Herb Baumeister : The Fox Hollow Farm Files Unsealed

Hosted by AC Wilson

Business

Website RSS feed

Episodes

Latest episode

Sep 2026

Language

About the show

Herb Baumeister: The Fox Hollow Farm Files Unsealed examines one of Indiana’s most disturbing and enduring true-crime investigations. In the 1990s, investigators searching the sprawling Fox Hollow Farm property outside Indianapolis discovered human remains scattered across the grounds. The property belonged to businessman Herb Baumeister, who became the central suspect in the disappearances and deaths of multiple men. Baumeister died before he could be arrested or tried in connection with the Fox Hollow Farm deaths. Decades later, the investigation is far from forgotten. Advances in DNA testing and forensic genetic genealogy have helped authorities work to identify remains recovered from the property, potentially providing long-awaited answers to victims’ families. DISCLAIMER Herb Baumeister: The Fox Hollow Farm Files Unsealed is an independent true-crime podcast created for informational, educational, and documentary purposes. This podcast is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any law-enforcement agency, government organization, victim or victim’s family, streaming service, publisher, production company, or other organization associated with the Fox Hollow Farm investigation. Information presented in this program is based on publicly available sources, including news reports, historical records, law-enforcement statements, court and government records where available, and other published materials. Details may change as additional evidence, identifications, or investigative findings become public. Herb Baumeister died in 1996 and was never tried or convicted in connection with the deaths associated with Fox Hollow Farm. References to him as a suspect or suspected serial killer reflect allegations, investigative findings, or statements attributed to authorities and should not be interpreted as a criminal conviction. This podcast discusses homicide, missing persons, human remains, and other disturbing subjects. Listener discretion is advised. The program strives to discuss victims respectfully and to distinguish established facts from allegations, theories, and unresolved questions.

Listen to episodes

7 recent

September 21, 202647 min

The Bone Collector of Fox Hollow Farm

The episode details the chilling investigation into Herb Baumeister, a businessman suspected of murdering numerous gay men at his Indiana estate during the 1990s. Authorities discovered approximately 10,000 bone fragments scattered across his property, leading to one of the most significant forensic identification efforts in American history. The narrative describes how Baumeister utilized a pseudonym to lure victims to his home before ultimately evading justice through suicide in Canada. Modern forensic teams continue to work alongside the Hamilton County Coroner to identify remains using DNA technology to provide closure for grieving families. This account highlights the initial investigative failures and the subsequent dedication of detectives and relatives who sought the truth behind the disappearances. Ultimately, the source serves as a somber overview of the Fox Hollow Farm crimes and the ongoing pursuit of dignity for the unidentified victims. Content Warning: This podcast contains discussions of homicide, violence, abuse, and other graphic themes related to real-life criminal events. It is intended for mature audiences and listener discretion is advised. This episode includes AI-generated content.

September 21, 202641 min

The Secret Graves of Fox Hollow Farm

The episode recounts the disturbing history of Herb Baumeister, an Indiana man suspected of being a highly prolific serial killer during the 1980s and 1990s. While maintaining a facade as a family man and business owner, Baumeister allegedly lured gay men to his sprawling estate, Fox Hollow Farm, where he murdered them and concealed their remains. The discovery of thousands of bone fragments on his property led to an intensive forensic investigation that continues to identify new victims decades after his 1996 suicide. The episode also explores the potential connection between Baumeister and the I-70 Strangler cold cases, alongside accounts from a man claiming to be a sole survivor. Modern DNA technology remains a central focus of the narrative as officials work to provide closure to the families of at least 25 suspected victims. Current media interest, including a recent Hulu docuseries, ensures that the grim legacy of his crimes remains a subject of public scrutiny. Content Warning: This podcast contains discussions of homicide, violence, abuse, and other graphic themes related to real-life criminal events. It is intended for mature audiences and listener discretion is advised. This episode includes AI-generated content.

September 21, 202637 min

DNA Confirms Identity of Likely First Fox Hollow Farm Victim

The episode details a significant breakthrough in a long-standing cold case involving serial killer Herb Baumeister, whose Indiana property yielded thousands of human remains in the 1990s. Recent advancements in DNA technology have allowed forensic experts to officially confirm the identity of Roger Goodlet, a man believed to be among the killer's first victims. While initial identifications were made decades ago using dental records, this new scientific verification is part of a renewed investigative effort spearheaded by the Hamilton County Coroner. This modern push for answers was inspired by a family seeking closure for their missing loved one, leading to a collaborative partnership between law enforcement and specialized laboratories. The project continues to analyze over 10,000 bone fragments found at Fox Hollow Farm to bring peace to the families of dozens of unidentified victims. Through these sophisticated genetic analysis techniques, authorities are finally resolving mysteries that have remained stagnant since Baumeister’s suicide in 1996. Content Warning: This podcast contains discussions of homicide, violence, abuse, and other graphic themes related to real-life criminal events. It is intended for mature audiences and listener discretion is advised. This episode includes AI-generated content.

September 21, 202645 min

Fox Hollow Farm: Inside One of Indiana’s Darkest Cases

This episode examines the harrowing history and ongoing forensic investigation of Fox Hollow Farm, the former Indiana estate of suspected serial killer Herb Baumeister. After thousands of human bone fragments were discovered on the property in 1996, Baumeister fled to Canada and died by suicide, leaving behind a massive forensic puzzle that remained stagnant for decades. The source details the killer’s deceptive double life as a businessman and family man, as well as his likely connection to a series of unsolved stranglings along Interstate 70. Under the leadership of a new coroner in 2022, modern DNA technology and genetic genealogy are finally being used to identify victims who were overlooked by 1990s authorities. By chronicling the names of the identified dead and the search for potential accomplices, the narrative emphasizes the long-delayed pursuit of closure for families. Ultimately, the passage frames the case as a tragic intersection of institutional neglect and a persistent modern effort to reclaim identities from the soil. Content Warning: This podcast contains discussions of homicide, violence, abuse, and other graphic themes related to real-life criminal events. It is intended for mature audiences and listener discretion is advised. This episode includes AI-generated content.

September 21, 202644 min

The Echoes of Fox Hollow Farm

The episode recounts the chilling history of Fox Hollow Farm, a private estate in Westfield, Indiana, where businessman Herb Baumeister is believed to have murdered up to twenty-five men. After his suicide in 1996, investigators discovered thousands of human bone fragments scattered across the property, sparking an identification process that continues with modern DNA technology. Beyond the criminal investigation, the source details pervasive paranormal reports from subsequent residents who encountered shadowy figures and auditory hauntings linked to the victims. The narrative traces Baumeister’s disturbed psychological background and his deceptive double life as a suburban father who lured men from gay bars to his home. Ultimately, the episode serves as an overview of one of the Midwest's most notorious serial killer cases and the lingering quest for victim closure. Content Warning: This podcast contains discussions of homicide, violence, abuse, and other graphic themes related to real-life criminal events. It is intended for mature audiences and listener discretion is advised. This episode includes AI-generated content.

September 21, 202634 min

The Killing Fields of Fox Hollow Farm

The episode details the investigation into Herb Baumeister, an Indiana businessman suspected of being a prolific serial killer during the 1980s and 90s. Following his suicide in 1996, authorities discovered thousands of human bone fragments scattered across his estate, Fox Hollow Farm, where he allegedly lured and murdered dozens of men. While the initial inquiry stalled after his death, the source highlights a renewed forensic effort launched in 2022 to identify the remaining victims using modern DNA technology and genetic genealogy. Investigators now estimate that Baumeister may be responsible for up to 25 deaths on his property, in addition to his suspected involvement in the I-70 Strangler cold cases. The episode emphasizes the ongoing work of the Hamilton County Coroner to provide closure to families who have waited decades for answers regarding their missing loved ones. Content Warning: This podcast contains discussions of homicide, violence, abuse, and other graphic themes related to real-life criminal events. It is intended for mature audiences and listener discretion is advised. This episode includes AI-generated content.

September 21, 202639 min

Fox Hollow Coroner Probes Potential Herb Baumeister Accomplice

The episode examines the ongoing investigation into Herb Baumeister, a deceased serial killer suspected of murdering at least 25 men and disposing of their remains at his Fox Hollow Farm estate. Hamilton County Coroner Jeff Jellison expresses significant doubt that Baumeister acted alone, citing the immense physical difficulty of moving bodies through dense terrain. The episode highlights the coroner's skepticism toward Mark Goodyear, a self-described survivor who Jellison believes is withholding critical information about the victims. This renewed inquiry utilizes advanced forensic efforts to identify over 9,000 bone fragments found on the property. Ultimately, the source details the challenges of providing closure to families whose loved ones may have been marginalized and never officially reported missing. Content Warning: This podcast contains discussions of homicide, violence, abuse, and other graphic themes related to real-life criminal events. It is intended for mature audiences and listener discretion is advised. This episode includes AI-generated content.