
#148 - Live Debate: Are Seed Oils Truly Harmful? Cherie Calbom
Cherie Calbom, MS, nutritionist and author of The Truth About Seed Oils, joins the Strong Ambition Podcast for a friendly debate about one of the most controversial topics in nutrition: Are seed oils actually harmful? Cherie explains why she believes industrial seed oils should be avoided, while Rhyland challenges whether the human evidence supports labeling seed oils as toxic. They discuss inflammation, randomized controlled trials, anecdotes versus population evidence, beef tallow, processed foods, calories, food sensitivities, and why the overall dietary pattern may matter more than any single ingredient. Despite disagreeing on seed oils, the conversation finds plenty of common ground around whole foods, sustainable nutrition, individual differences, and the importance of actually enjoying your life and the people you share it with. In This Episode, We Discuss: Cherie’s personal health transformation and journey into nutrition. Why juicing and whole foods became central to her nutrition philosophy. The argument that seed oils oxidize and create harmful byproducts. Are seed oils actually “toxic” in the human body? What randomized controlled trials can tell us about seed oils. Biological mechanisms versus real-world human outcomes. Anecdotes, food sensitivities, and population-level recommendations. Why Rhyland believes individual ingredients are often unnecessarily villainized. Seed oils versus overall calorie intake and dietary patterns. Is beef tallow actually healthier than seed oils? Why Japan creates an interesting challenge to the seed oil argument. Correlation versus causation in nutrition research. GMOs, food processing, chemicals, and the appeal to “natural.” Why different dietary restrictions can all improve adherence for different people. Finding the right balance between whole foods and flexibility. Listening to your body and recognizing individual food sensitivities. Why relationships, community, and enjoying food also matter for health. Where Rhyland and Cherie ultimately agree despite their differences. Episode Roadmap 00:47 – Cherie’s Health Transformation & Journey Into Nutrition 04:24 – Juicing, Whole Foods & Cherie’s Current Diet 09:47 – The Truth About Seed Oils 11:01 – Why Cherie Believes Seed Oils Are Toxic 13:33 – Rhyland Challenges the Evidence Against Seed Oils 17:37 – Where Rhyland & Cherie Agree — and Disagree 19:52 – Personal Stories, Food Sensitivities & Anecdotal Evidence 22:41 – Can Seed Oils Be Part of a Healthy Diet? 25:07 – Is the Ingredient the Problem or the Overall Diet? 26:55 – Beef Tallow vs. Seed Oils 29:27 – Calories, Processed Foods & the Bigger Health Problem 30:38 – Japan: A Challenge to the Seed Oil Argument 34:30 – GMOs, Cancer & Asking What the Evidence Actually Shows 35:00 – Correlation vs. Causation in Nutrition Research 37:40 – Why Rhyland Doesn't Think Seed Oils Are the Main Problem 39:38 – Dietary Restrictions, Adherence & Finding What Works for You 41:26 – What Does “Chemical” Actually Mean in Nutrition? 42:42 – Does Natural Automatically Mean Healthier? 44:03 – How Much Processed Food Can Fit Into a Healthy Diet? 46:24 – Food Sensitivities & Individualizing Your Nutrition 48:00 – Why Relationships and Community Matter for Your Health 50:33 – Where Rhyland & Cherie Find Common Ground 52:08 – Cherie’s Current Ambition & Making Healthy Eating Enjoyable 1:XX:XX – Rhyland’s Reflection https://amzn.to/3MU4EBg @juiceladycherie

