfect example, right? That I am doing incredibly well. I could keep on doing this, but in some way, it’s not only constraining my growth, but in some way it’s constraining my professional satisfaction. And I think more often than not, it’s about that. Because the audience I think we’re talking to in this podcast are really successful folks. There’s no question that there’s nothing we can tell them that would suggest that they’re not successful as they are. So if they decide to upset the apple cart or they decide to look for more, it’s because there is that fire in your belly, that something, that entrepreneurial spark or that something that’s not being satisfied. Louis Diamond: I agree. Yeah. I think sometimes it’s a matter of time says to me, if someone finds something that works, it’s a pretty sound business strategy to rinse, repeat, and keep doing it, focus on what’s essential, cut out the rest. You read any business book, it’s going to tell you double down on what’s working, cut out the rest. The 80/20, et cetera. But I think eventually you keep doing the same thing over and over again, and it might still yield results, but is it yielding the growth? Is it yielding exponential results? And at some point, does just doing the same thing, is it still driving you in the same way? Mindy Diamond: Yeah, and I think a lot of times people don’t really know what they’re missing. In other words, the growth strategy is working. I’m growing X amount per year. I’m living a good life. I’m consistently in the top five advisors in my firm. It’s working and nobody could argue that it isn’t. I think it’s just more about a lot of times as advisors, one of two things, either one of their friends move, a professional colleague that they respect and they say, “Holy cow, he was here or she was here for 30 years, like me, killing it. She would’ve been the last person I would’ve thought would move.” And then suddenly she does, and it makes them say, “What am I missing? What did she see that I am not aware of?” Or a lot of times these folks will, another example I’ll give you. An advisor that I’ve worked with for many years, probably 25 years, who is top of the food chain, doing incredibly well, never really thought about moving, talked over the years, “Boy, it would be nice to build something of my own, but the truth of the matter is that success and the thought of having to go back to zero and build something from scratch, no way.” But you and I came across an opportunity that was unbelievably compelling, and without going into too much detail about the opportunity, suddenly when we talked about that opportunity with this advisor, what he said was, “You can’t be what you can’t see.” All of a sudden we painted the picture of something that’s really compelling I didn’t even know I wanted, but holy cow, now I know I really want it. Louis Diamond: Yeah, because something, this dream was made tangible. It put a face on something that this advisor didn’t realize they were missing. I mean, I see this every day, this next question, I’d love to get your opinion. I feel like most advisors, they may sense something is off or something’s changing or shifting under their feet, but they say anyway, why do you think success is often the very thing that keeps advisors stuck? Mindy Diamond: Yeah, I think it’s more than good enough. And for most of us, most of the time, I might have that little voice in me or that little inkling that says, gee, maybe it could be better. Or gee, I wonder if or something of the sort, but I have a zillion competing priorities. I’m a dad or I’m a mom or I want to travel, or I’m 60 years old, or I’m filling any blank at any time. And I think that it’s really hard to give up on that. And I think that the example we just gave, of this advisor that saw an opportunity, a unique opportunity that solved for a lot of the things that he didn’t even know he was missing, that happens more often than not. Louis Diamond: Yep, I agree. I think too, what happens is a lot of advisors think about moving as strictly a financial trade. My grid rate is this and my fees are that I can get 3.5X here, but only 2X up front have Y in deferred comp. And I think when advisors are thinking about that, which is a reasonable lens to look through, end of the day, they’re business people. If the business is growing and they have to place Y or they know how to get things done, it’s much harder to justify that change. It’s like people who sell their house top of the market, it’s like, hey, it’s this thing and keep growing, and do you feel like you’re missing out because you’re leaving at this point in time? Typically, too, when things are good, clients are happy, the reviews are easier. We see it a lot with the market being up. In 2025, the market was up almost 20%, much harder for some folks to justify moving because they feel like, whether it’s artificial or it’s real, that their business is really cranking. So I think that’s a big part of it as well. Mindy Diamond: Yeah. And maybe another little spin on it is a lot of times to move is really, from a financial perspective, may only be marginally better in the short-term, whether it be because after taxes, the amount of tabs you get upfront is not that much greater than the deal you could get by retiring through your firm’s sunset program. Or if you move, you’re going to be leaving some clients behind. So if you factor in the breakage from losing clients and the short-term upside, the delta may not be that great. We see a lot of times when an advisor is already independent and they’re at a net 60 or 65% payout and they’re looking at something that gives them a 70% net payout and they say, “Yeah, okay, so those extra basis points are nice, but is it nice enough? Is it worth the hassle?” The answer to that is it is entirely an inside job. For some that delta, even if that delta was only 2 cents, would be more than enough to justify the change. And for others, if the delta was 2000000%, it wouldn’t be enough. So what’s this positive? What’s this positive or determinant is how badly they want it. How badly, beyond the financial piece, they want what another opportunity would give them. Either that I really have this fire in my belly, and I love that term, and I just can’t solve for it. I can’t extinguish that fire here. I can’t feed that fire here. Or opportunistically, I want to be something I just can’t here, and I want it so badly that even if, financially, it’s only marginally better in the short-term, I’m willing to go through the hassle to get it. Louis Diamond: No doubt. And one last point to put a bow on this segment is I think there’s also an element that advisors who are growing or they have a big pipeline, and to me, the best advisors always have a big pipeline. They always have the next big prospect. There’s definitely some, I think, real fear that I’m going from growing 10% per year to reflexively choosing to make my life really hard for a couple of months to slow down growth, perhaps lose some of the pipeline, lose some of the big clients I just onboarded. And that’s really hard to justify because the trade-off is that much more apparent to them. Mindy Diamond: Yeah. Which you really want it. Louis Diamond: But that’s always going to be the case. That’s the point. The good advisors, for the most part, are always growing and always doing these things. So it’s like running on a treadmill. The same thing with unvested deferred compensation. I have 2 million of unvested deferred, it’s so hard to walk away from. The counterpoint is you’re always going to have that. If anything, it’s just going to grow. So again, it’s taking a step back to take multiple steps forward. Some people want that and are excited by it. Some people aren’t, but that’s okay. Mindy Diamond: Yeah, and I think that’s the whole point. While we get paid to move people, our position and the relationships we’ve had for years with top advisors, with every advisor, is they trust us because we’re never looking to just sell them on a hot opportunity. We’ll bring opportunities to them and say, “Here’s what’s available, here’s what the upside could be,” but we know and respect better than anyone that you got to really want it. It is a hassle. It’s hard work to move, and you’ve got to have a real confidence in your clients, your current clients, that they’re going to follow you. You’ve got to have real confidence that your pipeline will follow you, that what’s not certain. You’ve got to have confidence that you can tolerate the risk, and you’ve got to have confidence that your team’s going to follow you and that you’ve got the support you need. And not everyone has the appetite for it, nor should they. Louis Diamond: Exactly. I mean, I would say there’s two competing, I guess, thoughts that oftentimes go through an advisor’s mind, and they’re both extremely reasonable. The first one is the fear of change, but at the same time it’s the fear of staying exactly where they are for another 10, 15, 20 years. How do you think advisors can reconcile the tensions, like the angel on one shoulder, the devil on the other? One’s super comfortable and safe. The other one is an unknown. One’s exciting, one, et cetera. So how would you reconcile that? Mindy Diamond: Well, first of all, the short answer is it takes years. The two examples I just raised, and I’ll ask you the same question, are advisors that I’ve been talking to for 10 years plus. In one case, it could be 15 or 20. So for 10 or 15 years, there was always a certain amount of angst, a certain amount of curiosity, but not at all a willingness to do anything about it until in one case, something happened. Something happened that made them realize that they’re paying an awful lot of money to their firm for value they’re not getting anymore, feeling limited. And so they decided to pick up their head and look elsewhere. In the other case, it was opportunistic. Really was perfectly happy doing their thing and heard or saw an opportunity that sounded compelling and began exploring. Now, I don’t know whether either one of these teams will ultimately move, so let’s say that, but these conversations are many years in the making. So I think the point I’m making is that devil on one side, an angel on the other are those two competing voices. They exist for a long time until either, in some cases, they never get reconciled and the advisor just retires and it is what it is. In other cases, they get reconciled, but sometimes five, 10 years after the voices begin to surface and they don’t happen, they don’t get reconciled until something happens to force it. Louis Diamond: Yeah. I also look at this concept as we’ll call it a midlife career crisis. So I’m 40 years old. Instead of buying three motorcycles and a Porsche and going skydiving, I’m thinking about my business. And sometimes, I think people just wake up and say, “Wow, I don’t really know what my identity is and I need to do something different. I need that additional spark.” So I think sometimes too, it’s just either an age thing or a certain birthday comes up or it’s just that a moment of clarity that pops into the mind. Mindy Diamond: Totally agree. Louis Diamond: Why do you think this feeling is showing up now more than ever? Is it because of recruiting deals? Is it because of the movement toward independence? Is it something else or somethings else? Mindy Diamond: Yes, I think it’s all of the above, and I think that’s the cool thing. Valuations are at an all-time high. So even if an advisor has zero interest in going independent, you have to be living under a rock not to know that your business has real value. That business, outside of the constraints of a major firm, is worth much more than it is on the inside. Now, that doesn’t mean that everybody should go independent, or will, but the fact that those multiples are hanging out there and that recruiting deals are at an all-time high, and they are, the fact that there’s more optionality, which means an advisor, if they go out and explore, is more likely to find their personal version of Utopia or something closest to it. The fact that movement begets movement. That’s something we haven’t talked about, but it’s worth mentioning that all you have to do is read AdvisorHub or just be sitting in your office and every day, watch somebody you respect make a move. And so the more you see top advisors move, the more you say maybe there really is something else out there for me as well. And then you and I always say that the big firms are one policy change, one comp change, one mandate, one something away from frustrating the heck out of a large constituency because the bottom line is, as long as you’re an employee, you’re vulnerable or captive to whatever choices the firm makes. Louis Diamond: Yeah. I think you’re talking about, in a very nice way, what happened with UBS at the end of 2024, but we even see it outside of the wirehouses. There’s independent firms that layer in new fees or they don’t allow their advisors to text. There’s always that risk that something big coming down the pike that motivates someone. I’ll give you two other reasons why they think this is happening with more frequency. The first one is advisors’ careers are oftentimes longer, either because they’re bringing their kids into the business or the business is so lucrative, and if the business is mostly fee-based and it’s on autopilot, it’s like, why should I hang up the old boots when I can just work for another handful of years? So I think with longer advisor careers and the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow, which is either a big exit or a retire in place deal, I think advisors just grapple with more and they grapple with it for longer. Mindy Diamond: Yeah, you brought up a point. I’m so happy you brought it up. I’m sitting here next to my son, my next generation. I have said oftentimes that, without my sons coming into the business, I don’t know that I would’ve had the same relationship to the business as I aged. As I got older, and I’ll be transparent, I’m 63-year-old now, if 10 years ago, my sons had not decided to join me, I think that I might have said, “I’ll work as long as it feels soulful and good, and if something better comes along, great.” But it wasn’t until they came along that I really began to think about everything through their lens. It was less about me because by the time I was 50, from a financial perspective, I could have left if I wanted to. But as long as my kids weren’t in the business, there’s no way I was going to do that. There was no way I wouldn’t want what was the absolute best for the business. And I guess that’s a long-winded way of saying in an industry where there’s so many multigenerational businesses, father-son, mother-daughter, whatever it is, senior advisors that really care, even if they’re not family, about their next generation, when they begin to look at their business through the lens of their next generation, the technology may be good enough for me, but it’s sure not cutting edge enough. Or they say things like, “The bureaucracy is killing me, but I work three hours a day,” or, “I have such a good life, I don’t want to upset the apple cart.” But then all of a sudden, one day we get a call either from that senior advisor, for whom it was more than good enough for years, or from the next generation that says, “This is not what I want. It may have been good enough for my dad and my mom, but it’s not good enough for me.” So it’s a long-winded way of saying I think that the next generation really forces the senior advisors, the elder states, G1 to grapple with whether or not this is good enough. Louis Diamond: Yep. I’ll answer my own question first and then get your opinion, because I feel pretty strongly about my answer. In thinking about our four to five point list here of why this is a bigger deal now, I tap in with more frequency. The question for both of us is which one do you think has the biggest psychological impact on advisors right now? I’m going to go first because I’m excited about my answer. I think by far, it’s practice valuations by far. Because what’s happening is advisors are reading news articles, hearing from their friend, getting cold-called from corporate development folks at firms, and they hear what used to be just ludicrous multiples. These were multiples that were reserved 100, $200 million revenue business are now getting paid to a three to $5 million practice. And any advisor, even ones who aren’t super financially motivated, I think just hearing about this, knowing what’s possible has a major psychological impact. It’s making it that much harder for folks to say, “You know what? It’s comfortable. It’s easy. I can retire here because the opportunity cost of staying put has accelerated that much.” What do you think? Mindy Diamond: So unequivocally, and I am money motivated for sure, so I agree with you. But at my stage and age, if I were an advisor, I absolutely wouldn’t be able to ignore the impact that maximizing enterprise value might have and how awesome it would be to be building a business that could be worth more. But I would equally, if not more so, be really concerned about, A, how it would feel. Like am I going to be able to live the professional life, do what’s soulful for me? Am I going to be able to build the business I want to? Is this going to be the business, the legacy I’m going to feel good about? Is this going to be the business that I want my sons to take over? And that, to me, would be equally important. And I’m making it about me, but I think that’s what a lot of senior advisors would say. Louis Diamond: No doubt. So for folks that are questioning their situation, what do you think is a question or three or four or five of the right questions they should start asking themselves before even thinking about making a move? Mindy Diamond: Yeah. Well, one is, listen, what’s your true north? And even before, I mean question two, and I think what I just said, assessing your true north, figuring out where your true north is, one, because question two is what is it that’s bothering you? What is it that you’re frustrated by? And simultaneously, to what extent does it frustrate you? Like how, okay, so I feel mildly annoyed that I have to do X, but is it enough to make me want to move? So being clear on that is important. But I think even before you begin to delineate how frustrated you are, you have to be really clear on what you want to be when you grow up. What is it that would feel soulful? What are you trying to solve for? What are the parameters or realities that you need to take into account? You’d love to do X, but you have a senior partner that you know is never going to want that, whatever it is. So what is the true north? What are you frustrated by? Then it’s what risk appetite do I have? Louis Diamond: To take risks, yeah. Mindy Diamond: What risk appetite and what appetite in general do I have for disruption to my life? How tolerant will I be if one of my clients doesn’t follow with me, because that is really possible? How tolerant will I be if I spend a few months and I’m working harder than I’ve ever worked in my life, whatever it may be. And then I think it’s that question, what I want to be when I grow up is really what’s just positive. Do I want to be a business owner or am I a big corporate person and that’s just who I am and I’m comfortable with leveraging the name that’s on the door? Louis Diamond: No doubt. I think an interesting one is ask yourself, if I stayed exactly where I am for the next 15 years, would I be proud of what I built? I think it’s a really important one sometimes too, when I’m speaking with advisors who are worried about a transition, and honestly people should be worried about a transition. It’s terrible. There’s no sugar-coating it. It’s a lot of work. It’s scary. It’s a risk. You’re disrupting your life, all your client’s life, et cetera. But sometimes, I’d say, the reframe is the three months, four months, whatever it is of backbreaking work that you put in, is that worth it for the next 10, 15, 20 years of doing something that really sparks you more? And I think, again, it comes back to your question of risk appetite, but I think just thinking about that is a lot of people get lost in the immediacy of the risk and of the work, but they forget to look beyond that work to what’s possible on the other side of the rainbow. Mindy Diamond: And how important it is to get it. In other words, I may be very clear that I would like to have X. I’d like to do Y. I would love, I mean we hear this all the time. I’d love to be independent and build my own business. Boy, if I were 20 years younger or I was, whatever it was. So the point of the matter is you can be aware of wanting those things. It’s admirable to want them, but whether or not you actually should go after them, that’s an inside job. Louis Diamond: No doubt. I think another one I like is which regret is bigger to you, trying something and failing or never testing what’s possible? I think that’s a good one. Another philosophical one. Okay. Let’s change gears a little bit here. So for successful, we’ll say mid-career advisors, why do you think the biggest risk is oftentimes not making the wrong move, but choosing the status quo by default? Mindy Diamond: Answering it from the perspective, we’ve had a lot of senior advisors that say, “I look back on my career and if only I had made the move or gone to this 15 years ago.” So I think that’s the you get comfortable in the discomfort, it’s easier to stay put, and then before you know it in your head, you’re too old or you’re too settled or you’re too entrenched and you can’t go or it’s too late to go. Or in some cases, you’ve got so much unvested deferred comp, it’s too expensive to go. And so I don’t think that’s only about mid-career. I think you want to make sure that you’ve lived a professional life that’s not filled with regret. That’s really what I think. Louis Diamond: No doubt about it. I think too, the fear of making the wrong move, call it buyer’s remorse, if you will. I honestly don’t really see it happen all that often. When I see it happen, it’s because someone went to their second or third choice firm because they got paid an extra 10% of their production. That’s where the wrong decision comes in. I usually find when advisors are thorough, they’re thoughtful, they’re making decisions for the right reasons, and there is a base level of motivation to do something different. You can’t really make the wrong choice. And I think, but again, it’s risk tolerance, et cetera. Let me give you two more questions here. What’s one step an advisor can take today to create clarity without committing to change? Mindy Diamond: Well, that question is the fundamental definition of how you and I see the world. So we traffic in advisors that are 10 years, 20 years from making a move or may never move. To us, it’s just about the relationship. That may sound foofy and crazy, but it is the truth. And so those conversations are all about being self-aware. That’s number one. Know thyself. Being self-aware of what’s important to me, what can I live with, how much risk tolerance do I have, et cetera. And then it’s also about having a clear understanding about what’s possible. So continuing to have conversation with people like you and I, continuing to read AdvisorHub or whatever it is about transitions that happen. Understanding the opportunities that are out there is not necessarily because you’re going to go take one of them or you’re going to change, but knowledge is power. It empowers you where you are. It’s competitive analysis, and that’s smart. That can only serve you well. Louis Diamond: Yep. I completely agree. One last question here, and I think probably a lot of people listening to this are thinking this personification of an advisor or advisors that we’re describing, are they just complainers? Are they just being ungrateful? On the one hand, there’s probably folks that are early in their careers working their butt up who are saying, “Hey, just be grateful for what you have. It’s really hard to get to where you are. So why are you looking a gift horse in the mouth?” So what would you say to that line of thinking, that questioning the status quo or questioning something that’s really good, does that means someone’s ungrateful or restless? Mindy Diamond: Oh my God, no. I think that the smartest and most successful, and honestly most grounded and grateful people are those that question the status quo. You can be, can and should be, simultaneously grateful for what you have. We say to advisors all the time, “We’re not from Merrill Lynch’s training program that catapulted you to the seat you are in now to become a 3 million, 5 million, $7 million advisor. You may be mad at Merrill Lynch now, or you may want something more than Merrill Lynch can give you today, but it doesn’t mean you’re ungrateful for what Merrill gave you.” And that’s the answer. I think that you can be grateful for this wonderful life that you’ve been afforded, but at the same time, aware of the fact that you may want more, and that’s a healthy, wonderful thing. Louis Diamond: Completely agree. Yeah. I mean, it’s similar to any large Fortune 500 company. You think of Apple, how many times they’ve reinvented themselves or everything that’s happening with AI. I think a big part of this too is future-proofing, right? It’s okay. It’s not being ungrateful. It’s more I’m taking proactive action to make sure I do have a business in 15 to 20 years, and that I’m positioning to myself and my clients to do the best possible work together. This is the fun topic. It’s obviously something on the mind of a live of advisor. It comes up probably in every group that we ever consult with, whether they’re a wirehouse advisor, they’re a private banker, they’re independent, et cetera. So I think a lot to learn here. My big takeaway from today is it’s okay to want more. There’s nothing wrong with you for wanting more. At the same time, there’s nothing wrong about being comfortable. Thank you very much for today. Mindy Diamond: Amen. My pleasure. Good topic. Louis Diamond: Thank you for joining us. We’ll be back with a new episode next week, so be sure to listen in. Mindy Diamond: As a financial advisor, you hold yourself to the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and credibility. You are successful because you take your professional responsibilities seriously and are dedicated to your clients. But are you living your best business life? Are your goals aligned with your firm’s, or could a better option exist? Should I Stay or Should I Go? is a book written with you in mind. It’s a self-guided journey that walks you through the key steps that we take with our advisor clients. This strategic thought process and roadmap to professional self-discovery is designed to help you ask the right questions and think critically and objectively, whether you’re considering change or not. Learn how to get your copy at diamond-consultants.com/thebook .

Is this your show?

Claim this listing to keep it up to date, reach guests who want to pitch you, and manage bookings with Guestify.

Claim this listing

More Business podcasts